KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Buying a House in France as an American: Notaire Closing Costs and What Each Line Pays For

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Buying a House in France as an American: Notaire Closing Costs and What Each Line Pays For

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You agree on a price for a house in France, and a few weeks later the notaire sends you a document called a décompte, a line-by-line closing statement, with a total that lands about seven percent above the purchase price. The notaire, the public officer who authenticates the deed and collects the taxes on it, is not overcharging you. French law routes most of the taxes on a property sale through the notaire’s office, and only a small slice of the total is the notaire’s own pay. The trouble is that the statement is written in dense French, the tax lines have names you have never seen, and nobody tells you which lines are fixed by statute, which line you can negotiate, how to challenge a bill that looks wrong, or what the Internal Revenue Service lets you do with each dollar of cost. This article decodes the whole bill in order. It gives you the exact statutes behind every line, a worked example on a 350,000 euro purchase of an older house and the same purchase new, the procedure for getting the regulated discount and contesting a wrong fee, and the American tax treatment of each cost, with the treaty text and the IRS guidance that controls your return.

The short version is this. On an older home you pay a transfer tax that can reach about 6.32 percent of the price, plus a 0.10 percent land-registry contribution, plus the notaire’s regulated fee computed on a sliding scale set by the Commercial Code, plus 20 percent VAT on that fee, plus a few hundred euros of disbursements. On a new or off-plan home the transfer tax drops to about 0.71 percent because VAT already sits inside the developer’s price. The notaire’s fee can be discounted by up to 20 percent on the upper price brackets, the total fee can never exceed 10 percent of the property value, and disputed fee bills go through a court fee-taxation procedure before the first president of the court of appeal. On the American side, none of these French closing costs generates a foreign tax credit, because the credit only covers income taxes, but the transfer taxes and most settlement costs increase your tax basis in the house, which lowers your gain when you sell. The sections below prove each point with the texts that govern your file.

I. How Much Cash Beyond the Price Must an American Buyer Wire, and What Does Each Line of the Décompte Pay For?

A. Why Does an Older Home Trigger About Seven Percent in Transfer Taxes and Registration Charges?

The heaviest line on the bill for an older property, called a bien ancien, is the taxe de publicité foncière, the land-registration tax. Article 683 of the General Tax Code provides that civil acts transferring ownership of real estate for payment, and I quote, “sont assujettis à une taxe de publicité foncière ou à un droit d’enregistrement au taux prévu à l’article 1594 D .” Every private sale of a French house for consideration is caught. The same article fixes the base of the tax, and I quote, “La taxe ou le droit sont liquidés sur le prix exprimé, en y ajoutant toutes les charges en capital ainsi que toutes les indemnités stipulées au profit du cédant, à quelque titre et pour quelque cause que ce soit, ou sur une estimation d’experts, dans les cas autorisés par le présent code.” The tax is computed on the stated price plus every capital charge and every indemnity promised to the seller, whatever its label. In practice, that means furniture listed separately in the deed with its own detailed price escapes the tax base, while anything folded into the headline price bears it, because the statute adds that when a transfer covers both real estate by nature and fixtures treated as real estate by destination, and I quote, “ces derniers doivent faire l’objet d’un prix particulier et d’une désignation détaillée”. American buyers should therefore check that the deed itemizes movable goods, called biens meubles, with a separate price and a detailed list.

The headline rate starts at 3.80 percent and the departments vote the rest. Article 1594 D of the General Tax Code provides, and I quote, “Sauf dispositions particulières, le taux de la taxe de publicité foncière ou du droit d’enregistrement prévu à l’article 683 est fixé à 3,80 %. Il peut être modifié par les conseils départementaux sans que ces modifications puissent avoir pour effet de le réduire à moins de 1,20 % ou de le relever au-delà de 4,50 % (1).” The base rate is 3.80 percent and each departmental council may move it within those bounds. Timing matters because the voted rates change on a fixed date: Article 1594 E of the General Tax Code provides, and I quote, “Les délibérations sont notifiées aux services fiscaux dans les conditions prévues à l’article 1639 A . Les décisions prennent effet le 1er juin. A défaut de vote ou en cas de non-respect des règles énumérées à l’article 1594 D, le taux en vigueur est reconduit.” If you sign in May or June, confirm which departmental rate your décompte uses, because a vote taking effect on June 1 can change your bill from one week to the next.

