The firm in the media
Watch the videos and read their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, social security law in Paris
Social security lawyer in Paris: CPAM, CAF and URSSAF disputes
A benefit refused, repayment of an overpayment demanded, a disputed incapacity rate or invalidity assessment, contributions, an enforcement order (contrainte) or a penalty: the firm assists insured persons, benefit recipients, pensioners, employers, self-employed workers and healthcare professionals as their social security lawyer in Paris in disputes with the CPAM (primary health insurance fund), URSSAF (social security contributions agency), the MSA (agricultural social insurance fund), the CAF (family allowance fund), pension funds and the MDPH (departmental centre for people with disabilities), from the mandatory prior appeal to the social division (pôle social) of the judicial court (tribunal judiciaire) and the court of appeal.
The firm can be reached 24/7. Unless legislation provides otherwise, the prior appeal and the court challenge must be brought within two months of notification of the contested decision (Article R. 142-1-A of the French Social Security Code (Code de la sécurité sociale)); these time limits can only be enforced if they were stated, together with the means of appeal, in the notification or, for an implicit decision, in the acknowledgement of receipt of the application.
4,9/5
Average Google rating270 reviews
I received very high-quality support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective defence in criminal law.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer. He got me out of trouble in a protection order case brought abusively by my ex
Very satisfied with the solution found for my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, with great empathy and a strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen carefully and to fully understand my situation. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, caring and available, and who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Urgent matters 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer (avocat) at the Paris Bar, social security litigation: amicable appeals, the social division (pôle social) of the judicial court, the court of appeal.
Official profile in the directory of French lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 1 November 2026.
Quick answer
Social security litigation in France covers, in particular, disputes over the application of social security and agricultural social insurance (mutualité sociale agricole) legislation, the collection of contributions, invalidity, unfitness for work (inaptitude), permanent incapacity after a workplace accident or an occupational disease, and certain decisions of the MDPH (Article L. 142-1 of the Social Security Code). Before any court action, a prior appeal is mandatory, with some exceptions (Article L. 142-4): to the body's amicable appeals board (commission de recours amiable), or to the medical amicable appeals board (commission médicale de recours amiable) for disputes of a medical nature (Articles R. 142-1 and R. 142-8), except for MDPH decisions, whose prior appeal follows its own rules. The time limit is in principle two months, and it only runs if the notification stated it together with the means of appeal (Article R. 142-1-A). The dispute then goes before the social division (pôle social) of a specially designated judicial court (Article L. 211-16 of the Code of Judicial Organisation (Code de l’organisation judiciaire)), where the procedure is oral, and then on appeal within one month. The parties may defend themselves or be represented by a lawyer (Article L. 142-9). Kohen Avocats, in the 16th arrondissement of Paris, acts for insured persons as well as for employers and professionals. Contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
A decision by the fund to challenge, an overpayment claimed back, a time limit already running?
Understanding your situation
French social security law, explained
The judicial courts (juge judiciaire) hear social security litigation (Article L. 142-8 of the Social Security Code). What can be challenged, how an appeal proceeds from the fund up to the court of appeal, what each party can argue, and what can be obtained in the face of an overpayment claim, contributions or a penalty.
Key points
What social security litigation covers
Four types of dispute, a single court, and bodies that first decide on their own.
Benefits and affiliation: any dispute over the application of social security and agricultural social insurance legislation and regulations, whether it concerns daily allowances (indemnités journalières), reimbursement of medical care, a retirement pension, family benefits or an overpayment claimed back (Article L. 142-1, 1°).
Collection: disputes over contributions owed to URSSAF or to the agricultural social insurance scheme fall within the application of social security and agricultural social insurance legislation (Article L. 142-1, 1°); points 2° and 3° of the same article add the collection of certain specific levies provided for by the Social Security Code and the Labour Code.
Medical conditions: the state or degree of invalidity, unfitness for work, and permanent incapacity and its rate after a workplace accident or an occupational disease (Article L. 142-1, 4° to 6°).
Disability: certain decisions of the commission for the rights and autonomy of disabled persons (commission des droits et de l'autonomie des personnes handicapées), and decisions of the president of the departmental council on the 'disability' (invalidité) and 'priority' (priorité) endorsements (Article L. 142-1, 8° and 9°).
These disputes go before specially designated judicial courts (tribunaux judiciaires), whose social division (pôle social) hears the litigation defined in Article L. 142-1, except for the rating of workplace accident contributions (7°), which is assigned to a specially designated court of appeal (Articles L. 211-16 and L. 311-16 of the Code of Judicial Organisation, the Code de l'organisation judiciaire). The competent court is in principle the one for the place where the claimant lives (Article R. 142-10). For an action by a commercial company, as employer, seeking to have the acceptance of a claim as work-related declared unenforceable against it (inopposabilité), the French Supreme Court (Cour de cassation) specifies that this domicile means, “for a commercial company, the registered office set by its articles of association” (Cass. 2e civ., 15 October 2026, No. 24-19.708, our translation).
