KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My Father Died With a House in France and I Live in America: Who Taxes the Inheritance and How the 1978 Treaty Cancels the Second Bill

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My Father Died With a House in France and I Live in America: Who Taxes the Inheritance and How the 1978 Treaty Cancels the Second Bill

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Your father has died, and he owned a house in France. You live in America. Within weeks, two tax administrations start asking for money on the same property: the French notaire (the public officer who settles every French estate) withholds French droits de succession (inheritance tax), and the Internal Revenue Service expects the federal estate-tax return to list the same house. Many American families in this situation pay twice, or pay in the wrong country first and discover that the second country will not refund the first. A treaty signed in Washington on November 24, 1978, amended in 2004, exists precisely to prevent that outcome: the Convention between France and the United States for the avoidance of double taxation of estates and gifts. It does not exempt the French house from tax. It organizes who taxes what, forces each country to credit the tax paid to the other, gives the surviving spouse and the heirs the same allowances as a purely French family, and sets hard deadlines for claiming the credit. This guide explains, step by step, when France taxes you, when the United States taxes you as well, how the credit wipes out the second bill, and the three traps, trusts, French life insurance, and gifts made from America, that still catch families who assume the treaty handles everything.

I. Will France Tax My American Family’s Inheritance, and Will America Tax It Again?

Two different questions hide inside every cross-border death, and they belong to two different bodies of rules. The first question is who inherits, which is governed by succession law, including the European Succession Regulation and any choice of American law your parent wrote into a will. The second question is who taxes, which is governed by French domestic tax law, American federal tax law, and the 1978 treaty that sits on top of both. Confusing the two is the most expensive mistake American families make: choosing United States law in a will changes the forced shares of the children, but it does not move the house out of the French tax net. Keep the two questions separate from the start, and everything that follows becomes readable.

A. When Does France Get to Tax the French House?

France starts from a simple connecting factor: the location of the property and the tax residence (domicile fiscal) of the deceased. Article 750 ter of the French General Tax Code (Code général des impôts) provides that, first, worldwide movable and immovable property is subject to French transfer tax “lorsque le donateur ou le défunt a son domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article 4 B”, and second, French-situated property is taxable “lorsque le donateur ou le défunt n’a pas son domicile fiscal en France”. In plain English: if your father was a French tax resident, France taxes everything he owned, in France and in America. If he lived in America and was not a French tax resident, France still taxes the French house itself, because it sits on French soil. Either way, the house in France is inside the French tax base. There is no exit through non-residence for real estate.

Tax residence itself is defined by Article 4 B of the same code: “Sont considérées comme ayant leur domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article 4 A : a. Les personnes qui ont en France leur foyer ou le lieu de leur séjour principal ; b. Celles qui exercent en France une activité professionnelle, salariée ou non”. An American retiree who moved his main home (foyer) to the Dordogne is therefore a French tax resident even with an American passport, and his worldwide estate, including his United States bank accounts, falls into the French return. Conversely, an American who never left Ohio but kept a vacation house in Brittany is not a French tax resident, yet the Brittany house is taxable in France under the second branch of Article 750 ter. Your first practical task is to fix, with evidence, which branch applies to the deceased, because it determines whether the French return covers the whole world or only the French assets.

The treaty confirms the situs rule for real estate in even broader terms than domestic law. Article 5 of the 1978 Convention states: real property is taxable in the State where it is situated (Article 5 of the treaty) And families who hold the house through a French property company should read the next paragraph with attention, because it closes the classic workaround: shares in a company whose assets consist, directly or through intermediaries, at least half of situated real estate count as real estate and are deemed situated where that property lies (Article 5, paragraph 3 of the treaty) A société civile immobilière (SCI, the French family property company) whose assets are at least half French real estate is treated as French real estate for treaty purposes. Putting the house into an SCI does not move it out of France.

Furniture, cars, and valuables inside the house follow a nearby rule: tangible movable property is taxable where it is situated, as Article 7 of the treaty allocates tangible movable property, other than cash, to the State where it is situated (treaty text). Debts reduce the taxable base, but only proportionally: Article 9 of the treaty provides that debts deductible under domestic law reduce the gross value of the property taxable in each State, in proportion to situated versus worldwide assets (Article 9 of the treaty) The mortgage on the French house therefore reduces the French base in the proportion the French property bears to the worldwide estate, not euro for euro against the French house alone when the estate spans both countries.

