KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Kavala v. Türkiye No. 2: Why an Ineffective Constitutional Remedy Could Not Delay Strasbourg Review

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Kavala v. Türkiye No. 2: Why an Ineffective Constitutional Remedy Could Not Delay Strasbourg Review

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 25 August 2026, the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights delivered a judgment that turns a familiar admissibility objection into the centre of a much larger rule-of-law question. In Kavala v. Türkiye (no. 2), application no. 2170/24, the Court held that Türkiye had to secure Osman Kavala’s release at the earliest possible date and eliminate the consequences of the measures taken against him. The Court stated that his criminal conviction was to be regarded, under Convention law, as null and void. The judgment concerns detention that continued after the Court’s 2019 ruling and criminal proceedings that ended with an aggravated life sentence. Its most consequential procedural feature is the treatment of exhaustion: an applicant could not be faulted for waiting for a Constitutional Court remedy whose effectiveness had, in the particular circumstances, been seriously compromised.

That holding does not create a shortcut around domestic courts, and it does not convert every delayed constitutional petition into an admissible Strasbourg complaint. It does create a demanding factual test for cases in which liberty is continuously lost, domestic remedies are used diligently, a prior international judgment has not produced practical relief, and the supposedly decisive remedy has become too slow or too uncertain to protect the right in time. For French lawyers handling an extradition, an international arrest request, or a cross-border detention file, the immediate lesson is practical: preserve the chronology, prove the remedy’s real capacity to prevent harm, and separate an extradition objection from an International Criminal Court surrender procedure. This analysis focuses on that procedural bridge rather than repeating the earlier Article 46 discussion.

I. What did Kavala v. Türkiye No. 2 decide about an ineffective constitutional remedy?

A. Why could Strasbourg examine application no. 2170/24 before the Turkish Constitutional Court finished?

The starting point is the distinction between a remedy that exists in a statute and a remedy that can protect a person before the alleged violation becomes irreversible. Article 35 § 1 of the Convention normally requires an applicant to use available domestic remedies before applying to Strasbourg. The rule expresses subsidiarity: national judges should have the first opportunity to prevent or repair a violation. It is not a demand that a person pursue a purely formal route forever, regardless of delay, institutional practice, or the harm that continues while the file waits.

The Grand Chamber’s decision arose from an unusually dense procedural history. Mr Kavala had been deprived of liberty since October 2017 in proceedings connected with the Gezi Park events and the allegation that he had attempted to overthrow the Government. In 2019, the Court found Convention violations in relation to his detention and the purpose attributed to it. The official material for the new case records that the detention and the later criminal proceedings continued after that judgment. The new proceedings ended in an aggravated life sentence, while the earlier international judgment had not produced the release that it required.

That history mattered to admissibility. A domestic remedy is assessed in the real setting in which the applicant must use it, not in isolation from the State’s conduct in the same file. The Grand Chamber examined the individual application to the Turkish Constitutional Court, the time it had taken, the applicant’s continuous detention, the steps he had taken through the available procedures, and the absence of practical relief after the earlier Strasbourg judgment. It concluded that the applicant could not be criticised for failing to await the outcome of the Constitutional Court proceedings in the particular circumstances of this case.

The point is narrower and more rigorous than the headline may suggest. The Court did not say that a constitutional complaint is generally ineffective in Türkiye. It found that the remedy’s effectiveness had been seriously compromised as applied to this applicant and this sequence of events. The Court’s reasoning links four facts. First, the deprivation of liberty was uninterrupted and exceptionally long. Secondly, the applicant had used domestic procedures consistently, diligently, and without ambiguity. Thirdly, the previous Strasbourg judgment had not had practical effect in securing the result it required. Fourthly, the Constitutional Court proceedings had been subject to delays that meant the remedy no longer offered a reasonable prospect of timely examination.

This is an effectiveness analysis, not a preference for Strasbourg over national constitutional adjudication. A constitutional court may retain power to order release, quash a decision, or provide meaningful redress in an ordinary case. But the legal power written in the code is only one part of the inquiry. The Court asks whether that power can be activated in time, by a procedure accessible to the applicant, with a realistic prospect of changing the detention or conviction before the harm continues. When the answer becomes no, waiting can cease to serve subsidiarity and start to convert delay into a barrier to review.

