You own a house in France, but on paper you do not own it at all. A Delaware LLC owns it, or a French société civile immobilière, the SCI, owns it, and you own the company. The structure was set up years ago, maybe on the advice of an American advisor who wanted to avoid probate, maybe by a French notaire who wanted to organize a purchase between relatives. Since then the company has done nothing except hold the house, and every year it quietly generates tax returns, disclosure duties, and sometimes a tax bill worth several percent of the value of the home. This guide answers the question more and more American owners are asking: how do I get the house out of the company and back into my own name, cleanly, without triggering a worse tax bill on the way out? The first part explains why the wrapper costs money, so you can confirm the diagnosis before operating. The second part walks through the exit itself: the decision rule for keeping or killing the structure, the dissolution mechanics for an LLC and for an SCI, the French duties and land registry steps, the January 1 deadline that decides whether next year’s bill exists, and what replaces the company once it is gone, including the co-ownership agreement and the estate plan you must put in place. Two companion guides published on this site cover the entry side in depth: the filing that exempts an American LLC from the annual 3 percent tax is explained in the guide on the LLC 3 percent exemption filing, and the creation and running of an SCI is covered in the guide on SCI creation, taxes, succession, and American reporting. This article is the mirror image: it is about leaving the structure, not entering it.
I. Why the company wrapper around your French house costs money every year
Before dissolving anything, confirm that the company is actually the problem, because unwinding a structure has its own costs and you should only pay them if the annual savings justify it. For most American owners of a pure vacation home, the math is brutally simple: the company adds at least one French return every year, sometimes two, plus American information returns, and in the worst case an annual tax equal to 3 percent of the market value of the house. A company that manages no business, employs nobody, and exists only on paper is an expensive mailbox.
A. The LLC or SCI on the title triggers the 3 percent tax and yearly disclosure
French law treats any company holding French real estate as a potential taxpayer for a special annual levy. The statute states, in its own words, that “Les entités juridiques : personnes morales, organismes, fiducies ou institutions comparables qui, directement ou par entité interposée, possèdent un ou plusieurs immeubles situés en France ou sont titulaires de droits réels portant sur ces biens sont redevables d’une taxe annuelle égale à 3 % de la valeur vénale de ces immeubles ou droits.” In plain English: legal entities, including companies, bodies, trusts, and comparable institutions, that directly or through an intermediary own one or more buildings located in France, or hold real rights over those properties, owe an annual tax equal to 3 percent of the market value of those buildings or rights. That text is Article 990 D of the French General Tax Code (Code général des impôts). On a 500,000 euro house that is 15,000 euros a year. On a 1,000,000 euro apartment it is 30,000 euros. The tax runs whether the house is rented or empty, profitable or not, visited or not.
Most American-owned structures can be exempted, but exemption is never automatic: it must be claimed each year with full disclosure of the ultimate owners. The statute sets the reference date bluntly: “La taxe est due à raison des immeubles ou droits immobiliers possédés au 1er janvier de l’année d’imposition”, meaning the tax is due on buildings or real estate rights owned on January 1 of the tax year. That text is Article 990 F of the French General Tax Code. The same article imposes the yearly ritual: covered entities “doivent déclarer au plus tard le 15 mai de chaque année la situation, la consistance et la valeur des immeubles et droits immobiliers en cause.” In English, they must declare, no later than May 15 of each year, the location, composition, and value of the buildings and real estate rights at issue. That text is also Article 990 F of the French General Tax Code. In practice the return is form 2746-SD, and the chain rule makes every intermediate entity jointly liable, so a living trust owning an LLC owning an SCI multiplies the paperwork and the exposure. The exemption categories begin with a sentence worth quoting: “La taxe prévue à l’article 990 D n’est pas applicable : 1° Aux organisations internationales, aux Etats souverains, à leurs subdivisions politiques et territoriales, ainsi qu’aux personnes morales, organismes, fiducies ou institutions comparables qu’ils contrôlent majoritairement ;”, which lists international organizations, sovereign states, and the entities they control. That text is Article 990 E of the French General Tax Code. The same article continues with the provisions ordinary American owners rely on: entities based in France, in the European Union, or in a country bound to France by an administrative assistance treaty against fraud and evasion, which covers the United States, provided they disclose their shareholders. The official English-language guidance of the French tax administration confirms the whole mechanism on the 3 percent tax page of impots.gouv.fr. If your LLC or SCI has been filing every May with complete disclosure, the wrapper costs you compliance fees but no 3 percent. If it has never filed, because nobody told you the form existed, the wrapper may have been accumulating exposure for years, and every additional January 1 that passes with the company still on the title starts another year of risk. That ticking clock is the first reason owners dissolve.
