KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
EU CBAM Verification Rules Arrive: What French Importers and Non-EU Producers Must Fix Before 1 September

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Hassan Kohen, employment lawyer in Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

EU CBAM Verification Rules Arrive: What French Importers and Non-EU Producers Must Fix Before 1 September

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

The European Commission has released new Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism guidance on 24 August 2026, just days before accredited verifiers can begin registering for access to the CBAM Registry. The announcement looks technical. Its practical effect is much broader: the emissions file created by a factory outside the European Union will become part of the legal evidence used by an importer, a customs representative, a national accreditation body and the Commission itself. A French company buying steel, aluminium, cement, fertiliser, electricity or hydrogen from a third-country supplier cannot treat the verification report as a supplier brochure. It will be a compliance document attached to the ability to complete future declarations and surrender the correct certificates.

The immediate question is therefore not simply whether a shipment crosses the 50-tonne threshold. It is whether the whole chain can prove who calculated the embedded emissions, who verified them, which installation was visited, which documents were retained and which entity accepted responsibility in the customs declaration. The amended Regulation (EU) 2023/956 applies the definitive regime from 1 January 2026, while the Commission’s new guidance places verification and registration at the centre of the next operational phase.

This is the French and European legal reading of the announcement. The guidance cannot rewrite the regulation, remove a penalty or transfer a statutory obligation by contract. It does, however, reveal how the administration expects the evidence chain to work. Importers and non-EU producers should use the short period before 1 September to close gaps in mandates, monitoring data, access rights, site-visit planning and appeal records. Waiting for the first disputed declaration would leave the company trying to reconstruct proof after the commercial relationship has already broken down.

I. What the 24 August CBAM guidance changes for cross-border imports

A. Why a French importer is now exposed to a verifier it does not control

The legal starting point is Article 4 of Regulation (EU) 2023/956: Goods shall be imported into the customs territory of the Union only by an authorised CBAM declarant. That sentence is more than a customs label. It makes the authorised declarant the operational gatekeeper for goods within the CBAM scope. The person signing or controlling the customs entry must be able to connect the imported quantity to the correct installation, country of origin, emissions methodology and supporting records. A purchasing department may negotiate the price and a freight forwarder may lodge the customs declaration, but neither fact alone answers who carries the CBAM duty.

Article 5 of the same regulation requires the importer established in a Member State to apply for authorised CBAM declarant status before importing. The current text also deals expressly with indirect customs representatives. An indirect representative must obtain the status before importing where the regulation assigns the obligation to that representative, and the representative becomes responsible for the obligations applicable to the importer for goods imported on the importer’s behalf. The rule is particularly important for a non-EU seller that has no establishment in a Member State: the indirect customs representative is not merely an agent for paperwork but may become the regulated declarant.

This is where the 11 February 2026 decision of the Commercial Chamber of the Cour de cassation, no. 24-18.748, matters as a warning about customs representation. The case concerned import VAT and customs representation, and the official decision records the European rule that representation must be express rather than presumed. A French importer should not assume that a logistics provider, customs broker or accounting firm has accepted indirect CBAM status because it has historically filed entries. The mandate should identify the exact goods, the relevant period, the CBAM functions accepted, the data the representative may access, and the party that will respond to a request for correction.

The 50-tonne threshold does not make that allocation optional. Article 2a and Annex VII of the consolidated CBAM regulation establish a single mass-based threshold of 50 tonnes for the relevant sectors, subject to the specific treatment of electricity and hydrogen. An importer that expects to exceed the threshold must plan for authorisation. Article 5 also requires an application where the importer expects to cross it. The safe question for a French business is not “Am I below 50 tonnes today?” but “What is the cumulative position across the relevant goods, and what will the customs record show if the forecast changes?”

The distinction matters because the threshold is assessed by reference to the importer and the regulated goods, while verification applies to the emissions generated at the installation. A group may buy from several plants through one European entity. A supplier may ship the same CN-coded product from more than one facility. A customs broker may receive instructions from a trading company while the manufacturing contract is signed by another group entity. Those facts can create a mismatch between the legal importer, the commercial buyer, the declarant and the installation whose emissions are being verified.

