KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Diverted to Dublin, Bags Missing in Paris: Lost and Delayed Luggage Rights After a Medical Diversion

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Diverted to Dublin, Bags Missing in Paris: Lost and Delayed Luggage Rights After a Medical Diversion

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 19 October 2026, a scheduled Houston to Paris service declared a general emergency south of Ireland and diverted to Dublin after a passenger fell seriously ill on board. According to the aviation press account published the same day, the Boeing 777 touched down safely in Dublin, the sick passenger was taken into medical care, and the aircraft later resumed its journey to Paris Charles de Gaulle, landing at about 11:30 local time instead of the scheduled 8:15. Tracking-data analysis of the same flight confirms the emergency squawk over the Irish coast and the Dublin landing at about 05:30 UTC, while noting that the cause could not be read from tracking data alone.

Most passengers on a diverted flight think first about the delay. A separate analysis published the same day on this site explains the flat-rate delay compensation track for that exact diversion, and it is linked below. This article answers a different question, the one that starts at the baggage carousel in Paris: your flight eventually arrived, but your checked bags did not follow, arrived late, or arrived damaged. Which court rules apply, which deadlines decide everything, and how do you claim from France.

The short answer is that baggage claims on an international flight to France live under a single treaty, the Montreal Convention of 28 May 1999, applied in France through the Transport Code. European flat-rate delay compensation does not replace a baggage claim, and French courts have just confirmed, on 23 September 2026, how a fellow passenger falling ill affects the delay track. For bags, three clocks matter: seven days for damage, twenty-one days for delay, and two years to sue, and missing any of them can end the case before it starts.

I. Which law decides the fate of your checked bags on a Paris-bound flight

A. The Montreal Convention governs delayed, lost and damaged baggage on your Paris flight

Any international carriage of passengers and baggage by an airline holding a European operating licence is subject, in France, to the provisions of the Montreal Convention. Article L6421-3 of the French Transport Code states it directly: «La responsabilité du transporteur aérien titulaire d’une licence d’exploitation délivrée en application du règlement (CE) n° 1008/2008 du 24 septembre 2008 établissant des règles communes pour l’exploitation de services aériens dans la Communauté est soumise, en ce qui concerne le transport aérien de passagers et de leurs bagages, aux dispositions du règlement (CE) n° 889/2002 du 13 mai 2002 modifiant le règlement (CE) n° 2027/97 relatif à la responsabilité des transporteurs aériens en cas d’accident et aux stipulations de la convention pour l’unification de certaines règles relatives au transport aérien international signée à Montréal le 28 mai 1999.» For carriers outside that licence regime, article L6421-4 of the same Code provides that liability is governed by the Montreal Convention under the conditions defined in the Code. The full text of that article is published on Legifrance.

The Convention itself sets three pillars for baggage. First, strict liability while the bags are in the carrier’s custody: the carrier answers for destruction, loss or damage to checked baggage on a no-fault basis whenever the triggering event occurred on board the aircraft or during any period in which the carrier had custody of the registered bags, with only the nature or inherent defect of the baggage itself as a partial defence, and with fault required only for unchecked effects. Second, delay of baggage sits on the same footing as delay of passengers: the carrier answers for damage resulting from delay unless it proves that it, its servants and agents took all measures reasonably required to avoid the harm, or that taking them was impossible. A diversion for a genuine medical emergency, with the aircraft turned to the nearest suitable airport and the onward journey resumed as soon as the authorities release it, is precisely the kind of situation in which a carrier will argue that every reasonable measure was taken. That defence goes to delay damages under the Convention, and it is separate from the European flat-rate scheme examined below.

Third, the amounts are capped per passenger in Special Drawing Rights: 4,150 for delay damage under article 19, and 1,000 for baggage destruction, loss, damage or delay under article 22, paragraph 2, unless the passenger made a special declaration of interest at check-in against a possible surcharge. The special declaration of interest when handing over checked baggage is therefore the only way to raise the ceiling before the loss happens. After the loss, the ceiling applies.

