Décisions de justice publiées par le cabinet
-
Court of Appeal (Criminal Division), 9 juillet 2024, n° [2024] EWCA Crim 958
Tuesday 9th July 2024 LORD JUSTICE HOLROYDE: 1. This case concerns a sexual offence against a young woman to whom we shall refer as "C". C is entitled to the...
-
First-tier Tribunal (General Regulatory Chamber) – Welfare of Animals, 9 juillet 2024, n° [2024] UKFTT 600 (GRC)
1. I agree with the parties that this appeal is suitable for determination on the papers in accordance with rule 32 of The Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal)(General Regulatory Chamber) Rules...
-
First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber), 9 juillet 2024, n° [2024] UKFTT 616 (TC)
Introduction 1. This appeal concerns the application of the Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme (“CJRS”) for employers who furloughed their employees during the coronavirus pandemic. 2. The issue in this appeal...
-
High Court (Family Division), 9 juillet 2024, n° [2024] EWHC 1784 (Fam)
Mrs Justice Judd : Introduction 1. This is an appeal by a mother from a number of orders made by His Honour Judge Scarratt sitting in the Family Court in...
-
Family Court, 9 juillet 2024, n° [2024] EWFC 176
Mr Justice Francis : Introduction 1. DR and her husband ES (known to all as E) are enmeshed in financial remedy proceedings following their separation. For the sake of convenience,...
-
High Court (King's Bench Division), 9 juillet 2024, n° [2024] EWHC 1770 (KB)
This judgment was handed down by release to The National Archives on 9 July 2024 Mr Justice Johnson: 1. This case concerns an encampment by students (and possibly others) at...
-
High Court (Family Division), 9 juillet 2024, n° [2024] EWHC 1778 (Fam)
MR JUSTICE HAYDEN: 1. I am concerned with E, who is a 16-year-old young person, who seeks to appeal the recognition and enforcement of an Irish Special Care Order, pursuant...
-
Court of Appeal (Civil Division), 9 juillet 2024, n° [2024] EWCA Civ 767
Lord Justice Lewison: Introduction 1. The issue on this appeal concerns the limits on a power to make alterations in the BBC pension scheme. The power is contained in rule...
-
Court of Appeal (Civil Division), 9 juillet 2024, n° [2024] EWCA Civ 765
LORD JUSTICE MALES: 1. The appellant, Kession Capital Ltd (‘KCL’), the 12th defendant in this action, is a person authorised under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (‘FSMA’) to...
-
Family Court (B - district and circuit judges), 9 juillet 2024, n° [2024] EWFC 228 (B)
1. This judgment considers the issue of whether my substantive judgment granting permission for the withdrawal of care proceedings should be published. 2. The original judgment was handed down on...
-
High Court (Administrative Court), 9 juillet 2024, n° [2024] EWHC 1763 (Admin)
FORDHAM J: Introduction 1. This is an appeal by way of case stated by the Justices for the County of Durham and Darlington in respect of their adjudication in this...
-
United Kingdom Supreme Court, 9 juillet 2024, n° [2024] UKSC 23
LORD Hamblen (with whom Lord Briggs, Lady Rose, Lord Richards and Lady Simler agree): Introduction 1. Under the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996 (“the 1996 Act”) there is...
-
Court of Appeal (Criminal Division), 9 juillet 2024, n° [2024] EWCA Crim 824
MR JUSTICE BRYAN: 1. The provisions of the Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act 1992 apply to this offence. Under those provisions, where a sexual offence has been committed against a person,...
