Kohen Avocats — emergency criminal defence
Comparution immédiate lawyer in Paris: urgent defence in court
Our comparution immédiate lawyer in Paris acts from the moment you are brought before the public prosecutor (procureur de la République). The firm represents you before the Paris judicial court (tribunal judiciaire) and across the Paris region (Île-de-France): deciding between an immediate appearance trial (comparution immédiate) and an adjournment, presenting evidence that you will attend court, and defending you at the hearing.
Confidential emergency assistance, 24/7. Same-day representation before criminal courts (tribunaux correctionnels) across the Paris region.
Immediate appearance trial · Paris
Receive a first analysis
If you are brought before the prosecutor for an immediate appearance trial, you can contact our criminal defence firm in Paris at any hour: a lawyer attends the hearing having already worked on your case.
24h/24
7 days a week
for urgent matters
Kohen Avocats, Paris 16
How we defend you in comparution immédiate in Paris
Emergency criminal defence · Paris 16th arrondissement
What a comparution immédiate lawyer does in Paris
- Paris Bar
- Emergency criminal defence
- Paris and the Paris region
- Available 24/7
An immediate appearance trial allows an offence (délit) to be tried on the same day as the person is brought before the prosecutor (déferrement). Where necessary, the person may be held at the courthouse to appear the following day, no later than twenty hours after the end of police custody (garde à vue) (Article 803-3 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure (Code de procédure pénale)). The lawyer acts when the key decisions are made: before the prosecutor, then before the criminal court. The lawyer reads the case file, checks the lawfulness of the procedure, gathers evidence that the person will attend court and advises on the choice between an immediate trial and an adjournment.
The firm acts before the Paris judicial court and criminal courts across the Paris region. Available at any hour on +33 6 89 11 34 45, it takes over as soon as a relative calls, attends court and defends the person through to judgment, then on appeal if necessary.
Official profile in the French National Bar Council (CNB) directory of lawyersOffice at 10 avenue du Colonel Bonnet, 75016 Paris
Criminal case file
Reviewing the procedure as soon as you are brought before the prosecutor: records, legal classification, interviews and possible procedural nullities.
Adjournment or trial
Clear advice before the presiding judge asks for the defendant’s consent in the presence of their lawyer.
Guarantees of appearance
Home, work, family, medical care: documents that can support an alternative to detention.
French Code of Criminal Procedure, Articles 393 to 397-7
Comparution immédiate: the expedited trial explained
A fast trial procedure reserved for offences, chosen by the prosecutor at the end of police custody.
2 years
statutory maximum prison sentence required outside flagrante delicto cases (flagrance)
6 months
is sufficient for a flagrante delicto offence (délit flagrant)
Same day
court appearance of the detained defendant
3rd day
working day at the latest, after the liberty and custody judge
After police custody
Being brought before the prosecutor
At the end of police custody, the person is brought before the public prosecutor. The prosecutor informs them of the alleged facts and their legal classification, their right to a lawyer of their choice or a court-appointed lawyer, and their right to remain silent. The lawyer is notified without delay, may consult the case file immediately, speak confidentially with the person and make observations on the lawfulness of the procedure, the legal classification or shortcomings in the investigation (Article 393 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). The prosecutor then decides what happens next: immediate appearance trial, another form of prosecution, the opening of a judicial investigation or further police enquiries.
Article 395
The conditions under Article 395
- An offence with a statutory maximum prison sentence of at least two years, or at least six months in a flagrante delicto case.
- Sufficient evidence, gathered during the investigation.
- A case ready for trial, without further investigation.
- Circumstances of the case that justify, in the prosecutor’s view, an immediate appearance trial.
The defendant is detained until their court appearance, which must take place on the same day, and escorted before the court (Article 395 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). The procedure does not apply to minors, press offences subject to exceptions, political offences or offences subject to a special procedure (Article 397-6 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). The Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation) permits immediate appearance trials outside flagrante delicto cases where the statutory maximum prison sentence is at least two years (Cass. crim., 18 July 1990, No. 90-81.095).
If no hearing is available
If the court cannot sit on the same day
Where the court cannot sit on the same day and the prosecutor considers detention necessary, the defendant may be brought before the liberty and custody judge (juge des libertés et de la détention, JLD). This judge may order detention, judicial supervision or house arrest with electronic monitoring. The order cannot be appealed, and the defendant must appear before the court no later than the third following working day; otherwise, they are automatically released (Article 396 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
The defendant’s first decision
Agree to an immediate trial or request an adjournment
The defendant can only be tried on the same day with their consent, obtained by the presiding judge in the presence of their lawyer (Article 397 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
Option A
Be tried immediately
Same-day decision
- Decision delivered on the same day.
