KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My Paris Tenant Says My Rent Is Illegal: Reference-Rent Caps, the Rent Supplement That Survives Them, and How an American Landlord Responds

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My Paris Tenant Says My Rent Is Illegal: Reference-Rent Caps, the Rent Supplement That Survives Them, and How an American Landlord Responds

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You own an apartment in Paris, you rent it to a tenant who lives there year-round, and a letter arrives saying your rent breaks the law. The tenant has gone to the local conciliation board, called the commission départementale de conciliation, and asks you to cut the rent and pay back several thousand euros of what French law calls trop-perçu, the overcharge collected above the legal ceiling. If you are an American landlord, everything about this moment feels foreign: a city where the rent on a private lease has a legal maximum, a tenant who can challenge the rent months or even years after signing, a judge who can rewrite the lease price back to day one, a prefect who can fine you on top, and an American tax return that has to absorb the whole story. This article walks you through the system exactly as it applies to your Paris lease. Part I explains how the reference-rent cap works and the single lawful way to charge above it, the rent supplement known as the complément de loyer. Part II explains what happens once a tenant challenges you: the three legal actions, the deadlines that decide everything, the refund math from two recent Paris court rulings, the administrative fine, and the United States tax consequences of a lowered rent. The cases and figures below come from decisions rendered in Paris and from the official guidance of the French administration, so you can check every step against the source before you negotiate, answer a conciliation notice, or instruct counsel.

I. Can Paris really cap my rent, and when can I lawfully charge more than the cap?

Yes. Since July 2019 Paris belongs to the cities where the starting rent of a residential lease has a legal maximum. The mechanism is called the encadrement des loyers, the rent cap, and its current legal home is Article 140 of the ELAN housing Act of November 23, 2018, which created the system as an experiment: “A titre expérimental et pour une durée de huit ans à compter de la publication de la présente loi”, expressly open to “la commune de Paris” among the territories that can request it. The foundation underneath is Article 17 of the Act of July 6, 1989, which defines the tense zones, the zones d’urbanisation continue of more than 50,000 residents with a marked housing imbalance, equips them with a local rent observatory, the observatoire local des loyers, and states that “Un décret fixe la liste des communes comprises dans ces zones.” Each year the State representative sets three reference figures per square meter for every apartment category and every neighborhood sector: the loyer de référence, the reference rent; the loyer de référence majoré, the enhanced reference rent, which is the ceiling; and the loyer de référence minoré, the reduced reference rent, which matters mostly at renewal. The ELAN text describes the machinery this way: “le représentant de l’Etat dans le département fixe, chaque année, par arrêté, un loyer de référence, un loyer de référence majoré et un loyer de référence minoré, exprimés par un prix au mètre carré de surface habitable, par catégorie de logements et par secteur géographique.” Each reference rent is the median observed by the observatory: “Chaque loyer de référence est égal au loyer médian calculé à partir des niveaux de loyers constatés par l’observatoire local des loyers selon les catégories de logements et les secteurs géographiques.” The ceiling sits twenty percent above the median and the floor thirty percent below: “Le loyer de référence majoré est égal à un montant supérieur de 20 % au loyer de référence. Le loyer de référence minoré est égal au loyer de référence diminué de 30 %.” The Paris rent observatory, known as OLAP, supplies the market data, and Paris is divided into 80 geographic sectors crossed with construction period, number of rooms, and furnished or unfurnished status, so the ceiling on your two-bedroom apartment in the 18th arrondissement has nothing to do with the ceiling on a studio in the 7th. For furnished units a yearly per-square-meter markup is added to reflect the furnished premium. Day-to-day rent changes during the lease are governed separately by Article 17-1 on annual indexation and renewal revaluations by Article 17-2 on undervalued rents, but the starting-rent ceiling itself is the ELAN provision quoted here.

