KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Montenegro Extradited an Iranian-Turkish Hacker to New York Over a $3.4 Billion University Hacking Case: What a Paris Court Would Test Before Any Surrender

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Montenegro Extradited an Iranian-Turkish Hacker to New York Over a $3.4 Billion University Hacking Case: What a Paris Court Would Test Before Any Surrender

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 1 October 2026, the Associated Press reported from Podgorica that Montenegro had extradited a 40-year-old Iranian-Turkish dual national, Amir Barati, to the United States over alleged intrusions into more than 150 American universities, said to have caused an estimated 3.4 billion dollars in damage. According to the Montenegrin police, Mr. Barati was arrested in June 2026 in Kotor by the national Interpol office and local officers, at the request of the American authorities, including the Federal Bureau of Investigation. He faces several charges in New York, including conspiracy to commit computer fraud, hacking and identity theft. The police account alleges a campaign running since 2013, conducted with an Iran-based entity, whose proceeds were said to have benefited the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps and other Iranian organisations.

At the date of writing, each of these elements remains an allegation reported by the press from a police announcement. No court has ruled on Mr. Barati’s guilt, no American judgment has been delivered, and no cited official source establishes the responsibility of any State or entity. The presumption of innocence applies in full; only the trial court will decide what is proven. The question examined here is strictly procedural: had such a request reached France rather than Montenegro, what would a Paris court have tested before any surrender, which obstacles could have blocked the transfer, and which safeguards would have followed the person across the Atlantic?

I. What Montenegro has just done, and what a Paris court would have checked first

A. Can a European state send an Iranian-Turkish dual national to the United States for hacking American universities?

Extradition from a European state to the United States is an ordinary judicial operation, but it is never automatic. Each requested state applies its own statute, its bilateral treaty with Washington, and the guarantees of the European Convention on Human Rights. Montenegro applied Montenegrin law and its own treaty framework. France would have applied the chapter of the Code of Criminal Procedure devoted to extradition, which states the baseline rule in plain terms: “En l’absence de convention internationale en stipulant autrement, les conditions, la procédure et les effets de l’extradition sont déterminés par les dispositions du présent chapitre.” That sentence, taken from article 696 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, matters because it organises the whole French reasoning: treaty first, statute second, and no surrender outside the conditions the two sources combine to impose. A Paris extradition chamber would therefore have started by reading the France-United States extradition treaty alongside the French statute, exactly as the Montenegrin courts will have read their own treaty with Washington before authorising Mr. Barati’s transfer.

The first French checkpoint concerns who may be surrendered at all. French law draws a sharp line around nationality: “Le gouvernement français peut remettre, sur leur demande, aux gouvernements étrangers, toute personne n’ayant pas la nationalité française qui, étant l’objet d’une poursuite intentée au nom de l’Etat requérant ou d’une condamnation prononcée par ses tribunaux, est trouvée sur le territoire de la République.” That is article 696-2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, and its logic is symmetrical with the best-known French refusal ground, restated in article 696-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure: “L’extradition n’est pas accordée : 1° Lorsque la personne réclamée a la nationalité française, cette dernière étant appréciée à l’époque de l’infraction pour laquelle l’extradition est requise”. Applied to the reported facts, the nationality shield would not have helped Mr. Barati in Paris any more than it helped him in Kotor. He is reported as an Iranian-Turkish dual national, not a French national, and neither of his nationalities blocks a French surrender to the United States. Dual nationality can complicate a file when one of the two nationalities is that of the requested state, or when the requesting state claims the person as its own national, but that configuration is absent here. A French chamber would simply have recorded that the first and most absolute French refusal ground was not triggered, and then moved to the harder questions: double criminality, the political-offence exception, and the compliance of the American penalty with French public policy.

The second checkpoint would have drawn the most commentary, because the Montenegrin police narrative connects the alleged hacking campaign to the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps. Whenever a requesting state describes an accused person as acting for the benefit of a foreign army, intelligence service or State-linked organisation, defence lawyers raise the political-offence exception, and journalists ask whether the prosecution is political. French law answers that question narrowly. The same article 696-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides: “2° Lorsque le crime ou le délit à un caractère politique ou lorsqu’il résulte des circonstances que l’extradition est demandée dans un but politique”. Two distinct doors exist: the offence itself is political by nature, or an ordinary offence is pursued for a political purpose. Computer intrusions into university networks, the alleged theft of research data and credentials, and the alleged resale or transfer of that material for the profit of State-linked bodies are, in French classification, ordinary economic and technological crimes, not political offences by nature. Attacking a university server does not become a political act because the ultimate beneficiary is said to be a foreign public body. The Cour de cassation has consistently required chambers of instruction to characterise the acts themselves rather than their distant geopolitical context, and a Paris court applying that method to the Barati allegations would most likely have treated the hacking counts as common-law offences, leaving the political-purpose branch as the only serious argument.