Disability follows a specific division of jurisdiction. Decisions of the commission for the rights and autonomy of disabled persons concerning, in particular, a disabled child or adolescent, or the allowances and the mobility inclusion card (carte mobilité inclusion) referred to in the text, go before the specially designated judicial court; those concerning an adult in matters of vocational rehabilitation or adapted or sheltered employment fall within the administrative courts, as does recognition of disabled worker status (Article L. 241-9 of the Code of Social Action and Families, the Code de l'action sociale et des familles). The firm first identifies the competent court: going to the wrong court costs months.
The wording of Article L. 142-1 changes on 1 November 2026: its 5° now refers to the state of permanent incapacity, no longer to the state of permanent incapacity for work, the other categories of dispute remaining unchanged. This page refers to the version in force on that date. Workplace accidents and the employer's inexcusable fault (faute inexcusable) have their own page: workplace accident lawyer in Paris.
The procedure
From the fund's decision to the appeal judgment
Each stage has its own time limit, and the first one often comes into play before a court is even involved.
Notification
The body's decision is notified by any means that establishes the date of notification. Unless legislation provides otherwise, the time limit for the prior appeal and the time limit for the court challenge are two months, and they can only be enforced if they were stated, together with the means of appeal, in the notification or, for an implicit decision, in the acknowledgement of receipt of the application (Article R. 142-1-A).
Amicable appeal
A complaint against a decision of a social security or agricultural social insurance body is submitted to its amicable appeals board (commission de recours amiable), which must be approached within two months of notification (Article R. 142-1). If there is no reply within two months of receipt of the complaint, the application may be treated as rejected (Article R. 142-6).
Medical appeal
Disputes of a medical nature, invalidity, unfitness for work and permanent incapacity go through the medical amicable appeals board (Article R. 142-8). It draws up a report with reasoned conclusions and gives an opinion that is binding on the body; if no decision is made within four months of the appeal being lodged, the application is rejected (Article R. 142-8-5).
Court
A case is brought before the social division (pôle social) by an application filed with or sent to the court registry by registered letter, with a brief statement of the grounds, the documents listed in a schedule and a copy of the contested decision or of the prior appeal that went unanswered (Article R. 142-10-1). “The procedure is oral.” (Article R. 142-10-4, our translation)
Expert assessment
In medical disputes, the medical report on which the decision was based is sent to the expert or consulting doctor appointed by the court and, at the request of an employer who is a party to the proceedings, notified to the doctor the employer appoints (Article L. 142-10); the costs of these consultations and expert assessments are borne by the health insurance scheme (Article L. 142-11).
Appeal
The time limit for appeal is one month in contentious matters (Article 538 of the Code of Civil Procedure), before a specially designated court of appeal (Article L. 311-15 of the Code of Judicial Organisation). “Appeal proceedings are conducted without compulsory representation.” (Article R. 142-11, our translation)
A time limit that was not stated does not run. The Cour de cassation has so held, under the earlier texts read together with Article R. 142-1-A, for a challenge to a permanent incapacity rate: in the absence of proper notification of the means of and time limits for appeal, the two-month time limit “to challenge the decision of a social security body on the permanent incapacity rate in the event of a workplace accident or occupational disease does not run” (our translation), and the employer, to whom the fund had indicated a court lacking jurisdiction, was “entitled to challenge that decision without any time limit” (Cass. 2e civ., 27 June 2024, No. 22-17.881, our translation). It again quashed a court of appeal judgment that had declared an insured person time-barred, as the notification did not specify the time limit for the court challenge after the board's silence, “so that it had not caused the time limit for the court challenge to start running” (Cass. 2e civ., 14 November 2024, No. 23-16.186, our translation). In October 2026, it added that designating a court lacking jurisdiction to hear the appeal “has the effect that the time limit for bringing it does not start to run” (Cass. 2e civ., 15 October 2026, No. 24-19.708, our translation).
The rule also works against the insured person. Where the decision of the medical amicable appeals board, notified with the means of and time limits for appeal, is not challenged in time, “the decision of the social security body had become final” (our translation) and the appeal is inadmissible, even if the case had been brought to court too early, before going to the board (Cass. 2e civ., 19 October 2023, No. 22-10.151). The firm therefore rereads every notification, every acknowledgement of receipt and every date of receipt before choosing the route.
A prior appeal is not always required. It does not apply, in particular, to warnings and penalties imposed under Articles L. 114-17 and L. 114-17-1 (Article L. 142-4); and the procedure before the amicable appeals board does not apply to disputes over waivers of the surcharge applied to overpayments claimed from healthcare professionals and establishments (Article L. 133-4), covered by Article R. 142-7. A complaint may also be taken to the body's mediator, after an approach to its departments and as long as no court challenge has been brought; mediation interrupts the time limits for appeal, from notification that the complaint is admissible until the mediator's recommendations are communicated (Article L. 217-7-1).
Both sides
You are an insured person or benefit recipient, or an employer or professional
The same texts read differently depending on where you stand in relation to the fund.
You are an insured person, benefit recipient or pensioner
- Challenging a refusal of daily allowances, an invalidity pension, a retirement pension, family benefits or the disabled adult allowance (AAH).
