KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
EU Delists Gutseriev After Second Court Defeat: How to Challenge an EU Sanctions Listing and Unfreeze Assets From France

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

EU Delists Gutseriev After Second Court Defeat: How to Challenge an EU Sanctions Listing and Unfreeze Assets From France

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 8 October 2026, the European Union removed Russian businessman Mikhail Gutseriev and Belarusian businessman Viktor Shevtsov from its Belarus sanctions list, following court rulings that the Council had failed to justify keeping them listed. The news, reported by RFE/RL’s Belarusian service and relayed the same day by The Moscow Times, lands in a paradoxical week: on the very same day, the Council extended its separate hybrid-threat sanctions against Russia until October 2027. One list shrinks because the judges annul; another grows longer because the politics harden. For anyone holding frozen accounts, securities or property in France, the lesson of the week is concrete: an EU listing can be beaten, but only by attacking the statement of reasons with evidence, within strict time limits, and by running the Luxembourg challenge and the French unblocking track in parallel.

This article explains what the General Court actually held in the Gutseriev litigation, why a Luxembourg annulment does not by itself reopen a Paris bank account, and the exact two-track method to challenge a listing and recover the use of frozen assets from France. It is written for listed persons, their families, business partners and banks: what to file, where, within what deadline, and which mistakes lose otherwise winnable cases.

I. Why did the EU have to delist Gutseriev and Shevtsov in October 2026?

A. What did the General Court actually decide in the Gutseriev case?

Mikhail Gutseriev had been listed under the EU Belarus regime, built around Council Regulation (EC) No 765/2006 concerning restrictive measures against Belarus, on the ground that he allegedly benefited from and supported the regime of President Alexander Lukashenko. He challenged his relisting of February 2025 before the General Court of the European Union, case T-286/25. In a judgment handed down on 13 May 2026, the Court annulled the relisting. The decisive holding, at paragraph 113, is worth quoting exactly as reported from the judgment: an error of assessment in treating the applicant, at the date of the contested acts, as a person still benefiting from and supporting the regime of President Lukashenko. In plain terms, the file as it stood on the day the Council acted did not prove the label the Council had stuck on the man.

Three points in that holding matter for every future challenge. First, the review is frozen in time: the Court examines whether the evidence available at the date of adoption supported the listing, not whether later press coverage or later conduct might have justified it. A Council that recycles old reasons without fresh probative material loses. Second, the standard is the individual file: broad assertions about a business sector, a nationality or proximity to an economy are not enough; the Council must tie the person, by specific evidence, to the listing criterion as drafted. Third, this was the second time the General Court annulled a Gutseriev listing, which explains the political outcome in October 2026: after two annulments on the same weakness, keeping the name on the list by adopting a near-identical statement of reasons would invite a third annulment, damages exposure and costs. The Council drew the consequence and removed both Gutseriev and Viktor Shevtsov, the latter on a comparable failure of evidence reported alongside the same delisting round.

The contrast with the Council’s parallel moves the same week sharpens the picture. On 8 October 2026 the Council prolonged its restrictive measures against Russian hybrid activities until October 2027, confirming that the general direction of EU sanctions policy remains restrictive. And the EU’s Russia sanctions architecture, extended in long cycles with a horizon now discussed toward 2029 in commentary, continues to generate fresh listings. Delisting is therefore never a political pardon; it is a legal finding that a particular file, on a particular date, did not meet the legal test. That is good news for applicants because it makes the remedy replicable: any listing that repeats the same defect, vague reasons, stale exhibits, confusion between ownership and control, reliance on unverified open-source claims, can be attacked with the same tools. It is also a warning: the Council learns from each annulment and drafts the next statement of reasons more tightly, so each new listing must be challenged on its own current file, quickly, before the reasons sediment into renewals.

French readers should note the institutional map. The listing itself is an EU act adopted in Brussels and reviewable only in Luxembourg, by the General Court with appeal to the Court of Justice. No Paris court can annul an EU listing. What Paris courts and the French administration control is everything downstream: the bank that freezes the account on the basis of the EU regulation, the Treasury that grants or refuses authorisations to release funds for basic needs or legal fees, and the civil or commercial judge who settles disputes between the account holder and the bank. This split explains why so many listed persons win half the battle and lose the other half: they obtain an annulment in Luxembourg eighteen months later but never asked the French Treasury for interim authorisations in the meantime, or they negotiate with their bank in Paris for a year without ever filing the two-month action in Luxembourg, and the listing becomes unchallengeable. The Gutseriev sequence shows the right order: challenge early in Luxembourg, manage the freeze daily in France.

