KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
France Expels Two Iranian Diplomats: What Persona Non Grata Means Under the Vienna Convention

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Hassan Kohen, criminal defence lawyer in Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

France Expels Two Iranian Diplomats: What Persona Non Grata Means Under the Vienna Convention

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

France has ordered two Iranian diplomats to leave after Iran declared two French diplomats persona non grata and after Iranian security forces detained French embassy staff in Tehran. The incident is moving quickly, but the legal mechanism is older and more precise than the political language around it. A declaration of persona non grata is not a criminal conviction, and an expulsion is not a French court judgment. It is a unilateral act by the receiving State under the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations.

The facts remain contested. French authorities say that two embassy representatives were subjected to serious intimidation and that one was physically assaulted during a July detention. Iranian authorities say that the French personnel were involved in unlawful interference and that their conduct exceeded diplomatic functions. On 18 August 2026, Foreign Minister Jean-Noël Barrot announced that France would expel two Iranian diplomats; the order was reportedly delivered after Iran had taken the reciprocal step. The French Foreign Ministry had already described the alleged treatment of its staff as contrary to Article 29 of the 1961 Convention in its 23 July press conference. The latest chronology is reported by Le Monde, while the European Union has called for accountability and compliance with the Vienna Conventions in its 28 July statement on Iran.

For diplomats, embassy employees, families, companies dealing with a mission, and people who may have been detained during a diplomatic incident, the practical questions are immediate: who has immunity, what can France lawfully do, and what remedy remains when the receiving State denies wrongdoing? French and European procedure supplies a framework, but it does not turn every diplomatic dispute into an ordinary criminal case.

I. What does France’s expulsion of two Iranian diplomats legally mean?

A. How does the persona non grata procedure work under Article 9?

The starting point is Article 9 of the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, incorporated into French law through Decree no. 71-284 of 29 March 1971, which published the Convention signed in Vienna on 18 April 1961. The receiving State may notify the sending State that the head of mission or any member of the diplomatic staff is persona non grata. It may also declare another member of the mission unacceptable. The receiving State is not required to explain its decision. After that notification, the sending State must recall the person or terminate the person’s functions with the mission within the period set by the receiving State. If it does not do so, the receiving State may refuse to recognise the person as a member of the mission.

That rule matters because it separates status from blame. France does not need to prove, in a French criminal judgment, that the Iranian diplomats committed an offence before requiring them to leave. The decision can be based on national security, suspected interference, a breach of diplomatic expectations, reciprocity, or a judgment that continued accreditation is no longer acceptable. The Convention deliberately leaves the reasons to the State’s diplomatic assessment. That flexibility is one of the mechanisms that keeps a crisis from requiring an immediate rupture of relations.

The measure also explains why the public announcement uses the language of expulsion even when the underlying legal act is a withdrawal of acceptance. An accredited diplomat is not an ordinary foreign national facing a deportation order under immigration law. The French ministry communicates a diplomatic decision to the sending State, gives a departure instruction, and can withdraw the person’s recognition as a member of the mission. The practical outcome may be an escorted departure, a short deadline, or an instruction to leave through normal channels. The legal foundation is diplomatic accreditation, not a conviction and not necessarily an allegation that can be proved in open court.

The power is broad, but it is not a licence to disregard the rest of the Convention. The receiving State must continue to protect the mission, its premises, property and archives. It must also respect the personal inviolability of diplomatic agents while they remain protected. A persona non grata notice therefore works as a prospective diplomatic remedy. It does not retroactively authorise the arrest, search, interrogation or physical coercion of the person while the person enjoyed diplomatic protection.

This is why the sequence in the France-Iran incident has legal significance. France’s decision followed an alleged detention of French embassy personnel in Tehran and an Iranian declaration that two French diplomats could not remain in Iran. The reciprocal timing may be politically deliberate, but reciprocity alone does not decide whether the underlying detention complied with international law. A lawful Article 9 notice by one State does not validate an earlier breach by the other. Nor does an allegation of interference automatically cancel the receiving State’s duties under Articles 29, 30 and 31.

French constitutional law gives the Convention a particularly strong position. Article 55 of the Constitution places duly ratified or approved treaties, once published, above statutes, subject to reciprocal application. The Convention’s publication was authorised by Law no. 69-1039 of 20 November 1969. In a French legal analysis, the relevant question is therefore not whether an ordinary administrative instruction can be used to bypass diplomatic immunity. It is whether the conduct, the status of the individuals, and the proposed measure fit within the treaty framework as applied by French courts.

