KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My Siblings and I Inherited a House in France and One of Us Will Not Sell: Indivision, Forced Sale, and the American Tax Tail

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My Siblings and I Inherited a House in France and One of Us Will Not Sell: Indivision, Forced Sale, and the American Tax Tail

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Your father died owning a stone house in the Dordogne. You live in Chicago, your sister lives in Boston, and your brother moved into the French house “temporarily” three years ago, pays no rent, pays none of the property tax, and refuses to discuss selling. The French notaire (the public officer who settles successions in France) tells you that the three of you own the house together in indivision, which is the French word for co-ownership without physical division of the property, and that your brother cannot be left in place forever but cannot be thrown out overnight either. This article explains exactly where you stand: what co-ownership in indivision means for American co-heirs, how the house is run while you disagree, how to buy each other out or force a sale through the French courts, what four recent and older Cour de cassation decisions change in practice, and what to clean up on the American tax side once the money moves. Every French term is explained the first time it appears, and every decisive legal statement is tied to the exact article or judgment behind it.

I. You Inherited a French House With Your Siblings and Now You Co-Own It in Indivision

A. What Indivision Means for American Co-Heirs: Automatic Co-Ownership, Shared Bills, and Shared Rent

Under French law, the moment your parent dies, the heirs automatically become co-owners of every asset in the estate that has not yet been divided. There is no need to sign anything to enter indivision. The closest American equivalent is a tenancy in common: each heir owns an undivided percentage called a quote-part, meaning a share of the whole rather than a defined bedroom or floor, and nobody owns any specific room. Your quote-part usually follows your hereditary share, so three children of the deceased generally hold one third each, subject to the surviving spouse’s rights and to any will choosing American law under the European Succession Regulation, points examined in earlier publications of this desk that you should confirm with the notaire settling your file.

The founding rule is short and absolute. Article 815 of the Civil Code states: “Nul ne peut être contraint à demeurer dans l’indivision et le partage peut toujours être provoqué, à moins qu’il n’y ait été sursis par jugement ou convention.” In plain English: no one can be forced to remain in co-ownership, and partition, called partage, meaning the legal operation that ends the co-ownership by allocating specific assets or cash to each heir, can always be demanded, unless a court judgment or a signed agreement has suspended it. Keep this sentence in mind, because it is the answer to every sibling who says the house can never be sold: Article 815 of the Civil Code.

While the indivision lasts, money in and money out follows the shares. Article 815-10 of the Civil Code provides: “Chaque indivisaire a droit aux bénéfices provenant des biens indivis et supporte les pertes proportionnellement à ses droits dans l’indivision.” Each co-owner, called an indivisaire, takes the profits and bears the losses in proportion to his or her share. Concretely, the taxe foncière, which is the annual French property tax paid by owners, the homeowner’s insurance, the roof repair, and the notaire’s distribution of any rent all split one third, one third, one third if you are three equal heirs. If your brother paid the property tax alone for two years, he holds a claim for reimbursement of your shares, and if he collected rent from a gîte on the property, that rent belongs to the indivision, not to him: Article 815-10 of the Civil Code.

Work done on the house also creates accounts between siblings. Article 815-13 of the Civil Code states: “Lorsqu’un indivisaire a amélioré à ses frais l’état d’un bien indivis, il doit lui en être tenu compte selon l’équité, eu égard à ce dont la valeur du bien se trouve augmentée au temps du partage ou de l’aliénation.” If a co-owner improved the property at his own expense, fairness requires crediting him for the added value measured at the time of partition or sale. The same article adds that necessary preservation expenses paid from personal funds must also be reimbursed even without added value, while the reverse applies to damage: “Inversement, l’indivisaire répond des dégradations et détériorations qui ont diminué la valeur des biens indivis par son fait ou par sa faute.” The co-owner answers for deterioration caused by his acts or fault. So the sibling who replaced the boiler keeps the receipts, the sibling who stripped the oak floors pays for the loss, and the final partition settles all these accounts at once: Article 815-13 of the Civil Code.

