KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Erasmus+ Fraud Before the Paris Criminal Court: What Germany- and Switzerland-Based Defendants Face Under EPPO Rules

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Erasmus+ Fraud Before the Paris Criminal Court: What Germany- and Switzerland-Based Defendants Face Under EPPO Rules

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 27 August 2026, the European Public Prosecutor’s Office (EPPO) in Paris announced that it had filed an indictment before the Paris Criminal Court against two individuals living in Germany and Switzerland. The case concerns suspected fraud involving €240,000 in ERASMUS+ funding awarded to a French non-profit for a children’s literacy project carried out, or intended to be carried out, between 2016 and 2019. The official EPPO announcement says that investigators suspect a lack of operational capacity, falsified supporting documents, non-compliance with the project obligations, misappropriation of part of the funding and subsequent laundering by one suspect.

This is not a conviction. The names of the defendants have not been released in the notice, and the facts remain allegations to be tested before the French court. The legal importance of the story lies elsewhere: a French grant, European money, a French prosecution, two defendants resident in two other countries and evidence that may be scattered across several banking, digital and administrative systems. This article explains why Paris can be the forum, how EPPO cross-border investigations divide responsibility between national prosecutors, and what a defence team or organisation should do immediately. It also separates criminal liability from grant recovery, because an administrative dispute over deliverables is not automatically proof of criminal fraud.

I. What does the Paris Erasmus+ indictment actually decide?

A. Why does EPPO bring Germany- and Switzerland-based suspects before a French court?

The first point is jurisdiction. EPPO is not a supranational criminal court that replaces national courts. It is an independent prosecution office operating through European Prosecutors and European Delegated Prosecutors in the participating Member States. Its legal basis is Article 86 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, implemented by Council Regulation (EU) 2017/1939 establishing the EPPO. The investigation is European in organisation, but a national court remains responsible for the trial and judgment.

The financial link is equally important. Erasmus+ grants are not merely private sponsorships. The alleged misuse of a grant can affect the financial interests of the European Union, particularly when the grant is financed through the EU budget and administered by a national agency. Article 325 TFEU expresses the constitutional policy in direct terms: “The Union and the Member States shall counter fraud”. The consolidated text of Article 325 TFEU continues by requiring measures that deter fraud and provide effective protection throughout the Union.

The PIF Directive, Directive (EU) 2017/1371, supplies the common criminal-law framework for fraud affecting EU expenditure. Its official summary identifies intentional fraud in expenditure, money laundering, corruption and misappropriation among the offences covered. It also states that the EPPO is responsible for investigating and prosecuting those crimes before the relevant national courts. The directive is not a substitute for the French charging decision. It is the European perimeter that explains why the EPPO may act where the suspected conduct concerns European funds.

France is therefore a logical forum when the grant was awarded by the French Erasmus+ agency, the beneficiary was a French association and the alleged false documents were submitted to that agency. The place where a suspect lives is relevant to evidence, service and appearance, but it does not by itself determine the forum. A person may reside abroad while the alleged offence is committed, in whole or in part, in France. The public release does not disclose every jurisdictional fact, so it would be wrong to infer the precise reasoning used by the handling European Delegated Prosecutor. The safer conclusion is that the Paris office considers the French connection sufficient to bring the case before the Paris Criminal Court.

Germany and Switzerland do not have the same position in this map. Germany participates in the EPPO system. Switzerland is outside the European Union and is not an EPPO participating Member State. That distinction does not make Swiss evidence unreachable, but it changes the legal channel through which investigators may seek it. A request for banking records, a search, an interview or service of a procedural document in Switzerland can require international mutual assistance, a treaty mechanism or another cooperation instrument. None of those steps is automatic merely because the EPPO has filed an indictment in Paris.

Nor does the announcement establish that an arrest warrant exists. Residence in Germany or Switzerland is not equivalent to flight, and an indictment is not itself a European Arrest Warrant. If a defendant does not appear or cannot be served, French authorities may consider further measures under the applicable procedural rules, but those measures require their own legal basis, proportionality assessment and execution route. An international defendant should not confuse a press release, a summons, a warrant and an extradition request. They have different consequences and different remedies.

The substantive classification is also not settled by the headline. The notice describes suspected subsidy fraud and related conduct, but it does not publish the complete French indictment with every legal provision. Depending on the evidence and the precise allegations, French prosecutors may seek to establish fraud under Article 313-1 of the Code pénal, forgery or use of a forged document under Article 441-1, laundering under Article 324-1, or another offence related to the handling of public or European funds. Those are legal routes to examine, not a statement that each one has been charged.