A. How do I know whether the cap applies to my Paris lease and which figure is my ceiling?

The cap covers homes rented as the tenant’s main home, called the résidence principale, or under a short mobility lease, called a bail mobilité, while furnished tourist rentals, subsidized social housing, and lodgings under the 1948 statute follow other rules. If your tenant lives in your Paris apartment year-round as their main home, you are inside the system. The Paris version was switched on by Decree 2019-315 of April 12, 2019, setting the experimental perimeter, and by prefectoral order 2019-05 of May 28, 2019, in force since July 1, 2019, a history a Paris trial court recounted in these terms: “depuis le décret n°2019-315 du 12 avril 2019 qui a rendu ce dispositif expérimental applicable et un arrêté préfectoral n°2019-05 du 28 mai 2019, entré en vigueur le 1er juillet 2019” (Paris Judicial Court, April 23, 2026, case 25/06419). Earlier, the Constitutional Council had reviewed the original 2014 version of the cap in Decision 2014-691 DC of March 20, 2014, published in the Journal officiel, which is why judgments about pre-2019 leases quote an older numbering of the statute. The starting-rent rule itself is short: “Dans les territoires où s’applique l’arrêté mentionné au I, le loyer de base des logements mis en location est fixé librement entre les parties lors de la conclusion du contrat de bail, dans la limite du loyer de référence majoré.” The basic rent, called the loyer de base and meaning the rent before charges and before any supplement, is freely agreed within the ceiling, and overstepping opens a reduction action: “Une action en diminution de loyer peut être engagée si le loyer de base prévu dans le contrat de bail est supérieur au loyer de référence majoré en vigueur à la date de signature de ce contrat.” Your lease must state the reference rent and the enhanced reference rent for your unit’s category, because “Le contrat de location précise le loyer de référence et le loyer de référence majoré, correspondant à la catégorie de logements.” If those figures are missing, the tenant can put you on formal notice, called a mise en demeure, by registered letter within one month after the lease takes effect: “En cas d’absence dans le contrat de location de cette mention, le locataire peut, dans un délai d’un mois à compter de la prise d’effet du contrat de location, mettre en demeure le bailleur de porter cette information au bail.” Silence or refusal then opens a three-month window to the judge. Before you sign or renew, run the official Paris reference-rent simulator and keep a dated printout, because the figure that counts is the one in force on the signature date, not the one in force when the dispute starts. Many American owners discover the cap only when the missing figures look like an admission, so put all three numbers in every lease and every listing from the start. All quotations in this section come from Article 140 of the ELAN Act, current version, except the court history passage credited to its judgment link.

B. What rent supplement above the ceiling can survive a challenge, and why do most of them fail?

The only lawful way to exceed the ceiling is the complément de loyer, the rent supplement: a fixed euro amount added on top of a basic rent that already sits exactly at the enhanced reference rent. A leading French landlord guide describes it accurately as a narrow exception, playable only when the unit offers somewhat exceptional location or comfort features. The statute allows it in these terms: “Un complément de loyer peut être appliqué au loyer de base tel que fixé au A du présent III pour des logements présentant des caractéristiques de localisation ou de confort le justifiant, par comparaison avec les logements de la même catégorie situés dans le même secteur géographique.” Two formalities are mandatory: “Le montant du complément de loyer et les caractéristiques du logement le justifiant sont mentionnés au contrat de bail”, and the supplement is arithmetically impossible below the ceiling: “Un complément de loyer ne peut être appliqué à un loyer de base inférieur au loyer de référence majoré.” The implementing conditions are strict and cumulative, set by Article 3 of Decree 2015-650 of June 10, 2015: the features must not have been counted when the reference rent was set, they must be decisive for the rent by comparison with same-category units in the same sector, and they must not already pay you through charges or energy-savings contributions. In the decree’s own words quoted by the Paris Court of Appeal, the features must satisfy that they “n’ont pas été prises en compte pour la détermination du loyer de référence correspondant au logement”, that they are “déterminantes pour la fixation du loyer, notamment par comparaison avec les logements de la même catégorie situés dans le même secteur géographique”, and that they “ne donnent pas lieu à récupération par le bailleur au titre des charges”. Size, building prestige, and general condition are already baked into the reference, so they cannot double as a supplement. Since the 2022 reform, the supplement is flatly prohibited for substandard units: “Aucun complément de loyer ne peut être appliqué lorsque le logement présente une ou plusieurs des caractéristiques suivantes : des sanitaires sur le palier, des signes d’humidité sur certains murs, un niveau de performance énergétique de classe F ou de classe G”, followed by drafty windows, a view blocked within ten meters, outside water infiltration or flooding, recent drainage problems, degraded wiring, and poor exposure of the main room. Check that list before claiming anything, because a single defect kills the whole supplement. The ELAN quotations in this section come from Article 140 of the ELAN Act, current version.

