Robert is 68, a retired engineer from Texas. He owns a two-bedroom apartment in the 11th arrondissement of Paris, bought fifteen years ago when his consulting work brought him to France several months a year. He is married for the second time, has a son from his first marriage with whom relations broke down a decade ago, and a daughter from his second marriage to whom he is very close. His Texas will leaves everything to his wife, then to his daughter. His Texas lawyer told him the will controls. Then a Paris notaire — the public officer who alone settles estates that include French real property — tells the family that the son holds a protected share in the Paris apartment that no will can simply erase, that gifts Robert made years ago can be pulled back into the calculation, and that choosing American law in the will changes much less than Robert assumed. This moment of shock is the most common crisis American families face with French assets, and it is entirely preventable once you understand three French mechanisms: the réserve héréditaire (the protected share of children, often called forced heirship), the action en réduction (the lawsuit that claws back excessive gifts), and the prélèvement compensatoire (the compensatory levy created in 2021 that reaches French assets even when a foreign law governs the succession).
This guide explains, in plain American English, how much of your French estate your children are guaranteed, how courts enforce that guarantee against wills and lifetime gifts alike, what an American choice of law in your will can and cannot do under the European Succession Regulation, and how the United States-France estate tax treaty prevents your children from paying full death taxes twice on the same Paris apartment. Every French legal term is explained the first time it appears, every decisive rule is quoted from its official text, and the final section gives you a practical checklist to put your paperwork in order while everyone is alive to sign.
I. Why your American power to disinherit stops at the French border
In most American states, a competent adult can disinherit an adult child almost entirely: the will controls, and the disinherited child receives nothing, subject only to narrow protections for a surviving spouse and, in Louisiana, a particular forced-heirship tradition of its own. France works the other way around. Children — including adult, independent, and even estranged children — are héritiers réservataires, meaning heirs with a protected share. The surviving spouse, by contrast, is not a protected heir in this sense, although the law grants the spouse separate safeguards and a full exemption from French death taxes, as explained below. Once you own real property in France, this protection attaches to the French assets regardless of your nationality, and your American will cannot waive it on your children’s behalf.
A. How much can you really give to anyone when you leave one, two, or three children?
The starting definitions come from Article 912 of the Civil Code, which states: “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent. La quotité disponible est la part des biens et droits successoraux qui n’est pas réservée par la loi et dont le défunt a pu disposer librement par des libéralités.” In American terms: the protected share is the slice of the estate the law delivers to certain heirs clear of charges, if they accept the succession; the quotité disponible, or disposable portion, is everything else — the only slice you may allocate by lifetime gift or by will to anyone you choose, whether that is your spouse, one favored child, a friend, or a charity.
The size of each slice is fixed by Article 913 of the Civil Code: “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” Put in numbers an American reader can use immediately: with one child, the protected share is one-half of the estate and you may dispose of one-half as you wish; with two children, the protected share is two-thirds (one-third per child) and you may dispose of one-third; with three or more children, the protected share is three-quarters and you may dispose of one-quarter. Take Robert’s Paris apartment, worth 600,000 euros, plus 300,000 euros in French bank and investment accounts — a 900,000-euro French estate. Robert has two children. The protected share is 600,000 euros, or 300,000 euros per child, and the disposable portion is 300,000 euros. His will leaving everything to his wife and daughter gives the wife and daughter 900,000 euros and the son nothing; the son’s 300,000-euro protected share is short by the full 300,000 euros, and the law gives him a direct action to recover it, as the next section explains.
Three practical consequences follow that surprise Americans most. First, the protected heir must accept the succession to claim the protection: a child who formally renounces the inheritance — the renonciation à la succession, executed before a notaire or the court registry within strict deadlines — is generally not counted, unless that child is represented by his or her own children or must account for a gift already received. Second, only descendants are protected heirs today: since the 2006 reform of successions, parents and siblings are no longer protected heirs, so an American without children but with living parents regains broad power to allocate by will. Third, lifetime gifts count exactly like testamentary gifts against the disposable portion: the 200,000 euros Robert gave his daughter five years ago toward her Brooklyn down payment is added back into the calculation on his death, a mechanism called fictitious reunion that the next section details. Gifts do not escape the protected share by being made early.
