KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Can ICC Officials Challenge the European Commission’s Refusal to Activate the EU Blocking Statute?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Hassan Kohen, employment lawyer in Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Can ICC Officials Challenge the European Commission’s Refusal to Activate the EU Blocking Statute?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

The latest United States sanctions against International Criminal Court President Judge Tomoko Akane and senior trial lawyer Abdoulaye Seye have turned a familiar political confrontation into a precise European litigation question: can an ICC official, an ICC-linked organisation, or an EU-based lawyer challenge the European Commission for leaving the EU Blocking Statute unavailable? The question matters because the American designation is not automatically an EU or French asset freeze, while the European instrument does not automatically cover every US measure. The legal result depends on the Annex to Council Regulation (EC) No 2271/96, the status of the person affected, the conduct of the bank or service provider, and the procedural step taken in Brussels.

The news is immediate. The Associated Press reported on 19 August 2026 that the ICC condemned the new designations as an attack on the Court’s independence. Le Monde reported on 20 August 2026 that France and Slovenia have pressed for a European response, while the Commission has not activated the Blocking Statute. The Commission’s own earlier answer, however, said that an amendment of the Annex remained under consideration and that diplomatic outreach was preferred. The legally useful conclusion is therefore narrower than the headline: a challenge is conceivable, but it is not an automatic injunction against the Commission, a French bank, or the United States. A claimant must first establish a European interest, identify a reviewable omission or decision, and preserve the evidence needed for an urgent national remedy.

I. Can ICC officials challenge the European Commission’s refusal to activate the EU Blocking Statute?

A. Why the current sanctions expose a European legal gap

The first distinction is between an American designation and the legal field of the European Blocking Statute. The statute is not a general European answer to every foreign sanction. Its protection is tied to the foreign laws and instruments listed in the Annex to Regulation No 2271/96. Article 1 describes the instrument as protection against the extraterritorial application of the laws specified in that Annex, where the application affects the interests of persons engaged in international trade, movement of capital, or related commercial activities. The current European Commission explanation states that the Annex currently concerns US measures relating to Cuba and Iran. The new US ICC designations are therefore politically connected to earlier sanctions, but they are not automatically within the operative Annex merely because they are American, extraterritorial, or directed at an international court.

For the broader background on French and EU exposure, this analysis should be read with the existing EU Blocking Statute analysis for French banks and lawyers. The present article narrows the question to the Commission’s omission and the procedural remedies available to a person who needs an answer before a euro account, mandate, or contract is lost.

That limitation is decisive. Article 4 of Regulation No 2271/96 prevents recognition or enforcement in the European Union of certain foreign judgments and administrative decisions based on listed laws. Article 5 prohibits an EU operator from complying with a requirement or prohibition based on listed laws, subject to a Commission authorisation where non-compliance would seriously damage the operator’s interests or the interests of the Union. Article 6 creates a damages route for an EU operator affected by the application of listed laws. Each protection is powerful, but each begins with the same gateway: the foreign measure must fall within the Annex and the claimant must be a person covered by Article 11.

The difference between “not activated” and “not applicable” must also be kept clear. The Commission may be receiving information, discussing diplomatic measures, or considering a delegated amendment without having adopted an act that makes the ICC sanctions part of the Annex. The Commission’s answer of 18 February 2026 said that an act amending the Annex was among the measures under consideration, while targeted diplomatic solutions remained its preferred course. That statement is not a current extension of the Annex. It is evidence of a continuing policy choice and a possible foundation for a request to act, not proof that Article 5 already protects every ICC-related payment or legal service in France.

The Court of Justice has already shown why the distinction can matter in private litigation. In Bank Melli Iran v Telekom Deutschland, Case C-124/20, judgment of 21 December 2021, the Grand Chamber held, in the context of the Iran measures listed in the Annex, that the EU-law prohibition on complying with US secondary sanctions “may be relied on in civil proceedings”. The same judgment recognised that the prohibition cannot be applied in a way that imposes disproportionate economic loss on the EU operator. That is not a shortcut around the Annex. It is a warning that, once the Blocking Statute applies, a bank or service provider must reconcile the European prohibition with its own freedom to conduct business. For the ICC sanctions, the first litigation question is consequently whether the Commission and the Member States will extend the instrument, not whether a claimant can simply quote Bank Melli as if the extension had already occurred.

