You are an American planning your retirement in France, and one question keeps you up at night: if you move to Lyon, Bordeaux, or Paris, who gets to tax your Social Security checks, your 401(k) distributions, your IRA withdrawals, and your company pension? The United States, France, or both? The answer is better than most newcomers expect, but it comes with traps that have already cost real taxpayers hundreds of thousands of euros in litigation. The tax treaty signed by France and the United States on August 31, 1994 gives the United States the exclusive right to tax almost every dollar of US retirement income paid to a French resident, and it forces France to wipe out its own income tax on that money through a treaty tax credit. France still takes its cut elsewhere, through social charges that can reach 9.1 percent of your pensions, and the filing mechanics punish anyone who reports the income in the wrong box. This guide walks through each income stream, the exact treaty and French-law rules that apply, three court decisions in which Americans fought the French tax administration over these very questions, and the forms to file so the treaty actually protects you.
I. Where Is Your US Retirement Income Taxed When You Retire in France?
A. Your US Social Security, 401(k), IRA and Pension Payments Are Taxable Only in the United States
The cornerstone rule sits in Article 18, paragraph 1 of the France-United States tax treaty, whose consolidated French text is published on the official French tax website. It provides that sums paid under the Social Security legislation of one contracting state to a resident of the other state, as well as sums paid under a retirement plan in connection with past employment, whether as periodic payments or as a lump sum, are taxable only in the state from which they come. For an American who has become a French tax resident, that means Social Security benefits, distributions from an employer 401(a) qualified plan, withdrawals from an individual retirement account, 403(b) plan payments, and private company pensions of US origin are all taxable only in the United States. France has no right to levy income tax on them. The treaty even anticipates the definitional fight: its second paragraph lists the US plans France accepts as corresponding in substance to a French retirement plan, including section 401(a) qualified plans, individual retirement plans and accounts, and section 403(a) and 403(b) plans. A lump-sum IRA payout therefore enjoys the same exclusive-US-taxation rule as a monthly pension check.
Two exceptions matter. First, government-service pensions fall under Article 19 of the treaty, not Article 18. Remuneration and pensions paid by a contracting state for public services are generally taxable only in the paying state, with a narrow exception when the services are performed in the other state by one of its nationals. A retired US federal employee living in France therefore stays, as a rule, in the US tax net for that pension. Second, the treaty contains a saving clause in Article 29, paragraph 2, under which the United States may tax its own residents and citizens as if the treaty did not exist. France’s exemption does not free you from the IRS: as a US citizen you still file a US return and report the income there. Paragraph 3 of that same article preserves the benefits of the pensions article and the double-tax relief article, so the two systems fit together instead of colliding.
On the French side, the starting point is domestic law. Article 79 of the French General Tax Code (Code général des impôts) provides: “Les traitements, indemnités, émoluments, salaires, pensions et rentes viagères concourent à la formation du revenu global servant de base à l’impôt sur le revenu. Il en est de même des prestations de retraite servies sous forme de capital.” In plain terms, pensions and even retirement benefits paid as capital form part of worldwide taxable income for a French resident, which is exactly why the treaty exemption mechanism described below is indispensable. And Article 158, 5, a of the same code grants pensioners a 10 percent allowance: “Les pensions et retraites font l’objet d’un abattement de 10 % qui ne peut excéder 4 439 €.” The same provision adds a floor: “L’abattement indiqué au deuxième alinéa ne peut être inférieur à 454 €, sans pouvoir excéder le montant brut des pensions et retraites.” These figures are the version in force since July 1, 2026. For treaty-protected US retirement income the allowance is academic, because France eliminates the tax entirely, but it matters for any French pension you also receive and for the income that sets your effective rate.
Before the treaty can protect you, France must regard you as its tax resident, and here Americans regularly stumble. Article 4 B of the General Tax Code treats as domiciled in France anyone with a home, a principal stay, a professional activity, or the center of economic interests in France, but it ends with a decisive reservation: “Les personnes qui satisfont à l’un au moins des critères fixés aux a à c du présent 1 ne peuvent toutefois pas être considérées comme ayant leur domicile fiscal en France lorsque, par application des conventions internationales relatives aux doubles impositions, elles ne sont pas regardées comme résidentes de France.” Domestic criteria therefore bow to the treaty tie-breaker. The treaty itself, in Article 4, paragraph 4, resolves dual residence step by step: permanent home first, then the state of closest personal and economic ties, then habitual presence. The Lyon administrative court of appeal applied exactly this ladder in a case pitting a taxpayer against the French administration over dual French-American residence. Citing the treaty, the court recalled: “Cette personne est considérée comme un résident de l’État où elle dispose d’un foyer d’habitation permanent ; si elle dispose d’un foyer d’habitation permanent dans les deux États, elle est considérée comme un résident de l’État avec lequel ses liens personnels et économiques sont les plus étroits (centre des intérêts vitaux)”. Because the taxpayer’s wife and schooled daughter stayed in the family home in New Jersey, which he owned and visited, the court fixed his center of vital interests in the United States and held: “Article 2 : La cotisation d’impôt sur le revenu à laquelle M. D… a été assujetti au titre de l’année 2013 est réduite à concurrence d’une somme de 7 539 euros.” The judgment, CAA Lyon, June 18, 2020, no. 18LY02139, shows that residence is won or lost on concrete facts, and that winning the tie-breaker can move thousands of euros. One related warning for green-card holders: the treaty provides that France treats a US citizen or permanent resident as a US resident only if that person principally stays in the United States, so keeping a green card while living full-time in France does not by itself settle residence in your favor.
