KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
We Are Divorcing in France and I Want to Keep Our House: Buyout (Soulte), Preferential Award, the 1.10% Split Tax, and the US Tax Bill

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

We Are Divorcing in France and I Want to Keep Our House: Buyout (Soulte), Preferential Award, the 1.10% Split Tax, and the US Tax Bill

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You are an American living in France, or married to a French resident, and the marriage is ending. You own a house or an apartment together. Your spouse wants to sell it and split the money. You want to keep it: the children are in the local school, your life is here, and selling now would mean losing the home twice. The question you ask your lawyer is simple: can a divorcing spouse in France force the other to sell the family home, or can you buy out your spouse and stay? The answer has two halves. On the French side, the law gives you a real path to keep the house through a court-approved buyout called a soulte, sometimes through a preferential award of the home called the attribution préférentielle, but that award is never automatic in a divorce and the judge can order you to pay the buyout price immediately in cash. If you cannot pay, the house can still end up sold at auction through a licitation. On the money side, keeping the house costs a 1.10 percent French split duty called the droit de partage plus the notaire bill, and the American tax return treats the buyout very differently from a sale, with a federal nonrecognition rule for transfers incident to divorce and a treaty that leaves France first in line to tax real estate gains. This article walks through both halves in order: first how French law divides the property and how you keep the house, then what the buyout costs in France and how the IRS sees it.

I. How do you keep the house when you divorce in France: dividing the property, the preferential award, and the buyout payment?

Everything starts with one idea that surprises many Americans: divorce in France does not just end the marriage, it forces a full financial untangling called the liquidation of the matrimonial property regime. That liquidation decides who gets the house, who owes whom money, and how much the spouse who keeps the house must pay the other. The payment that balances an unequal split is the soulte, the French word for equalization or buyout payment. Understanding the liquidation is what lets you keep the house instead of losing it at auction.

A. What does the divorce really divide: community property, paybacks, and the half split?

If you married without signing a French marriage contract called a contrat de mariage, you are almost always under the default regime called the communauté réduite aux acquêts, the community of property limited to acquisitions. In plain terms, what each of you owned before the marriage, and what each received during the marriage by gift or inheritance, stays separate property called biens propres. Everything bought during the marriage, including the house bought with salaries earned during the marriage, belongs to the community, even if only one name is on the deed. American readers should pause here, because this is the opposite of the reflex many bring from separate-property states: the name on the French deed does not decide who owns the home. The date and the source of the money decide.

When the divorce dissolves the community, a notaire, the French public officer who settles property transfers and successions, draws up the liquidation. The liquidation runs in three steps. First, each spouse takes back separate property and claims, called reprises, such as the down payment one spouse made with premarital savings. Second, the accounts between each spouse and the community are settled through payments called récompenses. The classic example is community money used to improve one spouse’s separate apartment, or separate money used to pay down the joint mortgage. The governing rule is short and worth reading in full: La récompense est, en général, égale à la plus faible des deux sommes que représentent la dépense faite et le profit subsistant. In practice, that sentence means the payback is usually the smaller of the amount spent and the benefit that still exists, with protections when the spending was necessary or when borrowed money bought, kept, or improved an asset. Third, after every payback is taken from the common mass, the remainder is split equally: Après que tous les prélèvements ont été exécutés sur la masse, le surplus se partage par moitié entre les époux. That same article adds a useful detail for houses: if a community building sits next to, or is an annex of, a building one spouse owns separately, that spouse can demand to be awarded the community building against his or her share or for a buyout payment, valued on the day the award is requested.

Between the divorce and the final split, you and your spouse own everything together in a temporary joint ownership called indivision post-communautaire, post-community undivided ownership. Either spouse can ask to end it at any time, because the foundational rule of French co-ownership is absolute: Nul ne peut être contraint à demeurer dans l’indivision et le partage peut toujours être provoqué, à moins qu’il n’y ait été sursis par jugement ou convention. Nobody can be forced to stay in joint ownership, and a split can always be demanded, unless a court or an agreement has paused it. That is the provision your spouse’s lawyer quotes when demanding a sale. Your answer is the set of rules that channels that split toward a buyout instead of an auction.

