Buying a newly built home in France can create an unwelcome surprise for an American owner: a taxe foncière bill arriving before the owner expected to pay French property tax. The key questions are not simply whether the property is “new” in ordinary English, or whether the buyer signed the deed recently. French law looks at the legal completion of the construction, the building’s use, the owner on January 1, the declaration filed with the tax administration, and decisions taken by the local authority. A late or incomplete H1 declaration can also change the practical value of the exemption.
This guide explains the rules in plain English for an American who owns a new house or apartment in France, including a purchase through a French developer or a sale in a state of future completion. It separates the two issues that are often confused: whether the property qualifies for the temporary exemption and whether the tax assessment is correct. It also gives a documentary method for challenging a bill from the United States, without treating the France–U.S. tax treaty as a general exemption from local French property taxes. The legal references below are linked to official French sources and the principal decisions that clarify how the rules operate.
For the wider purchase process, see this legal checklist for buying property in France as an American. This article focuses on the post-construction tax question that arises after the broader acquisition steps.
I. What French taxe foncière exemption applies to a new-build property?
A. When a new home qualifies and what “completion” means
Taxe foncière sur les propriétés bâties is France’s annual tax on built real estate. It is a local tax, assessed under the French tax code for a building located in France. The starting rule appears in Article 1380 of the French General Tax Code: the tax is established each year on built properties located in France unless the code expressly provides an exemption. Citizenship is not a condition. An American owner, a French owner, and a company owned by Americans are assessed under the same property-tax rules for the property.
The temporary new-construction rule is in Article 1383 of the French General Tax Code. Its first paragraph states, in the original statutory wording, “Les constructions nouvelles, reconstructions et additions de construction à usage d’habitation sont exonérées de la taxe foncière sur les propriétés bâties durant les deux années qui suivent celle de leur achèvement.” In English, new construction, reconstruction, and additions used as housing are exempt from the built-property tax during the two years following the year in which they are completed. This is a temporary exemption, not a permanent immunity.
The phrase “following the year of completion” matters. If a qualifying house is completed in 2025, the ordinary statutory period concerns 2026 and 2027. It does not automatically begin on the day the American buyer receives the keys, signs the notarized deed, wires the balance, or moves furniture into the property. A closing in 2026 can concern a building completed in 2025, in which case the year of construction and the year of acquisition are different legal facts. Conversely, a buyer who signed a reservation contract in 2024 may still be dealing with a building completed in 2026.
French tax administration guidance explains completion as the point at which the property can be used for its intended purpose, even if minor accessory work remains. For a private owner, the official impots.gouv.fr guidance on declaring a new home distinguishes a genuinely usable home from a building that is still incapable of normal occupation. This is why a delivery appointment, a developer’s completion certificate, a declaration of completion and conformity, and evidence of habitability are more useful than an English-language statement saying that the project was “substantially complete.”
For a house purchased under a sale in the future state of completion, commonly called VEFA (vente en l’état futur d’achèvement), the American buyer should ask two separate questions. First, when did the building become sufficiently complete for tax purposes? Second, who owned it during the 90-day declaration window? If the developer still owned the property during that window, the developer may have had the initial declaration obligation. If the purchaser acquires the property afterward, the purchaser can receive a special period to make the declaration from the acquisition date. The official guidance warns, however, that this purchaser’s period does not extend the underlying two-year exemption. The dates need to be reconstructed from the construction file rather than assumed from the closing statement.
The distinction between a new building and work on an existing building is also important. The Conseil d’État held in its decision of 24 October 2014, no. 366857, that work creating new residential premises can fall within the construction or reconstruction rule, while simply dividing already existing housing does not necessarily create a new construction for Article 1383 purposes. The decision is available on Légifrance, Conseil d’État no. 366857. An American buyer should therefore preserve the building permit, plans, change-of-use documents, invoices, and the developer’s description of the work. The label “new build” used by a real-estate website is not the legal analysis.
The same caution applies to a major renovation. In Conseil d’État no. 421237 of 29 May 2019, the court explained that a reconstruction analysis can involve the creation of new residential premises and important changes to structural work, while work limited to finishes is not automatically equivalent to new construction. That case arose in another tax context, so it should not be copied mechanically into every taxe foncière dispute. It is nevertheless a useful legal warning: the evidence of what was actually built and when it became usable will usually matter more than the marketing language in a purchase brochure.