Note carefully what this means for blended families, which are the classic American fact pattern in Paris notarial offices. You cannot use a will to leave the Paris apartment entirely to your second spouse and nothing to the children of your first marriage. The children of the first marriage each hold their protected fraction of the whole French estate, and the surviving spouse takes only within the disposable portion plus whatever specific spousal rights apply. If your goal is to favor your spouse as much as French law allows — for example by giving the spouse the largest permitted share or a lifetime right to live in the apartment — that result must be engineered inside the disposable portion and inside the matrimonial property regime, not by disinheriting the children. A Texas will that ignores this architecture does not fail everywhere: it may still govern your Texas house and your American accounts, but the Paris notaire will settle the French assets under French protective rules, and the children can compel him to do so.
B. How can your children claw back gifts you already made, even years ago?
The protected share would be an empty promise if a parent could defeat it by giving everything away before death. French law therefore gives each protected heir an action en réduction, a personal lawsuit to reduce excessive gifts — whether made by lifetime donation or by will — down to the disposable portion. Article 921 of the Civil Code reserves this action strictly to the protected persons: “La réduction des dispositions entre vifs ne pourra être demandée que par ceux au profit desquels la loi fait la réserve, par leurs héritiers ou ayants cause : les donataires, les légataires, ni les créanciers du défunt ne pourront demander cette réduction, ni en profiter.” Only the protected heir, or that heir’s own heirs and successors, may sue; the recipients of the gifts, the legatees, and the creditors of the deceased can neither demand the reduction nor benefit from it. If Robert’s son never acts, the excessive gifts stand; if he acts in time, they fall back to the lawful measure.
Time limits matter enormously for American families who discover the problem late. The same Article 921 provides: “Le délai de prescription de l’action en réduction est fixé à cinq ans à compter de l’ouverture de la succession, ou à deux ans à compter du jour où les héritiers ont eu connaissance de l’atteinte portée à leur réserve, sans jamais pouvoir excéder dix ans à compter du décès.” In practice: five years from the death, or two years from the day the heirs learned that their protected share was impaired, with an absolute ceiling of ten years from the death. An American child who learns three years after the death, from a French cousin or from a newly found will, that a Paris apartment was given entirely to a sibling, still has a two-year window from that discovery, capped at ten years from the death. Conversely, a family that waits twelve years before consulting a lawyer will find the action extinguished. The notaire settling the succession has a statutory duty to warn: when the officer sees that lifetime gifts may have impaired a protected share, he must inform each affected and known heir individually, if possible before any partition, of the right to demand reduction. American heirs should therefore read every letter from a French notarial office as potentially time-sensitive, answer it, and seek advice before signing any partition deed — the acte de partage that divides the estate — because signing without reserves can complicate a later claim.
The calculation itself is performed through a masse fictive, a recomposed fictional total. Article 922 of the Civil Code directs: “La réduction se détermine en formant une masse de tous les biens existant au décès du donateur ou testateur.” To that existing property the officer fictitiously reunites lifetime gifts: “Les biens dont il a été disposé par donation entre vifs sont fictivement réunis à cette masse, d’après leur état à l’époque de la donation et leur valeur à l’ouverture de la succession, après qu’en ont été déduites les dettes ou les charges les grevant.” Debts and encumbrances are deducted, donated property is valued as of the death (in the condition it was in when given), and property the recipient already sold is counted at its sale-time value. On this recomputed total, the officer measures the protected shares according to the number of children and determines whether the gifts exceeded the disposable portion. Return to Robert: 600,000-euro apartment plus 300,000 euros in accounts makes 900,000 euros existing at death; add the 200,000-euro lifetime gift to the daughter, and the fictional total is 1,100,000 euros. With two children, the protected share is two-thirds, or about 733,333 euros, and the disposable portion is about 366,667 euros. Total gifts to the wife and daughter (900,000 euros by will plus 200,000 euros already given, less lawful imputations) exceed the disposable portion by a wide margin, and the son recovers the shortfall.
