An American who moves to France often asks whether the balance in a 401(k), traditional IRA, Roth IRA, or U.S. brokerage account must be added to French wealth tax. The short answer is usually no for a financial account held as such, but that answer changes when the account owns taxable French real estate or an investment representing that real estate. France’s impôt sur la fortune immobilière (IFI, a tax on real-estate wealth) is based on net taxable real-estate assets as of January 1.
The name of the U.S. wrapper does not decide the result. The analysis follows the assets underneath it, the ownership chain, the account’s legal form, the taxpayer’s residence on the relevant date, the value of the real-estate exposure, and the debts that can legally be deducted. A French tax resident may have a worldwide real-estate analysis, subject to the special rule for a person who has just moved to France. A U.S. resident with a French home generally has a narrower French-situs analysis. The France–United States income-tax treaty helps classify pension contributions and distributions, but it does not replace the IFI asset-by-asset test.
This guide separates those questions. It explains why an ordinary 401(k), IRA, or Roth IRA balance is generally outside the IFI base, when a retirement account can contain a taxable real-estate interest, how a French plan d’épargne retraite (PER, a regulated retirement savings plan) differs from a U.S. plan, and which documents should be assembled before filing. It is written for an American reader with no prior knowledge of French tax terminology.
I. Are U.S. 401(k), IRA, and Roth IRA balances included in French IFI?
A. Why an ordinary retirement-account balance is normally outside IFI
For the general framework on French wealth tax, see our guide to IFI for Americans who own property in France. This article addresses the narrower retirement-account question and should be read with that broader overview.
Start with the object that France taxes. Article 964 of the French General Tax Code creates the tax in these words: “Il est institué un impôt annuel sur les actifs immobiliers.” In English, this is an annual tax on real-estate assets. The statutory threshold is not a threshold for all household wealth. It is a threshold for the value of the assets that the IFI provisions identify as taxable real estate, after permitted liabilities and exemptions have been considered.
The central rule is Article 965 of the French General Tax Code. It states that “L’assiette de l’impôt sur la fortune immobilière est constituée par la valeur nette au 1er janvier de l’année.” The assiette is the tax base. Article 965 then covers, first, real property and real-property rights owned by the relevant persons and, second, shares or interests in companies and organizations to the extent that their value represents real property held directly or indirectly.
A 401(k), a traditional IRA, a Roth IRA, and a U.S. brokerage account are normally financial claims or financial investments. Cash, ordinary corporate shares, Treasury securities, and ordinary bonds are not transformed into French real estate merely because their owner lives in France or because they are held for retirement. An account statement showing a large balance therefore does not, by itself, establish a large IFI base. French income-tax reporting and French IFI reporting are different exercises: a pension payment or foreign investment income can be relevant to income tax without becoming an IFI asset.
This is a classification conclusion, not a blanket statutory exemption for every U.S. retirement arrangement. The account must be reviewed to determine what it actually owns and whether a look-through rule applies. “My 401(k) is tax deferred in the United States” is not enough to answer the French question. Conversely, “the account appears on a U.S. information return” is not enough to make the full account taxable for IFI.
The applicable perimeter also depends on French tax residence. Article 964 distinguishes between a natural person whose tax domicile is in France and one whose tax domicile is outside France. A person domiciled in France is generally assessed on taxable real-estate assets in France and abroad. A person not domiciled in France is generally assessed on French real estate and the French real-estate fraction of certain entities. The rule is based on the taxpayer’s residence and the location and nature of the real estate, not on U.S. citizenship.
There is an important arrival rule. A person who was not fiscally domiciled in France during the five calendar years before establishing a French domicile is, for the statutory period, assessed only on the real-estate assets covered by the French part of the rule. The limitation runs through December 31 of the fifth year following the year in which the French tax domicile was established. The current text of Article 964 should be checked for the relevant filing year, especially where the move occurred during a year or where the person previously lived in France.