Once the base is fixed, France applies its own scale, and the treaty does not soften it. Article 777 of the General Tax Code sets progressive rates for direct-line heirs, starting at 5 percent up to 8,072 euros and climbing to 45 percent beyond 1,805,677 euros, with the middle brackets at 10, 15, 20, 30, and 40 percent. Before the scale applies, each child deducts a personal allowance (abattement) of 100,000 euros, since Article 779 provides that “il est effectué un abattement de 100 000 € sur la part de chacun des ascendants et sur la part de chacun des enfants vivants ou représentés par suite de prédécès ou de renonciation”. The surviving spouse, married or bound by a civil solidarity pact (pacte civil de solidarité, PACS, the French registered partnership), pays nothing at all: “Sont exonérés de droits de mutation par décès le conjoint survivant et le partenaire lié au défunt par un pacte civil de solidarité.” These allowances matter twice, because, as Part II explains, the treaty extends them to American domiciliaries and American beneficiaries exactly as if they lived in France.

One clarification before leaving French taxation. Choosing American law for the succession, the professio juris allowed by the European Succession Regulation, decides who receives which share under forced heirship rules. It never decides taxation. The Regulation itself states its boundary in Article 1: Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 states in Article 1 that it applies to succession to estates while revenue, customs and administrative matters fall outside its scope. Taxes are revenue matters. A valid American-law clause in your father’s will changes the heirs’ shares; the French house remains taxable in France under Article 750 ter and Article 5 of the treaty regardless.

B. When Does the United States Get to Tax It Too?

The United States taxes its citizens on their worldwide estates wherever they live, and the treaty openly admits it cannot stop that. This is the treaty’s saving clause, and every American family must read it before hoping the treaty shields them from the IRS. Article 1, paragraph 4 of the Convention provides that the treaty expressly preserves the right of the United States to tax under its own law the estate or gift of anyone who, at death or at the gift date, was a United States citizen, was domiciled in the United States, or had expatriated principally to escape tax, the last case for ten years after expatriation (Article 1, paragraph 4 of the treaty). If your father was an American citizen when he died, the United States keeps full power to apply its federal estate tax to his worldwide estate, including the French house. The treaty then works only in one direction for him: it obliges the other country to relieve the resulting double taxation through credits, which Part II details. It never obliges the United States to stand down.

The treaty’s personal scope confirms how wide the American net is. Article 1 covers estates of persons domiciled in France at death alongside estates of persons subject to United States tax by reason of domicile or American citizenship, with a matching rule for lifetime gifts (treaty text). Citizenship alone pulls an American into the treaty, even if he lived his whole adult life in France and died there. Conversely, a French citizen who lived in America can be treated as domiciled in both States at once, which is why the treaty contains a tie-breaker: habitual home first, then the center of vital interests (centre des intérêts vitaux), then habitual presence, then citizenship, in that order. Article 4 states the middle steps this way: a person with a permanent home in both States, or in neither, is deemed domiciled where personal ties are closest, then where presence is habitual, then in the State of citizenship (Article 4, paragraph 2 of the treaty). An American executive posted to Paris for three years who kept his family home, doctor, clubs, and daily life in Texas will usually keep an American domicile under this cascade; a retiree who sold everything in Florida and rebuilt his entire life in Provence will usually be treated as French-domiciled.

There is also a short-stay shield worth knowing for mobile Americans. A United States citizen who is technically domiciled in both countries is deemed domiciled only in the United States if he clearly intended to keep his American domicile and spent less than five years in France out of the previous seven. Article 4, paragraph 3 deems such a person domiciled only in the citizenship State where intent to keep that domicile is manifest and presence in the other State totaled under five years out of the prior seven (treaty text). The protection is narrow, intentional, and time-limited: it does not help the American who has lived in France for a decade, and the “manifest intention” must be documented, through kept voter registration, stated intent in correspondence, maintained American home, and similar evidence, not merely asserted after death.

