KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Selling or Renting Your French House as an American: the 17.2% Social Charges and How to Claim Back Overpaid CSG and CRDS

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Selling or Renting Your French House as an American: the 17.2% Social Charges and How to Claim Back Overpaid CSG and CRDS

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You bought a stone house in the Dordogne, or a two-bedroom apartment in the 11th arrondissement of Paris. You rent it out when you are back in the United States, or you decide to sell it after ten years. Your French notaire (a public officer who handles conveyancing, collects the taxes due on the transaction, and registers the deed) runs the numbers, and next to the income tax you expected, a second line appears that nobody in Ohio or California ever warned you about: the prélèvements sociaux, the French social charges. On rental income from an unfurnished letting and on the taxable gain from a sale, those charges add 17.2 percent on top of the income tax. On furnished rental income taxed as a non-professional landlord, they add 18.6 percent. For an American who is not covered by any European social security coordination rule, that surcharge is almost never reduced, it buys no health coverage and no pension rights, and the American Internal Revenue Service will not let you credit it against your United States tax bill. This article explains the mechanism in plain English: first, what France actually takes from your rent or your sale price and under which code articles; second, why your German or Dutch neighbor with the same house pays only 7.5 percent while you pay the full rate; third, the holding-period clock and the sale mechanics that legally shrink the bill; and fourth, how to challenge an assessment you believe is wrong and how to coordinate the French payment with your American return so the same euro is not taxed twice without relief.

I. Why Americans pay the full 17.2 percent on French rents and property gains

A. What France actually takes from your rent or your sale price: CSG, CRDS, and the solidarity levy

Start with the vocabulary, because three different charges hide behind the single line on your tax notice. The CSG (contribution sociale généralisée, the general social contribution) is the heavy one at 9.2 percent on most property income. The CRDS (contribution pour le remboursement de la dette sociale, the contribution that repays the social debt) adds 0.5 percent. The prélèvement de solidarité (a solidarity levy created to replace the CSG and CRDS for taxpayers outside the French social security system) adds 7.5 percent. Together they reach the 17.2 percent that applies to unfurnished rental income and to real estate capital gains, while furnished rental income taxed in the non-professional category carries a slightly higher CSG and reaches 18.6 percent in total. The official service-public.fr guide for taxpayers states these totals plainly: 9.2 percent CSG plus 0.5 percent CRDS plus 7.5 percent solidarity levy on land income and on real estate gains, and 10.6 percent CSG plus 0.5 percent CRDS plus 7.5 percent solidarity levy on non-professional furnished rental income. Keep that breakdown in mind for everything that follows, because each layer has a different legal nature, and only some layers can ever be challenged or credited.

The reason France can tax you at all, even though you live in Austin or Boston, is that French tax law treats the house itself as the connecting factor. Article 164 B of the French general tax code provides: “I. Sont considérés comme revenus de source française : a. Les revenus d’immeubles sis en France ou de droits relatifs à ces immeubles”. In other words, rents from a building located in France, and gains from selling rights in such a building, are French-source income by definition, regardless of where the owner lives. That single sentence is the hook for the entire French taxation of your house: the income tax on the rent, the levy on the capital gain, and the social charges on both.

The social charges themselves are organized by the Social Security Code, and the drafting distinguishes residents from nonresidents. Article L.136-6 of the Social Security Code opens with the resident rule: “I.-Les personnes physiques fiscalement domiciliées en France au sens de l’article 4 B du code général des impôts sont assujetties à une contribution sur les revenus du patrimoine assise sur le montant net retenu pour l’établissement de l’impôt sur le revenu”. Residents therefore pay the contribution on their net property income, including land income and capital gains. For nonresidents such as Americans, the key provision sits one article further. Article L.136-7 of the same code states in its paragraph I bis: “I bis.-Sont également soumises à la contribution les plus-values imposées au prélèvement mentionné à l’article 244 bis A du code général des impôts lorsqu’elles sont réalisées, directement ou indirectement, par des personnes physiques.” That sentence is the one that reaches across the Atlantic: gains taxed under the nonresident levy of article 244 bis A, when realized by individuals, also bear the social contribution. And the rates are set by article L.136-8, which provides: “I.-Le taux des contributions sociales est fixé : 1° A 9,2 % pour la contribution sociale mentionnée à l’article L. 136-1 ; 2° A 10,6 % pour les contributions sociales mentionnées aux articles L. 136-6 et L. 136-7”. Those are the CSG rates you see reflected in the 17.2 and 18.6 percent totals once the CRDS and the solidarity levy are added.