That second branch would then have been tested against the file, not against headlines. An extradition is sought for a political purpose when the circumstances show that the prosecution targets the person for opinions held, opposition activity, or membership of a persecuted group, rather than for the acts described. Nothing in the Associated Press dispatch of 1 October 2026 suggests such a configuration: the reported request rests on a federal investigation into intrusions, credential theft and fraud affecting identified universities, with quantified damage and named New York charges, and it was channelled through Interpol and the FBI in a transnational cybercrime framework. The mere fact that the alleged proceeds are said to have served Iranian organisations does not convert an American fraud prosecution into a political persecution, and the mere fact that the accused holds Iranian nationality does not create a presumption of political motive. A Paris chamber would have demanded concrete material: evidence that the New York charges were a pretext, that the acts were invented, or that the person was targeted for protected expression. Without such material, the political-purpose objection would have been dismissed, and the file would have moved to the decisive technical filter of every French extradition case, double criminality.

B. Are large-scale intrusions into university networks and the theft of academic data punishable under French criminal law?

France surrenders nobody for conduct that French law does not itself punish as a crime or misdemeanour. The rule is absolute: “En aucun cas l’extradition n’est accordée par le gouvernement français si le fait n’est pas puni par la loi française d’une peine criminelle ou correctionnelle.” That sentence closes article 696-3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which otherwise sets the applicable thresholds for the requesting state’s penalty. The same provision adds that attempt and complicity follow the same regime where they are punishable under both laws. In practice, the Paris chambre de l’instruction converts each American count into its French equivalent and asks whether the behaviour, as described, would have exposed the person to a criminal or correctional penalty in France. For the Barati allegations, that conversion exercise is straightforward, because French cybercrime law was written precisely for this kind of conduct.

The entry point is unauthorised access itself. Article 323-1 of the Criminal Code provides: “Le fait d’accéder ou de se maintenir, frauduleusement, dans tout ou partie d’un système de traitement automatisé de données est puni de trois ans d’emprisonnement et de 100 000 € d’amende.” The same article raises the penalty to five years and 150 000 euros where the intrusion causes deletion, modification or alteration of the system, and to seven years and 300 000 euros where the targeted system processes personal data on behalf of the State. Every alleged intrusion into a university server, every maintained fraudulent session inside a compromised mailbox, and every use of stolen credentials to move laterally through an academic network would fall, in French terms, within this provision, before any question of damage even arises. The Cour de cassation reads these texts as protecting the integrity of automated data systems as such, so that even an intrusion proven only by connection logs satisfies the corresponding French offence where the fraudulent character of the access is established.

The second layer is interference with the functioning of those systems. Article 323-2 of the Criminal Code states: “Le fait d’entraver ou de fausser le fonctionnement d’un système de traitement automatisé de données est puni de cinq ans d’emprisonnement et de 150 000 € d’amende.” Flooding authentication servers, deploying credential-harvesting pages that corrupt login processes, or neutralising security mechanisms to keep access open would each be examined under this heading. The third layer is the data itself. Article 323-3 of the Criminal Code punishes anyone who fraudulently introduces, extracts, holds, reproduces, transmits, deletes or modifies data: “Le fait d’introduire frauduleusement des données dans un système de traitement automatisé, d’extraire, de détenir, de reproduire, de transmettre, de supprimer ou de modifier frauduleusement les données qu’il contient est puni de cinq ans d’emprisonnement et de 150 000 € d’amende.” The alleged exfiltration of research corpora, dissertations, and authentication databases from more than 150 universities, followed by their transmission to third parties, maps directly onto the verbs of this article, and the reported scale would only aggravate the French assessment, not complicate it.

