KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My American Will Leaves My French House to One Child: Can I Cut Out the Others, Choose U.S. Law, and Avoid Double Tax?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My American Will Leaves My French House to One Child: Can I Cut Out the Others, Choose U.S. Law, and Avoid Double Tax?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You bought a stone house near Sarlat ten years ago, you live in Texas, and your American will leaves everything to your eldest daughter because she is the one who visits, maintains the place, and pays the local property bills. Your two other children expect nothing, and under Texas law that is your right. Then a French notaire (the public officer who alone can settle a French estate) tells you the plan will fail. In France, your children each own a forced minimum share of your estate, your will cannot take it away, and since 2021 even a foreign law chosen in your will may not save the disinherited child arrangement on property located in France. This guide explains, in plain English for an American reader, how the French forced share works, why the old trick of choosing California or Texas law in your will no longer fully protects a French house, and what planning tools still work, including lifetime gifts, the European choice-of-law clause, and the United States-France estate tax treaty that prevents your family from paying full death tax twice.

This article covers settled French succession law as it stands in September 2026. It does not cover French visas or residence permits, which belong to our immigration desk. Every French legal term is explained the first time it appears, and every decisive legal statement is tied to the exact statute or court decision linked below.

I. Why France Forces a Share of Your Estate to Your Children Even When Your American Will Says Otherwise

A. How the French Forced Share Works and How Much Your Children Must Legally Receive

French inheritance law starts from the opposite assumption from American law. In most American states, you can disinherit an adult child with a clear sentence in a valid will. In France, certain heirs, called réservataires (forced heirs), receive a guaranteed minimum that no will and no lifetime gift can take away without consequences. The statute defines the concept this way:

«La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent. La quotité disponible est la part des biens et droits successoraux qui n’est pas réservée par la loi et dont le défunt a pu disposer librement par des libéralités.» (Article 912 of the French Civil Code).

In practice, the estate is divided into two pots. The réserve héréditaire (forced share) goes to the protected heirs no matter what. The quotité disponible (free share) is the only part you can give to whomever you want, including one favored child, a spouse, a charity, or a friend. Your children are the first forced heirs. If you leave no children, your surviving spouse becomes a forced heir for one quarter of the estate (Article 914-1 of the French Civil Code). Parents and siblings are never forced heirs, which surprises many Americans who assume a surviving spouse is always fully protected.

The size of the forced share depends only on how many children survive you or take their place by representation (a predeceased child’s own children stepping into their shoes). The rule is short and strict:

«Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.» (Article 913 of the French Civil Code).

Put simply, with one child you can freely give away only one half of your estate, with two children only one third, and with three or more children only one quarter. Everything else belongs to the children in equal shares. A will that leaves a French house worth 400,000 euros entirely to one of three children gives that child far more than the one-quarter free share, and each of the other two children can sue to claw back the excess.

The claw-back lawsuit is called the action en réduction (action to reduce excessive gifts). Only the forced heirs, their heirs, or their assigns can bring it, and the notaire settling the estate has a statutory duty to warn them: «La réduction des dispositions entre vifs ne pourra être demandée que par ceux au profit desquels la loi fait la réserve, par leurs héritiers ou ayants cause : les donataires, les légataires, ni les créanciers du défunt ne pourront demander cette réduction, ni en profiter.» (Article 921 of the French Civil Code). The same article sets the deadline: five years from the opening of the succession, or two years from the day the heirs learned that their forced share was harmed, never more than ten years after the death. The Court of Cassation, France’s highest civil court, confirmed the nature of that deadline in a published 2024 ruling: «L’action en réduction, que l’article 921, alinéa 1er, du code civil reconnaît à ceux au profit desquels la loi fait la réserve et à leurs héritiers ou ayants cause, présente le caractère d’une action personnelle soumise à la prescription quinquennale prévue à l’article 2224 du même code, quand bien même elle aurait pour effet de résoudre la question de l’existence d’un droit réel sur les biens donnés ou légués.» (Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber, October 23, 2024, No. 22-19.365). For an American family, the message is practical: a disinherited child has years to challenge the distribution, and the claim follows the French house even if the favored child already took possession.