A qualifying new home can still carry charges that are not included in the temporary exemption. In particular, the official tax administration explains that the taxe d’enlèvement des ordures ménagères, or TEOM, may remain payable even when the built-property tax itself is exempt. A bill that contains a refuse-collection charge is not automatically proof that the whole exemption was denied. The owner must read the separate lines on the assessment and identify which charge is being challenged.
Local decisions can also affect the amount actually saved. Article 1383 permits the commune or the intermunicipal authority, in the circumstances set by the code, to limit or remove part of the ordinary two-year exemption. The question is not whether an American is entitled to a different rule; it is whether the relevant commune and EPCI, meaning the public intermunicipal cooperation body, adopted a lawful measure affecting the local share. The timing of local deliberations is governed by Article 1639 A bis of the French General Tax Code. The owner should therefore ask the tax office which local deliberation applied to the property for the relevant year and whether it limited only one share or the entire local benefit.
Finally, the January 1 rule controls the person assessed for a given year. Article 1415 of the French General Tax Code states that the tax is established for the whole year based on the facts existing on January 1. A buyer who acquired a completed home on January 2 may not be the person assessed for that year, while a buyer who owned it on January 1 may receive the full annual assessment even if the property was sold later. This rule is separate from the temporary exemption and must be checked separately.
B. Why the H1 or H2 declaration and the local vote determine the real benefit
The exemption is tied to a declaration. Article 1406 of the French General Tax Code requires new construction, reconstruction, and additions to be reported within 90 days of their definitive completion. In its original form, the relevant wording refers to reporting “dans les quatre-vingt-dix jours de leur réalisation définitive.” The practical rule for an American is simple: calculate 90 days from the legally relevant completion date, not from the date on which the buyer first notices the tax bill.
For an individual house, the usual declaration is form H1, number 6650. For an apartment, the usual declaration is form H2, number 6652, sometimes accompanied by form 6840 for relevant details. The official tax administration page identifies these forms and also points owners to the online “Gérer mes biens immobiliers” service. The implementing Article 321 E of Annex III to the French General Tax Code describes the information that the declaration must contain, including the legal interest held, the address and lot details, the nature of the work, the completion date, and the property’s physical characteristics. Article 321 G of the same annex directs the declaration to the tax service responsible for the place where the property is located.
An American living in the United States should treat the declaration as an evidentiary file, not as a formality delegated to a portal. Save the submitted form, every screen confirming transmission, the date and time, the property identifier, and any message from the service des impôts fonciers, or SDIF, which is the local property-tax office. If a notary, developer, property manager, or French accountant submits the form, obtain the final copy and proof of transmission. If the property is held in indivision, meaning shared ownership, keep the document identifying all co-owners and the person who signed.
The form question is not merely administrative. A late declaration can reduce or eliminate the period for which the exemption is effective. Article 1406 connects the benefit to compliance with the declaration obligation. The owner should not assume that filing today restores every year that has already passed. The precise effect depends on the completion date, the date of filing, the assessment years, and whether the tax office treats the filing as late, incomplete, or directed to the wrong office.
The case law shows why the document file must be precise. In Conseil d’État no. 420352 of 21 November 2019, the court noted that “la déclaration adressée le 17 juin 2015 à l’administration fiscale avait été déposée hors délai.” The court refused the exemption for the relevant years because the declaration was late. The facts concerned a commercial building, not an American homeowner, but the procedural lesson is directly relevant: a strong argument about the property will not replace a missed statutory deadline.
The opposite lesson comes from Conseil d’État no. 412473 of 5 June 2019. The court held that the taxpayer had satisfied the substantive conditions, had filed the declaration on time, and “s’était seulement trompée d’imprimé,” meaning that it had used the wrong form. The administration could not automatically defeat the exemption on that basis. This does not make the form irrelevant. It means that a timely declaration containing the required factual information can be legally different from no declaration or a late declaration.
That distinction gives an American owner a practical order of analysis. If there was no filing, investigate the late-filing consequence. If there was a timely filing, determine whether the tax office rejected it because of a wrong form, an incomplete field, a wrong completion date, or a genuine failure to satisfy the construction conditions. The remedy and the evidence differ in each situation.
Local policy must be checked at the same time. A bill can correctly reflect a local limitation and still be wrong because the home was not classified correctly, the completion year was entered incorrectly, the declaration was ignored, or the wrong owner was assessed on January 1. Ask for the calculation of the communal and intercommunal shares, the local deliberation, and the explanation for any amount that remains after the exemption. A generic statement that “new homes are exempt for two years” is not enough to audit a real assessment.
