The firm in the media
Watch the videos and read their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, appeal procedure in Paris
Appeal lawyer in Paris: appealing a judgment or defending an appeal
Time limits for appealing, the notice of appeal (déclaration d'appel), written submissions (conclusions) within the time limits of Articles 908 et seq. of the French Code of Civil Procedure (Code de procédure civile), postulation (the right to act as lawyer of record before a given court), procedural applications before the case management judge (conseiller de la mise en état), provisional enforcement (exécution provisoire): as your appeal lawyer in Paris, the firm represents appellants and respondents alike before the Paris Court of Appeal (cour d'appel de Paris), in civil, commercial and employment matters. Appeal proceedings are written and confined within short time limits, and missing one can extinguish the appeal.
The firm can be reached 24/7. The time limit for appealing is one month in contentious matters (Article 538 of the Code of Civil Procedure); as a rule, it runs from notification of the judgment (Article 528). The appellant then has three months from the notice of appeal to file its submissions with the court registry (greffe), failing which the notice of appeal lapses (caducité) (Article 908).
4,9/5
Average Google rating270 reviews
I received very high-quality support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective defence in criminal law.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer. He got me out of trouble in a protection order case brought abusively by my ex
Very satisfied with the solution found for my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, with great empathy and a strong sense of humanity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen carefully and to fully understand my situation. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, caring and available, and who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Urgent matters 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer (avocat) at the Paris Bar, appeal procedure in civil, commercial and employment matters, representation before the court of appeal.
Official profile in the directory of French lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 1 November 2026.
Quick answer
Subject to the jurisdiction conferred on other courts, the court of appeal (cour d'appel) hears appeals against civil and criminal first-instance court decisions subject to appeal, and makes its own determination on the merits (Article L. 311-1 of the Code of Judicial Organisation, Code de l'organisation judiciaire). An appeal reopens what was decided: the case is ruled on afresh, in fact and in law (Article 561 of the Code of Civil Procedure), within the limits of the heads of the judgment's operative part that are challenged (Article 562). The time limit is one month in contentious matters (Article 538). Before the court, a party must appoint a lawyer, unless otherwise provided (Article 899), and that lawyer must have the right to act as lawyer of record before that court (Article 5 of the Law of 31 December 1971). The procedure follows strict time limits: three months for the appellant's first submissions and three months for the respondent's, on pain of lapse or inadmissibility (Articles 908 and 909). In their current wording, these rules derive from Decree No. 2023-1391 of 29 December 2023, which applies to appeals brought since 1 September 2024, and were amended by Decree No. 2026-683 of 27 July 2026, which came into force on 1 October 2026. Kohen Avocats, in the 16th arrondissement of Paris, acts for appellants and respondents alike before the Paris Court of Appeal (cour d'appel de Paris). Contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
A judgment to challenge, an appeal brought against you, a time limit already running?
Understanding your situation
How to appeal a court decision in France: the procedure, explained
By challenging the judgment, an appeal seeks to have it varied or set aside by the court of appeal (Article 542 of the Code of Civil Procedure). Below: the time limits for appealing, the steps before the court, the role of the lawyer of record (avocat postulant), the sanctions to avoid, provisional enforcement and the appeal on points of law (pourvoi en cassation) to the French Supreme Court (Cour de cassation).
Key points
Appealing a judgment in France: four checks before filing the notice of appeal
An appealable decision, an interest in appealing, a time limit that is still open, the right court.
An appealable decision: an appeal lies in all matters, even non-contentious ones, against first-instance judgments, unless otherwise provided (Article 543). Judgments that decide all or part of the main claim, or that bring the proceedings to an end, may be appealed immediately (Article 544); other judgments may be appealed independently of the judgment on the merits only in the cases specified by law (Article 545).
An interest in appealing: the right of appeal belongs to any party with an interest in appealing, unless it has waived that right (Article 546). The respondent may, for its part, bring a cross-appeal (appel incident) against the appellant or against the other respondents (Article 548).
A time limit that is still open: one month in contentious matters and fifteen days in non-contentious matters (Article 538), from notification of the judgment, unless the law makes it run from the date the judgment is delivered (Article 528). The time limit is extended by one month for persons living in France's overseas territories and by two months for persons living abroad, where the court sits in metropolitan France (Article 643).
The right court: unless otherwise provided, the court of appeal hears appeals against judgments of the courts located within its territorial jurisdiction (Article R. 311-3 of the Code of Judicial Organisation). In the Paris region (Île-de-France), the postulation rule in Article 5-1 of the Law of 31 December 1971 links the judicial courts (tribunaux judiciaires) of Paris, Bobigny and Créteil with the Paris Court of Appeal, and the judicial court of Nanterre with the Versailles Court of Appeal.
The time limit is calculated to the exact day. It expires at midnight on the last day, and a time limit that would expire on a Saturday, a Sunday or a public holiday or non-working day is extended until the next working day (Article 642). The notification document must state very conspicuously the time limit for appealing and how the appeal may be brought (Article 680): reading it carefully is the firm's first step. A judgment that is never notified does not leave the time limit open indefinitely: if notification does not take place within two years of delivery, the party that appeared can no longer lodge a main appeal (Article 528-1). The Cour de cassation specifies, however, that “where a party lodges an appeal, even an inadmissible one, within two years of the delivery of the decision, this time bar does not apply” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 17 May 2018, No. 17-14.291).