How does the notaire compute whether the free share was exceeded? By building a fictitious total called the masse de calcul. The statute orders the notaire to add back every lifetime gift to the assets owned at death: «La réduction se détermine en formant une masse de tous les biens existant au décès du donateur ou testateur. Les biens dont il a été disposé par donation entre vifs sont fictivement réunis à cette masse, d’après leur état à l’époque de la donation et leur valeur à l’ouverture de la succession, après qu’en ont été déduites les dettes ou les charges les grevant.» (Article 922 of the French Civil Code). Gifts you made fifteen years ago to help one child buy a condo in Austin are therefore pulled back into the math. That is why last-minute American estate planning that ignores lifetime gifts regularly collapses in front of a French notaire.

B. Why the Old California-Law Escape No Longer Works Since the 2021 Makeup Levy

For decades, American owners used a clever bypass. Because the deceased was American and lived in America, the will said California or New York law governed the whole succession, and those laws have no forced share. In two 2017 rulings known in France as the Jarre decisions (Nos. 16-17.198 and 16-13.151, September 27, 2017), the Court of Cassation rejected the claims of children left out when French composer Maurice Jarre died in Los Angeles in 2009 leaving his estate through a California family trust. The Court held that «une loi étrangère désignée par la règle de conflit qui ignore la réserve héréditaire n’est pas en soi contraire à l’ordre public international français et ne peut être écartée que si son application concrète, au cas d’espèce, conduit à une situation incompatible avec les principes du droit français considérés comme essentiels» (a foreign law designated by the conflict rule which ignores the forced share is not in itself contrary to French international public policy and can only be set aside if its concrete application leads to a situation incompatible with the principles of French law considered essential) (Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber, September 27, 2017, No. 16-17.198). The Court stressed that the children did not claim to face economic hardship or need, and that the family had close ties to California. American advisers celebrated, and thousands of wills kept the same clause.

That celebration ended in 2021. After public criticism that the Jarre rulings abandoned French children, Parliament created a safety net called the prélèvement compensatoire (makeup levy). It sits in the second half of Article 913, and it deserves a full quotation because it now decides many American cases:

«Lorsque le défunt ou au moins l’un de ses enfants est, au moment du décès, ressortissant d’un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou y réside habituellement et lorsque la loi étrangère applicable à la succession ne permet aucun mécanisme réservataire protecteur des enfants, chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès, de façon à être rétablis dans les droits réservataires que leur octroie la loi française, dans la limite de ceux-ci.» (Article 913 of the French Civil Code, second paragraph).

Read carefully, because each condition matters for Americans. First, someone in the picture must be European at the death: either the deceased or at least one child must be a citizen of a European Union member state or habitually live in one. A purely American family, with an American deceased living in Florida and American children living in Florida, does not trigger the levy. But the common mixed cases do: your son who studied in Lyon and stayed there, your daughter who married a French citizen, or yourself if you retired to your Dordogne house and became habitually resident in France. Second, the applicable foreign law must give children no forced-share mechanism at all. Texas, California, Florida, and New York meet that test. Third, the claw-back applies only to assets located in France on the day of death: the French house, the French bank account, the Paris apartment. It cannot reach the Texas ranch or the Florida brokerage account.

When those conditions are met, the left-out child can take extra value directly from the French assets to rebuild the French forced share. The favored child still keeps the American assets, but the French house may have to be sold or shared to pay the makeup amount. The Court of Cassation had already drawn the doctrinal line in 2018, holding that «la dévolution successorale desdits immeubles devait tenir compte des règles de la réserve héréditaire, laquelle, d’ordre public interne, ne pouvait être écartée par des dispositions testamentaires établies selon la loi du domicile du défunt et régissant son statut personnel» (the transfer of the French buildings on death had to respect the forced-share rules, which, as domestic public policy, could not be set aside by will provisions made under the law of the deceased’s domicile) (Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber, July 4, 2018, No. 17-16.515). The 2021 statute turned that domestic protection into a cross-border enforcement tool. Practical result: a will that says Texas law governs, my eldest gets everything still works for the Texas assets, but the French house remains exposed whenever one child is European-connected.

Two misunderstandings must be cleared up. The makeup levy is not an extra tax paid to the French state. It is a civil rebalancing between the children, computed by the notaire and enforced through the partition. And it does not punish the favored child: gifts the deceased already made to the complaining child count toward their share, and the levy is capped at the French forced-share amount, never more. Still, for the American parent who wanted one child to keep the French house intact, the levy can force a sale the family never wanted. That is why the planning must move upstream, before death, using the European choice-of-law clause and lifetime gifts described in Part II.