- Disputing an overpayment: the calculation, the two-year limitation period, alleged fraud, a debt write-off in case of financial hardship.
- Obtaining compensation for loss caused by wrong information or a mistake by the fund.
You are an employer, self-employed or a healthcare professional
- Challenging contributions, a formal notice, an enforcement order (contrainte) or an affiliation.
- Challenging whether the acceptance of a claim as an occupational risk can be enforced against you (opposabilité), or an incapacity rate.
- Responding to an overpayment notice or a health insurance penalty.
The complaint letter defines the dispute. According to the Cour de cassation, the scope of the referral to the amicable appeals board “is determined by the content of the complaint letter and not by reference to the subsequent decision of that board” (our translation), and the board has before it the challenge to the merits of a reassessment “even where the complaint gives no reasons regarding certain heads of the reassessment” (Cass. 2e civ., 9 December 2021, No. 20-11.285, our translation). A broadly worded complaint therefore protects all the points in dispute. Conversely, what was never submitted to the board cannot be decided by the court: for the Grenoble Court of Appeal, “Failure to bring the said prior appeal renders the court challenge inadmissible.” (our translation) An insured person thus had his claim concerning a second period off work declared inadmissible, and the overpayment notified for the first upheld (CA Grenoble, social security chamber, 4 December 2025, No. 23/03265).
The court rules on the merits, not on the board's decision. Where the board has rejected the complaint, the Cour de cassation holds that “it is for the court hearing general social security disputes to rule on the merits of the dispute” (our translation), arguments based on an irregularity in the board's decision being ineffective; in that case, the court of appeal's judgment was quashed in its entirety and the contributing company ordered to pay the costs (Cass. 2e civ., 21 June 2018, No. 17-27.756). The firm therefore builds the case on the merits from the amicable appeal stage: a procedural error by the board is not enough to win.
The arguments the firm examines in every case:
The sums at stake
Overpayments, contributions and penalties: the rules that change the outcome
Limitation periods, mandatory preliminary steps, the court's powers: what the body must comply with before making a claim.
Health insurance overpayments
An action to recover cash benefits paid in error is time-barred two years after their payment, except in cases of fraud or false declaration (Article L. 332-1). Within the time limit stated in the overpayment notice, and before the prior appeal, the insured person may ask for the information that affects the amount of the overpayment to be corrected (Article L. 133-4-1).
Retirement and invalidity pensions
Repayment of an overpayment of old-age or invalidity benefits is time-barred two years after payment, except in cases of fraud or false declaration; where the body made the mistake, nothing is claimed from an insured person acting in good faith whose income is below the ceiling set by the text (Article L. 355-3).
Family benefits
The fund's action to recover benefits paid in error is time-barred after two years, or five years in the event of fraudulent manoeuvres or false declaration (Article L. 553-1). The debt may be reduced or written off in case of financial hardship, except in cases of fraud (Article L. 553-2).
Overpayments claimed from professionals
A recovery action against a healthcare professional or establishment is time-barred three years after payment, except in cases of fraud. It begins with a notice to pay or to submit observations within two months, followed, if the observations are rejected, by a formal notice to pay within one month (Article L. 133-4).
Contributions
The limitation period for social security contributions and levies is three years, running from the end of the calendar year for which they are due and, for self-employed workers, from 30 June of the following year (Article L. 244-3). Any enforcement action must be preceded by a precise and reasoned formal notice (Article L. 244-2).
Enforcement order (contrainte)
If the formal notice has had no effect after one month, the director may issue an enforcement order (Article R. 133-3), which has the effects of a judgment unless an objection is lodged with the court (Article L. 244-9). The objection must be lodged within fifteen days of notification or service (Article R. 133-3).
Fraud is not presumed. To set aside the two-year limitation period, the fund must establish fraud or a false declaration, and the Cour de cassation specifies that “a false declaration means an inaccurate declaration or an omission from a declaration, made deliberately in order to obtain payment of the benefit” (our translation). It quashed a court of appeal judgment that had relied merely on the inaccuracy of a salary declaration, without examining whether the insured person had intended it (Cass. 2e civ., 13 May 2026, No. 23-21.052). Even a correctly calculated debt can be reduced: apart from contributions and surcharges, the funds' claims may be reduced where the debtor is in financial hardship, except in cases of fraud (Article L. 256-4), and when a court hears a challenge to a refusal of a write-off, “it is for the court to assess whether the debtor's financial hardship justifies a total or partial write-off of the debt in question” (Cass. 2e civ., 28 May 2020, No. 18-26.512, our translation).
On the contributor's side, the formal notice “must enable the contributor to understand the nature, basis and extent of their obligation” (our translation). The Cour de cassation does not, however, accept purely formal criticisms: it quashed a judgment annulling a formal notice, holding that the notice “mentioned identifiable acronyms to designate the nature of the contributions due” (Cass. 2e civ., 20 March 2025, No. 22-24.609, our translation). Lastly, affiliation cannot be disputed solely on the basis of registration with the professional order (inscription ordinale): for a doctor in private practice, the obligation to be affiliated and to pay contributions “arises by the sole operation of the law as soon as the activity concerned is carried on” (Cass. 2e civ., 5 December 2024, No. 22-17.579, our translation).
