The firm in the media
Watch the videos and read their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, startup lawyer in Paris
Startup lawyer in Paris: from incorporation to fundraising
SAS articles of association, splitting the equity between co-founders, BSPCE share warrants and bonus shares, fundraising, shareholders' agreement, ownership of the software, SaaS contracts and GDPR: as a startup lawyer in Paris, the firm advises the founders, employee shareholders and investors of a startup at every stage, and assists them when a dispute arises. Every choice is made on the basis of the legislation in force and recent case law.
The firm can be reached 24/7. Anyone who acts in the name of a company in the process of formation remains jointly and severally liable, without limit, for the acts performed until the registered company has taken them over (Article L. 210-6 of the French Commercial Code, Code de commerce); a shareholders' agreement, a letter of intent or a BSPCE plan should be reviewed before signing, not after.
4,9/5
Average Google rating270 reviews
I received very high-quality support from this criminal defence lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective defence in criminal law.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer. He got me out of trouble in a protection order case brought abusively by my ex
Very satisfied with the solution found for my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, with great empathy and a strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen carefully and to fully understand my situation. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, caring and available, and who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Urgent matters 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer (avocat) at the Paris Bar, company law, fundraising, intellectual property and startup contracts.
Official profile in the directory of French lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 1 November 2026.
Quick answer
A startup is most often set up as a simplified joint-stock company (société par actions simplifiée, SAS), whose articles of association (statuts) freely set the conditions under which it is managed (Article L. 227-5 of the French Commercial Code), subject to the decisions that the law reserves to the shareholders (Article L. 227-9) and to the rule of the majority of votes cast laid down by the French Supreme Court (Cour de cassation) in 2024. Company founder share warrants (bons de souscription de parts de créateur d'entreprise, BSPCE) are reserved for companies registered less than fifteen years ago whose capital is at least 15% held by individuals, subject to the other conditions of Article 163 bis G of the French General Tax Code (Code général des impôts); an allocation of bonus shares (attribution gratuite d'actions) requires a vesting period of at least one year (Article L. 225-197-1 of the French Commercial Code). Fundraising relies on securities giving access to the share capital (Article L. 228-91) and on a shareholders' agreement whose exit clauses are reviewed in the light of employment law when the founder is an employee. A company cannot be the author of software, and is presumed to hold the author's rights in a collective work (œuvre collective): the founders' rights are therefore assigned in writing, right by right (Article L. 131-3 of the French Intellectual Property Code, Code de la propriété intellectuelle). Kohen Avocats, based in Paris (16th arrondissement), acts for founders, employee shareholders and investors. Call +33 6 89 11 34 45.
Articles of association to draft, a BSPCE plan to set up, a funding round to prepare?
Understanding your situation
Startup law and the French SAS, explained
The simplified joint-stock company (SAS) leaves it to the articles of association to set the conditions under which it is managed (Article L. 227-5 of the French Commercial Code). How to structure the company, give the team an equity stake, raise funds, protect the software and set the terms of customer contracts, with the texts and decisions that define the limits.
Key points
Structuring a French SAS: four choices to make in the articles of association
What the law leaves open, and what it imposes despite the freedom to draft the articles of association.
The form: a simplified joint-stock company may be set up by one or more persons who bear losses only up to the amount of their contribution; where there is only one shareholder, that person is called the sole shareholder (associé unique) (Article L. 227-1 of the French Commercial Code). The rules governing public limited companies (sociétés anonymes) apply to it insofar as they are compatible with this regime, except for those the article lists, in particular on the board of directors and shareholders' meetings.
Management: the articles of association set the conditions under which the company is managed (Article L. 227-5). The president (président) represents the company vis-à-vis third parties, limitations on the president's powers set by the articles cannot be relied on against them, and the articles may provide for a managing director (directeur général) or a deputy managing director (directeur général délégué) (Article L. 227-6).
Shareholders' decisions: the articles of association determine which decisions are taken collectively, but an increase or reduction of capital, a merger, a demerger, dissolution, conversion into another form, the appointment of statutory auditors, the annual accounts and profits always remain a matter for the shareholders acting collectively (Article L. 227-9).
Control of the share capital: a lock-up of shares (inaliénabilité) for ten years at most, adopted or amended unanimously (Articles L. 227-13 and L. 227-19); prior approval of transfers (agrément) (Article L. 227-14); an obligation to transfer one's shares under the conditions set by the articles (Article L. 227-16). Any transfer made in breach of the clauses of the articles is void (Article L. 227-15).
The freedom to draft the articles of association has limits enforced by the courts. The full court (assemblée plénière) of the Cour de cassation holds that a collective decision of the shareholders of an SAS “can only be validly adopted if it obtains at least a majority of the votes cast, any contrary clause in the articles being deemed unwritten” (our translation); a capital increase that had received fewer votes in favour than against was annulled (Cass. ass. plén., 15 November 2024, No. 23-16.670). Likewise, while the articles may provide for the exclusion of a shareholder, “any stipulation of the exclusion clause whose purpose or effect is to deprive the shareholder whose exclusion is proposed of the right to vote on that proposal is deemed unwritten” (our translation) (Cass. com., 29 May 2024, No. 22-13.158), applying Article 1844 of the French Civil Code (Code civil), under which “Every shareholder has the right to take part in collective decisions” (our translation).
