KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
I Rent Out My French House Unfurnished as an American: Revenus Fonciers, the 20% Nonresident Rate, Social Charges, and Why This Is Not LMNP

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

I Rent Out My French House Unfurnished as an American: Revenus Fonciers, the 20% Nonresident Rate, Social Charges, and Why This Is Not LMNP

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

The tenant signed a three-year empty lease. The notaire (the French civil-law lawyer who authenticates property deeds) called the sale a location nue — an unfurnished letting. Your US accountant asked whether this is LMNP, the French furnished-rental regime. It is not. An unfurnished French house or apartment that you rent as an American is taxed in France as revenus fonciers (property income), not as commercial profits. France taxes that rent because the building stands in France. The United States taxes it because you are a US person. The order of operations is French classification, French rates, then the credit in the US-France income-tax convention, not a California spreadsheet that treats a Paris flat like a beach condo in Florida.

This article is for the American who already owns, or is about to own, a French dwelling rented empty: a long-term bail d’habitation (residential lease) under which the tenant brings the bed and the pots. It is not the furnished, tourist, or Airbnb file, which we have already treated separately as LMNP. It is not the annual taxe foncière (property-tax) bill. It is the income-tax file: how France decides the lease is unfurnished, how a US nonresident is charged 20 percent then 30 percent plus social charges, when the 30 percent micro-foncier allowance is available, how a déficit foncier (property-income loss) works, and what Paris and Île-de-France offices actually collect. Visa questions belong elsewhere. The tax questions start with the code général des impôts (CGI, the French tax code) and with a furniture test that the Cour de cassation still treats as a fact inquiry, not a label on page one of the lease.

I. How France taxes an unfurnished French rental when the landlord is American

A. Is my French rental unfurnished revenus fonciers or furnished LMNP?

The first French question is not your passport. It is the category of income. Article 14 of the CGI puts the rent of built property into revenus fonciers when that rent is not already swallowed by a commercial, agricultural, or professional profit: “Sous réserve des dispositions de l’article 15 , sont compris dans la catégorie des revenus fonciers, lorsqu’ils ne sont pas inclus dans les bénéfices d’une entreprise industrielle, commerciale ou artisanale, d’une exploitation agricole ou d’une profession non commerciale : 1° Les revenus des propriétés bâties, telles que maisons et usines, ainsi que les revenus :” In plain English: the rent of a house or apartment in France is property income, unless another regime has already captured it.

The commercial trap is furnished letting. Article 35, I, 5° bis of the CGI treats as industrial and commercial profits the income of “5° bis Personnes qui donnent en location directe ou indirecte des locaux d’habitation meublés ;” Direct or indirect furnished residential letting is BIC, the French commercial-profit category, which is the legal home of LMNP (loueur en meublé non professionnel, a non-professional furnished landlord). That is a different return, a different social-charge rate, and a different US reporting story. We mapped that file in the furnished-rental article. An empty dwelling does not go there.

What empty means is not the word printed on the lease. The Cour de cassation, France’s highest civil court, has refused to let a landlord or a tenant hide behind a heading. In Cass. 3e civ., 27 April 2017, no. 16-12.357 (ECLI:FR:CCASS:2017:C300455), the Third Civil Chamber quashed a Nîmes appeal that had treated a dwelling as furnished because the receipts and one copy of the lease said so. The Court cited article 2 of the law of 6 July 1989, the statute that frames French residential leases, and held: “sans rechercher si le logement donné en location était garni de meubles en qualité et quantité suffisantes pour permettre au locataire de vivre convenablement, la cour d’appel a privé sa décision de base légale ;” The court of appeal had to ask whether the dwelling was actually stocked with furniture of a quality and quantity that let the tenant live there decently. A label is not a finding.