On the substance of what each country may tax, the treaty names the covered levies without ambiguity. Article 2 covers, for the United States, the federal estate and gift taxes including the generation-skipping transfer tax, and for France, succession and gift duties (treaty text) The IRS itself lists France in its table of estate and gift tax treaty partners, whose treaty table lists France as an estate-and-gift treaty partner (IRS treaty table). State-level inheritance taxes, where American states still impose them, sit outside this treaty: it binds only the federal estate and gift taxes on the American side. An heir in a State that taxes inheritances must check that State’s own rules separately; the 1978 Convention gives no credit against a Sacramento or Albany bill.

II. How Do I Pay Only Once, Claim Every Allowance, and File on Time?

Knowing that both countries may tax is only half the answer. The treaty’s real value is its machinery for making the total equal one country’s tax, not the sum of two, provided the family files in the right order, claims the credit expressly, and respects deadlines that run in months, not years. This part walks through the credit mechanism, a priced example on a typical French house, the spouse protections, and the filing calendar, before turning to the three situations the treaty does not fix by itself.

A. How the Treaty Erases the Second Tax Bill

The architecture is deliberately simple: each country first computes its tax under its own law, then subtracts what was paid to the other country. Article 12 starts from the principle that each State first levies its own tax, then organizes the relief (treaty text). When the deceased was domiciled in France, France taxes the entire estate, including the American assets, and grants on that tax a deduction equal to the United States tax paid on the doubly-taxed property transferred on the same occasion (Article 12 of the treaty). The deduction is capped: capped at the pre-deduction French tax attributable to that property (Article 12 of the treaty) In practice, France subtracts the American tax euro for euro, but never more than the French tax attributable to the doubly-taxed property. If the American tax on an asset exceeds the French tax on the same asset, the excess is lost; no refund of the difference comes from Paris.

The mirror relief runs from Washington toward American citizens and domiciliaries. Where the deceased was a United States citizen but, under the tie-breaker, domiciled in France, the United States credits the French tax collected, after any French deduction for United States tax (Article 12 of the treaty). The executor of a United States citizen who retired in France therefore pays the French droits first and credits them against the federal estate tax. Two guardrails frame the whole system. First, the allowances travel with the taxpayer: for French tax on a succession or gift by a United States citizen or domiciliary, the same allowances and credits apply as if the person had been French-domiciled, and symmetrically for an American beneficiary of a French-domiciled deceased (Article 12, paragraph 4 of the treaty). The 100,000-euro child allowance and the spouse exemption apply to your family exactly as to a family from Lyon. Second, the treaty never increases anyone’s bill: the treaty can never increase the tax due under either State’s domestic law (Article 12, paragraph 8 of the treaty) If applying the treaty somehow produced a higher tax than domestic law alone, domestic law prevails.

A concrete illustration shows how the pieces fit. Take a father, French tax resident, who dies owning a Paris apartment worth 420,000 euros, leaving one adult child living in Boston. France taxes the worldwide estate; assume the apartment is the whole estate. The child deducts the 100,000-euro allowance, leaving 320,000 euros taxable. The direct-line scale of Article 777 then applies: 5 percent up to 8,072 euros, 10 percent from 8,072 to 12,109 euros, 15 percent to 15,932 euros, and 20 percent above, up to 552,324 euros. The arithmetic gives roughly 404 euros on the first slice, 404 euros on the second, 573 euros on the third, and 60,814 euros on the balance, for a French bill near 62,194 euros. If the same apartment also bore American federal estate tax because the father had kept American citizenship, France would deduct that American tax from the 62,194 euros, capped at the French tax attributable to the apartment. If no American tax was due on it, the French bill stands alone and no American credit is needed. Families should run this calculation before the notaire closes the file, because the order of payment determines which country grants the credit, and paying in the wrong order can strand money for years.

