You built a life in France, you paid French tax for years, and now you are moving back to the United States. Then your accountant tells you that France wants to tax gains you have not even made yet. That is the exit tax, and for Americans leaving France after a long stay it is one of the most expensive surprises in French tax law. France treats your departure as if you had sold your shares, securities, and certain claims the day before you left, and it taxes those paper gains even though no cash has changed hands.
This article explains, for an American reader with no French tax background, when that bill hits you, why the France-United States tax treaty will not stop it at the border, how you can suspend payment while you keep your shares, how the bill can shrink or disappear entirely after two or five years, and how French courts review these cases. Every French term is explained the first time it appears, and every decisive rule is quoted from the statute, the official tax administration guidance, or a court decision you can check yourself.
I. Do You Owe France an Exit Tax When You Move Back to the United States?
A. The six-of-ten-years rule and the 800,000-euro or 50-percent triggers
The exit tax lives in article 167 bis of the French General Tax Code (Code général des impôts), often shortened to CGI. It does not hit every departing American. It hits you only if you were a French tax resident during at least six of the ten years before you moved out. The statute says, word for word: « Les contribuables fiscalement domiciliés en France pendant au moins six des dix années précédant le transfert de leur domicile fiscal hors de France sont imposables lors de ce transfert au titre des plus-values latentes constatées sur les droits sociaux, valeurs, titres ou droits » held by the members of their tax household on the transfer date. A plus-value latente is an unrealized gain, the difference between what your shares are worth today and what you paid for them. A foyer fiscal is your French tax household, generally you, your spouse, and dependent children filing together.
Even with six years of French residence, a second trigger must fire. Either your household’s rights in one company represent at least 50 percent of that company’s distributed profits (bénéfices sociaux), or the total value of all your shares, securities, and rights covered by the provision exceeds 800,000 euros on moving day. The official individual-tax guidance on impots.gouv.fr applies the same two triggers: six years of French residence out of the last ten, plus either 800,000 euros of holdings or a 50-percent stake. So an American executive who spent eight years in Paris holding 200,000 euros of listed stock is outside the tax. An American founder who spent seven years in Lyon holding 60 percent of a startup now valued at 3 million euros is squarely inside it, even if she never sells a single share.
What counts is broad: shares and stock (droits sociaux, valeurs mobilières falling under article 150-0 A of the CGI), mutual-fund units, stock options that have become securities, and certain claims (créances), such as a shareholder current-account advance whose repayment value exceeds what you put in. Exchange transactions done under the tax-deferral regime of article 150-0 B keep their original acquisition price, so a pre-departure merger does not reset your gain to zero. The statute, article 167 bis of the CGI, is explicit: « Lorsque les droits sociaux, valeurs, titres ou droits mentionnés au premier alinéa du 1 du présent I ont été reçus lors d’une opération d’échange bénéficiant du sursis d’imposition prévu à l’article 150-0 B avant le transfert de domicile fiscal du contribuable, la plus-value constatée est calculée à partir du prix ou de la valeur d’acquisition des titres remis à l’échange » If you swapped shares in a tax-free exchange before leaving, France still measures your paper gain from the old price.
Take a concrete example. You bought 40 percent of a French SAS for 100,000 euros in 2018, you were French-resident from 2018 through 2025, and you move to Austin in 2026 when the stake is worth 900,000 euros. You meet the six-of-ten test, you clear the 800,000-euro bar, and France records an 800,000-euro latent gain in your name on departure day. No buyer, no cash, but a real tax computation, which brings us to the question every American asks next: does the treaty with the United States not forbid this?
