KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Montenegro Just Handed an Alleged Iranian Hacker to America: Would Paris Have Surrendered Him?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Montenegro Just Handed an Alleged Iranian Hacker to America: Would Paris Have Surrendered Him?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 1 October 2026, Montenegro surrendered Amir Barati, a 40-year-old Turkish-Iranian dual citizen, to the United States, where federal prosecutors accuse him of playing a central role in one of the largest academic hacking campaigns ever charged: the alleged infiltration, between 2013 and 2017, of email accounts belonging to some 8,000 professors, the theft of at least 31 terabytes of research data from 144 American universities and dozens of institutions abroad, and losses the Department of Justice values at 3.4 billion dollars. Arrested on 25 June while on holiday in the coastal town of Kotor on the basis of an FBI arrest warrant, Barati was named in August in a 14-count indictment charging 17 people in connection with a campaign prosecutors attribute to the Mabna Institute acting on behalf of Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps. A Montenegrin court issued the final extradition decision this week, and the handover followed within days.

For an international reader, the story raises the question every cross-border file raises: what would have happened if the arrest had taken place at Roissy rather than in Kotor? France extradites to the United States regularly under its bilateral treaty, and its courts have built, decision after decision, a demanding but predictable test. The file would have passed through the 48-hour presentation to the prosecutor general, the adversarial hearing before the Paris chambre de l’instruction, a possible decree signed by the Prime Minister, and a pourvoi to the Cour de cassation whose review is confined to formal defects. Two rulings handed down by the criminal chamber in the spring of 2026, one of them in an American extradition case, show exactly how that control works today. On the facts reported by the American authorities, a Paris court would very likely have given a favorable opinion — provided the double-criminality check, the nationality bar, the political-offence exception and the detention-conditions scrutiny were all satisfied. This article explains each of those locks, with the exact texts and the latest decisions, so that anyone facing a comparable request understands what a French lawyer would plead, and in what order.

I. The Montenegro surrender: what the American file against the alleged Mabna hacker contains

A. Fourteen counts, seventeen defendants and 31 terabytes of stolen research: what Washington alleges

According to the Department of Justice, the case began long before the Kotor arrest. In August 2026, federal prosecutors unsealed a 14-count indictment charging 17 people in connection with what they describe as an expansive state-sponsored campaign run through an Iranian company known as the Mabna Institute on behalf of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps. The official press release is published on the Department’s website at justice.gov/opa/pr/17-iranians-charged-conducting-massive-cyber-theft-campaign-behalf-islamic-revolutionary, and the reporting of The Record, which broke the extradition news on 1 October 2026, draws directly on that document.

The method described by the prosecutors will be familiar to anyone who follows cybercrime cases. The group allegedly ran large-scale spearphishing waves against university staff, harvested login credentials, used the stolen accounts to enter library systems and email inboxes, and exfiltrated journals, theses, dissertations and electronic books across dozens of disciplines. About 8,000 professors’ email accounts were successfully targeted between 2013 and 2017, according to the indictment as reported. The loot — at least 31 terabytes of data and intellectual property — was then allegedly handed to the Iranian government and sold through two websites to universities inside Iran, one of which let Iranian customers use stolen credentials to browse American university library systems as if they were legitimate users.

The scale figures put forward by Washington are striking and, for a defence lawyer, the first thing to test. The prosecutors speak of breaches at 144 American universities and 42 American companies, plus 178 foreign universities and at least 11 foreign companies, of 3.4 billion dollars in damage, and of some 20 million dollars spent by the victim universities on investigation and remediation. Within that machinery, Barati is presented not as a peripheral figure but as an organizer: prosecutors say he tracked the progress of the spearphishing campaigns, exchanged compromised credentials with co-conspirators, built targeting lists, conducted network reconnaissance and crafted phishing messages. The charges against him include conspiracy to commit computer intrusions, wire fraud, computer fraud and identity theft — a stack of counts whose American maximum sentences run to many years, which matters enormously for the extradition thresholds examined below.