A 2023 Paris appeal ruling shows how judges apply these tests to American-style arguments about charm and standing. The lease of a 64.2 square-meter, fourth-floor apartment set “moyennant un loyer mensuel de 1.890,30 euros, dont un complément de loyer de 317,40 euros et une provision sur charges mensuelle de 95 euros”, a monthly rent of 1,890.30 euros including a 317.40 euro supplement and a 95 euro charge provision. The lease justified the supplement by “le parquet en chêne et la cheminée en marbre qui élèvent le confort et le standing de l’appartement par rapport à un logement de même catégorie, situé dans le même secteur géographique”, oak floors and a marble fireplace said to raise the comfort and standing above same-category units in the same sector, plus handwritten add-ons for a fitted kitchen and Hungarian-point parquet that the tenants had never initialed. The conciliation board had already found that “le complément de loyer demandé par le bailleur n’était pas justifié et qu’il convenait d’appliquer au maximum le loyer correspondant au loyer de référence majoré, soit 1.572,90 euros à compter du 21 décembre 2015 et de ramener le dépôt de garantie au montant équivalent”, the supplement was unjustified and the rent had to come down to the enhanced reference rent of 1,572.90 euros with the deposit reduced to match. The court agreed after comparing evidence: the move-in inspection, called the état des lieux d’entrée, showed oak parquet with holes, scratches, and stains and a fireplace described as merely “décorative” and stained, and the bailiff’s later report confirmed worn, mismatched, damaged parquet present only in some rooms and a small empty marble fireplace of average condition. The court concluded the parquet existed in Hungarian point only in some rooms and was in middling shape, and the white marble fireplace was likewise average with nothing singular about it. Result: the owner, by then a company that had taken over the property, was ordered to pay the tenants back rents of 28,111.18 euros covering December 2015 through February 2023, with the court’s order reading “Condamne la société par actions simplifiée Catherine à payer à M. [L] [N] et Mme [Y] [U] la somme 28.111,18 euros au titre des trop-perçus de loyers entre le 21 décembre 2015, date d’effet du bail, et le 28 février 2023”, fixed the 2023 rent at 1,711.16 euros before charges with the words “Fixe le nouveau loyer pour l’année 2023 à la somme, hors charges, de 1.711,16 euros”, and added 4,000 euros under the costs provision of Article 700 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Read the full ruling as Paris Court of Appeal, May 25, 2023, case 17/04761, which also quotes the 2015 version of the statute applicable to that lease. The lesson for an American owner is concrete: write the amount and each justifying feature into the lease, photograph them, keep the move-in inspection consistent with your claims, and compare against same-category units in the same sector in writing. Charm is not a legal category, wear destroys value arguments, and handwritten extras the tenant never approved look like improvisation to a judge.

II. My tenant is challenging the rent: which deadlines decide the case and what will it cost me on each side of the Atlantic?

Once the dispute starts, French law sorts tenant claims into separate actions, each with its own clock, and mixing them up is the most common way owners lose winnable cases. A detailed 2026 Paris judgment lays out the map: first, when the basic rent in the contract exceeds the enhanced reference rent set by prefectoral order, the tenant can seek a rent reduction and, together with it, restitution of the overcharge; second, when the contract omits the reference figures, a special fast procedure applies with a one-month formal notice and then a three-month window to go to the judge; third, when the owner charges a supplement above the enhanced reference rent, contesting that supplement follows its own regime of three months from signing with a mandatory prior hearing before the conciliation board. For the first action, the ordinary one most American landlords face, the court held that the claim derives from the lease and is subject only to the three-year limitations period of Article 7-1 of the 1989 Act: “Cette action, qui dérive du bail, est soumise à la seule prescription triennale de l’article 7-1 de la loi de 1989.” That means a tenant can come back years later and reclaim up to three years of monthly overcharges, which is how small monthly gaps become five-figure judgments (Paris Judicial Court, April 23, 2026, case 25/06419).

