Décisions de justice publiées par le cabinet
-
High Court (Business and Property Courts), 19 апреля 2023, n° [2023] EWHC 1215 (Ch)
Mr Justice Richard Smith : Witnesses testifying overseas 1. In the course of today’s pretrial review in this matter, having dealt with a number of matters that are agreed and...
-
High Court (Family Division), 19 апреля 2023, n° [2023] EWHC 844 (Fam)
Mr Justice Mostyn: 1. I shall refer to the appellant as ‘the mother’ and to the respondent as ‘the father’. 2. The mother is 50 and is a journalist although...
-
First-tier Tribunal (General Regulatory Chamber) – Information Rights, 19 апреля 2023, n° [2023] UKFTT 383 (GRC)
1. The Applicant has by Notice of Appeal dated 31 October 2022 applied for an order under s. 166 of the Data Protection Act 2018. 2. On 3 January 2023,...
-
Court of Appeal (Civil Division), 19 апреля 2023, n° [2023] EWCA Civ 418
LORD JUSTICE COULSON : 1. Introduction 1. Co-insurance in the construction industry is common. But it has historically given rise to some potentially complex issues. This appeal arises out of...
-
First-tier Tribunal (General Regulatory Chamber) – Information Rights, 19 апреля 2023, n° [2023] UKFTT 381 (GRC)
Introduction 1. On 31 March 2021, Mr O'Mara made the following request for information to South Yorkshire Police (“SYP”): I would like to place a Freedom of Information Request for...
-
High Court (Administrative Court), 19 апреля 2023, n° [2023] EWHC 871 (Admin)
The Hon. Mr Justice Bourne : Introduction 1. The claimant, a national of Afghanistan, has told the Court that she is living in hiding and that the Taliban are searching...
-
First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber), 19 апреля 2023, n° [2023] UKFTT 435 (TC)
INTRODUCTION 1. This appeal relates to payments made to the appellant under the Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme (the “Scheme”). Between 23 April 2020 and 18 December 2020, the appellant claimed...
-
High Court (Insolvency and Companies List), 19 апреля 2023, n° [2023] EWHC 852 (Ch)
Mr Justice Zacaroli: Introduction 1. This case is about the corporate consequences of the breakdown in the relationship between Ms Emma Fairclough (“Ms Fairclough”) and Mr Robert Tillett (“Mr Tillett”)....
-
Court of Appeal (Civil Division), 19 апреля 2023, n° [2023] EWCA Civ 414
Lady Justice Elisabeth Laing: Introduction 1. This case concerns rights to reside in the United Kingdom which were conferred by EU law and in particular by Directive 2004/38/EC (‘the Directive’)...
-
United Kingdom Supreme Court, 19 апреля 2023, n° [2023] UKSC 14
LORD STEPHENS (with whom Lord Reed, Lord Sales, Lord Hamblen and Lord Burrows agree): Introduction 1. Article 7(1) of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms...
-
First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber), 19 апреля 2023, n° [2023] UKFTT 385 (TC)
Introduction 1. The appellant appeals against a Notice to provide information (“the Notice”) dated 15 July 2021, issued by HMRC, pursuant to powers conferred by paragraph 40 Schedule 16 Finance...
-
High Court (Intellectual Property List), 19 апреля 2023, n° [2023] EWHC 873 (Ch)
Mrs Justice Joanna Smith: Introduction 1. The two consolidated claims in these proceedings between two well-known supermarket chains (to whom I shall refer as “Lidl” and “Tesco” Although there are...
-
High Court (Circuit Commercial Court), 19 апреля 2023, n° [2023] EWHC 1681 (Comm)
HIS HONOUR JUDGE HODGE KC: 1. This is my extemporary judgment on applications in a claim brought by Polypipe Limited against Mr Peter Russell Davidson in the Circuit Commercial Court...
