Your father lived in California for thirty years, wrote a California will, and put everything into an American living trust for his second wife. You, his daughter from a first marriage living in Ohio, receive nothing. Then the family notaire in Paris calls: your father still owned an apartment in the 11th arrondissement. Under American law, a parent can disinherit an adult child almost completely. Under French law, children have a locked-in minimum share called the réserve héréditaire (forced share). For almost a decade, American wills won that fight in French courts. Since late 2021, the fight has a new round: a statute lets a disinherited child take a prélèvement compensatoire (compensatory levy) directly from the French property to rebuild the French forced share. This guide explains, in plain English, when an American will can still cut you out, the two 2017 French Supreme Court rulings that allowed it, the exact 2021 mechanism that answers them, how much you can claim, the taxes and the 1978 France-US estate treaty that shape the net result, and the file you must build now. Every decisive rule is quoted from the official text, and every French term is explained at first use.
I. Why an American Will Can Disinherit You From French Property
To understand the remedy, you must first understand why the wound exists. The United States and France start from opposite philosophies. In most American states, testamentary freedom is nearly absolute: a parent may leave everything to a spouse, a charity, or a trust, and leave an adult child one dollar or nothing. The revocable living trust, the standard California estate-planning tool, moves assets into a private vehicle that passes outside probate to whoever the trust names. France starts from the opposite end: children the law calls héritiers réservataires (forced heirs) own a minimum share of the estate that no will and no gift can take away. When an American dies owning property in France, these two philosophies collide, and the question is which law governs the French apartment.
A. The American Tools of Disinheritance and the European Rule That Points to American Law
The American side of the collision uses three familiar tools. First, the will itself, which in most states needs no forced portion for adult children. Louisiana is the famous exception, but California, New York, Florida, and Texas are not: a valid will can give everything to the surviving spouse. Second, the revocable living trust, which holds legal title to houses, accounts, and royalties during the parent’s life and distributes them at death according to private instructions, outside any court. Third, beneficiary designations on life insurance and retirement accounts, which pass by contract and ignore the will entirely. An American parent who uses all three can leave a child from an earlier relationship with nothing under American law, and many do, especially in second-marriage families.
Whether French courts respect that outcome used to depend on a European text: the EU Succession Regulation No 650/2012, which France applies to cross-border successions. Its default rule points to the law of the country where the deceased had his habitual residence when he died (Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, Article 21). A father who lived his last thirty years in Los Angeles therefore dies under Californian law for the whole succession, including the Paris apartment. Worse for the disinherited child, the Regulation lets the deceased choose the applicable law himself, in particular the law of any country whose nationality he holds, whether at the time of the choice or at death (same Regulation, Article 22). A dual French-American father can therefore write into his will that American law governs everything, and the French notaire settling the Paris apartment must in principle apply it. Californian law knows no forced share, so the child gets nothing, and for years the story ended there.
France once had an old safety net for exactly this situation. A statute of 14 July 1819 gave French heirs a right to take a compensating share, a droit de prélèvement, from assets located in France when a foreign law cut them out. But that old levy did not survive constitutional review: seized through a priority question of constitutionality, the Constitutional Council declared its Article 2 contrary to the Constitution in its decision of 5 August 2011 (No. 2011-159 QPC), and the Cour de cassation later confirmed that once abrogated, the old provision could no longer be applied in pending cases and could no longer ground any claim. From 2011 to 2021, the disinherited child of an American parent had no levy at all, only one fragile argument: that the foreign law shocked French international public policy, the ordre public international, the narrow emergency brake that lets a French judge refuse to apply a foreign law that offends principles France treats as essential. In 2017, the Cour de cassation tested that brake twice, on the same family, and twice it held.
B. The 2017 Shock: Two Supreme Court Rulings That Let Californian Law Disinherit French Children
On 27 September 2017, the First Civil Chamber of the Cour de cassation, France’s supreme court for civil cases, handed down two published decisions in the same affair, and both rejected the children’s claims. The facts read like a Hollywood estate battle. A French composer had lived in California for nearly thirty years, married there, signed an American will leaving everything to a family trust benefiting his wife, and died in California survived by his wife, their two daughters, and four children from earlier unions. The four older children sued in France, arguing that Californian law, which ignores the forced share, violated French international public policy. The court answered with a holding every American heir must know: a foreign law designated by the conflict rule which ignores the forced share is not in itself contrary to French international public policy (Cass. 1re civ., 27 Sept. 2017, No. 16-13.151, published in the Bulletin). In plain English: a foreign law that ignores the forced share is not automatically contrary to French public policy; a judge sets it aside only if applying it in this specific case produces a result incompatible with principles France treats as essential.