Under Article 313-1, the prosecution must do more than show that an educational project was disappointing. It must establish the use of a false name or quality, abuse of a true quality or fraudulent manoeuvres, followed by deception of a person or legal entity and delivery of funds, property, a service or an act creating an obligation or discharge. In a grant case, that usually makes the application, supporting documents, representations about capacity and payment decision central. A later failure to meet a target may support an inference about an earlier intention, but it cannot automatically replace proof of deception at the time the money was obtained.

The ceiling of seven years’ imprisonment and a €750,000 fine mentioned by EPPO also needs to be read carefully. Article 313-2 of the Code pénal increases the penalties for fraud in specified circumstances, including fraud causing loss to a public person or an organisation charged with a public-service mission in order to obtain an allocation, payment or undue advantage. Whether that provision applies, whether another aggravating circumstance is relied upon, and whether the court ultimately imposes a custodial sentence are separate questions. “Up to” is a statutory maximum, not a forecast of the sentence.

The presence of falsified supporting documents can create a second evidential route. Article 441-1 of the Code pénal defines a false document as a fraudulent alteration of the truth capable of causing prejudice and intended, or capable, of establishing proof of a right or fact with legal consequences. The court will have to identify the document, its author or user, the alteration, the legal purpose and the intention. A spreadsheet containing an error is not automatically a criminal forgery; nor is every inaccurate projection proof that the author knowingly fabricated it.

The alleged subsequent laundering has its own logic. Article 324-1 of the Code pénal addresses the false justification of the origin of assets or income derived from an offence and assistance in placing, concealing or converting the proceeds. The prosecution would need to connect the later financial operation to criminal proceeds and prove the required knowledge or participation. A transfer between accounts may be entirely legitimate, may be a repayment or may be suspicious; the meaning depends on the records, explanations and chronology.

Finally, the French non-profit is not automatically criminally responsible simply because it received the grant. Article 121-2 of the Code pénal provides that legal persons, other than the State, may be criminally liable for offences committed on their behalf by their organs or representatives, while that liability does not exclude the liability of the natural persons involved. The EPPO notice says that the two suspects headed the association; it does not say that the association itself has been indicted. Its administrative exposure, repayment duties and civil position must therefore be distinguished from the personal criminal case.

B. What do the €240,000 allegations and the presumption of innocence mean?

The €240,000 figure is the amount of Erasmus+ funding identified in the EPPO notice. It is not necessarily the final criminal loss, the amount to be repaid or the fine that could be imposed. A grant may contain eligible expenditure, advances, co-financing and a final balance. If part of the project was genuinely performed, the court and the funding authority may have to separate legitimate expenditure from sums obtained or retained through deception. The defence should not accept or contest the headline amount without reconstructing the grant account line by line.

The practical question is not simply “Was the project completed?” It is “What was represented when the funding decision was made, what obligation was accepted, what was actually delivered, and what did each defendant know at each stage?” That chronology matters because three different disputes can exist at once.

First, the granting authority may treat a project as non-compliant and demand repayment under the grant agreement. That is an administrative or contractual response. It may rely on missing deliverables, ineligible costs, inadequate records or failure to satisfy a condition. Its standard of proof and procedure are not identical to a criminal trial.

Second, the prosecution may allege that the grant was obtained through deception. It must identify the representation or manoeuvre that influenced the agency and link it to the payment. A genuine operational failure, a management error or an unexpected collapse of a partner organisation may create serious repayment exposure without proving that the original application was deliberately fraudulent.

Third, the prosecution may allege that funds were diverted after receipt, documents were fabricated or money was later concealed. Those allegations require their own material and mental elements. They should not be collapsed into one undifferentiated narrative simply because the same bank account or association appears in every stage.

The presumption of innocence is therefore operational, not ceremonial. The EPPO release expressly says that all persons concerned are presumed innocent until proven guilty in the competent French courts. The absence of names in the notice also matters. It prevents an international audience from turning an untested allegation into a reputational conclusion about identifiable individuals or an organisation.

French criminal procedure permits the use of a broad range of evidence, but that does not mean that a document wins merely because it came from an investigator. Article 427 of the Code de procédure pénale states that, except where the law provides otherwise, offences may be established by any mode of proof and that the judge decides according to personal conviction. It also requires the decision to rest on evidence brought to the hearing and discussed contradictorily. In the official wording, the evidence must be “contradictoirement discutées devant lui”. The adversarial debate is the safeguard against treating an audit summary, an untranslated email or a bank anomaly as self-proving.

