KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Durov at Two Years: How France Prosecutes a Platform CEO and What Comes Next

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Durov at Two Years: How France Prosecutes a Platform CEO and What Comes Next

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Two years after French police arrested Pavel Durov on the tarmac at Le Bourget airport, the Telegram founder is free to travel, posting publicly, and still under formal criminal investigation in Paris. On August 24, 2026, Durov himself marked the anniversary: three days in police custody in 2024, an unprecedented decision to treat the head of a major platform as the alleged accomplice of his own users’ crimes, and an investigation that, in his words, is still ongoing. For founders, general counsels, journalists, and anyone facing a French investigation from abroad, the Durov case is no longer just a headline. It is a live masterclass in how French criminal procedure works when it targets the person at the top of a global tech company: garde à vue, mise en examen, contrôle judiciaire, investigating judges, and a slow-burning instruction that can end in a trial or in a dismissal. This article explains, from inside the French system, what has happened so far, what the prosecution must still prove, and what comes next.

The facts below are drawn from the reporting of Agence France-Presse, France 24, Le Monde, and Reuters, and from Durov’s own public statements. The legal analysis cites the French Criminal Code, the Code of Criminal Procedure, and a January 2026 Cour de cassation ruling, each quoted word for word and linked to its official source. No other commentary in this piece should be mistaken for a court filing: the investigation is ongoing, Durov denies the accusations, and only the French courts will decide how it ends.

I. Arrested at Le Bourget, indicted in Paris: how France prosecutes a tech CEO step by step

International coverage often compresses the Durov case into a single word, arrested. French procedure is more precise, and each stage matters, because each stage carries different rights, different judges, and different consequences for the defence. Three distinct phases have already played out: police custody in August 2024, the mise en examen that same week, and two years of judicial supervision under investigating magistrates, with the restrictions gradually loosened. Understanding this sequence is the key to understanding everything that follows.

A. Three days in custody, then mise en examen: the August 2024 sequence

On August 24, 2024, Pavel Durov, who holds French and Russian passports, was detained by French police after landing at Le Bourget airport near Paris. He was held for three days, which Durov later described as the longest period French police can hold someone before charging them. He was then brought before the investigating magistrates. On August 28, 2024, a French judge placed him under formal investigation, the mise en examen, in a probe into organized crime allegedly facilitated through the Telegram messaging application, as Reuters reported at the time. Le Monde confirmed that he was simultaneously prohibited from leaving France.

Two points about this sequence deserve attention from an international reader. First, French police custody, the garde à vue, is not an American-style arrest followed by a quick bail hearing. It is a coercive investigative measure run by the police under the supervision of the prosecutor, during which the suspect is interrogated, confronted with evidence, and given access to a lawyer under strict conditions. Its duration is capped by law and extended only for the most serious criminality, which is why the three-day figure immediately signalled to French lawyers that the case had been classified at the highest level of seriousness from day one.

Second, the mise en examen is not a conviction, not a trial, and not even a decision to send someone to trial. It is the formal decision by which an investigating judge, the juge d’instruction, notifies a person that there is a case to answer. The legal threshold is set by Article 80-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure: “Le juge d’instruction ne peut mettre en examen que les personnes à l’encontre desquelles il existe des indices graves ou concordants rendant vraisemblable qu’elles aient pu participer, comme auteur ou comme complice, à la commission des infractions dont il est saisi.” In plain terms, the judge must identify serious and consistent indications making it plausible that the person took part, as perpetrator or accomplice, in the offences under investigation. That threshold is deliberately lower than proof of guilt. It opens the door to the full arsenal of the judicial investigation, searches, seizures, expert reports, wiretaps, and repeated interrogations, while granting the suspect the complete rights of the defence: access to the file through counsel, the right to request investigative acts, and the right to appeal key decisions to the chambre de l’instruction.

What made the Durov mise en examen unprecedented, as Durov himself stressed on the second anniversary, is the theory behind it. French authorities did not accuse him of personally selling drugs, distributing abuse images, or laundering money. They accused him of complicity in running an online platform that allowed illicit transactions, child sexual abuse images, and other illegal content, in the wording used by Agence France-Presse. His lawyers’ response, delivered after a full day of questioning in July 2025, was that the session had allowed Durov his lawyers said the full-day session had allowed Durov to give further explanations that, in their view, exposed the emptiness of the case against him. The first interrogation, in December 2024, had already set the pattern: Durov denied creating Telegram for illicit use, acknowledged a growing criminal presence on the platform, and pledged to strengthen moderation. That acknowledgement, and the documented improvements in Telegram’s cooperation with French investigators that judicial sources later confirmed to AFP, will likely become central exhibits whenever the investigating judges decide the outcome of the case.