The new Commission announcement is precise about the next step. It states that CBAM verifiers must register in the CBAM Registry within two months of receiving their CBAM accreditation, but not before 1 September 2026. Accreditation by a national accreditation body comes first; registration with the competent authority comes next. A verifier that is technically capable but not properly accredited and registered cannot be treated as interchangeable with an accredited verifier simply because it has issued environmental reports for another regime.

The Commission’s separate verification page describes a chain involving national accreditation bodies, non-EU installation operators, accredited verifiers and CBAM declarants. The verifier reviews the monitoring approach, emissions calculations and evidence, then issues a report that can be included in the declaration. This means the importer will need contractual access to a file that is partly outside its control. It will also need to know whether the verifier can speak directly with the overseas operator, whether the plant will allow a physical site visit, and whether a change in production process will require a new calculation before the declaration deadline.

Article 8 of Regulation (EU) 2023/956 provides the core rule for actual emissions: are verified by a verifier accredited pursuant to Article 18. The wording leaves no room for a private certificate from an unaccredited consultant to replace the required verification. It also makes the quality of the emissions calculation a legal issue rather than only a sustainability issue. A report that cannot be traced to the installation, the monitoring method and the underlying records may expose the declarant to correction, additional certificates and penalties even if the commercial invoice is accurate.

French customs law reinforces the need to treat import formalities as controlled legal data. Under current Article L. 231-1 of the French Customs Code, goods subject to restrictions or particular formalities are treated as prohibited for the purposes of that code. The provision does not convert every CBAM mistake into a customs offence, and a company should not overstate its effect. It does show why a missing authorisation or an inconsistent declaration cannot be handled as a minor administrative inconvenience. The importer must separate a correctable data error from a failure that affects the legality of release for free circulation.

The post-May 2026 customs recodification also requires updated internal references. Article L. 512-4 of the French Customs Code defines importation without declaration by referring to the customs declaration and complementary declaration duties in the Union Customs Code. A company preparing its CBAM controls should map the CBAM Registry record to the EORI number, CN code, origin, quantity, customs procedure and declaration date transmitted through the customs system. If its internal team still relies on the old numbering of the French code, the legal memo may look complete while the operational checklist points to provisions that ceased to be the current reference on 1 May 2026.

B. Why a non-EU installation must treat its emissions file as an evidentiary record

The factory outside the Union is not the authorised CBAM declarant in every transaction, but its data can determine the declarant’s financial liability. The Commission’s 24 August guidance says that the new material focuses on verifiers checking emissions reports from operators of installations outside the EU that produce goods imported from 1 January 2026. The installation operator therefore sits at the beginning of a chain in which a methodological choice can later become a customs, financial and litigation issue in France.

The file should identify the installation rather than only the corporate group. It should preserve the production boundary, fuel and electricity records, input materials, output volumes, process emissions, allocation choices, default values used, carbon price paid in the third country and all calculations transmitted to the verifier. If the plant makes both CBAM and non-CBAM goods, the allocation method needs an explanation that can be understood by a verifier who was not present when the production system was designed.

Article 6 of the regulation requires the authorised declarant to submit the annual declaration through the CBAM Registry by 30 September each year, for the first time in 2027 in respect of 2026 imports. The declaration records quantities, embedded emissions, certificates and verification reports. Article 8 links actual-emissions data to accredited verification. Article 10 allows a third-country operator to register an installation and disclose verified information, while Article 10a sets the registration route for accredited verifiers. These provisions form a chain: a missing installation record cannot be cured by simply attaching a general corporate environmental report.

The current consolidation also requires records to be sufficiently detailed for verification and later review. Article 19 gives the Commission and competent authorities a review role, and Article 25 provides for the communication of customs information. In practical terms, an importer should assume that the authorities can compare the CBAM declaration with the customs trail. The critical documents are not only the emissions spreadsheet but also the documents that explain why a quantity, an origin, an installation and a calculation belong together.

The Registry itself creates a confidentiality problem. Article 14 distinguishes information that is protected from information about operators, installations and accredited verifiers that may be made available. A manufacturer should decide in advance which data can be disclosed to the importer, which must go to the verifier, and which should be redacted in a manner consistent with the regulation. A confidentiality clause in a supply contract cannot block an obligation imposed by EU law, but the parties can design a controlled access process that reduces accidental disclosure of trade secrets.