Two biographical details reported by Iran International add context that an extradition judge would weigh carefully. Barati, who is said to have a long history in the Iranian hacking scene with groups that reportedly targeted Microsoft and MIT, was allegedly arrested by Iran’s Intelligence Ministry in 2010 and coerced into working for the authorities for several years; he is then reported to have left Iran, changed his name and acquired Turkish citizenship in 2021. None of this is established by a court judgment to date — everything in this section is accusation, drawn from the American indictment and press reporting — but it sketches the profile of a defendant who might later invoke, before a French court, both the political dimension of his prosecution and fears about what awaits him in an American prison. Both arguments have a precise legal home in French extradition law, and both usually fail for reasons this article will explain.

B. Arrested on holiday in Kotor, surrendered within weeks: how Montenegro moved faster than Paris ever could

The second half of the story is procedural, and it is where the comparison with France becomes instructive. Barati was arrested on 25 June by Montenegro’s Police Directorate after the FBI issued an arrest warrant, and he was picked up in Kotor, a resort town where he was spending his holidays — the classic extradition scenario of a wanted person intercepted while travelling. A Montenegrin court then issued what the Montenegrin authorities describe as a final decision to extradite, announced on the government’s official portal at gov.me/clanak/sluzbenici-ncb-interpol-podgorica-izrucili-sad-u-visokoprofilnu-metu, and the surrender to American custody followed this week, roughly three months after the arrest.

Three months from arrest to surrender is fast by French standards, and the contrast is deliberate. In France, the same sequence would have involved at least four stages, each with its own clock: presentation to the prosecutor general within 48 hours of arrest, an adversarial hearing before the chambre de l’instruction within ten working days if the person refuses surrender, a reasoned opinion within one month, a government decree, and then a pourvoi to the Cour de cassation followed, in hard-fought cases, by applications to the European Court of Human Rights for interim measures. A comparable American request examined by the Aix-en-Provence chambre de l’instruction in September 2025 was still before the Cour de cassation in April 2026 — seven months for the judicial phase alone. Speed is not a quality French extradition procedure optimizes for; adversarial completeness is.

There is a second lesson in the Kotor arrest: the decisive role of presence on the territory. Extradition, unlike the European Arrest Warrant, is not available against a person who stays home — Iran has no extradition treaty with the United States and would never surrender its own national, and that is precisely why the American strategy in state-sponsored hacking cases is to wait for travel. The 2018 indictment of the original Mabna defendants produced no arrests for years; it was the defendant’s decision to holiday on the Adriatic coast that made this surrender possible. For readers, the practical moral is blunt: an FBI arrest warrant or an Interpol red notice does not expire, and a seaside holiday in a cooperative state can end in a cell on another continent. France applies exactly the same logic — anyone arrested at a Paris airport on a foreign warrant enters the pipeline described in Part II — which is why understanding that pipeline matters even for people who have never set foot in a French courtroom.

II. Arrested at Roissy instead of Kotor: the four locks a Paris court would test before surrendering him

A. Is American computer fraud punishable in France? Double criminality and the French cybercrime arsenal

The first lock is double criminality, and it is written into Article 696-3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure: the requesting state’s law must punish the conduct as a crime or as a correctional offence carrying a maximum of at least two years’ imprisonment — or, for a convicted person, a sentence of at least two months — and, crucially, “En aucun cas l’extradition n’est accordée par le gouvernement français si le fait n’est pas puni par la loi française d’une peine criminelle ou correctionnelle.” No punishment under French law, no surrender — that is the whole rule in one sentence.

On these facts, the lock would open easily, because French cybercrime law mirrors the American charges almost count for count. The spearphishing intrusions into university messaging systems fall under Article 323-1 of the Criminal Code, which provides that “Le fait d’accéder ou de se maintenir, frauduleusement, dans tout ou partie d’un système de traitement automatisé de données est puni de trois ans d’emprisonnement et de 100 000 € d’amende”, rising to five years where data was deleted or altered. The harvesting, holding and transmission of stolen credentials and documents fall under Article 323-3 of the Criminal Code: “Le fait d’introduire frauduleusement des données dans un système de traitement automatisé, d’extraire, de détenir, de reproduire, de transmettre, de supprimer ou de modifier frauduleusement les données qu’il contient est puni de cinq ans d’emprisonnement et de 150 000 € d’amende.” And because the indictment describes a structured group of 17 alleged conspirators with divided roles — targeting lists, credential exchanges, reconnaissance — Article 323-4 of the Criminal Code would add the organized-group dimension: “La participation à un groupement formé ou à une entente établie en vue de la préparation, caractérisée par un ou plusieurs faits matériels, d’une ou de plusieurs des infractions prévues par les articles 323-1 à 323-3-1 est punie des peines prévues pour l’infraction elle-même ou pour l’infraction la plus sévèrement réprimée.”