Married couples receive dedicated protection that pure domestic law does not always give. Where an American-domiciled or American-citizen spouse acquired property for consideration during the marriage and leaves it to the other spouse, Article 11 treats it as community property for French tax purposes, unless the couple expressly chose a different regime: such property counts as community property for French tax purposes unless the couple expressly chose a different regime (Article 11, paragraph 1 of the treaty) And where the surviving spouse is not an American citizen, the estate can elect a treaty marital deduction replicating the American spousal deduction, provided the executor opts in and irrevocably waives any other American marital deduction for the estate, within the American domestic deadline for electing a qualified domestic trust: the treaty conditions the benefit on the executor electing it and irrevocably waiving every other American marital deduction for the estate (Article 11, paragraph 3 of the treaty). The election is irrevocable, so it must be modeled before it is signed: in some estates the French spouse exemption already zeroes the French tax, and the American election then only affects the American side.

Deadlines decide whether the relief survives contact with reality. In France, heirs file the déclaration de succession (estate return) within six months of death when the deceased died in metropolitan France, and within twelve months when the death occurred abroad: the official service-public.fr page sets six months from death for metropolitan France and twelve months for deaths abroad (déclaration deadlines) The return uses the official estate forms, each completed in two signed copies, and the detailed form notices are listed on the administration’s form page at Déclaration de succession. These domestic time limits run alongside the treaty’s own credit deadline: a credit or refund claim under the Convention must be filed before the longest of the applicable periods, including one year after the final administrative or judicial determination and payment of the tax for which Article 12 credit is claimed, provided that determination and payment occur within ten years of death (Article 13 of the treaty). Concretely, an American executor waiting for the final IRS assessment before claiming the French deduction keeps a one-year window after that final determination, capped at ten years from death. And when the two administrations disagree, on domicile, on valuation, on the credit amount, Article 14 opens a mutual agreement procedure letting any person facing treaty-contrary taxation submit the case to either State’s competent authority alongside domestic appeals (treaty text). File the domestic appeals and the treaty request in parallel; one does not replace the other.

B. Trusts, Life Insurance, and Gifts From America: Three Traps That Survive the Treaty

The treaty divides taxing rights, but it does not rewrite French civil characterization, and three American planning tools change character when they cross the Atlantic. The first is the revocable living trust. An American who places the French house in a trust often believes the trust owns the house and no French succession occurs. French courts disagree twice over. First, French courts recharacterize American trust-and-insurance packages as indirect gifts (donations indirectes) when the settlor has irrevocably parted with the assets. In a June 30, 2025 ruling concerning an American family’s irrevocable discretionary trusts funded with United States life-insurance contracts, the Paris Court of Appeal held that “par l’effet de ces stipulations des actes constitutifs des trusts et des contrats d’assurance-vie, [U] [E] s’est irrévocablement dessaisi de son vivant, au profit des bénéficiaires désignés des trusts LIT 1 et LIT 2, des actifs investis dans les contrats d’assurance-vie, eux-mêmes placés dans ces trusts”. Because the trustees, not the insured, owned and controlled the policies, the payouts were not insurance proceeds but trust distributions, so “ni les dispositions des articles L. 132-12 et L. 132-13 du code des assurances, ni celles des articles 757 B et 990 I du code général des impôts, qui disposent que les sommes versées aux bénéficiaires d’un contrat d’assurance-vie ne font pas partie de la succession et qui prévoient les prélèvements auxquels ces sommes sont soumises, ne sont applicables aux sommes perçues par Mme [W] en tant que bénéficiaire, non des contrats d’assurance-vie souscrits sur la tête de [U] [E], mais en tant que bénéficiaire des trusts”, and the court concluded that “ces opérations constituent ainsi des donations indirectes”. The trust did not escape French transfer tax; it was pulled inside it as a taxable indirect gift, with the disclosure duties of Article 784 attached. Second, for tax timing, the commercial chamber ruled in 2020 that where assets sit in a trust, the taxable event is not the settlor’s death but the distribution: “En application de ce texte, le fait générateur des droits de mutation à titre gratuit est constitué par le transfert de propriété, qui, s’agissant de biens placés dans un trust, s’opère par l’effet de la distribution de l’actif du trust au bénéficiaire final, au jour de sa clôture, laquelle peut être postérieure au décès du constituant.” That 2020 case itself involved an American resident who had settled a revocable trust in 1964 and died in the United States, with French taxation following years later at the trust’s closing. The lesson for American families is symmetrical and uncomfortable: the trust neither avoids French tax nor accelerates it onto a convenient date. It defers the French charge to the distribution, which means the heirs must keep the trust records, the closing accounts, and the valuation evidence for years after the funeral, or face reassessment without proof.