Those channeling rules sit in one bridging article that every divorcing homeowner should know: Le partage de la communauté, pour tout ce qui concerne ses formes, le maintien de l’indivision et l’attribution préférentielle, la licitation des biens, les effets du partage, la garantie et les soultes, est soumis à toutes les règles qui sont établies au titre ” Des successions ” pour les partages entre cohéritiers. Toutefois, pour les communautés dissoutes par divorce, séparation de corps ou séparation de biens, l’attribution préférentielle n’est jamais de droit, et il peut toujours être décidé que la totalité de la soulte éventuellement due sera payable comptant. Two warnings hide in that second sentence, and both matter for an American counting on time to refinance. First, the preferential award of the house is never automatic in a divorce: the judge always has discretion to refuse it. Second, the judge can order the entire buyout payment due immediately in cash, which means a spouse who is awarded the house but cannot fund the soulte within the deadline can still lose it. Get the valuation, the financing, and the timing aligned before you ask for the house, not after.

One more protection exists for the spouse who owes the buyout over time. When payment deadlines have been granted, the law adjusts the debt if the property market moves sharply: Lorsque le débiteur d’une soulte a obtenu des délais de paiement et que, par suite des circonstances économiques, la valeur des biens qui lui sont échus a augmenté ou diminué de plus du quart depuis le partage, les sommes restant dues augmentent ou diminuent dans la même proportion, sauf exclusion de cette variation par les parties. If the house rises or falls by more than a quarter after the split, the remaining balance moves in the same proportion, unless the parties excluded that adjustment. In a volatile market, that clause belongs in your settlement agreement, the convention de divorce, in explicit terms.

B. Can the judge give you the house: the preferential award, the buyout price, and the auction fallback?

The attribution préférentielle, the preferential award, is the legal tool that lets one co-owner take a specific asset in the split and pay the others a soulte for the difference. It was written first for successions: the surviving spouse or any co-owner heir can request it for a business tied to his or her work, and the surviving spouse or heir can also request it for the home that was actually his or her residence, with its furnishings, for professional premises, and for farm equipment tied to a continuing lease. Through the bridging rule quoted above, divorcing spouses use the same tool for the marital home and its contents. For an American reader, the closest translation is a court-approved exclusive allotment of the home against a cash equalization, granted because that spouse actually lives there and needs it, not because that spouse wants it as an investment.

Three practical points decide whether you get it. First, actual residence controls. The spouse who genuinely lives in the home, especially with minor children, is the natural candidate; the spouse who moved to another country two years ago and rents the place out on a short-term platform is not. Gather proof early: utility bills, school certificates, tax notices, attestations from neighbors. Second, financing controls. The judge wants to know the house value on the day of the award, the exact soulte number, and how you will pay it: new mortgage offer called an offre de prêt, sale of other assets, or a payment schedule with guarantees. A request that says keep the house now and figure out the money later is the standard way to lose. Third, fault and fairness play a role at the margins. Misconduct does not automatically bar the award, but a judge weighing two equal candidates can consider who turned the home into a battleground, who paid the mortgage alone since separation, and who blocked every valuation attempt.

The strongest shield around this award comes from the Cour de cassation, France’s highest civil court, in a divorce case about exactly this scenario. A court of appeal had awarded the husband the former marital home as a preferential allotment, then added a forfeiture clause: if he failed to pay the soulte within six months after service of the decision, the house would be sold by private sale and, failing that, auctioned at the court. The husband challenged the clause, and the First Civil Chamber restated the governing principle word for word: Attendu que ce texte ne prévoit aucune cause de déchéance du droit à l’attribution préférentielle qu’il institue au profit d’un époux, lorsque la communauté a été dissoute par divorce, séparation de corps ou séparation de biens ; then drew the consequence: Qu’en statuant ainsi, la cour d’appel a violé le texte susvisé ; and it annulled the decision precisely on that point: CASSE ET ANNULE, mais seulement en ce qu’il dit qu’à défaut de versement de la soulte dans le délai de six mois à compter de la signification de la décision, il sera procédé à la vente amiable et à défaut à la licitation de l’immeuble situé lot 39 du lotissement Erima îlot C, cadastré section […], pour une contenance de 5 a 20 ca, l’arrêt rendu le 1er septembre 2016, entre les parties, par la cour d’appel de Papeete That ruling, First Civil Chamber, February 7, 2018, appeal number 16-26.892, is the passage to show any lawyer who drafts an automatic forfeiture of your award for late payment. The court can set consequences for nonpayment under general enforcement law, but it cannot write a self-executing loss of the preferential award into the judgment.

