Your mother died in Lyon owning an apartment with a mortgage bigger than its likely sale price, a stack of unpaid bills, and three American children who want nothing to do with it. You each signed a renunciation, the French notaire nodded, and you flew home thinking the file was closed. Then a letter arrives: the succession has been declared vacante, the Domaine — the property arm of the French State — has been appointed curateur, and the apartment will be inventoried, managed, and sold by a civil servant. Did your renunciation really work? Who pays the bank now? Can a creditor still come after you in Ohio or California? And if the apartment turns out to be worth more than the debts, does the money sit in France forever or can your family still claim it? This guide answers each question in order: what your renunciation did and did not do, how the court declares vacancy and appoints the State curateur, how the house is sold and the creditors ranked, and the doors that remain open afterward — coming back into the succession, claiming a surplus, and closing your American tax file cleanly.
I. We Renounced the French Estate — Was That Final, and Did We Just Create a Vacant Succession?
Two things happened the day you renounced, and they must be kept separate. First, your personal legal bond with the estate was cut. Second, the estate itself did not disappear: somebody still owns the apartment, somebody still owes the bank, and if nobody steps forward the court hands the whole file to the State. This part explains the cut, then the handover.
A. Is my renunciation final, and what did I keep or lose?
Under Article 805 of the Civil Code, and I quote it word for word because every American heir should read it before signing anything: L’héritier qui renonce est censé n’avoir jamais été héritier. Sous réserve des dispositions de l’article 845, la part du renonçant échoit à ses représentants ; à défaut, elle accroît à ses cohéritiers ; s’il est seul, elle est dévolue au degré subséquent.
In plain English: a renouncing heir is deemed never to have been an heir at all. Your share does not vanish; it passes first to your own descendants by representation, failing that to your co-heirs, and if you were the only heir, to the next degree of kin. The practical consequence Americans miss is the first branch: when you renounce your French parent’s estate, your own children — even minors born and living in the United States — can become heirs in your place by representation. If the estate is underwater, each of them must renounce too, and for a minor child the renunciation needs the guardianship judge’s authorization. A French appellate court restated that exact requirement in 2025 when a lower court had refused vacancy precisely because, and I quote, il n’était pas justifié de la renonciation de l’ensemble des héritiers de M. [W] à la succession, d’autant que pour les héritiers mineurs, l’autorisation du juge des tutelles était requise
(Chambéry Court of Appeal, 1st Chamber, March 11, 2025, RG 24/01359). So count heads all the way down the family tree before you celebrate.
Renunciation does not strip you of everything. Article 845 of the Civil Code provides, again verbatim: L’héritier qui renonce à la succession peut cependant retenir le don entre vifs ou réclamer le legs à lui fait jusqu’à concurrence de la portion disponible à moins que le disposant ait expressément exigé le rapport en cas de renonciation.
Gifts your parent made you during life, and legacies left to you, can be kept up to the freely disposable portion, unless the donor expressly demanded return in case of renunciation. For American families where the parent wired money years ago toward a down payment or made lifetime gifts, that sentence decides whether the old money is safe: keep the gift documents, check whether the deed of gift imposed return on renunciation, and measure the gift against the disposable portion before assuming anything.
Timing protects you twice. First, Article 771 of the Civil Code states: L’héritier ne peut être contraint à opter avant l’expiration d’un délai de quatre mois à compter de l’ouverture de la succession.
Nobody — not the bank, not a co-heir, not the State — can force you to choose between acceptance and renunciation during the four months after death; that period runs from the death itself, the opening of the succession. Once it expires, pressure becomes possible: Article 772 continues: Dans les deux mois qui suivent la sommation, l’héritier doit prendre parti ou solliciter un délai supplémentaire auprès du juge lorsqu’il n’a pas été en mesure de clôturer l’inventaire commencé ou lorsqu’il justifie d’autres motifs sérieux et légitimes.
A creditor, a co-heir, a next-degree heir, or the State can serve you a formal summons to take sides, and you then have two months — extendable by the judge for serious reasons such as an unfinished inventory — to decide. Miss that extended window and the same article deems you a pure and simple acceptor, which is exactly how an undecided American abroad can wake up personally liable for French debts. At the far end, Article 780 closes the option after ten years: La faculté d’option se prescrit par dix ans à compter de l’ouverture de la succession. L’héritier qui n’a pas pris parti dans ce délai est réputé renonçant.
