
Kohen Avocats · Paris Bar · 16th arrondissement
Environmental
lawyer in Paris.Residents, businesses,
associations.
Your environmental lawyer in Paris, from the first letter to the hearing.
Preliminary review: €80 incl. VAT
Written reply within 24 working hours
The firm in the media
Watch the videos and read their transcriptsVideos
- Third-party challenges to an environmental permit: two months from the last required public notice
- Administrative court (tribunal administratif), judicial court (tribunal judiciaire), criminal court (tribunal correctionnel)
- Written analysis of your documents within 24 working hours
- Paris 16th arrondissement, the Paris region (Île-de-France), courts elsewhere in France depending on the case
YOUR SITUATION
Environmental lawyer: ten situations, the same starting point.
An order displayed at the town hall, a formal notice, construction work starting, a persistent smell. Your environmental lawyer in Paris starts each case with the document received and the deadline. Find your situation: each card opens the case review form.
A project near you has just been authorised.
Third parties have two months to apply to the administrative court, from the last required public notice: display at the town hall or publication on the prefecture's website (Article R. 181-50 of the French Environmental Code, Code de l’environnement). The challenge must be notified to the authority that issued the decision and to its beneficiary, otherwise it is inadmissible (Article L. 181-17).
Explain my situation ↗ Formal notice from the prefectAn inspection has identified a breach.
The prefect (préfet) serves formal notice requiring you to comply within a specified period. Once that period expires, the prefect may require a financial deposit, have works carried out at your expense, suspend operations and impose an administrative fine of up to €45,000, with a daily penalty of up to €4,500 (Article L. 171-8). Before each sanction, you are given time to submit observations.
Explain my situation ↗ Regulated industrial facility (installation classée)Operating without a permit, or despite a suspension.
Operating a regulated industrial facility without the required permit or registration is punishable by one year's imprisonment and a €75,000 fine; continuing to operate despite a suspension or closure order, or a formal notice, carries two years and €100,000 (Article L. 173-1). The first point to check is the regulatory regime governing the activity.
Explain my situation ↗ Contaminated landYou bought land that previously housed a regulated industrial facility.
The seller of land on which a facility requiring a permit or registration has operated must inform the buyer in writing. If the seller fails to do so and contamination makes the land unsuitable for its intended use, the buyer may, within two years of discovery, seek rescission of the sale, repayment of part of the price or, where the cost is not disproportionate, remediation of the site at the seller's expense (Article L. 514-20).
Explain my situation ↗ Abnormal neighbourhood nuisance (trouble anormal de voisinage)Noise, smells, dust, loss of sunlight.
Anyone responsible for a disturbance exceeding normal neighbourhood inconvenience is strictly liable, without any need to prove fault (Article 1253 of the French Civil Code, Code civil). A pre-existing activity that complies with the law and continues under the same conditions bars the claim: the chronology and measurement of the disturbance determine the case.
Explain my situation ↗ Water pollutionA discharge, a watercourse, a criminal complaint.
Discharging or allowing a substance to flow into water where it harms health, fauna or flora is punishable by two years' imprisonment and a €75,000 fine; the limitation period runs from discovery of the damage (Article L. 216-6). The liberty and custody judge (JLD) may order operations conducted in breach of the law to be suspended for up to one year (Article L. 216-13).
Explain my situation ↗ WasteIllegal dumping, fill material, construction waste.
The enforcement authority informs the producer or holder of the alleged breaches and may, after receiving their observations, impose a fine of up to €15,000 and serve formal notice. Failure to comply may lead to a financial deposit, works carried out at their expense, a daily penalty of up to €1,500 and a fine of up to €150,000 (Article L. 541-3). Under criminal law, abandoning waste in breach of the Code is punishable by four years' imprisonment and a €150,000 fine (Article L. 541-46).
Explain my situation ↗ Protected speciesConstruction work, a habitat, a missing derogation.
Harming the conservation of protected species or their habitats, intentionally or through gross negligence, is punishable by three years' imprisonment and a €150,000 fine (Article L. 415-3). The project developer must plan ahead for the derogation; a resident or association may rely on its absence to challenge the project.
Explain my situation ↗ Ecological damage (préjudice écologique)Remedying damage to nature itself.
Anyone responsible for ecological damage must remedy it (Article 1246 of the French Civil Code), provided the harm to ecosystem components or functions is not negligible (Article 1247). Those entitled to bring proceedings include the State, the local authorities concerned and associations that are accredited or have existed for at least five years (Article 1248). The court may also order measures to prevent or stop the damage (Article 1252).
