You are an American citizen, you own a house in France, and you want to leave it to your spouse, to one child only, or to someone outside the family. Your American will says so in clear terms. Then a French notaire tells you that your child can challenge the will and take a fixed share of the house anyway. That surprise has a name: the réserve héréditaire, which Americans usually call forced heirship. This article explains, in plain English, why you generally cannot disinherit a child under French law, how much each child is guaranteed, why choosing American law in your will does not solve the problem on its own, and which legal tools actually let you favor one person within the rules.
French terms appear throughout this article because the notaire and the courts will use them. Each one is explained the first time it appears. The key distinction to keep in mind is between the réserve héréditaire, meaning the locked share of your estate that the law reserves for your children, and the quotité disponible, meaning the free share you can give to anyone you choose. Everything in French succession planning is a negotiation between those two fractions.
I. Why French law stops you from disinheriting a child, even with an American will
A. How much of your French estate your children are guaranteed by law
Article 912 of the French Civil Code gives the starting definition: the forced share is the portion of the estate that the statute passes on, free of charges, to the protected heirs who are called to the succession and accept it. For most American families, the protected heirs, called héritiers réservataires, are simply the children. For most American families, the protected heirs, called héritiers réservataires, are simply the children. A surviving spouse is not a réservataire when there are children; the spouse has other protections, but not the forced share.
The same article defines the other half of the system: “La quotité disponible est la part des biens et droits successoraux qui n’est pas réservée par la loi et dont le défunt a pu disposer librement par des libéralités.” The free share is whatever is left after the forced share, and it is the only part you can give away freely by gifts made during your lifetime, called donations entre vifs, or by testament, meaning a will. The full text of these definitions is published on Article 912 of the Civil Code on Légifrance.
The size of the forced share depends on how many children you leave. Article 913 of the Civil Code sets the fractions: “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” Read from the other side, the rule means that with one child, half of your estate is locked for that child and half is free; with two children, two thirds are locked and one third is free; with three or more children, three quarters are locked and one quarter is free. The official text is available at Article 913 of the Civil Code on Légifrance.
Take a concrete example. You own a house in France worth 600,000 euros and you have two children from a marriage in the United States. You write an American will leaving the entire house to your surviving spouse. Under Article 913, the two children together are guaranteed two thirds of your estate, meaning 400,000 euros of value, and the free share is only one third, or 200,000 euros. Your spouse can receive the free third, but the children can demand the rest. If there is not enough outside the house to pay them, the gift to your spouse is reduced and your spouse may owe them a balancing payment.
That balancing mechanism is called the action en réduction, the legal action to reduce excessive gifts. Only the protected heirs, their own heirs, or their successors can bring it; neither the recipients of the gifts nor the creditors of the deceased can demand it or benefit from it. Since 2021, the notaire settling the succession has a statutory duty: when the file shows that a protected heir’s forced rights may have been harmed by lifetime gifts or legacies, the notaire must inform each affected and known heir individually, if possible before any partition, of the right to demand reduction. Time limits are strict. Article 921 provides: “Le délai de prescription de l’action en réduction est fixé à cinq ans à compter de l’ouverture de la succession, ou à deux ans à compter du jour où les héritiers ont eu connaissance de l’atteinte portée à leur réserve, sans jamais pouvoir excéder dix ans à compter du décès.” In practice, that means five years from the death, or two years from the day the heirs learned that their forced share was harmed, with an absolute ceiling of ten years from the death. The full provision is at Article 921 of the Civil Code on Légifrance.
Crucially, the modern reduction almost never takes the house itself away from the recipient. Article 924 states: “Lorsque la libéralité excède la quotité disponible, le gratifié, successible ou non successible, doit indemniser les héritiers réservataires à concurrence de la portion excessive de la libéralité, quel que soit cet excédent.” When a gift exceeds the free share, the recipient must compensate the protected heirs up to the excessive portion, however large that excess is. The recipient keeps the property and pays money. A child who was counting on being cut out of the deed therefore still receives value, just in cash rather than in stone. See Article 924 of the Civil Code on Légifrance.