Penalties are subject to a proportionality review. The director of the health insurance fund may impose a penalty on an insured person, an employer or a professional, set according to the seriousness of the facts up to 70% of the sums concerned, a ceiling raised in cases of fraud (Article L. 114-17-1); family allowance and pension funds have a comparable power, up to four times the monthly social security ceiling (Article L. 114-17). It is for the court “to assess whether a sanction of a punitive nature imposed by a social security body is commensurate with the seriousness of the offence committed” (our translation); in the case decided, however, the nurse's appeal to the Cour de cassation was dismissed, the court of appeal having upheld one penalty and reduced the other (Cass. 2e civ., 24 September 2020, No. 19-19.132). See our pages on health insurance fraud and CAF benefit fraud.
Our dedicated pages
One page per body and per stage of the appeal
Each body has its typical decisions and its pitfalls; these pages deal with them in detail.
CPAM: refusal of daily allowances or medical care, health insurance overpayments and penalties, on our CPAM lawyer page.
MSA: contributions, affiliation and benefits under the agricultural scheme, on our MSA lawyer page.
CIPAV: affiliation, contributions and pensions of self-employed professionals (professions libérales), on our CIPAV lawyer page.
CARSAT: calculation and effective date of the retirement pension, overpayments and information to insured persons, on our CARSAT lawyer page.
CAF: refused family benefits, overpayments and debt write-offs, on our CAF lawyer page.
MDPH: disabled adult allowance, incapacity rate and prior appeal against decisions of the commission for the rights and autonomy of disabled persons, on our MDPH lawyer page.
Amicable appeals board: drafting a complete complaint within the time limit, on our page lawyer for amicable appeals board complaints.
Social division (pôle social): bringing the case, the hearing and evidence before the judicial court, on our page lawyer before the pôle social.
Several related areas already have their own page on the site. URSSAF inspections and reassessments, enforcement orders and formal notices are covered on the page URSSAF litigation lawyer. Recognition of a workplace accident or an occupational disease, and inexcusable fault, which entitles the victim to additional compensation (Article L. 452-1), on the page workplace accident lawyer. Prosecutions for fraud, on the pages CAF fraud lawyer and health insurance fraud lawyer. Lastly, retirement pensions have their own page: social protection and pensions lawyer.
Social security law often extends an employment dispute: sick leave, unfitness for work, termination. The firm handles both aspects together, before the social division (pôle social) and before the employment tribunal (conseil de prud'hommes), from its page employment lawyer in Paris.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Fourteen detailed answers, based on the texts in force and on verified decisions.
What does a social security lawyer do in France?
A social security lawyer challenges the decisions of social security bodies and defends the people to whom they are addressed. The field is wide: the application of social security and agricultural social insurance legislation, the collection of contributions, invalidity, unfitness for work, permanent incapacity after a workplace accident or an occupational disease, and certain decisions of the commission for the rights and autonomy of disabled persons (Article L. 142-1 of the French Social Security Code). The bodies and courts involved are the CPAM, URSSAF, the MSA, the CAF, pension funds, the MDPH, and the social division (pôle social) of the judicial court.
A lawyer is not compulsory. “The parties may defend themselves.” (our translation) They may also be assisted or represented by a lawyer, or by certain persons exhaustively listed, such as a spouse, a trade union representative or the delegate of an association set up at least five years earlier in the fields covered by the text; these other representatives must produce a special power of attorney (Article L. 142-9). The value of a lawyer lies in the procedure: time limits that do or do not run depending on what the notification states, the complaint that sets the scope of the dispute, the choice of the competent court, medical evidence and expert assessment.
The firm reviews the decision and its notification, drafts the prior appeal, brings the case before the social division, argues it at the hearing, then handles the appeal. It acts for insured persons and benefit recipients as well as for employers, the self-employed and healthcare professionals.
How long do I have to challenge a CPAM, CAF or URSSAF decision?
In principle, two months. Unless otherwise provided, the time limit for the prior appeal and the time limit for the court challenge are two months from notification of the contested decision (Article R. 142-1-A of the French Social Security Code), and the amicable appeals board must be approached within that time limit (Article R. 142-1). Specific time limits exist, such as the fifteen days for an objection to an enforcement order (Article R. 133-3).
These time limits come with a condition: “These time limits are only enforceable on condition that they have been stated, together with the means of appeal, in the notification of the contested decision or, in the case of an implicit decision, in the acknowledgement of receipt of the application.” (Article R. 142-1-A, our translation). The Cour de cassation applies this rule. Where the notification named a court lacking jurisdiction, the two-month time limit “to challenge the decision of a social security body on the permanent incapacity rate in the event of a workplace accident or occupational disease does not run” (Cass. 2e civ., 27 June 2024, No. 22-17.881, our translation). Where the notification did not specify the time limit for the court challenge after the board's silence, the time limit did not run either (Cass. 2e civ., 14 November 2024, No. 23-16.186).
