You bought a flat together in Paris, or you rent one near your children’s school, and now you are divorcing. One of you wants to stay. The other has already left, or has been told to leave, and keeps paying half the mortgage while sleeping somewhere else. The questions that arrive first are never abstract. Who is allowed to stay in the family home while the divorce runs its course. Whether that stay is free or paid. Who pays the mortgage, the building charges, the property tax and the insurance in the meantime. And what happens years later, when the notary handling the final sharing of the property tells the spouse who stayed that an occupation indemnity is owed to the other. This guide answers those four questions for English-speaking couples divorcing in France. In French procedure, the family judge is the juge aux affaires familiales, usually shortened to JAF. The interim use of the home is the jouissance du logement familial. The payment for exclusive use after the divorce is the indemnite d’occupation. The maintenance duty between spouses while still married is the devoir de secours. Once you understand how these three tools fit together, the Paris practice becomes predictable, and the file you build from day one decides whether you pay, or recover, tens of thousands of euros at the final sharing.
I. Who stays in the French family home while the divorce is pending and who pays for it
French divorce procedure separates two periods. During the proceedings, the marriage still exists, the duty of support still exists, and the judge organises a temporary life. After the divorce becomes final, the marriage is over, the support duty ends, and the property rules of undivided ownership take over. The order made at the start of the case therefore shapes the money for years. An expat who asks only for the home, without asking in the same breath whether its use is free or paid and who pays the loan, wins the roof and loses the accounts.
A. How to ask the family judge for the Paris home during a French divorce
A judicial divorce in France opens with a summons, followed by an early hearing at which the judge takes the measures needed to organise the life of the spouses and the children from the filing of the petition until the judgment becomes final. The Code states this in direct terms: Article 254 of the Civil Code provides that “Le juge tient, dès le début de la procédure, sauf si les parties ou la partie seule constituée y renoncent, une audience à l’issue de laquelle il prend les mesures nécessaires pour assurer l’existence des époux et des enfants de l’introduction de la demande en divorce à la date à laquelle le jugement passe en force de chose jugée, en considération des accords éventuels des époux” (the judge holds, from the start of the proceedings, unless waiver, a hearing after which he takes the measures needed to ensure the spouses and children can live from filing until the judgment becomes final, in light of any agreements). The official service-public.fr page for judicial divorce describes the same step in plain language: the summons may contain requests for interim measures, meaning the temporary organisation for property and children during the proceedings, and the early orientation hearing puts those measures in place, for example the attribution of the home, with the possibility to ask the preparation judge to change them later if a new fact occurs. See the service-public.fr page on judicial divorce procedure.
In practice before the Tribunal judiciaire de Paris, the request is made in the summons or in written submissions for the orientation hearing, with one paragraph per measure sought. The spouse who wants the flat asks for three things together: exclusive use of the home and the household furniture, a finding that this use is free or paid with a proposed monthly figure, and the provisional sharing of the housing costs, meaning the mortgage instalments, the building charges, the insurance and the taxes. The judge can also order the handover of clothes and personal objects, set interim maintenance between spouses and for the children, designate which spouse provisionally pays debts, grant advances on liquidation rights if needed, appoint an expert for valuation and appoint a notary to prepare the liquidation of the matrimonial property regime. The margins are wide, and the judge decides in light of any agreements, the children’s residence, each spouse’s housing options, proximity to work and school, and allegations of violence. When violence is alleged, the home question is often decided together with a protection order, and the violent spouse is the one who leaves, even if he or she owns the flat.
Ownership and tenancy follow different tracks once the order is made, and expats often confuse them. If the flat is rented, the lease continues and the judge attributes the right to the lease to one spouse for the duration of the proceedings, with the rent remaining due to the landlord and the question of reimbursement between spouses settled later. If the flat is owned jointly, whether under the default community regime or in undivided ownership after a separation of property, the judge attributes its use to one spouse and that attribution is enforceable against the other, but it binds third parties, including buyers and creditors, only once the divorce formalities are published. The Code fixes that publicity rule bluntly: Article 262 of the Civil Code states that “La convention ou le jugement de divorce est opposable aux tiers, en ce qui concerne les biens des époux, à partir du jour où les formalités de mention en marge prescrites par les règles de l’état civil ont été accomplies” (the divorce agreement or judgment binds third parties as to property only once the civil-status marginal notation has been completed). Until that date, the bank, the co-ownership manager and the tax office continue to treat both spouses as liable according to their own contracts. A Paris order that says the wife stays and the husband pays the loan does not release the wife vis-a-vis the bank, and it does not release the husband either. It only creates a claim between spouses that the notary settles at the end.