The time limit for appealing and an appeal brought within it suspend enforcement of the judgment (Article 539), but this rule gives way to provisional enforcement: first-instance decisions are provisionally enforceable as of right, unless the law or the decision provides otherwise (Article 514). In most cases, therefore, appealing does not prevent the other party from enforcing the judgment. An abusive appeal also comes at a price: where a main appeal is dilatory or abusive, the appellant may be ordered to pay a civil fine of up to €10,000, without prejudice to damages (Article 559).
The procedure
From the notice of appeal to the ruling: the steps and their time limits
A written procedure, conducted electronically, in which each step has its own time limit and its own sanction.
Notice of appeal
An appeal is brought by a unilateral notice of appeal or by a joint application (Article 900). The notice states, among other things, the parties, the appointment of the appellant's lawyer, the decision challenged, the purpose of the appeal (reversal or setting aside) and the heads of the judgment's operative part that are expressly challenged, unless the appeal seeks to have the judgment set aside; filing it with the court registry counts as a request to enter the case on the court's list (Article 901). It must be filed electronically, failing which it is inadmissible (Article 930-1).
Notice to the respondents
The court clerk sends the notice of appeal to each respondent, stating that a lawyer must be appointed. If no lawyer is appointed within the month, the appellant's lawyer must serve the notice of appeal within the month following the registry's notice, failing which the notice of appeal lapses (Article 902).
Case allocation
The First President of the court of appeal (premier président) assigns the case to a chamber (Article 904). The presiding judge of that chamber allocates the case either to an expedited hearing (bref délai) with a foreseeable closing date, or to a case management judge; the registry's notice invites the parties to enter into a participatory procedure agreement for case preparation (convention de procédure participative aux fins de mise en état) or, since 1 October 2026, a simplified case management agreement (convention de mise en état simplifiée) (Article 905).
Fast track
The expedited hearing applies in particular to appeals against an urgent-application order (ordonnance de référé), a judgment given under the accelerated procedure on the merits or a protection order (ordonnance de protection) (Article 906). The appellant serves the notice of appeal within twenty days of the notice setting the hearing date (Article 906-1), then each party has two months to file submissions (Article 906-2).
Case management
The appellant files its submissions within three months of the notice of appeal, failing which the notice of appeal lapses (Article 908). The respondent has three months from notification of those submissions to file its own and to bring a cross-appeal, failing which they are inadmissible (Article 909); the same time limit applies to a respondent to a cross-appeal and to an intervening party (Article 910). Submissions are notified to the lawyers within the time limit for filing them (Article 911).
Closure and ruling
Within the month following the expiry of the time limits for filing submissions, the case management judge reviews the case and sets the date of closure and the date of the oral hearing, or a timetable if further exchanges are needed (Article 912). Closure is ordered by an order that states no reasons (Article 914).
The case management judge plays a central role. The judge ensures that the proceedings are conducted fairly, in particular that submissions are exchanged and documents disclosed on time, and may order the parties to meet a conciliator or a mediator (Article 913). Once appointed, the judge alone has power to declare the notice of appeal lapsed, to declare the appeal or the submissions inadmissible, to rule on procedural objections relating to the appeal, to award an interim payment or to order an investigative measure; the judge is seised by submissions specifically addressed to him or her (Article 913-5). As a rule, the judge's orders cannot be challenged independently of the court's ruling, except by referral to the court (déféré) within fifteen days where they bring the proceedings to an end or rule, in particular, on lapse or on the admissibility of the appeal (Article 913-8).
The time limits for filing submissions are interrupted by an order to meet a conciliator or a mediator, by the conclusion of a participatory procedure agreement for case preparation or of a simplified case management agreement, and by a summons to an amicable settlement hearing (audience de règlement amiable) (Article 915-3). As for the transitional rules, Decree No. 2023-1391 applies “to appeal proceedings brought from that date” (our translation), namely 1 September 2024 (Article 16 of Decree No. 2023-1391). Decree No. 2026-683 of 27 July 2026 came into force on 1 October 2026 and “applies to proceedings pending on that date” (our translation), subject to the exceptions it provides for (Article 21 of Decree No. 2026-683). The firm therefore first checks the date of the notice of appeal, which determines the applicable rules.
Representation
Lawyer of record (avocat postulant): who can represent you before the court of appeal
Appointing a lawyer is mandatory; that lawyer must also have the right to act as lawyer of record before the court hearing the appeal.
Before the court of appeal, the parties must, unless otherwise provided, appoint a lawyer, and that appointment entails election of domicile at the lawyer's office (Article 899). The appointed lawyer is the lawyer of record (avocat postulant): the mandate to represent a party in court carries the power and the duty to perform the procedural acts on the client's behalf (Article 411). The lawyer of record may be different from the lawyer who pleads the case. Lawyers may plead without territorial limits, but they may act as lawyers of record only before the judicial courts within the territorial jurisdiction of the court of appeal where they have established their professional residence, and before that court of appeal (Article 5 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971).