Explain my situation ↗ Building permits & planningYour neighbour's building permit, or yours.
A neighbour has standing to challenge a building permit only if the project directly affects the occupation, use or enjoyment of their property (Article L. 600-1-2 of the French Planning Code, Code de l’urbanisme). For third parties, the time limit to challenge runs from the first day of a continuous two-month period of display on the land (Article R. 600-2). Building without a permit or in breach of one is punishable by a fine of €1,200 to €6,000 per square metre of floor area built, or up to €300,000 in other cases (Article L. 480-4).
Explain my situation ↗WHO YOU ARE
Your environmental law firm: residents, operators, associations. The same care.
As an environmental law firm in Paris, we advise individuals, businesses and associations. Your position in the case, whether bringing a claim or facing one, determines how the firm acts.
The project next door, the noise, the smell, the view.
A permit displayed at the town hall, construction work starting, a persistent disturbance: time limits run from publication of the decision, and evidence is gathered from the first days.
↗ Businesses and operatorsInspection, formal notice, prosecution.
The inspection report, formal notice, administrative sanction and then criminal summons follow one another. Each stage opens a period for submitting observations or bringing a challenge.
↗ Associations and local authoritiesActing in the collective interest.
An association protecting nature and the environment may apply to the administrative court on any ground relating to its objects (Article L. 142-1 of the French Environmental Code) and, subject to conditions, seek redress for ecological damage (Article 1248 of the French Civil Code).
↗PREPARING YOUR CASE REVIEW
Your documents provide the starting point.
- The prefectural order, authorisation or building permit being challenged, with its display date
- The formal notice, inspection report or official report (procès-verbal)
- Bailiff's reports, measurements, photographs and expert reports
- The deed of sale, diagnostic report or soil survey
- The summons, criminal complaint or notice to appear received
- Any correspondence from the prefecture, town hall or court
HOW THE FIRM SUPPORTS YOU
Understand. Choose. Act.
The strategy is built on your documents and priorities: stopping a project, ending a disturbance, preserving an activity, avoiding a conviction or limiting its consequences.
Reviewing the procedure
Time limits for challenges, publication of the decision, validity of the formal notice, the facility's regulatory regime, missing documents. What the case actually allows.
Defining the engagement
A challenge and urgent application (référé) before the administrative court, a response to formal notice, an abnormal neighbourhood nuisance claim, a criminal complaint or defence before the criminal court. Fees are agreed before any commitment.
Representing your interests
Preparation, written submissions, advocacy and monitoring enforcement of the decision.
YOUR FIRST STEP WITH THE FIRM
Send your documents. Receive a written analysis.
Hassan Kohen personally reads your documents and replies in writing within 24 working hours. Preliminary case review: €80 incl. VAT.
WHAT THE COURTS RULE
French environmental law: what judges decided for residents, operators and associations.
A challenge filed out of time, a disputed formal notice, a smell amounting to abnormal nuisance, a discharge into a river: the courts have already ruled on these situations. Each decision links to the official text so you can read it yourself.
The immediate neighbour of a project, or a co-owners' association (syndicat de copropriétaires), in principle has standing to challenge the permit when it describes the nature, scale or location of the construction.
“Given their particular position, the immediate neighbour in principle has standing to bring proceedings when they present to the court, which rules on all the documents in the case file, information relating to the nature, scale or location of the construction project. The same applies where the applicant is a co-owners' association.” (our translation)Council of State (Conseil d’État), 28 January 2026, No. 500730
Before serving formal notice, the prefect must have provided you with the inspection report; without that disclosure, the formal notice is procedurally defective.
“The fact that the inspector's report recording the breaches was not first brought to the operator's attention under the conditions prescribed by Article L. 171-6 of the Environmental Code is liable to render the formal notice issued procedurally defective.” (our translation)Nancy Administrative Court of Appeal, 16 June 2022, No. 19NC01549
The seller's disclosure duty covers the entire perimeter of the former regulated industrial facility, even where the property sold is simply a house.
“Whereas it had found that the plot formed the entrance to the factory operated from 1893 to 1961 to process gasworks waste in order to extract black sulphur, and that the dwelling was a caretaker's house, from which it followed that the land sold was within the perimeter of the regulated industrial facility requiring a permit, the court of appeal infringed the above provision.” (our translation)Cass. 3e civ., 21 September 2022, No. 21-21.933
A factory's pre-existing activity does not protect it where it has reorganised its site and exceeded noise limits; in this case, the court ordered remedial works rather than a shutdown.
