KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Can Russia Seize a French Merchant Ship in Retaliation for Shadow-Fleet Sanctions? The Law of Countermeasures

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Can Russia Seize a French Merchant Ship in Retaliation for Shadow-Fleet Sanctions? The Law of Countermeasures

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Russia has threatened to answer Western action against vessels linked to its “shadow fleet” with action against merchant ships of states it considers hostile. The warning followed reports that France and the United Kingdom had detained tankers suspected of helping Russia evade the oil-price cap and other sanctions. Moscow has described such detentions as piracy and suggested that retaliation could reach commercial shipping far from Europe. For owners, charterers, insurers and crews, the urgent question is not whether the rhetoric is alarming. It is what legal event has actually occurred, which authority acted, and which remedy remains available.

The European Union’s 21st sanctions package, adopted on 23 July 2026, added 41 vessels to its measures against the shadow fleet. That policy can close ports, prohibit services, freeze assets and restrict transactions. It does not create a general French power to capture any Russian-linked ship on the high seas, and it does not give Russia an automatic right to seize a French ship in response. A lawful analysis must separate sanctions listing, port-state control, civil ship arrest, flag-state jurisdiction and the narrow law of countermeasures. This distinction matters now because a commercial detention can become a diplomatic crisis before the parties have agreed on the facts.

I. What can France and the EU lawfully do to shadow-fleet vessels?

A. Can France bar a shadow-fleet tanker from a French port without seizing it?

Yes, in principle, but the legal basis must be identified precisely. The EU measures against Russia operate through a combination of vessel listings, prohibitions on access to ports, restrictions on services and financial transactions, and measures directed at the maritime infrastructure that supports the evasion of sanctions. The Council of the European Union said on 23 July 2026 that the 21st package listed 41 additional shadow-fleet vessels and that the measures were aimed at ships used to circumvent the oil-price cap, support Russia’s energy and transport sectors, or move stolen Ukrainian grain. The Council’s sanctions timeline records the same date and the additional port-access restrictions. These are public regulatory measures. They are not, by themselves, a judgment that every crew member or cargo owner on board has committed a criminal offence.

The operative EU framework is the consolidated Regulation (EU) No 833/2014 concerning restrictive measures in view of Russia’s actions destabilising the situation in Ukraine. Its maritime provisions must be read with the vessel-specific annexes, the applicable amendments and the exceptions. A port authority therefore needs to check the ship’s IMO number, the legal designation in force on the date of arrival, the service or transaction proposed, the cargo, the flag, the operator and any emergency circumstances. A name match is not a sufficient compliance analysis: vessels change names, companies use similar names, and a beneficial owner, charterer or cargo interest may create a different sanctions question from the registered owner.

For the wider sanctions background, see our earlier analysis of the EU’s 1,600-company Russia sanctions package. This article addresses the narrower maritime question that follows when a listed vessel, a suspected shadow-fleet ship or a French commercial operator becomes the immediate subject of a port or detention decision.

Port denial is also different from physical capture. A French authority may refuse entry or services under EU restrictive measures, while a harbour master may act under French maritime-safety powers. Article L5241-4-5 of the French Transport Code states: Sous réserve des dispositions de l’article L. 5331-3, l’autorité administrative refuse l’accès aux ports : — in English, subject to the stated exception, the administrative authority refuses access to ports. The same provision continues by addressing circumstances in which a vessel presents a high risk for maritime safety, security or the marine environment, as well as an expulsion decision. The official text is available at Article L5241-4-5 of the French Transport Code.

That French provision shows why the word “seizure” can mislead. Refusal of port access prevents a vessel from entering or receiving a service; it does not transfer ownership, authorise a prize-taking operation or decide the merits of a sanctions challenge. A ship may remain at sea, divert to a permitted port, seek a place of refuge or contest the legal ground for the refusal, depending on the applicable EU and French rules. The authority must still respect safety obligations. A blanket refusal that creates an immediate grave risk to life or the marine environment cannot be analysed as if it were an ordinary commercial scheduling decision.

Article L5241-5 reinforces that safety distinction. It provides: Au cas où le navire ne pourrait prendre la mer sans risque pour la sécurité ou la santé de l’équipage ou des personnes embarquées, le milieu marin et ses intérêts connexes ou les autres navires, son départ peut être interdit ou ajourné, après visite. The practical meaning is that a vessel can be prevented from sailing after inspection where departure would endanger people, the marine environment or other ships. The official wording is at Article L5241-5 of the French Transport Code. A detention under that rule is a safety measure with an inspection logic. It is not interchangeable with a sanctions listing or a civil arrest for a debt.