The second reason is the American side. A single-member American LLC is disregarded for United States federal income tax, so the IRS sees you as owning the house directly, while France sees a company. The mismatch produces dual reporting with no dual benefit: French rental income declared transparently in France and again on the American Schedule E, French bank accounts tied to the house triggering both French Form 3916 and the American FBAR, and a 3 percent tax that, when actually paid, generally does not convert into an American foreign tax credit because it is not an income tax. The double-reporting burden is described in the guide on French Form 3916 and American FBAR double reporting. Add the accountant’s questions about classifying a French SCI for American purposes, and the mailbox company starts looking like what it is: a liability factory, not a liability shield. Genuine liability protection for a French vacation home comes from adequate French homeowner’s and umbrella insurance, not from a Delaware charter. Probate avoidance for French real estate comes from a French will covering the French assets, not from an LLC membership certificate, as explained in the guide on American wills and French forced heirship for a French house.
B. The SCI adds wealth tax complexity without shielding the house from forced heirship
The French SCI deserves its own diagnosis because it is a domestic company, so owners assume it must be harmless. Legally it is a civil company: company law first defines the general concept, “La société est instituée par deux ou plusieurs personnes qui conviennent par un contrat d’affecter à une entreprise commune des biens ou leur industrie en vue de partager le bénéfice ou de profiter de l’économie qui pourra en résulter.” In English, a company is formed by two or more persons who agree by contract to devote property or work to a shared enterprise in order to share the profit or benefit from the savings that may result. That text is Article 1832 of the Civil Code (Code civil). Its civil character follows from the rule that “Ont le caractère civil toutes les sociétés auxquelles la loi n’attribue pas un autre caractère à raison de leur forme, de leur nature, ou de leur objet.” In English, all companies to which the law does not attribute a different character by reason of their form, nature, or purpose are civil in character. That text is Article 1845 of the Civil Code. The default SCI is tax-transparent, expressed in the rule that “les associés ou actionnaires sont personnellement soumis à l’impôt sur le revenu ou à l’impôt sur les sociétés, suivant le cas, pour la part des revenus sociaux correspondant à leurs droits dans la société.” In English, the partners or shareholders are personally subject to income tax or corporate tax, as applicable, on the share of the company’s income corresponding to their rights in the company. That text is Article 1655 ter of the French General Tax Code. Transparency means the SCI changes nothing about who ultimately pays French tax on the rents; it only changes the plumbing.
Transparency also extends to the wealth tax. France taxes nonresident Americans only on French real estate, but shares in an SCI count to the extent they represent French buildings. The charging provision states the founding principle: “Il est institué un impôt annuel sur les actifs immobiliers désigné sous le nom d’impôt sur la fortune immobilière.” In English, an annual tax on real estate assets is established, called the real estate wealth tax. That text is Article 964 of the French General Tax Code. The same article sets the threshold every owner should memorize: taxation applies “lorsque la valeur de leurs actifs mentionnés à l’article 965 est supérieure à 1 300 000 €”, meaning when the value of the assets described in Article 965 exceeds 1,300,000 euros. That text is also Article 964 of the French General Tax Code. The base is defined as follows: “L’assiette de l’impôt sur la fortune immobilière est constituée par la valeur nette au 1er janvier de l’année :”, meaning the base of the real estate wealth tax consists of the net value on January 1 of the year. That text is Article 965 of the French General Tax Code. And valuation follows the rule that “La valeur des actifs mentionnés à l’article 965 est déterminée suivant les règles en vigueur en matière de droits de mutation par décès.” In English, the value of the assets mentioned in Article 965 is determined according to the rules applicable to transfers on death. That text is Article 973 of the French General Tax Code. The administration’s English page for nonresidents confirms the territorial logic on the impots.gouv.fr IFI page for nonresidents. A worked example: a California couple holding a 2,000,000 euro Provençal house through an SCI with a 300,000 euro French loan outstanding has a net base around 1,700,000 euros, above the threshold, so the IFI return is due with progressive slices from 0.5 to 1.5 percent. The SCI did not create that bill, direct ownership would produce the same bill, but the SCI forces the computation through the share-fraction method, adds a layer of valuation argument, and contributes nothing in return when the house is a pure second home. Nor does the SCI disinherit anyone: shares in a single-asset family SCI are treated economically as the house itself for the children’s forced shares, and an action for reduction can claw back excessive gifts of shares just as it claws back gifts of bricks. Families relying on the SCI as a substitute for an American living trust should read why France ignores the American living trust and what to do instead. When the diagnosis is complete, most vacation-home wrappers fail every test: no business, no deadlock to manage, no tax saved, and a yearly compliance meter running. That is when the exit decision ripens.