An expired time limit is therefore not always fatal. The firm checks the date of receipt and what the notification and the acknowledgement of receipt state, before concluding that a claim is time-barred or raising the time bar against the other side.
Do I have to go to the amicable appeals board before going to court?
Yes, in most cases. Court challenges in the matters covered by Article L. 142-1, except for the rating of workplace accident contributions, must be preceded by a prior appeal (Article L. 142-4 of the French Social Security Code). For an administrative decision of the body, the prior appeal goes to its amicable appeals board (commission de recours amiable) (Article R. 142-1); for a dispute of a medical nature, invalidity, unfitness for work or permanent incapacity, it is the medical amicable appeals board (Article R. 142-8).
Skipping this step is costly. For the Grenoble Court of Appeal, “Failure to bring the said prior appeal renders the court challenge inadmissible.” (our translation) In that case, the insured person was disputing the calculation of his daily allowances for two periods off work; as no prior complaint had been made about the second, his claim on it was declared inadmissible, and the overpayment notified for the first was upheld (CA Grenoble, social security chamber, 4 December 2025, No. 23/03265).
There are exceptions. The prior appeal does not apply, in particular, to warnings and penalties imposed under Articles L. 114-17 and L. 114-17-1 (Article L. 142-4), and the procedure before the amicable appeals board does not apply to disputes over waivers of the surcharge applied to overpayments claimed from healthcare professionals and establishments (Article L. 133-4), covered by Article R. 142-7. Lastly, the complaint must cover everything that is being challenged: the scope of the referral to the board “is determined by the content of the complaint letter and not by reference to the subsequent decision of that board” (Cass. 2e civ., 9 December 2021, No. 20-11.285, our translation). See the page lawyer for amicable appeals board complaints.
The amicable appeals board has not replied: what should I do?
Treat the application as rejected and go to court. Where the board's decision has not been brought to the applicant's attention within two months, the applicant may treat the application as rejected; this time limit runs from receipt of the complaint by the body, or from receipt of the documents subsequently produced by the complainant (Article R. 142-6 of the French Social Security Code). For the medical amicable appeals board, the absence of a decision by the body within four months of the appeal being lodged amounts to a rejection (Article R. 142-8-5).
The time limit for going to court against this implicit rejection depends on the acknowledgement of receipt. In the case of an implicit decision, time limits can only be enforced if they were stated, together with the means of appeal, in the acknowledgement of receipt of the application (Article R. 142-1-A). Under the earlier texts, read together with Article R. 142-1-A, the Cour de cassation thus quashed a court of appeal judgment that had declared an insured person time-barred, as the initial notification did not specify the time limit applicable to the court challenge after the board's silence, “so that it had not caused the time limit for the court challenge to start running” (Cass. 2e civ., 14 November 2024, No. 23-16.186, our translation).
Going to court against the implicit rejection remains valid if the board rules later: the claimant cannot be held time-barred merely because he or she did not challenge in court the express rejection decision issued during the proceedings (Article R. 142-10-1). The firm keeps proof of filing and receipt, and goes to court without delay when the time limit is uncertain.
How do I challenge an incapacity rate, an invalidity decision or a refusal on medical grounds?
By appealing to the medical amicable appeals board, then to the social division (pôle social). Disputes of a medical nature, invalidity, unfitness for work and permanent incapacity after a workplace accident or an occupational disease go to this board (Article R. 142-8 of the French Social Security Code). The fund's medical adviser (praticien-conseil) sends it the full medical report on which his or her decision is based, and professional secrecy cannot be raised against the board; this report is notified, at the employer's request, to the doctor the employer appoints (Article L. 142-6). “It gives an opinion, which is binding on the body responsible for the benefits.” (Article R. 142-8-5, our translation)
Before the court, the medical report is sent to the appointed expert or consulting doctor (Article L. 142-10), and the costs of consultations and expert assessments are borne by the health insurance scheme (Article L. 142-11). The employer can also challenge the rate given to its employee: the Cour de cassation held that it was entitled to act “without any time limit” (our translation) where the notification named a court lacking jurisdiction (Cass. 2e civ., 27 June 2024, No. 22-17.881).
The timetable is unforgiving. The court can only hear a claim against a decision of a body “after it has been submitted to the medical amicable appeals board of that body” (our translation), and the appeal against the board's decision, notified with the means of and time limits for appeal, must be brought within two months. Otherwise the decision becomes final: that is what the Cour de cassation held against an insured person who had gone to court before the board, then had not challenged its decision (Cass. 2e civ., 19 October 2023, No. 22-10.151). See our article on challenging the permanent incapacity (IPP) rate and the page lawyer for CMRA appeals against the IPP rate.
How does a case before the social division (pôle social) of the judicial court work?
Social security litigation is heard by specially designated judicial courts (Article L. 211-16 of the Code of Judicial Organisation), where it is decided by the social division (pôle social). The competent court is in principle the one for the place where the claimant lives (Article R. 142-10 of the French Social Security Code); for an action by a commercial company, as employer, seeking to have the acceptance of a claim declared unenforceable against it, the Cour de cassation looks to the registered office set by its articles of association, not to the establishment where the employee worked (Cass. 2e civ., 15 October 2026, No. 24-19.708).