One more protection matters when a sibling has personal debts. Article 815-17 of the Civil Code provides: “Les créanciers personnels d’un indivisaire ne peuvent saisir sa part dans les biens indivis, meubles ou immeubles. Ils ont toutefois la faculté de provoquer le partage au nom de leur débiteur ou d’intervenir dans le partage provoqué par lui.” A sibling’s personal creditors cannot seize his undivided share of the French house directly, but they can force partition in his name or join a partition already started. American families should understand the consequence: a brother’s creditors cannot auction one third of the roof, yet they can push the whole house toward a court-ordered sale, which is one more reason to exit indivision on your own schedule rather than under pressure: Article 815-17 of the Civil Code.

B. Running the House While You Disagree: Two-Thirds Majority Votes, Tacit Mandates, and the Price of Living There Alone

Day-to-day management does not require unanimity. Article 815-3 of the Civil Code provides: “Le ou les indivisaires titulaires d’au moins deux tiers des droits indivis peuvent, à cette majorité : 1° Effectuer les actes d’administration relatifs aux biens indivis”, meaning the co-owners holding at least two thirds of the shares can perform management acts by that majority. Management acts, called actes d’administration, cover routine decisions: insuring the house, hiring a gardener, approving small repairs, and signing or renewing ordinary residential leases. Two siblings holding two thirds can therefore keep the house insured and rented without the third sibling’s signature, but they must inform the others, failing which their decisions cannot be enforced against them. Anything beyond normal operation, and any disposal such as selling or mortgaging, requires everybody’s consent: Article 815-3 of the Civil Code.

The same article recognizes real life. It states: “Si un indivisaire prend en main la gestion des biens indivis, au su des autres et néanmoins sans opposition de leur part, il est censé avoir reçu un mandat tacite, couvrant les actes d’administration mais non les actes de disposition ni la conclusion ou le renouvellement des baux.” If one sibling openly manages the property and nobody objects, the law presumes a tacit mandate covering management acts only, never sales and never leases. Your brother paying the insurance and arranging repairs while you thanked him by email is probably acting under this tacit mandate, which protects his routine decisions but gives him zero power to sell, mortgage, or grant himself a lease. Silence helps him manage; it never transfers ownership: Article 815-3 of the Civil Code.

Use of the house itself follows a simple principle. Article 815-9 of the Civil Code states: “Chaque indivisaire peut user et jouir des biens indivis conformément à leur destination, dans la mesure compatible avec le droit des autres indivisaires”, meaning each co-owner may use and enjoy the property consistently with its purpose and compatibly with the siblings’ equal rights. A brother spending two weeks each summer in the family house alongside everyone else owes nothing. A brother living there year-round while the others cannot use it owes an occupation indemnity, called indemnité d’occupation, because the article continues: “L’indivisaire qui use ou jouit privativement de la chose indivise est, sauf convention contraire, redevable d’une indemnité.” The co-owner who privately uses and enjoys the undivided property owes compensation unless otherwise agreed: Article 815-9 of the Civil Code.

The Cour de cassation, France’s supreme court for civil cases, strictly controls when this indemnity is due. On September 5, 2018, its First Civil Chamber quashed an appeal ruling that had charged a co-owner 300 euros per month merely because his furniture remained stored in the house, holding: “Qu’en se déterminant ainsi, sans rechercher, comme il le lui incombait, si l’occupation de l’immeuble par M. X… excluait la même utilisation par ses coïndivisaires, la cour d’appel n’a pas donné de base légale à sa décision” By deciding without examining, as it was required to do, whether the occupation excluded the same use by the co-owners, the appeal court gave no legal basis to its ruling, and the Court “CASSE ET ANNULE, mais seulement en ce qu’il fixe à la somme de 300 euros par mois le montant de l’indemnité d’occupation”, quashing the monthly amount. The lesson for siblings is precise: private use means use that excludes the others in law or in fact, and judges must verify that exclusion before charging rent: Cass. 1re civ., September 5, 2018, no. 17-22.439.

