You did what your American adviser told you to do. When you bought the stone house in the Dordogne, you formed a Delaware limited liability company, put the purchase funds through it, and had the French notary register the LLC as the buyer. The pitch was familiar: privacy, liability protection, and probate avoidance back home. Then, months or years later, a French tax bill arrived that nobody in Delaware had mentioned: the taxe annuelle de 3 %, an annual tax equal to 3 percent of the market value of the house, assessed against your LLC every single year. On a house worth 800,000 euros, that is 24,000 euros a year, due even if you never rent the place out and even if the LLC never earns a dollar. This article explains why France taxes your American company, how a yearly disclosure filing switches the tax off, what the IRS demands from you on the American side, and how a sale or a death is taxed on both sides of the Atlantic. The French side of the problem is mechanical and solvable: identify the exact legal basis, file the right paper before May 15 each year, and keep the proof. The American side requires a written classification analysis of your LLC, because everything about your IRS reporting changes depending on whether Washington treats your company as invisible or as a corporation. Read the whole piece before you call anyone, because the cheapest mistake in this file is paying the 3 percent for years when a disclosure would have erased it, and the most expensive mistake is unwinding the LLC in a hurry and triggering two countries worth of transfer taxes at once.
I. Why Does France Charge My LLC 3% Every Year — and How Do I Turn the Tax Off
A. How my Delaware LLC became a French taxpayer on January 1
France does not see your Delaware LLC the way Delaware does. Under French tax law, your LLC is a foreign legal entity that owns French real estate, and that single fact is enough to create a yearly taxpayer. The charging provision is article 990 D of the French Tax Code, the Code général des impôts, article 990 D published on Legifrance. Its first sentence is worth reading in full: “Les entités juridiques : personnes morales, organismes, fiducies ou institutions comparables qui, directement ou par entité interposée, possèdent un ou plusieurs immeubles situés en France ou sont titulaires de droits réels portant sur ces biens sont redevables d’une taxe annuelle égale à 3 % de la valeur vénale de ces immeubles ou droits.” In plain English, every legal entity, body, trust, or comparable institution that owns French buildings directly or through a chain of intermediaries owes an annual tax of 3 percent of the market value, the valeur vénale, of those buildings or rights. The same article adds that an entity counts as owning through an intermediary whenever it holds any participation, of any form and any size, in another entity that owns the property or sits anywhere in the ownership chain. Layering does not help: if your LLC owns a French property company that owns the house, or if your living trust owns the LLC that owns the house, each level of the structure is inside the scope of the tax. Our companion piece on French property companies explains the parallel French-side vehicle, the société civile immobilière and its own 3 percent exposure, which is useful background but a different file from yours: that article covers a French company you form, while this one covers the American company you already have. Three features of the French charge surprise Americans every time. First, the taxable event is ownership on January 1. Article 990 F of the Tax Code, published on Legifrance, opens with this rule: “La taxe est due à raison des immeubles ou droits immobiliers possédés au 1er janvier de l’année d’imposition, à l’exception des biens régulièrement inscrits dans les stocks des personnes morales qui exercent la profession de marchand de biens ou de promoteur-constructeur.” If your LLC sells the house on February 2, it still owes the full 3 percent for that year, because it owned the property on New Year Day. Second, the base is market value, not purchase price and not cadastral rental value. You need a defensible valuation every year: a local agent opinion is a starting point, a formal appraisal is better, and whatever number you declare should be consistent with the value your French rental and wealth filings imply, because the administration cross-checks files. Third, the people in the chain are jointly on the hook. The same article 990 F provides: “Toute personne morale, organisme, fiducie ou institution comparable, interposé entre le ou les débiteurs de la taxe et les immeubles ou droits immobiliers est solidairement responsable du paiement de cette taxe.” Every intermediary between the taxpayer and the bricks is