II. Getting the house out: the dissolution path, the calendar, and life after the company
Dissolving the wrapper is a conveyancing operation, not a boardroom formality. The house must travel from the company’s patrimony into the owners’ personal patrimonies through a French notaire, with land registry publication, tax computations, and new paperwork to replace everything the company used to do. Done in the right order, the exit converts two tax returns into one, ends the May filing duty, and simplifies every future sale or succession. Done backwards, it can trigger duties nobody modeled or strand co-owners in a deadlock worse than the one they left.
A. Voting the dissolution, moving the title, and paying the exit duties before January 1
Start with the decision rule, which fits on an index card. Keep the company only if it manages something real: three siblings in three states sharing one house who need bylaws, voting rules, and a manager empowered to hire a roofer; parents gifting shares gradually to children while keeping control; a genuine rental business with employees or commercial premises. Dissolve it if the company exists only because someone once said it would avoid probate or save taxes, if the house is a pure vacation home, and if the annual French compliance bill exceeds any American benefit you can name with a number attached. Everything that follows assumes the answer is dissolve.
For a French SCI, dissolution begins with the partners’ vote. The Civil Code lists the ways a company ends, including, in its fourth item, “Par la dissolution anticipée décidée par les associés”, meaning early dissolution decided by the partners. The full provision reads: “La société prend fin : 1° Par l’expiration du temps pour lequel elle a été constituée, sauf prorogation effectuée conformément à l’article 1844-6 ; 2° Par la réalisation ou l’extinction de son objet ; 3° Par l’annulation du contrat de société ; 4° Par la dissolution anticipée décidée par les associés ; 5° Par la dissolution anticipée prononcée par le tribunal à la demande d’un associé pour justes motifs, notamment en cas d’inexécution de ses obligations par un associé, ou de mésentente entre associés paralysant le fonctionnement de la société ; 6° Par la dissolution anticipée prononcée par le tribunal dans le cas prévu à l’article 1844-5 ; 7° Par l’effet d’un jugement ordonnant la clôture de la liquidation judiciaire pour insuffisance d’actif ; 8° Pour toute autre cause prévue par les statuts.” That text is Article 1844-7 of the Civil Code. In practice the partners meet, vote the early dissolution, appoint a liquidator, settle the company’s debts, and distribute the house to the partners in proportion to their shares, or first consolidate all shares in one hand through buyouts and then dissolve a one-person company. Every French step passes through the notaire, because the transfer of French real estate from the company to the members must be recorded and published at the land registry, the service de publicité foncière. Registration is not optional: the tax code provides that “Doivent être enregistrés dans le délai d’un mois à compter de leur date : 1. Sous réserve des dispositions des articles 637 et 647 : 1° Les actes des notaires à l’exception de ceux visés à l’article 636 ; 2° (Abrogé) ; 3° Les actes portant transmission de propriété ou d’usufruit de biens immeubles”, meaning must be registered within one month of their date, subject to the stated exceptions, notarial deeds and deeds transferring ownership or usufruct of real estate. That text is Article 635 of the French General Tax Code. The notaire models the exit duties before anyone signs: registration duties vary with the chosen route, distribution on liquidation, sale by the company to its own members, or prior share buyouts, and the capital gains profile depends on the SCI’s tax regime. A transparent SCI that never elected for corporate tax generally produces gain at the partner level under the real estate capital gains rules with time-based relief growing over the years of ownership, while an SCI that elected for corporate tax can produce a different and heavier gain on exit. The modeling session with the notaire is the single most important meeting of the whole operation; never vote the dissolution before it.
