KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Can an American Living in America Buy French SCPI Units? Price, PFIC Trap, French Tax and How to Sell

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Can an American Living in America Buy French SCPI Units? Price, PFIC Trap, French Tax and How to Sell

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

An American who searches “invest in French real estate” will quickly meet four letters that look like a shortcut: SCPI. A société civile de placement immobilier (a real-estate investment company, usually translated as a French property fund) lets thousands of savers pool their money, buy office buildings, shops, clinics, and apartment blocks, and share the rents. The brochures promise yields around four to six percent, professional management, and tickets as low as a few thousand euros. For an American who cannot fly over every time a boiler breaks, that sounds like owning a slice of France from home.

The reality is more complicated, and Americans face three layers of complication that French brochures never mention. First, many French funds quietly refuse money from US persons (American citizens and residents, as defined by American tax law) because the American anti-tax-evasion rules known as FATCA impose paperwork and costs on any foreign financial institution that accepts them. Second, the American tax code treats almost every SCPI as a passive foreign investment company, universally known by its initials PFIC, which triggers one of the most punitive tax regimes in American law, with its own return, Form 8621, and interest charges that can swallow the yield. Third, France taxes the rents and the resale gain at source, so every dollar of French rental income must be reported twice, once in each country, with the treaty and the foreign tax credit doing the work of preventing double tax. This article explains, in plain English and with the exact French statutes and court decisions, what an SCPI is, how an American can actually buy units from the United States, what the real price looks like line by line, how both countries tax the income and the exit, and what happens to the units when the holder dies.

I. Can an American Living in the United States Buy French SCPI Units and What Does the Price Really Cover

A. What an SCPI Is, Who Runs It, and Why Some Funds Turn American Money Away

An SCPI is not a stock, not a bond, and not a mutual fund in the American sense. It is a société civile (a non-commercial company) whose exclusive purpose is to buy and manage buildings on behalf of its members. Each saver buys parts (units), becomes an associé (a member, the equivalent of a shareholder), and receives a share of the rents the buildings produce, after the manager takes its fees. The manager is a société de gestion (a licensed management company) supervised by the Autorité des marchés financiers (the French financial-markets regulator, usually called the AMF), and any offer of units to the public requires that company’s license plus a bank guarantee covering the minimum capital. Article L214-86 of the Monetary and Financial Code sets that framework: units may be offered to the public only once the founding members hold a minimum capital and the fund shows an AMF-approved bank guarantee for the reimbursement mechanism described at article L214-116.

Two families of SCPI exist, and Americans should know which brochure they are reading. SCPI de rendement (income SCPIs) buy offices, shops, warehouses, clinics, and sometimes residential buildings, and distribute most of the rents. SCPI fiscales (tax-driven SCPIs) buy housing eligible for French income-tax reductions, such as Pinel-type or historic-building schemes, and the tax benefit only helps someone who actually pays French income tax. For an American living in the United States who pays little or no French income tax, the tax-driven family is usually pointless, while the income family is the one that creates the American tax problem described in Part II.

Your liability as a member is capped, but not in the way stockholders of a Delaware corporation understand limited liability. The default rule of French company law for this kind of company is severe: members answer indefinitely for the company’s debts in proportion to their holdings. Article 1857 of the Civil Code states that rule in one sentence: “A l’égard des tiers, les associés répondent indéfiniment des dettes sociales à proportion de leur part dans le capital social à la date de l’exigibilité ou au jour de la cessation des paiements.” For SCPIs, however, a special statute softens the blow. Article L214-89 of the Monetary and Financial Code provides: “La responsabilité des associés ne peut être mise en cause que si la société civile ou la société d’épargne forestière a été préalablement et vainement poursuivie en justice.” In plain English, creditors must first sue the SCPI itself and fail before turning against you, and even then each member’s exposure is capped at a multiple of their holding: “La responsabilité de chaque associé à l’égard des tiers est engagée en fonction de sa part dans le capital et dans la limite de deux fois le montant de cette part.” Most SCPI bylaws go further and cap liability at the amount of the holding itself, which the same article expressly allows: “Les statuts de la société civile ou société d’épargne forestière peuvent prévoir que la responsabilité de chaque associé est limitée au montant de sa part dans le capital de la société.” Read the bylaws before signing: the cap you get is the cap written in the statuts (the bylaws).