The fate of the company's directors is also settled in the articles. For the Cour de cassation, the conditions for their removal “are, where the law is silent, freely set by the articles of association, whether as to the grounds for removal or its procedure” (our translation); a managing director was thus removed without just cause, as no clause required one (Cass. com., 9 March 2022, No. 19-25.795). A founder who shares management with an investor therefore negotiates, before the funding round, the grounds and the procedure for his or her own removal. See our page on the appointment and removal of SAS directors.
Before registration, the founders often sign a lease, a development contract or a promise for the company in the process of formation (société en formation). Those who acted in its name are jointly and severally liable, without limit, for these acts, unless the registered company takes them over, in which case the commitments are deemed to have been entered into by the company from the outset (Article L. 210-6 of the French Commercial Code). Since 2023, the Cour de cassation has recognised the court's power to assess, “by examining all the circumstances, both intrinsic and extrinsic to the act, whether the common intention of the parties was that the act should be concluded in the name or on behalf of the company in the process of formation” (our translation) (Cass. com., 29 November 2023, No. 22-21.623). The choice of legal form, the articles of association and contributions are covered in detail on our company formation page.
Giving the team a stake
BSPCE, BSA and bonus shares: the conditions for each instrument
Each instrument has its own beneficiaries, thresholds and tax treatment; a badly drafted plan can backfire on the employee as well as on the company.
Eligible company
To grant BSPCE, the joint-stock company must be liable to corporate income tax in France and registered with the Trade and Companies Register (registre du commerce et des sociétés) for less than fifteen years, and at least 15% of its capital must be held directly and continuously by individuals, certain holdings of venture capital companies and investment funds being disregarded. It must not have been formed through a concentration, a restructuring, an extension or a takeover of pre-existing activities, save for exceptions (Article 163 bis G, II, of the French General Tax Code).
Beneficiaries
Employees, directors subject to the tax regime for employees and members of the board of directors, of the supervisory board or, in an SAS, of any equivalent body provided for in the articles, as well as those of subsidiaries at least 75% owned. The warrants are non-transferable (Article 163 bis G, II).
Issue and price
The issue is authorised by the extraordinary general meeting, a power exercised in an SAS by the shareholders acting collectively (Article L. 227-9 of the French Commercial Code). The acquisition price of the shares is set on the grant date; if a capital increase through the issue of securities conferring rights equivalent to those resulting from the exercise of the warrant took place in the previous six months, the price is at least equal to the issue price then set, less, where applicable, a discount reflecting the loss of economic value of the security since that issue; where the shares obtained on exercise do not carry rights at least equivalent to those of the securities then issued, the price may also be reduced by a discount reflecting that difference (Article 163 bis G, III).
Taxation
The exercise gain is taxed in the year the shares are sold, at the flat rate under Article 200 A or, by election, under the rules for wages and salaries; the rate is 30% where the beneficiary has worked in the company for less than three years on the date of the sale. The capital gain on the sale follows Article 150-0 A (Article 163 bis G, I and I bis).
BSA
Joint-stock companies may issue securities giving access to the share capital (Article L. 228-91 of the French Commercial Code). Share subscription warrants (bons de souscription d'actions, BSA) can thus be granted to a consultant, an independent director or an investor, without the tax regime specific to BSPCE.
Bonus shares
Authorised for thirty-eight months at most, up to 15% of the share capital, or 20% in an SME for certain categories of employees if the articles so provide; the allocation becomes final at the end of a vesting period of at least one year, and the combined length of the vesting and holding periods cannot be less than two years (Article L. 225-197-1). In an SAS, the president or the directors designated by the articles exercise the powers of the board of directors (Article L. 227-1).
The plan is the law between the parties. The Paris Judicial Court (tribunal judiciaire) refused the award of 87 BSPCE to an employee who had left the company, whose registered letter, the form required by the plan unless the request was handed over in person, had arrived one day after the three-month deadline following the end of her employment: “The request received on 5 July 2022 is therefore late” (our translation), and her earlier emails had not amounted to an exercise (TJ Paris, 4e ch. 2e sect., 27 March 2025, No. 22/14634). The exercise timetable, the form of notice and what happens to the warrants on departure are therefore drafted with care, then explained to the beneficiaries.
For bonus shares, the Employment Chamber (chambre sociale) of the Cour de cassation holds that the beneficiary acquires them definitively “only at the end of a vesting period and subject to meeting the conditions freely set by the bonus share allocation plan” (our translation), and that their distribution “is not consideration for work and therefore does not have the legal nature of an element of remuneration” (our translation) (Cass. soc., 18 June 2025, No. 23-19.754). Employees whose contracts had been transferred before the end of the vesting period obtained no compensation.
