Décisions de justice publiées par le cabinet
-
Court of Protection, 19 janvier 2023, n° [2023] EWCOP 2
MR JUSTICE HAYDEN: 1. This is an application brought by NHS Surrey Integrated Care Board (“the ICB”), in respect of the respondent, JH. The ICBare represented by Miss Sutton who...
-
Court of Appeal (Civil Division), 19 janvier 2023, n° [2023] EWCA Civ 12
Lady Justice Falk Introduction 1. This is an appeal from a decision of His Honour Judge Jarman QC (sitting as a Deputy High Court judge) on a Part 8 claim....
-
First-tier Tribunal (General Regulatory Chamber) – Information Rights, 19 janvier 2023, n° [2023] UKFTT 67 (GRC)
1. The Applicant has by Notice of Appeal dated 9 September 2022 applied for an order under s. 166 of the Data Protection Act 2018. 2. On 7 December 2022,...
-
Court of Appeal (Criminal Division), 19 janvier 2023, n° [2023] EWCA Crim 347
LORD JUSTICE LEWIS: 1. On 23 November 2021 in the Crown Court at St. Albans, Waseem Khan, Taswir Mohammed and Mohammed Jahangeer were convicted of conspiracy to supply a class...
-
Family Court (B - district and circuit judges), 19 janvier 2023, n° [2023] EWFC 345 (B)
HER HONOUR JUDGE SEARLE: 1. This is a final hearing in relation to two boys: B and C. B and C are both under the age of 8 and attend...
-
Upper Tribunal (Administrative Appeals Chamber), 19 janvier 2023, n° [2023] UKUT 4 (AAC)
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that this appeal be ALLOWED. SUBJECT MATTER:-Application for a standard international licence; good repute; offences sustained; CASES REFERRED TO:-NT/2013/82 Arnold Transport & Sons Ltd v DOENI;...
-
Court of Appeal (Criminal Division), 19 janvier 2023, n° [2023] EWCA Crim 70
LADY JUSTICE CARR: Introduction 1. We have before us an application by His Majesty's Solicitor General for leave to refer a sentence which he considers to be unduly lenient. On...
-
First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber), 19 janvier 2023, n° [2023] UKFTT 73 (TC)
Introduction 1. Danielle Katie Sexton and Emma Rachel Sexton (“the Taxpayers”) jointly acquired Flat 10, 42 Onslow Gardens, London, SW7 3PY (“the Flat”) on 19 January 2018. 2. On 11...
-
First-tier Tribunal (General Regulatory Chamber) – Environment, 19 janvier 2023, n° [2023] UKFTT 330 (GRC)
1. The appeal is dismissed. 2. Upon the agreement of Natural England on hearing the evidence of the appellant, the restoration notice imposed pursuant to the Regulatory Enforcement and Sanctions...
-
First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber), 19 janvier 2023, n° [2023] UKFTT 71 (TC)
1. The application submitted on 22 November 2022 by Jordan Jackson, officer of HM Revenue and Customs, was considered in hearing held in private of which notice was only given...
-
First-tier Tribunal (General Regulatory Chamber) – Information Rights, 19 janvier 2023, n° [2023] UKFTT 66 (GRC)
1. On 15 December 2022, I directed the parties to provide dates on which they could attend a case management hearing. I told Ms Raynor and her father Mr Kirby...
-
First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber), 19 janvier 2023, n° [2023] UKFTT 63 (TC)
Introduction and summary 1. This is Mr West’s application for permission to make late appeals in relation to assessments and closure notices issued in 2018, and in relation to penalties...
-
First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber), 19 janvier 2023, n° [2023] UKFTT 61 (TC)
Introduction 1. The Appellant appeals against a determination dated 26 March 2019 issued under regulation 80 of the Income Tax (Pay As You Earn) Regulations 2003 (the “Determination”). The Determination...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 janvier 2023, n° 15910/21.3T8PRT.P1.S1
Relator: NUNO ATA?DE DAS NEVES. N?o existe viola??o do princ?pio do contradit?rio, na vertente da proibi??o das decis?es surpresa, quando, embora podendo as partes ser ouvidas nos termos do art....