B. How France Eliminates the Double Tax: The Treaty Credit Equal to the French Tax
Exclusive taxation in the United States is only half the story; the other half is how France zeroes out its own claim. The mechanism is Article 24, paragraph 1, a of the treaty, on the elimination of double taxation for France. US-source income that is taxable or taxable only in the United States is taken into account in computing the French tax, the US tax is not deductible, and the beneficiary receives a tax credit against the French tax. For income outside the dividends, interest, capital-gains, directors-fees, and entertainers categories, and pensions fall outside those categories, the credit equals the French tax attributable to that income. The economic result is an exemption with progression: France counts your US retirement income to set the rate applied to your other income, then erases the French tax on the US income itself with a credit of exactly the same amount.
The Conseil d’État confirmed this machinery in a 2025 decision involving an American national domiciled in France who received close to 1.9 million dollars through US partnerships after the sale of a California building, declared 1,647,943 euros in France, and claimed a treaty credit of 313,110 euros equal to the corresponding French tax, while the administration wanted to cap the credit at the 205,400 euros of US tax actually paid. The court restated the treaty rule in these terms: “Dans ce cas, l’impôt américain n’est pas déductible de ces revenus, mais le bénéficiaire a droit à un crédit imputable sur l’impôt français.” It then rejected the administration’s appeal outright: “Article 1er : Le pourvoi du ministre de l’économie, des finances et de la souveraineté industrielle et numérique est rejeté.” That decision, CE, February 28, 2025, no. 491788, concerned a capital gain rather than a pension, but the paragraph it interprets is the same one shielding your retirement income, and its lesson is general: for this class of income the treaty credit tracks the French tax, not the foreign tax paid. You do not need to have paid a single dollar to the IRS to get the full French credit; the credit follows the French computation.
In practice the French return implements this in three layers, as the official guidance of the French tax administration explains. First, you detail foreign pensions in schedule 2047, whose first section covers employment-related income including pensions. Second, you carry the amounts onto the main 2042 return. Third, because the treaty credit here equals the French tax rather than the foreign tax, you report the total on the dedicated lines for such credits, currently lines 8TK and following of the 2042 return, while income merely used to compute the effective rate goes on line 1AC and following of schedule 2042-C. Keep the treaty PDF and the US tax documents with your file: the administration can ask why a six-figure household with a French address pays French income tax on only a fraction of its cash flow, and the answer is one treaty article plus one credit line.
A final courtroom lesson concerns years when France withholds at source instead of waiting for your return. In a widely followed case, the California Public Employees’ Retirement System, the giant US public pension fund known as CalPERS, challenged French withholding tax levied on French-source dividends paid to a foreign pension fund that would have been exempt had it been established in France. The Conseil d’État annulled the appellate ruling against the fund, holding that its earlier 2009 decision striking down the administrative doctrine “révèle directement la non-conformité de la loi fiscale à une norme supérieure”, and it closed with: “Article 1er : L’arrêt de la cour administrative d’appel de Versailles du 7 juin 2016 est annulé.” That ruling, CE, January 24, 2018, no. 402167, is about dividends, not retiree pensions, but it establishes two points an American retiree should keep: discriminatory French withholding can be challenged, and claims for repayment run under strict time limits, so an erroneous levy discovered late can still be recovered if you identify the legal event that reopens the clock. If a French payer ever withholds on income the treaty reserves to the United States, do not let the file sleep.
II. What France Still Takes From an American Retiree
A. French Social Charges on Your Pensions: CSG, CRDS and CASA Rates and Thresholds That Apply to You
Here is the part many American retirees discover with shock: income tax and social charges are two different levies in France, and the treaty article that kills the income tax does not kill the social charges. As a French resident affiliated with the French health system, your pensions, including US-source pensions, bear the CSG (generalized social contribution), the CRDS (contribution to the repayment of the social debt), and in most cases the CASA (additional solidarity contribution for autonomy). The official service-public.fr information sheet, verified in June 2026, states the rule plainly: retirement pensions are subject to CSG and CRDS, with four possible CSG rates depending on household income: exemption, the reduced 3.8 percent rate, the median 6.6 percent rate, and the full 8.3 percent rate. For 2026 the applicable rate follows the reference tax income shown on your 2025 notice for 2024 income. For a household with one tax share, exemption runs up to 13,048 euros of reference income, the reduced rate from 13,049 to 17,057 euros, the median rate from 17,058 to 26,472 euros, and the full rate above 26,472 euros, with scaled thresholds for larger households. The combined burden, once CRDS at 0.5 percent and CASA at 0.3 percent are added for the upper brackets, reaches 4.3 percent at the reduced rate, 7.4 percent at the median rate, and 9.1 percent at the full rate, applied to the entire pension. Part of the CSG is deductible from income tax, 3.8 points at the reduced rate, 4.2 at the median rate, 5.9 at the full rate, which softens the blow slightly for the portion of your income France actually taxes. Two refinements protect retirees with fluctuating income: moving up from the reduced rate requires exceeding the threshold two years in a row, and households at the zero rate pay neither CRDS nor CASA. Full details are on the official CSG and CRDS page.