The second trap is French life insurance, the assurance-vie, which many American residents of France buy from their French bank without realizing it is a succession instrument under French law and a foreign trust-like contract in American eyes. On the French side, payouts to a named beneficiary escape the normal reporting and reduction rules of the estate, but only within limits. Article L. 132-13 of the Insurance Code states: “Le capital ou la rente payables au décès du contractant à un bénéficiaire déterminé ne sont soumis ni aux règles du rapport à succession, ni à celles de la réduction pour atteinte à la réserve des héritiers du contractant. Ces règles ne s’appliquent pas non plus aux sommes versées par le contractant à titre de primes, à moins que celles-ci n’aient été manifestement exagérées eu égard à ses facultés.” A recent judgment of the Toulon court, December 11, 2025, RG 23/07530, applied exactly this test, recalling that primes manifestement exagérées (manifestly excessive premiums) are assessed at the time of payment, considering the subscriber’s age, wealth, family situation, and the usefulness of the contract. An American who pours most of his liquid wealth into an assurance-vie at eighty, disinheriting the children in substance while naming a new spouse as beneficiary, invites exactly this challenge: the premiums fall back into the estate, the forced shares revive, and the treaty credit cannot help because the dispute is about who inherits, not about double taxation. Fund the contract early, in proportion to your means, document its retirement-savings purpose, and the protection holds.

The third trap is the lifetime gift made from America. Families often give the French house, or the money to buy it, years before death, assuming a gift avoids the estate treaty altogether. It does not: the Convention covers gifts by French domiciliaries and gifts by persons subject to United States tax through domicile or citizenship, and the Article 12 allowance parity applies to gifts exactly as to estates (Articles 1 and 12 of the treaty). A gift of a French house by an American parent to an American child is therefore taxable in France under Article 5, creditable in America under Article 12, and reduced by the same 100,000-euro allowance as an inheritance. The only structural difference is timing: gift tax is assessed and credited at the date of the gift, which can be advantageous when French property values are rising, since the later appreciation accrues to the child outside the parent’s estate. Run both scenarios with the notaire before choosing.

Finally, two treaty safety valves deserve a last look because they decide edge cases. If property ends up taxable in only one State under the treaty but that State, for any reason other than an exemption, allowance, exclusion, credit, or deduction, does not actually collect the tax, the other State may step in: property taxable in only one State under the treaty but left uncollected there for reasons other than an exemption, allowance, exclusion, credit, or deduction may be taxed by the other State (Article 12, paragraph 6 of the treaty) No asset should be assumed untaxed anywhere simply because the treaty assigns it to a State that fails to assess. And charitable gifts cross the ocean cleanly: a bequest to a qualifying nonprofit in either country is exempt or fully deductible in the other, provided the recipient holds tax-exempt status at home and operates exclusively for religious, charitable, scientific, literary, educational, or cultural purposes with substantial public support. American families with French philanthropic intentions should verify the recipient’s status before death, not after, because the exemption is conditioned on it.

Conclusion

A French house in an American family’s estate is taxed in France in nearly every configuration: worldwide taxation if the deceased was a French tax resident, situs taxation of the house itself if he was not, with companies, furniture, debts, and allowances each governed by a precise article. The United States adds its own claim whenever the deceased was an American citizen, and the 1978 treaty does not remove that claim; it converts it into a credit. The families who emerge with a single bill are the ones who fix domicile early with evidence, pay in the order that preserves the credit, claim the same allowances a French family would receive, file the French return within six or twelve months, and keep the credit claim alive through the treaty’s one-year-after-final-assessment window. Trusts, life insurance, and lifetime gifts each obey their own French characterization on top of the treaty, and each has generated Cour de cassation litigation that American planners ignore at their peril. Start from the treaty text, run the numbers before the notaire closes the file, and never assume that an American-law solution works in France without a French-law check.

📄 Official circular