The American side of the equation presents no difficulty either: conspiracy, wire fraud, computer fraud and identity theft each carry maximum sentences well above the two-year threshold, and the 14-count stack removes any argument about the quantum. A French defence lawyer would therefore not waste ammunition on double criminality here — unlike in cases involving conduct that is lawful in France, such as certain speech or drug offences — and would move immediately to the refusal grounds, where the real fights are fought. One preliminary skirmish is worth mentioning: the defence could argue that some victim servers stood in France, triggering Article 696-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which bars extradition “3° Lorsque les crimes ou délits ont été commis sur le territoire de la République”. But that provision protects French territorial jurisdiction where France intends to prosecute itself; where — as here — the overwhelming weight of victims, servers and evidence sits in the United States, the chambre de l’instruction treats scattered French effects as insufficient to keep the case, and the argument fails.

The same Article 696-4 contains the two shields a lawyer would actually plead. The first is nationality — “L’extradition n’est pas accordée : 1° Lorsque la personne réclamée a la nationalité française” — but Barati is Turkish and Iranian, so the shield does not apply; had he been French, refusal would have been automatic and the story would end here, since France never extradites its own nationals and prosecutes them at home instead. The second is the political-offence exception — “2° Lorsque le crime ou le délit à un caractère politique ou lorsqu’il résulte des circonstances que l’extradition est demandée dans un but politique” — and this is where the IRGC connection cuts both ways. The defence would argue that a prosecution driven by an American-Iranian confrontation, against a man allegedly coerced by Tehran’s intelligence services, is political by nature. French courts, however, read the political exception narrowly: ordinary profit-driven or espionage-adjacent cybercrime, even when a state stands behind it, is treated as common-law crime, and the theft-and-resale of academic data for money looks like precisely that. The exception protects dissidents prosecuted for opposing a regime, not hackers accused of stealing terabytes for one. Added to this is the time-bar check in the same article — prescription must not have run under either law before the request — and with conduct ending in 2017, an American indictment and a 2026 request, limitation arguments would require showing that the American clock had already expired, a difficult submission given conspiracy and concealment doctrines that suspend it.

B. Forty-eight hours, one adversarial hearing and a pourvoi that almost never wins: the procedure and its two 2026 precedents

Suppose, then, that Barati lands at Roissy and is arrested on the FBI warrant. The clock starts immediately. Under Article 696-10 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, “Toute personne appréhendée à la suite d’une demande d’extradition doit être conduite dans les quarante-huit heures devant le procureur général territorialement compétent”, who verifies identity, notifies the request in a language the person understands, and warns them — on pain of nullity — of the right to counsel of their choice or court-appointed counsel, with immediate access to the file. Consent at this stage means fast-track surrender; refusal, which is the norm in serious cases, sends the file to the Paris chambre de l’instruction.

That hearing is the heart of the French system. Under Article 696-15 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the person appears within ten working days, and if they confirm their refusal, “la chambre de l’instruction donne son avis motivé sur la demande d’extradition”, delivering it within one month absent further inquiries — and “Cet avis est défavorable si la cour estime que les conditions légales ne sont pas remplies ou qu’il y a une erreur évidente.” A favorable opinion does not surrender anyone by itself: surrender requires a government decree, which can itself be challenged before the administrative courts. But the decisive sentence of the article, for any lawyer calibrating a client’s hopes, is the last one: “Le pourvoi formé contre un avis de la chambre de l’instruction ne peut être fondé que sur des vices de forme de nature à priver cet avis des conditions essentielles de son existence légale.” In other words, the Cour de cassation does not re-weigh the evidence, the American file or the proportionality of surrender; it checks that the procedure existed legally. Most pourvois die on that sentence.