To these system-based offences must be added the identity component of the New York charges. Article 226-4-1 of the Criminal Code provides: “Le fait d’usurper l’identité d’un tiers ou de faire usage d’une ou plusieurs données de toute nature permettant de l’identifier en vue de troubler sa tranquillité ou celle d’autrui, ou de porter atteinte à son honneur ou à sa considération, est puni d’un an d’emprisonnement et de 15 000 € d’amende.” Compromised professor and student accounts used to send phishing messages, to authenticate fraudulent sessions, or to mask the intruder’s trail would be examined under this text alongside the computer-fraud provisions, and French courts have long accepted that the use of identifying data on an online public communication network falls within the article. Taken together, the four provisions give a Paris chamber everything it needs: each American count described in the dispatch has a French criminal mirror carrying a correctional penalty, attempt and complicity are covered by the closing words of article 696-3, and the quantitative thresholds of that article are plainly met where the requesting state alleges multi-billion-dollar damage and decades of potential imprisonment. Double criminality, the filter that kills a large share of French extradition requests at birth, would therefore have been satisfied on the reported facts, subject always to proof of the facts themselves, which belongs to the trial court alone.

That conclusion is reinforced by the way the Cour de cassation polices double criminality. In a published extradition ruling that every Paris extradition practitioner knows, the criminal chamber recalled that “l’extradition est accordée pour le ou les faits qui, aux termes des législations des deux Etats, constituent des crimes ou des délits punis d’une peine privative de liberté d’au moins deux ans”, before adding the decisive limit: “cette disposition ne saurait être interprétée comme ayant pour effet d’autoriser l’extradition pour un fait qui ne constitue pas une infraction pénale dans la loi de l’un des deux Etats” (Cour de cassation, criminal chamber, 19 June 2019, No. 19-80.182, published in the Bulletin). The passage is worth quoting because it states both sides of the test in one breath: treaty thresholds open the door, but a missing domestic offence closes it. In the Barati hypothesis, no door stays closed, because the French catalogue punishes each alleged behaviour. A Paris court would have said so expressly, count by count, and then turned to the third and most human part of its review: what the person risks once surrendered. Readers who follow these columns will recognise the method from a recent analysis of a Canadian fraud warrant executed in France, where the same nationality and double-criminality filters decided the outcome before any discussion of surrender conditions (Arrested in France on a Canadian fraud warrant: the French nationality test).

II. What surrender means in practice, and how French law protects the person sought

A. Once transferred to New York, what limits the prosecution, the sentence and the detention conditions?

Surrender is not a blank cheque handed to the requesting state. Under the specialty principle, which France treats as a condition of every extradition, the person delivered may be prosecuted, tried or detained only for the facts that motivated the surrender, as accepted by the requested state, and any extension to new charges requires the consent of that state. Concretely, had Paris surrendered a suspect on the basis of described intrusions into identified universities between stated dates, the New York prosecutors would be expected to try those facts and those facts alone; adding unrelated counts, recycling the surrender to investigate a different hacking campaign, or re-characterising the same conduct into far graver offences without returning to the requested state would breach the commitment on which the surrender rested. Defence teams in transatlantic cases therefore read the surrender decree line by line, because the decree draws the perimeter inside which the American trial must stay. Where the reported Montenegrin transfer is concerned, the same logic applies under Montenegro’s own commitments: the specialty perimeter will have been fixed by the decision authorising Mr. Barati’s extradition, and any American attempt to go beyond it would require a fresh Montenegrin consent. The principle protects the sovereignty of the requested state as much as the liberty of the individual, which is why French chambers verify its future effectiveness before giving a favourable opinion, and why they expect the requesting state to honour it after delivery.

The second post-surrender question is the sentence. American federal computer-fraud and identity-theft counts can accumulate into very long aggregate exposures, especially where the indictment alleges a campaign running since 2013, more than 150 institutional victims, and billions of dollars in loss. French extradition law does not ask the chamber to re-sentence the case, but it does impose an outer barrier: article 696-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure refuses surrender where the requesting state’s penalty is contrary to French public policy, and it separately refuses surrender where the person would face a court that does not guarantee fundamental procedural and defence rights. No death-penalty issue arises on the reported New York charges, which removes the classic deal-breaker of Franco-American extradition files. The remaining debate would concern exceptionally long aggregate sentences and the conditions in which they are served. French courts examine this through Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which prohibits torture and inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment: irreducible life sentences without any prospect of release, and detention regimes found to attain the minimum level of severity under the Convention, can block a surrender or require individualised diplomatic assurances before it. A Paris court would therefore have asked what maximum the New York counts realistically carry, whether parole, good-time credit or presidential clemency preserves a genuine prospect of release, and under which regime the person would be held pending trial and after conviction.

