KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
US Moves to Free Accused Bosnian War Criminal Hamdija Alukic: Extradition, the Political-Offense Defence and What France Would Do

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

US Moves to Free Accused Bosnian War Criminal Hamdija Alukic: Extradition, the Political-Offense Defence and What France Would Do

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

In March 2026, United States Marshals arrested a 70-year-old man in Mobile, Alabama, on allegations dating back more than three decades to the Bosnian war. Bosnia and Herzegovina wants Hamdija Alukic extradited to stand trial for war crimes against the civilian population: two attacks in 1992, two civilians killed, homes set on fire with people inside, according to a 261-page American criminal complaint. He has been in jail ever since. Then, on 10 September 2026, the case took a turn that extradition lawyers rarely see: the United States Attorney’s Office itself asked a federal judge to cancel the extradition hearing scheduled for 9 November, to halt the written briefing both sides were preparing, and to release the accused war criminal from custody while the State Department reviews, in its words, extensive additional documentation that could change whether pursuing extradition remains appropriate at all. Behind that motion sits the defence that has shadowed the file since March, the claim that the American extradition treaty exempts political offenses, and a question with direct resonance in Paris: what would happen if a man in Alukic’s position were arrested in France on a Bosnian war-crimes request. This article reconstructs the Alabama proceedings from the local reporting, then gives the view from Paris, step by step, through the checks French judges would run before handing anyone over, and through the second track French law keeps open, putting the suspect on trial in France itself.

I. Arrested in March, Facing Release in September: How the American Case Against Hamdija Alukic Turned Into a Review

A. What Bosnia Alleges Against the Quiet Neighbour From Wilmer: Two Attacks in 1992, Two Civilians Dead

Hamdija Alukic was arrested by United States Marshals in Mobile on Wednesday 18 March 2026 and has been held without bond ever since, first reported in the Baldwin County Jail. A former neighbour told local television that Alukic had lived a quiet life with his family in Wilmer, Alabama, for several years before moving. His arrest, more than three decades after the alleged acts and thousands of miles from where they occurred, rests on federal court documents describing war crimes said to have been committed in Bosnia and Herzegovina in 1992. According to witness interviews summarised in those documents, Alukic was a member of a Bosnian Muslim paramilitary group during the civil war that ran from 1992 to 1995. The records allege that he planned and carried out two different attacks that killed a total of two people. In the second attack, the documents say, he led the operation: he and other members split into two parties and set fire to two different homes with people inside. Photographs from the attacks in Bosnia and a picture of Alukic from his 1987 identity document are attached to the court records. The criminal complaint against him runs to 261 pages. Under the arrest warrant, the authorities are seeking his extradition to Bosnia and Herzegovina, where he is expected to be prosecuted for war crimes against the civilian population. A second local outlet confirmed the frame in its own terms, reporting a man from Bosnia and Herzegovina arrested in south Alabama for allegedly committing crimes against Serbian civilians during the war, and awaiting extradition to Bosnia and Herzegovina.

For an international reader, three features of the file matter immediately. First, the age of the allegations: acts said to have been committed in 1992, arrests in 2026, a 34-year gap that puts limitation, the reliability of witness memory, and the completeness of the transmitted file at the centre of any surrender litigation. Second, the civilian character of the alleged victims, which is what lifts the accusations from ordinary homicide into the category of war crimes against the civilian population, the exact category on which the Bosnian request is built. Third, the context of an internal armed conflict, a civil war from 1992 to 1995, which raises the classic defence effort in this kind of file: presenting the acts as those of a combatant in a political and military struggle, and therefore as political offenses sheltered from extradition. That defence was on the table within days of the arrest. On 31 March 2026, a federal judge weighed whether Alukic should be allowed out of jail while he fights extradition, with federal prosecutors opposing his release. He stayed in custody. The extradition hearing itself was set for 9 November 2026, with both sides preparing written arguments. Everything pointed to a long custodial battle of the kind American extradition practice produces routinely, because in international extradition proceedings in the United States there is a strong presumption in favour of detention, and release on bail is the exception. American prosecutors made exactly that argument in the parallel extradition litigation over the Tate brothers in Miami this same month, and the magistrate judge there kept the brothers jailed as, in her words, quintessential flight risks. Alukic, 70 years old, a long-time Alabama resident with family ties, presented a very different custodial profile, yet he too remained locked up from March onward.