The recovery today takes the form of money, not necessarily a physical slice of the apartment. Article 924 of the Civil Code provides: “Lorsque la libéralité excède la quotité disponible, le gratifié, successible ou non successible, doit indemniser les héritiers réservataires à concurrence de la portion excessive de la libéralité, quel que soit cet excédent.” Whether the recipient is an heir or a stranger, that recipient must compensate the protected heirs up to the excessive amount, however large the excess. The protected heir is paid by taking less from the remaining estate and by priority set-off against the heir’s own rights in the protected share — the mechanism called payment en moins prenant. For American families this is often good news wrapped in sobering news: the favored daughter does not necessarily lose the Paris apartment itself and can keep it by paying her brother the value of his impaired share, but she must actually pay it, with interest and valuation disputes that a notaire, and if needed a French court, will arbitrate. Gifts of family businesses, farms, and apartments occupied as a main home follow special allocation and payment-over-time rules, which is one more reason to plan the funding of that compensation while the parent is alive — through balanced lifetime gifts to each child or through life-insurance designations — rather than leaving the children to finance a court-ordered equalization after death.
One related instrument deserves a clear warning because American parents use it constantly: the assurance-vie, the French life-insurance savings contract. Amounts payable to a named beneficiary under an assurance-vie pass outside the succession to that beneficiary, which makes these contracts a precise tool for balancing children — for example, naming the less-favored child as beneficiary to top up that child’s share. But the tool cuts both ways: premiums that were clearly disproportionate to the parent’s means when paid can be brought back into the protected-share calculation by courts, and a beneficiary designation that contradicts the overall balance of the estate is a classic source of lawsuits between siblings. Review every beneficiary clause whenever you rewrite your will, keep the amounts proportionate across children, and tell the notaire about all contracts at the opening of the succession. Consistency across wills, insurance designations, and account titles is not elegance; it is the difference between an estate that settles and an estate that litigates.
II. How Americans keep control anyway: European choice of law and the estate tax treaty
So far this guide may read as bad news for testamentary freedom. This second part shows the two legal instruments that restore a large measure of control to American families — the European choice-of-law mechanism combined with careful drafting, and the bilateral tax treaty that prevents double taxation — while explaining honestly where each instrument stops working. Neither instrument deletes the protected share described above; each channels it, funds it, or prices it so the family can live with the result.
A. Can choosing American law in your will defeat the French protected share?
Start with the European framework, because it governs which country’s succession law applies before French protective rules even enter the picture. The European Succession Regulation — Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 4 July 2012 on jurisdiction, applicable law, recognition and enforcement of decisions and acceptance and enforcement of authentic instruments in matters of succession — lays down one general rule and one permitted escape. The general rule, in Article 21, is that the whole succession is governed by the law of the country where the deceased had his or her habitual residence at death. The escape, in Article 22, called professio juris, allows any person to choose in advance, in a will or similar disposition, the law of the country of his or her nationality to govern the entire succession — for an American, the law of the United States, or more precisely the law of the relevant American state. The full official text, Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 of 4 July 2012, is directly applicable in France and consultable on the official EUR-Lex portal. The United States is not a European Union member, but the Regulation still controls whenever French courts or a French notaire handle the succession or French-situated assets are involved, because its conflict rules apply universally, not only between member states.