On a sale, the nonresident income-tax levy itself comes from article 244 bis A of the general tax code, which provides: “I. – 1. Sous réserve des conventions internationales, les plus-values, telles que définies aux e bis et e ter du I de l’article 164 B , réalisées par les personnes et organismes mentionnés au 2 du I lors de la cession des biens ou droits mentionnés au 3 sont soumises à un prélèvement selon les taux fixés au III bis.” The same article then lists who pays, and American sellers are squarely in the first category: “2. Sont soumis au prélèvement mentionné au 1 : a) Les personnes physiques qui ne sont pas fiscalement domiciliées en France au sens de l’article 4 B”. So the architecture is two-layered: article 244 bis A takes the income-tax slice of your gain at the nonresident rate, and article L.136-7 takes the social-charges slice on top. Your notaire withholds both at the closing table, which is why the check you receive is smaller than the headline price minus the income tax alone. The detailed mechanics of the income-tax slice, including the 19 percent rate, the allowances, and the exemptions, are covered in our companion guide to selling a French house as an American; this article stays focused on the social-charges slice, which is the part most Americans discover last and understand least.

Two practical points complete the picture. First, the charges are collected like an income tax but give you nothing in return. Paying the CSG and CRDS on your Paris rents does not enroll you in the French health system, does not open rights to a French pension, and does not count toward unemployment coverage. They are taxes with a social name, not contributions that buy coverage. Second, the administration that bills you is the tax office for nonresidents in Noisy-le-Grand: if you file your French return on time, it sends the social-charges notice between August and September with the calculation detail, the total, the payment methods, and the deadline. An American who rents out a French apartment therefore has a yearly French filing and payment cycle even with no other French income, and an American who sells has a one-shot withholding at closing followed by possible balance notices. Missing either cycle produces late-payment interest and penalties on top of a bill that already feels disproportionate.

B. Why your European neighbor pays only 7.5 percent: the de Ruyter rule that does not protect Americans

Here is the comparison that stings. A Dutch or German owner of the identical house next door, affiliated with the social security system of their home country, pays only the 7.5 percent solidarity levy on the same rent or the same gain. You pay 17.2 percent. The difference is not a preference for Europeans written into the rate tables. It is the consequence of the biggest social-security case in recent French tax history, a case every American landlord in France should understand, because it explains both why the neighbor is protected and why you are not.

The story starts with a Dutch national living in France but working in the Netherlands, who was charged French CSG and CRDS on his income even though he belonged exclusively to the Dutch social security system. The Court of Justice of the European Union ruled on February 26, 2015, in the case known as de Ruyter, C-623/13, that levies with a direct and relevant link to the branches of social security fall inside the European coordination regulations, and that those regulations allow only one national social security legislation to apply to a given person at a given time. A person insured in one member state cannot be charged social-security-linked levies by another. France had to stop charging the CSG and the CRDS to taxpayers who were already affiliated with another European social security system, and it replaced those two charges, for that protected group, with the 7.5 percent solidarity levy, which is classified as a purely budgetary tax with no link to social security. That is the origin of the two-track table you see today: 7.5 percent for taxpayers affiliated with a compulsory scheme of the European Economic Area or Switzerland, 17.2 or 18.6 percent for everyone else.

The French Court of Cassation restated that principle as recently as September 25, 2025. In a decision of its Second Civil Chamber, appeal number 22-24.634, the Court recalled that the European regulations “consacrent le principe d’unicité de la législation de sécurité sociale, selon lequel la personne à laquelle les règlements s’appliquent n’est soumise qu’à la législation d’un seul État membre, en sorte que celle-ci, affiliée à un régime de sécurité sociale d’un État membre, ne doit pas contribuer au régime de sécurité sociale d’un autre État membre (CJUE, arrêt du 26 février 2015, De Ruyter, C-623-13, point 35)”. In plain terms: one person, one social security system, no double social contribution across Europe. Taxpayers who prove their European affiliation with the official honor attestation and supporting documents pay the reduced 7.5 percent track.