The court then explained why this case did not cross that line. After recalling that the normally applicable law was California’s, which does not know the forced share, it noted that nobody claimed the application of that law would leave any of the claimants, all adults at their father’s death, in a situation of economic precarity or need, that the father had lived almost thirty years in California where his three youngest were born, and that nearly all his real estate and most of his movable wealth sat in the United States. From those findings it exactly deduced that the Californian law, which had let the father give everything to a trust for his wife, the mother of their two then-minor daughters, without reserving anything for his other children, did not offend French international public policy. The companion decision, concerning the same succession under No. 16-17.198, repeats the identical holding for the late Maurice Y., whose last domicile was in California and whose unions since 1965 were contracted in the United States: the parties did not claim to be in any situation of economic precarity or need, so there was no ground to set Californian law aside in favor of French law (Cass. 1re civ., 27 Sept. 2017, No. 16-17.198). The message was brutal and clear: adult children in no financial need, disinherited by a parent genuinely rooted abroad, had no remedy. Parliament found that message unacceptable and rewrote the Code.
II. The 2021 Answer: Taking Your Forced Share From the French Property
The political reaction was swift. The statute of 24 August 2021 on republican principles, Law No. 2021-1109, contains an Article 24 that rebuilt a levy for the modern era by rewriting the Civil Code’s flagship succession provision. Since 1 November 2021, the forced share and its compensating levy live in the same article, and the mechanism is automatic in its conditions: no proof of poverty, no proof of need, and no need to prove that the foreign law shocks public policy. If the statutory conditions are met, the child takes from the French assets. Before using it, you must understand exactly what the French forced share protects, because the levy only rebuilds that share, nothing more.
A. What You Reclaim: The Forced Share, Its Fractions, and the New Levy Word for Word
French law divides every estate into two slices. The Code defines them in one breath: “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent. La quotité disponible est la part des biens et droits successoraux qui n’est pas réservée par la loi et dont le défunt a pu disposer librement par des libéralités” (Civil Code, Article 912). The réserve héréditaire is the locked box for the children; the quotité disponible (disposable portion) is the slice the parent may give to anyone, spouse, charity, or trust. The sizes are fixed by statute: gifts and wills “ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre” (Civil Code, Article 913). Translate that into shares: with one child, the forced box is half the estate; with two children, two thirds split between them; with three or more, three quarters. The locked box is not computed on what merely sits in the estate on the day of death: “La réduction se détermine en formant une masse de tous les biens existant au décès du donateur ou testateur. Les biens dont il a été disposé par donation entre vifs sont fictivement réunis à cette masse” (Civil Code, Article 922). In plain English, lifetime gifts are fictively added back, the réunion fictive, so a father cannot empty the box by giving everything away before death. Only descendants and, in the absence of descendants, the surviving spouse are forced heirs, and in American-disinherited-child cases the claimants are always the children. Gifts that bite into the box can be clawed back through the action en réduction (reduction action), which “ne pourra être demandée que par ceux au profit desquels la loi fait la réserve, par leurs héritiers ou ayants cause” (Civil Code, Article 921). That action is time-barred: “Le délai de prescription de l’action en réduction est fixé à cinq ans à compter de l’ouverture de la succession, ou à deux ans à compter du jour où les héritiers ont eu connaissance de l’atteinte portée à leur réserve, sans jamais pouvoir excéder dix ans à compter du décès” (same article). The official service-public.fr page “Can children be disinherited?” confirms the principle in everyday language: under French law, a child cannot be fully disinherited.
The 2021 levy sits in the third paragraph of that same Article 913, and because your whole case turns on its wording, here it is in full: “Lorsque le défunt ou au moins l’un de ses enfants est, au moment du décès, ressortissant d’un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou y réside habituellement et lorsque la loi étrangère applicable à la succession ne permet aucun mécanisme réservataire protecteur des enfants, chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès, de façon à être rétablis dans les droits réservataires que leur octroie la loi française, dans la limite de ceux-ci” (Civil Code, Article 913, paragraph 3). Every word counts, so unpack it slowly. First, the gateway: the deceased or at least one of the children must, at the moment of death, be a national of an EU Member State or habitually resident there. A French-American dual-national father satisfies it through his French nationality; an American child habitually resident in Paris satisfies it through residence; a purely American family with no EU link does not enter the mechanism at all. Second, the trigger: the foreign law governing the succession, usually Californian or New York law through the EU Regulation’s habitual-residence rule or through the deceased’s choice of his American national law, must offer no reserve-like protection for children. Third, the target: the levy bites only on biens existants situés en France au jour du décès, assets physically or legally situated in France on the day of death, which in practice means the Paris apartment, French bank balances, and French securities, never the California house or the Delaware trust. Fourth, the ceiling: the child is restored to the French forced rights “dans la limite de ceux-ci”, up to those rights and not beyond, meaning the fractions above cap the claim. A concrete example: a father leaves three children and a two-million-euro estate consisting of a 600,000-euro Paris apartment plus American assets, with everything willed to the second wife. The global forced box is three quarters, so each child’s French-law right is one quarter of the total, 500,000 euros. Each child can levy up to 500,000 euros on the French assets, and the Paris apartment covers the first 600,000 of those claims. Raise the claim at the first notaire meeting, because the related reduction action runs on the five-year, two-year, and ten-year clocks quoted above, and delay weakens every succession file.