Fourth, the Convention shuts the door on parallel routes to higher damages: any action for damages, however framed, in contract, in tort or on any other ground, lies only within the conditions and limits set by the Convention, which also excludes punitive or exemplary damages. A baggage claim pleaded in tort, in contract, or under national consumer law remains bound by the Convention’s conditions and limits. That exclusivity is why the deadlines in Part II of this article are decisive rather than indicative.

One practical consequence follows for codeshare and package flights: an action for carriage performed by the actual carrier may be brought, at the claimant’s choice, against the actual carrier or the contracting carrier, or against both. The First Civil Chamber of the French Court of Cassation confirmed exactly that on 26 January 2012 (no. 10-30.800, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2012:C100070, appeal dismissed), upholding recovery against the airline up to the amounts due for both the passenger delay and the baggage loss occurring while the carrier had custody. The full decision is published here: Cour de cassation, 26 January 2012, no. 10-30.800. If your ticket to Paris was sold by one company and operated by another, you choose your defendant.

B. European flat-rate delay compensation does not replace your baggage claim

Regulation (EC) No 261/2004 of 11 February 2004 applies to the Dublin diversion itself, because the flight departed from a third country to an airport in a Member State on a Community carrier: the Regulation covers passengers departing from a third-country airport to a Member State airport on a Community carrier, absent benefits or assistance received in that third country. But the Regulation’s flat-rate machinery compensates denied boarding, cancellation and long delay. It contains no baggage-damage schedule. Baggage stays under the Convention, and the Court of Cassation has repeatedly policed the boundary between the two tracks.

Start with the delay track, because it determines what the diversion itself is worth. Under article 5, paragraph 3 of the Regulation, the carrier owes no flat-rate compensation where it proves extraordinary circumstances unavoidable despite all reasonable measures, and the case law extends the test to long delay. On 23 September 2026, the First Civil Chamber ruled, in a case where a passenger’s malaise had forced a disembarkation and a missed connection of more than five hours, that such a malaise, being neither inherent to the normal exercise of the airline’s activity nor within its effective control, may qualify as an extraordinary circumstance for the carrier, and it dismissed the passenger’s appeal (Civ. 1, 23 September 2026, no. 25-14.563, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2026:C100548). The decision is published here: Cour de cassation, 23 September 2026, no. 25-14.563. A mid-flight medical emergency leading to a Dublin diversion sits squarely in that line: external to the airline, outside its effective control, and capable of qualifying as extraordinary, provided the carrier also shows it took all suitable measures, including re-routing passengers at the earliest opportunity.

Contrast that with illness on the crew side. On 5 February 2020, the same Chamber held, for a Paris to Delhi service cancelled because the pilot fell suddenly ill and had to be hospitalised, that such illness or sudden medical unavailability is not an unusual event and cannot qualify as an extraordinary circumstance, and it dismissed the carrier’s appeal (Civ. 1, 5 February 2020, no. 19-12.294, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2020:C100113). The decision is published here: Cour de cassation, 5 February 2020, no. 19-12.294. Crew staffing, unlike a passenger collapsing mid-flight, belongs to the normal exercise of the airline’s activity. The two rulings together draw the line that matters for the Dublin diversion: a passenger medical emergency can excuse flat-rate delay compensation, while crew sickness cannot.

Even where flat-rate compensation is excluded, the duty of care survives. The Court of Cassation held on 14 February 2018 (no. 16-20.354, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2018:C100177, partial cassation) that a delayed departure gives passengers the right to hotel accommodation at the carrier’s charge where an overnight wait becomes necessary, and it recalled, following the Court of Justice’s Sousa Rodriguez ruling of 13 October 2011 (C-83/10), that the Regulation’s standardised and immediate measures do not block an individualised action for proven loss under the Montreal Convention, within the Convention’s articles 19, 22 and 29. The decision is published here: Cour de cassation, 14 February 2018, no. 16-20.354. The Regulation itself lists, for long delay, meals and refreshments in reasonable relation to the waiting time, hotel accommodation where an overnight stay becomes necessary, transport between the airport and the accommodation, and two telephone calls, telex or fax messages, or e-mails. Those care duties apply while you wait in Dublin, whatever the cause of the diversion.