The Paris region (Île-de-France) has its own rule. Lawyers registered with the Paris, Bobigny, Créteil or Nanterre Bar may act as lawyers of record before each of these judicial courts; they “may act as lawyers of record before the Paris Court of Appeal when they have acted as such before one of the judicial courts of Paris, Bobigny and Créteil, and before the Versailles Court of Appeal when they have acted as such before the judicial court of Nanterre” (our translation) (Article 5-1 of the Law of 31 December 1971). An isolated order of the case management judge of the Paris Court of Appeal took a restrictive reading of this rule: it held that “a lawyer of the Bobigny Bar may not act as lawyer of record before the Paris Court of Appeal, without restriction, for all decisions appealable to the Paris Court of Appeal” (our translation), and declared void a notice of appeal filed by a lawyer who had not been the lawyer of record at first instance (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 13, ord., 7 July 2026, No. 25/13960). This reading is open to debate in light of Article 5, paragraph 2, of the same Law, from which Article 5-1 is presented as an exception, and which allows lawyers to act as lawyers of record before the judicial courts within the territorial jurisdiction of the court of appeal where they have established their professional residence, and before that court. Such an order may, moreover, be referred to the court (Article 913-8). The right to act as lawyer of record is therefore checked before the notice of appeal is filed, not after.
You are the appellant
- File the notice of appeal within the time limit and set out in it the heads of the judgment's operative part that are challenged.
- File and notify the submissions within three months, with an operative part that asks for the judgment to be reversed or set aside.
- Set out all claims on the merits in the first submissions, and prepare the question of provisional enforcement.
You are the respondent
- Appoint a lawyer without delay and check the validity of the notice of appeal, its devolutive effect and its service.
- File submissions within three months of notification of the other side's submissions and, where appropriate, bring a cross-appeal.
- Where appropriate, apply for the case to be removed from the list for non-compliance with the judgment before your own time limits expire.
Changing lawyer on appeal is possible, but not without care. A party that dismisses its lawyer must immediately arrange a replacement (Article 418), and where representation is mandatory, the lawyer can withdraw only from the day on which a new representative is appointed (Article 419). The Cour de cassation infers from this that “the message by which the lawyer informs the court of appeal that they no longer represent the appellants has no effect on the lawyer's mandate of representation, and the lawyer continues to represent the party until a new lawyer is appointed” (our translation); in that case, the referral (déféré) lodged out of time by the appellants was declared inadmissible (Cass. 2e civ., 23 November 2023, No. 21-23.405). The firm takes over, during proceedings, the appeal cases entrusted to it, after identifying the time limits that are still open.
What the firm checks on receiving an appeal file:
The sanctions
Lapse, inadmissibility, devolutive effect: what can extinguish an appeal
Appeals are often lost on procedure; these sanctions must be anticipated from the notice of appeal onwards.
Lapse (caducité): the notice of appeal lapses if the appellant does not file its submissions within three months (Article 908), or within two months on the fast track (Article 906-2), or if it does not serve the notice of appeal within the prescribed time limit (Articles 902 and 906-1), or if it does not notify its submissions to the other parties' lawyers within the time limit for filing them (Article 911).
Inadmissibility of submissions: a respondent that does not file submissions within three months of notification of the appellant's submissions has its submissions declared inadmissible (Article 909), and can no longer bring a main appeal against the judgment if it has not brought a cross-appeal within that time limit (Article 916).
Devolutive effect: an appeal refers to the court only the heads of the judgment's operative part that are expressly challenged and those that depend on them, unless the appeal seeks to have the judgment set aside (Article 562); the appellant may add to, remove or correct them in the operative part of its first submissions (Article 915-2).
Concentration: the parties must set out all their claims on the merits in their first submissions, on pain of inadmissibility raised by the court of its own motion (Article 915-2).
New claims: they are inadmissible, except to claim set-off, to defeat the other side's claims, or to have the court rule on issues arising from the intervention of a third party or from the occurrence or discovery of a fact (Article 564); claims that pursue the same ends are not new (Article 565).
No second appeal: a party whose notice of appeal has lapsed, or whose appeal has been declared inadmissible, can no longer bring a main appeal against the same judgment and against the same party (Article 916).
Lapse is raised by the court of its own motion. In an order of 1 July 2026, the judge in charge of case management at the Paris Court of Appeal found that the appellant, who had appealed on 27 February 2026, had not filed submissions within three months, and drew the consequence: “the lapse of his notice of appeal must be declared” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 1, ord., 1 July 2026, No. 26/04487). The case management judge may, at a party's request or of the judge's own motion, extend or shorten these time limits; otherwise, only force majeure allows a party to escape the sanction, which the text now defines as a circumstance not attributable to the party's own conduct and which is insurmountable for that party (Article 911). Under former Article 910-3, applicable to an appeal of 16 August 2024, the Aix-en-Provence Court of Appeal reversed an order declaring the notice of appeal lapsed, the appellant's lawyer having shown “insurmountable circumstances and that he had been unable to practise his profession during the period in which the time limit for filing the appeal submissions expired” (our translation), following a road accident (CA Aix-en-Provence, ch. 3-1, 30 October 2025, No. 25/01487).
The notice of appeal determines the devolutive effect. Under the former wording of Article 562, the Cour de cassation held that “where the notice of appeal seeks variation of the judgment without mentioning the heads of the judgment that are challenged, the devolutive effect does not operate, even if the plea that the notice of appeal was void on that same ground has been rejected” (our translation): a notice that describes itself as a total appeal, without identifying any head of judgment, refers no claim to the court (Cass. 2e civ., 19 May 2022, No. 21-10.685). Under the current rules, it has given the opinion that Article 915-2 “establishes a mere option available to the appellant” (our translation) and that, if the appellant does not use it, mentioning the challenged heads of judgment in the notice of appeal produces the devolutive effect, “without the appellant being required to mention them again in the operative part of its first submissions” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., avis, 20 November 2025, No. 25-70.017).