On top of the departmental share comes the communal surcharge. Article 1584 of the General Tax Code levies an additional tax for the commune on sales of local real estate, and I quote, “Cette taxe, dont la perception est confiée au service des impôts, est fixée à 1,20 %.” The same article confirms the new-build exception discussed below, noting, and I quote, “La taxe additionnelle n’est pas perçue lorsque la mutation est soumise au droit proportionnel de 0,70 %”. A further small line is the contribution de sécurité immobilière, the fee for the land-registry formalities themselves: Article 879 of the General Tax Code provides, and I quote, “I. – Une contribution de sécurité immobilière est due à l’Etat par toute personne qui requiert l’accomplissement des formalités prévues aux 1° et 2° de l’article 878 .” The French tax administration’s buyer guidance puts this contribution at 0.10 percent of the price with a 15 euro minimum, breaks the full burden on an older home into 3.80 percent for the department at the base rate, 1.20 percent for the commune, and collection costs equal to 2.37 percent of the departmental share, and totals the maximum burden at 6.32 percent (see the official breakdown of purchase taxes and fees, in French). That 6.32 percent is the figure your wire must cover on an older home before a single euro of notaire pay.

The base rule has teeth that surprise foreign buyers: side payments made to vacate the property count as part of the price. On 27 May 2026 the Grasse court of justice applied exactly this logic to a 7,000,000 euro commercial sale where the buyer had also funded a 2,000,000 euro payment to end the sitting tenant’s lease (Tribunal judiciaire de Grasse, 1st chamber B, 27 May 2026, case 25/02447). The court treated the lease-exit payment as a charge increasing the purchase price and held, and I quote, “L’Administration fiscale était donc bien fondée à rehausser l’assiette des droits de mutation à titre onéreux du bien à hauteur de 9.000.000 € et à rectifier à la hausse les droits initialement versés de ce chef.” The buyer lost the claim for a full refund of 172,001 euros in duties, penalties, and interest, and the judgment went on to discuss the 40 percent increase for deliberate understatement of the base. For an American buyer the lesson is concrete: if your deal includes money paid on the side to a tenant to leave, to a neighbor to drop a claim, or to anyone else to deliver the house vacant, expect the tax office to add it to the taxable base, and make sure the notaire prices it into the estimate rather than letting you discover it in a reassessment years later.

Take a concrete example. You buy an older apartment for 350,000 euros. At the maximum combined burden of 6.32 percent, the transfer taxes come to about 22,120 euros. Add the 0.10 percent registry contribution, about 350 euros. The notaire’s own fee, computed in the next section, comes to about 3,833 euros including VAT, and the disbursements add several hundred euros more. Your total cash beyond the price lands near 26,500 to 27,000 euros, roughly seven and a half percent. The same 350,000 euros spent on a new or off-plan home, called a vente en l’état futur d’achèvement, tells a different story: where VAT already sits inside the developer’s price, the departmental share falls to the reduced 0.70 percent rate referenced in article 1584, collection costs fall with it, and the administration’s guidance totals the reduced burden at 0.71 percent, or about 2,485 euros on 350,000 euros. The registry contribution and the notaire’s fee still apply, but the tax envelope shrinks by nearly 20,000 euros. That gap is why the ancien-or-neuf question belongs at the very start of your search, not at the signing table.