Ten years of silence from the death equals renunciation by operation of law — comforting, but a decade of limbo during which creditors act and the house decays is no strategy.
The deadliest trap for Americans is signing papers that look administrative but count as acceptance. Article 782 of the Civil Code defines the two acceptances: L’acceptation pure et simple peut être expresse ou tacite. Elle est expresse quand le successible prend le titre ou la qualité d’héritier acceptant dans un acte authentique ou sous seing privé. Elle est tacite quand le successible saisi fait un acte qui suppose nécessairement son intention d’accepter et qu’il n’aurait droit de faire qu’en qualité d’héritier acceptant.
On December 10, 2025, the Paris Court of Appeal applied that text to an heir who had signed the estate tax declaration drawn up by the notaire more than a year after the death, a declaration that named him as heir and liquidated his share at 102,558 euros, and who had also pocketed cash from estate bank accounts (Paris Court of Appeal, Pole 3 Chamber 1, December 10, 2025, RG 23/14881). The court held, and these are its own words: en signant la déclaration de succession, laquelle n’est pas seulement une obligation légale pour l’héritier acceptant et ne l’est d’ailleurs pas pour un héritier renonçant, [l’héritier] a fait acte d’acceptation de la succession
, confirmed by the cash he took. Then came the hammer, again verbatim: Son acceptation étant définitive, à défaut d’avoir agi en décharge d’une dette successorale dans les cinq mois de la connaissance d’une telle dette, [l’héritier] ne pouvait valablement renoncer à la succession de sa mère. Sont donc nuls l’acte de renonciation et, par voie de conséquence, l’acte de révocation de la renonciation.
Both the later renunciation and its attempted revocation were declared void. The rule behind the hammer is Article 786: L’héritier acceptant purement et simplement ne peut plus renoncer à la succession ni l’accepter à concurrence de l’actif net.
The same article offers one narrow escape — discharge from a debt you had legitimate reasons not to know about, where paying it would gravely burden your personal estate — but the action must be brought within five months of learning of the debt’s existence and size, a deadline that runs from your discovery, not from the death. For the American reader the lesson is brutally concrete and it connects to our earlier guide on how paying a French parent’s bills from America can count as tacit acceptance: never sign a French succession declaration, never take the title of heir in any paper, and never touch estate money before your renunciation is recorded, unless a French lawyer has cleared the exact document. Keep in mind that the declaration duty itself, Article 800-I of the General Tax Code, falls on Les héritiers, légataires ou donataires, leurs tuteurs ou curateurs, [qui] sont tenus de souscrire une déclaration détaillée
— heirs, legatees, and donees. Once you have validly renounced and kept nothing, you are none of those for the renounced share, because the declaration covers property à eux échus ou transmis par décès
, property that vested in you — and under Article 805 nothing vested in you.
B. How does the court declare the succession vacant and appoint the State as curateur?
Vacancy is a court finding, not an automatic status, and it has exactly three doors. Article 809 of the Civil Code provides the full text you should keep: La succession est vacante : 1° Lorsqu’il ne se présente personne pour réclamer la succession et qu’il n’y a pas d’héritier connu ; 2° Lorsque tous les héritiers connus ont renoncé à la succession ; 3° Lorsque, après l’expiration d’un délai de six mois depuis l’ouverture de la succession, les héritiers connus n’ont pas opté, de manière tacite ou expresse.
Your family most likely enters through the second door — every known heir renounced — but the third door matters enormously for Americans: six months after the death with no express or tacit choice by the known heirs, and the succession can be declared vacant even if nobody formally renounced. Silence from abroad, unanswered notaire letters, unsigned forms — after six months from the death, that drift alone can satisfy the statute. The Chambéry case proves the point has teeth: a creditor bank petitioned for vacancy where the direct heirs had renounced but some descendants had never taken sides, and the court held, and I quote the operative reasoning, that la succession, qui s’ouvre par le décès, est ouverte depuis [2019], soit depuis plus de 6 mois et il résulte du courriel du notaire en charge de cette succession, que les héritiers connus n’ont pas tous opté que ce soit de manière tacite ou expresse. Ainsi, en application des dispositions du 3° de l’article 809, les conditions de la vacance sont réunies
(Chambéry, March 11, 2025, RG 24/01359). Note who knocked on the courtroom door: the bank. The same decision confirms that a creditor holding an authentic loan deed is an admissible petitioner. Your parent’s French mortgage lender does not need your permission to start the vacancy procedure; it needs only its loan deed and six months of heir indecision — or your completed renunciations.