Finally, the operative part of the submissions governs what the court decides. Ruling on a notice of appeal of 2 July 2021, and therefore under the rules that preceded Decree No. 2023-1391, the Cour de cassation held that the operative part of the appellant's first submissions “must contain a claim expressly seeking reversal or setting aside of the judgment under appeal” (our translation); failing that, the court “can only uphold the judgment, save for its power to raise the lapse of the appeal of its own motion” (our translation), and in that case it was lapse that was applied (Cass. 2e civ., 30 April 2025, No. 22-23.482). Under the current text, the requirement is spelled out in Article 954: the operative part is the one “in which the appellant states whether it seeks the setting aside or the reversal of the judgment” (our translation). A ground, by contrast, need only be set out in the discussion: the court of appeal rules only on the claims set out in the operative part and examines grounds only if they are raised in the discussion (Article 954), and a court of appeal was censured for disregarding an indemnity scale relied on in the body of the submissions in support of claims quantified in the operative part (Cass. 2e civ., 22 May 2025, No. 22-21.399). See our articles on challenged heads of judgment and the request for reversal and on the concentration of claims under Article 915-2.
Around the appeal
Provisional enforcement, appeal to the Cour de cassation and appeals covered on their own page
Stopping enforcement of the judgment, avoiding removal from the list, considering an appeal to the Cour de cassation, and appeals specific to a field of law.
Provisional enforcement is argued before the First President. On appeal, the First President may be asked to stay provisional enforcement as of right where there is a serious ground for setting aside or varying the judgment and enforcement is likely to have manifestly excessive consequences; a party that appeared at first instance without making observations on provisional enforcement must also show manifestly excessive consequences that came to light after the decision (Article 514-3). Where provisional enforcement was ordered by the judge, the First President may stay it only if it is prohibited by law, or where there is a serious ground for setting aside or varying the judgment and enforcement is likely to have manifestly excessive consequences (Article 517-1). For the First President of the Paris Court of Appeal, a serious ground for variation “is one that has a reasonable chance of success” (our translation), and “The two conditions laid down in the aforementioned Article 514-3 are cumulative.” (our translation): the application was dismissed because no manifestly excessive consequences had been established (CA Paris, pôle 1, ch. 5, ord., 14 April 2026, No. 25/20007).
An appellant that does not comply with the judgment risks having the case removed from the list (radiation). At the request of the respondent, made before its own time limits for filing submissions expire, the First President or the case management judge may remove the case from the court's list where the appellant cannot show that it has complied with the decision or deposited the sums due, unless compliance would have manifestly excessive consequences or is impossible (Article 524). This application is distinct from an application to stay provisional enforcement: a ruling of inadmissibility made by the First President in urgent proceedings (référé) does not dispense with examining the application for removal, which “does not pursue the same objective and is not based on the same criteria” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 11 June 2026, No. 24-11.444). Since 1 October 2026, the period after which the proceedings are extinguished for want of prosecution (péremption) runs from the decision ordering removal from the list (Article 524), and the proceedings are extinguished where none of the parties takes any step for two years (Article 386). Under the former wording, which made this period run from notification, the Cour de cassation quashed a ruling that had made it run earlier (Cass. 2e civ., 21 May 2026, No. 23-20.561); for removals ordered before 1 October 2026 that had not been notified, a new period runs from that date (Article 21 of Decree No. 2026-683). See our article on removal from the list and extinction for want of prosecution since the Decree of 27 July 2026.
After the court of appeal's ruling, an appeal to the Cour de cassation (pourvoi) remains possible. It lies only against decisions against which no ordinary appeal lies (Article 605) and seeks to have the decision censured for failing to comply with the rules of law (Article 604): the Cour de cassation does not retry the facts. The time limit is two months, unless otherwise provided (Article 612); the parties must appoint a lawyer admitted to the Conseil d'État and the Cour de cassation, unless otherwise provided (Article 973), and the brief setting out the grounds must be filed within four months of the appeal, on pain of forfeiture (Article 978). An appeal to the Cour de cassation does not suspend enforcement unless the law provides otherwise (Article 579).
Criminal appeals: an appeal against a judgment of the criminal court (tribunal correctionnel) or of the police court (tribunal de police) is governed by the Code of Criminal Procedure, with its own time limits. See our page criminal appeal lawyer in Paris.
Employment tribunal appeals: an appeal against a judgment of the employment tribunal (conseil de prud'hommes) follows rules specific to employment law. See our page appealing an employment tribunal judgment.
Appeals against decisions of the family court judge (JAF): divorce, parental authority, maintenance. See our page appealing a family court judge's (JAF) judgment in Paris.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Thirteen detailed answers, based on the texts in force and on verified decisions.
What does an appeal lawyer do before a French court of appeal?
The lawyer represents the party, whether appellant or respondent, in a written procedure where almost everything turns on the procedural documents. Before the court, the parties must, unless otherwise provided, appoint a lawyer (Article 899 of the Code of Civil Procedure), and the mandate of representation carries the power and the duty to perform the procedural acts on the client's behalf (Article 411). An appeal reopens what was decided: the case is ruled on afresh, in fact and in law (Article 561), but only on the heads of the judgment's operative part that the appeal challenges and on those that depend on them (Article 562).