B. Why Washington Now Wants Its Own Extradition Case Paused: New Documents, a Review, and the Political-Offense Shield

The 10 September motion reverses the posture of the requesting machinery without withdrawing the case. The United States Attorney’s Office asked the federal judge to cancel the 9 November extradition hearing, to halt the written arguments both sides were preparing, and to release Alukic. Its stated reason is a letter received that same Thursday from the United States State Department indicating that since Alukic’s arrest, the department has, in the words quoted by local reporting, received extensive additional documentation regarding the case, adding that this new information necessitates additional review by the Department to determine whether it remains appropriate to pursue extradition in this case. Alukic’s lawyer supports the motion. At the time of reporting, the judge had not immediately ruled, and a status hearing was scheduled for the following day, Friday. The honest procedural picture, as of this article, is therefore a narrow one: the executive branch that arrested the man in March is asking the judiciary to stand down the surrender calendar in September while diplomats re-examine the file, and the defence agrees. Whether the judge grants release, whether the State Department maintains or drops the extradition, and what the new documentation contains, remain open questions that future hearings will answer.

That narrow picture is precisely what makes the file instructive. In extradition law, the decision to surrender a person is never a single act; it is a chain in which the police arrest, the prosecutors litigate, the judges review, and the executive authorises, and any link can seize up. Here the executive link is seizing up under the weight of new material, six months after the arrest. The defence’s substantive shield, meanwhile, is the political-offense exception: Alukic’s lawyer has argued that the extradition treaty exempts political offenses, inviting the court to treat attacks carried out as a member of a paramilitary group in a civil war as political acts rather than extraditable common crimes. American courts construe that exception strictly, and the prevailing American approach excludes violent attacks on civilians from its protection, but the argument has to be litigated document by document, victim by victim, and the State Department’s review suggests that something in the expanded file complicates the government’s own confidence. For a French extradition lawyer, the configuration is familiar to the point of being textbook: old facts from a civil war, a paramilitary past, a political-offense defence, a requesting state whose prisons and courts will themselves be scrutinised, and a requested person who has built a family life over decades in the country of refuge. France handles dozens of files with exactly this shape, from Algerian, Balkan, Rwandan, and Latin American requests, and its courts have built a dense body of method for them. The second part of this article walks through that method as it would apply to a man in Alukic’s position arrested in France.

II. Arrested in France on a Bosnian War-Crimes Request: Every Test French Judges Would Run Before Any Surrender

A. The Extradition Audit in Paris: the File, the Political-Offense Bar, Custody, the Reasoned Opinion, and the Decree

Start with the file itself, because in France an extradition request lives or dies on its paperwork before any judge reaches the substance. Under Article 696-8 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, in force on 20 September 2026, every extradition request is addressed to the French government through diplomatic channels and must be accompanied by a conviction or by a formal committal order or arrest warrant issued by a judicial authority, provided those instruments contain a precise statement of the facts for which they were issued and the date of those facts, with the requesting government also producing a copy of the statutory texts applicable to the charged conduct. Transposed to the Alukic file, that means the Bosnian warrant would have to identify each of the two 1992 attacks with its date, its place, the victims, and Alukic’s alleged role, attack by attack, and attach the Bosnian criminal provisions on war crimes against civilians. A 261-page complaint is impressive, but the French test is not volume, it is precision: vague dating of 34-year-old facts, confusion between the two attacks, or missing statutory texts would draw an adverse finding at the first hearing. Defence counsel in Paris therefore begins every extradition file with an audit of dates, places, counts, and texts, and the oldest files are often the weakest on exactly these points.

The second test is the catalogue of mandatory refusal grounds, and it is here that the political-offense defence would meet its French equivalent. Article 696-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides that extradition is not granted in eight situations, including where the requested person is French, where the offense has a political character or where the circumstances show that extradition is sought for a political purpose, in the exact statutory phrase, where extradition is sought dans un but politique, where the acts were committed on French territory, where they have already been finally tried in France, where limitation has run under either law, where the penalty offends French public policy, where the requesting court does not guarantee fundamental procedural rights, and where the offense is a purely military one. A Bosnian request concerning a former paramilitary member would force the chambre de l’instruction, the specialised chamber of the cour d’appel that reviews extradition requests, to examine the political-character argument count by count. French practice on this point is demanding on both sides: the court verifies whether the acts, by their nature and their targets, are genuinely political, and acts directed against the civilian population, homes set on fire with people inside, sit at the far end of the spectrum from protected political expression. The very recent ruling of the Criminal Chamber of the Cour de cassation of 27 May 2026, pourvoi no. 25-84.904 (ECLI:FR:CCASS:2026:CR00687), in an extradition to Algeria, confirms the method: the chambre de l’instruction had ruled on the applicable convention, the absence of political character of the charged acts, the completeness of the transmitted documents, the sentence threshold, limitation, and double criminality, and the Cour de cassation upheld that full legality review. The lesson for an Alukic-type file is direct: the political-offense argument would be heard seriously, tested against each attack and each victim, and weighed alongside every other bar, from double criminality to fair-trial guarantees in the requesting state.