The order is not frozen. If a new fact occurs, loss of a job, birth of a child from another relationship, departure of the children to study, proven non-payment of the loan, or a move that makes the flat oversized, either spouse can ask the preparation judge to change or delete an interim measure. In Paris, that request is made by motion with updated pay slips, bank statements, proof of rent for the new dwelling and, where children are concerned, school certificates. The spouse who simply leaves the flat without asking for anything should record the date of departure in writing, return one set of keys against receipt, redirect insurance and energy contracts, and keep paying what the order requires, because leaving without a decision changes neither the right to return nor the money owed. The spouse who stays should keep every receipt from the first month, because the final account will ask for them line by line.
B. Free or paid use while still married: the one line that fixes money for years
The decisive line in the interim order is the one that says whether the use is free or paid. The Code gives the judge the choice in open terms. Article 255 of the Civil Code provides that “Attribuer à l’un d’eux la jouissance du logement et du mobilier du ménage ou partager entre eux cette jouissance, en précisant son caractère gratuit ou non et, le cas échéant, en constatant l’accord des époux sur le montant d’une indemnité d’occupation” (attributing to one spouse the use of the dwelling and furniture or sharing it, stating whether it is free or paid and, where relevant, recording agreement on an occupation indemnity). The same article allows the judge, in paragraph 6, to “Fixer la pension alimentaire et la provision pour frais d’instance que l’un des époux devra verser à son conjoint, désigner celui ou ceux des époux qui devront assurer le règlement provisoire de tout ou partie des dettes” (fixing the maintenance and costs advance one spouse pays the other, and designating who provisionally pays debts). Read together, these two paragraphs explain the Paris routine. The judge attributes the flat to the parent with whom the children principally live, often the mother in contested cases but increasingly either parent where alternating residence is ordered, then balances the money through maintenance, payment of debts and the free or paid character of the use.
While the marriage lasts, free use is usually explained as performance of the support duty between spouses. The husband or wife who earns more lets the other live in the home without charge, and that advantage counts as part of interim support. It can be combined with a monthly sum, or it can replace it where the value of the roof roughly equals the maintenance that would otherwise be due. The judge calibrates by comparing incomes, rents in the same arrondissement, the remaining loan, and the children’s needs. A free flat in the 16th arrondissement is not the same as a free studio in Saint-Denis, and Paris orders reflect that by adjusting the cash maintenance down when the roof is valuable. The trap for expats is to read free use as a gift that continues after the divorce. It does not. The support duty ends with the divorce, and the final judgment or the later sharing converts the same roof into a debt.
The Cour de cassation drew that boundary in a Paris case that every Paris practitioner now cites. A wife had been granted free use of the former family home by a non-conciliation order of the Paris family judge dated 27 November 2013, expressly as performance of the support duty, and she later claimed a compensatory allowance on divorce. The court of appeal rejected the claim on the ground that she had enjoyed the free home for nearly seven years. The Cour de cassation quashed that reasoning. In its decision Cass. 1st civ., 13 April 2022, No. 20-22.807, the Court held that the appeal court, “qui a pris en considération l’avantage constitué par la jouissance gratuite du domicile conjugal accordée à l’épouse au titre du devoir de secours pour apprécier l’existence d’une disparité créée par le divorce dans les conditions de vie respectives des époux, a violé les textes susvisés” (which took into account free use granted as support when assessing disparity, thereby violating those provisions). The provisions violated were Article 270 of the Civil Code, under which “Le divorce met fin au devoir de secours entre époux. L’un des époux peut être tenu de verser à l’autre une prestation destinée à compenser, autant qu’il est possible, la disparité que la rupture du mariage crée dans les conditions de vie respectives” (divorce ends support; compensation for disparity may be ordered as a lump sum, refusable on fairness grounds), and Article 271 of the Civil Code, under which “La prestation compensatoire est fixée selon les besoins de l’époux à qui elle est versée et les ressources de l’autre en tenant compte de la situation au moment du divorce et de l’évolution de celle-ci dans un avenir prévisible” (payment fixed by needs and resources at divorce date plus foreseeable change). For an expat reader, the lesson is concrete. The free roof you enjoyed for years while still married cannot be used to deny you a compensatory allowance, because that roof belonged to the marriage that is ending. By the same logic, the spouse who paid the loan alone for years while the other lived there for free does not lose the right to claim that money back in the sharing. Each advantage is priced in its own period, with its own rules.