Confidentiality, intellectual property and exclusivity clauses in the employment contract are subject to the same rigour: no one may restrict personal rights and individual freedoms in ways that are not justified by the nature of the task to be performed or proportionate to the aim pursued (Article L. 1121-1 of the French Labour Code, Code du travail). See our articles on the taxation of BSPCE when the holder leaves within three years and on bonus shares lost after a dismissal.
Raising funds
Term sheet, shareholders' agreement, exit clauses: what is negotiated
Founders and investors do not read the same clauses in the same way.
If you are a founder
- Limit the duration and scope of the exclusivity granted in the letter of intent, and protect the information disclosed during due diligence.
- Discuss the rights attached to the investor's preference shares: voting, veto, dividends, liquidation.
- Frame the leaver clauses: departure events, price, vesting schedule.
If you are an investor
- Obtain representations and warranties on the share capital, intellectual property and key contracts.
- Provide for promises to sell by departing founders and for tag-along or drag-along clauses.
- Have the clauses that must bind everyone, such as approval or lock-up clauses, written into the articles of association.
Negotiation is a matter of freedom, within limits. The initiation, conduct and breaking-off of pre-contractual negotiations are unrestricted but must meet the requirements of good faith, and compensation for a fault can cover neither the loss of the benefits expected from the contract that was not concluded nor the loss of the chance of obtaining them (Article 1112 of the French Civil Code); anyone who uses or discloses without authorisation confidential information obtained during the negotiations incurs liability (Article 1112-2). In a business sale preceded by a letter of intent with an exclusivity clause, the Versailles Court of Appeal noted that “breaking off negotiations without a legitimate reason is wrongful” (our translation), then held that the buyer's failure to show proof of its bank financing “constitutes a legitimate reason for breaking off the negotiations” (our translation) (CA Versailles, ch. com. 3-2, 19 May 2026, No. 25/01504).
The securities issued in the round are governed by the law on joint-stock companies. Preference shares may be created, with or without voting rights, carrying special rights of any kind, on a temporary or permanent basis, defined by the articles of association (Article L. 228-11 of the French Commercial Code). The BSA AIR (a share warrant issued under a rapid investment agreement, accord d'investissement rapide), a market practice with no specific legal regime, remains a security giving access to the share capital (Article L. 228-91): everything turns on its issue agreement, which sets the price and the conversion terms at the next round.
Leaver clauses are assessed case by case. The Paris Court of Appeal held that the clause requiring a founder who had become an employee to sell his shares at their nominal value in the event of dismissal for gross or wilful misconduct (faute grave or faute lourde) was deemed unwritten (réputée non écrite): its enforcement “amounts to a financial penalty, as he finds himself dispossessed, at a derisory price, of the shares in the company he had founded” (our translation), a penalty prohibited by Article L. 1331-2 of the French Labour Code (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 9, 12 May 2022, No. 20/05597). The same court, by contrast, upheld the promise to sell given by a manager who had been removed from office, which “corresponds in principle to a standard clause in shareholders' agreements” (our translation), the price, which varied according to the departure date, being clearly set out in the agreement (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 8, 18 October 2024, No. 22/09370). Finally, the Cour de cassation holds that the nullity of transfers made in breach of the articles “is intended solely to penalise the breach of any clause of the articles whose purpose is the transfer of shares freely agreed to by their holder” (our translation): an exclusion clause in the articles therefore does not render void, on the basis of Article L. 227-15 of the French Commercial Code, the promise to sell provided for in the shareholders' agreement, whose specific performance may be sought; the case was remanded to the Amiens Court of Appeal (Cass. com., 21 June 2023, No. 21-25.952).
The clauses the firm reviews in every shareholders' agreement:
These clauses are covered in detail on our shareholders' agreement page; the agreement between the shareholders of an SME has its own page, shareholders' agreement (pacte d'associés). See also our article on the validity and price of bad leaver clauses.
Assets and customers
Software, contracts and data: what gives a startup its value
An investor first checks that the company owns its code and that its contracts are sound.
Software, including preparatory design material, is a work of the mind protected by copyright (Article L. 112-2, 13°, of the French Intellectual Property Code).
Authorship belongs, unless proven otherwise, to the person or persons under whose name the work is disclosed (Article L. 113-1); a legal entity cannot have that status, the Cour de cassation holds (Cass. 1re civ., 15 January 2015, No. 13-23.566). It may be vested with the author's rights in a collective work, created on its initiative and disclosed under its direction and name (Articles L. 113-2 and L. 113-5).
The economic rights in software created by employees in the performance of their duties or on their employer's instructions vest in the employer, unless statutory provisions or contractual stipulations provide otherwise (Article L. 113-9). The provision covers only employees: a founder who is a corporate officer but not an employee, and an outside contractor, remain outside its scope.
An assignment requires each right assigned to be mentioned separately and the scope of exploitation to be defined as to its extent, purpose, place and duration (Article L. 131-3); the global assignment of future works is void (Article L. 131-1).