The administrative furniture list sits in decree no. 2015-981 of 31 July 2015, still in force on 17 September 2026. The decree, read with article 25-4 of the 1989 law, requires at least: “Le mobilier d’un logement meublé, mentionné à l’ article 25-4 de la loi du 6 juillet 1989 susvisée , comporte au minimum les éléments suivants : 1° Literie comprenant couette ou couverture ; 2° Dispositif d’occultation des fenêtres dans les pièces destinées à être utilisées comme chambre à coucher ; 3° Plaques de cuisson ; 4° Four ou four à micro-ondes ; 5° Réfrigérateur et congélateur ou, au minimum, un réfrigérateur doté d’un compartiment permettant de disposer d’une température inférieure ou égale à – 6 °C ; 6° Vaisselle nécessaire à la prise des repas ; 7° Ustensiles de cuisine ; 8° Table et sièges ; 9° Etagères de rangement ; 10° Luminaires ; 11° Matériel d’entretien ménager adapté aux caractéristiques du logement.” Bedding with a duvet or blanket, window coverings in bedrooms, cooktop, oven or microwave, fridge meeting the minus-six test, dishes, kitchen tools, table and seats, shelves, lights, and cleaning equipment sized to the dwelling. If that kit is missing, the letting is not furnished for the 1989-law definition that the tax administration itself cites when it distinguishes location nue from location meublée.

The Paris Court of Appeal has used that same list as a checklist, not as decoration. In CA Paris, pôle 4, chambre 4, 28 November 2023, no. 21/01746, the court quoted decree 2015-981 item by item after recalling the 1989-law test that furniture must let the tenant sleep, eat, and live there in ordinary conditions. A sofa and a box of IKEA cutlery do not convert a three-year empty lease into LMNP. Conversely, leaving a full kitchen and a made-up bed in a so-called bare letting can push the file into article 35. The tax category follows the facts in the apartment, not the marketing brochure.

Two more boundaries keep Americans out of accidental categories. First, if you live in the place yourself, there is no rental income to declare as revenus fonciers. Article 15, II of the CGI says: “Les revenus des logements dont le propriétaire se réserve la jouissance ne sont pas soumis à l’impôt sur le revenu.” The owner who keeps the enjoyment of the dwelling is not taxed on a fictional rent. That is the second-home file, which is about annual property taxes, not about Schedule E. Second, article 12 of the CGI taxes the income the taxpayer “réalise ou dont il dispose au cours de la même année.” Cash-basis receipts matter. A lease signed in December with the first rent paid in January is next year’s income, not a 2025 phantom.

Gross receipts are defined tightly. Article 29 of the CGI states that, subject to two narrow articles, “le revenu brut des immeubles ou parties d’immeubles donnés en location, est constitué par le montant des recettes brutes perçues par le propriétaire, augmenté du montant des dépenses incombant normalement à ce dernier et mises par les conventions à la charge des locataires.” Rents actually collected, plus owner charges that the lease shifted onto the tenant, plus subsidies and indemnities that finance deductible expenses. Tenant charges that truly belong to the tenant are left out. Americans who net the rent in an email to the agence (rental agency) and then declare only the wire that arrived in New York are not applying article 29. The French return starts from what was received and what the owner should have borne.

Net income is a subtraction, not a feeling. Article 28 of the CGI is one sentence: “Le revenu net foncier est égal à la différence entre le montant du revenu brut et le total des charges de la propriété.”

Those charges live in article 31 of the CGI, in force with a deferred repeal that does not take effect before 1 January 2027. For urban property they include repair and maintenance actually borne by the owner, insurance premiums, unpaid tenant charges still on the owner’s back at year-end after the tenant left, copropriété provisions under the 1965 condominium statute, improvement works on dwellings that are not construction or enlargement, local taxes that fall on the owner rather than the occupier, and “Les intérêts de dettes contractées pour la conservation, l’acquisition, la construction, la réparation ou l’amélioration des propriétés,” Mortgage interest on a loan used to buy, keep, build, repair, or improve the property is a statutory deduction under the real regime. It is not a US Schedule E habit that France happens to tolerate.

Proof is the whole game. The Paris Administrative Court of Appeal, in CAA Paris, 7th chamber, 6 November 2025, no. 24PA01311, quoted article 31 and restated the classic filter: “De façon générale, les dépenses mentionnées au I de l’article 31 du code général des impôts ne peuvent être déduites du revenu foncier brut que dans la mesure où, notamment, les charges alléguées sont dûment justifiées, se rapportent à des immeubles dont les revenus sont imposables dans la catégorie des revenus fonciers, sont effectivement supportées par le propriétaire et sont engagées en vue de l’acquisition ou de” The landlord in that case had to show that loan interest was actually paid for buildings that produced property income. When he did, the court cut his 2013, 2014, and 2015 income-tax bases by €6,988.52, €19,218.43, and €19,218.71 and discharged the matching extra assessments. A PDF of a US mortgage statement with no French property on it will not do that work. A French loan tied to the Paris apartment, with bank proofs of the interest paid in the year, will.