The scope of Article 11 adds a second gap. The Regulation covers an individual who is resident in the Community and a national of a Member State, a legal person incorporated in the Community, certain service providers, other residents subject to the Regulation’s conditions, and a professional person physically within the Community acting in a professional capacity. An ICC judge who is Japanese or a prosecutor who is Senegalese may have a strong practical connection with the European Union, especially through work in The Hague, but nationality, residence, employment, and the legal identity of the ICC must be documented rather than assumed. A French law firm, French bank, French consultant, or EU-incorporated NGO normally presents a more straightforward Article 11 argument. The individual official may still qualify, but the case must explain which paragraph of Article 11 applies and which economic or financial interest has been affected.

This is why the current story is not just a question of diplomatic solidarity. If the Annex remains limited to Cuba and Iran, the Commission’s decision not to extend it leaves European operators facing a dual exposure. Their US-connected activity may be threatened by a foreign designation, while their EU-law protections remain incomplete. A French bank can be commercially cautious without being entitled to treat an American designation as a French asset freeze. Conversely, a bank cannot present an American compliance preference as a complete answer to mandatory French anti-money-laundering duties, contractual rules, or a properly activated EU prohibition. The litigation must identify the exact norm that governs the transaction.

B. Who can bring a legal challenge, and what must be proved?

The most visible procedural route is the action for failure to act under Article 265 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union. The official text states that the action is available where the Commission or another EU institution “abstain[s] from acting” in violation of the Treaties. It also imposes a sequence: the institution must first be invited to act; if it has not taken a position after two months, the action may be brought within a further two months. The provision adds that a natural or legal person may complain that an institution failed to address an act other than a recommendation or an opinion. The official text is available on EUR-Lex, Article 265 TFEU.

That wording creates both an opportunity and a serious standing problem. The applicant cannot simply file a political complaint saying that the Commission has been too slow. The pre-litigation invitation should identify the requested act, explain why the applicant is directly affected, identify the Treaty or legislative duty relied upon, and request a formal position. For an ICC-related applicant, the letter should attach the US designation, proof of the European connection, the concrete financial or professional impact, the relevant contracts or blocked services, and a precise request: for example, adopt the necessary act to include the designated US measures in the Annex, take a position on the requested extension, or explain why the Commission considers that no act is legally required.

The hard question is whether the Commission has a legal duty to extend the Annex whenever an EU operator is harmed. Regulation No 2271/96 does not say that every foreign sanction must be added. It creates a system in which the European institutions determine the listed laws and the Commission implements the instrument. The applicant would therefore need to show more than serious harm. It would need to show that the Commission’s refusal to take a position, after a proper invitation, is a reviewable failure to address an act that the legal framework requires or makes sufficiently determinate. If the Commission responds within the relevant period by explaining that it is assessing diplomatic, economic, and security consequences, the case may become harder to characterise as an omission.

The identity of the claimant is crucial. An individual ICC official may have standing if the designation directly disrupts a European bank account, salary, pension, insurance, housing contract, legal representation, or other protected economic interest and if the person falls within Article 11. The ICC itself may need to establish its legal personality and its status under its host arrangements before arguing that it is an EU operator. An EU-incorporated NGO, French law firm, or European supplier may have a stronger route if it has lost a contract or faces a concrete prohibition because a US-listed person is involved. A general interest group that has only political concerns will face a weaker standing argument.

The applicant should also separate a challenge to the Commission from a challenge to a French bank. Article 265 is directed at an EU institution. It cannot by itself order BNP Paribas, Société Générale, or another private institution to reopen an account. A bank dispute belongs in national civil proceedings, potentially with a preliminary reference to the Court of Justice if the interpretation of Regulation No 2271/96 becomes decisive. A French public authority’s failure to implement or enforce a directly applicable EU rule may raise a separate administrative-law issue, but it must be tied to an identifiable French decision or omission. Filing a French administrative emergency application against the Commission would confuse the defendants and the source of the alleged breach.