The delegated accreditation framework adds another layer. Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2025/2551 sets conditions for accreditation, supervision, recognition and peer evaluation. It also requires information about accreditation decisions and administrative measures to flow to the competent authority for the Registry. The supplier should therefore ask for the verifier’s accreditation scope, current status, relevant sector coverage and any suspension or withdrawal information, not merely for the verifier’s brand name.

A site visit is central to the evidence. The Commission states that verification applies at the level of the installation and describes the verifier’s role as reviewing the monitoring approach, calculations and supporting evidence. The current regulation makes installation visits mandatory subject to the criteria for an exception. The overseas operator should preserve a visit plan, visitor access record, photographs or equivalent observations where permitted, the list of personnel interviewed and an explanation of any unavailable document. An unexplained refusal to allow access can create a gap that the importer may discover only when the report is challenged.

The legal risk is not limited to a false number. A calculation can be challenged because the wrong installation was selected, because a group-level average replaced plant-level data, because a carbon price deduction was unsupported, because a process change was not reported, or because the verifier’s scope did not cover the relevant sector. The declarant should establish a correction protocol before the report is issued: who can stop a declaration, who can request an amended report, who communicates with customs, and how the decision is recorded.

The evidence should also survive a change of supplier. CBAM obligations attach to goods and the legal declarant, not to the goodwill of a particular sales manager. Contracts should require the supplier to retain the source data for the period needed by the regulation, cooperate with the accredited verifier and notify the importer of a change in installation, process, ownership or accreditation status. A termination clause should not permit the supplier to destroy the file while the importer remains exposed to review or penalty.

This approach is consistent with the French principle that an EU trade framework cannot be rewritten by a unilateral national shortcut. In its decision of 28 January 2025, no. 445088, the Conseil d’État considered the common commercial policy and held that a Member State could not unilaterally prohibit the relevant imports where Union rules controlled the field. The case concerned origin labelling rather than CBAM, but it is a useful boundary: France can enforce the Union framework and apply national procedural law, but it cannot invent a different emissions system for the same goods.

II. How to allocate risk, challenge refusals, and prepare before the Registry opens

A. What the importer, customs representative, and verifier should sign before 1 September

The first document should be a responsibility matrix, signed by the importer and, where applicable, the indirect customs representative. It should state who is authorised to import, who submits the application, who controls the EORI account, who receives Registry notices, who appoints the verifier, who pays for a site visit, who owns the emissions file and who signs off the annual declaration. It should not use a generic phrase such as “the broker will handle compliance.” The CBAM regulation assigns functions by legal status, and a vague service description cannot change that allocation.

Article 5 of Regulation (EU) 2023/956 should be read together with Article 18 of Regulation (EU) No 952/2013 on customs representation. Where a non-EU importer depends on an indirect representative, the contract should specify whether the representative accepts authorised CBAM declarant status. The representative should have a right to refuse an entry when the authorisation, installation data or verification report is missing. The importer should have a corresponding right to obtain copies of the customs declaration, the Registry submission and the communications with the competent authority.

The second document should be a supplier data annex. It should list every installation expected to supply goods, the CN codes, the production route, the emissions methodology, the reporting period, the records to be provided and the timetable for corrections. It should distinguish actual emissions from default values. If the supplier wants to rely on information disclosed through the Registry under Article 10, the contract should explain how the importer will verify that the information concerns the same installation and the same goods. A parent-company sustainability report is not a substitute for that mapping.

The third document should govern the verifier relationship. It should require proof of accreditation under Article 18, define the relevant sector scope, preserve independence, regulate site access and prohibit an unrecorded substitution of personnel or methodology. The importer should obtain a copy of the verification report and a clear statement of the material limitations, assumptions and unresolved non-conformities. Where the verifier identifies a problem, the contract should state whether the supplier or importer can request a correction and how that request affects the annual filing.

Article 19 review powers make document retention a central issue. The importer should maintain a secure audit folder containing the customs declaration, EORI data, purchase order, invoice, transport record, installation identifier, production period, emissions calculation, verifier accreditation proof, report, correspondence and correction history. It should also preserve the decision to use actual or default values. The folder should be readable by a lawyer or a new compliance officer who was not involved in the original transaction.

Article 22 requires surrender of the certificates corresponding to the verified emissions by 30 September each year under the current consolidated text. Article 26 imposes a penalty where the declarant fails to surrender the required number. The commercial contract should therefore allocate the cost of a corrected declaration and the cost of additional certificates without pretending that private indemnity removes the regulatory liability. An indemnity may transfer money between the parties; it cannot make an unverified declaration compliant or prevent the competent authority from addressing the authorised declarant.