This is where the project’s operational capacity may become decisive. Investigators may ask what staff, premises, partners, teaching materials, travel arrangements, beneficiary records and accounting systems existed when the application was submitted. The defence should identify contemporaneous proof rather than rely on a later assertion that the association intended to perform. Conversely, the prosecution should be required to distinguish a lack of capacity at the outset from capacity that deteriorated after an unforeseen event.

The supporting documents require the same care. A document can be false because its content was fabricated, because a signature was imitated, because a genuine document was altered or because a genuine document was used to create a misleading impression. The legal analysis changes with each possibility. Metadata, version history, email headers, authorisation chains, digital signatures and the original files can be more valuable than a printed copy.

The financial analysis also has to remain concrete. If the association received €240,000, the file should map the amount received, the dates of each payment, the account into which each payment arrived, the expenditure claimed, transfers to related persons or entities, cash withdrawals, repayments and any balance returned to the agency. A suspicious-looking transfer is not a conviction. It becomes meaningful when linked to a false invoice, an unexplained benefit, a personal purchase or an instruction showing knowledge of the alleged scheme.

The grant agreement is the reference point for the civil and administrative analysis. Its annexes may define eligible costs, reporting dates, procurement requirements, staffing commitments, evidence of attendance and the consequences of non-performance. The application may contain representations that never became contractual obligations. The final report may contain estimates that were permissible under the programme rules or statements that were materially false. Lawyers should obtain the complete agreement and amendments before characterising any discrepancy.

Time is another issue. The allegations concern conduct between 2016 and 2019, but Article 8 of the Code de procédure pénale sets a general six-year limitation period for misdemeanours, subject to special rules and the law applicable at the relevant time. The calculation cannot be made from the press-release date alone. Investigators and defence counsel must examine the date of each act, any concealed or continuing conduct, interruption or suspension of limitation and the transitional provisions in force. A limitation argument may be powerful, but only after the procedural record has been reconstructed accurately.

The possibility of a legal-person case also requires separate analysis. If an association were prosecuted and convicted for an offence committed on its behalf by an organ or representative, Article 131-38 of the Code pénal provides that the maximum fine applicable to a legal person is generally five times the fine applicable to a natural person. That rule does not mean that every repayment claim becomes a criminal fine or that the organisation is guilty because its officers are accused. It means the board, members and counsel should identify the association’s procedural status immediately.

The case also illustrates why international reporting should preserve the distinction between allegation, charge, evidence and judgment. A 27 August indictment creates a courtroom dispute; it does not decide the dispute. The legal work now is to test each element, preserve the defence evidence and prevent administrative or media shorthand from determining the criminal narrative before the Paris court has heard both sides.

II. What should cross-border defendants and organisations do next?

A. How are evidence, documents and financial claims tested across borders?

EPPO’s advantage in a case like this is coordination. The organisation can keep a French investigation connected to activity, records and people located elsewhere. But coordination does not erase national safeguards. Article 31 of Regulation (EU) 2017/1939 says: “The European Delegated Prosecutors shall act in close cooperation by assisting and regularly consulting each other in cross-border cases.” Where a measure must be carried out in another participating Member State, the handling European Delegated Prosecutor adopts the necessary measure and assigns it to a Delegated Prosecutor in the State where it will be executed.

That division creates two questions for every foreign measure. What justified and authorised the measure? How was it executed? The Regulation addresses both, and national law remains important for searches, seizures, interviews, bank access and other intrusions. A defence team should therefore ask for the decision initiating the measure, the legal basis, the competent authority, the scope of the request, the date and method of execution, and the record showing what was actually collected.

The Court of Justice clarified the allocation in its Grand Chamber judgment of 21 December 2023, G.K. and Others, Case C-281/22. The Court held that a court in the Member State of the assisting European Delegated Prosecutor reviews the enforcement of the assigned measure, while the justification and adoption of the measure belong to the judicial review in the Member State of the handling prosecutor. Where fundamental rights are seriously interfered with, “the latter matters must be subject to prior judicial review”. The decision is not a licence for unchecked evidence collection; it is a map of where each objection must be raised.