The distinction matters for the owner’s first response. If the port decision cites an EU vessel listing, the owner should request the exact legal act, the listing entry, the prohibited service and the exception considered. If it cites seaworthiness, the owner should request the inspection record, deficiencies, photographs, certificates and the reason why departure is said to create a risk. If it cites customs, pollution, trafficking or a judicial order, the procedural route changes again. Treating every detention as a political seizure can lose the short deadline for a technical challenge; treating every detention as a routine inspection can lose evidence needed for an urgent diplomatic or judicial application.

The EU system can also affect a ship without putting a guard on its deck. A bank may refuse a payment, an insurer may suspend cover, a port agent may decline services, and a supplier may stop bunkering or repairs because a listed vessel or counterparty is involved. The legal question is then whether the restriction is mandatory, whether an exception or authorisation is available, and whether the institution has over-screened a non-listed party. France’s financial-freezing rules, discussed below, impose duties on covered persons, but they do not convert every commercial suspicion into proof of ownership or control by a listed person.

France’s public position is part of the same broader policy. The French Ministry for Europe and Foreign Affairs stated in June 2026 that France and its partners were pressing for EU measures against roughly 650 shadow-fleet vessels and the logistics and financial ecosystem around them. That statement explains the political objective, but an individual detention still requires an individual legal basis. A vessel operator can use the EU’s sanctions explanations and guidance, the relevant Council decision and regulation, and the port authority’s written reasons to identify the exact measure. The Council’s sanctions timeline is useful for chronology, but it is not a substitute for the operative legal text.

B. When can a French court order a conservatory seizure of a merchant ship?

A French conservatory seizure is a separate judicial mechanism. It is normally connected to a claim, a maritime security interest, a risk that recovery will be compromised or a recognised procedural basis. The applicant must identify the debtor, the claim and the asset with enough precision for a judge to assess the request. A government’s decision to list a ship for sanctions does not automatically establish a private creditor’s claim, and a private claim does not automatically authorise a state to use sanctions language as a substitute for judicial evidence.

The French Transport Code makes the procedural link explicit. Article R5114-15 states: Les modalités selon lesquelles les navires peuvent faire l’objet de saisies conservatoires sont régies par les dispositions générales du code des procédures civiles d’exécution, sous réserve de l’application des conventions internationales et des dispositions particulières de la présente sous-section. In English, conservatory seizures of ships follow the general rules of the French Civil Enforcement Procedures Code, subject to international conventions and the special maritime provisions. The official text is at Article R5114-15 of the French Transport Code.

Jurisdiction is not a detail to be left until after the order. Article R5114-16 provides: Le juge territorialement compétent pour autoriser une mesure conservatoire est celui du lieu de l’exécution de la mesure. The competent judge is the judge of the place where the measure will be executed. The text appears at Article R5114-16 of the French Transport Code. For a vessel physically present in a French port, that rule can make the local court central to an urgent application. For a vessel outside France, the French court cannot be treated as a universal maritime police authority merely because the claimant, owner or cargo has a French connection.

The terminology used in a public statement therefore needs care. “Detained” may describe a port-state prohibition on departure, a judicial arrest, a customs hold, a safety inspection, a sanctions refusal or a voluntary pause while documents are reviewed. “Seized” suggests a coercive measure against property, but even that word does not answer whether the measure is conservatory, penal, administrative or an act of state jurisdiction. The order, notice, inspection report or listing entry should be obtained before an owner tells the market that a seizure has occurred.

The high-seas question imposes an additional limit. The United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea provides in Article 92 that: Ships shall sail under the flag of one State only and, save in exceptional cases expressly provided for in international treaties or in this Convention, shall be subject to its exclusive jurisdiction on the high seas. The official UN Convention materials are available through the United Nations Audiovisual Library’s law-of-the-sea page. The flag-state principle does not make a ship immune from every lawful intervention, but it means that a coastal state cannot treat the high seas as an extension of its port. A vessel’s registration, nationality, location, cargo and conduct all need to be separated.

Article 110 of UNCLOS is equally important for rhetoric about piracy. It says that a warship meeting a foreign ship on the high seas is not justified in boarding it unless there is reasonable ground for suspecting piracy, slave trade, unauthorised broadcasting, lack of nationality, or that the ship is of the same nationality despite refusal to show its flag. The exact official wording is addressed in the official United Nations materials on the Convention on the Law of the Sea. A sanctions violation may be serious, but it is not automatically “piracy” in the UNCLOS sense. Nor does a political accusation of piracy itself create the reasonable-ground category needed for a high-seas boarding.