Article 9 also avoids a common misunderstanding. Persona non grata is not an international arrest warrant. It does not ask French police to locate a suspect for prosecution. It is not an Interpol Red Notice, and it does not create a finding that the person is guilty of espionage, violence or interference. It changes the person’s ability to remain accredited in the receiving State. If evidence exists of a separate offence, the sending State may investigate, waive immunity, or prosecute after the person returns. France may preserve evidence and raise the matter through diplomatic or judicial channels, subject to the immunity rules that apply at each stage.

In short, France can use Article 9 quickly because the procedure is designed for a crisis. The same speed should not be confused with a finding on the contested facts. The order to leave is the immediate legal result; responsibility, proof and any individual remedy are separate questions.

B. Does diplomatic immunity protect agents during a security incident?

The answer depends first on status. The expression “diplomat” is used in news reporting for several different categories of embassy personnel. A head of mission and a diplomatic agent on the diplomatic list normally receive the strongest protection. Administrative and technical staff, service staff, locally recruited employees, and private contractors may have narrower protection. A person’s passport, job title or proximity to an embassy does not settle the issue by itself. The receiving State’s notification and acceptance of the person’s status, together with the person’s functions, are central evidence.

The French Supreme Court made that point in a case decided on 20 December 2017, no. 17-84.574. In the official text, the Court states: “la détention d’un passeport diplomatique ne suffit pas en soi à entraîner une immunité absolue de juridiction, ni à conférer le statut d’agent diplomatique au sens de la Convention de Vienne du 18 avril 1961.” The case is available on Court of Cassation. In English, a diplomatic passport alone does not create absolute jurisdictional immunity or establish diplomatic-agent status. For the current incident, that principle means that investigators must identify the two French personnel, their formal accreditation, their notified functions and the exact legal protection attached to those functions before drawing conclusions about immunity.

Once diplomatic-agent status is established, Article 29 of the Convention protects the person from arrest or detention and requires the receiving State to treat the agent with due respect and to take appropriate steps to prevent attacks on the person’s freedom or dignity. Article 30 extends comparable inviolability and protection to the agent’s private residence. Article 31 grants immunity from the criminal jurisdiction of the receiving State and broad civil and administrative immunity, subject to narrow exceptions that do not normally cover a diplomatic act or an allegation arising from official mission work. Article 41 still requires every person enjoying privileges and immunities to respect the laws and regulations of the receiving State and not to interfere in its internal affairs.

The rules are cumulative rather than optional. Article 41 can govern conduct, but it does not give security services a free-standing power to detain an accredited agent and decide later whether the Convention applied. If the receiving State believes that a diplomat has abused the mission, it can document the conduct, summon the mission, seek a recall, withdraw acceptance, or declare the person persona non grata. Physical detention is a different act and must be tested against Article 29.

The Court of Cassation used direct language in its criminal chamber decision of 20 September 2000, no. 00-84.335: “la personne de l’agent diplomatique est inviolable ; qu’il ne peut être soumis à aucune forme d’arrestation ou de détention”. The official decision is available here. That proposition does not depend on whether a receiving State considers the person’s meeting politically suspicious. The question is whether the person was an agent protected by the Convention at the time of the restraint.

Status can become more complicated when a mission includes nationals of the receiving State or when the person has a mixed appointment. In its decision of 8 April 2010, no. 09-88.675, the Court of Cassation stated: “les agents diplomatiques ayant la nationalité de l’Etat accréditaire ne bénéficient de l’immunité de juridiction et de l’inviolabilité que pour les actes officiels accomplis dans l’exercice de leurs fonctions”. The official text is available on Cour de cassation. The rule illustrates the importance of the agent’s nationality, function and official act. It also shows why a news report that calls someone a diplomat cannot replace the underlying accreditation record.

The protection of a private residence and the protection of mission premises must also be kept distinct from the protection of a person’s personal devices. Article 22 makes mission premises inviolable, while Article 30 protects the private residence of a diplomatic agent. The First Civil Chamber applied Article 30 in its decision of 7 July 2021, no. 20-15.994, available here. The decision is a reminder that the treaty’s protection follows the legally protected status and location; it is not a general immunity for every object, employee or private activity associated with a foreign embassy.

The same distinction is crucial for digital evidence. Copying a phone, forcing a password, searching a bag or photographing documents during an interrogation may engage personal inviolability, the inviolability of mission communications, domestic criminal law, and the law of State responsibility at the same time. The treaty analysis should identify what was taken, from whom, by which authority, under what claimed power, and whether the material was part of official mission work. A later allegation of unlawful interference cannot erase an earlier act of detention or coercion if the Convention protected the person.