-
Employment Appeal Tribunal, 9 juillet 2024, n° [2024] EAT 113
THE HONOURABLE MRS JUSTICE EADY DBE, PRESIDENT Introduction 1. This appeal concerns the dismissal of a claim upon failure to comply with the terms of an unless order, and the...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 9 juillet 2024, n° 1083/16.7T8VNG.P2.S1
Relator: LUIS CORREIA DE MENDON?A. I- Ao sindicar o racioc?nio presuntivo do segundo grau, o STJ n?o tem de se pronunciar sobre considera??es produzidos pela Rela??o, em mero refor?o de...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 9 juillet 2024, n° 392/23.3T8MFR-A.L1.S1
Relator: RICARDO COSTA. I. O art. 370?, 2, do CPC, como regra de irrecorribilidade em revista de decis?es proferidas relativamente a procedimentos cautelares, s? admite como salvaguarda a revista extraordin?ria...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 9 juillet 2024, n° 331/19.6T8FAF.G1.S1
Relator: RICARDO COSTA. Sindicada a regra de irrecorribilidade em revista prevista no art. 671?, 3, do CPC, para a modalidade normal interposta a t?tulo principal, verifica-se o bloqueio da ?dupla...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 9 juillet 2024, n° 1375/04.8TYLSBAM.L1.S1
Relator: RICARDO COSTA. I. A argui??o de nulidades do ac?rd?o final recorrido, proferido pela Rela??o, tendo por fundamento os arts. 615?, 1, 666?, 1, e 674?, 1, c), do CPC,...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 9 juillet 2024, n° 5677/17.5T8GMR-A.G1.S1
Relator: MARIA OLINDA GARCIA. A decis?o, proferida em a??o executiva, sobre a oposi??o ? penhora n?o ? suscet?vel de recurso de revista, porque tal se encontra vedado pelo artigo 854.?...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 9 juillet 2024, n° 3068/21.2T8STR.E1.S1
Relator: LEONEL SER?DIO. I-A an?lise cr?tica da prova a que se refere o artigo 607? n.? 4 do CPC, mormente por parte do Tribunal da Rela??o, n?o tem de ser...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 9 juillet 2024, n° 1871/23.8T8LRA-B.C1.S1
Relator: LUIS ESP?RITO SANTO. I ? ? ineg?vel a contradi??o l?gica que resulta da circunst?ncia de o cr?dito garantido pelo penhor ter prefer?ncia sobre o cr?dito laboral (artigo 666?, n?...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 9 juillet 2024, n° 1132/23.2T8OER-A.L1-A.S1
Relator: RICARDO COSTA. I. O Regulamento (UE) 1215/2012, relativo ? compet?ncia judici?ria, ao reconhecimento e ? execu??o de decis?es em mat?ria civil e comercial, tem aplica??o directa e priorit?ria na...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 9 juillet 2024, n° 170/09.2TBEPS-AN.G1.S1
Relator: MARIA OLINDA GARCIA. I- O art.? 172?, n.? 2 do CIRE estabelece regras para determinar o modo de pagamento das d?vidas da massa. II- Em primeiro lugar devem responder...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 9 juillet 2024, n° 4357/19.1T8LRA.C1.S1
Relator: MARIA CLARA SOTTOMAYOR. N?o se verifica a nulidade de ac?rd?o com base em excesso de pron?ncia (arts. 615.?, n.? 1, al. d), 2.? parte, 666.?, n.? 1, e 685.?,...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 9 juillet 2024, n° 12524/18.9T8LSB.L1.S1
Relator: HENRIQUE ANTUNES. I - Sempre que a admissibilidade do recurso dependa de uma fundamenta??o espec?fica, como por exemplo, a ofensa do caso julgado, h? que proceder ao distinguo entre...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 9 juillet 2024, n° 2830/18.8T8CSC.L1.S1
Relator: HENRIQUE ANTUNES. I - A admissibilidade da revista excepcional depende de uma fundamenta??o espec?fica, como, por exemplo, a necessidade, pela sua relev?ncia jur?dica, para uma melhor aplica??o do direito,...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 9 juillet 2024, n° 607/24.0T8GMR.G1.S1
Relator: JORGE LEAL. I. Enferma de ineptid?o a peti??o inicial onde n?o constam a causa de pedir e o pedido. II. N?o enferma de ineptid?o, por falta de causa se...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 9 juillet 2024, n° 1199/20.5T8AGD-A.P2.S1
Relator: JORGE LEAL. I. Tendo a Rela??o confirmado a decis?o da primeira inst?ncia, sem altera??o na fundamenta??o, mas com antecedente rejei??o da impugna??o da decis?o de facto, por alegado incumprimento...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 9 juillet 2024, n° 1591/17.2T8LOU-A.P1.S1
Relator: JORGE LEAL. I. A declara??o de d?vida, com assinatura reconhecida por not?rio, constitui t?tulo executivo, nos termos do art.? 703.? n.? 1 al. b) do CPC. II. A declara??o...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 9 juillet 2024, n° 414/22.5T8AGD-E.P1.S1
Relator: JORGE ARCANJO. No ?mbito do processo executivo, a compatibiliza??o entre o princ?pio do art.625 n?1 CPC ( casos julgados contradit?rios) e o disposto no art.729 f) CPC ( o...