Your divorce judgment sets a monthly amount, you receive it more or less regularly, and then the real bills arrive: 1,800 euros for the private bilingual school in the 16th arrondissement, 2,400 euros for orthodontics, 900 euros for the ski trip with the school, 600 euros for glasses, football club fees, tutoring in English, the summer camp your child has attended for three years. Your ex answers that the pension alimentaire, the monthly child support paid by one parent to the other for the upkeep and education of the child, already covers everything, and refuses to pay a euro more. For English-speaking parents in France, this is one of the most frequent and most expensive misunderstandings in family law: the monthly payment and the sharing of large one-off costs obey different rules, and the difference between winning and losing before the juge aux affaires familiales, the family court judge who decides residence, visitation and financial contributions for children, often comes down to a single sentence in your judgment and a handful of receipts kept in the right order. This guide explains, entirely under French law, which costs your ex must share on top of monthly support, how to read the decisive clause in your existing decision, and the exact path to obtain and enforce a sharing order, including the Paris and Ile-de-France specifics.
I. Your monthly child support does not cover every bill: what French law calls extraordinary expenses
French law starts from a simple principle that surprises many expatriates: both parents must contribute to the upkeep and education of their children in proportion to their respective resources and to the needs of the child, whether they are married, divorced, separated without marriage, or whether the child is a minor or a young adult who cannot yet support himself. The Civil Code states it in these exact words: “Chacun des parents contribue à l’entretien et à l’éducation des enfants à proportion de ses ressources, de celles de l’autre parent, ainsi que des besoins de l’enfant.” (Each parent contributes to the upkeep and education of the children in proportion to his or her resources, those of the other parent, and the needs of the child.) Married parents carry the same duty from the day of the wedding, since “Les époux contractent ensemble, par le fait seul du mariage, l’obligation de nourrir, entretenir et élever leurs enfants.” (Spouses together contract, by the sole fact of marriage, the obligation to feed, maintain and bring up their children.) The monthly pension alimentaire is only one possible form of that contribution. The same article that organises support payments adds that “Cette pension peut en tout ou partie prendre la forme d’une prise en charge directe de frais exposés au profit de l’enfant ou être, en tout ou partie, servie sous forme d’un droit d’usage et d’habitation.” (This payment may wholly or partly take the form of direct payment of expenses incurred for the benefit of the child, or be wholly or partly provided as a right of use and habitation.) In practice, family judges combine the two layers: a fixed monthly sum for everyday life, plus a sharing proportion, often half and half, for the big foreseeable bills. The Cour de cassation, France’s supreme court for civil matters, confirmed the architecture of this system when it recalled, express reference to article 371-2 of the Civil Code, that “pour fixer la contribution à l’entretien et à l’éducation des enfants, le juge doit se placer au jour où il statue pour apprécier les ressources des parents” (to set the contribution to the upkeep and education of the children, the court must place itself on the day on which it rules to assess the parents’ resources). The amount is therefore never frozen by a scale or a circular: in another ruling the same court quashed a decision that had relied on a reference table, holding that “Qu’en fondant sa décision sur une table de référence, fût-elle annexée à une circulaire” (By basing its decision on a reference table, even one annexed to a circular), the appeal court had failed in its duty, since “à laquelle il incombait de fixer le montant de la contribution litigieuse en considération des seules facultés contributives des parents de l’enfant et des besoins de celui-ci” (it was for that court to set the disputed contribution having regard solely to the respective means of the child’s parents and to the needs of the child). For general background on how the monthly amount itself is calculated, changed and enforced, readers can consult the detailed guide to child support amounts, modification and enforcement in France for expatriate parents.