There is also a difference between immunity and a permission to act with impunity. The Assembly Plenary of the Court of Cassation wrote in its decision of 25 July 2025, no. 24-84.393: “L’immunité n’équivaut pas à l’impunité.” The official decision is available here. That case concerned the personal immunity of a serving foreign leader, not the precise status of an embassy employee, so it must not be transplanted mechanically. Its useful lesson is narrower: immunity is a procedural bar or limitation on the forum at a given time; it does not decide the moral or factual merits of an allegation and it does not prevent a sending State from taking action.

II. What can France and the affected diplomats do next?

A. Can French courts investigate, prosecute or order compensation?

French authorities can begin by preserving evidence without deciding that a trial is immediately possible. Statements from the two personnel, medical records, travel and accreditation documents, embassy logs, electronic-device evidence, photographs, messages with the mission, and any contemporaneous diplomatic notes may become important. The French prosecutor can analyse conduct that occurred in France, including threats, coercion, unlawful disclosure or attacks directed at French personnel after their return. French authorities can also ask Iran for explanations and request that the sending State waive immunity for a person whose conduct is alleged to be criminal.

That investigative work is not the same as prosecuting an accredited foreign diplomat. If an Iranian agent in France has immunity from French criminal jurisdiction, a prosecutor cannot simply convert a diplomatic allegation into an ordinary summons or arrest. Article 31 of the Vienna Convention is the first filter. A waiver must come from the sending State and must be express. A declaration that the conduct was unacceptable is not, by itself, a waiver. Nor does a persona non grata order automatically remove all immunity on the day it is issued. The practical protection normally lasts until the person leaves or the protected status ends, subject to the Convention’s rules on official acts after departure.

French territorial jurisdiction remains relevant where immunity does not apply. Article 113-2 of the Penal Code provides that French criminal law applies to offences committed on French territory and treats an offence as committed there when one constituent act occurred there. That principle can support an investigation into conduct in France, but it does not override a treaty-based immunity. The order of analysis is therefore: identify the conduct, locate the relevant acts, establish the person’s status, test the applicable immunity, and only then determine the available French procedure.

France also has treaty-based extraterritorial mechanisms for certain offences. Article 689-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides, in the cases covered by the international conventions referred to in the following provisions, for French prosecution and judgment of a person found in France for specified offences committed abroad. That route is not a universal answer to a diplomatic dispute. It depends on the offence, the applicable convention, the person’s presence in France, procedural conditions and immunity. A serious allegation may therefore produce a French case file without producing an immediately arrestable suspect.

The immunity question may also change over time. A former diplomat may lose personal immunity for private acts once the functions end, while retaining functional immunity for acts performed in the exercise of official functions. The classification of the alleged conduct then becomes decisive. A meeting arranged as part of a cultural or cooperation programme may be presented by one State as official work and by the other as interference. A French court would need evidence about the mission, the instructions, the accreditation and the precise act alleged. The label attached to the meeting by either government is not conclusive.

Civil compensation is no simpler. A person who says that they were detained, assaulted or had data taken may have a claim under French law if a French forum has jurisdiction and no immunity blocks it. A foreign State may also invoke State immunity for sovereign conduct, which is distinct from the personal immunity of a diplomat. The French Supreme Court’s case law on foreign State agents and sovereign acts shows why the character of the act matters. A claim framed as a private commercial wrong is not analysed in the same way as a claim arising from the exercise of governmental authority.

The main immediate route is often diplomatic rather than judicial. France can demand an explanation, request an investigation, seek the identification and punishment of those responsible, ask for a waiver, and use the expulsion decision to protect its mission. The affected personnel can give evidence through their government, and their lawyers can preserve a record of injury and loss. If the two Iranian graphic designers detained in Tehran are not protected by diplomatic status, their families and counsel may explore Iranian proceedings, consular assistance, international complaints and any later forum with jurisdiction. The existence of those options cannot be assumed from the news alone, particularly where access to the detainees and reliable information is limited.

The central legal point is that a French investigation can remain active even when a French trial is blocked. Investigators may establish facts, identify perpetrators, protect victims, and prepare a future case. A diplomatic immunity objection usually concerns the exercise of jurisdiction at a particular time. It does not require France to accept the receiving State’s narrative, and it does not prevent France from maintaining a detailed evidential record for a later waiver, a later change of status, a bilateral settlement, or an international claim.

B. What do the Vienna Conventions and European coordination change now?

The 1961 Convention governs diplomatic relations, but not every person working for an embassy has the same protection. Consular staff are governed by a separate instrument, the 1963 Vienna Convention on Consular Relations, published in France by Decree no. 71-288 of 29 March 1971. Its Article 36 contains the familiar rules on consular notification and communication when a national is arrested or detained. Those rules are important for French nationals held in Iran and for Iranian nationals held in France, but consular access is not a substitute for Article 29 protection of an accredited diplomatic agent. A consular officer’s functional immunity and a diplomatic agent’s personal inviolability should not be merged in public commentary.