jointly liable for payment, which means neither the LLC nor any holding entity above it can point fingers down the chain. Two narrow escape hatches exist inside the statute itself. An entity whose share of the French property is worth less than 100,000 euros or less than 5 percent of the market value of the property falls outside the exemption system under article 990 E of the Tax Code, published on Legifrance: “Dont la quote-part du ou des immeubles situés en France ou des droits réels détenus directement ou indirectement portant sur ces biens est inférieure à 100 000 € ou à 5 % de la valeur vénale desdits biens ou autres droits”. And an entity whose French real-estate assets represent less than half of its French assets can also escape, under the provision that excludes entities “Dont les actifs immobiliers, au sens de l’article 990 D, situés en France, représentent moins de 50 % des actifs français détenus directement ou par l’intermédiaire d’une ou plusieurs entités juridiques.” Most single-house LLCs fail both tests, because the house is the only French asset. For them, the statute offers something better than an escape hatch: a disclosure procedure that cancels the bill, which is the subject of the next section. One procedural point matters immediately. The tax is self-assessed: no French office sends a polite reminder with the amount pre-filled. Article 990 F requires that “Les redevables ainsi que les entités juridiques mentionnées aux d ou e du 3° de l’article 990 E doivent déclarer au plus tard le 15 mai de chaque année la situation, la consistance et la valeur des immeubles et droits immobiliers en cause. Cette déclaration, accompagnée du paiement de la taxe, est déposée au lieu fixé par arrêté du ministre chargé du budget.” Every taxpayer, and every entity using the disclosure exemptions, must declare the location, composition, and value of the property by May 15 each year, with payment attached when tax is due. The administration own guide to this tax, the TVVI page on impots.gouv.fr, states the rule the same way: a 3 percent charge on the January 1 market value, with several possible exemptions. Three percent, January 1, several possible exemptions. Your French notary will not make this filing for you after the purchase; it is a recurring owner obligation, and the calendar is unforgiving.
B. How I claim the exemption: the May 15 disclosure that cancels the bill
The statute taxes every foreign entity, then exempts the transparent ones. Article 990 E, 3 degrees, published on Legifrance, opens the exemption to entities seated in France, in a European Union member state, or “dans un pays ou territoire ayant conclu avec la France une convention d’assistance administrative en vue de lutter contre la fraude et l’évasion fiscales ou dans un Etat ayant conclu avec la France un traité leur permettant de bénéficier du même traitement que les entités qui ont leur siège en France”. The United States maintains an exchange-of-information framework with France under the bilateral tax relationship documented on the France tax treaty documents page of the IRS, and in practice American entities use the disclosure path described below; because treaty practice evolves, have French counsel confirm the current qualification of a United States-seated entity before the first filing, then the procedure is identical every year. Two disclosure routes exist, and choosing the right one is the most practical decision in this file. The first route, paragraph d, requires the entity to declare each year, no later than May 15, “la situation, la consistance et la valeur des immeubles possédés au 1er janvier, l’identité et l’adresse de l’ensemble des actionnaires, associés ou autres membres qui détiennent, à quelque titre que ce soit, plus de 1 % des actions, parts ou autres droits, ainsi que le nombre des actions, parts ou autres droits détenus par chacun d’eux”. Every holder of more than 1 percent, with name, address, and number of rights: full transparency buys full exemption. The second route, paragraph e, uses the annual form number 2746 and covers the holders known to the entity, with the exemption granted proportionally: the entity declares each year by May 15 “la situation, la consistance et la valeur des immeubles possédés au 1er janvier, l’identité et l’adresse des actionnaires, associés ou autres membres qui détiennent plus de 1 % des actions, parts ou autres droits dont ils ont connaissance à la même date, ainsi que le nombre des actions, parts ou autres droits détenus par chacun d’eux, au prorata du nombre d’actions, parts ou autres droits détenus au 1er janvier par des actionnaires, associés ou autres membres dont l’identité et l’adresse ont été déclarées.” The administration guide confirms the mechanics on impots.gouv.fr: qualifying entities may also obtain exemption under article 990 E, 3 degrees, paragraph e by voluntarily filing form number 2746 each year by May 15 at the latest, with the exemption granted proportionally to the shares, units, or other rights held on January 1 by disclosed holders whose identity and address appear on the form. For a single-member Delaware LLC whose owner discloses fully, the prorata math reaches 100 percent and the exemption wipes out the tax. Filing is now electronic: the same guide notes the mandatory online filing for form 2746-SD, so paper filing through the mail is no longer compliant. Three court decisions show how strictly the administration and the judges read these disclosure conditions, and each one is worth understanding before you sign a form. The leading decision is commercial chamber of the Court of Cassation, May 10, 2024, appeal number 21-11.230, (Court of Cassation, commercial chamber, May 10, 2024, appeal no. 21-11.230). Its holding is a warning against assuming the tax away: “Il résulte de la combinaison de ces textes que toute entité est redevable de la taxe de 3 % sur la valeur vénale des immeubles qu’elle possède en France, sauf à justifier relever d’un des cas énumérés par le dernier.” Every legal entity owes the tax unless it affirmatively proves an exemption. In that case a foundation that had no shareholders, no partners, and no members, and could name only a future, hypothetical beneficiary of its assets in its 3 percent filings, lost the exemption. The court drew a bright line: “Seuls peuvent être assimilés aux actionnaires, associés ou autres membres qui détiennent, à quelque titre que ce soit, plus de 1 % des actions, parts ou autres droits les bénéficiaires économiques réels au 1er janvier de l’année d’imposition des entités juridiques concernées, et non des bénéficiaires éventuels.” Only the real economic beneficiaries as of January 1 count; possible future beneficiaries do not. For your LLC, the lesson is direct: name the actual human owner or owners as of January 1, with addresses, every year. Naming a trust vaguely, naming a future heir, or writing the name of a management company instead of the member will not survive a challenge. The second decision applies the same strictness to a layered foreign structure. On March 13, 2019, the commercial chamber, appeal number 17-21.938, rejected the claim of an Austrian foundation, the Nafond Privatstiftung, which held two French Riviera villas through a French property company and a French dealer-in-property company and had filed the article 990 E 3 degrees declarations each year to claim exemption. The administration had issued a reassessment for 2007 through 2012, maintained its refusal of the exemption, and sent a collection notice in August 2013; the foundation sued for discharge and lost at every level, with the Aix-en-Provence appeal court ruling of March 21, 2017 confirmed on the essential point. Chains of entities, foreign foundations, and years of routine filings did not cure a disclosure that the administration found substantively insufficient. If your LLC sits under a trust or above a French company, every level must be disclosed coherently, and the reassessment window reaches back years, with penalties computed under the registration-duty rules that article 990 F imports. The third decision is older but explains why the exemption system looks the way it does. On December 13, 2005, the commercial chamber, appeal number 02-10.359, asked the Luxembourg court whether the EC Treaty provisions on establishment and capital movement permitted a law “Les articles 52 et suivants et 73 B et suivants du Traité CE s’opposent-ils à une législation telle que celle prévue par les articles 990 D et suivants du Code général des impôts qui accorde aux personnes morales qui ont leur siège de direction effective en France la faculté de bénéficier de l’exonération de la taxe sur la valeur vénale des immeubles possédés en France”. That reference produced the European case law that reshaped the exemption list, and its trace remains visible today in the 990 E 3 degrees opening words on assistance conventions and non-discrimination treaties. Practically, your yearly routine has five steps. Confirm each January who holds more than 1 percent of the LLC and at which address. Value the property at January 1 with a written basis. Prepare form 2746-SD electronically before May 15, disclosing every qualifying holder. Keep stamped proof of filing and payment records for the reassessment period. And calendar the filing as a recurring obligation independent of any rental return: the 3 percent file, the rental-income file, and the wealth-tax file are three separate tracks with three separate deadlines, and filing one never covers the others.