The distinction also explains why an applicant should not describe the judgment as a general suspension of Article 35. The exhaustion rule still requires a serious effort to use domestic routes. An applicant who simply bypasses a functioning appeal, fails to raise the Convention complaint nationally, or files at Strasbourg on the basis of speculation remains exposed to inadmissibility. Kavala is powerful because the record showed the opposite: repeated domestic litigation, a prior binding judgment, persistent detention, and a constitutional remedy whose timing had become disconnected from the protection sought.

The official judgment is available through the Court’s HUDOC record for Kavala v. Türkiye (no. 2), application no. 2170/24. The Court’s public case page states that Türkiye had to secure release at the earliest possible date and eliminate the consequences of the measures taken against Mr Kavala. It adds, in the Court’s own words, that “His criminal conviction was to be regarded, under Convention law, as null and void.” That sentence is not a domestic annulment decree issued by a French judge or an automatic rewriting of the Turkish court record. It is the Convention-law consequence of a judgment binding on the respondent State within the European human-rights system.

For practitioners, the sentence has two dimensions. The first is immediate: the respondent State must take measures that end the continuing violation and remove its consequences. The second is evidential: where a later file asks a French court to assess the risk created by a foreign prosecution, conviction, detention, or remedy, the judgment becomes a high-value official document. It can help establish the chronology, the legal findings, and the gap between a remedy’s formal availability and its actual capacity. It cannot replace the individual analysis required in the French proceeding.

B. Why does the judgment remain case-specific rather than abolishing exhaustion?

The judgment’s force lies in its limiting conditions. Article 35 is not defeated by an applicant’s impatience; it is affected when the domestic process has ceased to offer a timely and practical route to the right at issue. The relevant comparison is between the protection requested and the likely date on which the domestic remedy could provide it. That comparison is especially exacting where the harm is detention. A remedy that might eventually produce a declaration or compensation may not be equivalent to a procedure capable of stopping unlawful detention while the person is still in prison.

Four questions help identify the boundary. What right is at stake, and can delay itself intensify the violation? What precise power does the domestic body have: release, annulment, retrial, interim protection, or only a later finding? How has that body dealt with the applicant’s filings in practice? And what has the State done after any earlier international judgment? These questions prevent the reasoning from becoming a country label. A delayed remedy is not ineffective merely because it is slow; it becomes legally important when the delay, combined with the nature of the harm and the surrounding record, destroys any reasonable prospect of timely protection.

The Grand Chamber also separated admissibility from the merits. Its decision on exhaustion did not by itself prove every underlying complaint. The Court then examined the detention, fair-trial guarantees, the use of criminal law against protected activity, the absence of an adequate review mechanism for an aggravated life sentence, and the relationship between those measures and the Convention rights invoked. The official country material identifies violations involving Articles 3, 5, 6, 10, 11, and 18. That sequence matters. A finding that a domestic remedy cannot postpone Strasbourg review opens the door; it does not decide the merits without evidence.

Nor does the judgment make Strasbourg a fourth-instance appeal. The Court is not asked to recalculate every factual inference made by a national judge or to substitute its assessment of ordinary criminal evidence. The relevant questions are whether the detention had a Convention-compliant legal basis and purpose, whether the proceedings were fair and independent, whether protected activity was criminalised for an improper purpose, whether the sentence exposed the applicant to treatment contrary to Article 3, and whether the State complied with the binding consequences of an earlier judgment. Those are Convention questions, not a general appeal on the facts.

The enforcement history reinforces the point. The European system has a distinction between a judgment on an individual application and supervision of execution by the Committee of Ministers. The earlier Kavala litigation had already generated an execution dispute and an infringement procedure under Article 46. By the time the new application was decided, the Court was not looking at an isolated first-instance complaint. It was examining a continuing deprivation of liberty against the background of a binding judgment whose practical outcome had not been delivered. That background did not dispense with Article 35, but it changed the factual assessment of whether another domestic waiting period could reasonably be demanded.