B. Why the France-United States tax treaty will not stop the bill at the border
The short answer is timing. France taxes the latent gain the day before you stop being a French tax resident, while you are still fully inside French tax law. A tax treaty divides taxing rights between two countries for people caught between them, but it has nothing to divide when only France is taxing you as its own resident. The Paris administrative court of appeal said exactly that in a 2026 exit-tax case, CAA Paris, 2nd chamber, 4 February 2026, no. 24PA03156: « les plus-values en litige ont été imposées lors du transfert du domicile fiscal de M. A… au Luxembourg, réputé intervenu le jour précédant celui à compter duquel il a cessé d’être soumis en France à une obligation fiscale sur l’ensemble de ses revenus en vertu des dispositions précitées du III de l’article 167 bis du code général des impôts, il n’entrait pas, à la date de cette imposition, dans le champ de la convention franco-luxembourgeoise, dont il n’est, par suite, pas fondé à se prévaloir pour faire obstacle à l’imposition en France. » The destination there was Luxembourg, but the mechanism is identical for a move to Texas or California: the tax crystallizes while you are still France’s taxpayer, so the treaty cannot be brandished to cancel it.
The same court added a broader warning in CAA Paris, 4 February 2026, no. 24PA03156 that American leavers should memorize. When a sum can be taxed in France under domestic law, the tax judge must apply a treaty instead if the treaty reserves that tax for the other country, but « un moyen tiré de la méconnaissance de ces stipulations par des dispositions législatives de portée générale ne saurait être utilement invoqué à l’appui d’un recours contentieux tendant à la décharge d’impositions. » In plain English: you cannot ask a French court to erase your exit-tax bill merely by arguing that a general French statute sits uneasily with a treaty. You must point to a treaty clause that gives the exclusive right to tax that exact gain to the other country at the exact moment France taxes it. For latent gains taxed on departure day, that clause does not exist in the France-United States convention of 31 August 1994, published by Decree no. 96-222 of 15 March 1996. The taxpayer in the Paris case lost on every count: « La requête de M. A… est rejetée. »
There is a second reason Americans should not count on treaty rescue. The United States taxes its citizens on worldwide income wherever they live, so Washington was going to tax your real gain on a later sale anyway. What the treaty and American domestic law give you instead is a credit mechanism. The federal foreign tax credit, claimed on Form 1116, is available only for foreign taxes imposed on the taxpayer, and generally only for foreign income, war-profits, and excess-profits taxes. In practice this means the French exit tax you actually pay can, within American limits and timing rules, offset the American tax on the same economic gain when you finally sell. It is a credit against double taxation after the fact, not a shield that prevents the French bill. Coordinate the two calendars early: France taxes the paper gain at departure, America taxes the real gain at sale, and the credit only works if you keep proof of what France assessed, when you paid it, and on which shares.
One more American trap hides in the household rule. Because the 800,000-euro test aggregates the whole foyer fiscal, an American couple in France can cross the threshold on combined holdings even when neither spouse would cross it alone. Conversely, shares held through a foreign trust or an American LLC do not vanish from the computation; France looks at direct and indirect holdings, and judges have applied the tax to shares in a Cyprus company held by departing French residents, as the Versailles court did in CAA Versailles, 1st chamber, 1 March 2022, no. 20VE01104, where the administration taxed latent gains and a deferred gain on shares in Jamesmon Ltd, a company established in Cyprus. Structure does not erase substance.
II. How You Suspend, Shrink, or Erase the Bill
A. Automatic or on-request suspension, guarantees, and the 2074 paper trail
Being inside the exit tax is not the same as having to wire money before boarding your flight. French law offers a sursis de paiement, a formal suspension of payment, and for most Americans moving home it is the single most important procedure in the file. There are two doors. The first is automatic suspension (sursis de droit). The statute, article 167 bis, provides: « Il est sursis au paiement de l’impôt afférent aux plus-values et créances constatées dans les conditions prévues au I du présent article et aux plus-values imposables en application du II, lorsque le contribuable transfère son domicile fiscal hors de France dans un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou dans un autre Etat ou territoire ayant conclu avec la France une convention d’assistance administrative en vue de lutter contre la fraude et l’évasion fiscales ainsi qu’une convention d’assistance mutuelle en matière de recouvrement ayant une portée similaire à celle prévue par la directive 2010/24/UE du Conseil du 16 mars 2010 concernant l’assistance mutuelle en matière de recouvrement des créances relatives aux taxes, impôts, droits et autres mesures, et qui n’est pas un Etat ou territoire non coopératif au sens de l’article 238-0 A. » Automatic, in other words, is reserved for European Union destinations and for states that have signed both an anti-fraud assistance convention and a recovery-assistance convention with France, and that are not on France’s blacklist of non-cooperative states.