The lawyer's work begins before the notice of appeal: checking the time limit, the court with jurisdiction and the lawyer's own right to act as lawyer of record, then choosing the heads of the judgment to challenge, which must appear in the notice of appeal (Article 901). The lawyer then drafts the submissions, which set out separately a statement of the facts and the procedure, a discussion of the claims and grounds, and an operative part in which the appellant states whether it seeks the setting aside or the reversal of the judgment (Article 954). The lawyer also conducts procedural applications before the case management judge, who alone has power over lapse, inadmissibility of the appeal or of submissions, and procedural objections relating to the appeal (Article 913-5).
The firm acts for appellants and respondents alike, and for the party seeking or opposing a stay of provisional enforcement of the judgment before the First President.
What is the time limit to appeal a judgment in France?
One month in contentious matters and fifteen days in non-contentious matters (Article 538 of the Code of Civil Procedure), unless a specific provision applies. The time limit runs from notification of the judgment, unless the law makes it run from the date the judgment is delivered, and it runs even against the party giving notification (Article 528). It expires at midnight on the last day, and it is extended until the next working day if it expires on a Saturday, a Sunday or a public holiday or non-working day (Article 642). It is extended by one month for persons living in France's overseas territories and by two months for persons living abroad, where the court sits in metropolitan France (Article 643).
The notification document must state very conspicuously the time limit for appealing and how the appeal may be brought (Article 680). If the judgment has never been notified, the time limit does not remain open indefinitely: the party that appeared can no longer lodge a main appeal two years after delivery, for judgments that decide the whole of the main claim or bring the proceedings to an end (Article 528-1). The Cour de cassation holds that “where a party lodges an appeal, even an inadmissible one, within two years of the delivery of the decision, this time bar does not apply” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 17 May 2018, No. 17-14.291).
A cross-appeal follows other rules: subject to the time limits for filing submissions, it may be brought at any stage, even by a party that is time-barred from bringing a main appeal, but it falls away if the main appeal is inadmissible or has lapsed (Article 550). Send the notification document to the firm as soon as you receive it: the date it bears sets the whole timetable.
Can you appeal a judgment in France without a lawyer?
As a general rule, no. Before the court of appeal, the parties must appoint a lawyer, unless otherwise provided, and the appointment entails election of domicile at the lawyer's office (Article 899 of the Code of Civil Procedure). The notice of appeal is made by the appointed lawyer, who dates and signs it (Article 901), and procedural documents are filed with the court electronically, on pain of inadmissibility raised by the court of its own motion (Article 930-1).
Some matters fall under a procedure without mandatory representation, where the law so provides. The parties then conduct their own case, with the option of being assisted or represented under the rules that apply before the court that gave the judgment (Article 931), and the appeal is brought by a declaration that the party or any authorised representative makes at, or sends by registered post to, the registry of the court (Article 932). Before going without a lawyer, you therefore need to check which procedure applies to the decision under appeal.
Even where representation is not mandatory, an appeal remains a technical remedy: the court rules only on the heads of the judgment referred to it (Article 562), and new claims are in principle inadmissible (Article 564). See our article on appealing a judgment of the social division (pôle social) and representation. From the first review, the firm tells you whether representation is mandatory in your case.
What is a lawyer of record (avocat postulant) at the court of appeal?
It is the appointed lawyer, the one who represents the party and performs the procedural acts on its behalf (Articles 411 and 899 of the Code of Civil Procedure). The lawyer of record may also plead, or work with another lawyer who pleads: lawyers may plead before all courts without territorial limits, but they may act as lawyers of record only before the judicial courts within the territorial jurisdiction of the court of appeal where they have established their professional residence, and before that court of appeal (Article 5 of the Law of 31 December 1971). A lawyer from another area who keeps the case on appeal must therefore work with a lawyer of record registered within the territorial jurisdiction of the court hearing the appeal.
In the Paris region (Île-de-France), lawyers of the Paris, Bobigny, Créteil and Nanterre Bars may act as lawyers of record before each of these judicial courts; they may act as lawyers of record before the Paris Court of Appeal when they have done so before one of the judicial courts of Paris, Bobigny and Créteil, and before the Versailles Court of Appeal when they have done so before the judicial court of Nanterre (Article 5-1 of the Law of 31 December 1971). In an isolated order, whose restrictive reading is open to debate in light of Article 5, paragraph 2, of the same Law, the case management judge of the Paris Court of Appeal declared a notice of appeal void, holding that “the notice of appeal of Mr and Mrs [K] is declared void for lack of power of their lawyer of record to represent them in court” (our translation), as the lawyer from the Bobigny Bar had not been the lawyer of record at first instance (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 13, ord., 7 July 2026, No. 25/13960).
The firm, registered with the Paris Bar, checks this point before any notice of appeal is filed, and acts as lawyer of record before the Paris Court of Appeal under the conditions laid down by these texts.
How long does an appeal take at a French court of appeal?
No text sets the total length of appeal proceedings: it depends on the chamber, on how the case is allocated and on procedural incidents. The texts do, however, set the time limits imposed on the parties, which give the minimum timetable. On the standard track, the appellant has three months from the notice of appeal to file its submissions (Article 908 of the Code of Civil Procedure), then the respondent has three months from their notification to file submissions and bring a cross-appeal (Article 909), the respondent to that cross-appeal having three months in turn (Article 910). The case management judge then reviews the case within the month following the expiry of the time limits for filing submissions and sets the closure and the oral hearing, or a timetable if further exchanges are needed (Article 912).