The courts apply these rules to foreign families without hesitation when French real estate is involved. In a decision of July 4, 2018, the First Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, appeal number 17-16.515, upheld a ruling that the descent of houses located in France had to take the forced heirship rules into account, holding that those rules, being a matter of domestic public policy, could not be brushed aside by testamentary provisions drawn up under the law of the deceased’s domicile governing his personal status. The Court’s own words, published in the Bulletin, were that “la dévolution successorale desdits immeubles devait tenir compte des règles de la réserve héréditaire, laquelle, d’ordre public interne, ne pouvait être écartée par des dispositions testamentaires établies selon la loi du domicile du défunt et régissant son statut personnel”. The full decision is published at Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber, July 4, 2018, No. 17-16.515. For successions opened before August 17, 2015, the courts divided the estate by category: movable property followed the law of the last domicile, while houses in France followed French law, including the forced share. That split was confirmed in a 2021 ruling on a 2013 succession with a Swedish domicile, where the Court recalled that the law governing the succession designates the protected heirs and the amount of their forced share, and that “celle-ci s’applique donc également à la réduction des libéralités qui excèderaient la quotité disponible”, meaning that same law also governs the reduction of gifts exceeding the free share. See Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber, April 14, 2021, No. 19-24.773.
B. Why writing your will under American law does not let you disinherit on its own
Many Americans hear about the European Succession Regulation, Regulation 650/2012, and conclude that choosing American law in their will solves everything. The mechanism is real but its effect is narrower than most people think. The Regulation’s default rule, in Article 21, points to the law of the country where the deceased lived day to day at the time of death, applied to the succession as a whole. If you retire to France and live there daily, French law therefore governs your worldwide succession by default, including your French house. The choice-of-law option, called professio juris, meaning the choice of the applicable law, is found in Article 22: a person may submit the whole succession to the law of any country whose nationality they hold, whether at the time of the choice or at death. An American can therefore validly designate the law of a US state in a will, and a French notaire must in principle apply it.
The trap is that this choice governs the civil side of the succession, meaning who inherits what, but it no longer blocks the forced share safety net that the French legislature built for children. In 2021, Parliament added a third paragraph to Article 913, creating what practitioners call the prélèvement compensatoire, meaning a compensatory levy. The statute provides: In plain terms, when the deceased or at least one of the children is, at the time of death, a national of a European Union member state or habitually resident there, and the foreign law governing the succession offers children no forced-share protection at all, each child or their own heirs can take a compensatory levy from the property located in France on the day of death, so as to recover the forced rights French law grants, up to that amount.
Read that condition list carefully, because Americans misunderstand it in both directions. A family in which everyone is American and habitually resident in the United States, owning only a vacation house in France, does not obviously trigger the levy, since neither the deceased nor a child is an EU national or EU resident. But the moment one child lives in France, or the deceased retired to France and became habitually resident there, the doorway opens. And even where the levy does not apply, the default Regulation rule often points right back to French law anyway when the deceased lived in France. Choosing Texas or New York law in your will is still worth doing, because it unifies the succession and avoids splitting the estate asset by asset, but it is not a disinheritance machine.
The courts have already blessed this architecture. On September 24, 2025, the Paris Court of Appeal, division 4 chamber 8, case number 23/05397, rejected an argument that Articles 912 and 913 violate European property rights, noting that “la loi n° 2021-1109 du 24 août 2021 a introduit un troisième alinéa à l’article 913 du code civil, instituant un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens situés en France, lorsque la loi étrangère applicable à la succession ne permet aucun mécanisme réservataire protecteur des enfants”. The court added that through that later statute, “le législateur français a rappelé l’importance du mécanisme de la réserve successorale, y compris dans les successions soumises à la loi étrangère”, and that the legislature had thereby clarified that the forced-share mechanism serves the general interest. The decision is published at Paris Court of Appeal, September 24, 2025, No. 23/05397. In short, a judge in Paris will not set the forced share aside because an American will says otherwise.