A case is brought before the court by an application filed with or sent to the registry by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt. It contains a brief statement of the grounds, the documents listed in a schedule, a copy of the contested decision or, for an implicit decision, of the initial decision and of the prior appeal and, where applicable, the name of the doctor designated to receive the medical documents (Article R. 142-10-1). “The procedure is oral.” (our translation) A party may set out its arguments in a letter to the judge, if it shows that the other side had knowledge of them before the hearing, and need not attend (Article R. 142-10-4). The presiding judge prepares the case for trial with the powers of the pre-trial judge, the juge de la mise en état (Article R. 142-10-5).
The court decides the merits of the dispute. The Cour de cassation holds that “it is for the court hearing general social security disputes to rule on the merits of the dispute” (our translation), arguments based on irregularities in the amicable appeals board's decision being ineffective; the court of appeal's judgment was quashed and the contributing company ordered to pay the costs (Cass. 2e civ., 21 June 2018, No. 17-27.756). The firm therefore prepares full written submissions and the documents that prove the right claimed. See our article on appealing a judgment of the pôle social.
The fund is claiming back an overpayment: do I have to repay it?
Not before checking three points: the calculation, the limitation period and the allegation of fraud. The calculation first: in health insurance, the insured person may, within the time limit stated in the notification, ask for the information affecting the amount of the overpayment to be corrected, and the notification must state this time limit as well as the means of and time limits for the prior appeal (Article L. 133-4-1 of the French Social Security Code).
The limitation period next. An action to recover health insurance cash benefits paid in error is time-barred two years after payment, except in cases of fraud or false declaration (Article L. 332-1); the same time limit applies to an overpayment of a retirement or invalidity pension (Article L. 355-3); for family benefits, two years, or five years in the event of fraudulent manoeuvres or false declaration (Article L. 553-1). Where the fund made the mistake, Article L. 355-3 prohibits claiming an overpayment of a retirement or invalidity pension from an insured person acting in good faith whose income is below the ceiling it sets.
Fraud last. A fund that relies on a false declaration to set aside the two-year limitation period must prove that it was deliberate: “a false declaration means an inaccurate declaration or an omission from a declaration, made deliberately in order to obtain payment of the benefit” (our translation). The Cour de cassation quashed a court of appeal judgment that had relied solely on the inaccuracy of a salary declaration (Cass. 2e civ., 13 May 2026, No. 23-21.052). The firm goes back over the calculation, period by period, before any challenge. See our article on overpaid daily allowances when combining employment and retirement.
Can I get a debt write-off from the fund?
Yes, in cases of financial hardship, unless there is fraud. Apart from contributions and late-payment surcharges, the funds' claims arising from the application of social security legislation may be reduced where the debtor is in financial hardship, by reasoned decision of the fund, except in cases of fraudulent manoeuvres or false declarations (Article L. 256-4 of the French Social Security Code). For family benefits, the fund's claim may be reduced or written off in case of financial hardship, except in cases of fraudulent manoeuvres or false declarations (Article L. 553-2).
The fund's refusal is not the last word. When hearing an appeal against a decision rejecting all or part of a request for a write-off, “it is for the court to assess whether the debtor's financial hardship justifies a total or partial write-off of the debt in question” (our translation). In that case, the Cour de cassation upheld the court that had granted a full write-off of two invalidity pension overpayments to an insured person with no salary who was receiving the disabled adult allowance (Cass. 2e civ., 28 May 2020, No. 18-26.512).
A write-off request is prepared like a case built on evidence: income, outgoings, family and medical situation, good faith. It does not dispense with challenging the overpayment itself where its amount or limitation period is open to dispute. The firm submits both requests together, in the prior appeal and then before the social division (pôle social).
URSSAF, the MSA or a fund for self-employed professionals is claiming contributions: how can I defend myself?
First by checking the limitation period and the procedure. Social security contributions and levies are time-barred three years after the end of the calendar year for which they are due; for self-employed workers, the period runs from 30 June of the following year, and it is suspended during the adversarial phase of an inspection (Article L. 244-3 of the French Social Security Code). Any enforcement action must be preceded by a formal notice sent by registered letter or by any means that establishes the date of receipt, whose content must be precise and reasoned (Article L. 244-2).
The formal notice “must enable the contributor to understand the nature, basis and extent of their obligation” (our translation). But the Cour de cassation refuses annulment where the notice “mentioned identifiable acronyms to designate the nature of the contributions due” (Cass. 2e civ., 20 March 2025, No. 22-24.609, our translation). A purely formal challenge therefore has little chance of success; it must show that the contributor could not understand what was being claimed. On affiliation, the same chamber holds that the obligation of a doctor in private practice to be affiliated and to pay contributions “arises by the sole operation of the law as soon as the activity concerned is carried on” (Cass. 2e civ., 5 December 2024, No. 22-17.579, our translation).