For this Erasmus+ case, a German record and a Swiss record may therefore require different procedural analysis. A German search or hearing request may be connected to the EPPO framework for participating Member States. A Swiss request may follow an international assistance channel outside that framework. The fact that the French file contains a document from abroad does not answer whether it was lawfully collected, whether the request was sufficiently specific, whether privilege was respected, whether the document is authentic or whether the translation is reliable.

The recent French case law on EPPO asset measures is a useful warning. In Cour de cassation, criminal chamber, 8 October 2025, appeal no. 24-84.283, the case concerned a seizure of real property in proceedings involving alleged organised fraud affecting European-funded renovation support. The Court rejected the appeal and examined the relationship between French seizure rules and Article 30 of Regulation 2017/1939. The decision shows that the procedural route matters: a measure ordered by the liberty and custody judge cannot be challenged as though it were an order made directly by the European Delegated Prosecutor, and the scope of the court’s review must be identified precisely.

The defence should preserve the original evidence, not only a translated or exported copy. A practical evidence file should contain the grant application and every version of its annexes; the grant agreement and amendments; the project budget; staff and partner records; deliverables; attendance or beneficiary records; invoices; procurement material; bank statements; accounting ledgers; correspondence with the French agency; correspondence with German or Swiss partners; and a chain-of-custody note for every digital source. If a document is translated, retain the original language, the translation, the translator’s identity and the reason the translation was commissioned.

The file should also contain a single chronology. Each event should record the date, the person acting, the document supporting it, the account affected and the explanation offered. This avoids a common failure in cross-border cases: each country’s counsel prepares a plausible local story, but nobody explains how the stories fit together. The chronology should show when the association applied, when capacity was assessed, when money was received, when activities were performed, when difficulties emerged, when documents were sent and when payments moved.

The same method applies to the alleged laundering. Counsel should map the source account, destination account, beneficial owner, purpose, authorisation, accounting treatment and subsequent use of every transaction that investigators describe as suspicious. If money was transferred to Germany or Switzerland, that fact alone does not establish concealment. It may reflect a partner invoice, repayment, payroll, travel cost or a personal benefit. The correct question is whether the transaction was part of a knowingly false explanation of criminal proceeds.

Investigators and defence counsel should be careful with cloud data. A download from an email account can omit metadata; a screenshot can conceal the surrounding conversation; an exported spreadsheet can lose formulas; a messaging application can display local time rather than the sender’s time zone. The original device or server may be unavailable, but that limitation should be recorded rather than silently filled by an assumption. Experts may be needed to distinguish a genuine file created contemporaneously from a later reconstruction.

Organisations should take their own preservation steps without destroying or altering material. Suspending automatic deletion policies, securing accounting backups, preserving board minutes and appointing a single document custodian are defensible first steps. Employees should be told not to rewrite documents, delete messages or create retrospective explanations. A new explanatory memo can be useful if it is clearly dated and expressly identifies the documents on which it relies; it should never be presented as a contemporaneous record.

There is also a civil dimension. The funding agency, the European Union or another injured entity may seek recovery, while a person or organisation that suffered direct harm may seek compensation. Cour de cassation, criminal chamber, 3 June 2026, appeal no. 25-84.224 held, in a separate fraud case involving an association, that a victim’s direct loss must be assessed through the elements of the offence and that the lower court had not adequately justified refusing compensation. The decision does not decide the Erasmus+ dispute, but it underlines why the injured entity and the amount of direct loss must be identified rather than assumed.

An older but particularly relevant authority is Cour de cassation, criminal chamber, 12 November 2015, appeal no. 14-82.819. It held that using subsidies obtained for a specified project to pay for work devoted to another activity could constitute misappropriation of public funds, and it criticised a decision that had treated audit and investigation findings as mere unverified allegations. The case is not an EPPO judgment and its facts differ, but it demonstrates why the intended purpose of the grant, the actual work and the audit trail must be compared precisely.

B. Which French procedural deadlines, sanctions and remedies matter now?

The immediate procedural task is to determine the exact status of each person. “Indicted before the Paris Criminal Court” may describe a case ready for trial, but the practical consequences depend on the document served, the date and method of service, the charges, the hearing date, the language used and any application for a postponement or appearance by counsel. A person living abroad should obtain the complete French procedural document and a reliable translation, not rely on a news summary.

The first response should identify the next deadline and protect the ability to contest evidence. That usually means instructing French criminal counsel, obtaining access to the file, checking how the summons or indictment was served, and coordinating with German or Swiss counsel where a local measure is pending. The team should avoid contacting witnesses or the funding agency in a way that could be characterised as pressure, coordination of testimony or destruction of evidence. Cooperation with investigators should be deliberate and legally advised, not improvised across several countries.