Inventions made by an employee whose contract includes an inventive mission corresponding to his or her actual duties belong to the employer, the employee being entitled to additional remuneration (Article L. 611-7).
General terms and conditions take effect against the other party only if it was aware of them and accepted them (Article 1119 of the French Civil Code); a business that draws up general terms and conditions of sale provides them to any business buyer who requests them (Article L. 441-1 of the French Commercial Code).
The Cour de cassation quashed the judgment that recognised a company as the author of software developed by its shareholders, “whereas a legal entity cannot have the status of author” (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 15 January 2015, No. 13-23.566). The Paris Court of Appeal held admissible the action of a departing engineer and shareholder who claimed copyright in software which, as the correspondence produced showed, had been “fully integrated into the business of MEISO so as to become a necessary tool for it” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 1, 18 October 2023, No. 22/07097). The written assignment of the founders' and contractors' rights is therefore signed before the funding round, whose due diligence will check it. See our article on the contractor who keeps the source code.
With business customers, unbalanced clauses are policed through the French Commercial Code: anyone who subjects or attempts to subject the other party to obligations creating a significant imbalance in the rights and obligations of the parties incurs liability (Article L. 442-1, I, 2°). The Cour de cassation holds that Article 1171 of the French Civil Code “therefore does not apply to contracts concluded by a person engaged in production, distribution or service activities” (our translation), unless Article L. 442-1 is excluded by another provision (Cass. com., 13 May 2026, No. 24-17.137). The software publisher remains bound by a duty to advise: the Paris Court of Appeal held that a publisher of time-management software “did not fully satisfy its duty to advise its non-specialist client” (our translation), while refusing termination of the contract, the breaches not being “serious enough” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 31 January 2025, No. 22/13233).
Personal data must be taken into account from the design of the product: the controller implements appropriate technical and organisational measures, such as pseudonymisation, and ensures that, by default, only the data necessary for each purpose are processed (Article 25 of Regulation (EU) 2016/679). A software publisher that processes data on behalf of its customers acts as a processor: a contract sets out the subject matter, duration, nature and purpose of the processing, and the processor does not engage another processor without the prior written authorisation of the controller (Article 28). See our GDPR and IT contracts pages.
The practice area
The stages of a startup, with a dedicated page for each
This page is the entry point; each topic has its own detailed page.
Before incorporation
Splitting the equity between co-founders, articles of association, founders' agreement, assignment of the rights in code already written, takeover of acts signed for the company in the process of formation.
First hires
Employment contracts, intellectual property and confidentiality clauses, BSPCE or bonus share plan.
First customers
General terms and conditions, SaaS contract, data processing agreement, service levels and limitation of liability.
Fundraising
Letter of intent, due diligence, amendment of the articles of association, shareholders' agreement, issue of securities, representations and warranties.
Disputes
Departing shareholder, removed founder, employee claiming his or her warrants, customer disputing the software, investor breaking off negotiations.
Company law: the life of the company after incorporation, shareholders' decisions, disputes, share transfers and directors' liability.
Company formation: choice of legal form, articles of association, contributions, registration and takeover of the acts performed during formation.
Shareholders' agreement: governance, investors' rights, liquidity and leaver clauses, enforcement of the agreement and remedies for breach.
Intellectual property: trade marks, copyright and software, designs, assignment and licence agreements, infringement.
Deeptech: commercialisation of public research, patents and trade secrets, research collaboration agreements and innovation funding.
Legaltech: the boundaries of regulated legal services, platforms connecting clients and lawyers, legal artificial intelligence and court decision data.
For innovation, the tax credit provided for in II(k) of Article 244 quater B of the French General Tax Code is available, until 31 December 2027, to micro, small and medium-sized enterprises for their expenditure on designing prototypes or pilot installations of new products, at a rate of 20% and within an overall limit of €400,000 of expenditure per year; see our research tax credit (crédit d'impôt recherche) page.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Fourteen detailed answers, based on the legislation in force and on verified decisions.
When should a startup consult a lawyer?
Before signing anything on behalf of the future company. Those who acted in the name of a company in the process of formation are jointly and severally liable, without limit, for the acts performed, unless the company, once registered, takes over the commitments entered into, which are then deemed to have been entered into by the company from the outset (Article L. 210-6 of the French Commercial Code). The Cour de cassation now leaves it to the court to assess, “by examining all the circumstances, both intrinsic and extrinsic to the act” (our translation), whether the act was to be concluded for the company in the process of formation (Cass. com., 29 November 2023, No. 22-21.623); it is better for the act to say so.
Then come three decisive moments. First, drafting the articles of association, since the articles set the conditions under which the company is managed (Article L. 227-5) and lock-up clauses can only be adopted or amended unanimously by the shareholders (Article L. 227-19): they are easier to put in place with two founders than with ten shareholders. Next, the first hire, which raises the question of who owns the code and of employee incentives. Finally, the funding round, which requires a company in good order: rights assigned, share register up to date, key contracts reviewed.