II. How an American Owner Can Still Plan Ahead With a United States Law Clause, Lifetime Gifts, and the Tax Treaty

A. Choosing United States Law in Your Will Under the European Succession Regulation and What It Can and Cannot Do

Since August 17, 2015, one European text governs which country’s inheritance law applies when a succession touches several countries. It is Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 on jurisdiction, applicable law, recognition and enforcement of decisions in matters of succession (search EUR-Lex for Regulation 650/2012 for the official text), and France applies it directly. The default rule in Article 21 points to the law of the country where the deceased habitually lived at death. For an American who retired to France and lived there year-round, that default is French law, with its full forced share, unless the will says otherwise. The escape hatch is Article 22, called professio juris in lawyer Latin: any person may choose, in a will or a separate declaration, the law of a country whose nationality they hold at the time of the choice or at death. An American citizen can therefore validly write: I choose the law of the State of Texas, of which I am a national of the United States, to govern my entire succession. The choice must cover the whole estate, not just the French house, and it must be express. A vague sentence such as I want American law to apply is risky because the United States has fifty state laws; name the state whose law you want, and confirm with a United States estate lawyer that the clause is valid under that state’s own requirements.

A valid choice of Texas or California law changes the analysis in three concrete ways. First, the notaire must apply the chosen American law to the French house for questions of who inherits, in what proportions, and whether a will is valid. That is the whole point of the Regulation: one law for the whole estate, avoiding a split where France applies French law to the house and Texas applies Texas law to everything else. Second, the forced-share action described in Part I disappears as a matter of applicable law, because Texas law has no forced share for adult children. The left-out child cannot bring a French action en réduction against a succession governed by Texas law. Third, and this is the trap many English-language blogs hide, the 2021 makeup levy can still bite on the French assets whenever the European-connection condition is met. The levy is classified by French law as a protective override, not as ordinary succession law, so it operates even when the succession itself is governed by Texas law. Choosing United States law therefore protects the American assets completely and the French assets partially: fully against the classic forced-share claim, but not against the makeup levy if one of your children lives in the European Union or holds a European passport.

So when is the choice-of-law clause worth signing? Almost always, for an American owner, because it costs one sentence and it removes the worst outcome, which is a full French-law succession with all three forced-share claims computed on worldwide assets. But it must be combined with family reality. If all your children live in the United States and hold only United States citizenship, and you keep your habitual residence in the United States, the levy does not trigger and the Texas-law choice shields the French house too. If one child lives in France, assume the levy will apply and plan the French house accordingly: either accept that the child living in France will recover a forced minimum from the French assets, or move value during your lifetime so the French house is no longer the battleground, using the gift tools described next.

Form matters as much as substance. Write the choice-of-law clause in every will you sign, American and French, in identical terms, and tell each drafter about the other will. Contradictory wills are the leading cause of Franco-American estate litigation: a French will silent on applicable law and an American will choosing Texas law invite years of argument about which document revoked the other. Keep both wills consistent, name the same state law, state that each will covers only the assets in its country unless you want a single worldwide will, and have the French will received by a notaire or drafted with a French lawyer so its form survives French scrutiny. Review the clause after every life event: naturalization, a child’s move to France, a marriage, a divorce, or a permanent move to your French house can all switch the default law or activate the levy. A clause that was perfect in 2020 can be half-useless in 2026.

One more boundary: the choice-of-law clause never governs taxes. Even when Texas law decides who gets the house, French tax law alone decides what death tax France charges on it, and American tax law alone decides what the Internal Revenue Service charges. That is why the second half of the planning is fiscal, and why families who win the civil-law battle sometimes lose the money battle by paying tax twice. The tax treaty and the French allowances below close that gap.

B. Paying Tax Once, Not Twice: French Allowances, United States Credit, and the Steps to Take Now

France taxes the French house no matter where you live and no matter which law your will chooses. The territorial rule is set by the French Tax Code: «Sont soumis aux droits de mutation à titre gratuit : 1° Les biens meubles et immeubles situés en France ou hors de France […] lorsque le donateur ou le défunt a son domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article 4 B» and, where the deceased was not fiscally domiciled in France, French-situated property remains taxable (Article 750 ter of the French General Tax Code). In plain terms, if you die domiciled in Texas, France still taxes the Dordogne house because it sits in France. If you die domiciled in France, France taxes the Dordogne house and, in principle, your worldwide assets too, with treaty relief to avoid double taxation. The United States-France estate and gift tax treaty of 1978, as amended, then allocates the primary right to tax and obliges the other country to grant a credit, so the same house is not fully taxed twice. Our desk has already explained how domicile under that treaty is proved when an American family faces a death connected with France (our guide on proving treaty domicile), and the credit mechanism below builds on that analysis.