The Bordeaux court has applied the same article 31 filter to legal fees spent to protect the rent. In CAA Bordeaux, 7th chamber, 11 February 2021, no. 18BX04353, the court quoted the management-fee limb of article 31 and allowed lawyers’ invoices incurred to defend the landlord against neighboring owners over disturbances affecting a rented apartment, because the court then held: “Ces sommes sont donc effectivement déductibles de leurs revenus fonciers.” Procedure costs that keep the rent alive can be property charges. Procedure costs that settle a family fight over the will are not. Category follows purpose.

B. How much French income tax and social charges do I actually pay as a US nonresident?

Once the rent is property income, France still has to decide whether you are a French tax resident. Article 4 B of the CGI, in the version in force since 16 February 2025, treats as fiscally domiciled in France, for article 4 A, “a. Les personnes qui ont en France leur foyer ou le lieu de leur séjour principal ;” plus those whose principal professional activity is in France, plus those whose center of economic interests is in France, unless a tax treaty assigns residence to the other State. The American who has actually moved the household to Paris is not the reader of this section; that file is the tax-residence article. This section is for the US person who remains a nonresident under article 4 B and under the treaty tie-breaker, and who still owns a rented French dwelling.

French-source income of a nonresident includes the rent. Article 164 B, I, a of the CGI is blunt: “Sont considérés comme revenus de source française : a. Les revenus d’immeubles sis en France ou de droits relatifs à ces immeubles ;” Income from immovables located in France, or from rights in those immovables. An American passport does not make a 7th-arrondissement lease foreign. Undivided ownership, usufruct, and shares in some real-estate companies are pulled in by the same letter a and by the later limbs of 164 B. The treaty does not pull the other way. Article 6 of the convention of 31 August 1994, in the IRS official text, provides that income from real property situated in a Contracting State may be taxed in that State, and article 6(3) extends that rule to income from the direct use, letting, or use in any other form of real property. France may tax the letting. May in a treaty is a grant of taxing rights to the situs State, not a courtesy.

The rate for a nonresident is not the ordinary household scale. It is a floor. Article 197 A of the CGI, in force since 1 January 2018, applies the computational rules of article 197, I, 1 and 2, to persons who do not have their tax domicile in France and who receive French-source income, with this minimum: “l’impôt ne peut, en ce cas, être inférieur à un montant calculé en appliquant un taux de 20 % à la fraction du revenu net imposable inférieure ou égale à la limite supérieure de la deuxième tranche du barème de l’impôt sur le revenu et un taux de 30 % à la fraction supérieure à cette limite ;” Twenty percent up to the top of the second bracket of the scale; thirty percent above that line. The same article lets the taxpayer prove that the French tax on worldwide income would produce a lower average rate; that lower rate then applies to the French-source slice only. The US-France convention is a convention of administrative assistance, so the honor declaration that article 197 A offers to residents of assisting States is, on the face of the statute, available while the supporting papers are gathered. The floor is the rule. The average-rate claim is the exception, and it requires a worldwide income picture, not a rent figure in isolation.

The second-bracket ceiling is not a mystery number from a blog. Article 197, I, 1 of the CGI, in the version in force from 21 February 2026, computes tax on each share of income above €11,600 at “11 % pour la fraction supérieure à 11 600 € et inférieure ou égale à 29 579 € ; – 30 % pour la fraction supérieure à 29 579 € et inférieure ou égale à 84 577 € ;” The upper limit of the second bracket is therefore €29,579. A US nonresident’s net property income is tested at 20 percent up to that line and 30 percent above it, unless the average-rate proof in article 197 A succeeds. Overseas departments have reduced percentages in 197 A; metropolitan France does not. Americans who were told that France always takes 30 percent of the rent are describing the upper slice, not the statute.