A. How to tell an ordinary cost already covered by the pension alimentaire from an extraordinary cost to share
No statute gives a closed list of frais exceptionnels, the French term for extraordinary expenses that fall outside the monthly budget and are shared separately between parents. The classification comes from judgments and from the wording of each decision, and it follows practical logic rather than labels. Ordinary costs are the recurring, predictable expenses of daily life that the monthly payment is deemed to cover: food, everyday clothing, housing, utilities, local transport passes, basic school supplies for a public school, routine pocket money. Extraordinary costs are the large, irregular or optional expenses that neither parent could absorb alone within the monthly sum: enrolment in a private or bilingual school, university tuition, tutoring and exam preparation courses, competitive exams, driving lessons, unreimbursed medical and dental care such as orthodontics, glasses, psychological follow-up or speech therapy, expensive sports equipment and club travel, music conservatory fees and instrument hire, school trips abroad, ski weeks, summer camps, a first laptop for secondary school, passport and visa costs for court-authorised travel. In the 7 October 2015 ruling mentioned above, the dispute concerned exactly this boundary: the lower courts had ordered that current upkeep costs be split 65% to the father and 35% to the mother and that frais exceptionnels such as examination enrolment fees follow the same split, and the Cour de cassation examined the case through article 371-2 rather than through any scale. The lesson for expatriate families is direct: do not argue about the English label, argue about the nature of the bill. A 45-euro visit to the general practitioner reimbursed by assurance maladie will almost never qualify; a 2,800-euro orthodontic treatment plan with 1,200 euros remaining after reimbursement almost always does. The same reasoning applies to schooling: supplies for the local public college belong to everyday life, while 1,500 to 4,000 euros a year for a private bilingual establishment in Paris, Boulogne-Billancourt or Saint-Germain-en-Laye belong to the extraordinary layer when both parents agreed to that schooling or when the judge ordered it. Travel and leisure follow the same test of foreseeability and magnitude: the weekly football training subscription is ordinary, the 950-euro tournament trip to Spain is extraordinary. Medical and paramedical costs deserve particular care because English-speaking parents often hold complementary insurance with different reimbursement levels: always compute the remainder after assurance maladie and mutuelle, keep both statements, and claim only the documented remainder. Judges in Paris and Versailles expect this arithmetic and reject global claims such as 5,000 euros of medical costs without a line-by-line breakdown. Three practical filters therefore decide the issue before any court filing: is the expense irregular or unusually large compared with the monthly payment, is it incurred for the benefit of the child rather than for the household, and can you prove both the payment and the remaining balance with invoices and reimbursement slips. If the answer to all three is yes, the bill belongs in the extraordinary category and your ex cannot defeat it by pointing to the monthly transfer alone. If one answer is no, fold the cost into a request to increase the monthly amount instead, because the judge will treat it as part of everyday needs assessed on the day of the ruling.
B. The one sentence in your judgment or agreement that decides who pays half
Once the nature of the expense is established, the outcome turns on the precise wording of your divorce judgment, your homologated agreement, your mutual-consent divorce deed, or your parental agreement given enforceable form. Many English-speaking parents discover too late that their decision says nothing beyond the monthly sum, and that silence benefits the debtor parent. The enforceable formulas used by the juge aux affaires familiales in Paris, Nanterre, Bobigny and Creteil typically read: one half of extraordinary medical costs not reimbursed, school enrolment fees in a private establishment, school trips, driving licence costs and extracurricular activities shall be shared between the parents upon presentation of receipts, sometimes with a requirement of prior written agreement for amounts above a threshold such as 300 or 500 euros. Each word matters. A clause that shares costs upon presentation of receipts allows you to enrol the child, pay, and claim reimbursement afterwards. A clause that requires prior written agreement before any commitment allows your ex to block the expense in advance by withholding consent, and spending first exposes you to bearing the full cost. A clause that lists only medical costs will not cover the bilingual school; a clause that lists school costs will not cover the conservatory unless the wording adds extracurricular activities. Read your decision today, in French, line by line, and identify four points: the sharing proportion, which is not