Now the American-specific obstacle. Nothing in French law forbids an American from buying SCPI units. But many management companies refuse subscriptions from US persons because accepting them means registering FATCA compliance procedures, identifying American account holders, and reporting them to the US Internal Revenue Service every year. The refusal is a business decision, not a statute, so practices differ from fund to fund. The practical consequence is that the American buyer must ask the question before wiring a cent: does this fund accept US persons, and will it provide the annual statements an American CPA needs for the PFIC return? Get the answer in writing. Funds that accept Americans exist, generally among the large income SCPIs, but their subscription packs include FATCA self-certification forms, a W-9 request, and sometimes a minimum ticket higher than the brochure headline. A fund that discovers your American status after the sale can freeze distributions or force a buyback under its compliance clauses, so disclosure at subscription is protection, not option.

Voting rights inside the fund follow French company law, and one rule matters for American families who hold units jointly or pass them to children. Article 1844 of the Civil Code provides that co-owners of an undivided unit are represented by a single proxy: “Les copropriétaires d’une part sociale indivise sont représentés par un mandataire unique, choisi parmi les indivisaires ou en dehors d’eux.” If siblings inherit SCPI units together and cannot agree on that representative, the court appoints one at the request of the most diligent heir. The same article splits voting when a unit is split between a nu-propriétaire (the bare owner, who will take full ownership when the usufruct ends) and an usufruitier (the usufruct holder, who collects the income for life or for a fixed term): voting belongs to the bare owner except on profit-allocation decisions, which belong to the income holder. American couples who split units between spouse and children for estate planning must understand this division before the first general meeting, because the person who cashes the check is not always the person who votes the resolution.

B. How Americans Subscribe From the United States and What Fifty Thousand Euros Really Buys

Buying from America follows the same paperwork as buying from Paris, with distance added. The standard path is a cash subscription to a variable-capital SCPI: you sign a bulletin de souscription (a subscription form), attach identity documents, proof of address, proof of the origin of the funds, the FATCA self-certification and W-9, and wire the money to the fund. The management company checks the file, including anti-money-laundering screening, and registers you as a member. No French bank account is strictly required for the subscription itself, though distributions are far easier to receive on a euro account, and some funds insist on a SEPA-capable account for monthly wires. Remote signing is routine: electronic signature of the subscription pack plus scanned documents, with the original wire carrying the anti-money-laundering trail. Keep every document, because both the French notaire at succession and the American CPA at tax time will ask for the subscription confirmations, the annual statements, and the proof of the euro-dollar rate on each payment date.

The price has four layers, and the brochure headline only shows the first. Take a clearly labeled illustration, not a promise: a subscription of 50,000 euros in a large income SCPI at a headline price of 200 euros per unit buys 250 units. Out of those 50,000 euros, roughly 4,000 to 6,000 euros, or eight to twelve percent, is the commission de souscription (the subscription fee) taken by the manager and its distributors. That fee is not recoverable on resale: the valeur de retrait (the withdrawal value you receive if you exit) equals the subscription price minus the fee. So on day one, the realizable value of a 50,000-euro ticket is already around 44,000 to 46,000 euros. The second layer is the délai de jouissance (the waiting period before new units earn distributions), typically three to six months from subscription. During that window your money is invested but pays nothing, which cuts the first-year yield roughly in half on a calendar-year basis. The third layer is the manager’s annual cut: management fees of around eight to twelve percent of the rents collected, plus acquisition and disposal fees on each building the fund buys or sells, all deducted before your distribution. The fourth layer is foreign-exchange risk: you wire dollars, the fund accounts in euros, and distributions arrive in euros that your American bank converts at its own rate, often one to two percent off the market rate, on every payment.

Run the illustration to its end so the yield figure means something. Suppose the fund advertises a five percent gross distribution rate. On 250 units at 200 euros, the full-year gross would be 2,500 euros. Subtract the waiting period, roughly half the first year, and year one pays about 1,250 euros. Subtract French tax at source and American tax as described in Part II, subtract currency-conversion spreads, and the first-year cash in hand in Ohio is far closer to 800 or 900 euros on 50,000 euros wired, before any PFIC compliance fees charged by your CPA, which commonly run from several hundred to a few thousand dollars per year for Form 8621 preparation. From year two onward, with a full year of distributions, the same illustration pays roughly 2,500 euros gross, reduced by both countries’ taxes and conversion costs. None of this makes the SCPI a scam; French savers accept the same fee structure. It means the American buyer must compare the net-of-everything figure, not the brochure rate, against a plain American dividend portfolio that carries none of this machinery.

