KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Selling Your French Home as an American: Capital Gains Tax, Notaire Withholding, and the US Credit

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Selling Your French Home as an American: Capital Gains Tax, Notaire Withholding, and the US Credit

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You bought a small apartment in Paris fifteen years ago, or you inherited your parents’ stone house in the Dordogne, and now you are ready to sell. The French buyer signs, the money moves, and then a second number lands on the table: the French capital gains tax on the sale, withheld before you ever see the funds. American sellers are routinely surprised twice, first by the size of the French bill, then by the discovery that the United States taxes the same gain again and leaves them to sort out the overlap. This article walks through the full path in order: how France computes your taxable gain and which rate hits an American seller, the exemptions that can legally reduce the bill to zero, what the closing officer withholds and which papers prove you paid, and how the France-United States tax treaty lets you credit the French tax against your American return.

A few French terms will return throughout, so here they are in plain English. The plus-value immobilière is the capital gain on real estate, meaning the taxable profit on the sale. The notaire is the French public legal officer who closes every real estate sale, computes the gain, files the tax form, and pays the tax out of the sale price before distributing the balance. The prélèvement is the withholding levied on sellers who do not live in France for tax purposes. The résidence principale is the seller’s main home, which carries the most powerful exemption in the system. Keep these four in mind and every official text quoted below will read clearly.

I. How Much French Capital Gains Tax Do You Owe When You Sell Your French Property as an American?

A. How Is Your Taxable Gain Computed, and What Rate Applies to an American Seller?

France taxes the gain, not the price. The starting rule sits in the French Tax Code, the Code général des impôts, whose Article 150 U provides that “lors de la cession à titre onéreux de biens immobiliers bâtis ou non bâtis ou de droits relatifs à ces biens, sont passibles de l’impôt sur le revenu”. In other words, an individual selling a built or unbuilt property in France for payment falls inside the capital gains system, whether the seller lives in Lyon, London, or Los Angeles. The computation itself is short. Article 150 V defines the gross gain as the sale price minus the purchase price by the seller, as explained in the same section of the Tax Code. Sale price minus purchase price gives the gross gain, and the notaire adjusts each side with the documented costs the statute allows before applying ownership-duration relief.

Living in America does not take the sale outside French tax. The Code expressly treats gains on French real estate as French-source income. Article 244 bis A applies to gains “telles que définies aux e bis et e ter du I de l’article 164 B”, the provisions that capture gains on buildings and rights located in France, so a Florida resident selling a Nice apartment realizes French-source income in the eyes of French law, and a dedicated provision aims directly at nonresidents. Article 244 bis A of the same Code aims directly at nonresidents. As restated by the Conseil d’État, it provides: “Sous réserve des conventions internationales, les plus-values, telles que définies aux e bis et e ter de l’article 164 B, réalisées par les personnes et organismes mentionnés au 2 du I lors de la cession des biens ou droits mentionnés au 3 sont soumises à un prélèvement selon le taux fixé au deuxième alinéa du 1 de l’article 219.” That withholding is the mechanism that reaches across the Atlantic: the tax is computed and paid in France at closing, even though the seller files American returns in dollars.

The rate an American individual faces has been litigated all the way to the top of the French administrative courts, and the outcome is now settled. For years, sellers living outside France paid a higher withholding rate than French residents, and nonresident owners challenged the gap. In a decision of June 23, 2022, No. 445785, the Conseil d’État, France’s highest administrative court, described a case in which a Swiss national living in Monaco sold a Nice property in 2012 and was assessed at 33.33 percent, then received during the proceedings a partial rebate “d’un montant égal à la fraction de cet impôt excédant le taux de 19 % applicable aux plus-values immobilières réalisées par les résidents de France, de l’Union européenne et des autres Etats parties à l’accord sur l’Espace économique européen (EEE) ayant conclu avec la France une convention d’assistance administrative en vue de lutter contre la fraude et l’évasion fiscales”. The court upheld the approach that caps the income-tax portion at the resident rate, recalling that “Les plus-values réalisées dans les conditions prévues aux articles 150 U à 150 UC sont imposées au taux forfaitaire de 19 %”, and it closed the case with the words “Le pourvoi de M. B… est rejeté.” The practical lesson for an American seller is straightforward: budget 19 percent income tax on the taxable gain after relief, exactly as a French resident would, because the courts have aligned the two. The withholding framework itself has also survived constitutional review: in Decision No. 2017-668 QPC of October 27, 2017, issued in a dispute over social charges on a nonresident sale, the Constitutional Council declared the nonresident capital-gains provision conforme à la Constitution.