The newest decision every American family should know sets the time limit for claiming that money. On December 10, 2025, the First Civil Chamber restated the combined effect of Articles 815-9 and 815-10: “l’indivisaire qui use ou jouit privativement de la chose indivise est, sauf convention contraire, redevable d’une indemnité”, then notes that “aucune recherche relative aux fruits et revenus ne sera recevable plus de cinq ans après la date à laquelle ils ont été perçus ou auraient dû l’être”, and concludes: “Il en résulte qu’un co-indivisaire est en droit d’obtenir le paiement, au bénéfice de l’indivision, d’une indemnité d’occupation pour la période des cinq années qui précèdent sa demande” A co-owner is entitled to payment, for the benefit of the co-ownership, of an occupation indemnity covering the five years before the claim. The statute behind it reads: “Aucune recherche relative aux fruits et revenus ne sera, toutefois, recevable plus de cinq ans après la date à laquelle ils ont été perçus ou auraient pu l’être”: Article 815-10 of the Civil Code No claim about income and fruits is admissible more than five years after they were or could have been received. In practice, every year you wait without a written demand permanently erases one year of compensation, so the demand letter asserting the indemnity should go out early, even while negotiations continue: Cass. 1re civ., December 10, 2025, no. 23-22.620.

II. How to Get Out of the Indivision When One Sibling Will Not Sell

A. The Friendly Exits: Family Agreement, Buying Each Other Out, and the Preemption Right That Blocks Outside Buyers

The cheapest exit is a written family agreement organizing the co-ownership for a defined period. Article 1873-1 of the Civil Code provides: “Ceux qui ont des droits à exercer sur des biens indivis, à titre de propriétaires, de nus-propriétaires ou d’usufruitiers peuvent passer des conventions relatives à l’exercice de ces droits.” Holders of rights over undivided property, as owners, bare owners, or usufruct holders, may sign agreements governing how those rights are exercised. Such a convention d’indivision, meaning a co-ownership agreement, can allocate summer weeks, set the brother’s monthly compensation, create a joint repair fund, and schedule a sale date, all before a notaire or a lawyer: Article 1873-1 of the Civil Code.

But an agreement cannot lock anyone in forever. On October 3, 2000, the First Civil Chamber held, visa Articles 1873-2 and 1873-3: “Attendu qu’il résulte de ces textes que les coïndivisaires peuvent convenir de demeurer dans l’indivision pour une durée déterminée ou indéterminée ; que dans ce dernier cas, le partage peut être provoqué à tout moment, pourvu que ce ne soit pas de mauvaise foi ou à contretemps” Co-owners may agree to remain undivided for a fixed or indefinite period, and in the indefinite case partition can be demanded at any time, provided it is not done in bad faith or at an inappropriate moment. A brother who signed an open-ended agreement in 2019 cannot invoke it in 2026 to block the sale indefinitely; a five-year fixed agreement signed in 2024 can, until it expires. Choose the duration deliberately, because it temporarily switches off the Article 815 right to leave: Cass. 1re civ., October 3, 2000, no. 97-16.036.

The full friendly partition is the partage amiable, the amicable division. Article 835 of the Civil Code states: “Si tous les indivisaires sont présents et capables, le partage peut intervenir dans la forme et selon les modalités choisies par les parties. Lorsque l’indivision porte sur des biens soumis à la publicité foncière, l’acte de partage est passé par acte notarié.” If all co-owners are present and legally capable, partition can take whatever form and terms they choose, but where the property is subject to land registration, which every French house is, the partition deed must be drawn by a notaire. One sibling can therefore receive the house while paying the others a balancing cash amount called a soulte, or the house can be sold to a third party and the price split, with all the sibling accounts for taxes, repairs, rent, and occupation indemnities settled inside the same deed. American heirs living abroad sign through a procuration, a notarized power of attorney, usually legalized with an apostille, so nobody must fly to France for the closing: Article 835 of the Civil Code.