If an enforcement order (contrainte) is issued, the objection must be lodged within fifteen days of its notification or service, with the registry of the competent court or by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt (Article R. 133-3); otherwise, the order has the effects of a judgment (Article L. 244-9). See the pages URSSAF litigation lawyer, MSA lawyer and CIPAV lawyer, and our article on the limitation period for URSSAF debts.
Healthcare professional: how do I challenge a health insurance overpayment claim or penalty?
For the overpayment, by following the procedure specific to professionals. Where the rules on pricing, dispensing or billing have not been followed, the body recovers the overpayment from the professional or establishment. The action is time-barred three years after payment of the sum unduly paid, except in cases of fraud, and begins with a notice to pay or to submit observations within two months; if the observations are rejected, the director sends a formal notice to pay within one month, which may only cover sums included in the notice (Article L. 133-4 of the French Social Security Code).
For the penalty, directly before the court. The director of the body may impose a warning or a penalty, set according to the seriousness of the facts up to 70% of the sums concerned, or as a flat amount where no sums can be determined, with higher ceilings in cases of fraud (Article L. 114-17-1). These decisions are not subject to the prior appeal (Article L. 142-4).
The court reviews the proportionality of the sanction: it is for the court “to assess whether a sanction of a punitive nature imposed by a social security body is commensurate with the seriousness of the offence committed” (our translation). This review does not guarantee annulment: in the case decided by the Cour de cassation, the nurse's appeal was dismissed, the court of appeal having upheld one penalty and reduced the other (Cass. 2e civ., 24 September 2020, No. 19-19.132). The firm disputes whether the anomalies actually occurred, for each billed procedure, then the proportionality. See the pages CPAM lawyer and health insurance fraud lawyer.
The pension fund gave me wrong information: can I get compensation?
Yes, if the error is proven and has caused loss. Insured persons have a right to information on the pension system, at no cost to them, organised by law at different stages of their career (Article L. 161-17 of the French Social Security Code), and the minister, with the assistance of the bodies, takes the measures needed to inform insured persons generally (Article R. 112-2).
This obligation has limits. The Poitiers Court of Appeal points out that, where the insured person has made no request, “it is not for the fund to take the initiative of informing him of any rights he may have” (our translation). But when the insured person asks the fund, the answer must be accurate. In that case, the court held that the late filing of the pension application “resulted from incorrect information provided by the fund” (our translation), reversed the judgment and ordered the Carsat to compensate the loss of one month's pension, €337.88, the rest of the claims being dismissed for lack of proof (CA Poitiers, social chamber, 26 March 2026, No. 22/02572).
The lesson is twofold: keep a written record of the questions asked and the answers received, and quantify the loss precisely. Lastly, the same court points out that “whatever the fund's liability for the delay in filing the application, the pension’s starting date cannot be set earlier than the filing of the application” (our translation): compensation takes the form of damages. See the page CARSAT lawyer.
The MDPH refused the disabled adult allowance (AAH): how can I appeal?
A prior appeal, then the social division (pôle social) of the judicial court. Social security litigation includes disputes over the decisions of the commission for the rights and autonomy of disabled persons referred to in the first paragraph of Article L. 241-9 of the Code of Social Action and Families (Article L. 142-1, 8°, of the French Social Security Code), and the court challenge must be preceded by a prior appeal (Article L. 142-4).
The competent court depends on the decision. Decisions by which the commission assesses whether the person's condition or incapacity rate justifies the disabled adult allowance, the disabled child education allowance or the mobility inclusion card (Article L. 241-6, I, 3°, of the Code of Social Action and Families), as well as guidance decisions concerning a child or adolescent, fall within the specially designated judicial court; this appeal is open to any interested person or body, and in principle it does not suspend the decision. Decisions concerning an adult in matters of vocational rehabilitation, adapted or sheltered employment, and recognition of disabled worker status fall within the administrative courts (Article L. 241-9 of the Code of Social Action and Families).
The medical or confidential information on which the decision was based is passed on to the authority handling the prior appeal, then to the expert or consulting doctor appointed by the court, and confidentiality cannot be invoked against them (Articles L. 142-7 and L. 142-10 of the French Social Security Code). The firm gathers the certificates and assessments that describe the actual limitations, and checks the time limits in the notification. See the page MDPH lawyer and our article on the mandatory prior appeal when the AAH is refused.
Can I appeal a judgment of the social division (pôle social)?
Yes, before a specially designated court of appeal, which hears appeals against decisions of the courts dealing with social security litigation (Article L. 311-15 of the Code of Judicial Organisation). “The time limit for an ordinary means of appeal is one month in contentious matters” (Article 538 of the Code of Civil Procedure, our translation). Claims are brought, prepared and decided under the Code of Civil Procedure, subject to the rules specific to social security litigation (Article R. 142-1-A of the French Social Security Code).
“Appeal proceedings are conducted without compulsory representation.” (Article R. 142-11, our translation) The appellant can therefore act alone, but the court decides on the written submissions and documents put before it: it is often on appeal that a case poorly prepared at first instance is saved, or that a favourable judgment is lost for want of an answer to the fund's arguments.