The Convention also sets out what happens if diplomatic relations are broken or a mission is recalled. Under Article 45, the receiving State must respect and protect the mission premises, property and archives even in a rupture, and the sending State may entrust their protection to a third State acceptable to the receiving State. That provision makes a complete closure different from a limited expulsion. Paris and Tehran can reduce the number of personnel, suspend particular forms of cooperation, or recall staff while still carrying duties toward the premises and archives. The treaty text published through Légifrance remains the controlling reference for those steps.

Article 40 is relevant when a diplomatic agent travels through a third State, because the third State must accord the person the inviolability and protection required for transit in the circumstances set by the Convention. Article 45 can become important if either government considers closing or materially reducing the mission. Article 22 protects the mission’s premises, and Article 24 protects its archives and documents. Those provisions are not technical footnotes. In a high-tension relationship, they govern what police, customs officers, landlords, private security companies, courts and creditors may do around a foreign mission.

The European response does not replace the bilateral treaty, but it changes the political and evidential setting. The EU statement of 28 July 2026 described the reported treatment of the French personnel as a violation of the Vienna Conventions and called on Iran to hold perpetrators accountable. A common European position can support coordinated démarches, consular assistance, travel warnings, protective measures and pressure for access to detainees. It does not give the EU power to order France to prosecute an accredited diplomat or to impose a judicial remedy that the Vienna Convention does not provide.

European coordination may also matter if the incident becomes linked to sanctions, migration, cultural cooperation, or the safety of nationals. Each measure must have its own legal basis. A diplomatic expulsion under Article 9 is not an asset freeze. A consular request is not a waiver of criminal immunity. A public condemnation is not evidence sufficient for a conviction. Keeping those categories separate reduces the risk that a political response will be challenged because it was presented as a criminal measure without the safeguards of criminal procedure.

The safest route for France is therefore a layered response. First, it should document the alleged breach and protect the affected personnel. Second, it should confirm the status and functions of every person involved. Third, it should use Article 9 or other diplomatic measures to protect the mission and communicate consequences. Fourth, it should seek accountability through an Iranian investigation, a request for waiver where appropriate, and any international mechanism for which jurisdiction exists. Fifth, it should coordinate with European partners while maintaining consular channels for nationals and detainees.

That sequence also protects the legal position of the two Iranian diplomats ordered to leave France. Their expulsion does not erase any evidence France may have about their conduct, but it does not prove an offence either. If they were accredited diplomatic agents, the French order is the appropriate channel for ending their presence without a contested arrest. If their status was narrower, the order may still be valid as an immigration or diplomatic decision, but the immunity analysis would differ. In either event, the sending State can challenge the factual narrative diplomatically, request reasons even though Article 9 does not require them, or decide whether to recall the persons and pursue the dispute through bilateral channels.

The legal significance of this week’s events is therefore larger than the number of diplomats expelled. The case tests whether two States will use the Convention as a safety valve or treat immunity as a political weapon. France’s strongest argument is not that every French employee was immune from every Iranian rule. It is that the receiving State had treaty-compliant ways to respond to suspected interference without detention, violence or coercive examination of protected personnel. Iran’s strongest legal answer, if it wishes to maintain one, would require a precise account of status, conduct, official functions and the steps taken to protect inviolability. General accusations of espionage or interference do not answer those questions.

Conclusion

France’s decision to expel two Iranian diplomats is legally intelligible under Article 9 of the Vienna Convention, but it is not a judgment on the alleged detention of French embassy staff and it is not a substitute for an investigation. Persona non grata is a diplomatic status decision. It allows the receiving State to end accreditation without proving an offence in court. It does not authorise conduct that the Convention separately prohibits, and it does not turn a reciprocal response into evidence of guilt.

The decisive questions are status, timing and conduct. Were the affected French personnel diplomatic agents, administrative staff, consular officers or locally engaged employees? Were they acting within official functions? Did Iranian authorities arrest, detain, search, interrogate or copy material from protected persons? Which parts of the incident took place in France, and which took place in Iran? The answers determine whether French criminal jurisdiction, civil claims, consular assistance, diplomatic protection or an international remedy can be used.

French authorities can preserve evidence and pursue accountability even if a court cannot immediately exercise jurisdiction over an accredited foreign diplomat. The Vienna Conventions provide a disciplined sequence: protect people and missions, verify status, use diplomatic channels, request a waiver where relevant, and keep any criminal or civil proceedings within their legal limits. The next test for Paris and Tehran will be whether that sequence is respected while the political crisis continues.

📄 Official circular