always half and half and may be 60-40 or 70-30 where incomes differ sharply; the categories covered; whether prior agreement is required and above which amount; and the proof mechanism, usually registered letter or email with invoices and proof of payment within a stated time. If your judgment dates from before the separation of everyday and extraordinary costs became standard, or if it was rendered abroad and merely registered in France, it may contain no sharing clause at all. That gap is not fatal, but it means you must ask the family court for a supplementary order rather than sending invoices under a clause that does not exist. The separation of the parents, the statute recalls, “La séparation des parents est sans incidence sur les règles de dévolution de l’exercice de l’autorité parentale.” (The separation of the parents has no effect on the rules governing the devolution of the exercise of parental authority.), and joint autorite parentale, the set of rights and duties both parents hold to decide the child’s residence, schooling, health and travel, survives the breakdown. Because major decisions on schooling and health require both parents, the other provision of the same article gives you the procedural key when dialogue fails: “En cas de désaccord, le parent le plus diligent saisit le juge aux affaires familiales qui statue selon ce qu’exige l’intérêt de l’enfant.” (In case of disagreement, the more diligent parent seizes the family court judge, who rules according to what the best interests of the child require.) For adult children the same logic continues: “Le parent qui assume à titre principal la charge d’un enfant majeur qui ne peut lui-même subvenir à ses besoins peut demander à l’autre parent de lui verser une contribution à son entretien et à son éducation.” (The parent who principally assumes responsibility for an adult child who cannot support himself may ask the other parent to pay him a contribution to the child’s upkeep and education.) University tuition, student housing in Paris and preparatory class costs for a student aged 18 to 25 therefore belong to the same fight, with the added question of direct payment to the young adult. Parents who hold sole exercise of autorite parentale, ordered only where the best interests of the child so require under article 373-2-1 of the Civil Code, still face the contribution duty, because the financial obligation survives the withdrawal of decision-making power. The decisive practical step is therefore a short audit of your own papers before any confrontation: locate the judgment or agreement, highlight the sharing sentence, check whether your disputed bill falls inside its categories, and verify whether you needed written consent first. If the sentence covers your bill and you obtained or did not need prior agreement, your claim is a straightforward enforcement case. If the sentence is missing, too narrow, or imposes a prior-agreement condition you did not meet, your case becomes a modification case in which you ask the judge to add or widen the clause for the future and to settle the past on equitable grounds. Both routes go to the same judge, but they require different exhibits and different wording in the application, which is why misreading the clause is the single most expensive mistake expatriate parents make in this field.
II. How to make your ex pay half in France: proof, family court and enforcement
French family judges do not decide extraordinary expenses on principle or on fairness in the abstract; they decide on dated documents, on proof that the other parent knew and could object, and on a precise calculation of each parent’s means on the day of the hearing. The official public guidance on the mechanics of child support, its amount and its revision is published by the administration on service-public.fr: pension alimentaire, montant et revision, and the dedicated Caf portal explains the collection and intermediation remedies at pension-alimentaire.caf.fr portal (aide au recouvrement) and pension-alimentaire.caf.fr portal (intermediation financiere). The remainder of this part translates that framework into the concrete file an English-speaking parent must assemble, the court that will hear the case in Paris and the Ile-de-France, and the enforcement tools that work when the debtor still refuses after being ordered to pay. Two preliminary warnings shape everything that follows. First, limitation and promptness matter: the longer you pay alone without protest, the harder it becomes to argue that the expense was urgent or that the other parent tacitly accepted it, and some judges treat prolonged silence as acquiescence to the status quo. Second, unilateral decisions on schooling, major medical treatment or expensive activities weaken your position even where the expense itself is legitimate, because joint autorite parentale requires joint decision-making and the judge may reduce your reimbursement to punish the method rather than the merits. Write before you spend wherever possible, spend only after a documented refusal or a genuine emergency, and keep every receipt, bank statement and reimbursement slip from the first euro.