For an American LLC holding the French house, the operation runs on two tracks. On the American track, the members vote to dissolve under the law of the state of formation, wind up any American liabilities, and distribute the LLC’s principal asset, the French house, to the members. On the French track, that distribution is a conveyance of French real estate that must pass through a French notaire with land registry publication and French registration duties, exactly as with an SCI exit. American advisors sometimes suggest simply abandoning the LLC by stopping filings in Delaware or Florida; that is a trap. An administratively dissolved LLC still appears on the French title, the French administration still sees a company holding the house on January 1, and the May filing duty survives until the French land registry shows natural persons as owners. Only a completed French publication moves the needle. And the calendar rule dominates everything: because the 3 percent tax and the IFI are both assessed on ownership as of January 1, a house still in the company on January 1 generates that year’s filing duties even if the dissolution closes in February. Families that decide to simplify should therefore aim to complete the French publication before December 31. Miss New Year’s Eve and you have bought yourself one more full year of company compliance. The same January 1 logic governs the American reporting tail: keep the state dissolution certificate, the French notarial deed of distribution, and the land registry receipt together, because the American accountant will need them to close the entity’s American filings and to establish the owners’ cost basis in the house going forward.
B. After the company: indivision rules, the written house agreement, and the estate reset
The morning after the dissolution, the former partners wake up as direct co-owners in indivision, the French regime of undivided co-ownership. This is the moment careless exits go wrong, because the SCI’s bylaws, voting majorities, and manager disappear overnight, and the default law takes over. The default rule has two faces. Its liberating face is the sentence every co-owner should know: “Nul ne peut être contraint à demeurer dans l’indivision et le partage peut toujours être provoqué, à moins qu’il n’y ait été sursis par jugement ou convention.” In English, no one can be forced to remain in undivided ownership, and partition can always be demanded, unless a court or an agreement has postponed it. That text is Article 815 of the Civil Code. Its disciplining face is that major decisions about a house in indivision require strong majorities, and any co-owner can force a sale through partition proceedings if no agreement holds the group together. Three siblings who dissolved the SCI to save compliance fees and then disagree about selling can end up in the court-ordered auction they created the SCI to avoid. The cure is to sign, at the same time as the dissolution, a written convention d’indivision, the co-ownership agreement that replaces the bylaws: who uses the house in which weeks, who pays the taxe foncière, the insurance, and the gardener, how repairs above a set amount are approved, whether any co-owner has a buyout priority, and for how long partition is postponed within the legal limits. A house that cost 15,000 euros a year in company compliance deserves a 2,000 euro agreement that keeps the peace for a decade.
The exit is also the moment to reset the estate plan, because moving from shares to direct ownership changes how French succession law sees the family. Gifts of SCI shares made over the years must be revalued in the forced heirship arithmetic as representing the house; the surviving spouse who managed the SCI may need a different protection, such as the legal housing rights and usufruct options explained in the guide for the American surviving spouse of a French house owner; and children from a first marriage regain a clearer path to challenge arrangements favoring a second spouse, the scenario detailed in the guide on first-marriage children clawing back their share of the French house. Concretely, the reset means four documents reviewed or signed around the dissolution: a French will covering the French house under the law chosen for the succession, beneficiary coordination for any insurance contracts, updated gift records with valuations, and, where heirs live in the United States and will one day face a French notaire from abroad, preparation of the European Certificate of Succession pathway described in the guide on the European Certificate of Succession for American heirs. Dissolve first and plan second is backwards; the notaire should model the succession effects in the same session as the exit duties. One final check closes the file: confirm with the French tax office that the dissolved entity is removed from the 3 percent tax rolls so no estimated bill issues the following May, confirm the mortgage lender re-registered any loan in the owners’ names where the SCI had borrowed, and confirm the American accountant closed the entity’s filings. When those confirmations arrive, the house is what it should have been all along: a home owned by people, taxed once, and transferable without unwrapping a company.
Conclusion
Companies that hold French vacation homes rarely earn their keep. The LLC adds a yearly May disclosure duty with a 3 percent sword hanging over it; the SCI adds share-fraction wealth tax math and American classification headaches while shielding no one from forced heirship. Dissolution through the partners’ vote, a modeled exit with the notaire, land registry publication before December 31, a written co-ownership agreement under the partition freedom of Article 815, and a coordinated estate reset convert a structure that taxed patience into a house that is simply owned. Keep the company only when it manages real people or a real business, file everything it requires, and revisit the question every few years. Otherwise, take the house back into your own names and let January 1 find nothing but owners on the title.