B. Why does a Luxembourg victory not automatically reopen a frozen account in Paris?

The most common misunderstanding after a delisting headline is the belief that money moves by itself. It does not. EU regulations are directly applicable, which means a French bank freezes the moment the name appears in the Official Journal, without waiting for any French decree. Symmetrically, the bank unfreezes only when it has a solid legal basis to do so: the removal published in the Official Journal, plus, in practice, updated consolidated lists, internal compliance clearance and, for complex structures, proof that the entity asking for the funds is not itself owned or controlled by a person who remains listed. Between the Luxembourg judgment and the effective release, weeks can pass, and each intermediary asks for documents. Planning for that gap is part of the case strategy, not an afterthought.

French domestic law organises this downstream layer in the Monetary and Financial Code, and every practitioner should know its architecture by heart. The opening definitions state the vocabulary: “fonds” covers cash, deposits, claims, payment instruments, savings products, insurance surrender values, financial instruments and their income, while “gel des fonds” means “toute action tendant à empêcher un changement de leur volume, montant, localisation, propriété, possession, nature, destination ou toute autre modification qui pourrait permettre leur utilisation, notamment la gestion de portefeuille” in the wording of Article L562-1 of the Monetary and Financial Code. The national freezing power itself is framed narrowly: “Le ministre chargé de l’économie et le ministre de l’intérieur peuvent décider, conjointement, pour une durée de six mois, renouvelable, le gel des fonds et ressources économiques” against persons involved in terrorism and their emanations, in the wording of Article L562-2 of the Monetary and Financial Code, while a parallel provision allows the economy minister to act alone in related configurations described by Article L562-3 of the Monetary and Financial Code. These national provisions matter less for EU-listed persons than for nationally designated ones, but they shape the reflexes of the French administration and the banks, and they explain why the Treasury is the natural interlocutor for authorisation requests.

The operational core for banks sits in the next articles. The Code provides that the persons subject to the regime “Sont tenus d’appliquer sans délai les mesures de gel et les interdictions de mise à disposition ou d’utilisation prévues au présent chapitre et aux articles L. 712-4 et L. 712-10 et d’en informer immédiatement le ministre chargé de l’économie” and to report, in the language of Article L562-4 of the Monetary and Financial Code, and it adds a strict prohibition on making funds or economic resources available, directly or indirectly, to designated persons, set out in Article L562-5 of the Monetary and Financial Code. For the account holder, three consequences follow. First, the bank that refuses a transfer to a listed client is not committing a fault; it is obeying the law, and suing the bank for breach of contract without addressing the underlying designation wastes time and costs. Second, any payment circuit that routes money to the listed person through relatives, companies or intermediaries exposes everyone in the chain, including lawyers’ handling of funds, to criminal and regulatory risk. Third, the only lawful path to use frozen money during the listing runs through exemptions and authorisations, not through pressure on the counterparty.

French law also settles opposability and publicity, two points that decide real cases. National freeze decisions “Les décisions des ministres arrêtées en application des articles L. 562-2 , L. 562-2-1 , L. 562-2-2 et L. 562-3 sont publiées par extrait au Journal officiel et sont exécutoires à compter de leur date de publication.” of publication under Article L562-9 of the Monetary and Financial Code, and EU regulations follow their own Official Journal publication with direct effect. Measures “Les mesures prises en vertu du présent chapitre sont opposables à tout tiers qui peut invoquer un droit sur les fonds ou ressources économiques faisant l’objet d’une mesure de gel, y compris lorsque ce droit est né antérieurement auxdites mesures.” under Article L562-10 of the Monetary and Financial Code, which means a spouse, a business partner or a creditor cannot defeat the freeze by invoking a private agreement, a pledge or a subsequent assignment; at most they can assert their own distinct rights through the authorisation or de-listing channels. The exit door during the freeze is the authorisation regime: the ministers’ power to “Le ministre chargé de l’économie et le ministre de l’intérieur peuvent conjointement autoriser le déblocage et la mise à disposition d’une partie des fonds ou ressources économiques faisant l’objet d’une mesure de gel en vertu des articles L. 562-2 , L. 562-2-1 et L. 562-2-2 si leur utilisation est compatible avec la sauvegarde de l’ordre public.” for defined purposes, in the terms of Article L562-11 of the Monetary and Financial Code, mirrored at EU level by the derogations each sanctions regulation provides for basic needs, legal fees, maintenance of frozen property and, under conditions, release of funds subject to judicial decisions. A file that never requests these authorisations leaves money sleeping that the law would allow to be used.