That does not mean a French or EU authority can never act at sea. Jurisdiction may arise from the flag state, a treaty, consent, a coastal-state zone, a hot pursuit scenario, a judicial cooperation instrument, customs law or a specific sanctions rule. The point is narrower and more useful: the legal source must be named. If a French officer stops a vessel in a French port, the analysis begins with French port and judicial powers. If an EU-listed ship is denied a service, the analysis begins with the EU measure and its exceptions. If a warship boards a foreign merchant ship on the high seas, the analysis begins with UNCLOS, the flag state and any applicable treaty or consent.

For a corporate group, the evidence should be organised accordingly. Keep the IMO number, registry extract, flag history, classification status, charterparty, bill of lading, cargo origin, beneficial-owner chart, insurance certificate, AIS history, port calls, sanctions-screening results and all communications with the authority. The same packet should distinguish facts known before the detention from material discovered afterward. That distinction can be decisive when challenging an asset designation, arguing that a vessel was misidentified, seeking an exception or defending a later claim for losses.

II. What would Russian retaliation mean and what can a French operator do?

A. Would a Russian seizure be a lawful countermeasure or unlawful coercion?

Russia’s threatened response cannot be assessed by symmetry alone. If France, the United Kingdom or the European Union takes a vessel-related measure, Russia does not acquire a general entitlement to take a French merchant ship. A countermeasure is not a licence for punishment, confiscation or indiscriminate retaliation. The legal analysis asks whether the prior conduct was internationally wrongful, whether the response is attributable to Russia, whether the affected state was the injured state or is invoking a recognised collective interest, whether notice and an opportunity to resolve the dispute were given, and whether the response is temporary, reversible where possible and proportionate.

The International Law Commission’s Articles on Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts are not a treaty that mechanically decides every maritime incident, but they are an important statement of the general framework. Article 49 describes countermeasures as measures taken by an injured state in response to an internationally wrongful act in order to induce compliance, and requires that they be directed toward the responsible state. Article 51 requires proportionality. Article 52 addresses notice and the offer to negotiate; Article 53 requires termination when the responsible state has complied. A measure designed to induce compliance is fundamentally different from a permanent taking of an unrelated commercial asset.

Article 50 sets hard limits. The official UN text provides: Countermeasures shall not affect: (a) the obligation to refrain from the threat or use of force as embodied in the Charter of the United Nations; (b) obligations for the protection of fundamental human rights; … The complete provision is published in the UN International Law Commission text of Article 50. The omitted items continue with other protected obligations, including humanitarian obligations prohibiting reprisals and certain obligations arising from peremptory norms. A threat to attack merchant vessels, or an actual violent seizure, cannot be made lawful simply by calling it a countermeasure.

Even if Russia argues that a Western detention breached international law, a retaliation against a French ship would need a close legal and factual connection. A French-flagged vessel carrying unrelated cargo is not transformed into a responsible state actor because France supported an EU sanctions package. A Russian authority would also need to explain the location of the ship, the legal basis for exercising jurisdiction, the status of the crew, the evidence of the alleged breach and the reason that detention rather than a less intrusive step is necessary. A measure that is permanent, confiscatory or directed at civilians and independent commercial parties would be difficult to reconcile with the countermeasure framework.

The location changes the immediate risk, not the underlying legal question. In a Russian port or territorial sea, Russia has more jurisdictional tools than it would on the high seas, although those tools remain subject to international law, treaty obligations, due process and the ship’s status. In an area under another coastal state’s jurisdiction, Russia cannot assume that a bilateral dispute with France overrides that state’s authority. On the high seas, Article 92 of UNCLOS places the vessel under the exclusive jurisdiction of its flag state except for recognised exceptions. A seizure by force could therefore create separate questions about jurisdiction, use of force, safety of navigation, crew detention, consular access, property interference and state responsibility.

Operators should also avoid an overconfident opposite claim. Calling every Western detention lawful because it is labelled “sanctions enforcement” is no safer than accepting Russia’s piracy allegation. A listed-vessel measure can be challenged if the vessel was misidentified, the legal act was applied at the wrong time, an exception was ignored, the decision-maker lacked authority or the reasons were inadequate. Port-state safety action can be challenged or remedied if the inspection record does not support the risk asserted. A private conservatory arrest can be attacked if the claim, jurisdiction or procedural conditions are missing. The remedy depends on the act, not the political headline.