Financing the purchase with a French mortgage is possible in theory and difficult in practice from America. French banks lend to nonresidents, but they demand French-taxable income or large deposits, full documentation translated and apostilled, and life insurance from an approved insurer, and very few banks finance SCPI units on credit because the units themselves are weak collateral. Most American subscriptions are therefore cash deals, which simplifies the file and removes the interest deduction, since interest on a loan taken to buy SCPI units would in principle be deductible from the rental income in France only under strict conditions and with full documentation. The buyer who borrows in the United States against American assets to fund the subscription should know that the French tax administration will not treat the American loan as acquisition debt of the French income without a clear paper trail linking the funds to the units, and the American side will apply its own interest-tracing rules. Cash remains the clean structure for a first ticket.

II. How France and the United States Each Tax the SCPI Income and How Americans Sell or Pass On the Units

A. Taxed in France First, Reported in America Second: Rental Income, the Treaty, and the PFIC Trap

France taxes SCPI distributions because the buildings stand in France. The connecting rule is written in the General Tax Code: Article 164 B lists as French-source income “Les revenus d’immeubles sis en France ou de droits relatifs à ces immeubles” (income from buildings located in France or from rights relating to those buildings). SCPI income is rental income that flows through a transparent vehicle: Article 239 septies of the General Tax Code provides that qualifying SCPIs fall outside corporate income tax and that “chacun de leurs membres est personnellement passible, pour la part des bénéfices sociaux correspondant à ses droits dans la société, soit de l’impôt sur le revenu, soit de l’impôt sur les sociétés” (each member is personally liable, for the share of profits matching their rights, for income tax or corporate tax). In practice the management company sends each member an annual statement, the imprimé fiscal unique (the single annual tax statement), showing the taxable rental share, any financial income, and any capital-gain distributions, and the American holder reports that share on the French nonresident return even if the cash was paid into an American bank account. Readers who already own a house in France will recognize the machinery: the same logic that governs annual French property taxes and the treaty credit applies here, with France taxing first as the country where the bricks stand.

The France-United States income tax treaty of 1994, as amended, confirms the result. Article 6 of the treaty reserves to the country where real property is located the right to tax income from that property, and Article 13 reserves gains from the alienation of real property, and of shares deriving most of their value from real property, to that same country. SCPI distributions backed by French buildings therefore fall squarely on the French side for primary taxation, and the United States then taxes its citizen or resident on worldwide income while granting a foreign tax credit for the French tax paid, within the limits and baskets of the American foreign-tax-credit rules. The treaty does not exempt the income anywhere; it allocates the first bite to France and obliges America to relieve the second bite through the credit. Keep the French tax notices forever: without the French assessment, the American credit has no proof, and without proof the same euro of rent is taxed twice in fact even though the treaty says it should not be.

The American side is where the SCPI turns from an investment into a compliance project. Under sections 1291 through 1298 of the Internal Revenue Code, a foreign corporation that earns seventy-five percent or more of its income passively, or holds fifty percent or more of its assets for passive production, is a passive foreign investment company. An SCPI that collects rents through buildings held by a corporate vehicle meets the income test in almost every case, and the Internal Revenue Service says so in the instructions to the very form at issue: a United States person that receives certain distributions from a PFIC or recognizes gain on PFIC shares files Form 8621, Information Return by a Shareholder of a Passive Foreign Investment Company. The default American regime for a PFIC with no special election, the section 1291 excess-distribution regime, is deliberately harsh. Distributions above one hundred twenty-five percent of the prior three-year average, and the entire gain on sale, are spread retroactively over the holding period, taxed at the highest ordinary rate in effect for each past year, with a nondeductible interest charge running from each past year to the current one. The economic effect is that a buy-and-hold American who receives steady SCPI distributions and then sells at a gain can owe American tax plus interest that exceeds the cash actually earned in the early years.

Two escape elections exist on paper and rarely work for SCPI holders. The qualified electing fund election would let the holder pay tax currently on their share of the fund’s earnings, but it requires the foreign fund to sign an agreement and supply an annual information statement computed under American tax principles, which French SCPIs do not provide. The mark-to-market election requires the shares to be regularly traded on a qualifying exchange, which SCPI units are not, since they change hands on the manager’s private order book or by withdrawal, not on the New York Stock Exchange. Most American SCPI holders therefore live under the default excess-distribution regime for the whole holding period, filing Form 8621 every year, paying their CPA for the privilege, and keeping a running spreadsheet of every distribution, every euro-dollar rate, and every prior-year average. The additional American disclosure forms follow from the same facts: foreign financial accounts holding the distributions may trigger the FBAR report, and the units themselves may count as specified foreign financial assets reportable on Form 8938 above the applicable thresholds, with France’s own foreign-account declaration, the formulaire 3916 (the French foreign-account disclosure form), applying in mirror image if the holder is also French-resident. None of these forms is optional, and penalties for missing them are fixed per form, not proportional to the tax.

