KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
I Am an American Selling My French House: How Much Capital Gains Tax France Takes, What the US-France Treaty Saves You, and How to Challenge the Bill

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

I Am an American Selling My French House: How Much Capital Gains Tax France Takes, What the US-France Treaty Saves You, and How to Challenge the Bill

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You bought a house in France years ago — a Paris apartment, a stone farmhouse in the Dordogne, a sea-view villa on the Riviera. Now life has changed and you are selling. The buyer has signed, the notaire (the French public officer who handles every real-estate closing) has prepared the deed, and then comes the surprise: a large slice of your profit never reaches your bank account. France taxes the gain, France withholds the tax at closing, and the United States taxes the same gain again on your federal return. This guide explains, step by step, how the French capital-gains bill on your sale is computed, which exemptions can reduce it to zero, how the notaire collects it before you ever see the money, how the United States-France income tax treaty prevents you from paying twice, and how you fight back when the bill is wrong. Every French term is explained, every key rule is tied to the statute or court decision that created it, and every number comes from an official source.

I. How Much French Tax Will You Owe When You Sell Your French House as an American?

France taxes the profit you make selling French real estate even if you live in Florida, Texas, or California and even if you have not set foot in France for years. French tax residence is defined by Article 4 B of the French Tax Code (Code général des impôts), but for real estate it hardly matters where you live: Article 244 bis A of the Tax Code brings non-residents into the French net, and Article 164 B of the same code covers as French-source income the gains dealt with in Articles 150 U, 150 UB and 150 UC where they relate to buildings located in France or rights over such buildings. In plain English, gains on buildings located in France, or rights over those buildings, count as income from a French source. If your property sits on French soil, France claims the first right to tax the profit. The treaty with the United States confirms that right, and your only shield against double taxation is a tax credit, not an exemption. Understanding the French computation is therefore the foundation of everything that follows.

A. How Is Your Taxable Capital Gain Calculated, and Which Holding-Period Allowances Apply?

The starting point is the gross gain: sale price minus purchase price. The purchase price is not just the number on your old deed. The official English-language guidance of the French administration, published on service-public.fr, explains that you add to the acquisition cost the expenses paid to the seller, the acquisition fees (registration duties and notaire fees) for their proven amount or as a flat 7.5 percent of the purchase price, and qualifying construction, rebuilding, enlargement, or improvement work — for the proven amount, or as a flat 15 percent of the purchase price if you have held the property for more than five years. On a house bought long ago, where invoices are lost, those two flat-rate uplifts (7.5 percent and 15 percent) are often worth tens of thousands of euros, and American sellers routinely leave them unclaimed because nobody told them they exist. The sale price, for its part, is the price actually agreed between the parties. The Conseil d’État (France’s supreme administrative court) said so bluntly in a February 2026 ruling on the non-resident levy: “le prix de cession des biens immobiliers ou des droits portant sur ces biens est le prix réellement convenu entre les parties” — the transfer price is the price genuinely agreed between the parties (CE, 9th-10th chambers combined, 24 February 2026, No. 496482). In that case the tax office had replaced the deed price with a higher market value to inflate the gain, and the court struck the reassessment down, discharging even the accredited representative who had collected the tax. Keep that sentence in mind: if the French tax office ever recalculates your sale price upward without proving that the deed hid the real price, that decision is your shield.

Once the gross gain is set, France applies holding-period allowances (abattements pour durée de détention) that reward patient owners. The mechanism is official and mechanical: service-public.fr explains that the gain is reduced by an allowance that depends on how long you have owned the property. The allowance runs at a different speed for the two layers of the French bill — income tax and social charges (prélèvements sociaux) — and the table below is the heart of your tax planning. From the 6th through the 21st year of ownership, the allowance is 6 percent per year against income tax and 1.65 percent per year against social charges. For the 22nd year, it is 4 percent against income tax and 1.6 percent against social charges. Beyond the 22nd year, the gain is fully exempt from income tax for any property held more than 22 years, while social charges continue at 9 percent per year until full exemption for property held more than 30 years. Concretely, a 100,000 euro gain on a property held ten years loses 30 percent (6 percent times five years from year 6 to year 10) for income-tax purposes, so only 70,000 euros enter the income-tax base, and 8.25 percent (1.65 percent times five) for social charges, leaving 91,750 euros in the social-charges base. On a property held 25 years, income tax is zero and social charges apply to only 45 percent of the gain. Time is literally money in French real-estate taxation, and the date on your old deed determines everything.