II. What Does the LLC Cost Me in America — and What Happens When I Sell or Die
A. How the IRS taxes my French rent and which forms I must file
Killing the French 3 percent bill solves France, not America. The United States taxes its citizens and residents on worldwide income, so your French rent is reportable in both countries, and the LLC itself creates a second layer of American paperwork that surprises owners who thought of it as a mere envelope. Start with classification, because every other American answer flows from it. Under the American check-the-box rules, a single-member LLC defaults to disregarded-entity status, meaning the IRS looks straight through it to you, while a multi-member LLC defaults to partnership status, and a foreign eligible entity can elect to be treated as a corporation. France, meanwhile, generally treats your LLC as an opaque body: it taxes the entity for the 3 percent regime and applies its own company logic to French-source income. That mismatch, transparent here and opaque there, is the engine of every double-tax problem in this file. Do not guess your classification from memory of what the formation agent told you years ago; commission a short written American memo that states the classification, the election history if any, and the resulting return stack, with preparers named. The memo costs a fraction of one year of penalties. Next, understand where the rent is taxed first. The France-United States income tax convention of August 31, 1994, whose authentic text is published by the IRS at irs.gov/pub/irs-trty/france.pdf, gives France the first right to tax income from French land. Article 6, paragraph 1 gives France the right to tax income from French land, so your Dordogne rent may be taxed in France, full stop. The treaty defines real property by French law, which means French characterisation controls what counts as real-property income, and paragraph 3 extends the rule to letting income in any form. One paragraph of the treaty is especially practical for Americans and little known: a resident taxed in the other state on real-property income there may elect net-basis taxation if domestic law does not already provide it. If French domestic rules ever denied deduction of real expenses, the treaty preserves your right to be taxed on net rental profit. In practice France already taxes nonresident landlords on net income under its standard rental regimes, with French-source income categories listed in article 164 B of the Tax Code on Legifrance and residence defined by article 4 B on Legifrance, so you declare the rent in France, deduct the real charges under the applicable regime, and pay French tax first. America then taxes the same rent again on your federal return and relieves the double hit through the foreign tax credit and the treaty relief provisions, documented on the IRS treaty documents page. The credit has baskets, caps, and carryovers that your preparer must compute; the treaty does not make the French tax disappear from the American return, it gives you the mechanism to avoid paying twice. The third American layer is pure reporting, and it applies even in years the house sits empty. If the LLC holds a French bank account, that account can trigger the annual foreign-account report administered by the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, described at Report Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts, whenever aggregate foreign balances cross the filing threshold. The entity itself can trigger entity-level information returns: a disregarded foreign LLC generally means Form 8858 reporting by the American owner, a corporate election generally means the return the IRS calls the Information Return of U.S. Persons With Respect To Certain Foreign Corporations with its categories and potentially its per-form penalties, and large foreign financial assets can trigger the FATCA asset statement on top of the FinCEN report. None of these forms asks whether you already disclosed the same humans on the French 2746; the two transparency systems run on parallel tracks and never cross-file. Build a single calendar that lists the French 2746 deadline of May 15, the French rental return deadline, and every American information return with its preparer, and review the classification memo whenever the LLC admits a new member, elects a different status, or buys a second property, because each of those events can change the American return stack overnight.
B. How I sell the house or pass it on without paying tax twice
Sooner or later the LLC sells the house, or you die owning the LLC, and both events are taxed under rules that look through the company to the bricks. Take the sale first. French domestic law imposes a withholding-style levy on gains realised by nonresidents: article 244 bis A of the Tax Code, published on Legifrance, provides that “Sont soumis au prélèvement mentionné au 1 : a) Les personnes physiques qui ne sont pas fiscalement domiciliées en France au sens de l’article 4 B ; b) Les personnes morales ou organismes, quelle qu’en soit la forme, dont le siège social est situé hors de France”. A Delaware LLC, a legal person or body of whatever form with its registered office outside France, is expressly inside the levy when it sells French real estate or rights over it. In practice the French notary handling the sale computes the gain, withholds the levy from the price, and requires the appointment of a French tax representative, the représentant fiscal, whose fee scales with the price. Here the 3 percent file resurfaces at the closing table: article 990 F of the Tax Code, published on Legifrance, provides that on sale by an entity seated outside the European Union and outside the European Economic Area assistance-and-collection framework, “le représentant visé au IV de l’article 244 bis A est responsable du paiement de la