B. Taxes, the 1978 Treaty, and the File an American Heir Must Build
Winning the levy is only half the battle; the tax collector takes the other half, and an American heir faces two of them. Start with France. French inheritance tax, the droits de mutation à titre gratuit, catches the Paris apartment even when everyone involved lives in America. The Tax Code provides: “Sont soumis aux droits de mutation à titre gratuit : 1° Les biens meubles et immeubles situés en France ou hors de France”, where the donor or deceased was fiscally domiciled in France, and crucially “2° Les biens meubles et immeubles, que ces derniers soient possédés directement ou indirectement, situés en France”, which are taxed regardless of anyone’s domicile (General Tax Code, Article 750 ter). The Paris apartment therefore always passes through French inheritance tax. The direct-line scale runs from 5 percent to a top slice taxed at 45 percent: “Au-delà de 1 805 677 € 45” (General Tax Code, Article 777). Before the scale applies, each child deducts a personal allowance of 100,000 euros: “il est effectué un abattement de 100 000 € sur la part de chacun des ascendants et sur la part de chacun des enfants vivants ou représentés” (General Tax Code, Article 779), and each disinherited child recovers that allowance along with the levy, so it applies to what the levy restores. The succession must be declared to the French tax office “De six mois, à compter du jour du décès, lorsque celui dont on recueille la succession est décédé en France métropolitaine; D’une année, dans tous les autres cas” (General Tax Code, Article 641), six months for a death in metropolitan France and one year in every other case, which covers nearly every American file, and the notaire normally files that declaration, the déclaration de succession, with the payment.
Double taxation is then neutralized by the old but solid estate and gift tax treaty signed at Washington on 24 November 1978, whose consolidated text the French tax administration publishes officially (France-US Convention of 24 November 1978 on estates and gifts, consolidated version), with official commentary in the BOFiP doctrine page on the France-US estate treaty. Its architecture is simple: real estate is taxable in the country where it sits, so France taxes the Paris apartment first, and the United States then credits the French tax against any American estate or gift tax on the same property. On the American side, the federal estate tax exemption, above thirteen million dollars per person in recent years, means most families owe no US estate tax at all, but the return and disclosure duties survive: an American heir who receives authority over French accounts files the FBAR and Form 8938 thresholds as usual, and the estate’s American lawyer should confirm whether a Form 706 is required. Coordinate the two calendars early, because the French declaration deadline does not wait for the American probate to close, and interest and penalties accrue monthly on late French payment while the treaty credit can only be claimed with proof of the French assessment.
The practical file has five layers, and American heirs should assemble them before the first notaire appointment. First, civil status with cross-border validity: the American death certificate with an apostille under the Hague Convention plus a certified French translation, the California will and the trust deed with translations, and proof of the EU gateway, meaning the father’s French passport or national identity card, or your own proof of habitual residence in France. Second, the American-law proof: a legal opinion or affidavit from a California attorney confirming that the applicable American law gives the children no reserve-like mechanism, because the levy requires the absence of any such foreign protection. Third, the French-asset inventory: the notaire pulls the land registry extract, the relevé hypothécaire, for the apartment, orders a valuation, and lists French bank balances as of the day of death. Fourth, the notaire phase: the notaire draws up the acte de notoriété, the official deed listing the heirs, computes each child’s French forced right under the fractions above, and proposes the levy allocation on the French assets; if the surviving spouse or the trust contests it, the dispute goes before the French court, the tribunal judiciaire, in an action combining the levy with reduction of any excessive gifts. Fifth, the tax phase: the declaration of succession, the treaty-credit paperwork for the IRS file, and the release of funds. Three traps kill files at each stage: waiting more than a few months before asserting the levy, which lets the spouse sell or mortgage the apartment; signing any American settlement or waiver without checking its effect under French forced-share law; and assuming the EU gateway is automatic, when a fully American family with no EU nationality or residence cannot use the levy at all and must fall back on negotiation or American proceedings. Families who move fast, prove the gateway on day one, and keep the French and American lawyers on the same email thread recover the apartment’s value; families who discover the levy at year three litigate about deadlines instead of shares.
Conclusion
An American will can still say that a child gets nothing, and since the two 2017 rulings on the Californian succession of a French composer, French courts will not set that will aside merely because it ignores the forced share. Adult children with no financial need lost twice, and the old 1819 levy died with the 2011 constitutional decision. But the statute of 24 August 2021 changed the endgame for every family with a French foothold: when the deceased or at least one child is an EU national or resident, and the applicable American law offers children no reserve-like protection, each child levies directly on the assets sitting in France at death, up to the French forced fraction, with no precarity test and no public-policy pleading. The Paris apartment becomes the collection point. The price of that remedy is discipline: assert the levy at the first notaire meeting, prove the EU gateway with papers, document the absence of American forced protection, file the French succession declaration within the twelve-month foreign-death deadline, and claim the 1978 treaty credit on the American side. Do that, and the apartment your father thought his trust had swallowed pays you the share French law always meant you to have.