B. How Is the Notaire’s Own Fee Computed, and How Much of It Can You Negotiate?

Strip away the taxes and what remains is the notaire’s own pay, called the émolument, plus disbursements. The fee is not freely set: it follows a sliding scale in the Commercial Code. Article A444-91 of the Commercial Code provides that a private sale gives rise to a proportional fee, and I quote, “La vente ou cession de gré à gré (numéro 54 du tableau 5) donne lieu à la perception d’un émolument proportionnel, selon le barème suivant : Tranches d’assiette Taux applicable De 0 à 6 500 € 3,870 % De 6 500 € à 17 000 € 1,596 % De 17 000 € à 60 000 € 1,064 % Plus de 60 000 € 0,799 %”. Each bracket applies only to its slice of the price, so the effective rate falls as the price rises. On a 350,000 euro purchase the math runs as follows: 251.55 euros on the first 6,500 euros, 167.58 euros on the slice from 6,500 to 17,000 euros, 457.52 euros on the slice from 17,000 to 60,000 euros, and 2,317.10 euros on the remaining 290,000 euros, for a total of 3,193.75 euros before tax. Value added tax at 20 percent adds 638.75 euros, bringing the fee to 3,832.50 euros all taxes included. The public fee simulator on service-public.fr runs the same brackets and reaches the same result, which gives you an independent check on the notaire’s arithmetic before you wire anything.

Part of that fee is negotiable, and the discount has a precise legal frame. Article A444-174 of the Commercial Code allows notaires to grant rebates on the proportional fee, and I quote, “Dans la limite d’un taux de remise maximal de 20 % applicable à la part d’émolument calculée sur les tranches d’assiette supérieures ou égales à 100 000 €, pour les autres prestations.” For an ordinary residential purchase, the notaire may discount up to 20 percent of the fee slice computed on the price above 100,000 euros. On the 350,000 euro example, the slice above 100,000 euros bears 1,997.50 euros of fee, so the maximum discount is 399.50 euros before tax. Two conditions matter. First, the discount is a favor, not a right: the text says the notaire may grant it, so ask in writing before the deed is signed, when the notaire still has a reason to say yes. Second, the rebate applies only to the upper slice, so a buyer of a 120,000 euro studio negotiates over almost nothing while a buyer of a 900,000 euro house in the 16th arrondissement negotiates over real money. Get any agreed rebate written into the file, because an oral promise made across a desk in Paris is worth nothing once you are back in Ohio.

The fee is also capped by law. Article R444-9 of the Commercial Code provides, and I quote, “La somme des émoluments perçus par le notaire au titre des prestations relatives à la mutation d’un bien ou d’un droit immobilier ne peut excéder 10 % de la valeur de ce bien ou droit, sans pouvoir être inférieure à un montant fixé par l’arrêté prévu à l’article L. 444-3 , sans pouvoir être inférieure à 90 €.” On a standard purchase the cap never bites, since the sliding scale yields around one percent, but it protects buyers of very cheap property, where fixed minimums could otherwise explode in proportion to the price. The courts police these tariffs strictly, and two recent Court of Cassation rulings show how. In a 2 April 2026 ruling on notaire fees (Court of Cassation, 2nd civil chamber, 2 April 2026, appeal 24-12.467), the Court restated the general computation rule for proportional fees, holding, and I quote, “Selon le deuxième, sauf dispositions contraires des tarifs des notaires, les émoluments proportionnels sont perçus sur le capital énoncé dans les actes, augmenté de la valeur des charges figurant dans lesdits actes ou sur l’évaluation retenue pour la liquidation des droits et taxes, si elle est supérieure.” It added, and I quote, “Sont considérées comme charges les sommes que, dans l’acte et outre le prix, les parties s’engagent à payer ainsi que les prestations en nature qu’elles s’engagent à fournir.” The case concerned a court-appointed liquidation and sharing of an estate, but the tariff principle it states governs sale deeds the same way: the fee base is the stated capital plus the charges written into the deed, not a number the notaire invents. The Court quashed the fee order under review, which is a reminder that fee bills are reviewable and do get overturned. A second ruling points the same way from the opposite side: on 21 September 2023 the Court of Cassation held that a court-appointed notaire could only claim the regulated fee for a matrimonial liquidation plan if the draft plan had actually been filed, stating, and I quote, “Le notaire, désigné au titre de l’article 255, 10°, du code civil ne peut prétendre à l’émolument prévu à l’article A. 444-83 du code de commerce que s’il a déposé un projet de liquidation du régime matrimonial des époux et de formation des lots à partager” (Court of Cassation, 2nd civil chamber, 21 September 2023, appeal 21-25.456). Regulated means regulated: no filed work, no fee.

