On the morning of 29 September 2026, two 48-year-olds walked into Westminster Magistrates’ Court for a hearing scheduled to last five days and capable of ending with a one-way flight to California. Sukhi Ghuman, of Syerston Hall near Newark, and his former wife Kiranjit Ghuman are wanted by the United States, where an arrest warrant issued by the District Court of the Southern District of California in San Diego in October 2023 accuses them of running oncology clinics on cheap, unapproved chemotherapy drugs while billing the American taxpayer as if every vial had been approved. According to the BBC, which reported the opening of the hearing, the prosecution speaks of more than $9.6 million, about £7.2 million, of fraudulent billing sent to the federal Medicare programme, with more than $2.9 million, about £2.2 million, actually paid out to clinics the couple controlled. Mr Ghuman denies everything. He told the BBC he was trying to help patients who could not afford cancer treatment, and he disputes that he made any money from the scheme.
This article explains what the London court must decide before anyone boards a plane: the forum bar that asks why California rather than England, the evidence test, the human-rights lock and the minister’s final signature. It then holds the very same file up to French law, exactly as a Paris chambre de l’instruction would examine it, from dual criminality to release, re-arrest and the government decree. Two rulings of the French Cour de cassation handed down this summer, on 29 July and 9 September 2026, set the tempo for the French half of the comparison: interim freedom settles nothing, and health arguments pass only through a strict judicial dialogue with the requesting state. Anyone facing a transatlantic file, in London or in Paris, will finish this piece knowing which doors are genuinely open and which ones merely look that way.
I. Can London send two Newark residents to California for Medicare fraud?
The Ghumans are not accused of a street crime committed in Nottinghamshire. Everything the prosecution alleges happened between September 2019 and April 2023, while the couple were living in the United States, inside oncology clinics they controlled in California and Arizona. The American case, presented in London by Peter Caldwell KC on behalf of the United States government, has two limbs. First, the clinics allegedly obtained cheap, unapproved chemotherapy and other drugs from overseas, administered them to cancer patients, and then billed Medicare and private insurers as though more costly drugs approved by the United States Food and Drug Administration had been used, keeping the difference. American investigators say some of the medicine was out of date, and that searches of both clinics found traces of non-approved drugs thrown away alongside unused items in fridges. Secondly, the extradition request describes a separate scheme in which one of the clinics allegedly bought approved drugs from American wholesalers and resold them without a proper licence. A parallel drug-smuggling allegation carries a maximum sentence of twenty years in custody. That geography, conduct in America, loss in America, witnesses in America, shapes every bar the defence can raise, starting with the one that sounds the most promising and usually disappoints: forum.
A. Forum first: why “prosecute them in England instead” is the hardest door to open
Under the Extradition Act 2003, the United States is a category 2 territory, which means the Westminster judge works through a fixed list of statutory bars. The forum bar provides that, in the words of the statute, the extradition of a person (“D”) to a category 2 territory is barred by reason of forum if the extradition would not be in the interests of justice. That sentence helps the defence only if two cumulative findings follow: the judge, in the statutory language, decides that a substantial measure of D’s relevant activity was performed in the United Kingdom, and then decides, having regard only to the specified interests-of-justice factors, that surrender should not happen. The specified matters are a closed list, and the first of them is usually decisive: the place where most of the loss or harm resulting from the extradition offence occurred or was intended to occur. The list continues with the interests of victims, any belief of a prosecutor about the most appropriate jurisdiction, whether the evidence could be made available in Britain, delay, the practicality of a single trial where witnesses and co-defendants are located, and the requested person’s connections with the United Kingdom.