If neither spouse can fund a buyout, or if both demand the house and the judge awards it to neither, the fallback is the licitation, the court-ordered auction sale of the property to end the joint ownership. The tax code treats that outcome much more harshly than a buyout, as the second part explains, and the economics usually punish both sides: auction prices run below market, the notaire and court costs pile up, and the mortgage still has to be repaid from the proceeds. Tax law states the baseline bluntly: Les parts et portions indivises de biens immeubles acquises par licitation sont assujetties à l’impôt aux taux prévus pour les ventes des mêmes biens, with a reduced 2.50 percent duty only for buyouts by a former co-owner, spouse, ascendant, descendant, or universal successor. Every month spent refusing a realistic buyout number moves both spouses closer to that expensive exit, which is why serious negotiations start from a joint expert valuation rather than from each side’s wishful price.

A final French-law step that Americans often discover last is the mortgage. Keeping the house in the split does not automatically remove your spouse from the bank loan. You need a désolidarisation, the release of one co-borrower, negotiated with the lender alongside your new financing, plus a switch of the borrower insurance called assurance emprunteur to your name alone. Until the bank signs, your ex-spouse stays liable for the debt while no longer owning the house, a situation no divorce lawyer accepts for long. Line up the bank approval before the partage hearing, and make the award conditional on obtaining it where the judge allows such conditions.

II. What will the buyout cost you, and what will the IRS say: the 1.10 percent split duty, the notaire bill, and the American tax return?

Winning the house is only half the case. The other half is the check you write the day the split is signed, and the American tax return you file the following April. French transfer duties on a divorce buyout are far lighter than the 5 to 6 percent closing costs of a market purchase, but they are not zero, and the notaire fees, land-registry tax, and mortgage paperwork add their own layer. On the American side, the good news is that a buyout between divorcing spouses is usually not a taxable sale at all under federal law, while a later resale of the kept house stays reportable on both sides with France taxing first under the treaty. The two halves interact: money you pay in French duties is generally not creditable against US tax, so budget it as a sunk cost of keeping the home.

A. How much does France charge to let you keep the house: split duty, notaire fees, and the support payment trap?

The headline number is the droit de partage, the duty on partitions. The rule, with its divorce discount, reads: Les partages de biens meubles et immeubles entre copropriétaires, cohéritiers et coassociés, à quelque titre que ce soit, pourvu qu’il en soit justifié, sont assujettis à un droit d’enregistrement ou à une taxe de publicité foncière de 2,50 %. Ce taux est ramené à 1,80 % à compter du 1er janvier 2021 et à 1,10 % à compter du 1er janvier 2022, pour les partages des intérêts patrimoniaux consécutifs à une séparation de corps, à un divorce ou à une rupture d’un pacte civil de solidarité For a divorce split, the rate is therefore 1.10 percent of the net partitioned value, with a 25 euro minimum collection confirmed by the official public-service guide to the divorce property-split procedure and its companion page on the property-division rules between spouses. On a home with 400,000 euros of net equity being divided, the duty alone is 4,400 euros. The reduced rate covers splits of property interests following the divorce; related deeds, mortgage releases, and any side agreement that is really a disguised sale are taxed under their own rules, so the drafting of the partage deed matters down to the vocabulary.

On top of the duty comes the notaire cost stack. Because a house is involved, the split must be notarized in an acte de partage, a formal notarial partition deed, which is then published at the land registry through the publicité foncière. The stack typically includes the proportional notaire emoluments, the land-registry tax on the transfer, disbursements and formalities, the mortgage release fee called mainlevée d’hypothèque if the old loan is closed, and the new mortgage registration if you refinance the soulte. Ask the notaire for an itemized fee quote, a décompte, before signing anything, and check which costs each side bears: by default the split costs are shared, while the soulte financing costs sit with the spouse who keeps the house. Americans used to flat attorney fees should also note that French notaire emoluments follow a regulated sliding scale, so a second quote from another office should land in the same range; a large gap signals different assumptions about values or deeds, not a discount to chase.