Wealth tax adds a final French layer for large holders. SCPI units are real-estate assets for the impôt sur la fortune immobilière (the French real-estate wealth tax, universally called the IFI): units enter the taxable base at their withdrawal value on January 1 each year once the household’s net real-estate wealth exceeds the statutory threshold, currently 1.3 million euros, with the management company publishing the taxable value per unit annually. An American nonresident counts only French-situs real-estate wealth, which includes the SCPI units backed by French buildings, while an American resident in France counts worldwide real-estate wealth subject to treaty limits. Below the threshold there is nothing to file; above it, the return, the valuation, and the treaty credit in the United States all require professional coordination, because the IFI is generally not creditable against American income tax.

B. Getting Out Alive: Withdrawal, Private Sale, and What Happens When the Holder Dies

SCPI units are liquid the way a private club is liquid: there is a door, but the bouncer decides when it opens. In a variable-capital SCPI, the standard exit is the retrait (withdrawal): the member asks the manager to redeem the units at the published withdrawal value, and the request is honored only if new subscriptions offset it. When redemptions pile up with no new money, the manager suspends withdrawals, and the member waits, sometimes for quarters, sometimes for years, with distributions continuing but the capital locked. In a fixed-capital SCPI there is no withdrawal at all; sales happen by matching buy and sell orders on a register kept at the company’s seat. Article L214-93 of the Monetary and Financial Code describes that market: buy and sell orders are, on pain of nullity, entered on a register, the execution price comes from matching supply and demand, and each completed trade is recorded on the member register, which counts as the written transfer deed required by article 1865 of the Civil Code. The transfer becomes enforceable against the company and third parties from that entry. For transfers outside that organized market, the Civil Code requires writing: Article 1865 states that “La cession de parts sociales doit être constatée par écrit” (the transfer of company shares must be recorded in writing).

Private sales to a named buyer face one more filter that Americans discover late: the approval clause. Article L214-97 of the Monetary and Financial Code allows the bylaws to require the company’s approval for any transfer to a third party, “Sauf en cas de succession, de liquidation de communauté de biens entre époux, ou de cession soit à un conjoint, soit à un ascendant ou à un descendant” (except in cases of succession, liquidation of marital community between spouses, or transfer to a spouse, ascendant, or descendant). The request must state the buyer’s name, address, number of units, and price, and approval is deemed granted if the company does not answer within the statutory period. American sellers should therefore read the bylaws before marketing units to a friend in Florida: a sale signed without a required approval can be blocked or unwound, while a transfer to a spouse or child passes freely. Succession itself needs no approval, which leads directly to the death of the holder.

French courts have spelled out how exits and family splits work when members fight, and two decisions of the Third Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation deserve verbatim quotation because American families relive these exact disputes. On withdrawal versus private sale, the Court ruled on May 25, 2023, appeal number 22-17.246, in decision 22-17.246, concerning a property company where a member had started a formal withdrawal, accepted by the company, and then tried to sell his units privately to an outsider instead. The Court endorsed the appeal judges: “La cour d’appel a retenu que M. [C] [T] s’était engagé dans une procédure de retrait avec rachat de ses parts, acceptée par la SCI, dont l’échec n’avait pas été constaté et qu’il lui incombait de mener à son terme.” It drew the consequence “à bon droit”: “Elle en a déduit, à bon droit, que la procédure de cession desdites parts à un tiers, initiée par M. [C] [T] en méconnaissance de la procédure de retrait en cours acceptée par la SCI, devait être annulée.” The case concerned a family property company rather than a listed SCPI, but the reasoning travels: once a formal withdrawal accepted by the company is underway and its failure has not been established, a parallel private sale to a third party can be annulled. SCPI members who file for withdrawal and then quietly negotiate a private sale at a better price are playing the same dangerous game.