- Appropriate where the case is straightforward and guarantees of appearance are strong.
- The defence must be prepared in a very short time.
Option B
Request an adjournment
New hearing within 4 to 10 weeks
- A new hearing between four and ten weeks later; the defendant may expressly waive the minimum period.
- The court may be asked to order investigative steps concerning the facts or the defendant’s personal circumstances; reasons must be given for a refusal (Article 397-1).
- The court decides on release, judicial supervision or detention until the hearing.
The choice depends on the case file, the strength of the guarantees of appearance and the risk of detention. The firm gives its advice after reading the file, before the presiding judge asks the question.
Article 397-2
What else the court can decide
The court may order further investigation, entrusted to one of its members or to an investigating judge. If the complexity of the case requires extensive enquiries, it may refer the file back to the prosecutor, who then decides the appropriate next steps. On the prosecutor’s application, the court rules on detention pending the defendant’s appearance before the judge. That appearance must take place on the same day, or within five working days where the case is assigned to the specialist investigating unit of another court (Article 397-2 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
Committal order (mandat de dépôt) and pre-trial detention
Pre-trial detention and committal orders in immediate appearance trials
Three stages at which the defendant’s liberty is at stake: adjournment, conviction and enforcement of the sentence.
Article 397-3 · before judgment
During the adjournment
The court may place or keep the defendant under judicial supervision, under house arrest with electronic monitoring or in pre-trial detention. Detention requires a decision giving specific reasons by reference to objectives 1° to 6° of Article 144: preserving evidence, preventing pressure on witnesses or victims, preventing collusion, protecting the person, ensuring they remain available to the courts, ending the offence or preventing its repetition (Article 397-3 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). Disturbance of public order, listed at 7°, does not apply to offences tried by the criminal court (Article 144 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). If the defendant is detained, judgment on the merits must be delivered within three months of their first appearance; otherwise, they are released.
Article 397-4 · after judgment
After conviction
Where the court imposes an unsuspended prison sentence, it may order detention or continued detention, whatever the length of the sentence, by a decision giving specific reasons. If the detained defendant appeals, the court of appeal must rule within four months; otherwise, they are automatically released (Article 397-4 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
“is not subject to the requirements of Article 144 of the same code, laid down for pre-trial detention” (our translation)
Cass. crim., 13 April 2010, No. 09-87.398
This power does not apply to a defendant whom the liberty and custody judge released under judicial supervision or electronic monitoring before the hearing (Article 396).
French Criminal Code (Code pénal) · sentence enforcement
Adjustment of short prison sentences
6 months
unsuspended or less: adjustment is the rule
1 year
at most: adjustment if personal circumstances allow
An unsuspended prison sentence of six months or less must be served under electronically monitored house detention, day release (semi-liberté) or external placement (placement à l’extérieur), unless the convicted person’s character or circumstances make this impossible. Between six months and one year, adjustment is ordered if their character and circumstances allow (Article 132-25 of the French Criminal Code, Article 132-19). The court nevertheless retains the power to order detention under Article 397-4 and make its decision immediately enforceable. The guarantees gathered by the defence bear directly on this choice.
From the prosecutor to the decision
The stages of an expedited trial
Six stages, from the police station to a possible appeal.
End of police custody
The person is brought before the prosecutor. The lawyer is notified, consults the case file and speaks with them.
The prosecutor’s decision
Immediate appearance trial, another form of prosecution, judicial investigation or further police enquiries.
Same-day hearing
The defendant appears under escort, or the following day if held at the courthouse, within the twenty-hour limit. If no hearing is possible, they may be brought before the liberty and custody judge, then before the court no later than the third working day.
Consent or refusal
In the lawyer’s presence, the presiding judge asks whether the defendant consents to an immediate trial.
Judgment or adjournment
Judgment on the same day, or an adjournment for between four and ten weeks, with a decision on liberty until the hearing.
Appeal
Ten days from delivery of a judgment given in adversarial proceedings, with the period running from service in the cases provided for by law.
“On the same day” does not mean before midnight. The Court of Cassation holds that this requirement “cannot be interpreted as requiring the defendant to be tried before midnight” (our translation) (Cass. crim., 12 January 2021, No. 20-80.259). In an immediate appearance trial, the criminal court must sit as a panel comprising a presiding judge and two other judges (Article 398 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 398-1).