The recent European case law on restrictive measures shows why ownership and control need evidence. In C-483/23 T Trust and joined cases C-428/24 FZ AR and C-476/24 SX, the Court of Justice addressed how EU asset-freezing measures can reach funds or economic resources held through structures indirectly controlled or attributable to a listed person. The judgment does not turn a vessel into a listed asset by association alone. It does show that a compliance file must go beyond the registered owner: control, benefit, transactions and the economic reality of the arrangement can be legally significant. The reverse is also true: an allegation of indirect control needs an evidential chain that can be tested.

B. What should an owner, charterer or crew do after detention?

The first objective is to stop a political narrative from replacing the record. Within the first hours, the owner or charterer should ask for the written decision, identify the authority, record the exact time and location, and confirm whether the ship is blocked from entering, from departing, from receiving services, or from transferring cargo. The master should preserve the bridge log, AIS data, voyage plan, weather reports, radio traffic, photographs, crew list, certificates and all orders received. If a boarding occurred, preserve the identity of the boarding party, the stated legal ground, the search scope, any force used and the condition of the vessel when the party left.

A practical response should then follow six parallel tracks:

  1. Protect life and navigation. The master should report any immediate danger to the relevant coastal, port or flag-state authority and request a safe plan for crew, cargo, pollution prevention and medical needs. A sanctions dispute does not suspend the duty to prevent an avoidable maritime casualty.
  2. Fix the jurisdiction. Map the vessel’s exact coordinates, territorial-sea status, port status, flag, registration, ownership, chartering chain and cargo interest at the time of the act. A later change of flag or position should not overwrite the original facts.
  3. Preserve the sanctions file. Save every screening report, ownership document, certificate, payment instruction, insurer communication and port message. Record the IMO number as the primary identifier and keep former names and call signs as secondary identifiers.
  4. Separate legal remedies. A port-access refusal, a safety detention, a court-ordered ship arrest, an asset freeze and a criminal investigation require different applications, deadlines and evidence. Send the decision to maritime counsel, sanctions counsel and the flag-state contact at the same time.
  5. Protect the money trail. Do not route a payment through a new bank, intermediary or nominee before checking whether that transfer would breach an EU or French prohibition. Ask whether an authorisation, humanitarian exception, wind-down period or court order is available, and document the answer.
  6. Prepare the international record. Notify the flag state, insurer, P&I club, charterer, cargo interests, consular authorities and relevant lenders under the applicable contracts. Use a factual chronology, not an accusation that cannot yet be proved.

French freezing law creates concrete compliance duties for banks, insurers and other covered persons. Article L562-4 of the French Monetary and Financial Code provides: Sont tenus d’appliquer sans délai les mesures de gel et les interdictions de mise à disposition ou d’utilisation prévues au présent chapitre et aux articles L. 712-4 et L. 712-10 et d’en informer immédiatement le ministre chargé de l’économie : The provision then identifies persons in France and other covered persons and operations. The official text is at Article L562-4 of the French Monetary and Financial Code. A bank that freezes a payment should identify the measure and the affected person or resource; a customer challenging the freeze should ask for the legal basis and preserve the transaction’s commercial purpose.

Article L562-4-1 adds an internal-governance obligation. It states: I.-Les personnes mentionnées à l’article L. 561-2 mettent en place une organisation et des procédures internes pour la mise en œuvre des mesures de gel des avoirs et d’interdiction de mise à disposition ou d’utilisation des fonds ou ressources économiques prévues au présent chapitre, aux articles L. 712-4 et L. 712-10 et par les règlements européens portant mesures restrictives pris en application des articles 75 ou 215 du traité sur le fonctionnement de l’Union européenne, ainsi que l’interdiction de contournement de ces mesures. The full official provision appears at Article L562-4-1 of the French Monetary and Financial Code. For a shipping group, this means that screening, escalation, approval and record-keeping should exist before a crisis, not be improvised after a vessel is stopped.