The third test is custody, and it is where French and American practice diverge most visibly. In France, once the extradition request is notified, if the procureur general does not leave the requested person at liberty, the person is presented to the first president of the cour d’appel, who orders detention under a specific regime, the placement under extradition committal. Article 696-11 of the Code of Criminal Procedure so provides, while adding the safety valve: if the person’s appearance at every stage seems sufficiently guaranteed, the judge may instead impose judicial supervision or house arrest with electronic monitoring. Release can then be requested at any time: Article 696-19 of the Code of Criminal Procedure allows the application to be filed with the chambre de l’instruction at any moment, with a decision within twenty days, reduced to fifteen where the request follows within forty-eight hours of committal. A 70-year-old man with decades of settled family life, the profile Alukic presents in Alabama, is exactly the type of requested person for whom French judges seriously consider the supervision alternative, because the two risks that justify extradition detention, flight and interference, weigh differently at seventy than at thirty. The American presumption in favour of detention that kept Alukic jailed from March has no identical twin in Paris; the French judge individualises, and long residence plus family roots count.

The fourth test is the reasoned opinion itself, the heart of the French system. Where the requested person does not consent to surrender, Article 696-15 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides that the chambre de l’instruction is seised without delay, hears the person within ten working days, and delivers its reasoned opinion within one month, and that opinion is unfavourable, in the words of the statute, Cet avis est défavorable si la cour estime que les conditions légales ne sont pas remplies ou qu’il y a une erreur évidente. An unfavourable opinion ends the matter, since the government cannot surrender in defiance of it. The Cour de cassation polices only formal defects capable of depriving the opinion of the essential conditions of its legal existence, which makes the hearing before the chambre de l’instruction the decisive battle: double criminality count by count, limitation under both laws for the oldest counts, specialty mapping so that no later-added charge can be tried without fresh consent, and human-rights review. The 2018 Sandoval ruling, in which the Criminal Chamber upheld a partially favourable opinion on an Argentine request concerning crimes against humanity committed between 1976 and 1979, pourvoi no. 17-86.340 (ECLI:FR:CCASS:2018:CR01216), shows how limitation is handled for old atrocity files: the Court approved the reasoning that, for a continuing offense such as arbitrary detention and sequestration whose victim never reappeared, the starting point of limitation cannot be fixed arbitrarily, since, in the Court’s words, la prescription des infractions continues ne court qu’à partir du jour où elles ont pris fin dans leurs actes constitutifs et dans leurs effets. For 1992 Bosnian attacks configured as completed killings and arson rather than continuing detention, the limitation analysis would run differently, but the method, examining each count under both the requesting and the French law, would be identical.

The fifth and final test is the decree and its judicial review. Article 696-18 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides that extradition is authorised by decree of the Prime Minister on the report of the Minister of Justice, and that the action for excess of power against that decree must, on pain of foreclosure, be brought within one month, since, in the statutory phrase, l’extradition est autorisée par décret du Premier ministre pris sur le rapport du ministre de la justice. The Conseil d’Etat then reviews the decree’s legality, including the human-rights bars. Applied to a Bosnian war-crimes file, counsel would challenge the decree on every ground the chambre de l’instruction had cleared: political purpose, fair-trial guarantees before the requesting courts, and prison conditions on return. The French approach to that last point has just been restated with unusual concreteness. In the same 27 May 2026 Algeria ruling, the Cour de cassation upheld a chambre de l’instruction that had rejected the claim of inhuman or degrading treatment after ordering further information, noting the collective detention system in large rooms, the freedom to move, and at least six hours of open-air exercise, and it approved the lower court’s concrete examination, holding that the chamber, which had carried out, in the Court’s words, un examen concret des conditions de détention fondé sur les éléments fournis par les autorités requérantes, had lawfully set aside the risk of degrading detention. A Bosnian file would receive the same treatment: no presumption about Balkan prisons, no deference either, but a demand for documents, measurements, and hours, tested against the three-square-metre individual-space case law, and a negative opinion or an annulled decree if the answers do not come. The cabinet’s reference guide on extradition review by the Criminal Chamber, conditions and procedure 2023-2026 details each of these gates for readers facing a live request.