Two decisions from the spring of 2026 illustrate the point with unusual clarity, and both are freely readable on the Court’s official website. On 14 April 2026, the criminal chamber rejected a pourvoi against a favorable opinion given by the Aix-en-Provence chambre de l’instruction in proceedings brought at the request of the American government — the exact configuration of our hypothetical — holding that “chaque moyen, même de fond, aurait-il précédemment fait l’objet d’un complément d’information ordonné dans une autre composition, doit être examiné au fond, plaidé devant la chambre de l’instruction, et jugé par celle-ci dans une composition identique” (Crim., 14 April 2026, No. 25-86.772, courdecassation.fr/decision/69df2977cdc6046d4748e0ac). Six weeks later, on 27 May 2026, the same chamber rejected a pourvoi in an Algerian-request extradition where the defence challenged prison conditions, approving a chamber that had ordered further inquiries from the requesting state and then “souverainement écarté, par des motifs exempts d’insuffisance et de contradiction, l’existence du risque de conditions indignes de détention et a ainsi justifié sa décision” (Crim., 27 May 2026, No. 25-84.904, courdecassation.fr/decision/6a1682ebcdc6046d471178cb).

That second ruling maps directly onto the last serious defence in a file like Barati’s: the argument that surrender exposes the person to inhuman or degrading detention in the requesting state. French chambers now conduct what the Cour de cassation calls a concrete examination — square metres per detainee, hours of outdoor exercise, health and hygiene facilities — based on replies to formal requests for additional information, and American diplomatic assurances about placement, sentence administration and consular monitoring usually survive it. The European Court of Human Rights, whose extradition case law from Soering to Trabelsi sets the outer boundary, remains available through interim-measures applications in genuinely extreme cases, and its docket can be followed on the Court’s official portal; but the Strasbourg bar is deliberately high, and ordinary federal detention, even under a long prospective sentence, does not clear it. A French lawyer would plead the point — it is the duty to plead everything — while advising the client that it succeeds only where the file shows a specific, personal, documented risk, not a general critique of American prisons.

Readers who want to see how a neighbouring scenario played out will find the comparison instructive: Ireland’s surrender of a Conti ransomware builder to the United States, analysed on this site through the same Paris test, ended with a four-year American sentence after a guilty plea — the standard closing act of these cases, since the vast majority of extradited cyber defendants negotiate once they face the American sentencing guidelines. Barati’s trajectory will likely follow the same arc: extradition fight, then plea discussion, then sentence. The French procedure examined here would not have changed the destination; it would only have made the journey longer, more adversarial, and more protective of the defence’s right to force the requesting state to document every one of its claims.

Conclusion

Montenegro’s surrender of Amir Barati is legally unremarkable and strategically significant at the same time. Unremarkable, because every lock in a textbook extradition was aligned: a public indictment with detailed counts, thresholds far above every minimum, a defendant with no local nationality shield, no plausible political-offence claim, and a requesting state whose assurances courts routinely accept. Significant, because it confirms the American method in state-sponsored hacking cases — indict publicly, wait patiently, and arrest when the target travels — a method that works identically at Podgorica, at Kotor, and at Roissy. No accident, intrusion or damage has been established by any court against Barati to date; the American allegations remain accusations, the contracts and licences governing the universities’ data remain subject to their own terms, and only the trial judge in the United States will decide guilt, with the presumption of innocence intact until then. Had the arrest happened in Paris, the chambre de l’instruction would have tested double criminality against Articles 323-1, 323-3 and 323-4, verified each refusal ground of Article 696-4, heard the defence in full, and very likely given the same favorable opinion — which the Cour de cassation, faithful to its spring 2026 rulings, would then have left standing. The lesson for anyone living under a foreign warrant is therefore not that France is a refuge; it is that France is a procedure. And procedures reward those who prepare early: checking whether a red notice exists before travelling, understanding which conduct is punishable on both sides, and instructing counsel in the arrest state before the 48-hour clock starts. That preparation is the whole difference between suffering extradition and defending against it.

📄 Official circular