The practical starting table is therefore:
| Asset inside the U.S. retirement account | Initial IFI position | Question that can change it |
|---|---|---|
| Cash, U.S. Treasury securities, ordinary bonds, or ordinary operating-company shares | Normally outside the IFI base as financial assets | Does a fund or entity underneath the holding own taxable real estate? |
| A diversified U.S. mutual fund or exchange-traded fund | Not automatically included merely because it is held in a 401(k) or IRA | Does the fund meet a statutory real-estate look-through test or an exclusion? |
| A U.S. or French entity holding French apartments, land, or other taxable rights | The relevant real-estate fraction can be included | What is the January 1 value, the ownership percentage, and the entity’s debt? |
| A French PER held as a securities account | The taxable real-estate fraction can matter during the savings phase | Which underlying funds and real-estate assets are held? |
| A life-insurance or capitalization contract with units linked to real-estate assets | The relevant surrender-value fraction can be included | Does Article 972 and its collective-investment rules apply to the contract? |
| A retirement arrangement legally administered through a trust | Requires a separate trust and retirement-rights analysis | What does the instrument own, who is treated as the constituent, and which rule applies? |
Consider a French resident with a French home worth €900,000, a French rental property worth €500,000, and a 401(k) worth the equivalent of €1 million invested entirely in stock and bond funds. On the stated assumptions, the account balance is not added to the IFI base simply because it is a 401(k). The French real estate must still be valued, reduced by any deductible real-estate debt, and tested against the threshold. The result changes if the retirement account holds a vehicle that represents taxable real estate, or if the home is held through an entity whose shares must be valued on a real-estate fraction.
Now change the facts. The same taxpayer holds a fund inside the 401(k) that owns a French property through a controlled entity. The account is still a retirement wrapper, but a fraction of the underlying interest may be treated as real-estate exposure for IFI. The correct calculation is not “include 100 percent of the 401(k)” and not “ignore 100 percent of the 401(k).” It is a documented analysis of the taxable interest at the statutory valuation date.
B. When the investments inside the account can create French real-estate exposure
Article 965 is deliberately wider than direct ownership of a French apartment. Its second category covers shares or interests in entities established in France or abroad, but only “à hauteur de la fraction de leur valeur représentative de biens ou droits immobiliers détenus directement ou indirectement.” The point is proportionality: an entity interest is not necessarily taxed at its full financial value, yet a retirement wrapper does not erase a real-estate interest that the statute reaches.
This rule matters in several situations. A U.S. retirement plan might hold shares in a private company that owns a French villa, a French rental portfolio, or land. It might hold an interest in a partnership or fund that owns French property. It might hold a fund with real-estate assets in the United States or another country. For a person whose tax domicile is in France, worldwide taxable real estate can be relevant. For a person living in the United States who is not a French tax resident, the French-situs limits generally become central. The entity’s country of incorporation is not a substitute for tracing the location and legal nature of the underlying assets.
Article 965 also contains detailed exceptions and thresholds for operating companies and certain holdings. Article 966 explains that the management of an entity’s own real-estate assets is not treated as an industrial, commercial, artisan, agricultural, or professional activity for this purpose. That distinction prevents a label such as “real-estate business” or “investment company” from answering the question by itself. The text of Article 966 must be read with the ownership and operating-asset provisions of Article 965.
Collective investment funds require particular care. Under Article 972 bis, certain collective investment interests are not retained for the IFI base when the taxpayer holds less than 10 percent of the fund’s rights and the fund’s assets contain less than 20 percent of taxable real estate, subject to the statutory categories and conditions. The rule is not a universal “ETF exemption.” It asks what the fund owns, how much of it is taxable real estate under Article 965, and what percentage the taxpayer holds.
Listed real-estate investment companies have their own rule. Article 972 ter addresses shares of the French investment companies referred to in Article 208 C when the taxpayer’s direct and indirect interest is below the statutory 5 percent level. A U.S. REIT should not be declared or excluded by analogy without checking its legal form, its holdings, its listing, its percentage of ownership, and the territorial scope that applies to the taxpayer. A widely held security and a privately controlled property company are not interchangeable facts.
A French PER illustrates the difference between the wrapper and the investment. The official Service-Public explanation of IFI states that, during the savings phase, PERs opened as securities accounts are taxable for IFI to the extent of the value corresponding to taxable real-estate assets. That does not mean that every euro in a PER is real estate. It means that a French securities-account PER can require the same underlying-asset review as another investment account when its funds hold taxable property exposure.
An insurance-based arrangement is different again. Article 972 provides that the surrender value of a redeemable insurance contract or capitalization contract expressed in units of account is included to the extent that its units represent assets covered by Article 965, under the conditions of Article 972 bis. The official text uses the expression “La valeur de rachat des contrats d’assurance rachetables.” The link to Article 972 is important because a U.S. annuity, a French assurance-vie policy, and a U.S. IRA are not automatically the same legal product. The contract wording and underlying investments matter.