An appeal does not always stop enforcement. The court may order provisional enforcement of all its decisions, and decisions on the daily allowance are provisionally enforceable, notwithstanding appeal, for the allowance due from the accident until the thirtieth day following the appeal (Article R. 142-10-6). The firm analyses the judgment as soon as it is notified, assesses the prospects on appeal and drafts the submissions. See our article on appealing without mandatory legal representation.
How much does a social security lawyer charge in France?
Fees are set out in a written agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971: before committing, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs.
The firm favours a fixed fee per stage: analysis of the decision and its notification, appeal to the amicable appeals board or the medical board, request for a debt write-off, objection to an enforcement order, proceedings before the social division (pôle social), appeal. The costs of consultations and expert assessments ordered by the court in medical disputes are borne by the health insurance scheme (Article L. 142-11 of the French Social Security Code). Any new engagement is covered by an amendment to the agreement, with no unexpected billing.
The fixed fee is set after reading the contested decision and its notification, as the number of stages depends on the time limits still open and on the competent court. Where the dispute also concerns the employment relationship, the agreement distinguishes the part before the social division (pôle social) from the part before the employment tribunal (conseil de prud'hommes).
For a first opinion on documents, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, requested through the form on this page, provides a written analysis within 24 working hours. First contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, checked on 1 November 2026, and the firm's related practice areas.
Official texts
- Articles L. 142-1, L. 142-4, L. 142-8 and L. 142-9 of the French Social Security Code: social security litigation, prior appeal, judicial courts, representation
- Articles L. 142-6, L. 142-10 and L. 142-11: medical report, expert assessment, payment of costs
- Articles R. 142-1-A, R. 142-1, R. 142-6 and R. 142-7: time limits for appeal, amicable appeals board, implicit rejection, exceptions
- Articles R. 142-8 and R. 142-8-5: medical amicable appeals board
- Articles R. 142-10, R. 142-10-1, R. 142-10-4, R. 142-10-5, R. 142-10-6 and R. 142-11: territorial jurisdiction, bringing the case, oral procedure, case preparation, provisional enforcement, appeal
- Articles L. 332-1, L. 355-3, L. 553-1 and L. 553-2: limitation periods for overpayments, debt write-off for family benefits
- Articles L. 133-4, L. 133-4-1 and L. 256-4: overpayments claimed from professionals and insured persons, debt write-off for financial hardship
- Articles L. 244-2, L. 244-3, L. 244-9 and R. 133-3: formal notice, limitation period for contributions, enforcement order, objection
- Articles L. 114-17 and L. 114-17-1: financial penalties
- Article L. 161-17: right to information on pensions; Article R. 112-2: general information for insured persons
- Article L. 217-7-1: mediators of the bodies
- Article L. 452-1: employer's inexcusable fault
- Articles L. 211-16, L. 311-15 and L. 311-16 of the Code of Judicial Organisation: specially designated courts and courts of appeal
- Article L. 241-9 of the Code of Social Action and Families: appeals against decisions of the commission for the rights and autonomy of disabled persons
- Article 538 of the Code of Civil Procedure: time limit for appeal
- Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: fee agreement
Decisions cited
- Cass. 2e civ., 27 June 2024, No. 22-17.881: time limit not running, court lacking jurisdiction named
- Cass. 2e civ., 14 November 2024, No. 23-16.186: time limit for the court challenge not specified
- Cass. 2e civ., 15 October 2026, No. 24-19.708: court lacking jurisdiction, employer's registered office
- Cass. 2e civ., 19 October 2023, No. 22-10.151: medical appeals board, decision has become final
- Cass. 2e civ., 9 December 2021, No. 20-11.285: scope of the referral to the amicable appeals board
- Cass. 2e civ., 21 June 2018, No. 17-27.756: the court decides the merits of the dispute
- Cass. 2e civ., 13 May 2026, No. 23-21.052: false declaration and the two-year limitation period
- Cass. 2e civ., 28 May 2020, No. 18-26.512: debt write-off for financial hardship
- Cass. 2e civ., 20 March 2025, No. 22-24.609: formal notice, sufficient particulars
- Cass. 2e civ., 5 December 2024, No. 22-17.579: affiliation of a doctor in private practice
- Cass. 2e civ., 24 September 2020, No. 19-19.132: proportionality review of penalties
- CA Grenoble, social security chamber, 4 December 2025, No. 23/03265: inadmissibility for lack of a prior appeal
- CA Poitiers, social chamber, 26 March 2026, No. 22/02572: incorrect information from the pension fund
Further reading
Social security lawyer: a CPAM, CAF or URSSAF decision to challenge, a sum claimed, a time limit already running?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send the contested decision with its envelope or acknowledgement of receipt, your correspondence with the body and any documents you have. Hassan Kohen checks the time limits and what the notification states, then tells you the appropriate route: an appeal to the amicable appeals board or the medical board, a request for a write-off, an objection to an enforcement order, an action before the social division (pôle social) or an appeal.