KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
France protests: are police grenades legal against school demonstrators? Rules, court rulings and compensation

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Hassan Kohen, personal injury lawyer in Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

France protests: are police grenades legal against school demonstrators? Rules, court rulings and compensation

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 5 October 2026, as thousands of French secondary-school pupils blocked their schools for a third week, two teenagers were gravely injured on the margins of the protests. Outside a high school in Lens, in northern France, a 15-year-old boy had his hand blown off; according to Le Monde, citing a police union source, the boy appears to have picked up a sting-ball grenade fired by riot police and it exploded in his hand, while internal investigations have been opened into several instances of alleged police brutality (Le Monde with AFP on the Lens injury and the investigations). A few days earlier in Tours, a 16-year-old was blinded in one eye by what was reported as a defence-ball launcher round, and his family has filed a complaint (Le Parisien on the Tours complaint). With a national day of protests called for Tuesday 6 October, more than 400 of France’s 3,700 lycées closed, and over 5,000 arrests since the movement began on 17 September at a school in Créteil, British readers are asking a simple question: what does French law actually allow the police to do when a demonstration turns tense, and what happens when a weapon injures someone? This article answers from French statutes and court rulings, not from rumour. It starts from the reported facts, sets out the rules on dispersing crowds and firing weapons, then explains the criminal complaint route and how the State can be ordered to pay compensation. No finding has yet been made about Lens or Tours: investigations are under way, and everyone involved is presumed innocent.

I. What French law allows the police to do when a school demonstration turns tense

A. A crowd can only be dispersed after two warnings, and force has strict limits

French law starts with a definition. Article 431-3 of the Criminal Code (Code pénal) defines an attroupement, or unlawful assembly, as any gathering on the public highway or in a public place that is likely to disturb public order, and sends readers to Article L. 211-9 of the Internal Security Code (Code de la sécurité intérieure) for the dispersal procedure (Article 431-3, Code pénal, in force on 6 October 2026). Pupils standing outside their school therefore cannot lawfully be scattered by force on the spot without this procedure.

Article L. 211-9 of the Internal Security Code allows an unlawful assembly to be dispersed by the public force only after two orders to disperse (sommations de se disperser) have gone unheeded (Article L. 211-9, Code de la sécurité intérieure, in force on 6 October 2026). The orders must be given by designated officials wearing the insignia of their office: the State representative in the department (or the police prefect in Paris), the mayor outside Paris, or the judicial police officer in charge of public safety. The law adds an exception that matters for the current events: officers called to disperse an assembly may use force without the prior warnings if violence is used against them or if they cannot otherwise hold the ground they occupy. In Lens, officials said a large group of protesters had been throwing objects at the police when riot officers intervened; whether that threshold was met on the day is exactly what the investigation must establish, and no conclusion can be drawn before it reports. A decree in the Conseil d’Etat (Conseil d’État) form sets the practical details, including the insignia and the conditions for using firearms to keep order. Two practical points follow for the school movement. First, the warnings must be traceable: precisely because more than 400 lycées were fully or partly closed on 5 October and crowds gathered day after day outside the same gates, investigators will check which authority ordered each dispersal, whether the officers wore the required insignia, and whether the orders to disperse were actually audible to the pupils at the back of the crowd. Second, the exception for direct force is read narrowly by the courts: throwing objects can qualify as violence against the officers, but the response must still match the danger as it stood at that moment, and the presence of many minors in the crowd, repeatedly flagged by the Human Rights League, weighs in the proportionality assessment without creating a separate legal regime.

B. Firing a weapon requires absolute necessity and strict proportionality, at the very moment of the threat

Dispersing a crowd is one thing; firing a weapon is another, and French law treats it as an exception governed by Article L. 435-1 of the Internal Security Code. Officers in uniform may use their weapons, beyond the Article L. 211-9 cases, only in a case of absolute necessity (absolue nécessité) and in a strictly proportionate manner, in the listed situations opening with attacks on life or physical integrity (Article L. 435-1, Code de la sécurité intérieure, in force on 6 October 2026). The article then lists five closed cases, the first being when attacks on life or physical integrity are directed at the officers or others, or when armed persons threaten their lives or physical integrity. The weapons seen in demonstration policing include defence-ball launchers (lanceurs de balles de défense, often called LBDs, which fire rubber projectiles), sting-ball and disencirclement hand grenades (grenades à balles de défense, grenades à main de désencerclement, known as GMDs), and tear-gas grenades. Each is classed as an intermediate weapon, but the courts repeat that this label changes nothing about the test: necessity must be absolute and proportionality strict. Every authorised weapon comes with written employment rules, set by the administration, on matters such as minimum distances, aiming zones and prior warnings, and judges treat those rules as the concrete yardstick. In the February 2025 ruling the court verified the firing distance metre by metre, 36.35 metres against a 40-metre ceiling, which shows how fact-sensitive the review is. A sting-ball or disencirclement grenade adds a further question the Lens investigation will have to answer: these devices project danger in every direction once thrown or dropped, so the court will examine not only the decision to fire but where the device landed, who could pick it up, and whether firing it into a crowd of schoolchildren could ever satisfy strict proportionality.

The Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation) gave this test teeth in a ruling on a flash-ball eye injury from 2016, reviewed on 6 October 2021 (appeal no. 21-84.295, Cass. crim., 6 October 2021, no. 21-84.295). After recalling Article L. 435-1, the Criminal Chamber held that for the shot to be justified it must be fired at the very time when the attacks are carried out or the threats uttered against the officers or others. A shot fired before a threat materialises or after it has passed cannot satisfy the statute, even if the order given was to arrest troublemakers. In that case the officer, who denied that the victim had been among the most violent supporters, was sent for trial before the assize court (cour d’assises). The lesson for Lens and Tours is direct: investigators will reconstruct second by second what the officers faced when each round was fired, and any gap between the threat and the shot weakens the legal cover.

The criminal cover itself comes from Article 122-4 of the Criminal Code, which removes criminal liability from a person who performs an act prescribed or authorised by legislation or regulations, and likewise from a person acting on the orders of lawful authority unless the act is manifestly unlawful (Article 122-4, Code pénal, in force on 6 October 2026). The article adds that a person who performs an act ordered by lawful authority is likewise not liable, unless the act is manifestly unlawful. So an officer who fires within Articles L. 211-9 and L. 435-1 commits a justified act and bears no criminal liability; an officer who fires outside them faces ordinary criminal law, with no shield from the uniform. Everything therefore turns on the facts: warnings given or not, violence suffered or not, distance, aiming point, and whether a less harmful option existed.

II. When a police weapon injures a demonstrator: complaint, trial and compensation

A. The criminal path: file a complaint, join as civil party, and let the courts test necessity

The Tours family did what French procedure expects first: it filed a complaint (plainte). Article 15-3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Code de procédure pénale) obliges judicial police officers and agents to take complaints from victims of criminal offences, even at a station with no territorial jurisdiction, which then forwards the file (Article 15-3, Code de procédure pénale, in force on 6 October 2026). Every complaint is recorded in an official report and the victim immediately receives a receipt (récépissé) stating the limitation periods and the right to restart them through a complaint with civil-party joinder. For a minor, the parents or legal representatives file and sign; medical evidence should be secured at once, ideally through a forensic medical unit (unité médico-judiciaire), with the total incapacity for work (incapacité totale de travail, known as ITT) assessed in days, because the criminal classification depends on it. Photographs, torn clothing, witness names and any video should be kept aside from social media, where posting can backfire. Two parallel referrals cost nothing and often help: a report to the police inspectorate (Inspection générale de la Police nationale, the IGPN), which the prosecutor in Lens tasked with establishing the facts, and a referral to the Defender of Rights (Défenseur des droits), the independent authority that examines the conduct of security forces and can issue opinions and recommendations. For minors, every step is taken through the parents or legal representatives, who file the complaint, join as civil parties and instruct counsel in the child’s name, while any compensation ultimately belongs to the child and is protected accordingly.

The likely criminal qualifications turn on the injury. Article 222-11 of the Criminal Code punishes violence resulting in total incapacity for work (ITT) of more than eight days with three years of imprisonment and a 45,000 euro fine (Article 222-11, Code pénal, in force on 6 October 2026). A lost hand or a lost eye plainly exceeds that threshold and can amount to mutilation or permanent infirmity, the most serious bodily-injury counts. Article 222-12 raises the penalty to five years and 75,000 euros where the Article 222-11 offence is committed with aggravating circumstances, including where the victim is a child under fifteen (Article 222-12, Code pénal, in force on 6 October 2026). Readers should note the boundary precisely: this aggravator covers victims under fifteen, so it does not automatically apply to a 15- or 16-year-old; the prosecutor will instead weigh the full facts, including the victim’s minority. Where the shooter is identified as a police officer, the same provisions apply in principle, with Article 122-4 as the officer’s justification defence, exactly as tested in the two rulings below.

If the prosecutor closes the file without charges (classement sans suite), the victim is not left without a remedy. Article 85 of the Code of Criminal Procedure lets any person claiming harm from a felony or misdemeanour join the proceedings as a civil party (constitution de partie civile) before the investigating judge by filing a complaint (Article 85, Code de procédure pénale, in force on 6 October 2026). Admissibility requires either a notice that the prosecutor will not prosecute, or three months elapsed since the complaint, and the investigating judge (juge d’instruction) must then investigate. This civil-party complaint (plainte avec constitution de partie civile) is the standard lever in alleged police-violence cases when the first complaint stalls. Readers looking for the victim-focused companion to this guide, from the medical evidence to the first steps after the injury, can turn to our account of what to do when hurt at a France protest, between criminal complaint and compensation.