Service and appearance are particularly sensitive for foreign residents. A missed letter, an unrecognised electronic notification or a translation that does not explain the hearing can produce a practical crisis. It does not follow that every defect cancels the case, and it does not follow that a person can safely ignore a French summons. Counsel should verify the service record, the legal consequences of non-appearance and the available application to appear, postpone or challenge the procedural step. If a warrant or coercive measure is later issued, it must be analysed separately from the indictment and challenged through the route provided by the issuing and executing law.

Asset protection deserves the same priority as attendance. EPPO investigations can involve freezing or seizure of bank balances, real property and other assets where the authorities believe recovery or confiscation could be frustrated. The 24-84.283 decision shows that such measures can become a major part of an EPPO case before the criminal trial. A person whose property is affected should collect title records, loan documents, proof of third-party ownership, source-of-funds records and evidence of ordinary household or business use. A co-owner should not assume that an accusation against another person makes the co-owner’s interest disappear.

The remedy will depend on the measure. A challenge may address lack of jurisdiction, insufficient reasoning, failure to respect the relevant authorisation rule, overbreadth, third-party rights, proportionality or the connection between the asset and the alleged offence. The objection must be made in the correct court and within the applicable period. A general complaint that “the seizure is unfair” is rarely enough; counsel should identify the specific decision, the legal standard and the document proving why the standard is not met.

The criminal limitation issue should be raised with the same discipline. The dates in the EPPO announcement reach back to 2016, but a limitation calculation for fraud, forgery or laundering may involve separate acts and different starting points. Article 8 of the Code de procédure pénale contains the general six-year rule for misdemeanours in the version identified by Légifrance, while special provisions can affect concealed or continuing offences and procedural acts can interrupt or suspend time. The relevant question is not “Why did the case take so long?” but “Which offence, which act, which legal version and which interruption are being relied upon?”

The defence should also test the causal chain behind the €240,000. A useful table distinguishes the requested amount, the amount approved, each instalment, eligible spending, disputed spending, returned funds and alleged personal benefit. It should identify whether the French agency actually relied on the disputed representation and whether the agency’s own controls changed the payment decision. The more the case is based on a failure to perform, the more important it becomes to separate contractual non-compliance from proof of a fraudulent plan formed before payment.

The possible sanctions are broader than imprisonment and a fine. A conviction may lead to confiscation, restitution, damages, professional or management consequences and restrictions affecting future public or European funding, depending on the offences and the parties involved. If a legal person is prosecuted, its own fine and additional penalties must be analysed under the provisions applicable to legal persons. If it is not prosecuted, it may still face repayment, audit, exclusion or governance consequences through the grant framework. A board should therefore take advice on both the criminal file and the organisation’s funding obligations.

The recent EPPO case law also provides a procedural defence principle: do not wait until the Paris trial to discover that the real objection belonged in Germany, Switzerland or before an earlier French judge. The G.K. judgment in Case C-281/22 requires the defence to locate the challenge to the justification and adoption of a measure in the handling Member State when the law so provides, while enforcement issues remain with the assisting State’s court. A cross-border defence calendar should list each measure, issuing authority, executing authority, notification date, deadline and remedy.

The final strategic question is whether to explain the case publicly. Public statements can protect an organisation from a one-sided narrative, but they can also create admissions, expose confidential material, identify witnesses or conflict with the evidence that will be presented in court. The safe approach is usually a short statement preserving the presumption of innocence and declining to comment on evidence before counsel has reviewed the file. No public statement can replace a procedural act, a limitation argument or a challenge to a seizure.

Conclusion

The Paris Erasmus+ case is a live test of how European funds are protected when the grant, the association, the documents and the defendants cross borders. EPPO coordination can bring the case before a French criminal court, but it does not remove the need to prove deception, a causal link to payment, document intent, the origin of funds or the knowledge required for laundering. Nor does an indictment decide whether €240,000 is the criminal loss, the repayable balance or an amount that must be recalculated after a review of genuine performance.

For defendants and organisations, the decisive work is concrete: obtain the complete grant file, preserve originals, build one cross-border chronology, separate administrative non-compliance from criminal allegations, challenge measures in the correct jurisdiction and protect attendance and assets before deadlines expire. The presumption of innocence is meaningful only when the evidence is tested in that disciplined way before the Paris Criminal Court.

📄 Official circular