The parties should plan for data divergence. Customs data may show one quantity while the installation file shows another. A supplier may calculate emissions per tonne of product while the declaration requires the unit specified by the regulation. A shipment may be returned, processed under a special customs procedure or sold through a different European entity. The compliance matrix should contain an escalation rule for each mismatch: stop the entry, use a permitted default, request clarification, or seek a formal correction. The rule should include a named decision-maker and a time limit.

The French administrative framework gives useful discipline to that process. If a national authority issues an adverse individual decision that must be motivated, Article L. 211-2 of the Code of Relations between the Public and the Administration requires the reasons to be communicated. It covers, among other decisions, restrictive authorisation conditions, sanctions and refusals of an authorisation. The importer should ask for a decision that identifies the legal basis, facts, missing records and remedy rather than accepting an informal email that cannot be dated or challenged.

Article L. 121-1 of the same code provides for a prior adversarial procedure for certain individual decisions, while excluding decisions made on an application. That qualification is important. A company should not promise itself a full hearing in every CBAM authorisation dispute. It should instead identify the legal character of the decision, ask whether a response window exists, and submit the decisive evidence within the prescribed procedure. The absence of a hearing right in one phase does not eliminate the right to challenge a final decision.

Finally, French management should approve an internal one-page “release rule.” No covered shipment should be presented for import if the legal declarant is unclear, the authorisation application is inconsistent with the EORI data, the supplier cannot identify the installation, the verifier lacks the right accreditation scope, or the evidence file cannot be retrieved. That rule protects the customs team from commercial pressure and gives the board a traceable explanation for a delayed shipment. It is less expensive than discovering the gap after the goods have been sold onward.

B. What a French company can challenge when authorisation, verification, or customs access fails

A refusal or suspension must first be classified. A French company may face a decision by the national competent authority on authorised CBAM declarant status, a customs decision affecting release, a correction demand based on the Registry, a verifier’s professional conclusion, or a contractual refusal by a supplier. These are not the same dispute. The competent court, deadline, evidence and available interim measure can differ. A complaint addressed to the wrong institution will not preserve every route.

For a French administrative decision, Article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice sets the general two-month period from notification or publication, subject to the applicable rules and the content of the decision. The company should record the date, the channel of notification, the exact operative part and the appeal information. A Registry message or a customs-system alert may not be sufficient by itself to determine the judicial route. The compliance team should preserve the original electronic notice and its metadata.

Where an urgent administrative decision threatens a shipment, a production contract or a financing line, Article L. 521-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice allows the judge in urgent proceedings to suspend a decision when urgency exists and a serious doubt about legality is shown. The remedy is not an automatic pause button. The applicant must connect the imminent harm to the decision and identify a serious legal argument, such as a failure to apply the current regulation, a defective reasoning, a material error in the installation record or a procedural breach.

The evidence for an interim application should be assembled before the hearing. It should show the purchase contract, customs schedule, production stoppage or lost delivery, the precise data already supplied, the missing or disputed item, the verifier’s accreditation status and the authority’s written reasons. A general statement that CBAM is commercially important will be weaker than a dated document showing that a shipment cannot be released or that a customer will terminate if the goods are not delivered by a fixed date.

When the dispute concerns a customs claim, repayment, remission or guarantee, the new French Customs Code includes a specific allocation rule. Article L. 332-5 directs certain disputes to the judicial court at the place connected with the recovery notice, customs office or specialised service. The provision is a reminder that a CBAM problem with a financial customs consequence may not follow the same path as an administrative challenge to authorisation. Counsel should identify the operative decision rather than rely on the subject matter alone.

The customs court analysis also needs to account for the current offence provisions without exaggeration. Article L. 512-4 of the Customs Code concerns importation without declaration by reference to Union customs declaration duties. Article L. 231-1 addresses goods subject to restrictions or particular formalities. These provisions may become relevant where a company deliberately imports without the necessary customs data or authorisation, but a disagreement over the correct emissions factor is not automatically equivalent to smuggling. The defence should insist on the correct classification of the alleged failure, the relevant date and the evidence of intent where intent is legally required.