The phrase “null and void” must therefore be read with institutional precision. It is not a universal rule that every national conviction affected by an ECHR violation disappears automatically from every national database. It describes the status the conviction must have under Convention law after the Court’s finding. Domestic authorities must choose and implement the measures that make the judgment effective. In a French proceeding, the lawyer must identify the competent national forum and the legal consequence sought: refusal of extradition, a stay, interim protection, recognition of a risk, or a later remedy concerning a French decision. The international judgment supplies authoritative findings; the French court still applies French procedural law to the case before it.

That distinction is critical for cross-border files. A person facing surrender cannot rely on a slogan such as “the foreign judgment is invalid.” The useful argument is more exact: the foreign prosecution presents a documented risk to a protected right; the relevant domestic remedy has no reasonable prospect of preventing that risk in time; and the official record shows why assurances or later review would not cure it. Kavala gives that argument a sharper legal vocabulary. It does not eliminate the burden of connecting the international judgment to the requested person, the requesting court, the detention conditions, the procedural stage, and the remedy actually available.

The Court’s approach also protects against the opposite error. Governments may point to an appeal, constitutional petition, or compensation action and call the problem solved. The applicant must test that claim with dates and powers. When was the remedy filed? Was the detention reviewed? Could the body order release or only make a declaratory finding? Did it examine the decisive complaint? Did an earlier judgment change the person’s position? Did the remedy conclude before the harm became irreversible? A record answering those questions is more persuasive than a broad assertion that the national system is either wholly trustworthy or wholly defective.

II. What does the ruling change for French extradition and cross-border defence?

A. How should French courts test the effectiveness of a foreign remedy?

French courts do not enforce an ECHR judgment in Türkiye as if it were a French criminal judgment. They do, however, operate within a legal order in which treaty obligations matter when a person’s surrender would expose him or her to a real Convention risk. Article 55 of the French Constitution gives regularly ratified and published treaties authority above statutes, subject to reciprocity. The official constitutional text states: Les traités ou accords régulièrement ratifiés ou approuvés ont, dès leur publication, une autorité supérieure à celle des lois. The provision is not an automatic extradition veto, but it explains why Convention rights and Strasbourg case-law belong in the French court’s analysis.

The first domestic filter is Article 696-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. In its version in force in 2026, it excludes extradition where the offence is political or the circumstances show a political purpose, and where the person would be tried by a tribunal that does not ensure fundamental procedural guarantees and defence rights. The statute uses the phrase garanties fondamentales de procédure et de protection des droits de la défense. The complete provision is available on Légifrance, Article 696-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. A recent Strasbourg judgment about one applicant does not prove every element of those grounds, but it can be part of the evidence showing why a court, a prosecution, or a remedy must be examined closely.

The advocacy task is to translate Kavala into the facts of the person sought. Counsel should identify whether the requested person is exposed to pre-trial detention, a final sentence, a politically charged prosecution, a court lacking independence, restrictions on defence evidence, or a sentence without a genuine review mechanism. The argument should then identify the foreign remedy said to cure the risk and test its operation: its legal power, accessibility, average timing, treatment of similar applications, and capacity to deliver release or a new hearing. The question is not whether the requesting State has a constitution or a constitutional court. The question is whether this person can obtain effective protection before the harm persists or becomes irreversible.

The French Court of Cassation’s approach in extradition cases illustrates why individualized proof matters. In Criminal Chamber judgment no. 20-81.359 of 13 January 2021, the Court held that when the requested person faced a risk of inhuman or degrading treatment in the requesting State, the investigation chamber had to give an unfavourable opinion. The case concerned a person with subsidiary protection, and the Court treated that status as evidence of an established risk for as long as the protection had not ended. The official summary uses the words doit donner un avis défavorable. The lesson is not that every protection status produces the same result; it is that a documented, person-specific risk must be connected to the statutory extradition process.

The same method applies to a foreign constitutional remedy. A French judge may consider the official Kavala judgment as evidence about delay, implementation, or the practical value of a remedy, but the judge still needs the current record in the individual file. That record might include the constitutional petition, the date of registration, decisions on interim relief, the status of review, prison records, requests for release, the foreign courts’ reasoning, and independent material explaining whether a favorable decision would actually be implemented. A translated press report is not a substitute for the judgment or the procedural documents that prove what happened.