Apply that grid to the Ghuman file and the difficulty appears at once. The alleged relevant activity, sourcing unapproved drugs abroad, administering them in Californian and Arizonan clinics, submitting claims to Medicare, sits almost entirely on American soil. The loss, $9.6 million of claims and $2.9 million paid, hit an American federal programme. The victims in the legal sense, the public purse and the patients allegedly given unapproved or expired medicine, are American. The witnesses, clinic staff, wholesalers, Medicare administrators, federal agents who searched the fridges, are American. Against that, the defence can table genuine counterweights: the couple now live at Syerston Hall near Newark, their daily life, family and character evidence are in England, and more than two years passed between the San Diego warrant of October 2023 and this hearing. Connections with the United Kingdom and delay are real statutory factors. But the forum test is not a balancing of sympathies; the judge must first find a substantial measure of British activity, and on the facts as reported there is very little of it. Ordering drugs from overseas for use in American clinics does not become British conduct because the defendants now live in Nottinghamshire. Unless the five-day hearing reveals a far larger English chapter than the prosecution has described, for example procurement decisions, billing servers or management acts performed from England, forum is the bar the defence will raise loudly and lose quietly, exactly as Parliament designed it: an exception for cases where Britain is the natural courtroom, not a general right to be tried at home.
There is a second, quieter forum question inside the same hearing. Even where extradition is ordered, the defence will press for assurances about what happens after landing: that the couple will face only the offences named in the request, the specialty rule, and that sentencing exposure will be presented honestly to the court. The reported twenty-year maximum on the smuggling count is doing political and forensic work here. It frames proportionality, it colours Article 8, and it tells the judge what kind of punishment architecture awaits. Readers who want a sense of how American sentencing exposure looks from a French point of view can compare with the analysis of another transatlantic file, where a fugitive faced a theoretical century and a half behind bars: What France Would Do With an Extradition File Like This. The lesson carries over: headline maximums are not the predicted sentence, but they set the stakes of every negotiation over assurances, bail and appeal.
B. Evidence, human rights and the minister: the three locks after forum
If forum fails, the hearing moves to the evidence test, and here the length of the listing matters. A five-day extradition hearing is not a rubber stamp; it signals contested factual and expert material. For cases where the statute requires it, the judge, in the words of the Act, must decide whether there is evidence which would be sufficient to make a case requiring an answer by the person if the proceedings were the summary trial of an information against him. If the answer is negative, the judge must order the person’s discharge; if affirmative, he must proceed under section 87. This is a case to answer, not proof beyond reasonable doubt, and paper-heavy fraud files usually clear it. Billing records showing $9.6 million of claims built on allegedly unapproved drugs, payment records showing $2.9 million received, wholesaler invoices for the resale limb, and the physical fruits of the clinic searches, discarded traces and unused vials in fridges, together tell a coherent story. The defence answers, denial of profit, patients genuinely treated, cheaper drugs as access to care for the uninsured, go to guilt and mitigation, not to whether there is a case to answer. The realistic defence objective at this stage is narrower: knock out individual counts, especially the resale and smuggling limbs if the documents are thinner there, and force the prosecution to elect precise offences that will then bind specialty after surrender. Every count removed in Westminster is a count that cannot be revived in San Diego without fresh consent.
The human-rights stage is where this couple’s file gets personal. The judge must decide whether surrender would be, in the statutory phrase, compatible with the Convention rights within the meaning of the Human Rights Act 1998. If not, he must order the person’s discharge; if compatible, he must send the case to the Secretary of State for his decision whether the person is to be extradited. Article 8, respect for private and family life, will carry the weight: a former married couple with an established home at Syerston Hall, community roots in Nottinghamshire, surrender at 48 to face trial an ocean away, and a potential twenty-year sentence on one count alone, which stretches separation into a life chapter. Delay helps here too. The San Diego warrant dates from October 2023, yet the contested hearing opens in late September 2026. Delay attributable to the couple counts against them; delay in the machinery counts for them, and the court will want to know who caused what. Proportionality is argued in the round: the gravity of allegedly monetising cancer care against the shattering effect of extradition on settled adults who, the defence says, believed they were widening access to treatment. Article 3 arguments about American detention conditions are harder and require concrete, individuated evidence plus precise assurances, not general prison criticism; British judges send people to the United States every month, so the defence needs something specific to these two defendants, age, health, or a particular facility, and it needs it in writing from the requesting authorities. Bail during and after the hearing is litigated on the same axis: strong community ties and sureties against the classic transatlantic flight risk, with electronic monitoring and daily reporting as the middle ground. Even if the judge sends the case upward, the Secretary of State stage and the appeal to the High Court add months, sometimes more than a year, of continued fight, and each stage re-examines proportionality on an updated record.