Preparing the defence
Useful documents to gather
These documents help demonstrate that the defendant will attend court and limit the risk of detention. A relative can gather them during police custody and send them to the firm.
- Summons, hearing notice or case reference.
- Official records, any decision received or correspondence from the prosecution service.
- Identity documents and evidence of home address, work, health or education.
- Messages, witnesses, videos, supporting documents and a timeline.
- Previous history, criminal record, current measures or earlier decisions.
- Any supporting guarantee: family ties, medical care, compensation.
Access to the case file must be effective: the Court of Cassation reiterates that “unrestricted consultation of the case file entails making the equipment needed to read it effectively available to the person brought before the prosecutor and their lawyer” (our translation) (Cass. crim., 9 March 2022, No. 21-82.580).
Frequently asked questions
Your questions about immediate appearance trials
Should I agree to be tried immediately?
You are never obliged to agree. The presiding judge informs the defendant that they can only be tried on the same day with their consent, and that consent is only obtained in the presence of their lawyer (Article 397 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). Agreeing allows an immediate decision; it is appropriate where the case is straightforward and guarantees of appearance are strong.
Refusing leads to an adjournment, with a hearing set between four and ten weeks later. The court decides whether the defendant remains at liberty pending that hearing (Article 397-1 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). The right choice depends on the case and the risk of detention: the lawyer advises after reading the file.
Will I be placed in pre-trial detention if I refuse an immediate trial?
Not necessarily. If the case is adjourned, the court may release the defendant, place them under judicial supervision, order house arrest with electronic monitoring or order pre-trial detention (Article 397-3 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). Detention requires a decision giving specific reasons by reference to objectives 1° to 6° of Article 144, and is only possible if judicial supervision or electronic monitoring would be insufficient (Article 144 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
Evidence that the person will attend court (home address, employment, family ties, medical care) is therefore decisive. If the defendant is detained, judgment on the merits must be delivered within three months of their first appearance; otherwise, they are released.
How long does an immediate appearance trial take?
The law sets time limits, rather than a hearing duration. The defendant must appear on the same day as they are brought before the prosecutor (Article 395 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure) or, where necessary, the following day, no later than twenty hours after the end of police custody (Article 803-3 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). The Court of Cassation permits the hearing to continue after midnight (Cass. crim., 12 January 2021, No. 20-80.259). If the defendant has been brought before the liberty and custody judge because no hearing was available, they must appear no later than the third following working day (Article 396 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
If the case is adjourned, the new hearing takes place between four and ten weeks later (Article 397-1 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). Waiting time at court depends on the day’s list: the firm remains available during that time on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
Can I change lawyers after an immediate appearance trial?
Yes. A person brought before the prosecutor has the right to a lawyer of their choice (Article 393 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure), and a defendant appearing before the court may be assisted by the lawyer they appoint (Article 417 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). A new lawyer may therefore take over, particularly for the adjourned hearing, a release application or an appeal, after reviewing the case file.
The time limit for appeal is short: ten days from delivery of a judgment given in adversarial proceedings (Article 498 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). It is therefore best to contact the firm as soon as the decision is known, on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
What sentences can an immediate appearance trial lead to?
The same as before a criminal court hearing a case through another procedure: the procedure speeds up the trial without increasing the potential sentence. The maximum depends on the offence charged and, where applicable, legal recidivism. The court may impose a fine, alternative penalties, a suspended prison sentence or an unsuspended prison sentence.
An unsuspended prison sentence of six months or less must be adjusted, unless the convicted person’s character or circumstances make this impossible (Article 132-25 of the French Criminal Code). Where an unsuspended prison sentence is imposed, the court may nevertheless order detention by a decision giving specific reasons, whatever the length of the sentence (Article 397-4 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
Which offences can be tried in an immediate appearance trial?
Offences with a statutory maximum prison sentence of at least two years, or at least six months in a flagrante delicto case, where the evidence is sufficient and the case is ready for trial (Article 395 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). Flagrante delicto is not required where the statutory maximum prison sentence is at least two years (Cass. crim., 18 July 1990, No. 90-81.095).
The procedure excludes minors, press offences subject to the statutory exceptions, political offences and offences prosecuted under a special law (Article 397-6 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). The precise legal classification adopted by the prosecution service must therefore be checked as soon as the person is brought before the prosecutor.
Can I get the hearing postponed to prepare my defence?
Yes. If the defendant does not consent to be tried immediately, or if the case does not appear ready for trial, the court adjourns it to a hearing at least four weeks later, unless the defendant expressly waives that minimum period, and no more than ten weeks later (Article 397-1 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
The defendant or their lawyer may ask the court to order any useful investigative step concerning the facts or the defendant’s personal circumstances. If it refuses, the court must give a reasoned judgment. The adjournment is accompanied by a decision on liberty until the hearing.