The legal route also changes if the incoming request is not an extradition request. A request from the International Criminal Court is governed by a separate French regime. Article 627-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides that ICC requests for arrest for surrender are sent in original form with supporting documents, pass through the public prosecutor general after a formal-regularity check, and are executed through the statutory mechanism. The text is available at Légifrance, Article 627-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Article 627-7 sets the appearance process, including the initial presentation to the investigating chamber, on the schedule stated in Légifrance, Article 627-7.

The Court of Cassation made the distinction explicit in Criminal Chamber judgment no. 10-87.760 of 4 January 2011. It held that surrender to the International Criminal Court is not extradition and that the French court’s review is governed by the ICC surrender provisions. That decision prevents a lawyer from importing every Article 696-4 argument into an Article 627-4 procedure without checking the statutory text. It also prevents an authority from treating an extradition file and an ICC request as interchangeable. The first question in an urgent case is therefore procedural classification: extradition, European arrest warrant, ICC surrender, or another form of mutual assistance.

Once the correct procedure is identified, Kavala supplies a framework for assessing a remedy rather than a ready-made result. An assurance from a requesting State should be tested against the precise defect found in the record. If the concern is a court’s independence, the assurance must address the institutional and case-specific facts. If the concern is detention, it must explain review, release powers, and timing. If the concern is conviction after a politically motivated prosecution, it must identify a procedure capable of setting aside the consequences, not only a later possibility of compensation. If the concern is an ineffective constitutional petition, the file should show the dates and decisions that make the delay legally meaningful.

B. Which French deadlines and evidence must a person protect?

Extradition defence is a sequence of short procedural windows. Article 696-15 of the Code of Criminal Procedure governs the person’s opposition and the investigation chamber’s review. The provision refers to the appearance within un délai de dix jours ouvrables after notification and sets a further timetable for the chamber’s opinion. Its statutory text is available at Légifrance, Article 696-15. A person who waits for an international argument to develop while missing the first hearing, translation request, or cassation deadline may lose the opportunity to place the evidence before the French court when it can still act.

The file should begin with a dated procedural map. Record the arrest or notification, the provisional-detention decision, the date on which the requesting State’s documents were served, the language in which they were provided, the decision to consent or oppose, every hearing, the appointment of counsel and interpreter, each request for release, and every judgment or administrative act. Add the requesting State’s case number, charge, sentence, limitation period, and current enforcement status. Then place the Strasbourg material on the same timeline: the judgment date, the findings, any execution decision, the domestic steps said to implement it, and the remedy whose delay is relied upon.

Article 696-4 evidence should be separated into distinct folders. The first concerns political purpose: statements by prosecutors or officials, the choice of charges, treatment of comparable defendants, timing around elections or public controversy, and any link between protected activity and the prosecution. The second concerns procedure and defence rights: access to the case file, legal assistance, the ability to call or challenge witnesses, public hearing conditions, judicial independence, interpretation, and the reasoning given for rejecting decisive applications. The third concerns sentence and detention: review mechanisms, prison conditions, health, age, and the realistic prospect of release. Kavala may strengthen the second and third categories, but it does not eliminate the need for current evidence.

Article 696-18 adds another clock after an extradition opinion. Where extradition is authorised, the provision concerns the Prime Minister’s decree and the period in which the requesting State’s agents must take charge of the person. It also provides for release if the person is not taken within the statutory period, subject to the conditions stated by the text, and sets a one-month period for the application for judicial review of the decree. The current provision can be checked at Légifrance, Article 696-18. A defence strategy that addresses only the investigation chamber’s opinion and ignores the executive decree may leave an important remedy unused.

Administrative emergency procedure may matter when the challenged measure is an administrative act and the statutory conditions are met. Article L. 521-2 of the Code of Administrative Justice permits the urgent judge to order measures necessary to safeguard a fundamental freedom when there is a grave and manifestly unlawful infringement. It states that the judge decides within un délai de quarante-huit heures; the official text is on Légifrance, Article L. 521-2. This is not a universal replacement for criminal-procedure remedies. It is a reason to identify, immediately, which decision is being challenged and which court has jurisdiction to prevent its effects.