Whether the United States satisfies both assistance limbs on your exact departure date is a file-by-file verification, not a slogan. The United States is not a blacklisted non-cooperative state, and deep assistance frameworks exist between the two countries, but the double-convention test of article 167 bis, IV, must be checked against the current published lists before you claim the automatic route. In case of doubt, use the second door rather than gamble: suspension on express request (sursis sur option). Since a 2019 reform (article 112 of Law no. 2018-1317 of 28 December 2018), the tax administration confirms that on-request suspension now concerns only moves to non-cooperative states or to non-EU states that have signed neither assistance convention with France. Either way, an American leaver gets a suspension path; the only question is which paperwork it requires.
The on-request path has three strict conditions, and the clock is brutal. Under article 167 bis, you must file an express request, appoint a tax representative established in France who is authorized to receive all correspondence about assessment, collection, and disputes, and post guarantees with the public accountant before you leave that are capable of securing the Treasury’s claim. The statute says: « le sursis de paiement est subordonné à la condition que le contribuable déclare le montant des plus-values et créances constatées dans les conditions du I ou imposables en application du II, désigne un représentant établi en France autorisé à recevoir les communications relatives à l’assiette, au recouvrement et au contentieux de l’impôt et constitue auprès du comptable public compétent, préalablement à son départ, des garanties propres à assurer le recouvrement de la créance du Trésor. » The guarantee amount is fixed by law: « Le montant des garanties que le contribuable est tenu de constituer préalablement à son transfert de domicile fiscal hors de France pour bénéficier du sursis de paiement prévu au présent V est égal à 12,8 % du montant total des plus-values et créances mentionnées aux I et II, retenues pour leur montant brut » On our earlier example of an 800,000-euro latent gain, that means posting 102,400 euros of guarantees, typically a bank guarantee (caution bancaire) or a pledge of securities, before departure. And the request deadline is merciless: for moves on or after 22 November 2019, the administration requires filing at least 90 days before the transfer, through form 2074-ETD with the guarantee proposal attached.
Suspension is not forgiveness; it is a monitored sleep, and the monitoring runs through numbered forms every year. In the year after departure you file form 2074-ETD, the departure return. Each following year while suspension lasts, you file form 2074-ETS, the annual tracking return, and if nothing happened to your shares during the year you may use the light-touch version, form 2074-ETSL. The administration describes form 2074-ETS as the yearly tracking return for the years after departure while suspension lasts, with light-touch form 2074-ETSL when no terminating or relief event occurred during the year. You must also carry the total suspended amount onto box 8TN of schedule 2042C. Full details of the light-touch return are on service-public.fr, Déclaration Exit tax (suivi allégé). Miss a filing and article 167 bis bites immediately: « Le défaut de production de la déclaration et du formulaire mentionnés aux 1 et 2 ainsi qu’au dernier alinéa du 3 du présent IX ou l’omission de tout ou partie des renseignements qui doivent y figurer entraîne l’exigibilité immédiate de l’impôt en sursis de paiement. » One forgotten form can wake the entire suspended bill.
Suspension ends when real life catches up with the paper gain. A sale for consideration (cession à titre onéreux), a buyback-cancellation, a liquidation, a gift, or the taxpayer’s death each terminate suspension for the shares concerned, and the final tax is recomputed on the real outcome, as explained below. Gifts get special treatment: if you give the shares while domiciled in a state covered by the automatic-suspension rule, the related tax is relieved, but a gift from anywhere else is relieved only if you prove its main purpose was not to dodge the exit-tax bill. Death ends the story for income tax in most cases, with the related tax relieved. Your competent office after departure is the direction des impôts des non-résidents (DINR), the nonresidents tax office; fittingly, the Paris appeal court ordered in CAA Paris, 4 February 2026, no. 24PA03156 that a copy of its exit-tax judgment be sent there: « Copie en sera adressée à la direction des impôts des non-résidents. » That is the office your representative will deal with, in French, for years.