The petition goes to the local judge, and the cast of petitioners is deliberately wide. Article 809-1 of the Civil Code states: Le juge, saisi sur requête de tout créancier, de toute personne qui assurait, pour le compte de la personne décédée, l’administration de tout ou partie de son patrimoine, d’un notaire, de toute autre personne intéressée ou du ministère public, confie la curatelle de la succession vacante, dont le régime est défini à la présente section, à l’autorité administrative chargée du domaine. L’ordonnance de curatelle fait l’objet d’une publicité.
Any creditor, the notaire handling the file, any interested person, or the public prosecutor can file the request, and the judge entrusts the curatorship to the State property administration — in practice the DNID, the Direction nationale d’interventions domaniales, acting through the local public-finance director. The curatorship order is published, and so is everything important afterward. France’s official guidance for families describes the same sequence in everyday language: the Domaine has an inventory of assets and liabilities drawn up, publishes a curatorship-opening notice and the inventory in a legal-announcements newspaper so creditors or heirs can come forward, and administers the property — collecting what is owed, selling movable or immovable assets, especially after six months where needed to clear the deceased’s debts (economie.gouv.fr, preparing your retirement and succession). There is even a dedicated public portal where vacant successions can be searched and claimed (service-public.fr, settling an estate).
What the curateur finds first is fixed by statute. Article 809-2 orders: Dès sa désignation, le curateur fait dresser un inventaire estimatif, article par article, de l’actif et du passif de la succession par un commissaire-priseur judiciaire, un huissier ou un notaire, selon les lois et règlements applicables à ces professions, ou par un fonctionnaire assermenté appartenant à l’administration chargée du domaine.
Item by item, assets and liabilities, valued — the apartment, the bank balances, the mortgage, the tax arrears, the unpaid charges. Notice of that inventory goes through the same publication as the curatorship order, and creditors and money legatees who prove their title may consult the inventory, take a copy, and ask to be notified of every new publication. If you renounced but remain curious — or worried — about what the Lyon apartment really contained, that public inventory is your window, and our guide on how to read and challenge a French notaire’s succession bill explains the fee lines you will see in these files. A very recent decision shows the machine still runs exactly this way: on September 23, 2026, the Valenciennes judicial court declared vacant the succession of a man who died in 1999, appointed the regional public-finance director for Hauts-de-France and the Nord as curateur, and granted tous les droits et pouvoirs prévus aux articles 809 à 810-12 du Code Civil
, with a detailed work program — lifting seals, descriptive statement of furniture and securities, opening safe-deposit boxes, collecting rents and claims, signing leases up to nine years, insuring and repairing buildings, and settling minor priority costs such as appointment, seal, inventory, funeral, hospitalization, and last-illness expenses (TJ Valenciennes, September 23, 2026, RG 26/01832). Twenty-seven years after the death, the procedure was identical to the one your family faces today. One distinction to keep straight: vacancy is not escheat. When the State itself claims the estate of someone who died with no heir, or an abandoned succession, Article 811 requires it to seek a court order of envoi en possession: Lorsque l’Etat prétend à la succession d’une personne qui décède sans héritier ou à une succession abandonnée, il doit en demander l’envoi en possession au tribunal.
Curatorship administers for creditors and potential heirs; envoi en possession makes the State the owner. Your file is almost certainly in the first regime, which is good news, because the first regime keeps doors open that the second one closes — as Part II will show.
II. The State Curateur Has the House — How Is It Sold, Who Gets Paid, and What Can I Still Do?
The curateur is not the owner, not your agent, and not the bank’s agent either. It is a court-mandated administrator with one mission: turn the estate into money, pay the debts in legal order, and account to the judge. Understanding its powers tells you what happens to the apartment, and understanding its limits tells you where your family still has leverage.
A. How does the curateur sell the house and rank the creditors?
From the appointment, the curateur steps into the estate’s shoes. Article 810 of the Civil Code provides: Dès sa désignation, le curateur prend possession des valeurs et autres biens détenus par des tiers et poursuit le recouvrement des sommes dues à la succession.