Two recent rulings show how judges apply these rules to demonstration weapons. In the first, a man lost the sight in his left eye at the margins of a 2016 demonstration after being hit by a defence-ball launcher projectile; an investigation for wilful violence causing mutilation by a holder of public authority was opened, and the investigating judge issued a dismissal (non-lieu) confirmed on appeal. On 5 February 2025 the Criminal Chamber rejected the victim’s appeal (appeal no. 23-81.356, Cass. crim., 5 February 2025, no. 23-81.356). The judges had found that the shot came after the dispersal orders and while demonstrators were using prohibited devices, that incendiary rockets fired from the victim’s bank of the river had set fire to an awning above the officers, and that the officer had acted in absolute necessity to stop the rocket fire. They added that a defence-ball launcher, not being a lethal weapon, made the response a proportionate use of force against a man firing incendiary rockets, that the round was fired at 36.35 metres where use was permitted up to 40 metres, and that the masked victim standing near the rocket firer could have caused confusion. The Court of Cassation approved the reasoning and the Article 122-4 justification. The contrast with the 2021 flash-ball ruling is instructive: justification succeeds only where contemporaneous necessity and proportionality are proved step by step, and fails where the victim is not shown to have been part of the violent group. Neither outcome prejudges Lens or Tours, where the facts are still being gathered.

B. Holding the State liable and getting compensated: the civil and administrative route

A criminal case punishes; it is the liability action that pays for the injury, and it can run in parallel. The civil foundation is Article 1240 of the Civil Code (Code civil), the general fault-based liability rule obliging whoever causes damage to another through fault to make reparation (Article 1240, Code civil, in force on 6 October 2026). Where the author is a police officer acting in service, the victim sues the State, represented before the ordinary courts by the State Judicial Officer (Agent judiciaire de l’Etat), or brings the claim before the administrative courts where the management of a public service is at stake. A recent appellate ruling shows this route working for a grenade injury at a demonstration. After a disencirclement hand grenade carried by an officer exploded during an arrest and wounded a demonstrator, the trial court found the State had committed a serious fault by failing to supply enough grenade pouches, grounding liability on Article L. 141-1 of the Code of Judicial Organisation, under which the State must make good damage caused by defective functioning of the public justice service, a liability incurred only through serious fault (faute lourde) or denial of justice (Article L. 141-1, Code de l’organisation judiciaire, in force on 6 October 2026). The trial judges had split responsibility 50-50 with the victim; on 22 January 2025 the Toulouse Court of Appeal set that sharing aside and held the State solely liable for all of the harm suffered (CA Toulouse, 1st Chamber section 1, 22 January 2025, RG no. 22/04518, full text of the ruling). The court also ordered a medical assessment (expertise) of the victim before fixing the sums, which is the normal sequence: liability first, quantification after examination.

In practice, a family in this position should move on three tracks at once. First, preserve proof: emergency records, the forensic medical certificate with the ITT in days, photographs of the injuries, names of witnesses, and the complaint receipt, since compensation for a lost hand or a lost eye will later be itemised head by head (medical costs, assistance by a third party, loss of earnings and school disruption, pain and suffering, permanent functional deficit, and aesthetic harm). Second, ask the court for an advance: once liability looks established, the judge can order an expert examination and grant a provision (an interim payment) so the family does not wait years for treatment and adaptation costs. Third, choose the forum with advice: the administrative court (tribunal administratif) for a claim grounded in the organisation of the policing operation, or the judicial court against the Agent judiciaire de l’Etat, as in Toulouse. For facts in Paris, that means the Paris Administrative Court or the Paris Judicial Court; the complaint itself can be filed at any station, and a British family whose child was injured while on a school exchange in France follows exactly the same tracks, with the addition of notifying the travel insurer and keeping every receipt for accommodation and transport caused by the hospital stay. A parallel referral to the Defender of Rights (Défenseur des droits), the independent authority that investigates alleged misconduct by security forces, and to the police inspectorate (IGPN) costs nothing and creates additional records, while the Human Rights League’s warning that restraint orders were missing when facing children shows why outside scrutiny matters here. None of this requires waiting for the criminal case to end: the civil judge rules on compensation even while the investigation continues, and a dismissal in the criminal file does not extinguish the State’s liability, which follows its own test.

Conclusion

The October 2026 school protests have put a stark legal question before the public: French police may disperse an unlawful assembly only after two warnings, and may fire their weapons only in absolute necessity and with strict proportionality, at the very moment of the threat, as Articles L. 211-9 and L. 435-1 of the Internal Security Code and the Court of Cassation’s rulings require. When those limits are respected, Article 122-4 of the Criminal Code shields the officer, as the February 2025 defence-ball launcher ruling confirms; when they are not, the officer faces trial and the victim can force an investigation through a civil-party complaint under Article 85 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Either way, the State itself can be ordered to pay for the harm, as the Toulouse grenade ruling of January 2025 demonstrates, with medical assessment and interim payments along the way. For the boys of Lens and Tours, everything now depends on the investigations under way, which alone will say which rounds were fired, by whom, and in what circumstances. The framework above is what those findings will be measured against. Families who believe a child was hurt by a police weapon should file a complaint at once, keep every medical document, and take advice early on choosing between the criminal and the compensation routes, since each follows its own timetable and its own test.

📄 Official circular