Families sometimes discover a paper their parents signed long ago that supposedly already divided everything. Caution is required. On March 6, 2013, the First Civil Chamber quashed a ruling that had treated as a donation-partage, the parental gift-partition, an instrument giving five of six children only undivided rights, holding: “l’acte litigieux, qui n’attribuait que des droits indivis à cinq des gratifiés, n’avait pu, à leur égard, opérer un partage”, the disputed instrument, which granted only undivided rights to five beneficiaries, could not operate as a partition for them, so that “cet acte s’analysait en une donation entre vifs ayant eu pour effet de faire sortir les biens du patrimoine des donateurs et de créer une indivision conventionnelle entre les donataires à laquelle il pouvait être mis fin dans les conditions prévues par l’article 1873-3 du code civil” The instrument was merely an ordinary lifetime gift that moved the property out of the parents’ estate and created a conventional co-ownership among the children that could be ended under Article 1873-3. If your parents’ old deed gave each child fractions rather than defined lots, you are in exactly this situation and any sibling can still demand partition: Cass. 1re civ., March 6, 2013, no. 11-21.892.

The last friendly mechanism protects the family against outsiders. If your sister wants to sell her one-third share to her boyfriend or a stranger, Article 815-14 of the Civil Code requires: “L’indivisaire qui entend céder, à titre onéreux, à une personne étrangère à l’indivision, tout ou partie de ses droits dans les biens indivis ou dans un ou plusieurs de ces biens est tenu de notifier par acte extrajudiciaire aux autres indivisaires le prix et les conditions de la cession projetée ainsi que les nom, domicile et profession de la personne qui se propose d’acquérir” A co-owner selling for value to an outsider must formally notify the siblings, through an acte extrajudiciaire, a formal notice served by a commissaire de justice, the French procedural officer formerly called huissier, stating the price, the conditions, and the buyer’s name, address, and occupation. Then: “Tout indivisaire peut, dans le délai d’un mois qui suit cette notification, faire connaître au cédant, par acte extrajudiciaire, qu’il exerce un droit de préemption aux prix et conditions qui lui ont été notifiés.” Any co-owner has one month from that notice to declare exercise of a preemption right, called droit de préemption, a buy-first right at the notified price and terms: Article 815-14 of the Civil Code.

This notification is a trap for the careless, as a Paris family learned. On January 5, 2012, the First Civil Chamber rejected an appeal against the annulment of both a sale of undivided rights to a property company and a related promise, approving the appeal court’s reasoning “que dès lors que chacune des promesses de vente avait été conclue à des dates distinctes et portait sur une partie des droits indivis, l’indivisaire vendeur devait notifier les conditions de la vente projetée à l’autre indivisaire, qui bénéficiait du droit de préemption prévu par l’article 815-14 du code civil”, since each sale promise was signed on different dates and covered part of the undivided rights, the seller had to notify the other co-owner, who held the Article 815-14 preemption right, and noting “qu’ayant relevé que la vente des droits indivis par acte authentique était intervenue le 19 avril 2006 au profit de la SCI Z… 148 sans que l’identité de l’acquéreur substitué ait été notifiée à Mme X…, la cour d’appel en a justement déduit que cette vente ainsi que la promesse de cession signée le 1er mars 2006 au profit de M. Z… étaient nulles, faute d’avoir été régulièrement notifiées à l’autre indivisaire” Because the notarized sale went to a substituted company whose identity was never notified, both transactions were void for lack of proper notification. Splitting the deal into separate promises, hiding the real buyer’s identity, or notifying only the price without the buyer’s details all lead to nullity, and siblings who learn of a secret sale should act within the one-month window and then move fast: Cass. 1re civ., January 5, 2012, no. 10-21.208.