II. How can an American challenge a wrong bill or lost exemption?
A. Which evidence and administrative claim to file
The first response should be a dated legal and factual audit. Before writing to the tax office, create a one-page timeline with the following dates: building permit or construction start; date the building became usable; developer’s or architect’s completion certificate; declaration attesting completion and conformity, known as the DAACT; delivery of the home; notarized acquisition; H1 or H2 submission; any request for additional information; January 1 of each assessment year; and the date the assessment was placed in collection. If two documents use different dates for “completion,” explain why rather than silently choosing the date that produces the largest refund.
Then check the assessment line by line. Confirm the property address, cadastral or tax account reference, the owner shown on January 1, the taxable base, the commune, the EPCI, and the separate TEOM line. Compare the assessment with the H1 or H2 declaration and the property description in the deed. If only one share was reduced, ask whether the commune or EPCI limited that share under Article 1383. If the exemption was refused entirely, ask whether the reason was late filing, wrong form, ineligibility, missing information, or a local decision.
The most useful evidence for a nonresident owner is usually a chronological bundle rather than a long argument. Include:
- the French notarized deed and, where relevant, the VEFA contract and delivery report;
- the building permit, plans, invoices, DAACT, certificate of conformity, and developer correspondence;
- the H1 or H2 declaration, the online transmission receipt, and every response from the SDIF;
- the first assessment, later corrected assessments, proof of payment, and any collection notice;
- photographs or inspection records showing when the home was habitable;
- a translation of essential U.S. documents only when the French tax office needs them to understand ownership, an address, or a power of attorney; and
- a short calculation showing the tax, TEOM, local shares, exemption period, and amount requested for relief.
Do not send original passports, original deeds, or irreplaceable U.S. records unless the recipient gives a secure and documented reason. Send readable copies and keep the electronic submission receipt. If a French lawyer or agent acts for the owner, the power of attorney should identify the property, the tax year, and the authority to receive correspondence. A U.S. address does not eliminate the need to monitor French notices. It makes a reliable correspondence process more important.
The formal French procedure is a réclamation, meaning a written administrative claim against the assessment. It should identify the tax, the property, the years, the relief requested, and the legal and factual grounds. Article R*197-3 of the Book of Tax Procedures requires the claim to identify the assessment, state the conclusions and grounds, and be signed; it also addresses the French address election required in certain cases for a taxpayer domiciled outside France. The online tax account may be convenient, but preserve a PDF of the complete claim and its receipt. If filing by another channel, use a method that proves the date and content.
The deadline must be calculated from the applicable version of the procedural rules and the assessment notice. The current Légifrance section containing Article R*196-2 of the Book of Tax Procedures provides the general rule for local direct-tax claims: they must ordinarily be presented no later than December 31 of the year following the year in which the role was placed in collection. An assessment collected in 2026 will therefore normally require a claim by December 31, 2027, subject to the exact legal basis, a corrected notice, and any special rule stated on the assessment. Do not wait for the deadline if the first bill is already wrong; the tax office may need time to obtain the declaration file from another department.
The claim should request a specific outcome. For example: cancellation of the built-property tax for the qualifying exemption period; reduction of the amount to the taxable share that remains lawful; correction of the completion date; recognition of a timely H1 or H2 declaration; or correction of the owner assessed on January 1. Separate the request for taxe foncière from a request concerning TEOM. If the property has several owners, state whether the requested correction concerns the whole property or only the claimant’s legal position.
A late declaration does not necessarily make every argument useless, but it changes the requested relief. The owner may need to ask for the exemption only for the period that remains legally available after the late filing, while separately arguing that the administration misclassified the filing date or the completion date. A timely filing with the wrong form supports a different argument under Conseil d’État no. 412473. A challenge that mixes the two theories can make the file harder to understand.
The tax office can also ask whether the building was really complete or whether the works were merely an improvement to an existing home. For that question, plans and structural evidence are more persuasive than a contractor’s use of the word “renovation” or “new build.” Conseil d’État no. 369862 of 16 February 2015 illustrates that a building undergoing substantial demolition may not be treated as an ordinary built property while it is wholly unfit for use, until the works are complete. The factual issue is not whether an American owner was inconvenienced; it is what the building was, and when it became usable, under the tax rules.
If the assessment is close to its payment date, the owner should not simply ignore it. Filing a claim does not, by itself, guarantee that collection stops. Ask the tax office or counsel about payment under reservation and any available suspension procedure, while preserving the right to seek repayment. The correct choice depends on the amount, the strength of the claim, collection notices, and the risk of late interest. Under Article 1727 of the French General Tax Code, late payment can generate interest; that risk should be considered rather than left to accumulate unnoticed while the owner is abroad.