French law also contains tools for securing execution of French judicial decisions. Under Article L. 911-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice, a court can prescribe a necessary measure of execution when its decision requires a public body to take a defined step; the provision is available at Légifrance, Article L. 911-1. Article L. 911-4 allows an interested party to ask the court to ensure execution of a judgment, with measures, a time limit, and a penalty payment where appropriate; see Légifrance, Article L. 911-4. These provisions do not execute a Strasbourg judgment directly against Türkiye. They illustrate the domestic question a lawyer must ask: what concrete legal act will give effect to the ruling, and which forum can compel that act?

A final criminal decision in France has its own Strasbourg-related mechanism. Article 626-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure opens the possibility of re-examination where an ECHR judgment establishes that a conviction violated the Convention and the harm cannot be ended by just satisfaction alone. The provision begins, in its official wording, Le réexamen d’une décision pénale définitive peut être demandé; consult the full text on Légifrance, Article 626-1. That route concerns a French criminal decision, not the automatic annulment of a Turkish conviction. The comparison is still valuable because it shows why a Convention finding must be connected to a competent domestic mechanism if the requested person needs a practical remedy.

When the incoming request concerns an ICC surrender, evidence and deadlines follow the different Articles 627-4 to 627-15 pathway. The lawyer should obtain the original request and supporting documents, verify identity and translation, check formal regularity, and place any argument about a separate risk or legal bar before the chamber under the correct provision. The Court of Cassation’s companion decision, judgment no. 10-87.759 of 4 January 2011, concerns release in an ICC surrender context and is a reminder that the procedural vocabulary matters. An extradition objection framed under the wrong chapter can obscure an otherwise serious human-rights argument.

The evidential discipline required by Kavala can be expressed as a question of proof, not rhetoric. Do not write that a remedy is ineffective because an authority is hostile. Show the filing date, the requests made, the rulings delivered, the time elapsed, the powers available, the practical result, and the reason a future decision would arrive too late. Do not write that a conviction is void everywhere because the ECHR used the phrase “null and void under Convention law.” Explain the respondent State’s obligation, the status of the foreign record, and the specific French relief sought. Do not attach a general country report and leave the bridge implicit. Identify the court, defendant, charges, stage, detention, remedy, and evidence that makes the comparison sound.

This is where the new judgment may influence media-facing international work as well as courtroom submissions. Journalists and foreign counsel often need to know whether a Strasbourg judgment changes a French arrest or extradition risk immediately. The responsible answer is conditional. The decision makes an ineffective remedy a serious Convention issue when the facts show that waiting would deny timely protection. It does not create a universal bar to cooperation with Türkiye, invalidate every Turkish judgment, or remove French procedural deadlines. The value of the decision is that it makes institutional delay legally testable through an individual chronology.

For a person arrested in Paris or elsewhere in France, the first consultation should therefore produce three deliverables. It should identify the procedure and its next hearing. It should preserve the official legal material, with certified or reliable translations where necessary. It should produce a short risk memorandum matching each fact to the relevant rule: political purpose, fundamental defence guarantees, inhuman or degrading treatment, lack of effective review, or the practical impossibility of obtaining timely relief. If the file may later reach Strasbourg, domestic submissions should also preserve the Convention complaint and the dates needed to prove exhaustion or explain why the remedy was not effective in the particular circumstances.

Conclusion

Kavala v. Türkiye (no. 2) is not a licence to bypass national courts. It is a warning that a remedy cannot retain its procedural blocking effect when continuous detention, diligent litigation, non-implementation of a binding judgment, and institutional delay have removed any reasonable prospect of timely protection. The Grand Chamber’s answer is fact-sensitive but demanding: examine what the remedy can do, when it can do it, and whether it can still protect the person whose liberty is at stake.

In a French extradition file, that reasoning should be placed alongside Article 696-4, the timetable in Article 696-15, the executive stage in Article 696-18, and the Convention-based case-law of the French Court of Cassation. In an ICC file, the first task is to use the surrender provisions rather than the extradition chapter. The decisive work is documentary: obtain the official judgment, build the chronology, verify the foreign remedy, preserve the domestic deadlines, and ask the competent French court for a concrete form of protection. The 25 August 2026 ruling gives international counsel a stronger way to explain why formal availability is not the same as effective protection.

📄 Official circular