For executives watching from abroad, the practical lesson of August 2024 is stark. French nationality, which Durov holds, offers no shield against a mise en examen on French soil. Landing in France while wanted by an investigating judge exposes any executive, however prominent, to immediate detention. And the mise en examen, once ordered, structures years of procedure: it is the beginning of the case, not its climax.

B. Judicial supervision, travel ban, and the judges who decide: contrôle judiciaire and the liberty judge

After the mise en examen, Durov was not held in pretrial detention. He was placed under contrôle judiciaire, judicial supervision, with two headline obligations: a ban on leaving French territory and a requirement to report regularly to the police. This is the standard French middle path between liberty and detention, and its legal basis is Article 138 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which provides: “Le contrôle judiciaire peut être ordonné par le juge d’instruction ou par le juge des libertés et de la détention si la personne mise en examen encourt une peine d’emprisonnement correctionnel ou une peine plus grave.” The same article lists the obligations a judge may impose, beginning with: “1° Ne pas sortir des limites territoriales déterminées par le juge d’instruction ou le juge des libertés et de la détention”. Reporting duties, bans on meeting certain persons, bans on engaging in certain professional activities, and the surrender of passports complete the menu. Each obligation must be reasoned and proportionate, and each can be challenged before the chambre de l’instruction.

Behind the contrôle judiciaire stands a judge most international readers have never heard of: the juge des libertés et de la détention, the JLD. Created to separate the power to investigate from the power to detain, the JLD is the only judge who can order or extend pretrial detention. Article 137-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure states the rule plainly: “La détention provisoire est ordonnée ou prolongée par le juge des libertés et de la détention.” The investigating judge investigates and requests; the JLD decides on liberty, after an adversarial hearing with the defence. That split is a cornerstone of French procedural fairness, and it applied to Durov at every step: any request to detain him, and any major modification of his supervision, passed or would pass through the JLD’s adversarial filter.

The supervision was then relaxed in stages, and each relaxation tells the outside world something about how the investigating judges assess the case. In early July 2025, the judicial control was eased to allow Durov to reside in the United Arab Emirates for a maximum of two weeks at a time, according to AFP. In November 2025, France lifted the travel restrictions entirely, ending more than a year of mandatory police check-ins, as Le Monde reported. In French practice, such decisions reflect a judicial assessment that the risks the supervision was meant to prevent, flight, pressure on witnesses, renewal of the offence, have diminished, or that the investigation no longer requires the suspect’s constant availability. They are not an acquittal and not a signal about guilt. But they do mean the judges were satisfied that Durov, a billionaire with homes abroad and a private jet, could be trusted to answer future summons. His third round of questioning, a full-day session at the Paris courthouse on July 28, 2025, attended with four lawyers, shows the investigation continuing in parallel with the loosening of its coercive edge.

One further procedural front opened that same day. Durov’s lawyers announced they firmly contest the legality of the indictment and of numerous investigative acts, that they have filed a constitutional challenge in France, and that they have requested a preliminary ruling from the Court of Justice of the European Union. This two-pronged attack, a question prioritaire de constitutionnalité before the French courts and a preliminary reference to Luxembourg, is the classic defence strategy in a case that tests the boundary between national criminal law and European digital regulation. If the defence can persuade a court that the charges as applied to a platform operator conflict with constitutional rights or with EU law, entire counts could collapse before any trial. Those proceedings now run alongside the criminal instruction, and their outcome may shape the case as decisively as the evidence itself.

II. Can France convict a platform founder for his users’ crimes? Complicity versus the host shield

The procedural machinery described above is only the frame. The substance of the case is a single hard question: under what conditions can French criminal law hold the head of a messaging platform responsible for crimes committed by the platform’s users? The prosecution’s answer runs through complicity. The defence’s answer runs through the liability shield that European and French law grant to hosting providers. Both doctrines are codified, both have been recently interpreted by the highest courts, and their collision will decide whether this investigation ends in a courtroom or in a dismissal.

A. Complicity and the underlying offences: what the prosecution must prove

French complicity law is set out in Article 121-7 of the Criminal Code: “Est complice d’un crime ou d’un délit la personne qui sciemment, par aide ou assistance, en a facilité la préparation ou la consommation.” A second paragraph extends complicity to instigation by gift, promise, threat, order, or abuse of authority. Three elements therefore have to be proved against anyone charged as an accomplice: a principal punishable offence actually committed by someone, material assistance that facilitated its preparation or completion, and knowledge, the sciemment, meaning the accomplice knew what the assistance would serve. Applied to a platform CEO, each element becomes a battlefield. The principal offences are not in doubt as abstract categories: drug trafficking, fraud, and the distribution of child sexual abuse material plainly occurred on Telegram, as they have on every large communications network. The fight will be over the second and third elements: did the design and operation of Telegram, and specifically the alleged refusal to cooperate with lawful requests from the authorities, constitute assistance that facilitated those crimes, and did Durov know it and persist anyway?