One more confusion to clear up: the estate tax treaty between the United States and France, signed in 1978 and amended by a 2004 protocol, with its official technical explanation published by the United States Treasury, deals only with taxes, meaning which country taxes the inheritance and how double taxation is credited. It does not change who inherits. Civil law decides the shares; the treaty decides the tax bill. Keep those two questions separate and you will avoid the most common and most expensive misunderstanding American families bring to a French notaire.
II. What you can legally do to favor one person despite the forced share
A. Use the free share fully and secure it with a formal advance waiver
Everything you cannot take from the forced share, you can still organize inside the free share, and the free share of a French estate is often larger than Americans expect. With two children it is one third of the whole estate; with one child it is one half. Within that fraction you can make lifetime gifts, write legacies in your will, or combine both. The standard professional move for parents who want one child, or a spouse, to end up with the French house is to give that person assets up to the full free share and to document the operation so the other children cannot reopen it later.
The strongest lock is the renonciation anticipée à l’action en réduction, universally shortened to RAAR, meaning an advance waiver of the action to reduce excessive gifts. Article 929 of the Civil Code provides: “Tout héritier réservataire présomptif peut renoncer à exercer une action en réduction dans une succession non ouverte.” Any presumptive protected heir can waive, while the succession is still in the future, the right to bring a reduction action. The waiver must name the person or persons who benefit from it, it binds the waiving heir only once the future deceased has accepted it, and it can cover all or only part of the forced share, or only the reduction of a gift of a specific property, such as the French house. See Article 929 of the Civil Code on Légifrance. The formalities are deliberately heavy. Article 930 requires: “La renonciation est établie par acte authentique spécifique reçu par deux notaires.” The waiver must be drawn up as a standalone notarized deed received by two notaires, signed separately by each waiving heir in the presence of the notaires alone, spelling out its future legal consequences for each of them. A waiver missing these formalities is void, as is one obtained by mistake, fraud, or duress. See Article 930 of the Civil Code on Légifrance.
In practice, the RAAR works best as a family settlement: the parents give the French house to the child who lives nearby or who will maintain it, within the free share, and the other children sign advance waivers before two notaires in exchange for other assets, cash, or American property of equivalent value. Because the deed must be notarized and accepted while everyone is alive and in agreement, it cannot be improvised after a death. Families that start this conversation five or ten years early get clean results; families that discover the forced share at the first notaire appointment after a death get litigation.
Tax planning runs alongside the civil planning, and here American parents get genuine help from French law. For gift and inheritance tax purposes, Article 779 of the General Tax Code grants “un abattement de 100 000 € sur la part de chacun des ascendants et sur la part de chacun des enfants vivants ou représentés par suite de prédécès ou de renonciation”, meaning a 100,000 euro tax-free allowance on the share of each living child, or of each child represented by their own descendants. The full provision is at Article 779 of the General Tax Code on Légifrance. Beyond that allowance, the progressive direct-line rates of Article 777 apply, starting at 5 percent on the first 8,072 euros and rising in brackets to 45 percent above 1,805,677 euros, as published at Article 777 of the General Tax Code on Légifrance. Gifts can therefore be staged over time: earlier gifts generally drop out of the tax computation after fifteen years, because Article 784 of the General Tax Code orders gifts made more than fifteen years earlier to be left out when adding prior gifts back into the taxable base. The exact rule, worth reading before any large gift, is at Article 784 of the General Tax Code on Légifrance. None of this changes the civil forced share, but it changes the tax cost of using the free share well. Coordinate both with the notaire, and have an American tax adviser confirm the United States side, since the United States taxes its citizens on worldwide gifts and estates under its own exemption system.