The rates applied to those reduced bases are flat and identical for residents and non-residents: 19 percent for income tax on the gain after allowances, and 17.2 percent for social charges. The combined headline rate is therefore 36.2 percent of the taxable base, before allowances. American sellers sometimes assume that, as non-residents outside the French social-security system, they escape the 17.2 percent layer. That assumption is wrong, and it has been tested in court by taxpayers in exactly your position — affiliated to a social-security system outside Europe. In CAA Paris, 5th chamber, 19 May 2020, No. 19PA01723, a seller affiliated to the Hong Kong social-security scheme demanded a refund of about 19,406 euros of social charges paid on 2014 and 2015 Paris sales, arguing — “étant affilié à un régime de sécurité sociale à Hong-Kong pour les années en litige” — that being covered in Hong Kong barred French social charges. The court rejected the claim — “La requête de M. B… est rejetée” — holding that the famous de Ruyter case only protects people covered in the European Union, the European Economic Area, or Switzerland: the European Court’s ruling “dans l’arrêt du 26 février 2015, Ministre de l’économie et des finances contre Gérard de Ruyter, C 623/13”, which shields only persons covered by a social-security scheme of an EU member state, an EEA state, or Switzerland from the French capital-revenue levies. The United States, like Hong Kong, is a third country with no social-security coordination agreement extending the European regulation to its residents, so an American covered by Medicare or a US employer plan pays the 17.2 percent just like the Hong Kong seller did. Budget for the full 36.2 percent before allowances; any refund theory based on your American coverage will fail on this case law.

One more layer hits large gains: the surtax on real-estate gains above 50,000 euros, created by Article 1609 nonies G of the Tax Code. The statute provides: “La taxe est due à raison des plus-values imposables d’un montant supérieur à 50 000 €” — the tax applies to taxable gains over 50,000 euros — on a sliding scale from 2 percent to 6 percent of the full taxable gain, and it expressly covers gains taxed under Article 244 bis A, meaning non-residents pay it too. On a 200,000 euro taxable gain the surtax adds roughly 8,000 euros. It is computed on the gain after holding-period allowances, so the allowances pull double duty, and it does not apply to building land. When your notaire quotes the closing costs, verify that this surtax line is present when it should be — and absent when your taxable gain stays at or under 50,000 euros.

B. Which Exemptions Can Wipe Out the French Bill Entirely?

Three exemptions matter for American sellers, and each has traps that the courts have mapped precisely. The first and most powerful is the main-home (résidence principale) exemption of Article 150 U of the Tax Code: “Les dispositions du I ne s’appliquent pas aux immeubles, aux parties d’immeubles ou aux droits relatifs à ces biens : 1° Qui constituent la résidence principale du cédant au jour de la cession” — the gain is simply not taxable when the building is the seller’s main home on the sale date. If you lived in the French house as your everyday home until the sale, you owe nothing: no 19 percent, no 17.2 percent, no surtax. The litigation zone is the American who moved out before selling — back to the United States, or into another French home — and left the old apartment empty while waiting for a buyer. The Versailles administrative court of appeal confirmed the governing test in CAA Versailles, 1st chamber, 2 July 2024, No. 22VE02161: “un immeuble ne perd pas sa qualité de résidence principale du cédant au jour de la cession du seul fait que celui-ci a libéré les lieux avant ce jour, à condition que le délai pendant lequel l’immeuble est demeuré inoccupé puisse être regardé comme normal” — a building does not lose its main-home status merely because the seller vacated before closing, provided the vacancy period looks normal. Normal means you did everything needed to sell fast, given the reason for the move, the property’s features, and the local market. In that case the seller left a 250-square-meter prestige apartment in Paris’s 17th arrondissement empty for seventeen months, produced patchy agency mandates — one never countersigned, one expired and unrenewed — and showed only two viewings in a year. The court held that seventeen empty months “excède le délai d’une année constituant, en principe, le délai maximal dans un contexte économique normal, en vertu d’une tolérance de l’administration fiscale” — beyond the one-year period that the administration tolerates as the normal maximum — and taxed the 2017 sale. The lesson for an American seller is operational: move out, then sign a real mandate with a serious agency immediately, keep proof of every listing, price cut, and viewing, and close within a year. A departure for the United States does not kill the exemption; a sleepy eighteen-month marketing effort does.