And the two tracks can cumulate. Article 12, paragraph 1 of the Regulation applies without prejudice to further compensation, with the flat-rate sum deductible from it. In plain terms: the Regulation’s standardised and immediate measures do not block an individualised action for proven loss under the Montreal Convention, within the Convention’s limits. Hotel bills, replacement essentials and documented expenses caused by late or missing bags belong to that second action. The companion analysis of flat-rate delay compensation after this same Dublin diversion, published alongside this article, covers the first track in detail: Air France AF99 Emergency Landing in Dublin: Diverted Paris Flight, Compensation, Care and How to Claim.

II. Getting your bags back and getting paid for them from France

A. The three clocks that decide everything: seven days, twenty-one days, two years

Baggage litigation is won or lost on protest deadlines that most travellers have never heard of. Under article 31 of the Montreal Convention, damage requires a written protest promptly after discovery and no later than seven days from receipt for checked baggage, while delay requires a written protest no later than twenty-one days from the day the bag was placed at the passenger’s disposal, with every protest made by written reservation handed over or dispatched within the period. Two different clocks run from two different starting points, and a verbal complaint at the carousel is not a written protest. File the property irregularity report at the Paris airport desk on arrival, keep a copy, then confirm in writing to the carrier within the period, describing the contents, the value and the expenses incurred.

The penalty for silence is extinction of the action: without protest within the applicable period, all actions against the carrier are inadmissible, save fraud by the carrier. A court seised of a late claim must declare it inadmissible.

The twenty-one-day figure appears a second time, with a different meaning. Under article 17, paragraph 3 of the Convention, a bag still missing twenty-one days after it should have arrived, or earlier if the carrier admits the loss, lets the passenger enforce the full rights flowing from the contract of carriage. Before day twenty-one, a missing bag is legally delayed, and the claim is for delay damage: essentials bought while waiting, with receipts. From day twenty-one without delivery, or earlier if the carrier admits the loss, the passenger may assert the full rights under the contract, meaning the value of the lost contents up to the 1,000 Special Drawing Rights ceiling, absent a special declaration of interest.

Then comes the outer wall: two years, and it is forfeiture, not ordinary prescription. Under article 35, paragraph 1 of the Convention, the liability action must be brought within two years of arrival, of the day the aircraft should have arrived, or of the stoppage of carriage, on pain of forfeiture. Do not confuse this with the five-year period that governs flat-rate claims under Regulation 261/2004. Article 2224 of the French Civil Code provides that «Les actions personnelles ou mobilières se prescrivent par cinq ans à compter du jour où le titulaire d’un droit a connu ou aurait dû connaître les faits lui permettant de l’exercer.», and the Court of Cassation applies that five-year period to compensation and information claims brought under the European Regulation itself: a claim for breach of the duty of information under article 14 of the Regulation is a Regulation-based claim subject to the five-year limitation, not complementary Montreal compensation for particular loss (Civ. 1, 10 October 2019, no. 18-20.490, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2019:C100812; same solution 14 March 2018, no. 17-15.378, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2018:C100281). The decisions are published here: Cour de cassation, 10 October 2019, no. 18-20.490 and Cour de cassation, 14 March 2018, no. 17-15.378. But an action for baggage loss, damage or delay under the Convention must be brought within two years of arrival, or of the day the aircraft should have arrived, on pain of forfeiture. Two claims from the same diverted flight can therefore die on two different dates: the European flat-rate claim after five years, the Montreal baggage claim after two.

In practice, the sequence from the Paris carousel is: file the written irregularity report before leaving the airport and photograph the report reference; buy only reasonably necessary replacements and keep every receipt, since delay damage under article 19 covers proven loss, not disappointment; send the written protest to the carrier within seven days for damage or twenty-one days for delay, counting from receipt or from delivery of the late bag; diary the two-year forfeiture date from the arrival day. Passengers who checked valuables without a special declaration of interest should assemble proof of value now, because the 1,000 Special Drawing Rights ceiling will cap the recovery.