French courts apply these connecting factors as intensive factual inquiries, and an American family that assumes its ties are obvious can lose on the facts. The leading illustration is a judgment of the First Civil Chamber of the Cour de cassation of May 29, 2019, First Civil Chamber, appeal no. 18-13.383, concerning a father described in these terms: “que Z… H… est décédé le […], à New York, laissant trois enfants, M…, O… et A…, en l’état d’un testament exhérédant sa fille O… (Mme H…)” — a father who died in New York leaving three children in the state of a will disinheriting his daughter. The daughter argued the father had his habitual residence in Paris and sued her siblings before the French courts for judicial partition of the succession. The Cour de cassation upheld the Paris Court of Appeal, which had weighed duration, regularity, conditions, and reasons of the father’s presence in each country and concluded his habitual residence was in New York, so the French courts lacked general jurisdiction over the whole succession. The lesson for Americans is direct: habitual residence under the Regulation is a global assessment of the circumstances of the deceased’s life in the years before death — how long and how regularly the person was present in each country, under what living conditions, and for what reasons — revealing a close and stable link with the country concerned. Nationality and the location of the principal assets are only secondary considerations in complex cases of alternating residence. An American who splits life between New York and Paris must therefore build a clear evidentiary record of where daily life was actually centered — leases, tax filings, medical care, club and community life, the apartment filled with personal possessions of everyday use — because a disinherited child will attack exactly that point to pull the succession into the more protective forum.
A second judgment shows the mirror image: even when habitual residence lies outside Europe, French courts may still claim the succession through subsidiary jurisdiction. On September 21, 2022, First Civil Chamber, appeal no. 19-15.438, following a preliminary ruling of the Court of Justice of the European Union of April 7, 2022 in case C-645/20, the Cour de cassation held: “Selon ce texte, titré « Compétences subsidiaires », lorsque la résidence habituelle du défunt au moment du décès n’est pas située dans un État membre, les juridictions de l’État membre dans lequel sont situés des biens successoraux sont néanmoins compétentes pour statuer sur l’ensemble de la succession dans la mesure où le défunt possédait la nationalité de cet État membre au moment du décès.” Where habitual residence at death is outside the Union, the courts of the member state where estate assets are situated may nevertheless rule on the entire succession when the deceased held that state’s nationality — and the French court must raise this subsidiary jurisdiction on its own motion when it finds itself without general jurisdiction. For an American reader the practical translation is narrower but still important: American nationality alone does not create French subsidiary jurisdiction over the whole estate, yet any French-situated asset guarantees a French forum for at least those assets, and a French-national child or a dual-national deceased can widen that forum considerably. Your Paris apartment will be dealt with in France under European jurisdictional rules no matter what your Texas will says about forum.
Against this background, the 2021 compensatory levy is the provision American families most need to understand, because it was enacted precisely to stop families from using a foreign law to erase the French protection of children. The second paragraph of Article 913 of the Civil Code, added by the Law of August 24, 2021 confirming respect for the principles of the Republic, provides: “Lorsque le défunt ou au moins l’un de ses enfants est, au moment du décès, ressortissant d’un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou y réside habituellement et lorsque la loi étrangère applicable à la succession ne permet aucun mécanisme réservataire protecteur des enfants, chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès, de façon à être rétablis dans les droits réservataires que leur octroie la loi française, dans la limite de ceux-ci.” Three cumulative conditions, each of which must be verified on the facts: at death, either the deceased or at least one of the children is a national of a European Union member state or habitually resides there; the foreign law applicable to the succession — for example the chosen law of Texas or Florida — provides no protective reserved-share mechanism for children; and the levy operates only against existing assets situated in France at the day of death, restoring each child up to, and capped at, the protected rights French law grants. A Florida resident who elects Florida law, owns a Paris apartment, and leaves children living in France may see those children levy the Paris apartment back up to their French protected shares. The election of American law remains useful — it can govern the administration of the estate, the interpretation of the will, and relations with the surviving spouse — but it does not make children disappear from the French property.