The second exemption is pure arithmetic: hold 22 years and income tax disappears; hold 30 years and social charges disappear too. These clock-based exemptions apply to non-residents exactly as to residents, because Article 244 bis A computes the non-resident gain using the same rulebook — Articles 150 V and following — as residents. If your deed is from 2001 and you sell in 2026, the 19 percent is gone and only a sliver of social charges remains. Many Americans who bought in the early 2000s discover at closing that their bill is a fraction of what they feared, purely because of the calendar. Ask your notaire for the allowance computation in writing before signing anything; errors in counting the years are common and always expensive.

The third exemption is the narrowest and the most misunderstood: the one-time exemption for the first sale of a dwelling other than the main home, under item 1 bis of Article 150 U, II — available only if you never owned your main home in the four years before the sale, limited to a single sale, and only for the part of the price reinvested in a main home within 24 months. Here the statute discriminates on its face: Article 244 bis A refers non-residents only to items 2 through 9 of Article 150 U, II, which the Conseil d’État spelled out in CE, 9th-10th chambers combined, 12 February 2020, No. 415475: “Le renvoi, par le 1° du paragraphe II de l’article 244 bis A du même code, aux seuls 2° à 9° du paragraphe II de cet article 150 U a pour effet d’exclure les personnes physiques non fiscalement domiciliées en France lors de la cession de leur bien immobilier du bénéfice de l’exonération prévue en faveur de la première cession d’un logement autre que la résidence principale.” Non-residents are shut out of the first-sale exemption by domestic law. But — and this is the point that makes the decision worth reading for an American — a tax treaty can override the shut-out. The Swiss sellers in that case won the principle that equal-treatment language in a treaty forces France to extend the exemption to qualifying non-residents: the treaty’s promise that “Les gains provenant de l’aliénation des biens mentionnés aux paragraphes 1, 2 et 3, tels qu’ils sont retenus pour l’assiette de l’impôt sur les plus-values, sont calculés dans les mêmes conditions, que le bénéficiaire soit résident de l’un ou de l’autre Etat contractant” means computation under identical conditions regardless of residence, so “un résident suisse ne peut être exclu du bénéfice de l’exonération prévue par le 1° bis du paragraphe II de l’article 150 U du code général des impôts, s’il en remplit les conditions.” The court annulled the appeal ruling — “L’arrêt de la cour administrative d’appel de Versailles du 12 octobre 2017 est annulé” — for failing to check whether the sellers met the exemption’s conditions. For an American, the consequence is double-edged and must be stated honestly: the United States-France treaty contains no Swiss-style identical-conditions clause for capital gains, so you cannot import this victory automatically — your treaty’s Article 13 gives France the right to tax and Article 24 gives you a credit, nothing more — but the decision proves that whenever a treaty does promise equal treatment, the exclusion falls. Never let the tax office reject an exemption on the grounds that non-residents are excluded without checking your treaty’s exact wording; that is precisely the error the Conseil d’État punished here.

II. How Do You Pay the French Tax at Closing, Report the Sale in America, and Challenge a Wrong Bill?

Knowing the tax is half the battle; the other half is procedure. France collects before you leave the closing table, America taxes you again the following April, the treaty reconciles the two, and a formal objection path exists when the numbers are wrong. Each stage has its own actor, its own deadline logic, and its own case law — and mistakes at any stage cost real money.