Two practical consequences follow for the wording to seek in Paris. First, if you are the spouse who stays, ask for free use expressly linked to the support duty and to the children’s residence, with a monthly maintenance figure that reflects the real Paris rent you would otherwise pay, and keep evidence that you could not rehouse yourself nearby without harming the children’s schooling. If the judge grants free use, that order protects you against a claim for back occupation payments for the period before the divorce. Second, if you are the spouse who leaves, never accept a free-use clause without a time limit tied to the divorce becoming final, a provisional allocation of the loan and charges, and a recorded monthly rental value for the flat. Without that figure, the later fight over the indemnity starts from zero and costs an expert appraisal. With it, the later sharing applies the figure the judge already noted, adjusted for market movement. In both cases, ask the judge to state who pays the mortgage instalments, the co-ownership charges, the home insurance and the property tax pending the divorce, because silence on these points is the most expensive sentence in the file.
II. Who pays what after the order: mortgage, charges and the occupation indemnity counted at the final sharing
Once the divorce is final, the vocabulary changes. There is no more free use grounded in marriage. There is an undivided owner who uses the whole of a jointly owned flat alone, and who therefore owes the other owners the price of that exclusive use. The notary who liquidates the regime calls that price the occupation indemnity, deducts it from the occupant’s share, and adds it to the other’s. Expats who discover this at the notary’s office, three years after the divorce, feel ambushed. The file that avoids the ambush is built during the divorce, not after it.
A. How to calculate, prove and recover the occupation indemnity when your ex lives in the joint home
The legal basis is short and applies to every undivided owner, married or not. Article 815-9 of the Civil Code provides that “Chaque indivisaire peut user et jouir des biens indivis conformément à leur destination, dans la mesure compatible avec le droit des autres indivisaires et avec l’effet des actes régulièrement passés au cours de l’indivision. A défaut d’accord entre les intéressés, l’exercice de ce droit est réglé, à titre provisoire, par le président du tribunal. L’indivisaire qui use ou jouit privativement de la chose indivise est, sauf convention contraire, redevable d’une indemnité” (each co-owner may use the property compatibly with others’ rights; private exclusive use triggers an indemnity unless agreed otherwise). Three conditions therefore open the right to payment: joint ownership, exclusive private use by one owner, and no agreement to the contrary providing for free use after the divorce. Where the divorce judgment or a later agreement grants free use beyond the divorce, no indemnity runs for that period. Where it is silent, the indemnity runs.
The starting point most Paris courts apply is the date on which the divorce becomes final, meaning the date the judgment acquires the force of final judgment, or for a consent-based divorce by private deed countersigned by lawyers, the date it acquires enforceability. The Code fixes dissolution in those terms: Article 260 of the Civil Code states that “Le mariage est dissous : 1° Par la convention de divorce conclue par acte sous signature privée contresigné par avocats, à la date à laquelle elle acquiert force exécutoire ; 2° Par la décision qui prononce le divorce, à la date à laquelle elle prend force de chose jugée” (marriage ends on enforceability of the lawyer-signed agreement or when the judgment becomes final). Before that date, use is governed by the interim order, free or paid as the judge decided. After that date, exclusive use is presumed paid unless the parties agreed otherwise. The end point is the closest date to the sharing, in practice the date of the final partition deed, the date of sale to a third party, or the date of the licitation judgment where the flat is auctioned because the spouses cannot agree. A Paris illustration makes the arithmetic tangible. In a case concerning two Paris properties acquired during the marriage, the Paris family court held that the wife owed an occupation indemnity for the flat she occupied alone for the period running from the appeal judgment confirming the divorce until the closest date to the sharing, with the monthly rental value fixed at 1,167 euros, a ruling confirmed on appeal in Paris Court of Appeal, Pole 3 Chamber 1, 31 May 2023, RG No. 21/12840. Nine years at that monthly figure produces a six-figure debt that is then set off against the occupant’s share of the sale price. The length of French liquidation proceedings explains why the figure grows so fast in Paris, where values and rents are high and notarial operations often take two to four years.
