KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
The French Tax Office Taxed Your American Trust: 2026 Court Rulings on the 990 J Levy, the 20,000 EUR Reporting Fine, and How to Answer

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

The French Tax Office Taxed Your American Trust: 2026 Court Rulings on the 990 J Levy, the 20,000 EUR Reporting Fine, and How to Answer

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Your California estate lawyer told you a revocable living trust was the responsible choice. You signed it, you moved your French vacation house or your Paris bank accounts into it, and you named your children as the successor beneficiaries. Under American law, the arrangement works exactly as promised: the trustee holds legal title, you keep lifetime control, and your family avoids probate when you die. Then a letter arrives from the French tax office, the direction générale des finances publiques, and the numbers on it do not look like anything your American lawyer described. A yearly levy on the trust assets. A 20,000 euro fine for each unfiled trust return. A reassessment going back several years, with late interest on top. In the spring of 2026 alone, French courts handed down decisions putting assessments close to one million euros on trusts connected with France, while the highest French commercial court sent a landmark trust case back for retrial on a treaty question that also matters for American families. This guide explains, in plain English, why France taxes a legal creature it does not recognize, which three French tax bills your American trust can trigger, what the courts decided in 2025 and 2026, and the exact defense file to build when the assessment letter lands on your desk. Every French term is explained the first time it appears, and every decisive legal statement is tied to the statute, decision, or official guidance that supports it.

I. Why France Taxes Your American Living Trust Even Though It Does Not Recognize It

To understand every bill and every form described below, you must accept one uncomfortable starting point. Under French property law, the owner of your French house is a human being or a company, never a common-law trust. France never adopted the trust as a form of ownership. Yet since 2011 France has taxed trusts by name, forced trustees to declare trust assets every year, punished silence with a flat fine, and applied a yearly levy to trust property connected with France. Ownership and taxation live on two different tracks, and your American trust runs on both at once.

A. What France Calls a Trust and Why Your Revocable Living Trust Qualifies

French tax law gives the trust a deliberately wide definition. Article 792-0 bis, I, of the French General Tax Code provides, in the original French: « on entend par trust l’ensemble des relations juridiques créées dans le droit d’un Etat autre que la France par une personne qui a la qualité de constituant, par acte entre vifs ou à cause de mort, en vue d’y placer des biens ou droits, sous le contrôle d’un administrateur, dans l’intérêt d’un ou de plusieurs bénéficiaires ou pour la réalisation d’un objectif déterminé ». In English: any legal arrangement created under the law of a country other than France, by a person called the constituant (the settlor, meaning you), by lifetime act or on death, to place property or rights under the control of an administrateur (the trustee) for one or more bénéficiaires (beneficiaries) or a stated purpose. A California, New York, or Delaware revocable living trust fits that sentence perfectly. It does not matter that your trust is revocable, that you are your own trustee, or that American law sees through it for income tax purposes. For the French definition, the only questions are whether the arrangement was created under foreign law and whether someone controls property for someone else’s benefit.

The same article closes the most common escape route American families imagine. Where the trust was set up by a professional or a company, the individual who actually placed the property into it counts as the settlor. And a beneficiary can be reclassified as a settlor after the settlor’s death, which is how the tax office keeps taxing the assets when the second generation starts receiving them. Do not confuse this trust with the only domestic cousin France knows: the fiducie. Article 2011 of the French Civil Code defines it as follows: « La fiducie est l’opération par laquelle un ou plusieurs constituants transfèrent des biens, des droits ou des sûretés, ou un ensemble de biens, de droits ou de sûretés, présents ou futurs, à un ou plusieurs fiduciaires qui, les tenant séparés de leur patrimoine propre, agissent dans un but déterminé au profit d’un ou plusieurs bénéficiaires. » The fiducie is a narrow, contract-based French device with its own registry and its own tax regime. Your American living trust is not a fiducie, it cannot become one by re-labeling, and no American notarial certificate will persuade a French notaire (the public officer who alone authenticates French real-estate transfers) or the land registry, the fichier immobilier, to register a trust as owner. The practical companion to this article, which explains why the trust fails as a title-holding device and what actually works for the succession, is our guide on why an American living trust fails for a French house and what actually works. This article answers the next question: once France sees through the trust to you, what does it charge?