Bank accounts are collected, rents are recovered, debts owed to the deceased are pursued. And the money goes nowhere private: Après prélèvement des frais d’administration, de gestion et de vente, il consigne les sommes composant l’actif de la succession ainsi que les revenus des biens et les produits de leur réalisation.
After administration, management, and sale costs, everything is consigned — deposited with the public consignments institution — including income from the property and sale proceeds. The same article adds a warning Americans should love: Les sommes provenant à un titre quelconque d’une succession vacante ne peuvent, en aucun cas, être consignées autrement que par l’intermédiaire du curateur.
No creditor, no neighbor, no self-appointed family representative can intercept the funds; every euro passes through the curateur’s hands and the public deposit.
Speed is throttled by design. Article 810-1 freezes major moves: Pendant les six mois qui suivent l’ouverture de la succession, le curateur ne peut procéder qu’aux actes purement conservatoires ou de surveillance, aux actes d’administration provisoire et à la vente des biens périssables.
For six months counted from the death — not from the appointment — only preservation, supervision, provisional administration, and sale of perishables. The apartment cannot be sold off in that window; it is insured, secured, and maintained. Then the freeze lifts and the sale engine starts: Article 810-2 states: A l’issue du délai mentionné à l’article 810-1, le curateur exerce l’ensemble des actes conservatoires et d’administration. Il procède ou fait procéder à la vente des biens meubles ou immeubles jusqu’à l’apurement du passif. Il procède ou fait procéder à la vente des biens dont la conservation est difficile ou onéreuse, alors même que leur réalisation n’est pas nécessaire à l’acquittement du passif.
The curateur sells movable and immovable property until the liabilities are cleared — and may sell hard- or expensive-to-keep property even beyond what the debts require. A Lyon apartment with heavy co-ownership charges and no tenant is exactly the kind of asset this last sentence targets. The sale itself follows strict rails under Article 810-3: La vente a lieu soit par commissaire de justice ou notaire selon les lois et règlements applicables à ces professions, soit par le tribunal, soit dans les formes prévues par le code général de la propriété des personnes publiques pour l’aliénation, à titre onéreux, du domaine immobilier ou du domaine mobilier appartenant à l’Etat. Elle donne lieu à publicité.
Public sale with publicity, through a commissioner of justice, a notaire, the court, or State-domain sale forms. And creditors get a democratic weapon the same article hands them: Lorsqu’il est envisagé une vente amiable, tout créancier peut exiger que la vente soit faite par adjudication.
If a private-treaty sale is planned, any creditor can demand a public auction instead — with a sting attached, since a creditor who forces an auction that fetches less than the agreed private price answers to the other creditors for their loss.
Who gets paid, and in what order, is where the mortgage bank’s confidence meets its limits. Article 810-4 sets the frame: Le curateur est seul habilité à payer les créanciers de la succession. Il n’est tenu d’acquitter les dettes de la succession que jusqu’à concurrence de l’actif.
Only the curateur pays, and only out of the estate’s assets — never out of your pocket, since you renounced. Immediate payments before the liabilities plan are restricted to les frais nécessaires à la conservation du patrimoine, les frais funéraires et de dernière maladie, les impôts dus par le défunt, les loyers et autres dettes successorales dont le règlement est urgent
: conservation costs, funeral and last-illness bills, taxes owed by the deceased, rent, and other urgent estate debts. The building insurance, the co-ownership charges keeping the roof intact, the property tax already due — those ride on estate funds, not on the renounced family. Then comes the master document: Article 810-5 requires that Le curateur dresse un projet de règlement du passif. Le projet prévoit le paiement des créances dans l’ordre prévu à l’article 796. Le projet de règlement est publié.
The liabilities-settlement plan follows the ranking of Article 796 — Il paye les créanciers inscrits selon le rang de la sûreté assortissant leur créance. Les autres créanciers qui ont déclaré leur créance sont désintéressés dans l’ordre des déclarations. Les legs de sommes d’argent sont délivrés après paiement des créanciers
— secured creditors by rank of their security, then declared unsecured creditors in order of their declarations, with cash legacies served only after creditors. Publication starts a one-month fuse: Les créanciers qui ne sont pas intégralement désintéressés peuvent, dans le mois de la publicité, saisir le juge afin de contester le projet de règlement.