The firm acts at each of these stages, and when a dispute arises between shareholders, with an employee or with an investor.
French SAS or SASU: which legal form should a startup choose?
It is not a choice between two forms: the SASU is a simplified joint-stock company with only one shareholder, called the sole shareholder, who exercises the powers conferred on the shareholders where the law requires a collective decision (Article L. 227-1 of the French Commercial Code). The same company can switch from one to the other as shareholders join and leave.
Most startups choose the SAS because its articles freely set the conditions under which it is managed (Article L. 227-5) and the decisions taken collectively (Article L. 227-9), and because it can issue the instruments needed for a funding round: preference shares (Article L. 228-11), securities giving access to the share capital (Article L. 228-91), BSPCE (Article 163 bis G of the French General Tax Code). Shareholders bear losses only up to the amount of their contribution. It can also issue inalienable shares in return for contributions of know-how or services (apports en industrie), whose terms are set by the articles (Article L. 227-1).
This freedom has a limit, recalled by the full court (assemblée plénière) of the Cour de cassation: a collective decision of the shareholders “can only be validly adopted if it obtains at least a majority of the votes cast” (our translation) (Cass. ass. plén., 15 November 2024, No. 23-16.670). The firm drafts articles tailored to the project, rather than a template, and explains each clause to the founders. The other legal forms are presented on our company formation page.
How should co-founders split equity and control?
By separating what concerns capital, voting and management. Each shareholder's rights in the capital are proportionate to his or her contributions, in cash or in kind; a contribution of know-how or services (apport en industrie) does not form part of the share capital (Article 1843-2 of the French Civil Code) but gives rise, in an SAS, to inalienable shares whose subscription and allocation terms are set by the articles (Article L. 227-1 of the French Commercial Code). Voting can be arranged: preference shares, with or without voting rights, may carry special rights of any kind defined by the articles (Article L. 228-11). Management, finally, is a matter for the articles (Article L. 227-5).
Two rules limit these arrangements. Every shareholder has the right to take part in collective decisions (Article 1844 of the French Civil Code), so an exclusion clause cannot deprive the shareholder concerned of his or her vote on the proposal (Cass. com., 29 May 2024, No. 22-13.158). And a collective decision can only be adopted by at least a majority of the votes cast (Cass. ass. plén., 15 November 2024, No. 23-16.670).
The split must also anticipate the departure of one of the founders: a shareholder who leaves with a large share of the capital without contributing any further weighs on the next round. The articles may provide that a shareholder will be required to transfer his or her shares (Article L. 227-16), and the shareholders' agreement organises the promises to sell and their price. The firm builds this framework with the founders, piece by piece, before signing.
What is a BSPCE and which companies can grant them?
A company founder share warrant (BSPCE) allows its holder to subscribe for shares in the company at a price set on the grant date, with a specific tax regime (Article 163 bis G of the French General Tax Code). The warrants are non-transferable.
The issuing company must be a joint-stock company liable to corporate income tax in France and registered with the Trade and Companies Register for less than fifteen years, and at least 15% of its capital must be held directly and continuously by individuals, or by legal entities themselves at least 75% owned by individuals; certain holdings of venture capital funds are disregarded. A listed company must have a market capitalisation of less than €150 million, and the company must not have been formed through a concentration, a restructuring, an extension or a takeover of pre-existing activities, save for the exceptions provided for by the text.
The beneficiaries are employees, directors subject to the tax regime for employees and members of the board of directors or supervisory board or, in an SAS, of any equivalent body provided for in the articles, including in subsidiaries at least 75% owned. The issue is authorised by the extraordinary general meeting, which sets the price and the exercise period. The exercise gain is taxed at the flat rate under Article 200 A or, by election, as salary, and at 30% if the beneficiary has worked in the company for less than three years at the time of the sale. See our article on BSPCE when the holder leaves within three years.
What happens to an employee's BSPCE and bonus shares when they leave the startup?
The plan decides, and the court applies it as written. For BSPCE, the extraordinary general meeting determines the period during which the warrants may be exercised (Article 163 bis G, III, of the French General Tax Code), and the plan usually specifies what happens to the warrants when the beneficiary leaves. If the beneficiary dies, his or her heirs may exercise the warrants within six months (Article 163 bis G, II bis). The Paris Judicial Court dismissed the claim of an employee whose registered letter, the form required by the plan unless the request was handed over in person, had arrived one day after the three-month deadline following the end of her employment: “The request received on 5 July 2022 is therefore late” (our translation) (TJ Paris, 4e ch. 2e sect., 27 March 2025, No. 22/14634).
For bonus shares, the allocation only becomes final at the end of the vesting period, which lasts at least one year (Article L. 225-197-1 of the French Commercial Code). The Employment Chamber (chambre sociale) of the Cour de cassation holds that their distribution “is not consideration for work and therefore does not have the legal nature of an element of remuneration” (our translation), and refused any compensation to employees whose contracts had been transferred before the end of that period, in the absence of proven fraud (Cass. soc., 18 June 2025, No. 23-19.754).