The fast track is quicker. Where the case is set down for an expedited hearing, in particular on appeal against an urgent-application order (ordonnance de référé) or a protection order (Article 906), the appellant serves the notice of appeal within twenty days of the notice setting the hearing date (Article 906-1), and each party has two months to file submissions (Article 906-2).
Some events suspend or lengthen the timetable: the case management judge may extend or shorten the time limits (Article 911), and the time limits for filing submissions are interrupted by a decision directing the parties to meet a court conciliator or a mediator, or ordering conciliation or mediation, where the conclusion of a participatory procedure agreement for case preparation or of a simplified case management agreement is shown, and by a summons to an amicable settlement hearing (Article 915-3). An application to remove the case from the list for non-compliance with the judgment also suspends the respondent's time limits (Article 524). The firm sends you the timetable of your case as soon as it is appointed, and updates it with each notice from the registry.
What must a notice of appeal contain in France?
On pain of nullity, the notice of appeal states the identity of each appellant and respondent, the appointment of the appellant's lawyer, the court to which the appeal is brought, the decision challenged, the purpose of the appeal (reversal or setting aside of the judgment) and the heads of the judgment's operative part that are expressly challenged, unless the appeal seeks to have the judgment set aside (Article 901 of the Code of Civil Procedure). It may include an annex; it is dated and signed by the appointed lawyer and accompanied by a copy of the decision, and filing it with the court registry counts as a request to enter the case on the court's list.
The challenged heads of judgment define what the court will decide: an appeal refers to the court only the heads of the judgment's operative part that it expressly challenges and those that depend on them, the whole case being referred where the appeal seeks to have the judgment set aside (Article 562). Under the former wording of that text, the Cour de cassation held that a notice of appeal seeking variation of the judgment without mentioning the challenged heads produced no devolutive effect (Cass. 2e civ., 19 May 2022, No. 21-10.685). The current text allows the appellant to add to, remove or correct those heads in the operative part of its first submissions (Article 915-2); if the appellant does not do so, the Cour de cassation is of the opinion that the heads mentioned in the notice of appeal are referred to the court, “without the appellant being required to mention them again in the operative part of its first submissions” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., avis, 20 November 2025, No. 25-70.017).
The firm drafts the notice of appeal head by head, working from the operative part of the judgment. See our article on a notice of appeal that omits the challenged heads of judgment.
What is the lapse (caducité) of a notice of appeal in France?
It is the extinction of the appeal because the appellant failed to take in time a step that the rules require of it: filing its submissions within three months of the notice of appeal (Article 908 of the Code of Civil Procedure), or within two months of the notice setting the hearing date on the fast track (Article 906-2), or serving the notice of appeal within the prescribed time limits (Articles 902 and 906-1). On the standard track, the case management judge declares it, after inviting the parties' written observations, by an order that cannot be revoked (Article 911) and that may be referred to the court within fifteen days (Article 913-8). On the fast track, it is raised of the court's own motion by the presiding judge of the chamber or the judge designated by the First President (Articles 906-1 and 906-2), whose order may be referred to the court within fifteen days of its date (Article 906-3).
Its effects are serious: a party whose notice of appeal has lapsed can no longer bring a main appeal against the same judgment and against the same party (Article 916).
Once the time limit has expired, only force majeure, “consisting of a circumstance not attributable to the party's own conduct and which is insurmountable for that party” (our translation), allows the sanctions attached to the time limits for filing and notifying submissions to be set aside (Article 911 and, on the fast track, Article 906-2); Articles 902 and 906-1 do not provide for this exception where the notice of appeal lapses for failure to serve it. The Aix-en-Provence Court of Appeal accepted it, under former Article 910-3, for a lawyer who had a road accident during the period in which the time limit expired (CA Aix-en-Provence, ch. 3-1, 30 October 2025, No. 25/01487). An IT failure follows a similar rule: the inadmissibility of documents not filed electronically is set aside where there is a cause beyond the filing party's control (cause étrangère), which the Cour de cassation accepted for a substantiated breakdown (Cass. 2e civ., 10 June 2021, No. 20-10.522). The firm keeps a schedule of every time limit from the notice of appeal onwards.
Can you make new claims or produce new evidence on appeal in France?
New grounds and new documents, yes: to support on appeal the claims put to the first-instance judge, the parties may raise new grounds, produce new documents or offer new evidence (Article 563 of the Code of Civil Procedure). New claims, in principle, no: they are inadmissible, and the court raises this of its own motion, except to claim set-off, to defeat the other side's claims, or to have the court rule on issues arising from the intervention of a third party or from the occurrence or discovery of a fact (Article 564).
The line is more flexible than it seems. Claims are not new where they pursue the same ends as those put to the first-instance judge, even if their legal basis is different (Article 565), and the parties may add claims that are ancillary to, a consequence of or a necessary complement to their original claims (Article 566). The Cour de cassation thus quashed a ruling that had declared an estate agent's claim for damages to be new, whereas that claim “pursued the same ends as the one put to the first-instance judge” (our translation), namely payment of the agent's remuneration (Cass. 2e civ., 30 April 2025, No. 22-13.163).
A timing constraint is added: the parties must set out all their claims on the merits in their first submissions, on pain of inadmissibility raised by the court of its own motion; afterwards, only claims made in reply or arising, after the first submissions, from the intervention of a third party or from the occurrence or disclosure of a fact remain admissible (Article 915-2). The firm therefore settles the list of claims before the first submissions, not as the proceedings unfold.