-
Family Court (B - district and circuit judges), 19 апреля 2023, n° [2023] EWFC 60 (B)
1. On Friday 24 March 2023 I made an interim care order (“ICO”) in proceedings concerning a newborn baby, “V”, born earlier in the week. I gave an oral judgment...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 апреля 2023, n° 11379/21.0T8PRT.P1.S1
Relator: REMALHO PINTO. I- A letra da conven??o ? n?o apenas o ponto de partida da interpreta??o, mas o limite da mesma; II- A express?o ?dias consecutivos?, constante da Cl?usula...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 апреля 2023, n° 2930/18.4T8BRG.G1.S2-B
Relator: RAMALHO PINTO. I- O ac?rd?o j? transitado em julgado ? inatac?vel por via de argui??o de nulidades, sejam elas quais forem; II- O disposto no arto 672o, no 3,...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 апреля 2023, n° 26135/20.5T8LSB-A.L1-A.S1
Relator: J?LIO GOMES. Face ao disposto no artigo 296.o do CPC as normas do Regulamento das Custas Judiciais s?o atend?veis para c?lculo do valor da causa para efeitos das custas...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 апреля 2023, n° 1150/20.2T8EVR.E1.S2
Relator: RAMALHO PINTO. I- ? luz da decis?o do TJ de 16 de fevereiro de 2023, no processo C-675/21, ? claro que sendo a actividade de seguran?a privada uma actividade...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 апреля 2023, n° 1203/19.0T8MTS.P1.S2
Relator: RAMALHO PINTO. I- O recorrente que invoca, como fundamento de uma revista excepcional, a al?nea a) do no 1 do artigo 672o do CPC, tem o ?nus de indicar,...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 апреля 2023, n° 1570/18.2T8TMR-B.L1.S2
Relator: RAMALHO PINTO. ? de admitir a revista excepcional num caso em que, discutindo-se a ilicitude do despedimento da Autora com fundamento na improced?ncia do motivo justificativo do despedimento colectivo,...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 апреля 2023, n° 1829/21.1T8VLG.P1.S2
Relator: J?LIO GOMES. Existindo contradi??o entre o Ac?rd?o recorrido e o Ac?rd?o fundamento quanto ao modo como deve ser interpretada a Cl?usula 136.a do Acordo Coletivo de Trabalho do sector...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 апреля 2023, n° 179/19.8T8GRD.C1.S2
Relator: J?LIO GOMES. Existe contradi??o entre Ac?rd?os que, a prop?sito da prova do nexo causal entre a viola??o das regras de seguran?a pelo empregador e o sinistro, embora invocando ambos...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 апреля 2023, n° 23748/18.9T8LSB.L1.S2
Relator: J?LIO GOMES. N?o h? que admitir uma revista excecional sobre a quest?o de saber o que constitui infra??o disciplinar continuada quando o Tribunal j? decidiu que os factos de...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 апреля 2023, n° 29343/21.8T8LSB.L1-A.S1
Relator: M?RIO BELO MORGADO. A??es sobre interesses imateriais s?o aquelas cujo objeto n?o tem express?o pecuni?ria, visando a declara??o ou efetiva??o de direito ou direitos de natureza extrapatrimonial.
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 апреля 2023, n° 11324/21.3T8SNT.L1.S2
Relator: M?RIO BELO MORGADO. I- A relev?ncia jur?dica prevista no art. 672.o, no 1, a), do CPC, pressup?e uma quest?o que apresente manifesta complexidade ou novidade, evidenciada nomeadamente em debates...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 апреля 2023, n° 23135/20.9T8LSB-A.L1.S1
Relator: M?RIO BELO MORGADO. I- O dever de lealdade inclui um dever de honestidade, que implica uma obriga??o de absten??o por parte do trabalhador de qualquer comportamento suscet?vel de colocar...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 апреля 2023, n° 6365/20.0T8ALM.L1.S2
Relator: M?RIO BELO MORGADO. N?o suscitando os autos qualquer quest?o suscet?vel de ser tratada no ?mbito do princ?pio da irredutibilidade da retribui??o (invocado pela recorrente), nunca poderiam emergir dos autos...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 апреля 2023, n° 2930/18.4T8BRG.G1.S2-A
Relator: RAMALHO PINTO. I. O ac?rd?o j? transitado em julgado ? inatac?vel por via de argui??o de nulidades, sejam elas quais forem; II. O disposto no arto 672o, no 3,...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 апреля 2023, n° 964/16.2PBLSB.L2-A.S1
Relator: TERESA DE ALMEIDA. I. A aprecia??o da mat?ria relativa ? prova, ao exame da prova e ao quantum indemnizat?rio fora j? realizada pela senten?a condenat?ria e pelo Ac?rd?o do...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 апреля 2023, n° 37/23.1JAFAR-A.E1-A.S1
Relator: LOPES DA MOTA. I. A prote??o da garantia de imparcialidade do juiz ? assegurada pelos impedimentos (artigos 39.? a 42 do CPP), e, complementarmente, pelo instituto das suspei??es, que...