B. The Second Track Paris Keeps Open: Trying War Crimes in France Instead of Surrendering, and the Detention-Conditions Bar

Extradition is not the only lawful answer to a war-crimes allegation, and this is where French law offers something the Alabama proceedings cannot: trial in France for acts committed abroad. Article 689-11 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides that any person suspected of having committed abroad genocide, other crimes against humanity, or war crimes may be prosecuted and tried by the French courts, in the words of the statute, peut être poursuivie et jugée par les juridictions françaises toute personne soupçonnée d’avoir commis à l’étranger l’une des infractions suivantes, covering genocide, crimes against humanity, and war crimes as defined in the Criminal Code. The condition is habitual residence in France, defined as a sufficient link with the country, assessed in particular on the duration of presence, its conditions, and its reasons. A man who has lived quietly with his family in the country of refuge for years, the settled profile Alukic shows in Alabama, is precisely the profile the residence condition is written for. The Criminal Chamber spelled out the architecture in its ruling of 1 February 2023 concerning war crimes and crimes against humanity said to have been committed in Ivory Coast, pourvoi no. 22-82.235 (ECLI:FR:CCASS:2023:CR00123), recalling that French jurisdiction over crimes against humanity and war crimes committed abroad is conditioned on the ability of the French judicial authorities to prosecute a person habitually resident in France. And the Assemblee pleniere went further on complicity on 25 July 2025, pourvoi no. 24-84.071 (ECLI:FR:CCASS:2025:CR90684), holding that the combined provisions of Articles 689 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and 113-6 and 121-6 of the Criminal Code allow French courts to take cognisance of acts of complicity committed abroad by a French national even where the principal offense was committed abroad by a foreign principal. The definitions behind these heads of jurisdiction are written in broad terms: Article 461-1 of the Criminal Code defines war crimes as offenses committed during an international or non-international armed conflict and in relation to that conflict, in violation of the laws and customs of war or the applicable international conventions, against protected persons or property, while Article 212-1 of the Criminal Code defines crimes against humanity around acts committed in execution of a concerted plan against a civilian population group within a widespread or systematic attack. Two house-burnings with occupants inside during the 1992-1995 Bosnian civil war fit the war-crimes definition on their face, subject to proof, which is exactly why the French alternative matters: where extradition to Bosnia stumbled on documents, guarantees, or politics, prosecution in France would remain legally available if the suspect lived here.

The practical consequence is a choice of forum that defence and prosecution both prepare from day one. If Bosnia requested Alukic from France, the parquet could open a parallel preliminary inquiry on the French universal-jurisdiction track while the extradition file moves through the chambre de l’instruction, and the existence of French proceedings is itself a factor in the extradition balance, since France does not surrender lightly where its own courts can judge. The specialty principle would then be mapped count by count so that surrender, if granted, covered only the documented attacks, and any later Bosnian add-on charge would require fresh French consent. Meanwhile the detention-conditions bar described above would run in parallel: Bosnia would be asked to document, establishment by establishment, the space, hygiene, health care, and exercise regime awaiting the surrendered person, and the chambre de l’instruction would order further information until the answers allowed the concrete examination the Cour de cassation demands. The 2026 Algeria decision shows the standard in operation, down to collective rooms of 120 to 145 square metres, free movement within them, health and hygiene compliance, and a minimum of six hours of open-air exercise, with the Court accepting that even a reduction of individual space below three square metres can be compensated where movement, air, and dignity are otherwise secured. None of this prejudges guilt or innocence; it reflects the French conception that surrender is a judicial act subject to strict legal conditions, proved document by document by the requesting state. And where the requesting state’s file cannot survive that audit, the French answer is not impunity but the second track: investigation by the specialised crimes-against-humanity unit, committal, and trial before French courts, with victims constituted as civil parties and the full Criminal Code arsenal, from war crimes to crimes against humanity, available to the prosecution.

Conclusion

The Alabama file stands at an unusual crossroads. A 70-year-old man arrested in March on 1992 Bosnian war-crimes allegations, held without bond for six months, defended on political-offense grounds, was on track for a November extradition hearing until the very government seeking his surrender asked the court to stop the clock, free the man, and let diplomats review extensive new documentation. Whether that review ends in release, in a withdrawn request, or in a reinforced file will be decided in the coming hearings, and each outcome carries its own lesson: release would show the executive custody brake working as designed, withdrawal would show documentary self-correction, and a renewed request would show the political-offense fight joined on the merits. For readers facing the French side of such files, the method is settled even where outcomes are not: audit the warrant’s precision attack by attack, test the political-character claim against civilian victims, individualise custody rather than presume detention, force the chambre de l’instruction’s full legality review within its one-month reasoned-opinion discipline, challenge the Prime Minister’s decree within its one-month foreclosure period, demand documented detention conditions measured in square metres and hours of air, and keep the universal-jurisdiction track in reserve so that refusal of surrender never means refusal of justice. Old wars produce old files, and old files demand the strictest proof; that, in Paris as in Mobile, is the rule that decides who is surrendered and who is tried at home.

📄 Official circular