Any creditor not fully paid has one month from publication to challenge the plan before the judge. Finally the curateur answers for everything under Article 810-7: Le curateur rend compte au juge des opérations effectuées par lui. Le dépôt du compte fait l’objet de publicité. Le curateur présente le compte à tout créancier ou tout héritier qui en fait la demande.
The account is filed, published, and shown on request to any creditor — or any heir, a status that can matter again in Part B.
The bank’s mortgage deserves its own paragraph because American heirs consistently overrate it. A mortgage recorded before death keeps its rank in the Article 796 order. But creditors who rush to register securities after the death gain nothing against the estate’s other creditors once vacancy is declared. The Cour de cassation settled this on January 5, 2022, in a case where judgment creditors had registered judicial mortgages on a Martinique property after the owner’s 2008 death and the Domaine, as curateur of the vacant succession, sued for release (Cass., 3rd Civil Chamber, January 5, 2022, No. 20-21.359, published in the Bulletin). The Court recites the rule word for word: Aux termes de l’article 2427, alinéa 2, du code civil, l’inscription ne produit aucun effet entre les créanciers d’une succession si elle n’a été faite par l’un d’eux que depuis le décès, dans le cas où la succession n’est acceptée qu’à concurrence de l’actif net ou est déclarée vacante.
A registration made after death produces no effect among the succession’s creditors where the estate is vacant. The Court then anchors the curateur’s exclusive role — En vertu des articles 810-4 et 810-5 du code civil, [le curateur] est seul habilité à payer les créanciers de la succession. Il dresse un projet de règlement du passif
— and draws the conclusion: la mainlevée d’une inscription hypothécaire faite postérieurement au décès peut être demandée par le curateur d’une succession déclarée vacante
, upholding the release of the post-death mortgages. For your family, the message is two-sided. The pre-existing mortgage bank is paid according to its rank out of the sale price, and if the price falls short, the unpaid balance dies with the estate — it does not follow you to America, because a renouncer deemed never to have been heir owes nothing, and the curateur pays only up to the assets. Conversely, if a creditor tries to improve its position after death with fresh registrations, vacancy neutralizes them. One related lock: money legacies in a will the deceased may have left are served only after creditors, and the curateur may only deliver particular or universal legacies once the Article 810-1 six-month period has run and no opposition stands — the combined effect of Articles 796 and 1343 of the Code of Civil Procedure, under which Le curateur ne peut délivrer les legs particuliers ou à titre universel consentis par le défunt qu’à l’issue du délai mentionné à l’article 810-1 du code civil et lorsqu’ils ne font l’objet d’aucune opposition.
If your parent left a cash legacy to a neighbor or a charity, it waits behind every creditor. And if your parent left a French handwritten will at all, our guide on writing and securing a French holographic will from America explains the formalities that decide whether that will even counts.
B. Can I come back, claim money, or at least control the damage?
Renunciation is not always a one-way door, and vacancy does not always mean the money is gone. Three scenarios, in increasing order of hope. First, you renounced too fast and the estate turns out solvent: perhaps the apartment appraises higher than feared, or a forgotten life-insurance policy surfaces. Article 807 of the Civil Code gives you a way back, and its wording is worth memorizing: Tant que la prescription du droit d’accepter n’est pas acquise contre lui, l’héritier peut révoquer sa renonciation en acceptant la succession purement et simplement, si elle n’a pas été déjà acceptée par un autre héritier ou si l’Etat n’a pas déjà été envoyé en possession.
As long as your ten-year option period is still running, you may revoke your renunciation by purely and simply accepting — unless another heir has already accepted, or the State has already been sent into possession. The acceptance backdates to the death, sans toutefois remettre en cause les droits qui peuvent être acquis à des tiers sur les biens de la succession par prescription ou par actes valablement faits avec le curateur à la succession vacante
: third-party rights acquired by prescription or by valid dealings with the vacant-succession curateur survive your return. In practice that means: come back before the apartment is sold and the price distributed, move fast once the inventory shows a surplus, and expect the curateur’s completed acts — insurance, leases, preservation sales — to stand. The Paris December 2025 decision shows the mirror limit: revocation is impossible where your earlier conduct already made you an acceptor — signing the declaration and taking cash — because an acceptor cannot renounce at all, so there is nothing left to revoke. Check your own paper trail before attempting a return: no declaration signed as heir, no funds taken, renunciation properly recorded.