B. The two-or-five-year eraser, the social-levy trap, and how judges review challenges
Here is the good news that makes suspension worth the paperwork. If you simply keep your shares, the income-tax portion of the exit bill is erased by law after a waiting period. Since the 2019 reform shortened the old fifteen-year clock, the statute, article 167 bis, now provides: « A l’expiration d’un délai de deux ans suivant le transfert de domicile fiscal hors de France ou lorsque le contribuable transfère de nouveau son domicile fiscal en France si cet événement est antérieur, l’impôt calculé dans les conditions du II bis afférent aux plus-values latentes mentionnées au premier alinéa du 1 du I est dégrevé d’office, ou restitué s’il avait fait l’objet d’un paiement immédiat lors du transfert de domicile fiscal hors de France, lorsque les titres mentionnés au même alinéa ou les titres reçus lors d’une opération d’échange entrant dans le champ d’application de l’article 150-0 B intervenue après le transfert de domicile fiscal hors de France demeurent, à cette date, dans le patrimoine du contribuable. » A dégrèvement is a formal tax relief, granted automatically (d’office) here, or refunded if you paid upfront. The exception stretches the wait: « Par dérogation, ce délai est porté à cinq ans lorsque la valeur globale définie au premier alinéa du 1 du I du présent article excède 2,57 millions d’euros à la date du transfert du domicile fiscal hors de France du contribuable. » Keep 900,000 euros of shares untouched for two full years after leaving, and the income-tax bill dies on its own. Keep 4 million euros of shares, and you must wait five years. The official guidance confirms the cut from fifteen years to two or five years depending on whether the holdings fall below or above 2.57 million euros. Returns to France, gifts, and deaths can also trigger relief under the conditions quoted above, so a founder who moves back to Paris after eighteen months is freed even sooner.
Now the trap that has cost departing taxpayers hundreds of thousands of euros: for older departures, the social levies did not die with the income tax. The Conseil d’État confirmed in CE, 8th chamber, 9 November 2020, no. 440324 that under the 2011-2013 version of the law, « Il n’est pas fait application à la contribution du dégrèvement ou de la restitution prévus à l’expiration d’un délai de huit ans au 2 du VII de l’article 167 bis du code général des impôts et du dégrèvement prévu au premier alinéa du 4 du VIII du même article », a rule extended by reference to the other social levies on the same gains. The court upheld the administration’s official doctrine, BOI-RPPM-PVBMI-50-10, whose paragraph 40 states: « En revanche, les prélèvements sociaux restent dus. » The taxpayers’ challenge was thrown out in full: the court decided « La requête de M. et Mme B… A… est rejetée. » Parliament has since softened the blow: for 2011-2013 departures, article 11-II of the Finance Act for 2024 (Law no. 2023-1322 of 29 December 2023) allows the surviving social levies to be relieved or refunded too, provided the taxpayer proves the shares were still held when the eight-year period expired, while 2014-2018 departures see both income tax and levies relieved after fifteen years. If you left France in the mid-2010s and paid social levies everyone told you were gone, pull that file out now and check whether the 2024 window reopens it.
How much is the bill before relief? The income-tax slice is computed under the capital-gains flat-tax system set by article 167 bis: « l’impôt sur le revenu relatif aux plus-values et créances déterminées dans les conditions prévues aux I et II du présent article est établi dans les conditions prévues aux 1 ou 2 de l’article 200 A. » Article 200 A is the famous prélèvement forfaitaire unique, the single flat-rate levy, whose headline rate is fixed by law: « Le taux forfaitaire mentionné au premier alinéa du présent 1 est fixé à 12,8 % », in article 200 A of the CGI, with a global option to use the progressive scale instead. Social levies sit on top at the rate in force on departure day, through article L. 136-6 of the Social Security Code, which expressly reaches « Des plus-values et des créances mentionnées au I et au II de l’article 167 bis du code général des impôts » On our 800,000-euro example, the flat route means roughly 102,400 euros of income tax plus about 137,600 euros of social levies at 17.2 percent, before any relief, which is exactly why the two-year eraser and the guarantee math deserve professional attention rather than guesswork.