A. What are the exact deadlines for each challenge, and what happens if someone misses them?

Take the supplement challenge first, because its clock is the shortest and it runs from signature day: “Le locataire qui souhaite contester le complément de loyer dispose d’un délai de trois mois à compter de la signature du bail pour saisir la commission départementale de conciliation prévue à l’article 20 de la loi n° 89-462 du 6 juillet 1989 précitée, sauf lorsqu’il s’agit d’un bail mobilité soumis au titre Ier ter de la même loi.” The board stage is mandatory, and a judge can raise on their own motion the defense that the board was never approached: “La fin de non-recevoir tirée de l’absence de saisine préalable de la commission départementale de conciliation peut être soulevée d’office par le juge.” If conciliation fails, the tenant then has three months from receiving the board’s opinion to ask the judge to cancel or reduce the supplement: “En l’absence de conciliation, le locataire dispose d’un délai de trois mois à compter de la réception de l’avis de la commission départementale de conciliation pour saisir le juge d’une demande en annulation ou en diminution du complément de loyer.” Critically, the burden of proof sits on you: once contested, “il appartient au bailleur de démontrer que le logement présente des caractéristiques de localisation ou de confort le justifiant, par comparaison avec les logements de la même catégorie situés dans le même secteur géographique.” And the outcome applies retroactively: “Dans les deux cas, le loyer résultant du document de conciliation ou de la décision de justice s’applique à compter de la prise d’effet du bail.” Second, the missing-figures action: the tenant sends the registered formal notice within one month after the lease takes effect, you have one month to answer, and silence or refusal opens a three-month window to the judge for a rent cut. Third, the plain over-ceiling action: no conciliation is required first, and the three-year prescription governs, so calendar three years back from the court summons, called the assignation, to estimate exposure. At renewal time the mirror actions open: a reduction action when the rent exceeds the enhanced reference rent, and a revaluation action when it sits below the reduced reference rent, except that revaluation is closed for poorly rated units: “Toutefois, cette action ne peut pas être engagée pour les logements de la classe F ou de la classe G, au sens de l’article L. 173-1-1 du code de la construction et de l’habitation.” The initiative follows strict notice periods: “l’une ou l’autre des parties peut proposer un nouveau loyer à son cocontractant, au moins six mois avant le terme du contrat pour le bailleur et au moins cinq mois avant le terme du contrat pour le locataire, dans les conditions de forme prévues à l’article 15 de la loi n° 89-462 du 6 juillet 1989 précitée.” Miss the six-month notice and your revaluation fails on procedure alone. Separately, the prefect runs an administrative track in parallel with the courts: when a lease breaches the ceiling rules, “il peut mettre en demeure le bailleur, dans un délai de deux mois, d’une part, de mettre le contrat en conformité avec le présent article et, d’autre part, de procéder à la restitution des loyers trop-perçus.” If that formal demand goes nowhere, “le représentant de l’Etat dans le département peut prononcer une amende à l’encontre du bailleur, dont le montant ne peut excéder 5 000 € pour une personne physique et 15 000 € pour une personne morale.” That fine is administrative, on top of any court-ordered refund, and it lands harder on owners who hold through a property company, called a société civile immobilière or SCI, since the company rate is triple. The fine does not block the tenant: “Le prononcé de l’amende ne fait pas obstacle à ce que le locataire engage une action en diminution de loyer.” All quotations in this section come from Article 140 of the ELAN Act, current version, except the three-year prescription passage credited to its judgment link. An April 2026 Paris ruling illustrates the ordinary over-ceiling case from filing to judgment. The tenant of an unfurnished lease signed June 24, 2020, effective July 20, 2020, sued in May 2025 for reduction and refund with no supplement involved. The judge declared the reduction and refund claim admissible, ordered the owner to pay “la somme de 6 184,20 euros au titre du trop-perçu de loyer, avec intérêts à taux légal à compter du compter de l’assignation du 27 mai 2025”, a refund of 6,184.20 euros with statutory interest running from the May 27, 2025 summons, set off small balances the tenant still owed on rent and charge provisions, rejected the owner’s late charge true-up for 2022 and 2023, added 800 euros under Article 700 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and charged the owner with all court costs while recalling that the decision is immediately enforceable, a feature called exécution provisoire (Paris Judicial Court, April 23, 2026, case 25/06419). Note what the judge did not need: no conciliation, no supplement analysis, just a lease whose basic rent sat above the applicable enhanced reference rent. If your lease has that shape, settlement before judgment usually costs less than the judgment plus interest plus costs plus the fine risk.