Calculation starts from the rental value of the flat on the local market, meaning the rent the flat would command unfurnished for a comparable letting in the same street, with the same size, floor, lift, light and condition. Paris judges expect proof, not assertion. The file that persuades contains two recent written rental estimates from local agencies describing comparable lets with addresses and dates, photographs showing condition, the floor plan with exact surface area under the Carrez rule, and, where the gap exceeds a few hundred euros a month, a court-appointed valuation. Courts then adjust for the specifics of forced co-ownership: a modest reduction for precariousness and lack of exclusive tenant rights is sometimes granted where the occupant could be required to leave at any moment for the needs of the sharing, while no reduction is granted where the occupant blocked the sale or refused viewings. The presence of children does not cancel the indemnity after the divorce, but it can moderate its amount where the occupant houses the children full time and the other parent pays little support, because the judges read the indemnity together with support and housing need. What the occupant paid during the same period is then credited. Mortgage capital repaid alone, co-ownership charges for common areas, mandatory insurance and property tax paid for the undivided property give rise to claims or credits in the partition, while purely personal consumption, electricity, internet, voluntary embellishments without the other’s consent, does not. The bank’s direct debit in one spouse’s sole name does not prove sole payment where the funds came from a joint account fed by both incomes, and Paris notaries systematically ask for twelve to thirty-six months of statements to trace the origin of each instalment.
Proof and limitation decide recovery. The spouse claiming the indemnity must show exclusive occupation, which is usually done through the interim order attributing the home, bailiff’s reports noting who lives there, school registrations at that address, attestations from the building manager, and the absence of any agreement for continued free use. The occupant resisting payment must produce the agreement or judgment granting continued free use, or proof of shared use, or proof that the flat was left vacant and available. Time limits are strict and French courts apply them without indulgence. The periodic indemnity is treated as a recurring claim subject to a five-year limitation, so each monthly instalment older than five years at the date of the claim can be lost, while the underlying right to partition itself is not extinguished so quickly. In practice, the safe course is to claim the indemnity expressly in the divorce submissions, to repeat it in the deed engaging the notary, and to have the notary record it in the statement of difficulties if the spouses disagree, so that the family court fixes it in the partition judgment. Waiting until the sale deed to mention it for the first time invites a limitation defence and an eviction from the price. Tax follows the civil analysis. The tax administration treats occupation indemnities received by the former spouse as gross rental income where they relate to use of an unfurnished building, to be declared as property income, while the paying former spouse cannot deduct them as maintenance, because they are the price of private use of undivided property, not performance of a support obligation. See the impots.gouv.fr guidance on taxation of the occupation indemnity. Pricing the indemnity therefore also prices the tax, and Paris files above one thousand euros a month should be reviewed with an accountant before the partition deed is signed.
B. Paris and Ile-de-France in practice: mortgage, charges, taxes and the file that gets you paid
Paris adds three practical layers to the national rules: high fixed costs that continue whatever the judge writes, a bank that remains outside the divorce, and a notarial market where delays inflate the final account. The couple’s obligations to third parties do not follow the divorce. As long as both names are on the loan, both remain liable to the bank for the whole instalment, with the bank free to pursue either for the full sum. French solidarity for household debts confirms the principle for day-to-day commitments, with Article 220 of the Civil Code providing that “Chacun des époux a pouvoir pour passer seul les contrats qui ont pour objet l’entretien du ménage ou l’éducation des enfants : toute dette ainsi contractée par l’un oblige l’autre solidairement” (each spouse can bind both for household upkeep or children’s education). The loan itself is governed by its own offer and by the matrimonial regime, but vis-a-vis the bank the interim order attributing payment to one spouse is only an internal allocation. If that spouse stops paying, the bank debits the other, reports both to the Banque de France incident file, and may call the acceleration clause. De-joint liability, called desolidarisation, is therefore negotiated with the bank on the strength of the borrower’s sole income, stable employment in Ile-de-France, and a loan-to-value ratio reassessed at Paris prices, and banks grant it sparingly before the final sharing. The spouse who leaves must keep automatic alerts on the loan account, keep the ability to pay on short notice to protect credit history, and preserve every proof of payment for the later account between spouses. The spouse who stays must understand that paying the loan alone does not buy ownership. It creates a credit against the undivision that is repaid at the partition, not an extra share of the flat.
Contribution to the costs of the marriage adds a second layer that expats often discover late. Article 214 of the Civil Code states that “Si les conventions matrimoniales ne règlent pas la contribution des époux aux charges du mariage, ils y contribuent à proportion de leurs facultés respectives. Si l’un des époux ne remplit pas ses obligations, il peut y être contraint par l’autre dans les formes prévues au code de procédure civile” (spouses contribute to marriage costs in proportion to means, enforceable through court). During the proceedings, the judge applies this by allocating the mortgage, the co-ownership charges for the Paris building, the home insurance, the property tax known as taxe fonciere, and where still due the residence charges, between the spouses according to means and use. After the divorce, the same expenses paid for the undivided flat are treated as conservation costs giving rise to accounts, not as gifts. Concretely, a Paris owner-occupier who pays the full co-ownership charges for a Haussmann building, the full insurance and the full taxe fonciere while the other lives abroad, recovers half of those necessary outlays at the partition, with invoices and bank proofs. A spouse who pays the loan interest alone recovers the principal differently from the interest, and only the traced personal funds count. Joint funds create no claim. This is why Paris lawyers ask from the first meeting for separate bank statements, not screenshots, for the loan table, for the last three taxe fonciere notices, for the co-ownership calls for the current and past two years, and for the insurance receipts. Without them, the notary cannot settle, the judge cannot fix, and the money is argued away.