Income tax is not the end of the bill. Social charges sit on top. Article L. 136-6 of the Social Security Code first charges the CSG (contribution sociale généralisée, a broad social contribution) on property income of persons fiscally domiciled in France. Then I bis reaches nonresidents: “I bis.-Sont également assujetties à la contribution les personnes physiques qui ne sont pas fiscalement domiciliées en France au sens de l’article 4 B du code général des impôts à raison du montant net des revenus, visés au a du I de l’article 164 B du même code, retenu pour l’établissement de l’impôt sur le revenu.” A US nonresident is in I bis for the net French immovable income that income tax has already measured. I ter then carves out people who, under EU Regulation 883/2004, are covered for sickness insurance by another legislation subject to that regulation and who are not charged to a French compulsory scheme. That carve-out is the EEA and Swiss story. It is not the US Medicare story. The Direction générale des finances publiques (DGFiP, the French tax authority) says the same thing in plain language on its nonresident pages, updated into 2026: CSG and CRDS relief since 1 January 2019 is for people affiliated to a compulsory scheme in the EEA or Switzerland (and, by administrative continuation, the United Kingdom). A landlord in Boston or Austin is not in that list.

The CSG rate on property income is not the new 10.6 percent headline that applies to some other capital income. Article L. 136-8, IV, 1° of the Social Security Code, in the version in force from 27 June 2026, states: “IV.-Par dérogation au I, sont assujettis à la contribution sociale au taux de 9,2 % : 1° Les revenus mentionnés au a du I de l’article L. 136-6 ;” Letter a of L. 136-6 I is revenus fonciers. Unfurnished rent keeps CSG at 9.2 percent.

On top of that, article 235 ter of the CGI creates a prélèvement de solidarité (solidarity levy) on the same L. 136-6 property-income base, “sans qu’il soit fait application du I ter du même article L. 136-6.” The same article then fixes the rate: “III.-Le taux des prélèvements de solidarité mentionnés au I est fixé à 7,5 %.” The solidarity levy does not borrow the EU-sickness exemption. DGFiP’s pages for nonresident landlords of empty dwellings still state a combined social-charge rate of 17.2 percent. Its pages for furnished lettings state 18.6 percent from 2025 receipts, which matches the higher CSG that L. 136-8 I now sets as the default for L. 136-6 income that is not pulled back to 9.2 percent by IV. Empty and furnished are not the same bill, even before income tax.

Put a round number on it, without pretending it is a quote. €20,000 of net unfurnished rent, US nonresident, no average-rate claim: income tax at 20 percent is €4,000 because €20,000 sits below €29,579. Social charges at the 17.2 percent the tax authority publishes on that same empty-letting page are €3,440. Combined French take, before any US credit, is €7,440. The same €20,000 of furnished LMNP profit is a different social-charge rate and a different income-tax machinery. Mixing the two in one US spreadsheet is how Americans overpay one country and under-document the other.

The treaty does not erase those French charges. It allocates the primary right to tax the rent to France and then, in Article 24(1)(a) of the same IRS text, requires the United States to allow a citizen or resident a credit for the French income tax paid by or on behalf of that citizen or resident, subject to US limitations. Article 24 is a credit for French income tax as the convention defines that tax. It is not a blank check for every French acronym on the notice. Whether a particular social charge is an income tax for US foreign-tax-credit purposes is a US characterization question that Article 6 does not answer. What the treaty does answer is that France may tax the letting and that the United States, for its income tax, then works through the credit rules rather than through an exemption of the Paris rent. US citizens remain taxable at home on worldwide income. The saving clause in the convention, which we have already walked through in the residence article, does not need to be reinvented here: it leaves the United States free to tax its citizens. The practical US forms are Schedule E for the rent and Form 1116 for the credit, built on the French net figure after the French category has been chosen correctly.

II. What I must file, deduct, and credit — and what happens in Paris

A. Micro-foncier or réel, déficit foncier, and the US treaty credit

France offers two computational regimes for empty lettings. The default for small files is micro-foncier. Article 32, 1 of the CGI, in the version in force from 21 February 2026, says: “Par dérogation aux dispositions de l’article 31, lorsque le montant du revenu brut annuel défini aux articles 29 et 30 n’excède pas 15 000 €, le revenu imposable correspondant est fixé à une somme égale au montant de ce revenu brut diminué d’un abattement de 30 %.” If annual gross property income of the tax household, as articles 29 and 30 define it, does not exceed €15,000, taxable income is gross minus a 30 percent allowance. You do not deduct the real repairs, the real interest, or the real insurance. The 30 percent is the statute’s stand-in for charges. Article 32, 2 makes the regime apply to all of the household’s property income, puts the gross on the article 170 return, and locks out listed special properties (historic monuments, certain bare-ownership structures, and other named vehicles). Nonresidents are not written out of article 32. The tax authority’s dedicated nonresident page, updated 1 April 2026, tells the nonresident landlord of an unfurnished dwelling that below €15,000 of 2025 gross, without a special regime, the landlord falls under micro-foncier, with no annex 2044, and with the gross entered on form 2042, box 4BE. The 30 percent is computed by the administration. You do not subtract it yourself.