Article L562-5 states the prohibition in direct terms: Il est interdit aux personnes mentionnées à l’article L. 562-4 de mettre à disposition directement ou indirectement, ou d’utiliser des fonds ou ressources économiques au profit des personnes dont les fonds et ressources économiques font l’objet d’une mesure de gel en vertu des articles L. 562-2, L. 562-2-1, L. 562-2-2, L. 562-3, L. 562-3-1, L. 712-4 ou L. 712-10. See Article L562-5 of the French Monetary and Financial Code. The words “directement ou indirectement” are why an operator should review guarantees, onward payments, agents, group companies and economic benefits rather than looking only at the name on the invoice. They do not, however, eliminate the need to establish that the relevant person or resource falls within the freezing measure.

There are lawful channels for some transactions involving frozen accounts. Article L562-7 provides: Les interdictions prévues au présent chapitre ne font pas obstacle aux versements de fonds sur les comptes détenus auprès des personnes mentionnées à l’article L. 561-2, dont les fonds sont gelés en vertu des articles L. 562-2, L. 562-2-1, L. 562-2-2, L. 562-3, L. 562-3-1, L. 712-4 ou L. 712-10. It adds that a covered person crediting a frozen account must promptly inform the economy minister. The official text is at Article L562-7 of the French Monetary and Financial Code. The provision is not a general permission to pay a listed person; it is a reminder that the code distinguishes prohibited availability from regulated incoming funds and reporting duties.

Article L562-10 protects the effect of a freeze against third-party claims: Les mesures prises en vertu du présent chapitre sont opposables à tout tiers qui peut invoquer un droit sur les fonds ou ressources économiques faisant l’objet d’une mesure de gel, y compris lorsque ce droit est né antérieurement auxdites mesures. The official version is at Article L562-10 of the French Monetary and Financial Code. A lender, supplier or cargo claimant should therefore identify whether its contractual right is over a frozen asset and seek the appropriate authorisation or judicial route rather than simply exercising self-help.

Where the suspected breach concerns a customs restriction, the criminal risk should also be assessed separately. Article 459 of the French Customs Code provides that the same penalties apply to a person who contravenes or attempts to contravene restrictions on economic and financial relations laid down by EU rules adopted under Articles 75 or 215 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, or by treaties and international agreements approved and ratified by France. The official provision is in the French Customs Code, Chapter IV on criminal sanctions. A ship operator should not assume that a civil dispute over a detention is the only exposure; cargo documents, financing and attempts to route around a prohibition may create a different investigation.

For a French company facing an EU measure, the litigation map may include an application or action before the competent EU court, a challenge to an individual French administrative decision, an urgent application connected to the vessel’s presence in port, a request for a sanctions authorisation, and a contractual or insurance claim. The order in which those steps are taken matters. A court cannot always restore a lost voyage slot, crew rotation or perishable cargo value, while a written reservation of rights can preserve the later damages case. The company should ask counsel to identify the act being challenged, the decision-maker, the deadline, the admissibility standard and the evidence required for interim relief.

The same discipline applies if a French merchant ship is detained by Russia. The operator should request the detention order and alleged legal basis, ask for consular access and medical information for the crew, notify the flag state and insurer, and avoid signing a cargo or ownership admission without advice. If the vessel is in a Russian port, local judicial remedies and diplomatic channels may be immediate but not sufficient. If it is intercepted on the high seas, the location, flag, boarding authority, consent and use of force become central. If the vessel is taken into a third state, that state’s port and coastal jurisdiction may control the first court application.

The strongest public statement is often the most restrained one: the operator can say what the authority did, under which written instrument, where it happened, what the crew needs and what remedy has been filed. It should not call a detention “piracy”, “confiscation” or “lawful countermeasure” before the jurisdictional and evidential questions have been tested. That restraint protects negotiations, insurance coverage and court credibility. It also makes it easier for a French lawyer to explain to international media why the incident is legally significant without turning an unverified allegation into a second dispute.

Conclusion

Russia cannot lawfully answer every EU or French shadow-fleet measure by selecting a French merchant ship and calling the taking a countermeasure. France and the EU, for their part, must keep their own measures tied to the applicable sanctions text, port-safety powers, judicial procedure and evidence. The decisive questions are the vessel’s identity, location, flag, ownership and conduct; the written legal basis for the detention; the authority that acted; and the remedy available before the asset, cargo or crew suffers irreversible harm.

For an owner or charterer, the immediate legal work is practical: preserve the voyage record, obtain the decision, separate sanctions from safety and seizure procedures, screen every payment, notify the flag state and insurers, and seek the court or authorisation that matches the measure. The headline may be about piracy or retaliation. The defensible case will be built from the IMO number, the coordinates, the inspection file, the listing entry, the charterparty, the cargo documents and the exact rule invoked.

📄 Official circular