B. Fund life insurance correctly, because courts respect it within strict limits
The second classic tool is assurance-vie, meaning French life insurance, which under French law is not technically part of the succession. The capital or annuity payable on death to a named beneficiary sits outside the estate: it is neither brought back into the mass to be shared, a step called rapport, nor subject to reduction for harming the forced share. Article L132-13 of the Insurance Code states the principle: “Le capital ou la rente payables au décès du contractant à un bénéficiaire déterminé ne sont soumis ni aux règles du rapport à succession, ni à celles de la réduction pour atteinte à la réserve des héritiers du contractant.” The same article states the one exception: “Ces règles ne s’appliquent pas non plus aux sommes versées par le contractant à titre de primes, à moins que celles-ci n’aient été manifestement exagérées eu égard à ses facultés.” Premium payments also escape sharing and reduction, unless they were manifestly excessive in light of the policyholder’s means. The official text is at Article L132-13 of the Insurance Code on Légifrance.
That exception is where American families win or lose. Courts do not measure excess by looking at the contract in hindsight; they measure it on the day each premium was paid, against the age, wealth, family situation, and needs of the person paying, plus whether the contract was actually useful to that person. The Court of Cassation restated the test word for word at the end of 2024: “les primes versées par le souscripteur d’un contrat d’assurance sur la vie ne sont rapportables à la succession que si elles présentent un caractère manifestement exagéré eu égard aux facultés du souscripteur, un tel caractère s’appréciant au moment du versement, au regard de l’âge, des situations patrimoniale et familiale du souscripteur ainsi que de l’utilité du contrat pour celui-ci.” A court that punishes a policyholder merely because the contract ended up holding most of the wealth, without examining means and usefulness at the time of payment, misapplies the law. That is exactly what the Second Civil Chamber held on December 19, 2024, appeal number 23-19.110, quashing a ruling that had ordered 130,000 euros in premiums paid for the benefit of a cancer charity brought back into the succession. The decision is published at Court of Cassation, Second Civil Chamber, December 19, 2024, No. 23-19.110.
The practical lesson for an American parent is straightforward. A life insurance contract funded with reasonable premiums, kept proportionate to your wealth, serving a genuine savings or protection purpose, and naming the person you wish to favor, will normally pass outside the forced-share computation, and the children cannot claw it back. A contract stuffed at age eighty-five with nearly all of your assets, leaving the children an empty estate, will be treated as a disguised gift and pulled back in. American citizens should add one more check that French families never face: the United States taxes and reporting treatment of a French contract, and some French contracts are punished under American anti-deferral rules. Fund the contract at a level a judge would call reasonable, keep the subscription documents proving your means at the time, and clear the American tax side before signing.
Two final cautions close this second part. First, informal tricks do not work: backdated gifts, undeclared hand-to-hand transfers of large sums, or a will that silently gives everything to one child will be reconstructed by the notaire’s accounting, and the reduction action, with its information duty and its five, two, and ten year deadlines, exists precisely for that cleanup. Second, none of these tools require you to cut ties with any child. The RAAR is signed by the children themselves, the free share is computed openly, and life insurance names its beneficiary in a regulated contract. French succession law rewards families that plan in the open and punishes secrecy. If your goal is to protect a spouse in the French house for life, ask the notaire about combining the free share with a lifetime right of use; if your goal is to prefer the child who will keep the house, combine a gift within the free share with advance waivers from the others. Both routes stay inside the forced share instead of fighting it, which is why they survive court review.
Conclusion
An American owner of a French house generally cannot disinherit a child. The forced share locks one half, two thirds, or three quarters of the estate depending on the number of children; the reduction action lets each child recover the missing value in money, with five, two, and ten year deadlines; choosing American law in your will unifies the succession but does not by itself defeat the compensatory levy on French property when its conditions are met; and the estate tax treaty answers only the tax question, never the inheritance question. The lawful path runs through the free share: give it deliberately, secure sibling agreements with advance waivers signed before two notaires, stage gifts to use the 100,000 euro allowance per child and the fifteen year cycle, and fund life insurance at levels no court could call manifestly excessive. Start while everyone is alive, put every step through the notaire, and have the American tax side checked in parallel. Planned openly, a French succession with American heirs ends in signatures; discovered after a death, it ends in expert reports.