The first charge is not a tax at all but a paperwork duty with teeth. Article 1649 AB of the General Tax Code requires the trustee to declare, in the original French: « 1° La constitution, la modification ou l’extinction, ainsi que le contenu des termes du trust ; 2° Les informations relatives aux nom, prénoms, adresse, date, lieu de naissance et nationalité des bénéficiaires effectifs des trusts », plus « La valeur vénale au 1er janvier de l’année » of the property placed in the trust. In plain terms: every creation, amendment, or termination of the trust with its full terms; the full identity of every real human being behind it, meaning the trustee, the settlor, each beneficiary, any protecteur (protector), and anyone exercising effective control; and the fair market value of the trust property each January 1. The duty falls on the trustee whenever the settlor or at least one beneficiary has a French tax home, whenever the trust holds property or rights located in France, whenever a trustee based outside the European Union buys French real estate or starts a business relationship in France, and whenever the trustee personally has a French tax home. In practice the tax administration operates two returns: Form 2181-TRUST1 for each creation, amendment, or termination, and Form 2181-TRUST2, the annual return of the January 1 market value, due each year by June 15 at the nonresidents tax office, as the official tax doctrine explains in BOI-DJC-TRUST. Miss either return and the fine is flat and severe. Article 1736, IV bis, of the General Tax Code states, word for word: « Les infractions à l’article 1649 AB sont passibles d’une amende de 20 000 €. » Twenty thousand euros per violation, with no sliding scale. A trustee who ignored five years of annual returns is looking at five separate fines before a single euro of tax is even discussed.

B. The Three French Tax Bills Your American Trust Can Trigger

Once the trust is on the radar, three separate tax charges can apply, and they stack. The first is the yearly levy most American families discover in the assessment letter. Article 990 J of the General Tax Code opens with this sentence: « Les personnes physiques constituants ou bénéficiaires d’un trust défini à l’article 792-0 bis sont soumises à un prélèvement fixé au tarif le plus élevé mentionné au 1 de l’article 977. » Individuals who settled or benefit from a qualifying trust pay a levy at the highest rate of the real-estate wealth tax scale. The levy is owed on worldwide trust property by persons with a French tax home, and on French-situated trust property by everyone else, assessed on net market value each January 1. Two statutory exits exist: property already included in a properly declared wealth-tax base, and property declared under Article 1649 AB by a person who owes no wealth tax given the size of the estate. Courts describe this levy openly as a sanction for non-declaration: the Bobigny court wrote in 2025 that the prélèvement sui generis, meaning a one-of-a-kind levy, « a pour objet de sanctionner le défaut de déclaration au titre de l’ISF des biens placés dans un trust » (Bobigny judicial court, October 23, 2025, case 23/02471), exists to punish the failure to declare trust property for the former solidarity wealth tax, the impôt de solidarité sur la fortune. Declare every year and the levy generally has no base to bite; stay silent and it compounds year after year at the top rate, exactly as the million-euro assessments below demonstrate.

The second bill arrives at death, and it is the heaviest. Article 750 ter of the General Tax Code pulls trust property expressly into French death and gift taxation: when the deceased or donor had a French tax home, it catches movable and immovable property anywhere in the world, « biens ou droits composant un trust défini à l’article 792-0 bis et produits qui y sont capitalisés », and when the deceased or donor lived abroad, it catches the French-situated property including trust assets and capitalized income. The detailed rates sit in Article 792-0 bis, II. Transfers by gift or succession of trust property pay standard French transfer tax based on the family link between the settlor and the beneficiary. Where neither gift nor succession labels fit, for example when assets stay inside the trust after the settlor dies, the statute imposes death transfer tax under graduated fallbacks: a determined share for an identified beneficiary is taxed by family link; a share owed globally to the settlor’s descendants is taxed at the top rate of the first tax table; everything left is taxed at the top rate of the third tax table, which practitioners know as the 60 percent strangers rate. And there is a tripwire built for American families who moved property into a trust after settling in France: when the trust was created after May 11, 2011 while the settlor had a French tax home, gift and death taxes are due at that same top third-table rate. The trustee pays these death taxes to the tax collector within the succession-filing deadlines running from the settlor’s death, with a detailed estimated return naming the beneficiaries; if the trustee answers to the law of a non-cooperative state or a state with no recovery-assistance treaty with France and does not pay, the beneficiaries are jointly liable and must file the return themselves.