A. Who Withholds the French Tax at Closing, and How Does the US-France Treaty Stop Double Taxation?

France does not trust a departing seller to file and pay later. Article 244 bis A states the collection rule: the tax is paid when the deed is registered, or within a month of the sale if there is no registration, under the responsibility of a representative appointed under the same rules as for turnover taxes. The supreme administrative court still applies this collection rule in its recent decisions. In practice your notaire computes the 19 percent, the 17.2 percent, and any surtax, withholds them from the sale proceeds, and wires them to the tax office with the deed. For sellers from outside the European Economic Area — which includes Americans — a second actor appears: the accredited representative (représentant accrédité), a professional approved by the administration who guarantees the payment and signs the capital-gains return. The administration’s official doctrine on this role is published in the BOI-RFPI-PVINR-30-20 (appointment of an accredited representative), updated in January 2025, and your notaire will designate one and charge you the fee, typically a few hundred to a few thousand euros depending on the price. The same article makes the levy subject to international treaties and provides that the levy discharges the French income tax due on the amounts that bore it. Two practical consequences follow. First, the 19-percent rate is the same levy residents face through Article 200 B, and third-country sellers cannot demand better: in CE, 9th chamber, 23 June 2022, No. 445785, a Swiss seller taxed at 33⅓ percent obtained a reduction to 19 percent mid-trial but demanded total discharge under European free movement of capital; the court applied its comparison test — “Lorsqu’un contribuable non-résident conteste, au regard de la libre circulation des capitaux, l’imposition à laquelle il a été assujetti sur ses revenus de source française, il convient de comparer la charge fiscale supportée respectivement par ce contribuable et un contribuable résident de France placé dans une situation comparable” — found that European law only blocked a levy above the 19 percent resident rate — “faisait seulement obstacle à un prélèvement excédant le taux de 19 %” — and dismissed the appeal: “Le pourvoi de M. B… est rejeté.” An American taxed at 19 percent is treated exactly like a French resident; there is no treaty or European-law path to a lower French rate. Second, because the notaire withholds on figures you supply, the computation inputs are your last control point: verify the uplifted cost base, the allowance years, and the deed price before the funds move, because recovering over-withheld tax takes years while the buyer is long gone.

Then comes the American side, and here the news is structural: the United States taxes its citizens on worldwide income, so the French-house gain is reportable on your federal return in the year of sale, converted to dollars, with your own cost-base rules. Relief comes from the Convention between the United States and France for the avoidance of double taxation (IRS treaty text), whose Article 13, paragraph 1, on capital gains allocates the primary right to France by providing that gains from the alienation of real property situated in a contracting state may be taxed in that state. France may tax; so may the United States as your residence and citizenship state. The treaty resolves the overlap through its Article 24 on relief from double taxation, under which the United States allows its citizens and residents a credit against United States income tax for the French income tax paid by or on their behalf. You claim that credit on your US return — generally on Form 1116 for the passive or general category as your preparer determines — attaching proof of the French payment (the notaire‘s statement and the French assessment). Three warnings that American sellers learn too late: the credit covers French income tax but generally not the French social charges, which the IRS treats as a social-security levy rather than an income tax, so the 17.2 percent is usually a dead cost against your US bill; the credit cannot exceed the US tax attributable to the same gain, so timing the sale in a low-US-income year can strand part of the credit; and currency swings between the French closing and the US filing change the dollar value of both gain and credit. Coordinate the French closing statement with a US preparer who handles cross-border sales before you sign — once the deed is registered, the French numbers are frozen and your US planning window narrows to residence, timing, and documentation. Readers who bought through a French property company should also review our guide on buying through an SCI and its tax consequences, because selling shares rather than stone changes both the French levy and the treaty analysis, and landlords should compare with the rental-income rules in our guide on renting out a French apartment.