A separate withholding regime applies before you become a French resident, or to French-source pensions paid while you live abroad. Article 182 A of the General Tax Code provides: “les traitements, salaires, pensions et rentes viagères, de source française, servis à des personnes qui ne sont pas fiscalement domiciliées en France donnent lieu à l’application d’une retenue à la source.” The 2026 scale taxes the slice above 17,275 euros at 12 percent up to 50,112 euros and at 20 percent beyond, with lower 8 and 14.4 percent rates overseas, and the levy is creditable: “La retenue s’impute sur le montant de l’impôt sur le revenu établi dans les conditions prévues à l’article 197 A” Concretely, if you spend a transition year outside France while a French pension body pays you, expect withholding at these rates, then a true-up once residence and treaty status are settled. Once you are a French resident, this withholding article steps aside and the treaty credit takes over. The companion computation rule is Article 197 A of the General Tax Code, which applies the standard income-tax schedule to the French-source income of persons without a French tax domicile, subject to a minimum charge computed at 20 percent on the lower slice of net taxable income.
One planning point follows directly: because social charges track your French reference tax income, and treaty-exempt US pensions still count for the effective rate, a large IRA distribution can push you from the 3.8 to the 6.6 percent CSG bracket for two years even though France levies no income tax on that distribution. Spreading a conversion or a lump-sum withdrawal across calendar years can keep the all-in social-charge rate down. Run the numbers before you move money, not after.
B. Filing It Right in France: Forms 2047 and 2042, Deadlines and the Mistakes That Cost Money
The French filing season runs each spring for the prior year’s income, online filing being the norm, and every member of the household must declare foreign income. The official impots.gouv.fr guidance on foreign income walks through the exact path: detail the pensions in schedule 2047, carry them onto return 2042, and handle double-tax relief according to which kind of credit the treaty grants. Where the credit equals the foreign tax, you declare gross income and claim the credit on lines 8VL, 8VM, 8WM, or 8UM of schedule 2042-C. Where, as with your US retirement income, the credit equals the French tax, you declare gross income and use lines 8TK and following instead. Pensions relevant only for the effective rate go on line 1AC and following of schedule 2042-C. The same page confirms the social-charges declaration in boxes 8TQ and following. Bookmark the official foreign-income filing guide and the service-public page on declaring income received abroad, and declare pensions as the pension-declaration guide directs.
Four mistakes recur in American retiree files. First, reporting US retirement income as ordinary taxable pensions with no treaty credit, which means paying full French income tax plus social charges on money France had agreed not to tax; the fix is a corrective return invoking Article 18, paragraph 1 and Article 24, paragraph 1, a, i of the treaty. Second, assuming the French exemption ends US obligations: under the saving clause the IRS still taxes its citizens, so you keep filing US returns, keep paying estimated tax if needed, and coordinate through a US preparer who understands the treaty, while France stays out of that income. Third, forgetting that exempt income still drives the effective rate on your other French-taxed income and your CSG bracket, as explained above; a year with a big 401(k) withdrawal is the wrong year to realize a French capital gain if you can choose. Fourth, letting deadlines drift: French claims generally follow a December 31 of the second year rhythm, and while treaty-based repayment claims obey their own event rules illustrated by the CalPERS litigation, files left dormant lose options every month. Mark every notice date the day it arrives.
Two adjacent topics deserve a signpost rather than a shortcut. If you split your working life between the two countries, which state pays your Social Security benefit and how totalization fills gaps is a different question from which state taxes the benefit; our companion guide on Social Security totalization, tax, health care, and PUMA for Americans retiring in France covers the benefits side. And if you hold Roth accounts, do not assume symmetric treatment with traditional accounts: verify how each distribution qualifies under the retirement-plan definitions of Article 18, paragraph 2 before reporting, because labels do not decide treaty character, plan features do.
Conclusion
An American retiring in France sits in one of the most favorable treaty positions available anywhere: US Social Security, 401(k), IRA, and company pension payments flow to you with France’s income tax reduced to zero by a credit equal to the French tax itself, under treaty articles interpreted by the Conseil d’État as recently as February 2025. That protection is automatic only if you claim it properly, through residence correctly established under the tie-breaker the Lyon court applied to the dollar, through schedule 2047 and the right credit lines on return 2042, and through continued US compliance under the saving clause. France’s share arrives via social charges of up to 9.1 percent and via the effective rate your exempt income sets on everything else, so calendar-year planning around large distributions pays for itself. Get the residence analysis, the treaty credit lines, and the social-charge bracket right in year one, and the France-US treaty does exactly what it was written to do: one income, taxed once, in the country that paid the pension.