Trust structures create a further boundary. Article 970 states that assets covered by Article 965 placed in a trust are included, at their net market value on January 1, in the estate of the constituent or the beneficiary treated as a constituent under the statute. The full rule appears in Article 970 of the French General Tax Code. An IRA is not automatically a trust for French purposes, and an employer plan’s administrative trust is not automatically identical to an individual retirement account. The trust instrument, governing law, beneficiaries, and underlying property must be reviewed.
The distinction is not theoretical. In Conseil d’État, May 7, 2026, no. 511615, the court annulled a blanket administrative statement about trusts constituted to manage individual retirement plans. The decision concerned the separate levy on trusts and the interpretation of Article 990 J; it did not declare every U.S. retirement account exempt from IFI. It does show why a plan should not be classified from a short label. The court explained that the legislature intended to exclude certain employer retirement-rights trusts from that levy, without distinguishing between a plan benefiting several people and one benefiting a single person. The decision’s limited holding should be respected rather than expanded into a general IRA exemption.
Finally, direct property ownership is a practical warning sign. A retirement account that directly owns a French building would raise custody, authorization, valuation, and tax questions in addition to IFI. More commonly, the exposure is indirect: a private fund, partnership, corporation, or real-estate vehicle owns the building. The documents should show the chain from the retirement account to the underlying property. If the chain cannot be explained, a French filing position based only on the account’s headline value is vulnerable in either direction: it may overstate the base or omit an interest that the law reaches.
II. How should an American living in France test, value, and report retirement assets?
A. Which residence, treaty, and account documents control the analysis
The first factual question is not “How much is my IRA worth?” It is “What was my tax domicile and household on January 1 of the relevant year?” The IFI rules assess the conditions at that date. A married couple, civil-partnership couple, or couple living in a recognized common household may have a combined analysis, and minor children whose property is legally administered by the parents can matter. The current Article 964 text should be kept with the file used to prepare the return.
For an American who has recently moved to France, the five-year arrival limitation can be decisive. If the person was not fiscally domiciled in France during the five calendar years before the move, the French rule may temporarily leave U.S. real estate outside the IFI perimeter while French real estate remains within it. That limitation concerns real-estate assets; it is not a rule that makes every U.S. financial account taxable or every U.S. asset exempt. It also does not eliminate the need to test a retirement account that contains French property or a French real-estate fraction.
The France–United States treaty is then read alongside the domestic IFI provisions. The consolidated treaty text published by impots.gouv.fr is the working source for the 1994 convention as amended by the 2004 and 2009 protocols. Its Article 2 identifies the taxes covered and its subsequent-tax language matters when a tax is later changed. That text should be checked for the filing year instead of relying on a blog summary.
Article 18 is primarily an income-allocation provision. The U.S. Treasury version of the treaty describes pensions as “pensions and other similar remuneration, including distributions from pension and other retirement arrangements.” The provision can affect whether France or the United States taxes a pension payment and it can address contributions to a qualifying retirement arrangement. It does not answer the separate question whether an asset held inside the arrangement represents taxable real estate at January 1. A pension distribution may be income; the underlying account may be outside IFI; a property interest inside the account may require a fraction to be analyzed for IFI.
That separation prevents three common errors:
- Assuming that treaty relief for a pension distribution removes a French real-estate interest from an asset-based tax.
- Assuming that a U.S. Form 5498, Form 1099-R, FBAR, or Form 8938 is an IFI declaration. Those U.S. documents serve different reporting purposes.
- Assuming that French income reporting on Form 2047 decides the IFI treatment of the account’s assets. Form 2047 addresses foreign-source income; the 2042-IFI concerns taxable real-estate wealth.
The Conseil d’État has also treated treaty rules as allocation rules that must be read according to their text. In Conseil d’État, June 29, 2011, no. 320263, the court examined the France–United States convention and the interaction between U.S.-source income and a French tax credit. That case was not an IFI decision and should not be cited as one. Its value here is methodological: an American’s treaty analysis must identify the tax, the category of income or asset, the relevant article, and the credit mechanism instead of treating “the treaty” as a single exemption.
Assemble the account file before reaching a conclusion. At minimum, request the following:
- the account agreement and a description of the U.S. plan or custodian;
- the December 31 statement and the statement or valuation used for January 1;
- the list of securities, funds, private interests, REITs, partnerships, and insurance products;
- the fund prospectus or annual report showing real-estate holdings and percentages;
- any look-through or asset-composition certificate supplied by the fund manager;
- trust, plan, or beneficiary documents where a trust or employer arrangement is involved;
- the taxpayer’s French residence timeline, household details, and prior French filings; and
- deeds, valuations, acquisition documents, and loan statements for each underlying property or property-owning entity.