The honest drafting strategy follows from these limits and is the opposite of concealment. First, insert an express choice of American law under Article 22 of the Regulation in both the American and any French will, so that one coherent law governs interpretation, administration, and the surviving spouse’s position. Second, draft the dispositions as though the children’s protected shares could still reach the French assets — because the 2021 levy and the five-year reduction action give those shares real teeth — by keeping total gifts to any one beneficiary within the disposable portion measured on the recomposed estate, and by balancing unequal gifts with compensating provisions for the other children. Third, coordinate the matrimonial regime: American spouses married without a French marriage contract who settle in France may find French default community rules creeping into asset characterization, so a clear marriage contract or a recorded choice of matrimonial law, prepared while both spouses are alive and competent, prevents the succession plan from fighting the property regime. Fourth, calendar maintenance: revisit both wills after every major life event — marriage, divorce, birth, adoption, acquisition or sale of the French property, a move between states, or the acquisition of another nationality — and re-sign the choice-of-law clause whenever your connecting factors change. Families that complete this work now hand their children a settlement; families that postpone it hand them a file number.
B. Will your children pay tax twice, in France and to the IRS, on the same French house?
Civil-law entitlement and tax are two different battles, and American families must win both. France taxes the transfer; the United States taxes its citizens and domiciliaries on worldwide transfers; without coordination, the Paris apartment could bear both. French tax law casts its net through Article 750 ter of the General Tax Code, whose opening words repay close reading. Its first case covers worldwide movable and immovable property “lorsque le donateur ou le défunt a son domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article 4 B” — when the donor or the deceased had his or her tax domicile in France. Its second case covers French-situated movable and immovable property held directly or indirectly — including through companies in which the deceased held more than half the interests — when the deceased had no French tax domicile. And its third case catches property received by an heir, donee, legatee, or trust beneficiary who has held a French tax domicile for at least six years out of the last ten. An American who retired to the Dordogne and became French tax-resident leaves worldwide assets inside the French death-tax net; an American who always lived in Ohio but kept the Paris apartment leaves at least the apartment and the French accounts inside it; and an American child long settled in Lyon who inherits an Ohio brokerage account from an Ohio parent may owe French tax on that Ohio account under the six-year rule. Domicile for these purposes follows French tax criteria — home, principal place of residence, professional activity, center of economic interests — not immigration status or the address printed on the will.
The bilateral safety net is the Convention Between the United States of America and the French Republic for the Avoidance of Double Taxation and the Prevention of Fiscal Evasion with Respect to Taxes on Estates, Inheritances, and Gifts, signed at Washington on November 24, 1978, as amended by the Protocol signed at Washington on December 8, 2004. The 1978 Convention as amended by the 2004 Protocol is described by the French tax administration in its doctrine on the France-United States tax convention at BOI-INT-CVB-USA-20, with the United States Treasury technical explanation at Treasury Technical Explanation of the 2004 Protocol. In substance, the treaty allocates primary taxing rights over real property and business assets to the country where they are situated, gives the country of the deceased’s domicile the right to tax the remainder with a credit for the situs country’s tax, defines domicile by a treaty tie-breaker when both countries claim it, grants a pro rata unified credit to French domiciliaries facing United States estate tax, and — added by the 2004 Protocol — extends a limited United States marital deduction where the surviving spouse is not an American citizen. The treaty also contains a saving clause preserving the United States’ right to tax its citizens as if the treaty had not come into effect, which is why American citizens cannot treaty-shop their way out of IRS obligations: the treaty relieves double taxation through credits and allocation, it does not create exemption.