Two more layers sit on top of that 19 percent, and both come from official schedules your notaire applies automatically. The French administration states plainly that the gain, after relief, is taxed at a 19 percent income-tax rate It adds that sellers also pay social charges at 17.2 percent Those social charges apply to nonresident sellers as well: in an October 2023 ruling, the Marseille administrative court of appeal dealt with an Irish-Australian couple living in Australia who had paid both the Article 244 bis A withholding and the social charges on a 2019 sale near Eygalières, and the dispute turned on exemptions, not on whether the charges applied at all. Finally, large gains trigger a surtax: A surtax of 2 to 6 percent applies when the taxable gain exceeds 50,000 euros, on a scale set by the gain amount The surtax scale sits inside the declaration form, and computed on Form 2048-IMM, in practice calculated by the notaire from the table it contains

Ownership duration then reduces the bill on a fixed annual scale, which rewards patient owners. The administration publishes this table: no relief for the first five years, then 6 percent per year off the income-tax base from year 6 through year 21, 4 percent for year 22, and full income-tax exemption beyond that, while the social-charges base falls 1.65 percent per year from year 6 through year 21, 1.6 percent for year 22, 9 percent per year after, with gains on property held over 30 years also exempt from social charges Take a concrete case. You bought in 2015 for 300,000 euros and sell in 2025 for 450,000 euros, a 150,000-euro gross gain held ten full years. The income-tax relief equals five years at 6 percent, or 30 percent, leaving a taxable base of 105,000 euros and income tax of 19,950 euros at 19 percent. The social-charges relief equals five years at 1.65 percent, or 8.25 percent, leaving a base of 137,625 euros and charges of about 23,672 euros at 17.2 percent. The combined French bill is roughly 43,600 euros before any surtax, and because the taxable gain exceeds 50,000 euros, the 2-to-6 percent surtax scale adds a further line your notaire computes on Form 2048-IMM. Hold the same property past 22 years and the income-tax line disappears; hold it past 30 and the social-charges line disappears with it, since the administration confirms income-tax exemption for any property held over 22 years

B. Can You Pay Zero? The Exemptions an American Seller Can Actually Use

The strongest exemption belongs to the seller who actually lived in the property. Article 150 U removes from the system, first among all listed cases, buildings “Qui constituent la résidence principale du cédant au jour de la cession”, meaning property that is the seller’s main home on the day of sale. An American who moved to France, made the French house the genuine family home, and now sells it while still living there can therefore walk away with no gain tax at all. The exemption turns entirely on real life, not on paperwork labels, and a 2021 ruling of the Court of Cassation, France’s highest civil court, shows how strictly the courts police honesty on this point. A seller had the deed state that the sold lots were her main home, the tax office reassessed her on proof the home had not been her main residence at the sale date, and she sued her two notaires for letting the false statement through. The Court recalled that “Il résulte de ce texte que le notaire rédacteur d’acte doit mentionner les coordonnées des parties, conformément aux éléments dont il a connaissance.” Because the file showed the officers knew before closing that the main-home claim was false, the Court held that “En statuant ainsi, alors qu’il résultait de ces constatations que les notaires avaient connaissance avant la vente de la fausseté de l’affirmation selon laquelle le bien constituait à cette date la résidence principale de Mme [V], la cour d’appel a violé le texte susvisé.” The appeal ruling was quashed in these terms: “CASSE ET ANNULE, sauf en ce qu’il rejette la demande en paiement formée par Mme [V]”, quashing the Nancy appeal ruling of October 8, 2019 except for one small payment claim. For an American seller the message cuts both ways. A genuine main home in France is fully exempt, but a French vacation home you visit three weeks a year is not your résidence principale, and asking the notaire to present it as one exposes you to reassessment, not to savings.