The second French money question is the prestation compensatoire, the lump-sum payment that compensates, as far as possible, the living-standards gap the divorce creates. It is not the buyout: the soulte pays for property value received in the split, while the support payment compensates future lifestyle disparity. The statute opens with the architecture: Le divorce met fin au devoir de secours entre époux. Then it builds the payment: Cette prestation a un caractère forfaitaire. Elle prend la forme d’un capital dont le montant est fixé par le juge. The judge sets that capital sum using a needs-and-resources test that looks forward, not backward: La prestation compensatoire est fixée selon les besoins de l’époux à qui elle est versée et les ressources de l’autre en tenant compte de la situation au moment du divorce et de l’évolution de celle-ci dans un avenir prévisible. The listed factors include the length of the marriage, the age and health of each spouse, professional qualifications and situations, career sacrifices made for children or for the other spouse’s career, the foreseeable estates and incomes after liquidation, existing and foreseeable rights, and the foreseeable pension gap caused by those family choices. For the American spouse who paused a career abroad to raise children in France, the pension-rights factor is often the most valuable line in the file: document the missing US Social Security credits and the missing French trimesters alike.

The support payment can itself be paid in property, which is where it tangles with the house. The judge chooses among closed options: Le juge décide des modalités selon lesquelles s’exécutera la prestation compensatoire en capital parmi les formes suivantes : 1° Versement d’une somme d’argent, le prononcé du divorce pouvant être subordonné à la constitution des garanties prévues à l’article 277 ; 2° Attribution de biens en propriété ou d’un droit temporaire ou viager d’usage, d’habitation ou d’usufruit, le jugement opérant cession forcée en faveur du créancier. A property award operates as a forced transfer to the receiving spouse, but with one hard limit Americans dividing a French vacation home should know: the debtor spouse’s agreement is required for awarding, as support, property he or she received by inheritance or gift. Courts police the needs-and-resources test strictly. In one case the appeal court ordered a 60,000 euro capital payment through the award of property rights worth 120,000 euros, and the Cour de cassation annulled it for faulty reasoning, ruling: Qu’en se déterminant ainsi, sans prendre en considération, comme elle y était invitée, les sommes versées par M. Y… au titre de sa contribution à l’entretien et à l’éducation de sa fille R…, laquelle, constituant des charges, devait venir en déduction de ses ressources, la cour d’appel a privé sa décision de base légale ; and on the mirror argument: Qu’en se déterminant ainsi, sans rechercher, comme il le lui était demandé, si Mme X… ne partageait pas ses charges avec son nouveau compagnon, la cour d’appel a privé sa décision de base légale ; That decision, First Civil Chamber, July 4, 2018, appeal number 17-20.281, is a checklist for your file: prove your real charges including child-support contributions, and force the other side to disclose shared household costs with a new partner.

When the support payment takes the form of a right to use the house, valuation fights follow. In a January 2026 ruling the First Civil Chamber reviewed an award of an usufruit, a lifetime or long-term right to use and enjoy the former marital home, valued at 213,440 euros by applying a 40 percent rate tied to the recipient’s age under the tax scale, to a construction value of 533,600 euros carved out from a larger estate. The court annulled the award as reasoned, holding that a judge ordering support through an usufruit must account for the full legal framework governing that choice: CASSE ET ANNULE, mais seulement en ce qu’il alloue à Mme [Z] une prestation compensatoire sous forme d’attribution en usufruit de la maison, ancien domicile conjugal, située sur le territoire de la commune de [Localité 5], lieu-dit [Localité 3], cadastrée section B n° [Cadastre 1], et fixe la valeur de la prestation compensatoire à la somme de 213 440 euros, l’arrêt rendu le 6 septembre 2023, entre les parties, par la cour d’appel de Bastia, in First Civil Chamber, January 14, 2026, appeal number 23-22.958. The lesson for an American keeping the house is concrete: if your spouse seeks support as an usufruit over the home you want to own free and clear, challenge the valuation inputs one by one, the construction-only base, the age percentage, and the exclusion of the separate land, and push for cash instead so the title you recover is clean.