Below the fee line sit the déboursés, the disbursements: land-registry extracts, mortgage-register searches, town-planning documents, postage, and similar outlays the office advances for your file. These are pass-through costs, not profit, and a clean décompte itemizes them one by one. If your statement shows a single round lump sum labeled frais divers, ask for the breakdown before signing, because disbursements you cannot see are disbursements you cannot verify. Together, the three envelopes explain every euro: the tax envelope set by statute and your department’s vote, the fee envelope set by the sliding scale plus VAT minus any written rebate, and the disbursement envelope at cost. Once you can name the envelope, you can argue about the line.

II. How Does an American Buyer Verify, Challenge, and Fund the Bill Without Losing US Tax Benefits?

A. How Do You Check the Estimate, Get the Discount in Writing, and Contest a Bill That Looks Wrong?

Start early. As soon as the preliminary contract, called the compromis de vente, is signed, ask the notaire for a written estimate of the closing costs, called a provision sur frais, computed on your exact price and your exact property address. Compare that estimate against the public simulator and against the brackets quoted above. If the estimate exceeds your own math by more than the disbursement envelope can explain, ask which departmental rate was applied and whether the communal surcharge was included, because those two lines explain most gaps between a quick internet figure and the office’s number. If you are signing near June 1, confirm the rate year in writing, since article 1594 E moves the applicable rate on that date. And if the price includes furniture, verify that the deed project lists each item with its own price, because that separate valuation directly shrinks both the 6.32 percent tax base and the fee base under the rules quoted in Part I.

Negotiate the rebate before the signing appointment, not at the table. Write a short email asking whether the office will grant the maximum rebate allowed by article A444-174 on the fee slice above 100,000 euros, and keep the written answer with your file. Some offices grant it routinely to foreign buyers who ask; others refuse as a matter of policy. Either answer is lawful, but only a written answer counts. At the same time, confirm the practical terms of the wire: the notaire’s office must hold cleared funds before the deed is signed, and an international transfer from a US bank typically needs several business days plus currency-conversion time. Ask for the exact euro amount, the office’s escrow details, called the compte séquestre, and the latest value date, then send the wire with a margin of days, not hours. A missed value date postpones the signing, and a postponed signing in a chain of conditional dates can cost you the contractual penalty, called the clause pénale, sitting in your compromis.

If the final bill still looks wrong, do not simply refuse to pay and walk away, because the deed cannot be signed without the funds and the seller’s remedies for buyer default survive. Instead, dispute the specific line in writing with your math attached, referencing the article and the bracket, and ask the notaire to correct the décompte or explain the discrepancy line by line. Most errors settle at this stage: a departmental rate applied from the wrong year, a communal surcharge levied where the reduced new-build rate excludes it, a rebate promised but not applied, or disbursements billed twice. If the office holds its position on the regulated fee itself, know that fee bills are genuinely reviewable by the courts. Both Court of Cassation rulings cited in this article arose from fee-taxation orders, called ordonnances de taxe, issued by the first president of a court of appeal after a judge had set the notaire’s fees, in Paris on 28 November 2023 and in Orléans on 24 November 2021 respectively. The existence of that review path is proven by the published decisions themselves: fee orders get appealed, reach the Court of Cassation, and are quashed when the tariff was misapplied. For an American buyer, the practical sequence is therefore correspondence first, documented correction second, and court review of the fee as the last resort, with every step supported by the written estimate, the final décompte, and your own bracket math kept together in one file.

One related warning belongs here while the money is still in transit. French banks and notaires must verify where purchase funds come from, and your US bank will process the outgoing wire under its own compliance checks. Keep the paper trail for the transfer from its origin: bank statements showing the source of the funds, the currency-exchange confirmations, and the wire receipts matching the euro amount the notaire called for. If the funds come from the sale of US property, a gift from family, or a retirement-account distribution, keep the underlying document too, because each origin has its own US tax story that your CPA will need the following April. The closing file you build this week becomes the tax file you rely on for the next decade, so build it once and build it completely.