B. What happens after refusal, and how the France–U.S. treaty fits
If the SDIF rejects the claim or fails to provide an adequate correction, the next step may be litigation before the French administrative court with jurisdiction over the tax authority. Article L199 of the Book of Tax Procedures provides the route to the tribunal administratif for direct taxes after an adverse administrative decision, subject to the applicable procedural deadlines and the wording of the decision. A court file should contain the assessment, the claim, the administration’s response, the complete construction and declaration evidence, and a calculation that allows the judge to see exactly what correction is sought.
The strongest litigation arguments usually fall into four categories. First, the home satisfied the substantive conditions for the temporary exemption and the administration applied the wrong completion year. Second, the owner filed the required information on time and the administration treated a correct factual declaration as worthless only because the wrong form was used. Third, the administration treated a qualifying reconstruction as an ordinary renovation, or treated an unfinished building as complete too early. Fourth, the local share was calculated under a local decision that does not apply to the property or the relevant year. Each category requires a different set of documents.
The decisions already mentioned provide a useful map. No. 420352 shows the danger of a late declaration. No. 412473 shows why a timely, factually sufficient filing should not automatically fail because of a form error. No. 366857 limits the construction concept where existing housing is merely divided. No. 421237 explains why the scope of structural work matters when reconstruction is alleged. No. 369862 shows why the completion and habitability facts can be decisive. These are not slogans that guarantee a refund. They are authorities to match against the actual construction record.
An American owner should also check whether the tax office has confused the property tax with another French tax. Taxe foncière is not the same as taxe d’habitation, which has a different modern scope, nor is it the same as wealth tax on real-estate assets, rental-income tax, capital-gains tax, or inheritance tax. A property assessment may contain TEOM, but TEOM is not a substitute name for taxe foncière. A letter that asks for an “exemption” without identifying the tax can lead the administration to answer a different question from the one the owner intended to ask.
The France–U.S. tax treaty must be used with equal precision. The official French publication of the Convention between France and the United States signed on 31 August 1994 allocates taxing rights for categories such as income from immovable property, gains from the sale of immovable property, and wealth consisting of immovable property. In broad terms, the treaty permits the state where the real estate is located to tax those French real-estate categories. It does not create a general exemption from France’s local taxe foncière merely because the owner is a U.S. citizen or remains a U.S. tax resident.
That distinction matters in practice. The treaty may be relevant when the same French property produces rent, is sold at a gain, or forms part of a U.S. reporting and foreign-tax-credit analysis. It does not replace the H1 or H2 declaration, change the January 1 ownership rule, extend the 90-day deadline, or override a lawful local deliberation under Article 1383. The official French tax administration page on international tax conventions should be read together with the treaty text and the owner’s separate U.S. tax advice. A U.S. return, foreign-tax-credit position, or treaty disclosure should not be used as a substitute for a French administrative claim.
The same separation is important for U.S. compliance. Paying French taxe foncière is a French local-tax event. Rental income, a sale of the French property, ownership through an entity, and the transfer of funds can create different U.S. and French questions. An American owner should give the U.S. tax adviser the French assessment and proof of payment, but should not assume that the assessment itself reports income or that a treaty article automatically makes it creditable. The French property lawyer, French tax office, and U.S. tax adviser each answer a different part of the problem.
For a remote owner, the best appeal is therefore organized around three sentences: the property was or was not complete on a defined date; the H1 or H2 declaration was or was not filed within the legal period with identifiable proof; and the assessment is wrong for a stated amount under a stated rule. Attach the official documents, cite the relevant provisions, distinguish TEOM from the built-property tax, and preserve evidence that the claim was received. If the answer remains negative, the administrative court route can address the legal classification and the evidence more fully than a series of informal emails.
Conclusion
An American can challenge a French taxe foncière bill on a new-build property, but the case is won or lost on dates, classification, declarations, local shares, and proof. Article 1383’s two-year rule runs from the year of completion, not automatically from the purchase closing. Article 1406 makes the H1 or H2 declaration within 90 days central to the exemption. Article 1415 separately identifies the owner assessed on January 1. The France–U.S. treaty can help allocate income, gains, or wealth questions, but it is not a blanket exemption from French local property tax.
Start with the construction record, preserve the declaration receipt, audit each line of the assessment, and calculate the administrative deadline before sending the réclamation. A focused claim can seek recognition of the exemption, correction of a completion date, reduction of a local share, or repayment of an amount collected without legal basis. If the administration refuses, the complete file can support proceedings before the tribunal administratif.