Put back into the Gutseriev timeline, the practical moral is clear. The annulment of May 2026 did not move a euro by itself; the October 2026 removal from the list did, once published and digested by compliance departments. For persons still listed under comparable Belarus, Russia, hybrid or other EU regimes, the waiting posture, doing nothing until politics change, is the costliest option: interest accrues on frozen loans, asset managers charge, property deteriorates, limitation periods run. The winning posture combines an offensive Luxembourg action against the listing with a defensive French file for day-to-day survival: authorisations for living costs and defence fees, protection of mortgaged property, salary payments by owned companies where the regulation allows, and documented engagement with the bank so that the release, when it comes, executes in days rather than months. Readers who want the broader sanctions-challenge playbook applied from France can also consult our earlier analysis of the Usmanov and Fridman delistings and the extended sanctions horizon at EU Delists Usmanov and Fridman but Freezes Sanctions Until 2029: How to Challenge a Listing or a Frozen Account From France, which remains the hub for this cluster.

II. How do you challenge an EU listing and unfreeze assets from France?

A. How do you attack the listing itself before the EU courts?

The action that counts is the action for annulment under Article 263 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, brought before the General Court in Luxembourg within two months of the listing’s publication or its notification, plus the standard extension for distance. The deadline is strict and almost never extended: a file that arrives on day sixty-one is inadmissible, however strong the merits. The first operational rule is therefore calendaring. Diarise the publication date in the Official Journal, identify whether the person was individually notified, compute the two-month period with the ten-day distance extension, and file protectively if the file is incomplete, supplementing later with the Council’s file obtained through measures of organisation of procedure. Parallel political steps, letters to the Council, press statements, diplomatic representations, never suspend that deadline. The Gutseriev outcome rewards early filers; latecomers to the same listing wave inherit the same defects but no remedy.

The second rule concerns the statement of reasons. Every listing must state, individually and specifically, why this person meets the criterion. The advocate’s first job is a line-by-line audit of those reasons against the evidence bundle the Council discloses. Recurring winning arguments in recent Belarus and Russia cases include: reasons that merely restate the criterion without facts; reliance on outdated positions, divested shareholdings or resigned directorships; confusion between employment by a state-linked company and support for a regime; attribution to the applicant of acts by relatives or distinct legal persons without proof of control; and open-source exhibits that do not say what the summary claims they say. The Gutseriev paragraph 113 reasoning belongs to this family: at the adoption date, the material did not sustain the finding that the applicant could still be regarded as benefiting from and supporting the regime. Applicants should plead these defects precisely, exhibit by exhibit, rather than denouncing the sanctions policy in general terms, which the Court will not entertain. A focused fifty-page plea that destroys three exhibits beats a sweeping two-hundred-page memorandum that proves nothing.

The third rule is evidence from the applicant’s side. The Council bears the burden of justifying the listing, but the applicant who files nothing beyond denials leaves the Court with only the Council’s bundle. Winning files typically include: corporate registry extracts proving disposal of shares or resignation from boards before the relevant date; audited statements severing financial links; shareholder agreements and voting records showing absence of control; employment and tax records establishing a different centre of activity; travel and residence records where relevant; and independent expert or auditor attestations on ownership chains. Each document should be translated into the language of the case, dated, and mapped to the specific reason it rebuts. Where the listing turns on the notion of control over an entity, French company-law reflexes help: produce the cap table, the voting rights breakdown, the board minutes and the banking powers, because the EU judge reasons like a commercial judge on control, majority, veto rights, de facto management, not like a headline writer.