II. If the same file landed in Paris: the French extradition checklist
Now move the file across the Channel. Suppose the San Diego warrant had surfaced two British residents living in Paris, and Washington had asked France rather than Britain to surrender them. The architecture changes completely: no Westminster judge running statutory bars, but a French three-act procedure, prosecutor, chambre de l’instruction giving a reasoned opinion, government decree, with the Cour de cassation watching the formal regularity of every step. The comparison is not academic. It shows international readers what a Paris lawyer attacks first, and it exposes, by contrast, the strategic choices the Ghumans’ team is making in London. France starts from a blunt rule that shapes everything: Le gouvernement français peut remettre, sur leur demande, aux gouvernements étrangers, toute personne n’ayant pas la nationalité française qui, étant l’objet d’une poursuite intentée au nom de l’Etat requérant ou d’une condamnation prononcée par ses tribunaux, est trouvée sur le territoire de la République. Only non-nationals may be surrendered, and the offence must connect with the requesting state in one of the listed ways, including commission on its territory, which the California and Arizona facts satisfy effortlessly. Had the couple been French, the story would end on page one with a refusal, and France would offer to prosecute at home instead. A recent illustration of how nationality can dominate a French extradition file is the case of a former Canadian law dean arrested in France, where citizenship arguments took centre stage: former law dean arrested in France and facing extradition for fraud. The Ghumans, as British residents, would enjoy no such shield in Paris.
A. Would France surrender two British residents to the United States for foreign chemotherapy fraud?
The second French filter is dual criminality with teeth, and it has a quantitative threshold. Extraditable conduct means, first, offences punishable under the requesting state’s law as felonies, and for lesser offences a maximum of at least two years, or for convicts a sentence of at least two months, and second, in every case, conduct punishable under French law as a crime or délit: En aucun cas l’extradition n’est accordée par le gouvernement français si le fait n’est pas puni par la loi française d’une peine criminelle ou correctionnelle. The Medicare-billing limb maps onto French fraud without strain. Article 313-1 of the Criminal Code defines the offence as L’escroquerie est le fait, soit par l’usage d’un faux nom ou d’une fausse qualité, soit par l’abus d’une qualité vraie, soit par l’emploi de manoeuvres frauduleuses, de tromper une personne physique ou morale et de la déterminer ainsi, à son préjudice ou au préjudice d’un tiers, à remettre des fonds, des valeurs ou un bien quelconque, à fournir un service ou à consentir un acte opérant obligation ou décharge. Billing a federal insurer for approved drugs while administering cheaper unapproved ones is, on the alleged facts, a textbook manoeuvre frauduleuse, and the same article attaches cinq ans d’emprisonnement et de 375 000 euros d’amende, comfortably above every threshold. The resale-without-licence and smuggling limbs would be tested against French customs and medicines offences, count by count, which is precisely why a Paris defence dissects multi-count American requests rather than fighting them as a bloc: each offence must survive on its own. Note the calendar too. The alleged conduct spans September 2019 to April 2023, the warrant is from October 2023, and French limitation rules apply alongside American ones, so prescription is checked twice and can quietly kill older counts.