B. What Happens on the US Tax Return: Can You Deduct or Credit French Closing Costs?

American citizens are taxed on worldwide income wherever they live, so the French purchase must be reported correctly on the US return even though the house sits in France. The starting rule disappoints many buyers: the French transfer taxes, the registry contribution, and the notaire’s fee do not produce a foreign tax credit in the year of purchase. The foreign tax credit is designed to relieve double taxation of income, and the IRS limits it to taxes imposed on income as such. French registration duties and land taxes are levies on a transaction and on ownership, not taxes on your income, so they fall outside the credit even though they feel like income leaving your pocket. Do not claim them as a credit and do not deduct them as an expense of the year: both treatments invite an adjustment, and neither is needed, because the Code gives you something better, namely basis.

Almost every dollar of closing cost that is not a loan charge increases your tax basis in the house. The IRS explains in its guidance on basis of assets that settlement and closing costs, including transfer taxes, recording charges, and legal fees for the purchase, are added to the cost of the property rather than deducted (IRS Publication 551, Basis of Assets). Applied to the French décompte, that means the 6.32 percent transfer-tax envelope, the 0.10 percent registry contribution, the notaire’s regulated fee with its VAT, and the itemized disbursements tied to the acquisition all join your basis, while recurring loan costs such as mortgage arrangement fees and prepaid interest stay out. The payoff arrives years later when you sell: a higher basis means a smaller taxable gain on both the French and the American return. Keep the final décompte, the deed, and the exchange-rate confirmations with your permanent records for the house, annotated by year, because the sale-year return will ask what you paid and the only reliable answer is the paper you filed this week.

The France-United States income tax treaty confirms the architecture without changing this result. Its real-property article preserves each country’s right to tax local real estate and its income: under Article 6, paragraph 1, of the 1994 France-United States tax treaty, income from real property situated in one state may be taxed in that state. France therefore taxes the French house at every stage: its transfer taxes at purchase, its rental income while you hold it, and its capital gain at sale. The treaty then organizes relief in your state of residence, which for an American citizen is always the United States, through its own channels, credit for income taxes within their limits, and nothing in the treaty converts a French property-transfer tax into a creditable American benefit. The practical sequence is simple: pay the French closing taxes through the notaire without expecting American relief in year one, capitalize every eligible line into basis with clean records, and let the treaty do its work later on rental income and on the sale gain, where real double taxation would otherwise occur.

Two traps deserve a warning while the wire is still fresh. First, keep the purchase file physically separate from the loan file. If you borrow in France, the mortgage interest and the ongoing French property taxes follow their own American rules, distinct from closing costs: mortgage interest on a second home remains deductible within its limits for many buyers, while the annual French property taxes face strict federal limits that need a year-by-year answer from your CPA. Our breakdown of the annual taxe foncière and taxe d’habitation bills and their IRS treatment covers that recurring side in detail. Second, keep the purchase file away from your investment file. French bank investment products can trigger the American PFIC regime and its punishing forms, an entirely separate headache from the house. Closing costs belong in the house file, fund statements belong in the investment file, and mixing the two is how records get lost and elections get missed.

Conclusion

The notaire’s closing bill stops being intimidating once you read it as three envelopes. The tax envelope, transfer tax plus communal share plus collection costs plus the 0.10 percent registry contribution, is set by statute and by your department’s vote, reaches about 6.32 percent at most on an older home, and falls to about 0.71 percent on a new-build because VAT was already collected inside the developer’s price. The fee envelope, the sliding scale of article A444-91, is computed bracket by bracket, carries 20 percent VAT, tolerates a written 20 percent discount on the slice above 100,000 euros under article A444-174, and can never exceed 10 percent of the property value under article R444-9. The disbursement envelope is cost-only and should be itemized line by line. If a line looks wrong, challenge it in writing with your own bracket math, escalate through the documented correction, and remember that fee-taxation orders are genuinely reviewed by the courts, as the published Court of Cassation rulings prove. On the American side, capitalize nearly everything into basis, credit nothing at purchase, and keep the décompte until the sale year. Do these five things before you sign: run the official simulator on your exact address and price, demand the written estimate and compare it with your own math, ask for the rebate in writing, separate loan costs from purchase costs in your records, and file the final statement with the deed and the exchange confirmations. A French purchase rewards buyers who arrive with paperwork. Now you know which paperwork matters.

📄 Official circular