An employee who is leaving therefore checks the exercise deadlines and formalities before signing the termination of the contract; the company, for its part, applies its plan without adding to it. See our article on bonus shares lost after a dismissal.
BSA, BSA AIR or preference shares: which securities should a startup issue to raise funds?
Everything starts from the same text: joint-stock companies may issue securities giving access to the share capital or giving entitlement to the allotment of debt securities (Article L. 228-91 of the French Commercial Code). The share subscription warrant (BSA) is the most common form. The BSA AIR, a market practice with no specific legal regime, is a variant: the investor pays the funds immediately, and the number of shares to which it will be entitled is determined at the next round, according to the terms of the issue agreement. Its drafting therefore decides everything: conversion events, price, cap, what happens to the warrants if there is no new round.
Investors often subscribe for preference shares, created on incorporation or during the life of the company, with or without voting rights, carrying special rights of any kind, on a temporary or permanent basis, defined by the articles; preference shares without voting rights cannot represent more than half of the share capital (Article L. 228-11). In an SAS, a capital increase is a matter for the shareholders acting collectively (Article L. 227-9), by at least a majority of the votes cast (Cass. ass. plén., 15 November 2024, No. 23-16.670).
The firm compares these instruments according to the stage of the project, the amount raised and the expected governance, then drafts or reviews the documentation and the amendments to the articles.
What legal effect does a signed letter of intent or term sheet have?
As a general rule, it does not yet amount to a subscription agreement, but it is not without effect. The initiation, conduct and breaking-off of pre-contractual negotiations are unrestricted and must meet the requirements of good faith; in the event of fault, compensation can cover neither the loss of the benefits expected from the contract that was not concluded nor the loss of the chance of obtaining those benefits (Article 1112 of the French Civil Code). Anyone who uses or discloses without authorisation confidential information obtained during the negotiations incurs liability (Article 1112-2).
The court looks at the chronology. In a business sale preceded by a letter of intent with an exclusivity clause, the Versailles Court of Appeal recalled that “breaking off negotiations without a legitimate reason is wrongful” (our translation), held that the parties had agreed on the essentials, then found that the buyer's failure to show proof of its bank financing “constitutes a legitimate reason for breaking off the negotiations” (our translation) (CA Versailles, ch. com. 3-2, 19 May 2026, No. 25/01504). The buyer lost, having failed to show proof of its financing.
In a funding round, the letter of intent sets the valuation, the amount, the securities issued, the investor's rights, exclusivity and confidentiality. The firm helps the founders distinguish the provisions that are binding from signature, such as exclusivity and confidentiality, from those that remain to be negotiated, and prepares the next steps: due diligence, shareholders' agreement, articles of association. Equity transactions and the entry of investors are covered on our corporate law page.
Are good leaver and bad leaver clauses valid in France?
Yes in principle, but their application to a founder who is an employee is subject to review. Specific performance of a promise to sell given in the shareholders' agreement may be sought: the Cour de cassation holds that the nullity of transfers made in breach of the articles, provided for by Article L. 227-15 of the French Commercial Code, “is intended solely to penalise the breach of any clause of the articles whose purpose is the transfer of shares freely agreed to by their holder” (our translation), so that an exclusion clause in the articles does not render void the promise provided for in the shareholders' agreement; the case was remanded to the Amiens Court of Appeal (Cass. com., 21 June 2023, No. 21-25.952). The Paris Court of Appeal upheld the promise to sell given by a manager who had been removed from office, which “corresponds in principle to a standard clause in shareholders' agreements” (our translation), the price, which varied according to the departure date, being clearly set out (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 8, 18 October 2024, No. 22/09370).
The limit comes from employment law: “Fines or other financial penalties are prohibited” (our translation) (Article L. 1331-2 of the French Labour Code). The same court held that the clause requiring a founder who had become an employee to sell his shares at their nominal value in the event of dismissal for gross or wilful misconduct (faute grave or faute lourde) was deemed unwritten, because its enforcement “amounts to a financial penalty, as he finds himself dispossessed, at a derisory price, of the shares in the company he had founded” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 9, 12 May 2022, No. 20/05597). His shares were returned to him.
The firm therefore drafts departure events that do not rest on disciplinary misconduct alone, clear prices and a gradual timetable. For a founder facing such a clause, it checks the clause, how the departure is characterised and the price offered. See our article on the validity and price of bad leaver clauses.
What should a startup's shareholders' agreement contain?
It supplements the articles of association on what they do not say or should not say publicly: governance, investor information, pre-emption rights, tag-along and drag-along, founders' promises to sell, anti-dilution, founders' exclusivity undertakings. But the agreement creates obligations only between its signatories: third parties can neither demand its performance nor be compelled to perform it (Article 1199 of the French Civil Code).
Hence the value of including certain clauses in the articles. The articles may make any transfer of shares subject to the company's prior approval (Article L. 227-14 of the French Commercial Code), provide for a lock-up of the shares for ten years at most (Article L. 227-13) and require a shareholder to transfer his or her shares (Article L. 227-16); “Any transfer made in breach of the clauses of the articles is void” (our translation) (Article L. 227-15). Approval and compulsory transfer clauses are adopted by collective decision, lock-up clauses unanimously (Article L. 227-19).