Do you have to comply with the judgment while the appeal is pending?
In most cases, yes. The time limit for appealing and an appeal brought within it in principle suspend enforcement of the judgment (Article 539 of the Code of Civil Procedure), but first-instance decisions are provisionally enforceable as of right, unless the law or the decision provides otherwise (Article 514). The first-instance judge may set aside this provisional enforcement as of right, by a specially reasoned decision, if the judge considers it incompatible with the nature of the case, except, in particular, in urgent proceedings (référé) (Article 514-1).
On appeal, the First President may be asked to stay provisional enforcement where there is a serious ground for setting aside or varying the judgment and enforcement is likely to have manifestly excessive consequences. A party that appeared at first instance without making observations on provisional enforcement must also show manifestly excessive consequences that came to light after the judgment (Article 514-3). Where provisional enforcement was ordered by the judge, the conditions are set by Article 517-1.
Both conditions are demanding. The First President of the Paris Court of Appeal points out that a serious ground “is one that has a reasonable chance of success” (our translation), and that “The two conditions laid down in the aforementioned Article 514-3 are cumulative.” (our translation); the application of a debtor whose income allowed him to pay the sum ordered was dismissed (CA Paris, pôle 1, ch. 5, ord., 14 April 2026, No. 25/20007). The firm prepares the application with the financial documents that establish the harm, or opposes it on behalf of the respondent. See our article on staying provisional enforcement of a commercial judgment.
What happens if the appellant does not comply with the judgment?
The case may be removed from the court's list (radiation). Where provisional enforcement applies as of right or has been ordered, the First President or, once seised, the case management judge may, at the respondent's request and after hearing the parties' observations, remove the case from the list where the appellant cannot show that it has complied with the decision or deposited the sums due, unless compliance would have manifestly excessive consequences or the appellant is unable to comply (Article 524 of the Code of Civil Procedure). The respondent must make the application before its own time limits for filing submissions expire, on pain of inadmissibility, and the application suspends those time limits.
Removal from the list bars examination of the main appeal and of any cross-appeal, and the case is reinstated only on proof of compliance (Article 524). The decision to remove the case does not suspend the time limits imposed on the appellant by Articles 906-2, 908 and 911: an appellant whose case has been removed must still file submissions on time. Time matters: since 1 October 2026, the period after which the proceedings are extinguished for want of prosecution (péremption) runs from the decision ordering removal, no longer from its notification, and the proceedings are extinguished where no step is taken for two years (Article 386). For removals ordered before 1 October 2026 that had not been notified, a new period runs from that date (Article 21 of Decree No. 2026-683). Under the former text, the Cour de cassation quashed a ruling that ran the period from a date before service of the removal decision (Cass. 2e civ., 21 May 2026, No. 23-20.561).
An order of the First President on a stay of provisional enforcement, even one declaring the application inadmissible, does not settle the question of removal: the court must examine that application, which “does not pursue the same objective and is not based on the same criteria” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 11 June 2026, No. 24-11.444). The firm defends the appellant who cannot comply, or supports the respondent's application.
Can you change lawyer during an appeal in France?
Yes, at any time, but the change must be organised. A party that dismisses its representative must immediately either arrange a replacement or inform the judge and the other party that it intends to conduct its own case, where the law allows; otherwise, the other side may continue the proceedings dealing only with the dismissed representative (Article 418 of the Code of Civil Procedure). Where representation is mandatory, as before the court of appeal, the lawyer can withdraw only from the day on which a new representative is appointed by the party or, failing that, assigned by the President of the Bar (bâtonnier) (Article 419).
The Cour de cassation draws strict consequences from this. It holds that “the message by which the lawyer informs the court of appeal that they no longer represent the appellants has no effect on the lawyer's mandate of representation, and the lawyer continues to represent the party until a new lawyer is appointed” (our translation), and that the registry does not have to notify the lapse order to the party itself when the lawyer announces an intention to withdraw; the referral (déféré) lodged late by the appellants was declared inadmissible (Cass. 2e civ., 23 November 2023, No. 21-23.405). Time limits therefore keep running while you change lawyer.
The new lawyer must also have the right to act as lawyer of record before the court hearing the appeal (Article 5 of the Law of 31 December 1971). The firm takes over appeal cases under way: it files its appointment, identifies the time limits still open, in particular those of Articles 908 to 911, and takes up the submissions already notified. For further insight, see our article on regularising a defective notice of appeal.
Can you appeal a court of appeal ruling to the Cour de cassation?
Yes, but it is not a third tier of jurisdiction. An appeal to the Cour de cassation (pourvoi) lies only against decisions against which no ordinary appeal lies (Article 605 of the Code of Civil Procedure) and seeks to have the Cour de cassation censure the challenged decision for failing to comply with the rules of law (Article 604). The Court does not retry the facts: it reviews the application of the law and the reasoning. The court of appeal's ruling is therefore the last point at which the facts and the evidence can be argued.
The time limit for this appeal is two months, unless otherwise provided (Article 612), and it runs in principle from notification of the ruling (Article 528). The parties must, unless otherwise provided, appoint a lawyer admitted to the Conseil d'État and the Cour de cassation (Article 973), and the appellant must, on pain of forfeiture, file with the registry a brief setting out the grounds of law within four months of the appeal (Article 978). An appeal to the Cour de cassation does not suspend enforcement of the ruling unless the law provides otherwise (Article 579).