A second exemption helps the American who lived in France, left, and sells shortly after departure. The withholding statute itself provides that “Le premier alinéa du présent 1 n’est pas applicable à la cession de l’immeuble qui constituait la résidence principale en France du cédant à la date du transfert de son domicile fiscal hors de France”, provided the destination cooperates with France on tax recovery and is not blacklisted. The same text adds the two hard conditions: “Cette exonération s’applique à la double condition que la cession soit réalisée au plus tard le 31 décembre de l’année suivant celle du transfert par le cédant de son domicile fiscal hors de France et que l’immeuble n’ait pas été mis à la disposition de tiers, à titre gratuit ou onéreux, entre ce transfert et la cession.” Sell by December 31 of the year after you leave, keep the property empty of tenants and free guests in between, and the gain escapes the withholding. Miss either condition and the exemption collapses, as the Australian-based couple learned in Marseille: they claimed a 2018 move, filed no French income return for 2018 after filing for 2017, and produced Australian assessments ending June 2018 rather than June 2019. The court found these elements “ne sont pas suffisantes pour démontrer que les intéressés, qui au demeurant s’abstiennent de préciser la date à laquelle ils ont transféré leur domicile en Australie, auraient effectivement procédé à ce transfert au cours de l’année 2018”, because the sellers, who alone held the proof of their moving date, never pinned it down. An American moving back to Texas or California should therefore keep boarding passes, shipping records, lease contracts, and the exact departure date in a closing file, since the exemption is dated to the day.

Two smaller exemptions complete the picture for ordinary sellers. The administration confirms a de minimis rule and a reinvestment path: small sales escape the tax entirely, and a seller who was not the owner of a main home can reinvest the price into one. The first-sale reinvestment mechanism, technically the 1° bis of Article 150 U, was tested before the Conseil d’État in a February 2020 decision, No. 415475, where Swiss residents invoked it for a Paris sale. The court explained that “cette exonération s’applique lorsque le cédant n’a pas été propriétaire de sa résidence principale, directement ou par personne interposée, au cours des quatre années précédant la cession. Cette exonération est limitée à une seule cession et à la fraction du prix de cession employé, dans un délai de vingt-quatre mois à compter de la cession, à l’acquisition d’une résidence principale.” The Swiss sellers won the principle because their treaty states that “Les gains provenant de l’aliénation des biens immobiliers, tels qu’ils sont définis à l’alinéa 1er du paragraphe 2 de l’article 6, sont imposable dans l’Etat contractant où ces biens sont situés.” together with an equal-treatment clause, so that “un résident suisse ne peut être exclu du bénéfice de l’exonération prévue par le 1° bis du paragraphe II de l’article 150 U du code général des impôts, s’il en remplit les conditions”. American readers should note the limit of that analogy: the Franco-Swiss treaty contains an explicit same-conditions clause for real estate gains, while the France-United States treaty taxes French-situs gains in France without granting that same extension, so an American seller should verify each exemption under French domestic law rather than assume treaty equal treatment. And where the seller is not an individual at all, the computation changes again. In a May 2018 decision, No. 398055, the Conseil d’État dealt with “la société World Investment Corporation, créée en 1986 sous la forme d’une corporation de droit américain dans l’Etat du Delaware, a acquis au cours de cette même année un bien immobilier situé au 32, boulevard Suchet dans le 16ème arrondissement de Paris”, sold it in 2008 with a declared gain above 1.8 million euros, and fought over whether the withholding base followed individual or corporate rules. The court restated the dividing line: “les personnes physiques et morales qui ne sont pas résidentes de France sont soumises au prélèvement qu’elles instituent sur les plus-values résultant de la cession des biens, parts, actions ou droits visés au 3. du I suivant des modalités qui diffèrent selon qu’elles relèveraient, si elles étaient résidentes de France, de l’impôt sur le revenu ou de l’impôt sur les sociétés”. An American holding a French apartment through a Delaware LLC or corporation must therefore identify, before signing anything, which computation track the entity falls into, because the individual abatement scale described above does not automatically apply to entities taxed as companies.

II. How Do You Pay, Get the Money Home, and Avoid Paying Twice?

A. What Does the Notaire Withhold at Closing, and Which Papers Prove You Paid?

The American seller never files the gain computation alone. The administration describes a closed circuit: The notaire handles the tax steps with the administration, computes the taxable gain and the tax, draws up the declaration, and pays the tax to the land registry office of the property In practice the sequence runs itself. Weeks before closing, the notaire collects your purchase deed, proof of the purchase price and costs, the holding period, and your residence history. At the signing appointment, the deed states the computed gain, the tax is taken from the buyer’s funds, the notaire files Form 2048-IMM and pays the Treasury office covering the property, and you receive the net balance plus copies of the filed declaration. Those copies are the most valuable papers in the whole file, because the American tax return you file months later will need them to prove the French tax paid, in euros, on a specific date, for a specific property.