There is also a timing trap. If the Commission has not issued a formal refusal, a claimant should not describe a press report as the operative decision. The safer sequence is to create the decision: send the invitation to act, request a written position, notify the relevant competent authority, and record the date of receipt. A response may be a refusal, an authorisation, a request for information, or an indication that the matter is still under assessment. Each answer changes the available remedy. An actual Commission act might be contested through an action for annulment under Article 263 TFEU, but admissibility for a private applicant would require a separate analysis of direct and individual concern or of the regulatory-act conditions. A failure-to-act case is not a substitute for that analysis.

The evidence should show causation. A designation alone is not enough if the applicant’s French account remains open and no service has been refused. The file should identify the bank’s message, the compliance questionnaire, a blocked transfer, the cancellation of a mandate, the refusal of counsel, or a demonstrable loss of access to a European service. The applicant should preserve the US legal source, the bank’s internal or external explanation, the account terms, the dates of each attempted transaction, and evidence that the activity is lawful under French and EU law. This is also the point at which the EU operator should assess the Article 2 notification obligation, but only if the foreign law concerned is within the Annex. It would be a mistake to use a statutory notice designed for listed measures as a rhetorical substitute for proving that the ICC sanctions have been added.

II. What can a French bank, lawyer or ICC-linked organisation do now?

A. Which French emergency remedies can protect a euro account or legal service?

A French bank’s position must be tested under French law as well as under US risk policy. The right-to-account regime in Article L. 312-1 of the French Monetary and Financial Code gives specified persons a right to a deposit account when they are deprived of an account in France, subject to the conditions of the text. Its fourth paragraph permits unilateral termination of an account opened through that regime in defined situations, including when the client deliberately used the account for operations the institution has reason to suspect pursue illegal purposes, or when the institution falls within Article L. 561-8. The statutory wording refers to a minimum two-month notice, except for the specified exceptions.

The compliance boundary is set by Article L. 561-8 of the Monetary and Financial Code. The text provides that where a regulated person cannot satisfy the required identification or vigilance obligations, it “n’exécute aucune opération, quelles qu’en soient les modalités, n’établit ni ne poursuit aucune relation d’affaires”. This rule is not an American sanction. It is a French anti-money-laundering rule. A bank may have to refuse or end a relationship when it cannot complete customer due diligence, and the existence of an ICC designation cannot force the bank to ignore a genuine French compliance prohibition. But the reverse is equally important: an American designation is not, without more, a finding by a French authority that an ICC official has used an account for illegal purposes.

The Cour de cassation’s decision in Com., 30 June 2021, No 19-14.313, published in the Bulletin, is a useful boundary marker. The Court held, in the right-to-account context, that a bank could terminate without notice where the client had deliberately used the account for operations the bank had reason to suspect pursued illegal purposes. The verified passage states: “Il résulte de ce texte que l’établissement de crédit peut résilier unilatéralement la convention de compte assorti des services bancaires de base, ouvert en application du droit au compte, lorsque le client a délibérément utilisé son compte pour des opérations que l’organisme a des raisons de soupçonner comme poursuivant des fins illégales, auquel cas il est dispensé de lui accorder un préavis.” The decision concerned an Iranian commercial counterparty and a sanctions-related payment circuit. It supports a careful inquiry into conduct and suspicion; it does not convert every politically sensitive customer into an illegal account user.

If a bank blocks a payment, disables a card, or closes an account in breach of the contract or statutory notice rules, the immediate French route is often a civil référé application. Article 834 of the Code of Civil Procedure allows the president of the judicial court, in urgent cases, to order interim measures that face no serious challenge or are justified by the existence of a dispute. Article 835 authorises protective or restoration measures even where a serious dispute exists, to prevent imminent harm or end a manifestly unlawful disturbance. The applicant should ask for a narrowly framed measure: restore access long enough to pay employees and preserve assets, execute a specified transfer, deliver the reasoned termination notice, or maintain the account pending a full hearing.

The relevant Cour de cassation decision is Com., 12 June 2024, No 22-13.226. The Court held that a bank that blocked the use of a card and transfers before the end of the notice period it had itself fixed had committed a fault giving rise to compensation. The exact verified passage is: “la banque avait commis une faute ouvrant droit à réparation.” The point is practical. A French bank that announces a two-month termination cannot necessarily disable every service immediately, especially when its own letter created the notice period. A claimant should preserve the letter, the date of receipt, the last successful transaction, and the exact service that was disabled.

