KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Non-EU Parcel Refused or Returned in France: Who Pays Return Costs and Can You Recover the EUR 2 Handling Fee?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Non-EU Parcel Refused or Returned in France: Who Pays Return Costs and Can You Recover the EUR 2 Handling Fee?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 29 September 2026, Irish shoppers learned that their Christmas orders were about to get more expensive: the national broadcaster RTE, the Irish Independent and The Irish Times all reported that Revenue, the Irish customs authority, had confirmed a new “union handling fee” of €2 per distinct item on any goods bought online from outside the European Union, applicable from 1 November 2026. The charge comes on top of the €3 customs duty per item that has applied since 1 July 2026, and delivery companies will collect it where it has not been paid at checkout. Because the measure is imposed at EU level, it reaches far beyond Ireland: a buyer having a non-EU parcel delivered in France faces exactly the same bill, collected by French customs (dédouanement, customs clearance) under the same Union rules. The question that follows is immediate and practical. A buyer who refuses the parcel at the door, or who sends it back within the withdrawal period, still wants three answers: who pays the return shipping, what exactly the non-EU seller must refund and how fast, and whether the €3 duty and the €2 fee can be recovered from anyone. This article answers those three questions under the French and European rules that apply to a parcel delivered in France: first the distance-selling relationship with the seller, then the customs bill, which obeys a different and much stricter logic.

I. Refusing the parcel or sending it back: what distance-selling law requires from the seller

A. Handling fee douane shock at the door: the 14-day withdrawal right and who pays to send the goods back

The starting point is that customs charges do not remove consumer rights. A buyer in France who orders goods online from a seller outside the EU concludes a distance contract, and European consumer law gives that buyer a free way out. Article 9(1) of Directive 2011/83/EU on consumer rights gives the buyer fourteen days to withdraw from a distance contract without giving reasons and without extra costs beyond return shipping. For sales contracts, Article 9(2) makes the period run from the day the buyer takes physical possession of the goods. French law says the same thing in the national transposition: article L221-18 du code de la consommation states that « Le consommateur dispose d’un délai de quatorze jours pour exercer son droit de rétractation d’un contrat conclu à distance » (‘The consumer has fourteen days to exercise the right of withdrawal (droit de rétractation) from a distance contract’). Refusing a parcel at delivery because the handling fee and the duty make the order too expensive is therefore, in substance, an exercise of that withdrawal right, provided the buyer completes the formal step described below.

That formal step is frequently missed, and it decides cases. Withdrawing is not the same as merely refusing the parcel: Article 11 of Directive 2011/83/EU requires the consumer to inform the trader of the decision to withdraw before the period expires, either with the model withdrawal form or with any other clear written statement of the decision to withdraw, while the burden of proving withdrawal stays with the buyer. A buyer who turns the courier away but never writes to the seller has no proof of withdrawal and leaves the seller free to argue that the sale stands. The notice should be sent in writing, on a durable medium such as email or the seller’s returns portal, before the fourteen days expire, and a copy must be kept with the parcel’s tracking number. Where the seller never informed the buyer of the withdrawal right at all, Article 10 extends the period dramatically, to twelve months after the end of the initial period, falling back to fourteen days only once the information is finally supplied. Non-EU sellers whose checkout pages say nothing about European withdrawal rights are precisely the sellers against whom this extension matters most. French law places the same disclosure duty on the seller before the order is even placed: l’article L221-5 du code de la consommation requires the trader to supply, in a legible and comprehensible manner, « Lorsque le droit de rétractation existe, les conditions, le délai et les modalités d’exercice de ce droit ainsi que le formulaire type de rétractation » (‘where the withdrawal right exists, the conditions, time limit and procedures for exercising that right, together with the model withdrawal form’). A checkout page with no withdrawal information therefore extends the buyer’s exit window instead of closing it.

Once withdrawal is validly exercised, the return journey is governed by Article 14 of the directive. Unless the trader offered to collect the goods himself, the buyer must send them back without undue delay and within fourteen days of notifying withdrawal. The same rule settles costs in the buyer’s favour: only the direct return postage falls on the buyer, and only where the trader agreed nothing else and properly informed the buyer. French law mirrors this exactly: l’article L221-23 du code de la consommation provides that « Le consommateur ne supporte que les coûts directs de renvoi des biens, sauf si le professionnel accepte de les prendre à sa charge ou s’il a omis d’informer le consommateur que ces coûts sont à sa charge » (‘The consumer bears only the direct cost of returning the goods, unless the trader agrees to bear them or failed to inform the consumer that these costs fall on the buyer’). Return postage from France to a non-EU country is therefore, by default, paid by the buyer, and for a heavy parcel it can exceed the value of the goods. The seller can only impose that cost if it warned the buyer upfront: the same article L221-5 du code de la consommation obliges the trader to disclose « le fait que le consommateur supporte les frais de renvoi du bien en cas de rétractation » (‘the fact that the consumer bears the cost of returning the goods in the event of withdrawal’). Silence on this point at checkout means the return travels at the seller’s expense. Two limits protect the buyer: a seller who never disclosed that returns are at the buyer’s expense cannot charge them, and a buyer is only liable for diminished value resulting from handling beyond what is necessary to inspect the goods. Certain goods are excluded from withdrawal altogether, and buyers should check before ordering: under Article 16 of the directive and l’article L221-28 du code de la consommation, sealed audio, video and software once unsealed, perishable goods, and goods made to the consumer’s specifications cannot be sent back on a mere change of mind.