One American-specific formality must be arranged before closing day: the fiscal representative. The administration warns that a nonresident whose gain is taxable must appoint a fiscal representative This representative is an accredited professional established in France who guarantees the tax to the Treasury and signs the declaration alongside the process. The same page lists automatic exemptions, and Americans qualify for two of them: a sale price of 150,000 euros or less, and gains that are fully exempt from both income tax and social charges. The European-nationality exemption does not help a United States citizen, so the working rule is simple. If your sale price exceeds 150,000 euros and your gain is taxable, budget for an accredited representative and appoint that person as soon as the preliminary sale agreement is signed, because the closing cannot proceed without the signature. If the price stays at or under 150,000 euros, or the gain is fully exempt through the main-home or long-holding rules, no representative is needed. Your notaire confirms the position in writing before closing, and that confirmation belongs in your file next to the 2048-IMM.

Money movement deserves the same advance planning as the tax itself. French banks sometimes freeze outgoing wires above informal review thresholds while they verify the origin of funds, and American banks sometimes hold incoming international wires for review, so instruct both banks before closing, keep the signed deed and the 2048-IMM available as source-of-funds proof, and move the proceeds in euros before converting, since conversion at the French end usually costs more than conversion through your American bank. If the property was co-owned, for example with a spouse or siblings after an inheritance, each co-owner is taxed on a separate share and needs a separate proof of payment, because the American return of each owner will claim only that owner’s slice of the French credit. Where an heir sells a recently inherited property, the purchase price in the gain formula is generally the value declared in the French succession, so the succession valuation directly drives the later capital gains bill, and an undervalued succession declaration can resurface as a larger taxable gain at resale.

B. How Do You Report the Sale in the United States and Claim the Treaty Credit?

The France-United States income tax treaty, signed in 1994 and in force since 1996, divides the gain between the two countries instead of letting both tax it in full. Its capital gains article provides that gains from the alienation of real property situated in a treaty state may be taxed in that state, the sentence that decides every French-property sale A Paris apartment or a Provence farmhouse is real property situated in France, so France may tax the gain, and everything described in the first half of this article follows from that single permission. The treaty then defines French-situs interests broadly, covering not only the building itself but also shares in property-rich companies and interests in partnerships, trusts, and estates attributable to French real estate, which means an American selling shares of a French property company or an interest in a French property partnership generally faces the same French taxing right as a direct owner. For everything else, the treaty flips the rule: gains on other property are taxable only in the seller’s state of residence An American seller therefore reads the treaty in two steps, confirming first that the asset is French-situs real property or an interest tied to it, and only then accepting the French bill.

Accepting the French bill does not mean paying twice. The United States taxes its citizens and residents on worldwide income, so the same gain appears on the American return, converted into dollars, usually as a capital gain on the sale of foreign real estate. The treaty then orders relief: the United States allows its citizens and residents a credit against American income tax for the French income tax paid. In practice your American preparer claims that credit on the foreign tax credit form, attaching the French 2048-IMM and the payment proof the notaire gave you, and the French income-tax portion of your bill directly reduces your American tax on the same gain. Three mismatches routinely complicate the claim, and each has a concrete answer. First, the French and American gains are rarely equal: France applies its holding-period abatements while the United States applies its own basis rules, so the credit is limited to the American tax attributable to the gain, and any excess French tax becomes planning material rather than an automatic refund. Second, the credit covers French income tax, while the 17.2 percent social charges sit in a different category under American foreign-tax-credit rules, so your preparer must classify each French line separately instead of crediting the total bill as one number. Third, exchange rates move between the French closing date and the American filing date, so record the rate used for each leg and keep the wire confirmations, because the Internal Revenue Service measures both the gain and the credit in dollars. Handled this way, the treaty does its job: France taxes the French land, America credits the French income tax, and the seller pays the higher of the two systems on the shared base rather than the sum of both.

Conclusion

An American selling French property faces one French computation, one French closing circuit, and one American credit claim, and each stage rewards preparation. Before signing the preliminary agreement, confirm which exemption, if any, covers you: genuine main home, sale shortly after leaving France, long holding, or small price. Give the notaire the full residence history and the exact departure date where relevant, appoint an accredited fiscal representative early whenever the price exceeds 150,000 euros with a taxable gain, and keep the filed 2048-IMM with its payment proof as the key to the American credit. Entity owners should add one step upstream and clarify whether their LLC or corporation follows the individual or the corporate computation track, since the Delaware case shows the answer changes the base. With the French bill computed correctly, withheld once at closing, and credited properly in the United States, the sale closes the French chapter cleanly and leaves no tax trailing behind you across the ocean.

📄 Official circular