The Paris file that gets paid follows a timetable that mirrors the courts of the capital. At filing, the claimant joins the interim requests with a rental estimate for the flat, a loan amortisation table, the last co-ownership budget, proof of the children’s school in the same arrondissement, and a table showing each spouse’s income, rent capacity and rehousing options. At the orientation hearing, the claimant asks for exclusive use with a stated monthly rental value, allocation of the loan and charges, interim maintenance that reflects the housing advantage, and appointment of a notary. During the proceedings, both spouses keep a monthly ledger: loan debits with account origin, charges, taxes, insurance, maintenance received and paid, and any months where the flat stood empty or was shared. At the divorce judgment, the spouse expecting to claim later asks for an express reservation of the indemnity and the accounts, because silence is read as waiver for the earlier period. After the judgment becomes final, the creditor spouse writes to the notary within weeks, quantifies the indemnity month by month from the final date to the expected sharing, joins fresh rental estimates, and asks for a statement of difficulties if the other disputes the principle or the figure. If the occupant refuses viewings or blocks the sale, the creditor documents each refusal by the agent’s emails and bailiff’s reports, then asks the family court for sale by licitation with a floor price, eviction terms and, where needed, a penalty per day of delay. Paris courts grant licitation where disagreement is proven and the price method is serious, and they fix the indemnity in the same judgment so that the auction price is shared net of what the occupant already owes. For rented flats in Paris and the inner suburbs, the parallel track is simpler but urgent: give notice correctly, protect the deposit, agree in writing who pays the rent until the lease ends, and ask the judge to attribute the lease where the children must stay near their school, with proof from the school and from the landlord that rehousing nearby at comparable rent is impossible.
Three Paris pitfalls deserve explicit warning because they recur in expat files. The first is the occupant who renovates alone and expects full reimbursement. Necessary repairs proven by invoices are credited, but luxury upgrades decided alone are treated as personal spending and reimbursed only to the extent they increased the sale value. The second is the spouse who stops paying the loan to pressure a sale. The bank pursues both, the credit files of both are marked, and the Paris judge reads the arrears as disloyalty when fixing costs and penalties. The third is the couple who agree orally that the stay will remain free after the divorce because the children are young. After the divorce, oral promises do not defeat Article 815-9. Only a written agreement, ideally in the divorce settlement or in a notarised deed, providing for continued free use with dates and consideration, stops the indemnity. Where the children live full time with the occupant and support is low, the right request is not silence but a reasoned moderation of the monthly figure, documented by school, health and childcare costs, so that the judge can balance support and housing in the same decision. Handled this way, the Paris home ceases to be a trap. The spouse who stays knows the monthly price of staying. The spouse who leaves knows the monthly credit that accumulates. And the notary, two years later, divides a documented account instead of arbitrating a memory contest.
Conclusion
Divorcing in France does not give the family home to the spouse who shouts loudest or arrives first. The family judge attributes its interim use by weighing the children’s residence, each spouse’s means and rehousing options, and any violence, then writes the line that matters most, whether that use is free or paid and who provisionally pays the loan, charges, insurance and taxes. While the marriage lasts, free use counts as part of support and cannot later be recycled to deny a compensatory allowance, as the Cour de cassation held when it quashed a Paris decision that had done exactly that. Once the divorce is final, exclusive use of a jointly owned flat becomes a debt priced at market rent, running until the sharing or sale, proven by agency estimates and expert valuation, limited in time for each monthly instalment, taxed as rental income for the recipient, and set off by the notary against the occupant’s share. In Paris and Ile-de-France, where rents, charges and loan instalments are high and liquidation takes years, that monthly figure decides the outcome more surely than the argument over fault. Build the file early, with rental values, loan tables, tax notices and monthly proofs of who paid what from which account, and the home question answers itself in euros. Related reading on this site includes the guide on when your spouse wants you out of the Paris home and how occupancy is decided, the guide on what to do when your ex refuses to sign the property division before the notary, and the guide on how the compensatory allowance is calculated, claimed and challenged.