B. What the non-EU seller must refund, how fast, and the delivery-cost trap

The seller’s refund duty is broad but not unlimited. Article 13(1) of Directive 2011/83/EU requires the trader to refund everything received, delivery costs included, without undue delay and within fourteen days of learning of the withdrawal. The refund must use the same payment method unless the buyer expressly agrees otherwise, and for sales contracts the trader may hold it back until the goods come back or the buyer proves posting, whichever comes first. French law repeats the fourteen-day deadline: l’article L221-24 du code de la consommation provides that « le professionnel rembourse le consommateur de la totalité des sommes versées, y compris les frais de livraison, sans retard injustifié et au plus tard dans les quatorze jours à compter de la date à laquelle il est informé de la décision du consommateur de se rétracter » (‘the trader reimburses the consumer for all sums paid, including delivery costs, without undue delay and no later than fourteen days from the date on which he is informed of the consumer’s decision to withdraw’). A buyer returning a parcel to a non-EU seller should therefore calendar two fourteen-day periods: fourteen days to send the goods back, and fourteen days for the money to come back, with proof of posting unlocking the second period even before the goods arrive. Computing those periods follows l’article L221-19 du code de la consommation: neither the day of the contract nor the day of receipt counts, and « Si ce délai expire un samedi, un dimanche ou un jour férié ou chômé, il est prorogé jusqu’au premier jour ouvrable suivant » (‘if the period expires on a Saturday, Sunday or public holiday, it is extended to the next working day’). A withdrawal posted on the fourteenth day, a Saturday, remains valid on Monday.

The delivery-cost trap sits in Article 13(2): a buyer who expressly chose express delivery over the cheapest standard option only gets the standard rate back. Express shipping chosen at checkout is refunded only up to the standard rate, and customs charges paid at the door fall into a gap the directive does not fill: they were paid to the carrier or the customs authority, not to the trader, so the trader’s duty to reimburse “all payments received from the consumer” does not automatically cover them. VAT follows the same practical divide. Where French or Irish VAT was paid through the Import One-Stop Shop at checkout, the Irish Revenue guidance states that IOSS VAT paid at checkout can come back as part of the overall refund from the retailer, subject to the seller’s terms, while Revenue’s May 2026 press release warns that VAT refunds on returns depend on each business and its VAT accounting, with many sellers refusing them. Before ordering, a buyer should therefore read the returns terms for three distinct lines: the price of the goods, which is always refundable on withdrawal; the delivery costs, refundable up to the standard rate; and VAT and customs charges, which depend on the seller and on customs law rather than on the withdrawal right. The detailed computation of the French bill, with the €3 duty and French VAT line by line, is set out in the companion analysis of what buyers having goods delivered in France pay from 1 November 2026, which also covers how to challenge a wrongly calculated charge.

II. The customs bill once the parcel goes back: what France keeps and the three exits that work

A. Change-of-mind returns do not recover the €3 duty or the €2 handling fee

Customs law starts where consumer law stops. Since 1 July 2026, the old relief that exempted consignments worth €150 or less has been deleted from European law: Article 1 of Council Regulation (EU) 2026/382 of 11 February 2026 deletes the old duty relief in Chapter V of Title II of Regulation (EC) No 1186/2009 and replaces it for two years: from 1 July 2026 until 1 July 2028, consignments worth no more than EUR 150 in total bear a flat EUR 3 duty per item, for Import One-Stop Shop sales and postal consignments. The French customs authority, the Direction générale des douanes et droits indirects (DGDDI), applies this in France line by line: its official guidance confirms that each declaration line sharing the same goods nomenclature bears the €3 duty, that distance sales from third countries worth €150 or less cleared in the DELTA IE or DELTA H7 declaration systems are caught regardless of the VAT scheme used, and above all that the duty is not refundable outside the cases of Article 116 of the Union Customs Code. France even removed its own overlapping charge to make way for the European one: the DGDDI confirms that the French small-parcels tax ended on 1 July 2026 with the entry into force of the €3 flat-rate duty.