B. Suing from Paris: forum, package operator, mediation and the national enforcement body

A traveller living in France, or landing in Paris, will usually want to sue at home. Under article 33, paragraph 1 of the Convention, the claimant chooses among the courts of the carrier’s domicile, its principal place of business, the establishment through which the contract was made, or the place of destination. Paris Charles de Gaulle as the place of destination founds jurisdiction in France by itself. In addition, the Court of Cassation held on 8 November 2011 (Commercial Chamber, no. 10-28.069, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2011:CO01091, cassation) that article 33 lets the claimant sue the carrier where it has the establishment through which the contract was concluded. The decision is published here: Cour de cassation, 8 November 2011, no. 10-28.069. A ticket bought through the carrier’s French establishment, agency or French-language sales channel can therefore anchor the case before the French courts even apart from the destination.

Travellers who flew to Paris on a package should direct the first claim at the organiser, not only at the airline. The Tourism Code makes the package seller automatically liable for performance of the contracted services, whether performed by itself or by other travel providers, saving its recourse against them. Article L211-16 of the Tourism Code provides: «est responsable de plein droit de l’exécution des services prévus par ce contrat, que ces services soient exécutés par lui-même ou par d’autres prestataires de services de voyage, sans préjudice de son droit de recours contre ceux-ci». Strict liability of the package seller covers the air leg performed by the carrier, and the organiser then turns against the airline. The Court of Cassation validated exactly that chain on 26 January 2012, where a tour operator that had compensated travellers for lost baggage and delay recovered over against the airline under the Convention. Package travellers therefore have two debtors in sequence: the organiser automatically, then the carrier through the organiser’s recourse or through the traveller’s direct action against either the contracting or the actual carrier.

Before suing, French consumer law expects an attempt at amicable resolution through mediation. Article L612-1 of the Consumer Code organises that route, providing that «le professionnel garantit au consommateur le recours effectif à un dispositif de médiation de la consommation», and airlines operating in France designate a consumer mediator whose details appear in their general conditions. A mediation filing does not suspend the two-year forfeiture by itself, so it should be started early, with the court deadline kept separately in view.

Alongside the courts, the European Regulation designates a national enforcement body in each Member State, and every passenger may complain to it about an alleged infringement at a Member State airport or on a flight from a third country to such an airport. For a Houston to Paris service, that complaint route covers the care, re-routing and information duties surrounding the Dublin stop. It does not replace the written protest and the court action for the bags themselves.

One final scenario deserves mention because diversions create it: re-routing to a different Paris airport. If the carrier offers Orly instead of Charles de Gaulle, or Beauvais instead of either, the Regulation requires the carrier to bear the cost of transferring the passenger from the alternative airport to the booked one or to another nearby destination agreed with the passenger. The Court of Cassation applied that logic strictly on 17 February 2021 (no. 19-21.362, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2021:C100163, cassation), placing on the carrier the burden of proving that a passenger ultimately landed at Roissy instead of Orly still reached Orly with less than three hours of delay. The decision is published here: Cour de cassation, 17 February 2021, no. 19-21.362. Keep the taxi, bus or rail receipts for that transfer as well: they are recoverable on top of the baggage claim.

Conclusion

A medical diversion like the Dublin stop of 19 October 2026 splits each passenger’s file in two. The delay itself travels on the European track, where a fellow passenger’s malaise can qualify as an extraordinary circumstance under the Court of Cassation’s ruling of 23 September 2026, while crew illness cannot, and where the duty of care applies regardless. The bags travel on the Montreal track, which is exclusive: strict liability in the carrier’s custody, proven delay damage, a 1,000 Special Drawing Rights ceiling for baggage that only a pre-travel special declaration can raise, and three deadlines that admit no supplements, seven days for damage, twenty-one days for delay, and two years to bring the action on pain of forfeiture, against five years for the European flat-rate claim. File the written report at the Paris carousel, protest in writing within the period, keep every receipt, direct package claims at the organiser, and sue, if needed, before the French courts at the place of destination.

📄 Official circular