The third bill is the one American parents never expect: the forced share of the children. French law reserves a fraction of every estate for the children, the réserve hériditaire, and no American will or trust clause can simply delete it for French-situated property. Article 913 of the Civil Code caps lifetime and testamentary gifts at one-half of the estate with one child, one-third with two children, and one-quarter with three or more. Since 2021 the same article adds a compensatory levy, the prélèvement compensatoire, for cross-border families: « Lorsque le défunt ou au moins l’un de ses enfants est, au moment du décès, ressortissant d’un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou y réside habituellement et lorsque la loi étrangère applicable à la succession ne permet aucun mécanisme réservataire protecteur des enfants, chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès, de façon à être rétablis dans les droits réservataires que leur octroie la loi française, dans la limite de ceux-ci. » A trust that channels the French house to one child, to a surviving spouse, or to charity while leaving another child with nothing invites that child to claw back the French assets up to the reserved share. Our full guide to that mechanism is the article on forced heirship and the 2021 safety net for American families. The point for trust planning is simple: funding an American trust with the French house does not move the house out of the children’s reserved-share calculation.

II. How to Answer a French Trust Tax Assessment After the 2025-2026 Court Rulings

French trust litigation used to be a desert with a handful of old rulings. That era is over. Between October 2025 and March 2026, three courts decided trust tax cases on the merits, and in February 2026 the Commercial Chamber of the Court of Cassation, the Court of Cassation, France’s highest court for tax disputes, quashed an appellate victory by a trust administrator and restated the test every treaty-based defense must now pass. Read together, these four decisions draw the map: what the tax office must prove, where families actually win, and which arguments now fail.

A. What the Courts Just Decided: Oscar II, EL AL, and the Jersey Will Trust

The most important decision is the newest. On February 11, 2026, the Commercial, Financial and Economic Chamber of the Court of Cassation decided appeal number Z 23-14.305, quashing a February 6, 2023 ruling of the Paris Court of Appeal. The facts read like many American files with Canada in place of the United States. A French resident, Mrs. W, set up a Canadian-law trust called Oscar II in 1986 holding financial assets. During a documentary audit she admitted the trust’s existence. On July 31, 2017, the tax administration notified the trustee, Mr. T, of reassessments for 2012 through 2015 under Article 990 J, and Mr. T sued for full discharge. The Paris appeal court granted the discharge, reasoning that the trust counted as a person under the 1975 France-Canada tax treaty so that its assets were taxable in Canada, and that taxing the same assets again in France against the trustee would be treaty-barred double taxation. The Court of Cassation annulled that entire ruling. Its doctrinal core deserves quotation because it now governs every treaty defense, including American ones: « Selon le troisième de ces textes, les personnes physiques constituants ou bénéficiaires d’un trust défini à l’article 792-0 bis sont soumises à un prélèvement fixé au tarif le plus élevé mentionné au 1 de l’article 977 », and then the operative holding: « En se déterminant ainsi, sans rechercher, comme il lui incombait, si la Convention s’appliquait au prélèvement sur les trusts prévu à l’article 990 J du code général des impôts, et, en particulier, si ce prélèvement, institué après la date de la signature de la Convention, constituait un impôt de nature identique ou analogue à ceux qu’elle vise, la cour d’appel n’a pas donné de base légale à sa décision. » In English: the appeal court ruled without asking, as it was required to ask, whether the treaty even covered the 990 J trust levy, and particularly whether that levy, created after the treaty’s signature, was an identical or similar tax to those the treaty covers. The case goes back to a differently composed Paris bench, the trustee bears the court costs, and he was ordered to pay the tax administration 3,000 euros under Article 700 of the Code of Civil Procedure. For American families, the lesson is direct even though the treaty there was the Canadian one: the France-United States tax treaty signed in Paris on August 31, 1994 contains no trust-specific clause, so any defense that the treaty shields the trust assets must prove, tax by tax, that the 990 J levy or the related charge is an identical or similar tax covered by the treaty. Courts will no longer accept a general appeal to the treaty’s spirit.