Ask the custodian a precise question rather than requesting a generic “tax letter.” The useful question is whether, at the French valuation date, the account or each underlying vehicle held direct or indirect French real estate, foreign real estate, units of account representing such assets, or an interest that must be valued under an Article 965 fraction. A response that merely says “the account is qualified under U.S. law” does not identify the underlying assets.
If the administrator cannot supply a percentage, preserve the written request, the response, the prospectus, and the calculation method used. Article 965 contains a good-faith information provision for certain indirect holdings, but it has exceptions where the taxpayer controls the relevant company, retains use of the property, or exceeds the statutory ownership level. This is not a permission to omit a property interest because a foreign custodian is slow to respond. It is a reason to build evidence of the inquiry and the legal basis for the final figure.
B. How to calculate, document, and file the IFI position
A defensible calculation follows a fixed sequence.
- Fix the date and perimeter. Identify January 1, the French residence position, the arrival-year limitation if applicable, the household, and whether the taxpayer is resident or nonresident for IFI purposes.
- Separate wrappers from assets. List the 401(k), traditional IRA, Roth IRA, annuity, brokerage account, French PER, trust, and insurance contract separately. Then list the assets inside each one.
- Locate real estate. Identify direct property, property rights, and entities or funds that own real estate. Record the country, the type of property, the ownership chain, and the taxpayer’s percentage.
- Apply the statutory filters. Test operating-asset exclusions, collective-investment thresholds, listed real-estate-company thresholds, trust rules, and the relevant French-resident or nonresident scope.
- Value the taxable fraction. Use the January 1 value and the legal fraction of the account, units, shares, or entity that represents taxable real estate. Do not substitute the full retirement-account balance for that fraction.
- Review deductible liabilities. Deduct only debts connected to taxable assets and supported by contracts, balances, payment history, and the statutory limits.
- Combine the household figures. Add the taxable real-estate values and apply the threshold, rate, cap, credits, and foreign-tax rules that actually fit the facts.
- File the right form and retain the workpapers. The return should be reproducible from the statements, valuation reports, entity calculations, and legal provisions saved in the file.
Valuation is not a year-end guess. Article 973 provides that the value of Article 965 assets is determined under the rules used for death-transfer duties. It also states that listed securities are valued using the last known price or the average of the thirty prices preceding the tax date. The exact value of a private entity, fund, unit-linked contract, or property interest may require a different document set. The current text of Article 973 should be kept with the January 1 calculation.
For a 401(k) invested in a listed fund, preserve the account value, the number of units, the relevant price, and the fund’s asset-composition evidence. If the fund has a 2 percent taxable French-real-estate fraction, the working paper should show how that percentage was obtained and whether Article 972 bis or another rule excludes it. If the fund has no relevant real-estate assets, say so with the prospectus or manager certification rather than writing only “not taxable.” If a private vehicle owns a French apartment, obtain the property value, entity accounts, debt schedule, ownership percentage, and any applicable professional-asset analysis.
Debt is equally important. Article 974 allows deductions for debts existing on January 1, effectively borne by the relevant person, and connected to taxable assets. It lists acquisition, repair, maintenance, improvement, construction, certain property taxes, and qualifying acquisition costs for taxable entity interests. The provision also contains rules for principal-repayment-at-maturity loans, no-term loans, related-party loans, and high-debt situations. The full Article 974 should be applied to the property or real-estate interest, not to the retirement wrapper in the abstract.
A loan from a 401(k), a margin balance inside a brokerage account, a personal credit-card balance, or U.S. income-tax liability is not automatically a deductible IFI debt. The question is whether the debt is legally connected to an IFI-taxable asset and meets the French conditions. Keep the loan agreement, purpose, drawdown, balance, repayment terms, and proof of payment. When an entity owns the property, check both the entity-level debt rules and the proportional value of the taxpayer’s interest.
Three simplified examples illustrate the mechanics.
Example one: financial investments only. An American who is French-resident owns a €1.2 million French home and a €900,000 401(k) invested in U.S. operating-company stock and Treasury funds. The retirement account is not added merely because its balance exceeds the value of the home. The home is tested under the IFI rules, including any applicable principal-residence reduction and qualifying debt. The account remains relevant to income-tax and U.S. reporting questions, but its financial assets do not become real estate by association.