B. How much money is really at stake, and how does a French rent cut flow through to my American taxes?

Start with the French math, because it compounds. The refund runs from the lease start date, not from the complaint date: in the Paris appeal case the tenants recovered every euro above the lawful rent from December 2015 to February 2023, a total of 28,111.18 euros, and the judge reset the going rent to 1,711.16 euros. Add statutory interest from the summons, the deposit reduction to one month of the corrected rent, the irrecoverable costs under Article 700, which were 4,000 euros on appeal and 800 euros at trial in these two cases, the full court costs, called the dépens, and the possible prefectoral fine of 5,000 or 15,000 euros after a city report. Against that, an owner holding costs steady can still owe charge-provision balances, and a revaluation action at renewal can lift an underpriced rent toward the reduced reference figure, but only with the six-month notice done right and never for an F- or G-rated unit. During the lease itself, remember the two neighboring guardrails in the current 1989 Act: a new letting of an F- or G-rated unit cannot exceed the previous tenant’s rent, since “le loyer du nouveau contrat de location ne peut excéder le dernier loyer appliqué au précédent locataire” (Article 17, current version), and annual indexation plus work-related increases are barred for those ratings, since “La révision et la majoration de loyer prévues aux I et II du présent article ne peuvent pas être appliquées dans les logements de la classe F ou de la classe G” (Article 17-1, current version). For the Paris and Île-de-France specifics that decide real files, use the three local tools in this order: the official Paris reference-rent simulator to pin the ceiling for your sector and category on your signature date; the Paris housing advice agency ADIL 75 and practical guides such as PAP on the 2026 rent cap, which restate the 20 percent ceiling logic and the narrow supplement exception; and the City of Paris report page if you are the tenant, or your response file with lease, inspection, photos, and comparables if you are the owner answering one. Cases go before the Paris protection-litigation judge, so expect a judge who sees these files weekly and little patience for missing mention formalities. For the broader landlord picture, including taxation of the rents themselves, see our guide to renting unfurnished as an American at American unfurnished rental: income tax, treaty credit, and filing, which this article completes on the rent-level side. Then comes the American side, which many owners discover last. The France-United States income tax treaty gives France the first right to tax rental income from French real estate, while the United States taxes its citizens on worldwide income and relieves double taxation through the foreign tax credit. A court-ordered rent cut therefore moves three American figures at once: gross rental receipts fall from the judgment date forward, which lowers the Schedule E income you report; the French income tax paid on those rents falls in later years, which shrinks the credit you can claim against the American tax on the same rents; and a lump refund of past overcharges paid out to the tenant is not a foreign tax and generates no credit at all, even though it feels like a cost of the French property. Keep the French judgment, the bailiff’s computation, called the décompte, and the revised rent receipts, called quittances de loyer, because your American preparer needs dated proof of what rent was lawful, what was refunded, and what the new rent is. Do not mix the prefectoral fine into the credit either: foreign penalties and fines are not creditable income taxes. Finally, remember the two information returns that shadow every American-owned French rental account: the annual foreign-account report and the foreign-asset statement, which continue regardless of the rent level, and keep the French assessment notices, called avis d’imposition, alongside the American file so both countries’ numbers reconcile to the same euro amounts.

Conclusion

Paris caps your starting rent at the enhanced reference rent for your sector and category, and the lease must show the basic rent, the reference rent, and the enhanced figure on signing day. The only door above the ceiling is a supplement that already sits exactly at the ceiling, is written into the lease with its amount and each justifying feature, passes the three cumulative tests of features uncounted in the reference, decisive by comparison with same-category units nearby, and yielding no double recovery through charges, and avoids every item on the post-2022 prohibition list. Once challenged, the clocks take over: three months from signing to the conciliation board for a supplement, three more months from the board’s opinion to the judge, one month plus three months for missing mentions, three years back for a plain over-ceiling refund, and six months’ notice before lease end for any owner-led revaluation. The Paris courts enforce this system with refunds running from day one, reset rents, deposits, interest, costs, and a prefectoral fine behind it, while the American return absorbs lower rents, a smaller foreign tax credit, and no credit for refunds or fines. Check your ceiling on the official simulator today, fix your lease mentions, document any supplement like an exhibit, and answer the first tenant letter as if a judge will read it, because one will.

📄 Official circular