Can I appeal a conviction from an immediate appearance trial?
Yes. An appeal must be lodged within ten days of delivery of a judgment given in adversarial proceedings. In certain cases provided for by law, including where the defendant was not informed of the date on which judgment would be delivered, the period only starts when the judgment is served (Article 498 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
An appeal generally suspends enforcement of the judgment, subject to statutory exceptions (Article 506 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). A defendant placed or kept in detention at the hearing remains detained. The court of appeal must then rule within four months; otherwise, they are automatically released (Article 397-4 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). A procedural nullity raised at first instance must be raised again before the court of appeal, before any defence on the merits: “it was for the defendant alone, even as respondent to the appeal, to raise again, before any defence on the merits, the objection previously raised before the criminal court” (our translation) (Cass. crim., 15 April 2026, No. 25-84.977).
Can I be placed in pre-trial detention before the court hearing?
Yes, in a specific situation: where the court cannot sit on the same day and the prosecutor considers detention necessary. The defendant is then brought before the liberty and custody judge, who rules after hearing their observations or those of their lawyer (Article 396 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
The order cannot be appealed and must give reasons by reference to objectives 1° to 6° of Article 144. The defendant must appear before the court no later than the third following working day; otherwise, they are automatically released. The judge may instead choose judicial supervision or house arrest with electronic monitoring.
What happens if the court refers the case back to the prosecutor?
The court may refer the file back to the prosecutor where the complexity of the case requires extensive further investigation. The prosecutor then decides the appropriate next steps, for example opening a judicial investigation or bringing the case before the court again (Article 397-2 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
On the prosecutor’s application, the court decides whether to detain the defendant until they are brought before the liberty and custody judge or the investigating judge. That appearance must take place on the same day, or within five working days where the case is assigned to the specialist investigating unit of another court; otherwise, the defendant is released. If the same case comes before the court again, it cannot refer it back to the prosecutor a second time.
How long after arrest does an immediate appearance hearing take place?
It depends on the length of police custody, then on the appearance before the prosecutor (Article 393 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). Once an immediate appearance trial has been decided, the defendant is detained and must appear on the same day (Article 395 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). Where necessary, they may appear the following day, within twenty hours of the end of police custody (Article 803-3 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
If the court cannot sit that day, the defendant may be brought before the liberty and custody judge, then must appear before the court no later than the third following working day (Article 396 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). A relative who learns that someone is being brought before the prosecutor should therefore act quickly: the firm answers on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
What exactly does a lawyer do in an immediate appearance trial?
When the person is brought before the prosecutor, the lawyer consults the case file, speaks confidentially with them and makes observations to the prosecutor on the lawfulness of the procedure, the legal classification or shortcomings in the investigation (Article 393 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). The lawyer must be able to read the file effectively: the Court of Cassation requires the provision of “the equipment needed to read it effectively” (our translation) (Cass. crim., 9 March 2022, No. 21-82.580).
Before the court, the lawyer advises on an immediate trial or an adjournment, raises procedural nullities, presents guarantees of appearance, argues against detention and addresses guilt and sentence, including sentence adjustment. After judgment, the lawyer assesses whether an appeal is appropriate.
How does a committal order issued at the hearing work?
Where the court imposes an unsuspended prison sentence, it may order detention or continued detention, whatever the length of the sentence, by a decision giving specific reasons (Article 397-4 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). This decision “is not subject to the requirements of Article 144 of the same code, laid down for pre-trial detention” (our translation) (Cass. crim., 13 April 2010, No. 09-87.398).
Even for a short sentence that should in principle be adjusted, the court may order detention and make its decision immediately enforceable (Article 132-25 of the French Criminal Code). If the detained convicted person appeals, the court of appeal must rule within four months. This power does not apply to a defendant whom the liberty and custody judge placed under judicial supervision or electronic monitoring before the hearing (Article 396 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
Sources and related pages
Official texts and related pages
The articles of the French Code of Criminal Procedure cited on this page, in their versions in force on 13 October 2026.
See also the French Code of Criminal Procedure on Légifrance and the French Criminal Code on Légifrance.
Further reading
Page updated on 13 October 2026.
Facing an immediate appearance trial?
Has a relative just been brought before the prosecutor, or is the hearing already set? Call the firm at any hour: a lawyer reads the case file, gathers guarantees of appearance and defends you in court.