A. How to build a file the juge aux affaires familiales accepts, and where to file in Paris and Ile-de-France
Your application to the juge aux affaires familiales must do three things at once: prove the expense, prove the other parent’s knowledge or refusal, and prove the sharing key. The expense bundle starts with the contract or enrolment confirmation from the school, clinic, club or travel organiser, the invoice in your name or the child’s name, your bank transfer or card statement showing payment, and the reimbursement statements from assurance maladie and your mutuelle showing the exact remainder. For a 2,400-euro orthodontic plan, present the practitioner’s estimate, each invoice as treatment progresses, both reimbursement slips, and a one-page table totalling paid, reimbursed and remaining sums with dates. For a bilingual school, add the enrolment contract, the annual invoice, proof of payment per term, and evidence that the schooling choice was joint or ordered: the relevant passage of the divorce judgment, exchanged emails accepting the school, or the child’s continuous attendance over several years. The knowledge bundle proves that your ex was informed before or immediately after the commitment: a registered letter or an email with acknowledgement requesting written agreement, setting a reasonable deadline of fifteen days, describing the expense, the provider, the total, the requested share and the payment deadline, with the invoices attached. If your existing decision requires prior agreement, this letter is the condition of your right; if it requires only presentation of receipts, the letter still proves good faith and defeats the argument of surprise. Keep the refusal or the silence: a negative reply, an unread registered letter slip, or an unanswered email after the deadline all count. The means bundle follows the rule recalled by the Cour de cassation that resources are assessed on the day of the ruling: your last three pay slips, your last tax notice, your rent or mortgage statement, your other support obligations, and whatever you can document about your ex’s situation, including their salary where known, their new household composition and any visible change such as a new property or vehicle. Ask the judge for three orders in the alternative: primarily, an order that the debtor reimburse the documented arrears with a schedule and indexation; additionally, a clarified sharing clause for the future with categories, proportion, prior-agreement threshold and proof mechanism; and in the alternative, an adjustment of the monthly amount if the judge reclassifies some costs as ordinary. Jurisdiction in Paris and the Ile-de-France follows the child’s habitual residence: if the child lives in Paris, file at the tribunal judiciaire de Paris, family chamber, Porte de Clichy; if the child lives in Boulogne-Billancourt or Nanterre, at Nanterre; in Seine-Saint-Denis, at Bobigny; in Val-de-Marne, at Creteil; in Essonne, at Evry; in Yvelines, at Versailles; in Seine-et-Marne, at Meaux or Melun; in Val-d’Oise, at Pontoise. Representation by an avocat, a lawyer admitted to a French bar who alone can file and plead, is mandatory before the family court in contentious proceedings, and your application must be served by a commissaire de justice, the sworn officer formerly called huissier who serves process and enforces judgments. Allow three to six months for a decision in the Paris region, longer if a social inquiry or an expert appraisal of needs is ordered, and request provisional measures where the school threatens exclusion for non-payment or treatment is about to stop: the judge can order an advance on the share within weeks. For families whose internal organisation and hearings involve French administrative and judicial venues, practical guidance on Paris family venues is also summarised by the Paris family law team at family lawyers in Paris: divorce, children, maintenance and parental authority. At the hearing, speak the language of the file, not the language of the conflict: total claimed, remainder after reimbursement, clause relied upon, date of the request for agreement, date of refusal, proportion requested. Judges distrust round figures, undated tables and claims mixing ordinary pocket money with extraordinary bills; they reward chronological bundles where each invoice has its payment proof and its reimbursement slip. Where the debtor argues inability to pay, answer with the assessment-day rule and with concrete elements rather than assertions: the debtor’s declared income, the absence of documented charges, the continuity of their lifestyle. Where the debtor argues the expense was unnecessary, answer with the child’s interests: medical necessity certificates, school reports showing progress in the bilingual section, the club’s attestation of the child’s level, the travel organiser’s educational programme. The order you obtain should state the principal, the starting date, indexation on the INSEE consumer index, the future sharing proportion and its documentary trigger, so that next year’s bills require only an email with attachments rather than a new lawsuit.