You may elect the real regime even below €15,000. Article 32 of the CGI makes that election irrevocable for three years: “Irrévocable durant cette période, elle est valable tant que le contribuable reste de manière continue dans le champ d’application du 1.” The same three-year lock appears on the nonresident page: if you opt for the real regime the option binds you irrevocably for three years, even if later years are less advantageous. Americans who elect réel in a renovation year to deduct a new roof, and who then have a quiet year with no works, still live with réel. The election is a legal act, not a software toggle.

Above €15,000 of household gross, réel is mandatory. The real net is article 28: receipts minus article 31 charges. The result can be a profit or a loss. Losses have their own statute. Article 156, II, 3° of the CGI deals with “déficits fonciers, lesquels s’imputent exclusivement sur les revenus fonciers des dix années suivantes” then immediately carves out the ordinary case: “L’imputation exclusive sur les revenus fonciers n’est pas non plus applicable aux déficits fonciers résultant de dépenses autres que les intérêts d’emprunt. L’imputation est limitée à 10 700 €. La fraction du déficit supérieure à 10 700 € et la fraction du déficit non imputable résultant des intérêts d’emprunt sont déduites dans les conditions prévues au premier alinéa.” Property-income losses from expenses other than loan interest may offset other French income of the year, up to €10,700. Interest always stays inside the property-income basket and carries forward. The excess above €10,700 also stays in that basket, for up to ten years. The cap is raised to €15,300 for certain named article 31 deductions and can be raised as high as €21,400 for qualifying energy-renovation works that move the dwelling from energy class E, F, or G to A, B, C, or D, with a justification deadline of 31 December 2027 in the current text. Those raised caps are statutory conditions, not slogans. A US nonresident with little or no other French-source income gets less value from the €10,700 global offset than a French resident with a salary. The ten-year carryforward against later French rent remains useful. The American who takes the loss on Schedule E has not filed article 156.

The statute also claws the benefit back if the landlord stops letting. Article 156, II, 3° of the CGI continues: “Lorsque le propriétaire cesse de louer un immeuble ou lorsque le propriétaire de titres d’une société non soumise à l’impôt sur les sociétés les vend, le revenu foncier et le revenu global des trois années qui précèdent celle au cours de laquelle intervient cet événement sont, nonobstant toute disposition contraire, reconstitués selon les modalités prévues au premier alinéa du présent 3°.” Stop letting, or sell the shares of a pass-through company, and the income of the three preceding years is rebuilt as if the preferential offset had not applied, subject to death, listed disability, or layoff of the taxpayer or of a jointly taxed spouse. A one-year empty-and-renovate play that is followed by a sale to an American buyer is not a free €10,700. The three-year letting condition is in the tax code, not in a banker’s email.

Filing follows the regime. Micro: form 2042, box 4BE, gross only, as the 1 April 2026 nonresident page states. Réel: annex 2044 for ordinary buildings, 2044 spéciale for the listed historic and bare-ownership files, then the net profit on 2042 line 4BA or the deficit on 4BB or 4BC. If you elect the average-rate computation of article 197 A, that same page requires a declaration of worldwide income so that the rate can be computed; that rate is then applied only to French-source income. Worldwide figures set the rate; only French-source income is taxed at that rate. French and foreign property receipts are added to test the €15,000 micro ceiling if you go down that road. Crossing €15,000 of combined gross kills micro for the year.

The US side starts after the French net exists. Article 6 of the convention lets France tax the letting. Article 24(1)(a) then tells the United States to allow a credit for French income tax paid, in accordance with the provisions and subject to the limitations of US law as it may be amended without changing the general principle. Those US limitations are the Internal Revenue Code’s foreign-tax-credit baskets, the timing of the French tax, and the documentation of what was actually paid. A French 2042 is not a Form 1116. A US return that reports gross Paris rent and ignores the 30 percent micro allowance, or that reports a réel net without the French 2044, will not match the French assessment that the credit is supposed to cover. Double tax is what you get when the two returns tell different stories about the same keys. The convention’s job is to order those stories, not to invent a third category called expat rental.