The two trial-level judgments show how that strictness plays out in euros. On October 23, 2025, the Bobigny judicial court decided case 23/02471 against the taxpayer on every claim. The settlor, Mrs. Z, lived in Switzerland. Her trust, named EL AL, held all the shares of a Luxembourg company, MIA Real Estate, which in 1994 had bought a house in the Var region of southern France. She challenged the regional tax director’s January 13, 2023 rejection of her claim, and the court confirmed the regional tax director’s January 13, 2023 rejection of her claim in full, dismissed every one of her claims, ordered her to pay the court costs, and recalled that the judgment carries provisional enforcement, meaning the tax office collects while any appeal runs. The structure, Swiss resident, Luxembourg company, French villa, changed nothing: French-situated property inside a foreign trust stays within the levy.

On March 25, 2026, the Paris judicial court decided cases 23/02365 and 23/02366 on a Jersey will trust, the C. T. Will Trust, and the numbers explain why trustees now settle. The beneficiary received half the trust income for life, with a Jersey company taking the capital. The trustee had filed the annual 2181 Trust 2 returns for 2013 through 2017, but the administration treated the beneficiary as a deemed settlor, applied the 1.5 percent top-rate levy, and issued a collection notice on November 29, 2019 for 954,511 euros, consisting of 827,702 euros of principal and 126,809 euros of late interest. The court rehearsed the statutory chain word for word, starting with the definition: « Pour l’application du présent code, on entend par trust l’ensemble des relations juridiques créées dans le droit d’un Etat autre que la France », then the wealth-tax attachment rule that pulls trust property into the deemed settlor’s base at net market value each January 1. It then rejected the constitutional attack by recalling that in decision 2017-679 QPC of December 15, 2017, the Constitutional Council held the attachment rule consistent with the Constitution, finding that Parliament meant to tax the spending power that holding such property confers and built a rebuttable presumption for anti-fraud purposes, leaving the settlor or deemed settlor able to prove the property gives them no spending power at all. The outcome was mixed but stern: « REJETTE la demande de décharge totale de l’imposition litigieuse et prononce une décharge partielle », no full discharge, only a partial one reducing the base to a one-third share of the trust assets, with the court fixing the declared asset values year by year, starting at 20,532,141 euros on January 1, 2013 and 21,072,767 euros on January 1, 2014, and ordering the administration to recompute. Filing the annual returns did not save the trust, because the returns went to the wrong base theory; only proving the exact beneficial share moved the number, and even the winner still owed tax on one-third of a twenty-million-euro base.

B. Your Defense File: Treaty Protection, Correction, and Parallel United States Filings

If the assessment letter has arrived, or if you hold French property through an American trust and want to act before it does, build the file in four layers, in this order. First, reconstruct the trust’s French timeline with documents, not memories. The notaire handling the French property needs the complete trust deed with all amendments, certified translations into French, proof of which assets sit inside the trust and their January 1 values, and the identity papers of every settlor, trustee, beneficiary, and protector. Where the trust deed was never translated or the French house was moved into the trust by an American assignment the land registry never recorded, fix the title chain first, because every tax argument assumes the administration knows exactly what property it is taxing and in whose hands. Our guide on buying a French house as an American explains the transfer formalities the trust document alone cannot satisfy, and the guide on French succession for American heirs maps the settlement procedure the trustee will face at death.