Evidence should be obtained before the account disappears. Article 145 of the Code of Civil Procedure permits a person with a legitimate reason to preserve or establish, before any trial, evidence on which the outcome of a dispute may depend. A request may be made on petition or in référé. In an ICC sanctions file, the target may include the bank’s transaction logs, the compliance request, the account-closure history, the date on which a US screening result was generated, and the internal explanation for distinguishing a US designation from a French legal restriction. The measure must remain proportionate and should not be framed as a demand for unrestricted access to confidential risk reports.

The EU Blocking Statute adds a further argument only if its Annex applies. Article 5 of Regulation No 2271/96 may allow an EU operator to resist a requirement based on a listed US law, while Article 6 may support recovery of damages and legal costs. The Bank Melli judgment confirms that the prohibition can be invoked before a national civil court, but it also requires the court to examine proportionality and the operator’s business freedom. For the present ICC designations, counsel should therefore plead in layers: first, the French contractual or statutory breach; second, any applicable French right-to-account or emergency protection; third, the EU Blocking Statute if and when the relevant US measure is listed; and fourth, a request for a preliminary ruling if the EU-law question cannot be resolved safely by the national court.

A lawyer’s mandate must be treated separately from a bank’s payment risk. A French avocat may advise on the legality of US sanctions, represent a client in French or European proceedings, and protect professional secrecy, but the firm must still check its own payment channels, client-identification duties, insurance position, and any applicable French or EU restrictive measure. A bank’s refusal to process a fee does not automatically invalidate the mandate; it may instead create an urgent payment and evidence problem. The file should contain the engagement letter, the scope of work, the lawful purpose of the representation, the invoice, the attempted payment, and the bank’s reason for refusal. A French court can then distinguish legal assistance from a prohibited financial transaction rather than deciding from a single screening label.

B. What evidence and timetable should a cross-border applicant build?

The first 48 hours should be used to freeze the factual record, not to send an angry reply to the bank. Obtain the designation notice and identify whether it is a primary designation, a secondary-sanctions risk, a visa restriction, or a prohibition affecting only US persons and US-nexus transactions. Request the bank’s decision in writing and ask whether the bank relies on French law, an EU regulation, a contractual risk clause, a correspondent-bank requirement, or an American policy. Do not accept the phrase “sanctions compliance” without asking which legal source is being applied. A bank that refuses to state a reason may still have confidentiality limits, but the applicant needs enough information to select the correct court and remedy.

The second step is to map the person’s European status. An applicant should prove nationality, residence, place of professional activity, employer, legal personality, incorporation, and the location of the relevant bank account or contract. For an ICC official, the employment document and the location of the official’s European activity may be more important than the nationality reported in the news. For an NGO, the certificate of incorporation and the account or service contract may establish Article 11 coverage. For a French lawyer, the bar registration, engagement letter, client-identification record, and invoice show both the professional capacity and the economic interest. The question is not whether the applicant supports the ICC. It is whether the applicant is a protected European operator suffering a concrete effect from a listed or allegedly extraterritorial foreign law.

The third step is to separate an EU listing from a US listing. Search the applicable EU consolidated financial-sanctions list and French implementation materials. A US designation may affect access to US assets, US persons, or the dollar system without itself freezing every euro account in France. An EU or UN designation may produce a different result. The legal memo should record the search date, the exact name and identifiers, the result, and any spelling or transliteration issue. This prevents a French bank from treating a news article as the legal source and prevents the applicant from claiming that no restriction exists when an EU measure does apply.

The fourth step is contractual. Under Article 1103 of the Civil Code, “Les contrats légalement formés tiennent lieu de loi à ceux qui les ont faits.” Under Article 1104, contracts must be negotiated, formed, and performed in good faith. These provisions do not force a bank to perform an operation that French or EU law prohibits, and they do not eliminate a valid termination clause. They do require the court to examine the account agreement, the notice, the stated reason, and the bank’s conduct as a contractual relationship rather than treating a private policy document as self-proving law.