Two US reporting overlays sit next to the income-tax credit and should not be conflated with it. If the rents flow through a French bank account, that account is a foreign financial account for FBAR and, depending on thresholds, Form 8938. That is a reporting file, not a revenus fonciers computation. If the dwelling is held through an SCI, the 3 percent tax, forced heirship, and PFIC questions are the SCI article, not this one. An unfurnished letting by an individual owner is article 14 plus article 164 B plus article 197 A. Keep the wrappers in their own files.

Mortgage interest deserves a last practical note because Americans import the US habit of deducting it everywhere. Under réel, article 31, I, 1°, d allows interest on debts contracted for conservation, acquisition, construction, repair, or improvement. Under micro, interest is inside the 30 percent and is not deducted again. On the US return, qualified-residence interest and investment-interest limitations are US law; they do not rewrite article 31. A dollar of French interest that was never deducted in France because you were in micro is still French gross that the 30 percent already pretends to cover. Deducting it again in New York without adjusting the French figure is how the credit and the deduction step on each other. The Paris court in 24PA01311 allowed interest only where payment for the buildings in dispute was proved. That is the standard to copy: French loan, French property, French year, French proof.

B. Paris and Île-de-France filing, rent rules, and the papers the tax office will ask for

Geography does not change article 14. It changes who holds the file and which local overlay sits on the lease. A US nonresident landlord of a Paris apartment still has French-source property income under article 164 B. The return is the 2042, with or without the 2044, as the nonresident pages of impots.gouv.fr describe. If the American has actually installed a foyer in the 16th arrondissement, article 4 B may already have moved the person into French residence, in which case article 197 A no longer applies and the ordinary scale in article 197 does. That is a residence question, not a rental-category question. Do not let a Paris postcode decide it by folklore. The Paris Administrative Court of Appeal in 24PA01311 was reviewing extra assessments of a landlord who claimed article 31 interest on Île-de-France properties; the court reduced the bases when the proofs arrived and sent a copy of the decision to the regional public-finance directorate of Île-de-France and Paris. The local office will look at the same invoices. Keep them.

Paris leases add a civil-law layer that the tax category assumes but does not invent. An empty dwelling let as a primary home is the 1989-law bail d’habitation, with a three-year term for an individual landlord, a security deposit, an inventory, and a rent that local rent-reference rules may cap in the capital. Those civil rules decide whether you have a lawful unfurnished tenancy. They do not, by themselves, decide article 35. A Paris lease that is titled nue and is in fact full of furniture is still a furnished file for tax, as Cass. 16-12.357 requires a court to check the contents. A Paris lease that is truly empty remains revenus fonciers even if the rent is capped. The tax office reads the CGI. The commission départementale de conciliation and the tribunal judiciaire de Paris (the Paris judicial court) read the 1989 law. Bring both sets of papers to the consultation: the signed lease, the inventory, the furniture photos, and the 2044 working file.

Copropriété charges are the Paris-specific cost that article 31 actually names. Article 31, I, 1°, a quater of the CGI allows “Les provisions pour dépenses, comprises ou non dans le budget prévisionnel de la copropriété, prévues à l’article 14-1 de la loi n° 65-557 du 10 juillet 1965 fixant le statut de la copropriété des immeubles bâtis, supportées par le propriétaire, diminuées du montant des provisions déduites l’année précédente qui correspond à des charges non déductibles ;” The calls for funds from a Paris syndic (the building manager) are deductible under réel to the extent they are owner charges, after backing out last year’s provisions that funded non-deductible items. Americans who throw the entire quarterly call into repairs on a US spreadsheet will overstate the French deduction. The allocation line on the décompte (the building statement) is the document. Heating that is an occupier’s charge is not an owner’s article 31 cost. A special assessment for a new elevator may be. The syndic’s annual approved accounts, not a WhatsApp summary from a neighbor, are what CAA Paris will expect if the deduction is challenged.