B. How Do You Challenge an Excessive French Assessment and Get Your Money Back?

Over-taxation of American sellers follows recurring patterns: the allowance years miscounted, the 7.5 percent acquisition uplift or 15 percent works uplift forgotten, the main-home exemption denied after a normal marketing delay, the deed price replaced by a higher market value, or social charges applied where an exemption applied. Every one of these has a remedy, and the decisions above map the route. The first step is always a written claim (réclamation) to the French tax office, followed — if rejected expressly or by silence — by an appeal to the administrative court (tribunal administratif), then to the administrative court of appeal, and finally to the Conseil d’État. The Swiss couple in the 2020 decision walked exactly that path: “Par voie de réclamation adressée à l’administration fiscale, ils ont demandé à être déchargés de cette imposition en invoquant le bénéfice de l’exonération prévue au 1° bis du II de l’article 150 U du” (CE 12 February 2020, No. 415475), then seized the Montreuil court, won a partial victory, and rode the dispute to the supreme court. The Hong Kong seller went from the Paris tax office to the Paris administrative court (judgment of 26 March 2019) to the Versailles of Paris appeal court. File the claim as soon as the error surfaces — French tax claims expire on strict deadlines and a late claim dies without examination — and attach the deed, the cost-base evidence, the allowance computation, and proof of payment. Keep every document in French or with a certified translation; the tax office will not chase your American records for you.

At each stage, the case law above supplies the winning arguments. Deed price inflated by the tax office: cite the February 2026 ruling that “l’administration fiscale ne pouvait légalement substituer au prix de cession qui figurait dans l’acte authentique du 19 janvier 2011 un montant représentatif de la valeur vénale de l’ensemble immobilier cédé par la société Provim, dès lors qu’elle n’établissait pas que le prix de cession stipulé était inférieur au prix réellement convenu entre les parties à la vente” (CE 24 February 2026, No. 496482) — the office could not lawfully swap the deed price for market value without proving the deed hid the real price — and note that the accredited representative was discharged with the taxpayer: “la société SARF Azur est fondée à soutenir que c’est à tort que, par jugement du 22 février 2024, le tribunal administratif de Nice a rejeté sa demande” (CE 24 February 2026, No. 496482). Main-home exemption denied after you moved back to the United States: invoke the Versailles test that vacancy alone does not kill the exemption, and arrive with your signed agency mandate, listing history, price reductions, and viewing log to prove the delay was normal and your marketing diligent — the Paris seller lost precisely because his mandates were unsigned, expired, or produced two visits in a year. Rate challenged as discriminatory: know before spending fees that the 2022 ruling caps the European-law argument at 19 percent — beyond that, with no error of law in that reasoning — so an American already at 19 percent should attack computation and exemptions, not the rate. Social charges challenged on Medicare or US-employer coverage: the Paris 2020 decision closes that door for third-country affiliates, so redirect the effort toward exemptions that erase the base itself. Treaty-based exemption denied: deploy the 2020 equal-treatment reasoning and force the administration to answer on your treaty’s actual wording rather than slogans about non-residents. And throughout, remember that partial victories mid-trial are normal — the Swiss seller in 2022 received a reduction to 19 percent “en cours d’instance,” during the proceedings — so claim the full discharge, accept interim relief, and keep the appeal alive for the remainder. If the property you are selling was inherited rather than bought, the cost base and filing logic differ significantly — see our guide on inheriting a French house and the estate-tax treaty — and if you are selling to buy again, our step-by-step buying guide explains the closing mechanics from the other side of the table.

Conclusion

Selling your French house as an American means paying France first and America second, with the treaty credit bridging the two. France taxes the gain at 19 percent plus 17.2 percent social charges on a base reduced by holding-period allowances — 6 percent yearly against income tax from year 6 to year 21, full income-tax exemption beyond year 22, full social-charges exemption beyond year 30 — plus a 2-to-6 percent surtax above 50,000 euros, all withheld by the notaire at closing under Article 244 bis A with an accredited representative when you live outside Europe. The main-home exemption, the clock-based exemptions, and treaty equal-treatment language can erase the bill, but each has conditions the courts enforce strictly: market your former home diligently and sell within about a year of moving out, count your allowance years exactly, claim your cost-base uplifts, and never accept a deed-price substitution the tax office cannot prove. On the American side, report the sale, claim the Article 24 treaty credit for the French income tax with your notaire‘s proof of payment, and assume the French social charges stay a final cost. When the French bill is wrong, object in writing fast, climb the claim-to-court ladder the Swiss, Hong Kong, and French sellers climbed before you, and argue from the decisions in this guide rather than from general principles. A French sale rewards the prepared seller twice — once in tax saved, once in sleep kept.

📄 Official circular