Where a breach is established, Article 1217 of the Civil Code lists the available sanctions: refusal or suspension of the counter-performance, specific performance, price reduction, termination, and compensation for the consequences of non-performance. Article 1231-1 provides that the debtor may be ordered to pay damages for non-performance or delay unless force majeure is established. A claimant should quantify the harm: rejected payroll, failed rent or tax payments, additional bank fees, lost donations, interrupted legal services, currency conversion losses, or reputational damage. Speculative geopolitical harm will be less persuasive than a dated ledger tied to the bank’s refusal.

The emergency application should be designed around the decision-maker. If the defendant is a private bank, Articles 834 and 835 of the Code of Civil Procedure are the natural starting points. If the dispute concerns a French public authority, the administrative court may examine the decision under Article L. 521-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice, which requires urgency and a serious doubt as to legality, or under Article L. 521-2, where an urgent and serious unlawful interference with a fundamental freedom is alleged. The latter provision states that the judge rules within forty-eight hours. Neither provision is a general emergency appeal against the European Commission, and neither removes the obligation to identify a French administrative act.

Time limits must be built into the calendar. Article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice begins from notification or publication of the challenged decision and generally provides a two-month period; it also requires a prior administrative decision where the claim seeks payment of money. If a French authority is involved, the applicant should make the prior claim and record the date of receipt before asking for damages. If the applicant asks the court to order a public body to take a defined measure, Article L. 911-1 allows the court, where its decision necessarily implies such a measure, to prescribe it with a deadline. The remedy remains tied to the court’s jurisdiction and the legal effect of the judgment.

The Brussels procedure under Article 265 TFEU has its own calendar: invitation to act, two months for the institution to take a position, then two months for the action if the omission continues. That period should not be confused with a French two-month administrative deadline or with the short practical window for an account injunction. A claimant may need to run three tracks at once: preserve funds and evidence in France, demand a Commission position in Brussels, and negotiate a payment structure that does not create a new US or EU sanctions violation. The written record should say which track is protective, which is declaratory, and which seeks compensation.

Applicants should also anticipate the Commission’s likely defence. It may argue that the Annex is a political and regulatory choice, that no Treaty provision compels immediate extension, that the applicant lacks the required European status, that the alleged economic interest is indirect, or that diplomatic and security considerations make a detailed act inappropriate. The response must be evidence-led. Show the affected transaction, the protected status, the listed or proposed foreign measure, the exact request made to the Commission, and the failure to address an act that the applicant says is legally required. Avoid presenting the case as a demand that the EU adopt a preferred foreign-policy position. Courts are more likely to examine a defined failure to exercise a legal power than a request to supervise the entire sanctions policy of the Union.

Finally, a successful strategy should preserve optionality. The claimant may first seek a French order to keep a euro account functional, then ask the Commission to authorise or extend the Blocking Statute, then return to the national court with the EU-law position clarified. If the Commission adds the ICC measures to the Annex, Article 5 and Article 6 become materially stronger. If the Commission refuses, the applicant can decide whether the Article 265 conditions are met or whether the more effective claim is against the private operator that acted on an extraterritorial demand without a sufficient French-law basis. That sequencing is slower than a political slogan, but it is the route most likely to protect money, legal work, and evidence before the cross-border dispute becomes irreversible.

Conclusion

ICC officials and ICC-linked European operators may have a credible reason to demand action from Brussels, but there is no automatic cause of action simply because the United States has imposed a new designation. The EU Blocking Statute is Annex-based, operator-based, and procedurally structured. A viable Article 265 strategy requires a written invitation to the Commission, proof of European status and concrete economic harm, and a clear explanation of the act that the Commission allegedly failed to address. A parallel French case against a bank must rely on the account agreement, French anti-money-laundering duties, notice rules, and the urgent référé powers of the judicial court.

The practical message for a French bank, lawyer, NGO, or ICC official is equally precise: preserve the designation and every refusal, distinguish a US listing from an EU or French freeze, demand the legal basis for the bank’s decision, and act before an account or mandate is closed. The current dispute is likely to be decided through those documentary details. A political attack on the ICC becomes a justiciable French or European case only when the applicant can connect the headline to a specific payment, contract, administrative omission, or service that a court can order restored or compensate.

📄 Official circular