On the French side of the computation, two provisions do most of the practical work for American parents and children. First, Article 779 of the General Tax Code grants: “Pour la perception des droits de mutation à titre gratuit, il est effectué un abattement de 100 000 € sur la part de chacun des ascendants et sur la part de chacun des enfants vivants ou représentés par suite de prédécès ou de renonciation.” Each child deducts a 100,000-euro allowance from his or her taxable share before any rate applies — so Robert’s son, recovering a 300,000-euro protected share, pays French tax only on 200,000 euros. Second, Article 777 of the General Tax Code sets the progressive rates: “Les droits de mutation à titre gratuit sont fixés aux taux indiqués dans les tableaux ci-après, pour la part nette revenant à chaque ayant droit” — five percent on the first slice up to 8,072 euros, rising through ten, fifteen, and twenty percent, to thirty percent between 552,324 and 902,838 euros, forty percent up to 1,805,677 euros, and forty-five percent beyond. On the son’s 200,000 euros after allowance, the French tax is roughly 38,000 euros — a serious sum, but a fraction of the share’s value, and creditable in the United States computation to the extent the treaty and the Internal Revenue Code allow. Donations made during life use the same allowance, renewable every fifteen years, which is why staged lifetime gifts to children — a gift now, another after fifteen years — are a standard technique to move French value at lower cumulative tax, provided each gift respects the protected-share arithmetic described in Part I.
Two family situations deserve special emphasis because they recur in American files. The surviving spouse is fully exempt from French death taxes: Article 796-0 bis of the General Tax Code states: “Sont exonérés de droits de mutation par décès le conjoint survivant et le partenaire lié au défunt par un pacte civil de solidarité.” Leaving the disposable portion to your wife therefore costs her zero French inheritance tax, whatever the amount — a powerful reason to concentrate spousal protection inside the disposable portion rather than attempting to disinherit the children, which triggers both the reduction action and the tax bill. United States persons must still handle the American side: the estate of an American citizen may owe federal estate tax above the federal exemption with a return on IRS Form 706, and heirs claiming credit for French taxes paid need proper proof — the French tax assessment, proof of payment, and the notaire‘s certificate of the taxable base — translated and organized for the American accountant. Engage a Franco-American tax adviser before the French return is filed, because the French filing deadline runs from the death — six months for deaths in France, twelve months for deaths abroad — and elections or valuations conceded in a hurry to the French administration become very difficult to revisit when the American return is prepared months later.
A final tax trap for American owners of French property held through companies: French law looks through ownership chains. Where the deceased, alone or with close family, held more than half the shares or rights in entities that own French real estate, the real estate is deemed held indirectly and taxed as French-situated property, valued by apportioning the entity’s balance sheet. An Ohio limited liability company holding a Paris apartment does not remove the apartment from the French tax net, and it adds the French 3-percent annual tax on the market value of French real estate held by entities that fail to disclose their shareholders — the taxe de 3 % declared on form 2746 — plus potential treaty and reporting complications on the American side. Direct individual ownership, or a properly advised French property-holding company with full annual disclosures, is almost always cleaner than an opaque foreign vehicle. Tell both your notaire and your American accountant about every entity in the chain before the succession opens, not after.
Conclusion
An American in France cannot disinherit a child the way a purely domestic American will assumes: each child holds a protected fraction of the French estate — one-half for one child, two-thirds for two, three-quarters for three or more — enforceable by a personal action for reduction within five years of death, two years of discovery, and ten years at the outside, against wills and lifetime gifts alike, measured on a fictitiously reunited total and payable today in money compensation. Choosing American law under the European Succession Regulation organizes the succession and protects the surviving spouse, but the 2021 compensatory levy restores each qualifying child’s French protected rights against French-situated assets whenever the applicable foreign law offers children no equivalent protection. French death taxes then take their share under worldwide-or-situs rules, softened by a 100,000-euro allowance per child, progressive rates from five to forty-five percent, a full spousal exemption, and a 1978 bilateral treaty with a 2004 protocol that allocates taxing rights and credits the tax paid abroad instead of taxing the same apartment twice. The families who navigate this system successfully do four things while everyone is alive: they write coordinated American and French wills with an express choice of American law, they keep total gifts to any one person inside the disposable portion measured on the whole recomposed estate, they balance children through lifetime gifts and insurance designations reviewed on the same day as the wills, and they put a Franco-American tax adviser and a Paris notaire in contact with each other before the first return is due. Do this work now, and your Paris apartment becomes what you bought it to be — a gift to the people you love, not a file number for the people you leave behind.