The shareholders' agreement and the articles must be consistent with each other: a contradiction between the two fuels litigation. The Cour de cassation thus quashed the judgment that had annulled a promise in the shareholders' agreement on the ground that it contradicted an exclusion clause in the articles (Cass. com., 21 June 2023, No. 21-25.952). The clauses are covered in detail on our shareholders' agreement page, and the agreement between the shareholders of an SME on the shareholders' agreement (pacte d'associés) page.
Who owns the code written by the founders and developers?
Not automatically the company. Software is a work of the mind (Article L. 112-2, 13°, of the French Intellectual Property Code), and authorship belongs, unless proven otherwise, to the person under whose name the work is disclosed (Article L. 113-1). The Cour de cassation quashed the judgment that recognised a company as the author of software developed by its shareholders, “whereas a legal entity cannot have the status of author” (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 15 January 2015, No. 13-23.566). The company may, however, be vested with the author's rights in a collective work, created on its initiative and disclosed under its direction and name, where each person's contribution merges into the whole so that no separate right can be attributed to each author (Articles L. 113-2 and L. 113-5).
The law vests in the employer only the economic rights in software created by employees in the performance of their duties or on its instructions, unless statutory provisions or contractual stipulations provide otherwise (Article L. 113-9). A founder who is a corporate officer but not an employee, an independent developer and an agency remain the owners of their rights until they have assigned them. An assignment requires each right assigned to be mentioned separately and the scope of exploitation to be defined as to its extent, purpose, place and duration (Article L. 131-3); “The global assignment of future works is void” (our translation) (Article L. 131-1).
The risk is real: the Paris Court of Appeal held admissible the copyright infringement action brought by a departing engineer and shareholder against the company that was using the software he claimed (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 1, 18 October 2023, No. 22/07097). The firm audits the chain of title and drafts the assignments before the funding round. See our copyright page.
Terms of sale, terms of use, SaaS contract: how should a startup contract with business customers?
With general terms and conditions that are genuinely accepted and clauses that can be defended. General terms and conditions relied on by one party take effect against the other only if they were brought to its attention and it accepted them; where they conflict with specific terms, the latter prevail (Article 1119 of the French Civil Code). A service provider that draws up general terms and conditions of sale provides them to any business buyer who requests them, on a durable medium (Article L. 441-1 of the French Commercial Code). See our article on general terms and conditions not signed by the customer.
Review of unbalanced clauses between businesses falls under Article L. 442-1, I, 2°, of the French Commercial Code, which penalises subjecting or attempting to subject the other party to obligations creating a significant imbalance. The Cour de cassation holds that Article 1171 of the French Civil Code “therefore does not apply to contracts concluded by a person engaged in production, distribution or service activities” (our translation), unless the application of Article L. 442-1 is excluded by another provision (Cass. com., 13 May 2026, No. 24-17.137).
Finally, the software publisher must advise a non-specialist customer. The Paris Court of Appeal held that a publisher “did not fully satisfy its duty to advise its non-specialist client” (our translation) and ordered it to pay damages, without ordering termination of the contract (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 31 January 2025, No. 22/13233). The firm drafts the terms of sale, the terms of use, the SaaS contract and its service schedules.
What GDPR obligations apply to a startup that processes data?
They start before the product goes live. The controller implements, both when determining the means of processing and during the processing itself, appropriate technical and organisational measures, such as pseudonymisation, designed to implement data protection principles such as data minimisation; by default, only the data necessary for each purpose must be processed, as regards their amount, the extent of their processing, their storage period and their accessibility (Article 25 of Regulation (EU) 2016/679).
A startup that publishes online software often processes data on behalf of its customers. The Regulation then requires the controller to use only processors providing sufficient guarantees, and requires a contract setting out the subject matter and duration of the processing, its nature and purpose, the type of data and the categories of data subjects; the processor does not engage another processor without the controller's prior specific or general written authorisation (Article 28). A demanding customer will ask for this contract before signing, and an investor will look for it during due diligence.
The firm maps the processing operations, drafts the privacy policy, the data processing agreement and the data clauses of the SaaS contract, then supports the company when it receives a request from a data subject or faces an inspection. See our GDPR page.
Can a founder be removed from office as president?
Yes, under the conditions laid down in the articles of association. The articles set the conditions under which the company is managed (Article L. 227-5 of the French Commercial Code), and the president is appointed under the conditions they provide (Article L. 227-6). For the Cour de cassation, the conditions for removing the directors of an SAS “are, where the law is silent, freely set by the articles of association, whether as to the grounds for removal or its procedure” (our translation): a managing director was validly removed without just cause, as the articles did not require one (Cass. com., 9 March 2022, No. 19-25.795).