The third filter is the catalogue of absolute bars, and the defence reads it like a checklist where one ticked box ends the case: L’extradition n’est pas accordée : 1° Lorsque la personne réclamée a la nationalité française, cette dernière étant appréciée à l’époque de l’infraction pour laquelle l’extradition est requise ; 2° Lorsque le crime ou le délit à un caractère politique ou lorsqu’il résulte des circonstances que l’extradition est demandée dans un but politique. Healthcare fraud for profit is not political, and nothing reported suggests a political motive behind the San Diego prosecution, so the second item stays empty. The list continues with offences committed on French soil, cases already finally judged in France, limitation, and two human-rights clauses that matter here: 6° Lorsque le fait à raison duquel l’extradition a été demandée est puni par la législation de l’Etat requérant d’une peine ou d’une mesure de sûreté contraire à l’ordre public français ; 7° Lorsque la personne réclamée serait jugée dans l’Etat requérant par un tribunal n’assurant pas les garanties fondamentales de procédure et de protection des droits de la défense. No death penalty is in play, American federal courts plainly supply fair-trial guarantees, and a twenty-year maximum for smuggling, however heavy, does not by itself offend French public policy the way an irreducible life term or inhuman treatment would. The file itself must also be formally complete: toute demande d’extradition est adressée au gouvernement français par voie diplomatique et accompagnée soit d’un jugement ou d’un arrêt de condamnation, même par défaut, soit d’un acte de procédure pénale décrétant formellement ou opérant de plein droit le renvoi de la personne poursuivie devant la juridiction répressive, soit d’un mandat d’arrêt ou de tout autre acte ayant la même force et décerné par l’autorité judiciaire, and Le gouvernement requérant doit produire en même temps la copie des textes de loi applicables au fait incriminé. A Paris lawyer therefore opens the American file hunting for exactly what the Westminster defence hunts: missing statutes, vague counts, imprecise dates, because formal defects are the cheapest victories in extradition law.
B. Released today, rearrested tomorrow: why interim freedom settles nothing
Suppose our Paris couple contest extradition, as the Ghumans are contesting in London. The French procedural machine starts fast. Toute personne appréhendée à la suite d’une demande d’extradition doit être conduite dans les quarante-huit heures devant le procureur général territorialement compétent. The prosecutor verifies identity, gives notice in a language the person understands, warns of the right to counsel with nullity as the sanction for failure, and records consent or opposition. If liberty is not granted, le premier président de la cour d’appel ou le magistrat du siège désigné par lui ordonne l’incarcération et le placement sous écrou extraditionnel de la personne réclamée à la maison d’arrêt du siège de la cour d’appel, unless monitored release sufficiently guarantees appearance. The chambre de l’instruction then gives its reasoned opinion, normally within a month of appearance, and the opinion turns negative only on precise grounds: Cet avis est défavorable si la cour estime que les conditions légales ne sont pas remplies ou qu’il y a une erreur évidente. Custody, however, is not a one-shot decision. La mise en liberté peut être demandée à tout moment à la chambre de l’instruction selon les formes prévues aux articles 148-6 et 148-7. And where urgency preceded the formal request, En cas d’urgence et sur la demande directe des autorités compétentes de l’Etat requérant, le procureur général territorialement compétent peut ordonner l’arrestation provisoire d’une personne réclamée aux fins d’extradition par ledit Etat. Release applications are therefore the daily bread of French extradition practice, and a fresh ruling of the Cour de cassation, dated 9 September 2026, tells both sides exactly what a release is worth.
The case, appeal number 25-88.255, reads like a training exercise for the Ghuman scenario. A Turkish national sought for the enforcement of a remaining sentence of six years, one month and fifteen days was provisionally arrested, brought before the prosecutor in Limoges and placed under extradition detention. The Turkish arrest warrant had not arrived, so on 4 December 2025 the chambre de l’instruction ordered his release. He was then rearrested in the Versailles jurisdiction after the formal Turkish request arrived, and the Versailles chamber declared itself incompetent, reasoning that Limoges, which had released without ruling on the merits, remained seized. The Cour de cassation quashed that reasoning entirely. It recalled first that la mise en liberté de la personne visée par la demande d’arrestation provisoire ne s’oppose pas à une nouvelle arrestation et à son extradition si la demande d’extradition parvient ultérieurement, and second that le procureur général compétent est celui du lieu d’arrestation de l’intéressé. The first court’s release, the Paris judges explained, had closed the provisional-arrest phase for want of documents in time, while the later communication of the international warrant and the formal request required the procedure to restart before the court of the new place of arrest. For a defence team, the moral is double-edged and practical. A release won on missing papers is a real victory, it restores liberty, lets the client rebuild guarantees of appearance, work, housing, family anchors, and buys weeks to dissect the incoming American file. But it decides nothing on the merits, it never bars rearrest once the requesting state completes its file, and it can even shift the case to a new court in a new city. London litigators know the twin of this lesson: bail pending appeal keeps the client home, but the underlying surrender order survives untouched.