French death tax between parents and children is far gentler than Americans fear, provided the allowances are used. Each child can receive a tax-free allowance: «il est effectué un abattement de 100 000 € sur la part de chacun des ascendants et sur la part de chacun des enfants vivants ou représentés par suite de prédécès ou de renonciation» (Article 779 of the French General Tax Code). Only the amount above 100,000 euros per child is taxed, at progressive rates from 5 to 45 percent. A French house worth 400,000 euros shared equally among three children gives each child about 133,000 euros, so each child pays French tax only on roughly 33,000 euros, a few thousand euros each. The surviving spouse, meanwhile, is fully exempt from French death tax, a point Americans married to a French or American spouse should weigh when deciding whether to leave the house to the spouse first.

The allowance renews for lifetime gifts on a fifteen-year clock, and this is the most powerful planning tool for the American owner who wants one child to end up with the house. The statute provides that «La perception est effectuée en ajoutant à la valeur des biens compris dans la donation ou la déclaration de succession celle des biens qui ont fait l’objet de donations antérieures, à l’exception de celles passées depuis plus de quinze ans» (Article 784 of the French General Tax Code). A gift of 100,000 euros to each child today uses today’s allowance, and fifteen years later you can give again with a fresh allowance. Better still, gifts reduce the forced-share battlefield: a child who already received substantial lifetime gifts has less to claim through the makeup levy, and a donation-partage (a special French family gift that fixes values among the children once and for all) can freeze the distribution while everyone is alive and consenting. Our desk has detailed how that family gift works for Americans giving a French house to their children (our guide on donating a French house to children). The American side must be checked in parallel: lifetime gifts above the annual exclusion count against the very large United States lifetime exemption, and the estate must claim the treaty credit on IRS Form 706 with proof of the French tax paid, within the treaty deadlines.

Life insurance–style products add a second layer Americans often overlook. A French assurance-vie contract (a savings contract with a designated beneficiary, legally distinct from American life insurance) passes earmarked funds outside the succession under special allowance rules, and it pairs well with a house-centered plan: leave the house to the child who will keep it, and compensate the others with assurance-vie payouts. The mechanics and the United States reporting traps are explained in our dedicated guide (our guide on using assurance-vie as an American). Whatever combination you choose, keep one discipline: every gift, every beneficiary designation, and every will clause must be disclosed to the French notaire settling the estate, because hidden gifts discovered later reopen both the civil computation and the tax return, with interest and penalties.

Concrete next steps, in order. First, sign or update a will in each country with an identical choice-of-law clause naming one United States state, and have the French version reviewed by a French lawyer. Second, ask a notaire for a written forced-share simulation: the fictitious total, each child’s minimum, and the makeup-levy exposure given where each child lives today. Third, if one child is to keep the house, start the fifteen-year gift clock now rather than after a health scare, and consider a donation-partage while all children can sign. Fourth, coordinate the tax filings in advance: French declaration of succession within six months of death (twelve months if the death occurred outside France), United States estate return with treaty credit claim, and proof of payment flow between the two files. Families who complete these four steps rarely litigate; families who skip them meet each other again in front of a judge in Périgueux.

Conclusion

You cannot impose a purely Texan outcome on a French house with a single will sentence, but you are far from powerless. The forced share guarantees each child a minimum measured on a fictitious total that includes your lifetime gifts, the 2021 makeup levy lets a Europe-connected child collect that minimum from your French assets even when your will validly chooses Texas law, and the European Succession Regulation still rewards you for choosing one United States state law expressly and consistently in every will. Use the choice-of-law clause to unify the applicable law, use the fifteen-year gift allowances and, where the family agrees, a donation-partage to shape who actually ends up with the house, and use the United States-France estate tax treaty credit so the house is not taxed twice. The families who succeed are the ones who ask the notaire for the forced-share math while everyone is alive, put the plan in writing on both sides of the Atlantic, and revisit it every time a child moves, marries, or takes a second passport. Do that work now, and your eldest daughter keeps the house she maintains, your other children receive fair value, and no one discovers French succession law for the first time at the reading of the will.

📄 Official circular