taxe restant due à cette date.” Your sale representative is personally on the hook for any 3 percent tax still due that day, which is why competent notaries now ask for the LLC complete 2746 history before releasing funds: undisclosed years become a last-minute retention on the price. The treaty confirms that France may tax the gain. Article 13, paragraph 1 of the 1994 convention lets France tax gains from selling French real estate. And where France is the property state, paragraph 2 reaches not only the building itself but also shares or similar rights in a company whose assets are at least half French real estate or derive at least half their value, directly or indirectly, from French real estate. Selling the LLC membership interests instead of having the LLC sell the house does not leave France: a single-house LLC fails the 50 percent test in the wrong direction, and France taxes the share sale too. America then taxes the same gain on your federal return, with the French levy creditable subject to the usual limits, which is the detailed double-tax computation our companion guide to selling a French house as an American walks through for direct owners; your LLC adds the classification layer on top, because a disregarded entity generally passes the gain straight to you while a corporate election can split the event into a French entity-level gain and a separate American shareholder-level consequence. Death works the same look-through way, only with higher rates. Article 750 ter of the Tax Code, published on Legifrance, taxes “Les biens meubles et immeubles, que ces derniers soient possédés directement ou indirectement, situés en France”, including trust property, when the deceased was not domiciled in France, and deems property indirectly owned whenever it “appartient à des personnes morales ou des organismes dont le donateur ou le défunt, seul ou conjointement avec son conjoint, leurs ascendants ou descendants ou leurs frères et soeurs, détient plus de la moitié des actions, parts ou droits, directement ou par l’intermédiaire d’une chaîne de participations”, whatever the number of intermediaries in the chain. Own more than half the LLC alone or with close family, through however many layers, and France treats you as owning the house for death-tax purposes. The same article extends the logic to shares of unlisted foreign companies whose assets are mainly French real estate, in proportion to the French property value. French death duties then apply at rates that depend on the kinship link between the deceased and each heir, with allowances that also depend on kinship, and the 1978 France-United States estate and gift tax convention, listed among the American estate and gift tax treaties published by the IRS, provides the credit mechanism that prevents the same bricks from bearing full death tax in both countries. Two American probate illusions die here. First, your Delaware letters testamentary, your executor appointment, and your revocable living trust do not operate the French house by themselves: the French notary settles the French succession under French conflicts rules, collects the French duties, and only then releases funds and transfers title, as our guide for the American surviving spouse in the French house illustrates for direct ownership. Second, placing the house in the LLC never removed it from French forced-heirship or French death tax; at most it changed the paperwork. Many owners react to all of this by asking whether to dissolve the LLC and take the house back into their own name. Sometimes that is right, but price it before touching anything: unwinding can trigger French registration duties on the transfer into your name, a French capital-gains computation at the entity level, American gain recognition depending on classification, and a new French holding-period clock for future exemptions. Get the French and American exit computations in writing, compare ten years of 2746 compliance costs against the one-time unwinding bill, and only then instruct the transfer. The families who overpay in this file are the ones who act first and compute second.
Conclusion
Your Delaware LLC does not shield your French house from French tax; under article 990 D it creates a French taxpayer that owes 3 percent of the January 1 market value every year, with every intermediary jointly liable and every return due by May 15. The good news is procedural: full yearly disclosure of the real January 1 owners on the 2746 track cancels the bill for single-owner structures, and the courts forgive nothing else, as the 2024 foundation ruling, the 2019 Austrian-foundation rejection, and the 2005 European reference together prove. The American side runs on separate rails: treaty Articles 6 and 13 give France first taxing rights over the rent and the gain, the United States taxes the same income worldwide and relieves double taxation through credits, and the LLC classification dictates a stack of information returns that exists even in vacant years. Sales concentrate every risk at the notary table, where the 244 bis A levy, the tax representative, and the unpaid 3 percent years collide, and deaths concentrate them at the succession table, where article 750 ter looks straight through your majority-held LLC to the bricks. Before this year May 15, assemble three documents: a French memo confirming the 2746 calendar and the valuation basis, an American memo stating the LLC classification and the full reporting stack with preparers named, and a ten-year comparison of compliant LLC ownership against a priced unwinding into your own name. If you hold through a French property company instead, read our SCI guide for Americans; if a sale is already planned, read our sale guide; if the owner has died, read our surviving-spouse guide. Then file, keep the proofs, and stop paying a tax that transparency erases.