Removal from office does not in itself entail the loss of shares. The shareholders' agreement may, however, make the end of the founder's duties a departure event triggering a promise to sell the shares: the Paris Court of Appeal upheld such a promise against a manager removed sixteen months after the agreement was signed, at the progressive price provided for in the agreement (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 8, 18 October 2024, No. 22/09370). Where the founder is also an employee, a discount linked solely to his or her disciplinary dismissal may constitute a prohibited financial penalty (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 9, 12 May 2022, No. 20/05597).
The founder therefore negotiates, before the funding round, the grounds for removal, the required majority, the procedure and the link between removal and buy-back. In the event of a dispute, the firm examines whether the decision was lawful and its consequences for the share capital. See our pages on removal of directors, appointment and removal of SAS directors and disputes between shareholders.
How much does a startup lawyer cost?
Fees are set out in a written agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971: before committing, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs.
The firm favours fixed fees per stage: articles of association and founders' agreement, BSPCE or bonus share plan, assignment of software rights, general terms and conditions and SaaS contract, support for a funding round, formal notice or response, proceedings on the merits, appeal. Registration and legal publication costs are added to the fees. Any new work gives rise to an amendment to the fee agreement, with no unexpected billing.
The scope is set on the basis of the documents: number of shareholders and investors, instruments issued, whether or not there is an earlier shareholders' agreement, state of the chain of title to the software. A funding round is broken down into stages, from the letter of intent to signing, and each stage has its price announced in advance.
For a first opinion on the documents, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, through the form on this page, results in a written analysis within 24 working hours. For a first conversation, call +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, checked on 1 November 2026, and the firm's related practice areas.
Official texts
- Articles L. 227-1, L. 227-5, L. 227-6 and L. 227-9 of the French Commercial Code (Code de commerce): simplified joint-stock company, management, president, collective decisions
- Articles L. 227-13, L. 227-14, L. 227-15, L. 227-16 and L. 227-19: lock-up, approval, nullity of transfers, compulsory transfer, adoption of the clauses
- Article L. 210-6: legal personality and company in the process of formation
- Article L. 225-197-1: allocation of bonus shares
- Articles L. 228-11 and L. 228-91: preference shares, securities giving access to the share capital
- Articles L. 441-1 and L. 442-1: general terms and conditions of sale, significant imbalance between businesses
- Articles 163 bis G and 244 quater B of the French General Tax Code (Code général des impôts): BSPCE, research tax credit and innovation tax credit
- Articles L. 112-2, L. 113-1, L. 113-2, L. 113-5 and L. 113-9 of the French Intellectual Property Code (Code de la propriété intellectuelle): software, authorship, collective work, software created by an employee
- Articles L. 131-1, L. 131-3 and L. 611-7: assignment of copyright, employee inventions
- Articles 1112, 1112-2, 1119, 1171, 1199, 1843-2 and 1844 of the French Civil Code (Code civil): negotiations, confidentiality, general terms and conditions, standard-form contract (contrat d'adhésion), privity of contract, contributions and capital, shareholders' voting rights
- Articles L. 1121-1 and L. 1331-2 of the French Labour Code (Code du travail): employees' freedoms, prohibited financial penalties
- Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR): data protection by design and by default (Article 25), processor (Article 28)
- Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: fee agreement
Decisions cited
- Cass. ass. plén., 15 November 2024, No. 23-16.670: majority of the votes cast in an SAS
- Cass. com., 29 May 2024, No. 22-13.158: vote of the shareholder whose exclusion is proposed
- Cass. com., 9 March 2022, No. 19-25.795: removal of SAS directors under the articles
- Cass. com., 29 November 2023, No. 22-21.623: acts performed for a company in the process of formation
- Cass. com., 21 June 2023, No. 21-25.952: promise to sell in the shareholders' agreement and nullity under Article L. 227-15
- Cass. soc., 18 June 2025, No. 23-19.754: unvested bonus shares on departure
- Cass. 1re civ., 15 January 2015, No. 13-23.566: a legal entity is not an author
- Cass. com., 13 May 2026, No. 24-17.137: Article 1171 and contracts between businesses
- CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 9, 12 May 2022, No. 20/05597: bad leaver clause applied to an employee founder, financial penalty
- CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 8, 18 October 2024, No. 22/09370: removed manager's promise to sell upheld
- CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 1, 18 October 2023, No. 22/07097: action by the engineer shareholder over the software
- CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 31 January 2025, No. 22/13233: software publisher's duty to advise
- CA Versailles, ch. com. 3-2, 19 May 2026, No. 25/01504: breaking off negotiations after a letter of intent
- TJ Paris, 4e ch. 2e sect., 27 March 2025, No. 22/14634: lapse of BSPCE exercised out of time
Further reading
Starting a business in France, preparing a funding round, or dealing with a departing shareholder?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send the articles of association, the shareholders' agreement, the BSPCE plan, the letter of intent or the contract at issue: Hassan Kohen reviews the capital structure, the clauses and the deadlines, then tells you the appropriate course of action, whether drafting, negotiation, formal notice or court action.