The fourth rule is interim relief and damages, used sparingly and honestly. An application for interim measures suspending the listing almost never succeeds because the Court treats the public interest in sanctions as weighty and the harm, though severe, as financially reparable; file it only when a specific irreversible event looms, such as a forced sale at a loss or a regulatory licence withdrawal with a fixed date, and support it with dated proof. The damages action under Articles 268 and 340 TFEU for manifest and serious breach is a second-stage weapon after an annulment, not a substitute for it; it requires showing a sufficiently serious breach of a rule conferring rights, actual loss and causation, with quantification by experts. Costs follow the event in principle, so a well-built annulment case also protects the client’s costs position. Throughout, fundamental rights pleadings should be concrete: right to effective judicial protection and the duty to state reasons under Article 47 of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights, right to property and proportionality, and rights of the defence including access to the file. Abstract invocations add nothing; each right must be tied to a specific procedural failure, a document withheld, a reason unstated, a less restrictive measure ignored.

The fifth rule is renewal discipline. EU listings are renewed periodically, and each renewal is a new act that must itself be challenged within its own deadline if the name remains. Too many applicants win the argument on the initial listing but forget the renewal, or challenge the renewal while the initial case settles the decisive points. The clean method is to challenge each act that maintains the name, ask the Court to join or coordinate the cases, and update the evidence with everything that changed since: disposals completed, functions ended, new registry filings, fresh auditor letters. The Council’s October 2026 posture illustrates why: it delisted where its file had twice collapsed, while prolonging regimes and maintaining other names where it considers its evidence stronger. Each file lives or dies on its own current reasons. A second, related discipline is consistency across forums: statements made to a bank, to the French Treasury, to the press or in another jurisdiction’s proceedings can be disclosed and used against the applicant in Luxembourg. Align the factual narrative everywhere from day one, correct errors openly rather than letting contradictions accumulate, and keep a single master chronology of holdings, offices and transactions that every adviser uses.

B. How do you get frozen money released in France while the challenge runs?

While Luxembourg decides, life continues and the freeze bites daily. The French track has four levers, and serious files pull all four at once. The first lever is the authorisation request to the French Treasury for release of frozen funds under the derogations. EU regulations and the domestic authorisation framework converge on the same categories: basic needs of the listed person and dependent family members, payment of reasonable legal fees, fees for routine holding and maintenance of frozen assets, and payments due under contracts or judicial decisions predating the listing, subject to prior notification or approval procedures that vary by regulation. A granted authorisation flows from the ministers’ power to “Le ministre chargé de l’économie et le ministre de l’intérieur peuvent conjointement autoriser le déblocage et la mise à disposition d’une partie des fonds ou ressources économiques faisant l’objet d’une mesure de gel en vertu des articles L. 562-2 , L. 562-2-1 et L. 562-2-2 si leur utilisation est compatible avec la sauvegarde de l’ordre public.” recalled in Article L562-11 of the Monetary and Financial Code. The request must be documentary, not rhetorical: monthly budget with bank statements, lease and utility bills, school and medical certificates for dependants, engagement letters and fee estimates from counsel, property tax and insurance demands for frozen real estate, loan schedules showing default risk. File early, update monthly, and answer Treasury questions within days, because an incomplete file simply ages while interest and penalties accrue.

The second lever is the bank relationship, managed as a compliance file rather than a commercial dispute. Because banks “Sont tenus d’appliquer sans délai les mesures de gel et les interdictions de mise à disposition ou d’utilisation prévues au présent chapitre” under Article L562-4 of the Monetary and Financial Code and face the prohibition in Article L562-5 of the Monetary and Financial Code, threatening the branch achieves nothing. What works is a clean compliance pack: the current consolidated EU list extract showing the exact scope of the designation, the corporate chart distinguishing listed from non-listed entities with registry proof, the Treasury authorisations obtained, and written payment instructions that fit inside those authorisations. Ask the bank for its written requirements before moving funds, execute a small authorised test payment first, and keep every refusal in writing with reasons, since a documented refusal pattern supports escalation to the Treasury or, where appropriate, to the banking mediator or the competent civil court for non-listed co-holders whose own funds are caught by over-blocking. Over-compliance is frequent: banks sometimes freeze accounts of non-listed companies merely because a listed person once held shares. Those cases are winnable on proof of current ownership and control, using the definitions in Article L562-1 of the Monetary and Financial Code to show that neither detention nor control subsists.