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 janvier 2023, n° 40939/21.8YIPRT-A.P1.S1
Relator: OLIVEIRA ABREU. I. Respeitando a decis?o sob escrut?nio a procedimento de simplifica??o e agiliza??o processual, proferida ao abrigo do dever de gest?o processual que imp?e ao Tribunal adotar a...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 janvier 2023, n° 1066/19.5T8VRL.G2.S1
Relator: SOUSA PINTO. I. N?o obstante a converg?ncia decis?ria das inst?ncias, quanto ao m?rito da causa, ? admiss?vel recurso de revista, nos termos gerais, do ac?rd?o proferido pela Rela??o em...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 janvier 2023, n° 1335/19.4T8MAI-A.P1.S1
Relator: NUNO ATA?DE DAS NEVES. I ? S? a altera??o da mat?ria de facto (provada ou n?o provada) que vier a implicar uma vers?o jur?dico-normativa do Ac?rd?o da Rela??o distinta...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 janvier 2023, n° 283/21.2YHLSB-C.L1.S1
Relator: TIB?RIO NUNES DA SILVA. I. N?o se assume como recusa de meio de prova (depoimento de parte) o despacho que, aferindo da impossibilidade de compar?ncia dos depoentes, cuja falta...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 janvier 2023, n° 3122/18.8T8VCT.G2.S1
Relator: MANUEL CAPELO. I. - O art. 139 ? ?nico do RTA determinando ser vedado aos ve?culos empregados em carreiras interurbanas tomar passageiros e respetivas bagagens, desde que o local...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 janvier 2023, n° 4587/18.3T8VIS.C1.S1
Relator: FERREIRA LOPES. I - Na execu??o de um contrato de presta??o de servi?os de fiscalidade e de contabilidade, ? dever do prestador de servi?os fazer o adequado enquadramento fiscal...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 janvier 2023, n° 25603/21.6T8LSB.L1.S1
Relator: NUNO PINTO OLIVEIRA. I.? Os actos pelos quais o Estado da Rep?blica de Angola concedeu ao Autor, ao abrigo da Junta Nacional de Sa?de, a possibilidade de receber o...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 janvier 2023, n° 1327/19.3T8LRA.C1.S1
Relator: NUNO PINTO OLIVEIRA. Em regra, o Supremo Tribunal de Justi?a n?o pode pronunciar-se sobre a alega??o de erro na aprecia??o das provas e/ou na fixa??o dos factos dados como...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 janvier 2023, n° 3160/16.5T8LRS-A.L1-A.S1
Relator: NUNO PINTO OLIVEIRA. Entre os corol?rios do ?nus de delimita??o do objecto e de fundamenta??o concludente da impugna??o da decis?o sobre a mat?ria de facto, consagrado no n.? 1...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 janvier 2023, n° 4060/19.2T8LRS.L1.S1
Relator: F?TIMA GOMES. I. O RJMA consagra o crit?rio do primado da vontade do benefici?rio n?o apenas na escolha do acompanhante, mas tamb?m das pessoas que dever?o cooperar com este,...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 janvier 2023, n° 682/18.7T8PVZ.P1.S1
Relator: F?TIMA GOMES. I. Ocorrendo interven??o principal provocada pelo lado ativo ? isto ? para intervir como autor, com vista a suprir a preteri??o do litiscons?rcio necess?rio activo ? n?o...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 janvier 2023, n° 38/20.1YFLSB
Relator: PEDRO BRANQUINHO DIAS. I - A sec??o de contencioso do STJ ? materialmente incompetente para apreciar o pedido de indemniza??o por danos alegadamente sofridos pelo autor em consequ?ncia de...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 janvier 2023, n° 9/22.3YFLSB
Relator: EDUARDO LOUREIRO. I - O art. 216.? da CRP consagra o princ?pio da dedica??o exclusiva do juiz como garantia da sua independ?ncia. II - O juiz ?, pela sua...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 janvier 2023, n° 28/21.7YFLSB
Relator: EDUARDO LOUREIRO. I - O prazo para a propositura de a??o administrativa de impugna??o de delibera??es do CSM - arts. 169.? e 170.?, n.? 1, ambos do EMJ -,...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 janvier 2023, n° 28/22YFLSB
Relator: MANUEL CAPELO. I ? ? admiss?vel a interven??o principal espont?nea de um terceiro num processo de impugna??o de um ato administrativo, exigindo-se que os interesses invocados pelo interveniente se...
-
Supremo Tribunal de Justiça, 19 janvier 2023, n° 79/22.4YGLSB-A
Relator: ANT?NIO LATAS. I - Diferentemente do que se verifica com os impedimentos, previstos nos arts. 39.? e 40.? do CPP, que constituem um conjunto de ?proibi??es? absolutas de o...