The €2 handling fee follows the same non-refundable logic. The Council’s 3 September 2026 customs-reform conclusions provide for an EU-wide handling fee on small parcels applying from 1 November 2026, with the Commission setting the level before the Member States apply it, and the Irish Revenue has now confirmed a €2 charge per distinct item on goods bought from outside the EU, as RTE reported on 29 September 2026, adding that the fee is not refundable and that the selling company is responsible for paying it but will likely pass it on at checkout. The arithmetic reported by The Irish Times the same day translates directly to a parcel delivered in France: a €10 package with a pen, a notebook and a keyring, three different items, already bears €9 of duty since July and will bear €6 more of handling fee from November, €15 plus VAT in total; two identical pens count as one item, hence €3 plus €2; and above €150 the flat €3 gives way to the normal goods-specific duty rate, with the €2-per-item fee added on top. No duty and no fee are due where the goods are already in the EU or Northern Ireland when ordered, and some sellers collect both charges at checkout so that the price paid online is final. Two structural details complete the picture: from 1 November 2026 product identifiers become mandatory for traceability under the Commission’s June 2026 e-commerce guidance, and non-EU platforms will be treated as the importer itself, responsible for customs formalities and duty payment, with fines of up to 6% of annual import value for serious non-compliance, while the new EU customs authority opens in Lille, France, in 2027. A buyer who simply changes his mind and returns the parcel therefore loses the duties and the fee: Revenue’s returns guidance is explicit: a buyer who returns an item on a change of mind does not get the €3 duty back, the only exception being faulty goods, and Revenue never pays refunds directly to consumers in any circumstances.

B. Faulty goods, invalidated declarations and abandonment: deadlines, proof and the France procedure

The first working exit is the faulty-goods route, and it is the only return scenario Revenue itself preserves. Article 116(1) of the Union Customs Code (Regulation (EU) No 952/2013) lists four grounds for repaying or remitting import duty: overcharged amounts, defective goods or goods not complying with the contract terms, errors by the authorities, and equity. Article 118 develops the defective-goods ground for goods rejected by the importer because they were defective or non-compliant when released, a category that expressly covers goods damaged before release. Three cumulative conditions apply: the goods must not have been used beyond what was necessary to establish the defect, they must be taken out of the customs territory of the Union, and no repayment is granted where the defect was already reflected in the contract price or where the buyer resells the goods after discovering the defect. The deadline is short: defective-goods applications go within one year of notification of the customs debt, against three years for overcharged amounts, authority errors and equity cases. Revenue’s operational guidance mirrors this exactly for online buyers: where goods are defective or do not conform to the contract, first contact the platform or seller, then contact the courier or postal operator that handled the import formalities about a refund of duties and VAT, keeping in mind that the customs refund travels through the declarant, never directly from Revenue to the buyer.

The second and third exits concern parcels that never properly enter the market: invalidation of the declaration and abandonment to the State (abandon). Article 124(1) of the Union Customs Code extinguishes the customs debt itself, which is stronger than a refund, where a declaration for a duty-bearing procedure is invalidated, and likewise where dutiable goods are destroyed under customs supervision or abandoned to the State. Abandonment is not a unilateral gesture: Article 199 allows it only with the prior permission of customs, granted to the holder of the procedure or of the goods. In practice, a buyer in France who refuses a parcel at the door before it is released for free circulation should therefore do three things in order: notify the seller of withdrawal in writing to protect the consumer-law refund of the price; ask the delivering courier or postal operator, which usually acts as the customs declarant, what becomes of the parcel, whether it is returned to sender, re-exported or proposed for abandonment, and obtain that statement in writing; and only where the goods are defective, file the Article 118 repayment request through the declarant within the one-year period with the withdrawal notice, the tracking records and photographs of the defect. Overcharged duty, for example a parcel wrongly counted as three items instead of one, follows the three-year Article 117 route on proof of the error. For buyers in Paris and the Île-de-France, none of this requires travelling anywhere: the DGDDI applies the same DELTA-cleared rules at Roissy, Orly and the postal hubs as everywhere else in France, so the file is built at home from the checkout invoice showing IOSS VAT and any prepaid duty, the delivery notice stating the amounts demanded, the withdrawal email, and the courier’s return or abandonment confirmation. Where the seller collected the €3 and the €2 at checkout and the parcel comes back, the only person who can return that money is the seller, through the fourteen-day withdrawal refund of l’article L221-24 du code de la consommation. The broader computation rules and the challenge procedure for a wrongly assessed French bill are detailed in the companion guide to the November 2026 charges for goods delivered in France; the present article covers the distinct case of the parcel that goes back. Buyers should also keep the European calendar in mind: the €3 duty runs until 1 July 2028 pending the new central customs data hub, and the handling-fee regulation was still awaiting final parliamentary approval and Official Journal publication when the September announcements were made, so amounts and dates should be re-checked against the DGDDI and Revenue pages before any high-value Christmas order.

Conclusion

A non-EU parcel refused or returned in France splits into two disputes that must not be confused. Against the seller, European and French distance-selling law is generous: fourteen days to withdraw without reasons, fourteen days for the trader to refund the price and standard delivery costs, and up to twelve months where the seller concealed the withdrawal right, with the buyer paying only the direct cost of sending the goods back. Against customs, the logic reverses: the €3 duty per item and the €2 handling fee are not refunded on a change-of-mind return, in France as in Ireland, and only three narrow exits work, defective goods re-exported within one year, overcharged duty reclaimed within three years, and declarations invalidated or goods abandoned to the State with customs permission. Refusing the parcel therefore protects the buyer only when the written withdrawal notice goes to the seller the same day and the courier confirms in writing what happens to the goods. No inspection, no intrusion and no liability beyond these texts has been established at the date of writing; signed contracts and the DGDDI notices take precedence over any general analysis, and only the court decides contested cases.

📄 Official circular