Second, you do not want to come back, but you want the surplus if there is one. France’s official family guidance confirms the door stays ajar: even after vacancy, a person who is an heir or believes they are one may claim the succession by applying to the curateur — it is not automatic, the step must be taken (economie.gouv.fr). The same guidance explains the money path: sale proceeds and remaining assets first pay creditors, and with no claiming heir the net assets may be consigned; after a period — generally thirty years — they revert to the State if no heir has come forward. Thirty years is the guidance’s general horizon, not a personal deadline to test: the realistic window is the years while the curateur administers, before consignation scatters the file into the deposit system. Monitor the legal-announcements publications, request the curateur’s account under Article 810-7 — any heir may demand it — and file your claim with proof of kinship through the notaire or directly with the Domaine service named in the order, a search you can start on the vacant-successions portal. If the surplus eventually reaches you, remember the tax clock: Article 641 of the General Tax Code sets declaration deadlines of six mois, à compter du jour du décès, lorsque celui dont on recueille la succession est décédé en France métropolitaine ; d’une année, dans tous les autres cas
— six months from death for a death in metropolitan France, one year otherwise, here counted from the death, not from your claim. Late or missed filings draw penalties and interest against the estate’s funds, which is one more reason to surface early rather than at year twenty-nine; our walkthrough of missed French succession deadlines and how to fix them details the surcharges. Note the asymmetry that protects you: those penalties attach to the estate and its assets in the curateur’s hands, not to a renouncer’s American bank account.
Third, the damage-control checklist for the American who stays out. Confirm every renunciation in the chain is recorded — yours, your siblings’, and your children’s where representation pushed the share down to them — because one missing renunciation means one person still exposed, and a summons under Article 772 can turn their hesitation into deemed acceptance within two months of service. Keep the court clerk’s receipt of each renunciation forever; it is your proof that nothing vested in you and therefore nothing was taxable to you on the renounced share. Tell your American tax preparer in writing that you renounced a French succession, kept no asset from it, and received no distribution, and keep that letter with the French receipts — a renouncer who received nothing has no inheritance to report on either side of the Atlantic, while any lifetime gift you retained under Article 845 keeps its own history and paperwork. Do not sign, pay, or collect anything stamped with the estate’s name: no declaration as heir, no mortgage installment paid from your funds, no rent collected from the apartment, no repair ordered in your name — each such act reopens the tacit-acceptance analysis of Article 782 that the Paris court applied so strictly. If a French creditor writes to you personally in English demanding payment, answer once, in writing, that you are not an heir, attach the renunciation receipt, and stop: the creditor’s remedy lies in the vacancy procedure against the estate, through the curateur and the Article 810-5 plan, not against your American assets. And if the estate contained a mortgaged property with negative equity, read our companion analysis of debts, mortgages, and the three options of an American heir before deciding whether anyone in the family should accept up to net assets instead of renouncing — sometimes the capped acceptance preserves more than flight.
Conclusion
When every American heir renounces a French estate, the file does not close — it changes hands. The court declares the succession vacant once all known heirs have renounced or six months have passed since the death without any express or tacit choice, entrusts the Domaine as curateur, and the administration runs its public course: itemized inventory, published notices, preservation for six months from the death, then sale of the property with publicity, payment of creditors in the order of Article 796 through a published plan challengeable within one month, and a full account rendered to the judge. Post-death mortgage registrations are neutralized among creditors, the unpaid balance of an underwater loan dies with the estate, and a renouncer deemed never to have been heir is not the payer of last resort. Your renunciation stands or falls on paperwork discipline — no declaration signed as heir, no estate money touched — and your descendants must renounce in turn where representation carried the share to them, with the guardianship judge’s authorization for minors. Two doors stay open afterward: revoking the renunciation by accepting while the ten-year option runs, provided no other heir accepted and the State was never sent into possession; and claiming a surplus from the curateur before consignation carries it out of reach. Watch the publications, demand the account, calendar the six-month and one-month fuses from the cited texts, and keep every renunciation receipt where your American tax file can find it. The vacant succession is not a punishment for renouncing — it is the French legal system’s way of settling the debts without you, provided you truly stayed out.