The second summer ruling completes the picture on the argument the Ghumans are least likely, but most tempted, to raise: health. On 29 July 2026, in appeal 26-84.256, the criminal chamber reviewed a Paris refusal to surrender a woman to Germany under a European Arrest Warrant for alleged membership of a foreign terrorist organisation, where a medical report had found her condition incompatible with transfer and pre-trial detention. The Cour de cassation quashed the refusal, and its reasoning is now the compulsory method for every health-based objection in France. It restated the frame: l’exécution d’un mandat d’arrêt européen ne saurait être refusée pour des motifs autres que ceux que prévoient la décision-cadre et les textes pris pour son application. It then applied the Court of Justice’s E.D.L. ruling of 18 April 2023, case C-699/21: lorsque l’autorité judiciaire d’exécution appelée à décider de la remise d’une personne recherchée, gravement malade, en exécution d’un mandat d’arrêt européen, estime qu’il existe des motifs sérieux et avérés de croire que cette remise exposerait cette personne à un risque réel de réduction significative de son espérance de vie ou de détérioration rapide, significative et irrémédiable de son état de santé, elle doit, en application de l’article 23, § 4, de la décision-cadre précitée, surseoir à ladite remise et solliciter de l’autorité judiciaire d’émission la fourniture de toute information relative aux conditions dans lesquelles il est envisagé de poursuivre ou de détenir ladite personne ainsi qu’aux possibilités d’adapter ces conditions à son état de santé afin de prévenir la réalisation d’un tel risque. Only if the risk cannot be removed within a reasonable time must surrender be refused; otherwise a new surrender date is agreed. The Paris chamber had failed that test: it had called the German assurances too general, which they may well have been, but it had quashed surrender sans établir que la remise de la personne recherchée exposerait cette dernière à un risque réel de réduction significative de son espérance de vie ou de détérioration rapide, significative et irrémédiable de son état de santé ne pouvant pas être écarté dans un délai raisonnable, la chambre de l’instruction n’a pas justifié sa décision. There is a quiet irony in deploying this ruling beside a cancer-drug file. Defendants accused of monetising oncology care who invoke their own health to resist surrender walk into the strictest filter in French surrender law: individuated medical proof, formal dialogue with the requesting state, concrete adaptation measures, reasonable time, and no shortcut. General assurances fail, but so do general refusals. Transposed to Westminster, the same discipline applies to Article 3 detention-conditions arguments: British judges demand specific evidence about specific defendants and specific facilities, answered by specific written guarantees, and a five-day hearing is exactly where that paper battle is fought.
Conclusion
The Ghumans’ five days in Westminster will probably turn on two questions, not five. First, can the defence move the case from California to England through the forum bar, despite conduct, loss, victims and witnesses sitting overwhelmingly in the United States. On the facts reported so far, that door looks nearly shut, unless the hearing exposes a genuine English centre of gravity nobody has described yet. Secondly, can the couple convert a likely finding of extraditability into protection at the human-rights and ministerial stages, through rooted family life in Nottinghamshire, the delay since the October 2023 warrant, and tightly drawn assurances on counts, specialty and sentence. The evidence test in between favours the prosecution: $9.6 million of claims, $2.9 million paid, wholesaler paper and searched fridges make a case to answer even if denial of profit remains a full defence at a future American trial. In Paris, the same file would travel a parallel road with the same probable destination. Dual criminality through fraud is satisfied, no absolute bar fits, the file looks formally complete, and the chambre de l’instruction would more likely than not give a favourable opinion before the decree stage, where administrative challenge remains the last French lock. The two summer rulings from the Cour de cassation strip away the illusions on both sides of the Channel: interim release, whether in London on bail or in Paris under judicial supervision, preserves liberty without denting the surrender order, and health or detention objections succeed only through rigorous, documented, bilateral dialogue, never through atmosphere. For anyone holding a transatlantic file today, the practical programme writes itself. Map every count against domestic law before the hearing opens, translate community ties and medical realities into exhibits rather than speeches, demand assurances that name names, counts, facilities and time limits, and treat each procedural victory as what the 9 September 2026 ruling says it is: a stage, not a verdict.