“The industrial site did not continue to operate under the same conditions throughout its operation, since the noise disturbances exceeding tolerable limits arose following the reorganisation of the area used for unloading and processing logs during 2016” (our translation)Besançon Court of Appeal, 25 March 2025, No. 24/00085
The liberty and custody judge may urgently order a polluting discharge to stop, without criminal fault having already been established.
“Article L. 216-13 of the Environmental Code does not make an order by the liberty and custody judge, during a criminal investigation, for interim measures intended to end pollution or limit its effects conditional on establishing fault on the part of the person concerned capable of engaging their criminal liability” (our translation)Cass. crim., 28 January 2020, No. 19-80.091
An association may seek redress for ecological damage before the civil courts, including against a company whose activity is authorised by the administration.
“An action for redress for ecological damage under Articles 1246 et seq. of the Civil Code may, in the absence of any limitation on its scope, be brought before the civil courts against any private person or entity, including one carrying on an activity authorised by the administration.” (our translation)Cass. 3e civ., 13 November 2025, No. 24-10.959
YOUR QUESTIONS
What residents and operators ask the firm.
A project near me has just been authorised: how long do I have to challenge it?
For an environmental permit, third parties have two months from the last required public notice: display at the town hall or publication of the decision on the prefecture's website. If display is the last required notice, time runs from the first day of display (Article R. 181-50 of the French Environmental Code). The challenge must be notified to the authority that issued the decision and to its beneficiary, otherwise it is inadmissible (Article L. 181-17).
For a building, development or demolition permit, the time limit for third parties runs from the first day of a continuous two-month period of display on the land (Article R. 600-2 of the French Planning Code). The neighbour must show that the project directly affects the occupation, use or enjoyment of their property (Article L. 600-1-2). An immediate neighbour, like a co-owners' association, in principle has standing when they provide information about the nature, scale or location of the project (Conseil d’État, 28 January 2026, No. 500730). Send us the decision and a photograph of the display: the firm calculates the deadline and checks your standing to bring proceedings.
How much does an environmental lawyer cost?
The firm begins with a preliminary review of your documents, charged at €80 incl. VAT, with a written analysis by Hassan Kohen within 24 working hours. This analysis explains what the procedure allows, what you can reasonably seek and through which route.
If a further engagement follows, whether a challenge before the administrative court, a response to formal notice, proceedings before the judicial court or a defence before the criminal court, fees are set in an agreement signed before any commitment, according to the procedure and work required. You never pay for an engagement you have not accepted.
I have received formal notice from the prefect: what should I do?
The formal notice sets a deadline for complying with the requirements governing your facility or activity (Article L. 171-8 of the French Environmental Code). It can be challenged before the administrative court. Above all, you should prepare a documented response: works started, a timetable and observations on the inspection findings.
If the deadline expires without compliance, the prefect may, after giving you an opportunity to submit observations, require a financial deposit, have works carried out at your expense, suspend operations and impose an administrative fine of up to €45,000, with a daily penalty of up to €4,500. The fine can no longer be imposed three years after the breaches were recorded. Continuing to operate despite formal notice also carries two years' imprisonment and a €100,000 fine (Article L. 173-1).
Can a neighbour have my building permit annulled?
Only a neighbour whose property's occupation, use or enjoyment is directly affected by the project has standing to challenge the permit (Article L. 600-1-2 of the French Planning Code). The time limit runs from the first day of a continuous two-month period of display on the land (Article R. 600-2). Validity and proof of display are therefore decisive: “The display cannot be regarded as complete and compliant if the height is not stated or if it contains a substantial error, where no other information allows third parties to estimate that height” (our translation) (Conseil d’État, 25 February 2019, No. 416610).
Where a challenge amounts to abusive conduct and causes loss to the permit holder, the latter may ask the administrative court, in a separate written submission, to order the applicant to pay damages (Article L. 600-7). The same rule applies to environmental permits (Article L. 181-17). The firm acts for permit holders and for neighbours challenging permits.
What can I do about noise, smells or dust from a nearby activity?
Abnormal neighbourhood nuisance gives rise to strict liability on the part of whoever causes it, whether an owner, tenant, operator or project owner, without any need to prove fault (Article 1253 of the French Civil Code). Everything depends on evidence of the disturbance and its abnormal nature: bailiff's reports, acoustic measurements, witness statements and medical certificates.