The third lever is third-party and family protection. Because measures are “opposables à tout tiers” under Article L562-10 of the Monetary and Financial Code, a spouse’s salary landing on a frozen joint account, a child’s school fees paid from a frozen company card, or a partner’s loan secured on frozen shares all need restructuring through lawful channels, not informal workarounds that look like circumvention. Open separate non-tainted accounts for non-listed family members with clean funding sources, segregate pre-listing receivables from post-listing income of listed entities, and document the source of every euro that enters the authorised circuit. For jointly held property, anticipate the notary’s blockage at the sale stage: engage the notary early, obtain the Treasury position in writing, and align the sale timetable with the Luxembourg case so that a post-delisting completion can proceed without re-negotiation. For companies partly owned by a listed person, distinguish three questions the bank and the Treasury will ask separately: is the company itself listed, is it owned or controlled by a listed person, and is a specific transaction making funds available to that person. Each question has its own exhibits and its own answer, and confusing them delays everything.

The fourth lever is litigation in France, chosen for what it can actually deliver. The French judge cannot annul the EU listing, but can decide whether a bank over-blocked beyond the regulation’s scope, whether a creditor can enforce against non-frozen assets, how a matrimonial or partnership regime allocates frozen and unencumbered property, and whether an eviction, a foreclosure or a licence withdrawal should be stayed pending the Luxembourg outcome or the Treasury decision. Proceedings for interim relief before the civil courts can preserve the status quo where an irreversible sale threatens, provided the applicant shows urgency and a serious dispute, for example a bank’s freeze of an account whose holder demonstrates by registry and banking evidence that no listed person holds or controls it. Employment and corporate mandates need parallel care: salaries of non-listed employees of a frozen company, directors’ powers, shareholder meetings and audit obligations continue, and the file should keep the company alive and compliant so that there is something left to recover when the listing falls. Throughout, criminal prudence governs: any arrangement designed to make frozen value available to the listed person outside the authorisation channel risks prosecution for circumvention, and advisers must keep their own fee arrangements inside the authorised legal-fees derogation with transparent billing.

Timing ties the two tracks together. The Luxembourg action runs twelve to twenty-four months to judgment at first instance, sometimes longer on appeal; the French authorisations run month by month. The method that the Gutseriev week validates is therefore sequential in filing and parallel in management: file the annulment within the two-month window with the best available evidence, then improve it as the Council discloses its file; simultaneously, build the French survival file, authorisations, bank pack, family segregation, protective litigation, so that the client reaches judgment solvent and credible. When delisting comes, as it came for Gutseriev and Shevtsov in October 2026, the release phase must be pre-wired: updated KYC pack ready, bank compliance contact identified, notary and auditor on standby, Treasury informed, so that publication in the Official Journal converts into available funds within days. Clients who prepare only the Luxembourg half regularly discover that victory on paper takes a quarter to reach the account; clients who prepare both halves get the practical benefit of the judgment they paid to obtain.

Conclusion

The October 2026 delisting of Gutseriev and Shevtsov proves that EU sanctions listings are judicially reviewable acts, not political fate: where the Council’s file does not support its reasons on the adoption date, the General Court annuls, and repeated annulments lead to removal. But the same week proves the reverse: regimes are prolonged, other names stay listed, and frozen accounts do not reopen by themselves. The durable answer is the two-track method this article describes. In Luxembourg, challenge each listing and each renewal within its two-month deadline, destroy the statement of reasons exhibit by exhibit, and file the evidence that severs the alleged link. In France, live inside the law: request the authorisations the texts allow, run the bank as a compliance file, protect non-listed relatives and partners with segregated circuits, and litigate only what the French judge can actually order. Listings drafted on stale or generic material remain beatable, as case T-286/25 and its paragraph 113 on error of assessment demonstrate. The files that win are filed early, documented precisely and managed daily on both fronts until the Official Journal publishes the name’s removal and the bank releases the funds.

📄 Official circular