Now the American side of that principle. The United States is not a member of the European Economic Area, Switzerland is covered only by its bilateral coordination agreement with the European Union, and no equivalent coordination instrument shields an American affiliated with United States Social Security from French social charges on French-source capital income. An American who lives in Florida, works in Florida, and is insured in Florida has no European legislation to invoke, so the single-legislation shield never engages, and the full CSG plus CRDS plus solidarity levy applies. The result feels arbitrary when the Dutch neighbor pays less than half, but it follows mechanically from the architecture: the de Ruyter protection is a European coordination rule, not a general fairness rule, and Americans sit outside its perimeter.

One narrow edge case deserves mention because mixed families encounter it often. An American who also works in a European Union country and is genuinely affiliated there with a compulsory social security scheme can, in principle, claim the 7.5 percent track on the same terms as any European, by producing the honor attestation and the supporting documents the tax office may request. The test is real affiliation with a European scheme, not American citizenship plus an American insurance record. United States Medicare enrollment, private American health insurance, or voluntary contributions do not qualify. If your life genuinely straddles both systems, assemble the European affiliation proof before the assessment arrives rather than after, because the reduced rate is applied on the basis of documents, not on the basis of arguments.

II. How Americans cut the bill and recover overpaid French social charges

A. The holding-period clock, the allowances, and the sale mechanics that lower the charge

The good news is that the social-charges slice shrinks with time, and the same holding-period allowances that reduce the income tax on your gain also reduce the base on which the 17.2 percent is computed. The bad news is that the social-charges clock runs slower than the income-tax clock: the gain becomes exempt from income tax after 22 years of ownership, but it becomes exempt from social charges only after 30 years. Between those two milestones sits a zone many long-term American owners inhabit without realizing it, where the sale produces no income tax at all yet still produces a social-charges bill.

The starting point is the definition of the taxable gain. Article 150 U of the general tax code provides: “I. – Sous réserve des dispositions propres aux bénéfices industriels et commerciaux, aux bénéfices agricoles et aux bénéfices non commerciaux, les plus-values réalisées par les personnes physiques ou les sociétés ou groupements qui relèvent des articles 8 à 8 ter , lors de la cession à titre onéreux de biens immobiliers bâtis ou non bâtis ou de droits relatifs à ces biens, sont passibles de l’impôt sur le revenu dans les conditions prévues aux articles 150 V à 150 VH .” The gain is the sale price minus the purchase price as adjusted: the purchase price can be increased by documented acquisition costs or a flat allowance, by documented improvement work, and, for property received by gift or inheritance, the value used for the gift or estate tax computation is the starting point. Every receipt you kept since the purchase therefore matters twice, once against the income tax and once against the social charges, because both apply to the same net gain.

The allowance schedule then works as follows, and these are the official figures. For income tax purposes, the allowance is zero for the first five years, 6 percent per year of ownership from the 6th through the 21st year, 4 percent for the 22nd year, and total exemption beyond 22 years. For social-charges purposes, the allowance is zero for the first five years, 1.65 percent per year from the 6th through the 21st year, 1.6 percent for the 22nd year, 9 percent per year from the 23rd through the 30th year, and total exemption beyond 30 years. Two worked examples make the gap concrete. Sell after 10 years with a 10,000 euro gain: the income-tax allowance is 30 percent (6 percent times 5 years), so income tax applies to 7,000 euros, while the social-charges allowance is only 8.25 percent (1.65 percent times 5 years), so the 17.2 percent rate applies to 9,175 euros. Sell after 25 years with the same 10,000 euro gain: income tax is zero, but the social-charges allowance totals 55 percent (26.4 plus 1.6 plus 27), so the 17.2 percent rate still applies to 4,500 euros. An American who held a Paris apartment for 24 years and assumed the sale was fully exempt has experienced exactly this surprise at the notaire office.