Example two: a real-estate fund inside the account. The same person holds a fund worth €500,000 in the IRA, and the fund manager certifies that 12 percent of its relevant value represents taxable French real estate. The analysis must test the collective-investment conditions, the taxpayer’s percentage of the fund, the nature of the property, and the fund’s debts. If the statutory exclusion does not apply, the working figure may include the qualifying fraction, not automatically the full €500,000 and not automatically zero. The exact result depends on the fund documents and the Article 965 calculation.
Example three: an American who has not moved to France. A U.S.-resident taxpayer owns a French apartment valued at €1.4 million and a $2 million IRA invested in ordinary U.S. securities. The French real estate is the starting point for the French IFI analysis, subject to treaty provisions and deductible debt. The ordinary U.S. securities are not French real estate merely because the owner has a French apartment. If the IRA instead owns an interest in a French property company, the French real-estate fraction must be tested separately.
If the net taxable real-estate wealth exceeds €1.3 million, the official impots.gouv.fr 2042-IFI page states that Form 2042-IFI is required. The filing is made with the income-tax declaration when the taxpayer has an income-tax filing obligation; a person without taxable income uses the specific procedure described by the tax administration. The threshold is not the amount of IFI due. It is the entry point into the progressive calculation.
The current Article 977 rate table starts at zero up to €800,000, applies 0.50 percent to the next band up to €1.3 million, then 0.70 percent through €2.57 million, 1 percent through €5 million, 1.25 percent through €10 million, and 1.50 percent above €10 million. A narrow reduction applies between €1.3 million and €1.4 million. Because the bands and any later amendments must be checked for the filing year, use the official form and current code rather than an old calculator.
Two additional rules can matter to a retired American. First, Article 979 provides a limitation mechanism based on the prior year’s worldwide income and taxes for a person domiciled in France. In Conseil d’État, March 31, 2021, no. 440543, the court reviewed the IFI cap and held that the statutory mechanism used the prior-year rules described by Article 979. The case involved the transition to withholding at source and the modernization-of-collection credit; it does not convert retirement-account principal into real estate. It can, however, matter when pension income is part of the cap calculation.
Second, Article 980 allows a credit for foreign taxes whose characteristics are similar to IFI, limited to the foreign real-estate component described by the provision. U.S. federal income tax on an IRA distribution is not, simply because it is paid in the United States, a foreign real-estate wealth tax. Read Article 980 before claiming a credit. A U.S. state tax, property tax, or estate tax presents a different legal question and should not be inserted into the IFI calculation without a specific basis.
Use the following filing checklist before signing:
- Confirm the taxpayer’s French residence, arrival date, household, and January 1 position.
- Mark each U.S. retirement account as “financial assets only,” “real-estate exposure,” or “legal form requires further review,” with evidence for the mark.
- Obtain fund holdings, real-estate percentages, ownership percentages, and January 1 values.
- Separate French property from U.S. property and from other foreign property, then apply the applicable residence perimeter.
- Calculate each property-owning entity’s taxable fraction and preserve the formula.
- Document every claimed liability under Article 974 and remove liabilities that are merely personal or income-tax debts.
- Check Article 972 for insurance-based contracts and Article 970 for trust structures instead of applying the ordinary IRA conclusion by analogy.
- Compare the final net taxable figure with the official €1.3 million threshold and use the current 2042-IFI instructions.
- Keep a copy of the treaty provisions used for pension income separate from the IFI asset calculation.
If the French tax administration questions the return, the strongest response is a traceable classification file: residence facts, account agreement, January 1 statement, holdings, real-estate fraction, statutory filters, debt evidence, and a calculation that another professional can reproduce. Do not answer a request for information by sending only the total IRA balance. The administration may request explanations and evidence about the composition of the assets and liabilities; the response should address that composition directly.
Conclusion
For most Americans living in France, a 401(k), traditional IRA, Roth IRA, or similar account invested only in cash and ordinary financial securities is not added to the French IFI base as a whole. The result changes when the account contains direct or indirect real estate, a property-owning entity, a qualifying real-estate fund, units of account covered by Article 972, or a trust structure governed by the special rules. French residence determines the geographic perimeter; January 1 determines the valuation date; the France–United States treaty governs relevant income-tax questions but does not replace the IFI asset test.
The safest position is therefore neither “all retirement savings are taxable” nor “retirement savings are always exempt.” Trace the assets, calculate only the taxable real-estate fraction, document the exclusions and debts, and preserve the official sources used. A review before filing is especially useful when the account holds REITs, private funds, partnerships, insurance contracts, or a trust, or when the taxpayer has recently become French-resident.