B. How to recover the arrears when your ex still refuses: Caf, seizure and criminal complaint
A sharing order is only useful if it is collected, and French law gives the creditor parent a graduated ladder that English-speaking residents often discover late. The first rung is the Agence de recouvrement et d’intermediation des pensions alimentaires, known as Aripa, operated through the Caisse d’allocations familiales (Caf): where the monthly support itself is unpaid, Aripa can collect it, advance it under conditions, and implement systematic financial intermediation so that the debtor pays the Caf which forwards the sum to you, a mechanism now embedded in article 373-2-2 of the Civil Code whose second and third paragraphs organise the default use of the family benefits fund as paying agent. Extraordinary-expense arrears fixed by a judgment follow the same enforceable-title logic: once the judge has quantified them, the decision is an enforceable title that a commissaire de justice can execute by attachment of earnings, bank seizure or seizure of movable property, in addition to Aripa’s route for the monthly component. The second rung is civil enforcement with interest and costs: the bailiff’s payment order adds statutory interest from the formal demand, enforcement costs fall on the debtor where the enforcement succeeds, and repeated non-payment supports a request to increase guarantees, including a bank transfer order or a direct payment from the employer. The third rung is criminal law, which many debtors underestimate until the police summons arrives. The Penal Code punishes the complete failure to pay a family support obligation for more than two months: “en demeurant plus de deux mois sans s’acquitter intégralement de cette obligation, est puni de deux ans d’emprisonnement et de 15 000 euros d’amende.” (by remaining for more than two months without fully discharging that obligation, is punished by two years’ imprisonment and a 15,000 euro fine.) The criminal chamber of the Cour de cassation applies this offence strictly: in its ruling of 19 January 2022, no. 20-84.287, the court examined a case in which “le juge aux affaires familiales a fixé la contribution de M. [X] à l’entretien et à l’éducation des enfants à la somme mensuelle globale de 800 euros” (the family court judge had set the contribution of Mr X to the upkeep and education of the children at the overall monthly sum of 800 euros), and the debtor’s repeated defaults led to prosecution for abandon de famille, the criminal offence of family abandonment through non-payment, with custodial sentence and revocation of a prior suspended sentence. A criminal complaint does not replace civil enforcement but it changes the negotiation: file it with the quantified judgment, the formal demand, proof of two months of total or partial default, and evidence that the debtor could pay, and the prosecutor can summon, mediate or prosecute while your civil enforcement continues. Practical sequencing therefore runs as follows for a Paris-based creditor: formal demand by registered letter giving fifteen days; application to the family judge for quantification and a clarified future clause; service of the judgment; immediate instruction of a commissaire de justice for seizure alongside an Aripa file for the monthly part; and, after two months of continued default with means, a complaint for abandon de famille with the full documentary bundle. Throughout, keep paying your own share of the child’s costs and never suspend visitation or use the child as leverage, because judges punish retaliation and debtors invoke it. Keep every new invoice in the same format as the court-approved table so that next year’s enforcement is a copy-and-paste exercise. And update the file when circumstances change on either side, since the assessment-day rule cuts both ways: a genuine loss of income can reduce the share, while a salary increase, an inheritance or a new partner sharing housing costs can justify raising it. The families who recover fastest are not those who write the angriest letters but those whose bundle lets the judge, the Caf agent, the bailiff and if needed the prosecutor see within five minutes what was spent, what was reimbursed, what was requested, what was refused, and what remains due.
Conclusion
In France, the monthly pension alimentaire pays for everyday life, while large one-off costs for schooling, health, activities and travel are shared separately whenever your judgment provides for it and the judge orders it. Identify whether each bill is ordinary or extraordinary, read the sharing sentence in your decision and its prior-agreement condition, write to your ex with invoices and a deadline before spending wherever possible, and ask the juge aux affaires familiales to quantify the arrears and to write a clear clause for the future. Once ordered, collect through the Caf and Aripa, through seizure by a commissaire de justice, and after two months of default through a complaint for abandon de famille. Assembled in that order, with dated proof and a precise calculation of the remainder after reimbursement, an extraordinary-expenses file is one of the strongest cases an expatriate parent can bring before a French family court.