Works in a Haussmann building follow the same article 31 split that the rest of France uses, with Paris prices. Repair and maintenance actually paid by the owner are deductible under réel. Improvement of a dwelling is deductible; construction, reconstruction, and enlargement are not. The Paris reflex of calling every invoice renovation is not a tax category. Keep the contractor’s description, the before-and-after, and the payment. Energy-class works that hope to use the raised €21,400 deficit cap in article 156 must actually move the dwelling from E, F, or G to A, B, C, or D, with the justification the statute dates to 31 December 2027. A decorative kitchen in the 6th arrondissement that leaves the dwelling in class F is not that regime.

Collection is practical. Service-Public’s page on unfurnished rental income, checked 15 April 2026, describes withholding at source by a bank-account installment for property income and for social charges at 17.2 percent. A US nonresident who has no French account still has a French tax. The installment mechanics may require a French account or a mandate; the liability does not wait for one. If a French bank has already refused the American on FATCA grounds, that is a separate banking file. The income-tax filing does not disappear because SEPA failed. Late filing and late payment have their own CGI penalties; they are not the subject of this article, but they are why the 2042 should not be treated as optional correspondence.

The papers to assemble before anyone calls the office are boring and decisive. The deed or the attestation of ownership. The current unfurnished lease and every rider. The inventory on entry and exit. Photographs that show whether the 2015-981 list is present or absent. The rent ledger, in euros, by date of receipt, matching article 29. Insurance invoices. Syndic calls and the year-end allocation. Loan contracts and interest certificates that identify the French property, the fact pattern of 24PA01311. Invoices for works, split between repair and improvement. The prior 2042 and 2044, if any. The US return pages that already reported the rent, so that the treaty credit can be tied to a single net number. For a Paris apartment, add the rent-reference printout used when the lease was signed and the copropriété by-laws if short-term use is restricted. None of that is a visa file. All of it is how article 28 is proved.

If the prefecture, the tax office, or a buyer later argues that the letting was furnished, the answer is the Cassation test plus the decree list, not an adjective in the listing. If the office disallows interest, the answer is article 31, I, 1°, d plus payment proof, which is what CAA Paris required in 24PA01311. If the office refuses micro, the answer is the €15,000 ceiling in article 32 and the household-wide rule in article 32, 2. If the office applies 30 percent to the entire net, the answer is article 197 A and the €29,579 second-bracket ceiling in article 197, I, 1. If a US preparer has already filed the rent as LMNP or as Schedule C, the French category is still article 14 until article 35 is actually met. Correct the category first. The credit in Article 24 of the convention cannot repair a mismatch that starts in the wrong French box.

Conclusion

An unfurnished French rental owned by an American is French-source property income. Article 14 puts the rent of a built property into revenus fonciers unless a commercial regime has captured it. Article 35, I, 5° bis captures furnished residential letting, which is the LMNP file, not this one. Furnished status is a furniture fact: Cass. 3e civ. 16-12.357 requires a court to look at quantity and quality, and decree 2015-981 lists the minimum kit. Article 164 B, I, a makes the rent French-source. Article 6 of the US-France convention lets France tax the letting. Article 197 A then floors a nonresident’s income tax at 20 percent up to the top of the second bracket — €29,579 in the current article 197 — and 30 percent above, unless a lower average rate on worldwide income is proved. L. 136-6 I bis puts CSG on that same net for a US nonresident; L. 136-6 I ter does not open an EEA door to Medicare; L. 136-8 IV keeps CSG on property income at 9.2 percent; article 235 ter adds a 7.5 percent solidarity levy that ignores I ter. DGFiP still publishes 17.2 percent as the combined social-charge rate on empty lettings, and 18.6 percent on furnished receipts from 2025, which is why the LMNP contrast is not cosmetic.

Computation is article 32 or article 31. Below €15,000 of household gross, micro-foncier gives a 30 percent allowance and no 2044. The real regime is available, irrevocable for three years, and mandatory above the ceiling. Losses follow article 156, II, 3°: €10,700 of non-interest deficit against other French income, interest trapped in the property basket, a ten-year carryforward, and a three-year letting clawback. Article 24 of the convention then gives a US credit for French income tax paid, subject to US limitations. Paris and Île-de-France change the syndic, the court, and the proofs, not the code. The American who rents the Paris flat empty and reports it as LMNP, or who skips the 2042 because a US return already exists, is not applying the treaty. The treaty assumes that France has taxed the letting under its own categories first.

📄 Official circular