B. What does the buyout mean back home: federal nonrecognition, the treaty, and the later sale?

For the American tax return, the threshold question is whether buying out your spouse counts as buying property, which would be taxable to the seller, or as dividing marital property, which generally is not. Federal law answers with a special divorce rule, Internal Revenue Code section 1041, under which transfers of property between spouses, or between former spouses if incident to the divorce, are generally treated as gifts with no gain or loss recognized and with the recipient taking the transferor’s cost basis. The IRS guidance for divorced individuals in Publication 504 explains the scope and the timing conditions, including the one-year and six-year windows tied to the end of the marriage and the divorce instrument. A French partage that awards you the house against a soulte, signed as part of the divorce settlement, fits the natural core of that rule far better than a market sale does. The practical payoff is large: your ex-spouse generally recognizes no federal gain on the buyout itself, and you inherit his or her original cost basis in the transferred share, which sets your future gain when you eventually sell. Confirm the timing and the instrument with a US CPA before signing, because a buyout signed years after the divorce outside the statutory windows, or structured as a cash payment disconnected from the property transfer, can fall outside the protection.

The France-United States income tax treaty then allocates taxing rights the way every American homeowner should memorize: gains from real property situated in France may be taxed in France first. The IRS treaty documents page for France hosts the controlling texts, and the mechanism for the US side is the foreign tax credit claimed on Form 1116, which lets qualifying French income tax on the same gain offset the US tax on that gain within statutory limits. Two consequences follow for the divorcing owner. First, keeping the house through a soulte triggers no French capital-gains tax, because a partition is not a sale: there is no prix de cession, no sale price, and therefore no plus-value to compute. Second, if you later sell the kept house to a third party, both countries can tax the gain, France under its real-estate gain rules with its holding-period allowances, and the United States on your worldwide income with a credit for the French tax. Keep every paper from the divorce split, because the US basis computation will need the original purchase price, the refinancing history, and the soulte amount years later when memory has faded.

Do not confuse the French duties with creditable income tax. The 1.10 percent droit de partage and the land-registry tax are registration duties on the partition, not taxes on income, and they generally do not generate a US foreign tax credit. Budget them, with the notaire emoluments and the mortgage costs, as the sunk price of keeping the home. The same logic applies to the prestation compensatoire: a lump-sum capital payment between ex-spouses is neither deductible support nor taxable income at the federal level for post-2018 divorce instruments under current law, and French-side deductibility follows its own narrow conditions that your French counsel must verify. Get both advisers, French and American, on the same call before the partage deed is signed: the French notaire optimizes for a clean title and the lowest French duty, while the CPA protects the section 1041 treatment and the future basis, and each can wreck the other’s work with one badly drafted sentence.

Three reporting traps deserve explicit warnings. First, refinancing the soulte often moves large sums through French and American accounts in the same month; keep the transfer slips, because the paper trail proves the payment was part of the property division rather than a separate taxable deal. Second, if the buyout fails and the house goes to licitation to a third party, the transaction changes nature on both sides: France computes a real-estate capital gain for the sellers, and the United States taxes the sale with treaty relief, so the family that refused a 1.10 percent duty can end up paying full capital-gains tax in two countries. Third, the spouse who keeps the house and later returns to the United States does not escape French tax on a later French sale: nonresident sellers remain within the French gain rules with a withholding and representative mechanism, while the treaty credit follows them home. The through line is simple: a well-documented buyout now is the cheapest taxable event of the entire divorce, and a failed buyout that collapses into an auction is the most expensive.

Conclusion

An American divorcing in France can keep the family home, but the outcome is built, not granted. French law divides the community in halves after paybacks, lets either spouse demand an end to joint ownership, and offers the preferential award plus the soulte as the structured way to keep the house, with the judge free to refuse the award and to demand the buyout in cash. The 2018 ruling on appeal number 16-26.892 protects the award once granted against automatic forfeiture for late payment, while the 2018 ruling on appeal number 17-20.281 and the 2026 ruling on appeal number 23-22.958 show how strictly courts review support payments made in property or in rights over the house. The French cost of the buyout is dominated by the 1.10 percent split duty plus the notaire and registry stack, and the American return generally treats a timely divorce buyout as a nonrecognition transfer with carryover basis, leaving France first in line only when a real gain is later realized. Move in this order: commission a joint valuation, secure the bank’s release and refinancing in writing, ask the notaire for an itemized cost sheet, align the French deed language with the American CPA’s timing conditions, and only then request the preferential award. Kept on that sequence, the house stays yours without funding an auction that would have enriched everyone except the two people divorcing.

📄 Official circular