B. The Court Exits: Judicial Partition, Auction Sale, and the American Tax Cleanup Afterward

When one sibling refuses every friendly solution, the court door is expressly open. Article 840 of the Civil Code states that partition claims go to court: “1° S’agissant du partage, lorsque l’un des indivisaires refuse de consentir au partage amiable, s’il s’élève des contestations sur la manière d’y procéder ou de le terminer”, for partition, where one co-owner refuses the amicable route or where disputes arise about how to proceed or finish. A refusal to sell, a dispute over the price, or a fight about the occupation indemnity each independently justifies filing. The summons, called assignation en partage, must be carefully drafted because Article 1360 of the Code of Civil Procedure requires, on pain of inadmissibility: “l’assignation en partage contient un descriptif sommaire du patrimoine à partager et précise les intentions du demandeur quant à la répartition des biens ainsi que les diligences entreprises en vue de parvenir à un partage amiable.” The summons must summarize the property to divide, state what division the claimant seeks, and list the steps already taken toward a friendly settlement. Judges check this: a file showing a serious buyout offer and a mediation attempt starts far better than a file showing nothing but anger: Article 840 of the Civil Code and Article 1360 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

The court procedure typically appoints a notaire to value the property, draw up the accounts between siblings, and propose lots, while the judge rules on contested points such as the indemnity amount or the reimbursement of works. If the house can be physically divided without loss, which almost never happens with a single family home, each sibling receives a lot, if needed with balancing soultes. Otherwise comes the licitation, the court-ordered auction sale of undivided property. Article 1686 of the Civil Code provides: “Si une chose commune à plusieurs ne peut être partagée commodément et sans perte”, if a thing owned in common cannot be conveniently divided without loss, then “La vente s’en fait aux enchères, et le prix en est partagé entre les copropriétaires.” It is sold at auction and the price is divided among the co-owners. Siblings may bid at the auction themselves, which often happens when one of them truly wants to keep the house but could never agree on the price privately, and the sale terms are set by specifications called cahier des charges, approved by the court: Article 1686 of the Civil Code.

Expect the judicial route to take eighteen months to three years for a contested file, with notaire and lawyer fees, valuation costs, and auction advertising deducted from the price before distribution, plus the occupation indemnity and expense reimbursements credited and debited in the same accounts. The delay is painful, but filing has an immediate strategic effect: the five-year indemnity clock is anchored by a formal demand, the accounts stop growing silently, and many blocking siblings accept a buyout once the auction notice becomes real. Never file lightly, because costs advanced by the estate reduce everyone’s share, yet never fear filing, because Article 815 guarantees the exit and Article 840 organizes it.

After the money arrives, American heirs face the second file: United States tax. Each sibling reports his or her share of French rental income, if any, on the American return, with the French tax paid available under the foreign tax credit mechanics that prior publications of this desk have detailed for rental and sale income. The partition itself, the soulte received, and the auction proceeds each carry French and American characterization questions, gift versus sale versus inheritance basis issues, that differ from the French treatment, and foreign account filings such as the FBAR and Form 8938, plus Form 3520 if a foreign gift or trust distribution is involved, must reflect the French notaire’s distributions. The France-United States estate and gift tax treaty, which allocates primary taxing rights over French real property to France with a credit mechanism on the American side, frames the whole picture but does not replace individual computation. Coordinate the French notaire’s distribution statement, called décompte de partage, with an American CPA before spending a dollar, because the French deed fixes numbers the IRS will later ask about.

Conclusion

You cannot be forced to stay in indivision, but nobody will exit it for you. Start by having the notaire confirm each sibling’s quote-part and pull together the accounts: taxes paid, repairs funded, rent collected, and months of exclusive occupation. Send a written demand covering the occupation indemnity before the five-year window eats your oldest years. Offer a documented buyout with a soulte or a joint listing with a broker, notify any outside sale properly to preserve the preemption right, and if the blocking sibling still refuses, file an assignation en partage that shows the court every friendly step you already took. The auction is the last resort, not a failure: it converts a frozen house into divisible cash and closes accounts that polite silence only made worse. Handled in this order, the French procedure and the American tax cleanup fit together, and the house your parents left stops being a family dispute and becomes what it should have been all along, an inheritance.

📄 Official circular