The law excludes this liability where the activity existed before you arrived, complies with statutes and regulations, and has continued under the same conditions, or under new conditions that do not worsen the disturbance. A factory that reorganises its site and then exceeds noise limits loses this protection, and the court may order it to build a noise barrier rather than stop operating (Besançon Court of Appeal, 25 March 2025, No. 24/00085). A regulated industrial activity can also be reported to the prefect, who has the power to serve formal notice (Article L. 171-8 of the French Environmental Code).
Who pays if my land is contaminated by former industrial activity?
If a facility requiring a permit or registration operated on the land, the seller had to inform you in writing, and the deed of sale must record that disclosure (Article L. 514-20 of the French Environmental Code). Failing this, where contamination makes the land unsuitable for the use specified in the contract, you may, within two years of discovering the contamination, seek rescission of the sale, repayment of part of the price, or remediation of the site at the seller's expense if its cost is not disproportionate to the price.
This disclosure duty covers the entire perimeter of the former facility, including a caretaker's house at the entrance to a factory (Cass. 3e civ., 21 septembre 2022, n° 21-21.933). Following permanent cessation of a classified facility's activity, “making the site safe and restoring it are the responsibility of the last operator” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 11 mai 2022, n° 21-16.348). Failure to comply with restoration obligations or monitoring measures prescribed by the administrative authority under Articles L. 171-7 and L. 171-8 is punishable by two years' imprisonment and a €100,000 fine (Article L. 173-1). The deed of sale, diagnostic reports and site history are the first documents to gather.
A river or groundwater is polluted: should I bring a criminal complaint or a civil claim?
Both routes are available. Discharging, dumping or allowing a substance to flow into water where it harms health, fauna or flora is punishable by two years' imprisonment and a €75,000 fine; the limitation period runs from discovery of the damage (Article L. 216-6 of the French Environmental Code). In an emergency, the liberty and custody judge may, on the application of the public prosecutor (procureur de la République), who may be approached by the victim or an accredited association, order any useful measure for up to one year, including suspension of operations (Article L. 216-13), without criminal fault having already been established (Cass. crim., 28 January 2020, No. 19-80.091). A person already suspected must, however, be informed of their right to remain silent before being heard (Cass. crim., 28 January 2025, No. 24-81.410).
In civil proceedings, the victim seeks compensation for their own loss. Those designated by Article 1248 of the French Civil Code, including associations that are accredited or have existed for at least five years, seek redress for the ecological damage itself (Articles 1246 and 1247). The court may order measures to prevent or stop the damage (Article 1252).
My construction work affects a protected species' habitat: what are the risks?
Harming the conservation of protected animal or plant species or their natural habitats, intentionally or through gross negligence, is punishable by three years' imprisonment and a €150,000 fine, with attempts carrying the same penalties (Article L. 415-3 of the French Environmental Code). Applying the wording then in force, the Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation) held that the offence “may be committed simply by failing to comply with those requirements” (our translation), for example promised compensatory measures never implemented, and that “imprudence or negligence is sufficient to establish the mental element of the offence” (our translation) (Cass. crim., 18 October 2022, No. 21-86.965).
The project must therefore be preceded by a species and habitat survey and, where harm is unavoidable, by a derogation obtained before work begins. Faced with a neighbouring project, a resident or association checks whether this derogation exists and whether the impact assessment is accurate. It must pay particular attention to protected species and habitats (Article L. 122-1).
Can an association challenge a permit or seek redress?
Any association whose objects include protecting nature and the environment may apply to the administrative courts on any ground relating to those objects. An accredited association has standing to challenge any administrative decision directly related to its objects and causing environmental harm within the territory covered by its accreditation, provided the decision postdates that accreditation (Article L. 142-1 of the French Environmental Code).
It may also seek redress for ecological damage if it is accredited or has existed for at least five years when proceedings are brought (Article 1248 of the French Civil Code), including before the civil courts against a company whose activity is authorised by the administration (Cass. 3e civ., 13 November 2025, No. 24-10.959). It may also approach the public prosecutor with a view to an urgent environmental application in criminal proceedings (Article L. 216-13). The association's articles, accreditation and date of establishment are the first documents to check.
Does the firm act outside Paris?
The firm, an environmental law practice in Paris's 16th arrondissement, is based on avenue du Colonel Bonnet and represents clients before courts in Paris and the Paris region (Île-de-France): the administrative court, judicial court and criminal court. Depending on the case, it also acts before courts elsewhere in France.
The preliminary review is conducted remotely using your documents, and meetings can take place by video.
ANALYSIS & NEWS