The Article 55 of the French Constitution and Article 88-1 provide the constitutional setting for this European regime. Article 88-1 records France’s participation in the European Union and the exercise of shared competences; Article 55 addresses the authority of regularly ratified and published treaties over statutes. Neither provision itself answers a CBAM calculation question. They do explain why a French authority must read the national customs framework together with the directly applicable Union regulation and why a national instruction cannot lawfully substitute a different EU-wide rule.

The 28 January 2025 Conseil d’État decision no. 445088 is useful when a French company argues that a national authority should impose a unilateral import restriction or a different origin standard. The court’s reasoning is not a general immunity from customs controls. It is a warning against asking France to create a parallel trade barrier. A challenge should instead identify a conflict with the applicable CBAM regulation, an error in the competent authority’s application, a failure to consider a document, an unlawful penalty calculation or a procedural defect that affected the result.

A verifier’s report requires a different strategy. The verifier is not always a public authority whose professional conclusion can be attacked directly in administrative court. The importer should request the report, the scope of accreditation, the findings and the correction mechanism. If the verifier failed to apply the verification principles, ignored evidence or acted outside its scope, the importer may need to challenge the report contractually, notify the national accreditation body, ask the competent authority to review the Registry information and preserve the point for a later challenge to the declaration or penalty. A private dispute does not replace the statutory deadline.

The regulation also creates a time-sensitive distinction between a correction and a penalty. Article 19 review can lead to a request for information or a correction of the declarant’s position. Article 26 penalties attach to failures such as not surrendering the required certificates. The company should not wait for a final penalty before explaining an error. It should make a written correction proposal, identify the affected declaration and explain whether the problem changes quantity, emissions, carbon-price deduction or certificates. A candid record may not remove liability, but it can prevent a later argument that the company concealed the issue.

French companies should also preserve the ability to seek a contractual remedy against a supplier or representative. The contract should separate four losses: the cost of additional certificates, penalties paid to the authority, customs storage or demurrage, and downstream customer losses. It should define the proof needed for each loss and the period during which records must be kept. A generic “compliance with all laws” clause is unlikely to answer whether the supplier promised actual-emissions data, access to the installation, a competent verifier or timely cooperation with a correction.

The final precaution is to keep the legal and technical files connected. The calculation engineer may know why a default value was selected but not know which declaration used it. The customs broker may know the CN code but not the production installation. The lawyer may receive a refusal without the raw data needed to show an error. A single indexed file, with a chronology and version history, lets the company move from compliance to defence quickly. It also makes it possible to show that the importer acted on verified information rather than adopting a number supplied without scrutiny.

For a French importer preparing now, the practical sequence is clear. Confirm the authorised declarant and EORI path. Confirm whether the threshold is expected to be exceeded. Obtain the non-EU installation map. Verify the verifier’s accreditation route and sector scope. Agree the site-visit and records protocol. Test the Registry access chain before a commercial deadline. Create a correction and appeal timetable. Record every refusal or warning in a form that identifies the decision, reasons, date, authority and remedy. Those actions create evidence of governance at the same time as they reduce the probability of a failed declaration.

Conclusion

The Commission’s 24 August announcement is not a new tax and it is not a licence for national administrations to add their own carbon border rules. It is an operational signal that the definitive CBAM regime is moving from registration and reporting into verified, installation-level evidence. From 1 September, the verifier and Registry architecture becomes concrete. From 2027, the first annual declarations and certificate surrender for 2026 imports will test whether importers can prove each number.

The legal responsibility remains concentrated on the authorised CBAM declarant, even where the essential evidence is produced by an overseas factory or a private verifier. The importer should therefore make the chain explicit in writing, keep the installation evidence, verify accreditation, preserve customs records and distinguish an administrative refusal from a verifier disagreement or a customs claim. French administrative and customs remedies can be effective, but only if the company identifies the decision, preserves the deadline and brings the right evidence to the right forum.

The best preparation before 1 September is a short, signed file that answers five questions: who is the declarant, which installation produced the goods, who verified the emissions, what evidence supports the calculation, and what happens when the authority or verifier disagrees. If those answers are not available for the next shipment, the business does not yet have a defensible CBAM process.

Need a quick opinion on your case

We offer a telephone consultation within 48 hours with a lawyer from the firm.

We can review your importer status, CBAM evidence file, customs mandate and appeal timetable.

📄 Official circular