The underlying offences the Paris prosecutor’s probe covers, as described by AFP, map onto some of the heaviest provisions of the French Criminal Code. The dissemination of child sexual abuse images falls under Article 227-23 of the Criminal Code, which punishes severely: “Le fait, en vue de sa diffusion, de fixer, d’enregistrer ou de transmettre l’image ou la représentation d’un mineur lorsque cette image ou cette représentation présente un caractère pornographique est puni de cinq ans d’emprisonnement et de 75 000 euros d’amende.” Terrorism-related content engages Article 421-2-5 of the Criminal Code: “Le fait de provoquer directement à des actes de terrorisme ou de faire publiquement l’apologie de ces actes est puni de cinq ans d’emprisonnement et de 75 000 € d’amende.” The same article raises the stakes for the online context: “Les peines sont portées à sept ans d’emprisonnement et à 100 000 € d’amende lorsque les faits ont été commis en utilisant un service de communication au public en ligne.” That aggravation for online commission is precisely the kind of provision a prosecutor reaches for when the alleged offender runs the online service itself. Financial flows through the platform bring in Article 324-1 of the Criminal Code on money laundering: “Le blanchiment est le fait de faciliter, par tout moyen, la justification mensongère de l’origine des biens ou des revenus de l’auteur d’un crime ou d’un délit ayant procuré à celui-ci un profit direct ou indirect.” Each of these offences carries heavy correctional or criminal penalties, which is also what justified the full weight of the initial garde à vue and contrôle judiciaire.

For the prosecution, the strongest card is the alleged failure to cooperate with lawful requests. In complicity terms, sustained non-cooperation after formal requisitions from the authorities looks less like passive neutrality and more like knowing facilitation: the operator is told that specific criminal content circulates, has the technical ability to act, and chooses not to. French courts have long accepted that complicity can consist in an omission where a duty to act exists, and the investigating judges will examine, requisition by requisition, what Telegram was asked, what it answered, and what it changed. The documented improvement in Telegram’s cooperation since the August 2024 arrest, confirmed by judicial sources to AFP, cuts both ways: it shows good faith going forward, but a prosecutor may argue it proves the cooperation was always technically possible. Durov’s counter-narrative, that Telegram neither moderated worse than its rivals nor cooperated less, backed by his figures of 23.6 million groups and channels removed this year, including 370,777 linked to child abuse material and 164,099 to terrorist content, is designed to break the knowledge element: a platform removing abuse at industrial scale, he argues, cannot be described as knowingly facilitating it.

For the defence, the deepest difficulty is the personal nature of French criminal responsibility. Complicity requires the accomplice’s own guilty mind. Corporate failures, slow abuse teams, and unanswered emails do not automatically translate into Durov’s personal sciemment. The investigating judges will have to connect decisions, or deliberate non-decisions, to the man himself: what did he personally know, what did he personally order, and when. That is why the repeated interrogations matter more than the headlines. Each round of questioning locks in the suspect’s account, tests it against seized documents and internal communications, and builds the record on which the final decision, trial or dismissal, will rest.

B. The host defence: the liability shield, the active-role test, and European regulation

Against complicity stands the great shield of internet law: the hosting provider regime. Under Article 6 of the French law of June 21, 2004 on confidence in the digital economy, which transposes the EU e-commerce directive, a host that merely stores content provided by users is not liable for that content unless, having gained actual knowledge of its manifest illegality, it fails to act promptly to remove it. The Court of Justice of the European Union has policed the boundary of this regime for two decades, and the French Cour de cassation restated the test in a reported ruling this very year. In its judgment of January 7, 2026, n° 23-22.723, published in the Bulletin and the annual Report (decision of the Cour de cassation, Commercial Chamber, January 7, 2026), the Court recalled the European test in these terms: a provider falls outside the hosting shield when it goes beyond neutral intermediation, that is, when it, “au lieu de se limiter à une fourniture neutre de service au moyen d’un traitement purement technique et automatique des données fournies par ses clients, joue un rôle actif de nature à lui confier une connaissance ou un contrôle de ces données”, citing the CJEU’s Google France, L’Oréal, and YouTube rulings. And the Court added the operational definition: “l’exploitant joue un rôle actif quand il prête une assistance laquelle consiste notamment à optimiser la présentation des offres à la vente en cause ou à promouvoir celles-ci.”