The rulings cited on this page show the usual grounds for quashing in appeal procedure: a ground disregarded although it appeared in the discussion section of the submissions (Cass. 2e civ., 22 May 2025, No. 22-21.399), a claim declared new although it pursued the same ends (Cass. 2e civ., 30 April 2025, No. 22-13.163). The firm analyses the ruling, identifies the complaints that concern the law rather than the facts, and prepares the transfer of the file to the lawyer admitted to the Conseil d'État and the Cour de cassation (avocat aux Conseils).
What are an appeal lawyer's fees in France?
Fees are set out in a written agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971: before committing, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs.
The firm favours a fixed fee for each stage: review of the judgment and the time limit, notice of appeal, first submissions, submissions in reply, procedural application before the case management judge, application for a stay of provisional enforcement or for removal from the list, oral pleading. Any new assignment is covered by an amendment to the agreement, with no unexpected invoicing. Part of the costs may be charged to the other side: the judge orders the party liable for court costs (dépens), or the losing party, to pay the other party the amount the judge determines for the costs incurred and not included in the court costs, taking into account fairness or the economic situation of the party ordered to pay (Article 700 of the Code of Civil Procedure). See also our article on buying the tax stamp (timbre fiscal) to appeal a civil decision.
For a first opinion based on your documents, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, through the form on this page, leads to a written analysis within 24 working hours. First contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, checked on 1 November 2026, and the firm's related practice areas.
Official texts
- Articles L. 311-1 and R. 311-3 of the Code of Judicial Organisation: jurisdiction of the court of appeal
- Articles 528, 528-1, 538, 539, 642, 643 and 680 of the Code of Civil Procedure: time limit for appeal, notification, suspensive effect, extra time for distance
- Articles 542, 543, 544, 545, 546, 548, 550 and 559 of the Code of Civil Procedure: purpose of an appeal, appealable decisions, cross-appeal, abusive appeal
- Articles 561, 562, 563, 564, 565 and 566 of the Code of Civil Procedure: devolutive effect, new grounds and new claims
- Articles 411, 418, 419 and 899 of the Code of Civil Procedure: representation, dismissal and replacement of the lawyer
- Articles 900, 901, 902, 904, 905, 906, 906-1, 906-2, 906-3 and 930-1 of the Code of Civil Procedure: notice of appeal, case allocation, fast track, electronic filing
- Articles 908, 909, 910, 911, 912, 913, 913-5, 913-8, 914, 915-2, 915-3 and 916 of the Code of Civil Procedure: time limits for submissions, case management, concentration of claims, sanctions
- Articles 931, 932 and 954 of the Code of Civil Procedure: procedure without mandatory representation, content of submissions
- Articles 386, 514, 514-1, 514-3, 517-1 and 524 of the Code of Civil Procedure: extinction for want of prosecution, provisional enforcement, removal from the list
- Articles 579, 604, 605, 612, 973 and 978 of the Code of Civil Procedure: appeal to the Cour de cassation
- Article 700 of the Code of Civil Procedure: costs not included in court costs (dépens)
- Articles 5, 5-1 and 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: postulation, multi-court postulation in the Paris region (Île-de-France), fee agreement
- Article 16 of Decree No. 2023-1391 of 29 December 2023: entry into force of the appeal reform
- Article 21 of Decree No. 2026-683 of 27 July 2026: entry into force on 1 October 2026 and exceptions
Decisions cited
- Cass. 2e civ., avis, 20 November 2025, No. 25-70.017: the option under Article 915-2 and devolutive effect
- Cass. 2e civ., 19 May 2022, No. 21-10.685: notice of appeal without challenged heads, no devolutive effect
- Cass. 2e civ., 30 April 2025, No. 22-23.482: request for reversal in the operative part, lapse
- Cass. 2e civ., 22 May 2025, No. 22-21.399: ground raised in the discussion section of the submissions
- Cass. 2e civ., 30 April 2025, No. 22-13.163: claim pursuing the same ends on appeal
- Cass. 2e civ., 17 May 2018, No. 17-14.291: judgment not notified and the two-year time limit
- Cass. 2e civ., 10 June 2021, No. 20-10.522: external cause and filing on paper
- Cass. 2e civ., 23 November 2023, No. 21-23.405: change of lawyer and mandate of representation
- Cass. 2e civ., 11 June 2026, No. 24-11.444: removal from the list and stay of provisional enforcement
- Cass. 2e civ., 21 May 2026, No. 23-20.561: starting point of the extinction period after removal from the list
- CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 1, ord., 1 July 2026, No. 26/04487: lapse for failure to file submissions within three months
- CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 13, ord., 7 July 2026, No. 25/13960: multi-court postulation and nullity of the notice of appeal
- CA Paris, pôle 1, ch. 5, ord., 14 April 2026, No. 25/20007: stay of provisional enforcement, cumulative conditions
- CA Aix-en-Provence, ch. 3-1, 30 October 2025, No. 25/01487: force majeure, lapse not applied
Further reading
Appeal lawyers in Paris: a judgment to challenge or an appeal to fight?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send the judgment, the notification document, the notice of appeal or the submissions you have received: Hassan Kohen checks the time limits, the court with jurisdiction and the right to act as lawyer of record, then tells you the appropriate course of action: notice of appeal, appellant's or respondent's submissions, cross-appeal, procedural application before the case management judge, application for a stay of provisional enforcement or for removal from the list.