Second, test the treaty defense the way the Court of Cassation now requires. Identify each French charge separately, the 990 J levy, the reporting fines, the death-transfer tax, and ask for each whether the France-United States treaty covers it as an identical or similar tax, rather than invoking the treaty as a blanket shield. The Oscar II ruling makes that test mandatory, and the Bobigny and Paris judgments show courts enforcing the levy where the test is not met. This analysis belongs to a French tax lawyer working from the treaty text and the official commentary, not to a feeling that two countries should not tax the same house twice. Where the treaty does not cover the levy, the argument shifts to the statute itself: was the property correctly valued, was the deemed-settlor reclassification correctly applied to your share, and do the exemption cases, property already in a declared wealth-tax base or property declared under Article 1649 AB by a person below the wealth-tax threshold, remove the base? The Paris one-third ruling proves that fighting over the exact beneficial share is where real money is saved.

Third, regularize the returns before the dispute hardens. File the missing 2181-TRUST1 event returns and the 2181-TRUST2 annual returns with the nonresidents office, pay or provision the 20,000 euro fines per violation, and attach the valuations the administration can verify. Voluntary correction does not erase the fines, but it stops the yearly levy from compounding on an undeclared base, it opens the statutory exits that require declared property, and it changes the negotiation posture from concealment to compliance. Where the trust holds a French house that produces rent, align that income with the correct French return as well: our guide on renting out a French house as an American covers the furnished-rental regimes the trustee often overlooks, and the guide on selling a French house as an American covers the capital-gains computation when the trust disposes of the property.

Fourth, keep the American side of the file current, because the Internal Revenue Service runs its own trust reporting in parallel and one country’s paperwork never satisfies the other’s. The IRS foreign-trust reporting rules require United States persons connected with foreign trusts to file Form 3520, the annual return reporting transactions with foreign trusts and the receipt of certain foreign gifts, while a foreign trust with a United States owner is covered by Form 3520-A, the foreign trust’s own annual information return, all under Section 6048 of the Internal Revenue Code, with penalties measured as a share of the amounts involved. A French resident American with a Delaware trust holding a Nice apartment can therefore owe the French 2181 returns, the French levy, and the American 3520 family of returns on the same arrangement in the same year. Coordinate the valuations so the January 1 French market value and the American information returns tell one consistent story. Where the estate plan also uses life-insurance savings, note the boundary: French assurance-vie death benefits follow their own levies under Article 990 I and, for premiums paid after age seventy, Article 757 B of the General Tax Code, not the trust rules, as our assurance-vie and PFIC guide explains. And where the trust was created after your move to France, have counsel check the May 11, 2011 tripwire in Article 792-0 bis, II directly: post-2011 funding by a French-domiciled settlor pushes death taxation to the top third-table rate, the single most expensive line in the statute.

Conclusion

France will never register your American living trust as the owner of your French house, and it will tax the trust anyway. That is the whole subject in one sentence. The definition in Article 792-0 bis catches every revocable living trust created under American law. Article 1649 AB forces the trustee to declare the trust’s creation, its amendments, its beneficiaries, and its January 1 value every year, at a price of 20,000 euros per missed return. Article 990 J applies a yearly top-rate levy to undeclared trust property, Article 750 ter and Article 792-0 bis, II pull the property into French gift and death taxation with rates that climb to the top strangers bracket, and Article 913 lets a disinherited child claw back the French assets. The courts of 2025 and 2026 enforce each of these lines: full confirmation of the assessment in Bobigny, a near-million-euro bill cut only to one-third in Paris, and a Court of Cassation ruling that makes every treaty defense prove, tax by tax, that the levy is an identical or similar tax the treaty covers. The families who pay least are the ones who file first, value honestly, argue the exact beneficial share with documents, and keep the American 3520 returns consistent with the French 2181 returns. Bring your trust deed, your valuations, and your assessment letter to a lawyer who reads both tax systems, and do it before the next June 15 deadline adds another line to the bill.

📄 Official circular