On this point, recent case law invites precision rather than reflex. In a May 2024 ruling on a surrender mechanism with the United Kingdom, the criminal chamber held that disproportionality of the sentence in the issuing state was not among the listed refusal grounds of that specific cooperation agreement, so that the French enforcement judge had no mandate to assess it there (Cour de cassation, criminal chamber, 2 May 2024, No. 24-82.116, where the court stated that “Les griefs ne sont pas de nature à permettre l’admission du pourvoi au sens de l’article 567-1-1 du code de procédure pénale”). That solution belongs to its instrument and does not neutralise the classic extradition filter of article 696-4, which expressly targets penalties contrary to French public policy. A Paris chamber seized of an American cybercrime request would therefore have kept the full review: no death penalty, no irreducible life term, no court lacking defence guarantees, and, where American sentencing practice or supermax-style detention conditions raised an Article 3 question, a demand for precise, individualised and verifiable assurances from Washington before any favourable opinion. Assurances in Franco-American practice are not vague diplomatic notes; they identify the charges covered, the maximum penalty that will be sought, the absence of recourse to particular regimes, and the monitoring that makes the promise credible. Without them, the opinion turns unfavourable; with them, the surrender can proceed on a documented basis that the European Court of Human Rights can later review under its interim-measures procedure if new risks emerge between the decree and the boarding of the plane.

The detention-conditions limb deserves a final word because cybercrime defendants are routinely held in restrictive pre-trial regimes justified by the risk of remote deletion of evidence or witness interference. A Paris court distinguishes the legitimate needs of the investigation from regimes that would breach Article 3: prolonged solitary confinement, detention conditions combining overcrowding, lack of light, sleep deprivation and denial of care, or a documented lack of medical supervision for a vulnerable person. The chamber does not require American prisons to replicate French ones; it requires that the concrete placement envisaged for the concrete person stay below the Convention’s severity threshold. In a file of the reported magnitude, where pre-trial detention in New York could last many months given the volume of seized data and the number of victim institutions, a careful Paris opinion would have conditioned surrender on information about the facility, the regime, access to counsel and family contact, and medical coverage, and it would have reminded the parties that the European Court remains competent to suspend a removal where fresh material shows a real risk. That is the French equilibrium: cooperation against borderless cybercrime, yes, but never at the price of surrendering a person to treatment that French public policy condemns.

B. If the request had landed in Paris, which remedies could the person sought actually use?

French extradition procedure gives the person sought a genuine adversarial forum before any government decision, and understanding its calendar is the most practical part of this analysis. A person arrested in Paris on an American request is brought before the general prosecutor, who records identity, notifies the request, and asks whether the person consents to be surrendered. Consent simplifies and accelerates, but it is never required, and experienced practitioners almost never advise it in a contested file, because refusal opens the full review of the chambre de l’instruction. The statute then sets a brisk tempo: “Lorsque la personne réclamée a déclaré au procureur général ne pas consentir à son extradition, la chambre de l’instruction est saisie, sans délai, de la procédure. La personne réclamée comparaît devant elle dans un délai de dix jours ouvrables à compter de la date de sa présentation au procureur général.” That is the opening of article 696-15 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, and it explains why extradition defence in Paris is an emergency discipline: within days, counsel must challenge identity, double criminality, the political exception, prescription, and the American penalty, while gathering assurances material and, where needed, seizing the European Court of Human Rights for interim measures.

The hearing itself ends in a reasoned opinion, not a judgment of guilt. Article 696-15 of the Code of Criminal Procedure continues: “Si, lors de sa comparution, la personne réclamée déclare ne pas consentir à être extradée, la chambre de l’instruction donne son avis motivé sur la demande d’extradition.” And it fixes the standard: “Cet avis est défavorable si la cour estime que les conditions légales ne sont pas remplies ou qu’il y a une erreur évidente.”