Beyond the clock, three sale mechanics can eliminate or defer the bill. First, the former-principal-residence rule: article 244 bis A exempts the sale of the building that was your principal residence in France on the date you moved your tax domicile abroad, provided the sale closes no later than December 31 of the year following the move, the property was not made available to any third party in the meantime, and the same taxpayer has not already used the parallel domestic exemption. The article states the condition directly: the exemption applies on the double condition of timing and non-availability, and it extends to the immediate and necessary outbuildings sold together with the main dwelling. Americans who leave France after an assignment should therefore calendar the sale instead of drifting: a sale in the departure year or the next year can be fully exempt, while the same sale two years later is fully taxable. Second, members of European Union states who lived in France continuously for at least two years can, within ten years of departure and once per taxpayer, exempt a gain of up to 150,000 euros on a dwelling other than the principal residence, provided the property has been at their full disposal. That route is closed to Americans holding only United States nationality, which is one more place where the European perimeter matters, but it is open to Franco-American dual nationals who meet the residence history. Third, the tax-representative obligation: a nonresident whose gain is taxable must appoint an accredited French tax representative with financial guarantees, unless the sale price does not exceed 150,000 euros, the seller is a national of a European Union or treaty state with recovery assistance, or the gain is already exempt by holding period. The representative signs the return, computes both slices of tax, and remains liable, so choosing an established firm rather than the cheapest option is money well spent.

For rental income, there is no holding-period clock, but the base can still be managed. Unfurnished rents are taxed on net income after deductible charges: management fees, insurance, property tax, interest on the acquisition loan, and documented repair and maintenance work. Furnished non-professional rents fall under the micro or actual-expense regimes with their own allowances. Because the social charges apply to the same net base as the income tax, every deductible euro saves both the income-tax rate and the 17.2 or 18.6 percent surcharge. American owners who let a French agency manage the property while keeping no receipts are therefore paying the surcharge on a base they could have lawfully reduced. Keep the invoices, keep the loan statements, and have the French return prepared by someone who knows which charges are deductible, because the American preparer back home usually does not.

B. How to challenge a French assessment and coordinate it with the American return

Suppose the bill has arrived and you believe it is wrong: the tax office applied the full 17.2 percent although you were affiliated with a European scheme that year, it ignored documented improvement costs in the gain, or it taxed rents from a period before you owned the property. French law gives you a formal claim procedure, the réclamation contentieuse, and the code defines its scope generously. Article L.190 of the tax procedure book provides: “Les réclamations relatives aux impôts, contributions, droits, taxes, redevances, soultes et pénalités de toute nature, établis ou recouvrés par les agents de l’administration, relèvent de la juridiction contentieuse lorsqu’elles tendent à obtenir soit la réparation d’erreurs commises dans l’assiette ou le calcul des impositions, soit le bénéfice d’un droit résultant d’une disposition législative ou réglementaire.” Social charges are covered: errors in the base or the computation, and rights flowing from a statute or regulation, are exactly what the contentious claim is for. A wrongly applied full rate when the 7.5 percent track was due, or a gain computed without your documented costs, fits the text.

The procedure has strict deadlines, and this is where Americans lose winnable cases by waiting. As a rule, the claim must be filed before December 31 of the second year following the year of the assessment shown on the tax notice, so an assessment issued in 2026 can be challenged until December 31, 2028. The claim is filed with the tax office, increasingly through the secure messaging of the online personal account, and it must state the tax, the grounds, and the amount claimed, with supporting documents attached. If the administration does not answer within six months, that silence counts as an implicit rejection, and the taxpayer can then take the dispute to the administrative court. If the answer is unsatisfactory, the same court route opens. Three practical consequences follow. First, calendar the deadline from the notice the day it arrives; the French administration does not send reminders. Second, never file a bare protest letter: attach the assessment, the deed of sale or the rental accounts, the improvement invoices, the European affiliation certificate if the 7.5 percent track is claimed, and a computation showing the corrected base. Third, pay first and argue second unless you formally request and obtain a payment deferral, because the claim does not suspend collection by itself, and late-payment surcharges accrue while the file sits in the queue.