The law, still in article 167 bis, is fairer than it first looks when the shares fall. If the real sale price ends up below the departure-day value, or you sell at a loss, the tax is recalculated on the real result: « Si, à la survenance de l’un des événements mentionnés aux a et b du 1 du VII, le contribuable réalise une perte ou constate que les titres ont une valeur moindre que leur valeur d’entrée dans son patrimoine, l’impôt calculé en application du II bis afférent à la plus-value latente constatée conformément au I sur les titres concernés par l’un des événements précités est dégrevé, ou restitué s’il avait fait l’objet d’un paiement immédiat lors du transfert de domicile fiscal hors de France. » And if France itself taxes the eventual sale, for example through the nonresident capital-gains levies of articles 244 bis A or 244 bis B on French real-estate-rich shares, the exit-tax slice on those shares is relieved to avoid taxing the same gain twice: « Si, lors de la survenance de l’un des événements prévus au a du 1 du VII, du présent article le contribuable réalise une plus-value imposée en France conformément aux dispositions des articles 244 bis A ou 244 bis B, l’impôt calculé dans les conditions du II bis afférent à la plus-value latente constatée conformément au I sur les titres concernés par l’un des événements précités est dégrevé ou restitué s’il avait fait l’objet d’un paiement l’année suivant le transfert de domicile fiscal hors de France. » Founders with carried-over deferred gains (report d’imposition) face parallel mechanics, which is precisely what sank the taxpayers holding Cypriot shares in the Versailles case: they filed a departure return claiming no liability, the administration answered with a reassessment for latent and deferred gains, and the court upheld it, rejecting the appeal in full.
Two courthouse lessons close the loop. First, the guarantee burden is constitutional. The Versailles court held in CAA Versailles, 1 March 2022, no. 20VE01104 that taxing latent gains on departure day, « alors même que le sursis de paiement de cette imposition est subordonné à l’obligation de constituer des garanties propres à assurer le recouvrement de la créance du Trésor, ne porte pas atteinte au droit au respect des biens protégé par les stipulations précitées de l’article 1er du premier protocole additionnel à la convention européenne de sauvegarde des droits de l’homme et des libertés fondamentales. » You cannot defeat the exit tax by calling the guarantee an expropriation. Second, procedure decides cases as often as substance does. The Versailles taxpayers lost partly because their departure filings denied liability outright instead of securing suspension and tracking the shares; the administration reassessed, and the judges backed the reassessment. If you dispute an assessment, the French path runs through an administrative claim (réclamation contentieuse) to the tax office, then the administrative court (tribunal administratif), then the administrative court of appeal, as in the Paris and Versailles cases above. Every step has its own deadline, and the file that wins is the file with dated valuations, filed forms, guarantee receipts, and the DINR correspondence kept together.
One companion question deserves a signpost rather than a detour. Readers arriving in France face the mirror problem: when does French tax residence attach, and how does the treaty’s tie-breaker settle dual claims? That arrival-side analysis is covered in our companion piece on becoming a French tax resident as an American, the domicile test, and the treaty tie-breaker. Read the two together and you hold both ends of the stay: entry and exit.
Conclusion
France’s exit tax treats your move home as a sale that never happened: six years of French residence out of ten, plus 800,000 euros of securities or a 50-percent stake, and a paper gain is assessed in your name on departure day. The France-United States treaty does not cancel that assessment, because it falls while you are still France’s taxpayer, and American worldwide taxation means the real gain will be examined again in the United States, with only a foreign tax credit to soften the overlap. The rational response is procedural, not emotional. Confirm which suspension door fits your file, file the 2074-ETD request at least 90 days before departure if guarantees are needed, appoint your French representative, post the 12.8-percent guarantee base, then file the 2074-ETS or 2074-ETSL tracking return every year and carry the suspended total to box 8TN. Hold the shares two years, or five above 2.57 million euros, and the income-tax slice dies by automatic relief; verify separately what survives in social levies for your departure vintage, especially with the 2024 reopening for 2011-2013 leavers. If the shares fall, force the recalculation to the real price; if France taxes the eventual sale, claim the double-tax relief; and if the administration reassesses, challenge through the claim-to-court chain with a complete dated file. Departures reward the methodical and punish the hurried, so start the exit file before you book the movers.