A Paris chamber applying that standard would therefore have delivered a count-by-count opinion on the Barati allegations: identity verified through fingerprints and Interpol diffusion, double criminality confirmed through the cybercrime provisions discussed above, political exception rejected with reasons, prescription examined under both laws as article 696-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure requires where it bars surrender when limitation has run in either system, and penalty compatibility assessed with any American assurances annexed to the file. An unfavourable opinion ends the matter: the government cannot surrender in the face of it. A favourable opinion, by contrast, merely authorises the government to act; the Prime Minister signs, or refuses to sign, the extradition decree, and that decree is itself subject to an action for excess of power before the Conseil d’Etat, alongside a possible application to the European Court of Human Rights for suspension where an Article 3 risk is alleged. Cassation review of the chamber’s opinion exists but is deliberately narrow, confined to formal defects affecting the very legal existence of the opinion, which is why the battle is won or lost at the hearing, not months later in Paris or Strasbourg.

Liberty during the procedure is the question families ask first, and French law answers it without evasion. Detention pending extradition, known as detention under an extradition warrant, is the default where flight risk is real, and transatlantic cybercrime files with overseas digital assets present an obvious flight risk. But detention is reviewable at any moment: “La mise en liberté peut être demandée à tout moment à la chambre de l’instruction selon les formes prévues aux articles 148-6 et 148-7” That sentence opens article 696-19 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which adds that the chamber rules within short statutory deadlines and may attach supervision obligations to any release order. In a Paris version of this case, counsel would have sought release under judicial supervision from the first days: surrender of passports, residence at a declared Paris address with immediate notification of any change, regular reporting to a police station, and a prohibition on leaving the metropolitan area, calibrated to neutralise the flight risk while the chamber examines the merits. The chamber can also order house arrest under electronic monitoring under the referenced supervision provisions. Success is never guaranteed where the person has no ties in France and faces decades of American imprisonment, and courts weigh that imbalance openly, but the application itself forces the prosecution to justify continued detention rather than coasting on the extradition label, and renewed applications track every development in the file.

Two ancillary fronts complete the Paris toolkit and both would have mattered here. The first is Interpol itself: where a red notice or diffusion underpins the arrest, counsel can petition the Commission for the Control of Interpol’s Files for access, correction or deletion, arguing, for example, that the data is inaccurate, that the prosecution is predominantly political, or that the notice was misused. The second is time: prescription, parallel proceedings, and the territorial hooks of article 696-2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and article 696-3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure must be pleaded early, with American limitation and French limitation computed side by side, because a single time-barred count narrows the specialty perimeter and can change the entire negotiation over assurances. For readers arrested in the Paris region, the practical landmarks are stable: the investigation division of the Paris prosecutor’s office, the chambre de l’instruction of the Paris Court of Appeal sitting as the extradition chamber, detention Hirings at Fresnes or Villepinte pending the hearing, and the Conseil d’Etat for the decree challenge, with the European Court in Strasbourg as the last external judge. None of these steps decides guilt; each of them decides whether France lends its coercive power to a foreign prosecution, and under which documented conditions.

Conclusion

The Montenegrin transfer reported on 1 October 2026 illustrates how quickly a transnational cybercrime file can move from a quiet arrest in a coastal town to a federal courtroom in New York: an Interpol request, a June arrest in Kotor, and an October surrender on charges of conspiracy, hacking and identity theft spanning a decade and more than 150 alleged victim universities. Transposed to Paris, the same file would have passed through four successive filters: no French nationality to block surrender, no political offence on the acts as described, double criminality satisfied through the French computer-crime and identity provisions, and a penalty-and-conditions review capable of requiring individualised American assurances before any favourable opinion. Each filter would have produced a reasoned answer, each answer would have been subject to review, and release under supervision would have remained available throughout.

Three reservations close this analysis and must stay with the reader. First, nothing in the Associated Press dispatch establishes Mr. Barati’s guilt, the exact scope of the American charges, or the responsibility of any organisation named in the police narrative; allegations are not findings, damage estimates are not judgments, and only the competent trial court, hearing the defence, will determine what is proven. Second, no official source cited at the date of writing records any accident, intrusion or damage judicially established against any named entity, and no liability of any kind has been judicially declared. Third, the French tests developed here are hypothetical: they show what a Paris court would have examined, not what the Montenegrin courts decided under their own law. Within those limits, the lesson is clear. European states cooperate firmly against large-scale hacking of universities and research institutions, because the evidence is borderless and the victims are real, but France surrenders only after verifying, count by count and condition by condition, that its statute, its courts and the Convention permit it. That verification is not a formality; it is the moment when the rule of law does its quietest and most essential work.

📄 Official circular