The treaty between France and the United States frames the whole exercise but does not do what many Americans hope it does. The consolidated treaty text is published by the French tax administration, the administration’s official commentary explains it article by article in the dedicated BOFiP section for the France-United States convention, and the original publication appears in the March 1996 decree publishing the convention. In substance, the treaty confirms that France, as the country where the property sits, may tax the rental income and the gains from the property, and it organizes relief in the residence country rather than exemption at source. It does not cap the French social charges, it does not extend the de Ruyter shield to Americans, and it does not convert the CSG into a creditable income tax. Its value in a refund file is different: it confirms the situs rule that makes the French assessment lawful in principle, so the claim must attack the computation, the rate track, or the base, not the existence of French taxation itself. Arguments that France had no right to tax at all will fail, and filing them wastes the deadline window for the arguments that can succeed.

The American side of the coordination is where the BASE records contain the costliest mistakes, so read this paragraph twice. The United States taxes its citizens on worldwide income, which means the French rent and the French gain go on the American return too, in dollars, in the year the American rules recognize them. Relief comes through the foreign tax credit on Form 1116, which sorts foreign taxes into baskets, with rental income and gains on the French house generally falling in the passive or general category depending on the facts, each with its own limitation. Here is the trap inside the trap: the income-tax slice of the French bill, meaning the tax on the net rental income and the 19 percent nonresident levy on the gain, can feed the credit within those limits, but the social-charges slice cannot. Washington has long treated the CSG and the CRDS as social charges rather than as income taxes, so the 9.7 combined points they represent generate no credit at all, and the solidarity levy is in the same position. An American who mentally converts the whole French payment into a dollar-for-dollar credit against the American tax will therefore underpay the Internal Revenue Service and face interest. The correct sequence is to compute the French income tax and the French social charges separately, claim the credit only for the income-tax portion within the Form 1116 limitation, report the gain and the rents in the correct American year even when the French assessment arrives later, and keep the French notices, the deed, the cost invoices, and the exchange-rate computations together, because the credit is only as defensible as its paper trail. Currency timing adds a final wrinkle: the euro-to-dollar rate on the sale date and on the French payment date will differ, producing exchange gain or loss that the American return must handle on its own track.

A closing word on timing strategy ties the two systems together. When a sale is planned, run both computations before signing anything: the French computation with the holding-period allowances and the applicable 17.2 percent base, and the American computation with the cost basis, the exclusion rules that generally do not help a French second home, and the credit limitation. Sometimes accelerating deductible French works into the pre-sale year, sometimes choosing the sale year to match American loss harvesting, and sometimes simply waiting for the next allowance anniversary changes the combined outcome by thousands of dollars. The notaire computes the French withholding correctly as a matter of routine, but the notaire does not optimize your American return, and the American preparer does not know the French allowance table. The cases that end badly are the ones where each professional saw only half the file.

Conclusion

The 17.2 percent is not a mistake on your notice, and it is not negotiable in the abstract. It is the sum of three lawful charges: a 9.2 percent general social contribution, a 0.5 percent debt-repayment contribution, and a 7.5 percent solidarity levy, applied to French-source rental income and real estate gains under articles L.136-6 and L.136-7 of the Social Security Code at the rates of article L.136-8, on top of the nonresident levy of article 244 bis A. Europeans affiliated with a European scheme escape the first two layers through the single-legislation principle confirmed in de Ruyter and restated by the Court of Cassation in 2025, while Americans, outside that coordination perimeter, pay all three layers and receive no social coverage in exchange. From that starting point, everything useful follows: the holding-period allowances that erase the income tax after 22 years and the social charges after 30, the former-residence exemption for sellers who act within the year after departure, the documented costs that shrink the taxable base for both slices at once, the contentious claim that corrects wrong assessments before December 31 of the second year, and the foreign tax credit that absorbs the French income-tax portion but never the social charges. An American who understands this architecture sells and rents in France with clear eyes: the house can still be an excellent investment, but only when the 17.2 percent is priced into the decision before the deed is signed, not discovered on the notice after.

📄 Official circular