That ruling concerned a marketplace, not a messaging app, and it was a civil and commercial decision, not a criminal one. Its reasoning nonetheless frames the criminal debate perfectly. Telegram’s strongest argument is that it is the archetypal neutral host: user content is stored and transmitted by purely technical and automatic means, without editorial selection, ranking, or promotion of the criminal kind. If the platform merely provides the pipes, the shield applies, and knowledge must be assessed notification by notification, not as a general awareness that criminals use the service. The prosecution’s counter-argument writes itself from the same judgment: features such as public channels, recommendation systems, search tools for illicit marketplaces, and monetization instruments could be characterized as an active role giving the operator knowledge and control of the data. The criminal judges in Paris will not be bound by a commercial chamber ruling, but they will read it, because it is the most recent French high-court statement of where neutrality ends and responsibility begins.

Above the national shield sits the European layer: the Digital Services Act, Regulation (EU) 2022/2065, whose Article 6 preserves the hosting exemption at Union level while imposing graduated due-diligence duties on very large online platforms, including risk assessments, cooperation with trusted flaggers, and transparency on content moderation. The DSA is enforced primarily through administrative channels by the Commission and national coordinators, not through criminal courts, but its existence shapes the criminal case in two ways. First, compliance with DSA duties becomes evidence of good faith that the defence will brandish: a platform meeting its European moderation obligations is hard to paint as a criminal enterprise. Second, the defence’s request for a preliminary ruling from the Court of Justice, announced after the July 2025 questioning, likely targets exactly this articulation: can national criminal complicity law punish conduct that European digital law regulates as a matter of platform diligence? If Luxembourg were to find a conflict, the criminal counts built on moderation failures could unravel. That reference, combined with the constitutional challenge filed in parallel, means the Durov case may produce landmark rulings on the hierarchy between criminal repression and platform regulation before it ever reaches a trial court.

Durov’s broader political claims, that several governments demanded censorship and surveillance he deemed illegal, including requests linked to elections in Romania and Moldova, and that refusal triggered hostile campaigns, belong to the public debate, not to the case file. French investigating judges decide on evidence of specific offences, not on geopolitics. But the claims explain why the case resonates far beyond France: every government weighing how to pressure a platform, and every platform weighing how to resist, is watching Paris to learn where the line is drawn between lawful non-cooperation and criminal complicity.

Conclusion

Two years in, the Durov investigation stands at the classic midpoint of a major French judicial investigation. The coercive phase, custody, indictment, travel ban, has receded. The battle phase, interrogations, constitutional challenge, reference to Luxembourg, moderation data, is in full swing. Three endings are possible. The investigating judges may consider the evidence sufficient and order a trial before the tribunal correctionnel, where complicity and the host shield would be argued in open court. They may find the charges insufficient and issue an ordonnance de non-lieu. The legal standard for that dismissal is set by Article 177 of the Code of Criminal Procedure: “Si le juge d’instruction estime que les faits ne constituent ni crime, ni délit, ni contravention, ou si l’auteur est resté inconnu, ou s’il n’existe pas de charges suffisantes contre la personne mise en examen, il déclare, par une ordonnance, qu’il n’y a lieu à suivre.” Or the case may end in a partial outcome, with some counts dismissed and others sent to trial. Whichever path is chosen, the decision will be reasoned, appealable by the prosecutor, and closely read around the world.

For international observers, three lessons already stand. First, France claims and exercises criminal jurisdiction over global platforms through the person of their leaders as soon as they touch French soil, using complicity rather than direct perpetration. Second, French procedure gives the suspect formidable tools, access to the file, requests for investigative acts, appeals to the chambre de l’instruction, constitutional review, and European references, but it deploys them slowly, over years, under the direction of judges rather than juries. Third, the decisive legal frontier is the meaning of neutrality: the more a platform curates, recommends, and monetizes, the closer its operator moves to the active role that forfeits the host shield, in Paris as in Luxembourg.

Founders and executives who travel internationally should draw the operational conclusion now. Map your exposure before you land: know whether an investigation or warrant exists, understand what a mise en examen and a contrôle judiciaire would mean for your movements, and secure counsel in the jurisdiction of arrival in advance. Platforms should audit, document, and be able to prove their cooperation with lawful requests, because the paper trail of requisitions and responses may one day be read as the evidence of knowledge or of good faith. And anyone already targeted should act early: in the French system, the first interrogation shapes the file, the first appeal frames the litigation, and time, as the Durov case shows, does not stand still. Whether the Paris investigation ends in dismissal or in a historic trial, it has already rewritten the risk calculus for every tech leader who thought criminal law stopped at the company’s front door.

📄 Official circular