On families who split units between generations, the Court ruled on September 19, 2024, appeal numbers 22-18.687 and 22-18.733 joined, in decision 22-18.687, published in the Bulletin. A property company had sold all its buildings and the general meeting voted to distribute the proceeds as dividends while the units were split between bare owners and a lifetime income holder. The Court held: “Il en résulte que, dans le cas où l’assemblée générale décide une telle distribution, le dividende revient, sauf convention contraire entre le nu-propriétaire et l’usufruitier, au premier, le droit de jouissance du second s’exerçant alors sous la forme d’un quasi-usufruit sur la somme ainsi distribuée.” It added the sting: “Il s’en déduit que la décision, à laquelle a pris part l’usufruitier, de distribuer les dividendes prélevés sur le produit de la vente de la totalité des actifs immobiliers d’une société civile immobilière, sur lesquels il jouit d’un quasi-usufruit, ne peut être constitutive d’un abus d’usufruit.” In plain English, when the company sells the buildings and pays out the price, the capital goes to the bare owner and the income holder gets only a quasi-usufruit (a right to use the money and return the equivalent at the end, not to keep it), and voting that distribution cannot be attacked as an abuse. American parents who give SCPI units to children while keeping the income must understand this sentence before the fund sells a building: the big check at the end belongs to the children, and the surviving parent holds it as a debtor, not as an owner.

Tax on exit mirrors the entry logic in both countries. In France, the resale of SCPI units follows the real-estate capital-gains regime: Article 150 U of the General Tax Code makes gains on the paid transfer of buildings or rights relating to buildings subject to income tax under articles 150 V to 150 VH, which carry the holding-period allowances that reduce the taxable base year after year until full exemption after long ownership. The manager or the notaire-equivalent intermediary computes the gain from the documented purchase price plus acquisition costs against the sale price, applies the allowances, collects the tax and social levies for nonresidents where required, and issues the statement the American CPA needs. In America, the whole gain is a PFIC excess distribution in the year of sale, spread back over the holding period with tax at historic top rates plus interest, and the French tax paid becomes a foreign tax credit subject to the usual basket limits, which rarely erase the PFIC interest charge. The combined result is that a profitable SCPI exit is taxed in France under the real-estate schedule and taxed again in America under the PFIC schedule, with the credit softening but almost never eliminating the second bill.

Death does not simplify anything, but the procedure is at least mapped. Under European Succession Regulation 650/2012, the law governing the whole estate, SCPI units included, is by default the law of the holder’s last habitual residence, unless the holder chose in a will the law of their nationality, the choice American holders of French assets most often make to keep New York or California law in command. France will nonetheless require a French notaire to settle the French-situs portion: the notaire identifies the heirs, values the units at the death-day withdrawal value, files the French succession return, and releases the units to the heirs or to the buyer if the heirs sell. French succession tax applies to transfers of French-situs units under the France-United States estate tax treaty of 1978, with rates depending on kinship and allowances that differ sharply between direct children and unrelated beneficiaries, and the United States imposes its own estate tax on citizens’ worldwide assets with a credit for the French tax. Units held in indivision (joint undivided ownership) between siblings need the single representative of article 1844 quoted above before the manager will pay distributions, and any heir who wants out uses the withdrawal or approved-sale machinery described here. The file an American family should keep from day one, subscription forms, annual statements, proof of every euro-dollar rate, the bylaws, and the will with its choice of law, is the file that decides whether the succession takes six months or three years.

Conclusion

An American living in the United States can buy French SCPI units, and for the right buyer the product does what it promises: a diversified portfolio of French buildings, professional management, and regular euro distributions without ever boarding a plane to a closing. But the ticket price is only the first number in a long arithmetic. The subscription fee takes eight to twelve percent on day one, the waiting period halves the first year’s yield, the manager’s fees and the currency spread take their share every year, France taxes the rents at source, and the United States treats the whole vehicle as a PFIC with a default regime of retroactive tax plus interest that no brochure mentions. The exit is orderly but slow, through withdrawal or an approved private sale, and the death of the holder opens a Franco-American succession with a notaire, a choice-of-law will, and two tax returns.

The decision rule is therefore simple. Buy SCPI units from America only after confirming in writing that the fund accepts US persons and will supply PFIC-ready statements, only with cash whose full cost you have modeled net of fees, waiting period, both countries’ taxes, and CPA compliance fees, and only alongside an American tax adviser who has actually filed Form 8621 before. If those three conditions are met, the SCPI is a defensible way to hold France at a distance. If any one of them fails, the same dollars will work harder, and sleep better, in a plain American portfolio.

📄 Official circular