KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Flagged by AI in Lyon, Arrested Anywhere: Interpol’s Operation Shams II Identified 126 Terror Suspects — What France Does Next

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Flagged by AI in Lyon, Arrested Anywhere: Interpol’s Operation Shams II Identified 126 Terror Suspects — What France Does Next

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 18 September 2026, Interpol announced the results of a first-of-its-kind operation run from 1 to 5 June 2026 in Tunis, Tunisia: 28 specialised officers and experts from 11 countries extracted 108,076 facial images from visual content published by jihadist groups, used programmed AI agents to deduplicate and quality-check them down to 6,362 unique, high-quality faces, and ran them through Interpol’s Facial Recognition System. To date, 126 Foreign Terrorist Fighters have been identified from those images. The data is now being integrated into Interpol’s databases, investigative leads are already supporting judicial procedures in participating countries — including one case targeting two currently detained suspected Foreign Terrorist Fighters — and thousands more images are still being processed. The same operation deployed cryptocurrency tracing tools that produced three urgent requests to a Virtual Asset Service Provider to disclose customer data, and brought participating countries together with representatives of the online gaming industry to address youth radicalisation. For anyone living in France — a returnee, a relative, a person whose face appears in a propaganda video, or simply someone flagged by an international database — the question is concrete: what happens when an AI-generated match made in Lyon becomes an arrest, a prosecution or an extradition request on French soil? This article explains the French procedure step by step, the terrorism charges that follow, and how a lawyer challenges machine-generated evidence in a French courtroom.

I. From an AI Match in Lyon to a French Courtroom: Arrest, Prosecution and Extradition

A. Arrested in France After an Interpol Identification: Extradition, Surrender and Detention

An identification made during Operation Shams II does not itself arrest anyone. It becomes operational when it is entered into Interpol’s databases and surfaces as a Red Notice, a diffusion, or a bilateral intelligence tip that reaches the French authorities. From that moment, French procedure takes over, and it takes over in forms that every person concerned should understand. If you are arrested in France on the basis of a foreign request, two entirely different tracks exist, and confusing them is the most common and most costly mistake. Where the requesting state is outside the European Union, the classic extradition procedure of the Code of Criminal Procedure applies. Where the request comes from another EU Member State, the European Arrest Warrant framework applies. The Shams II identifications can feed either track, because Foreign Terrorist Fighters move across both EU and non-EU borders, and because France cooperates with states on every continent.

In a classic extradition case, the person arrested is brought before the public prosecutor, then before the investigating chamber of the court of appeal, which gives a reasoned opinion on the request. The statute is explicit: “la chambre de l’instruction donne son avis motivé sur la demande d’extradition.” And the opinion turns negative where the legal conditions fail: “Cet avis est défavorable si la cour estime que les conditions légales ne sont pas remplies ou qu’il y a une erreur évidente.” An unfavourable opinion is a formidable shield: it has historically blocked the government from authorising surrender. Only where the track reaches the government stage does the executive decide, since “l’extradition est autorisée par décret du Premier ministre pris sur le rapport du ministre de la justice.” That decree can itself be challenged before the administrative courts within a one-month time limit, and the person cannot simply be left in detention indefinitely: where the requested person has not been collected by the requesting state’s agents within one month of notification of the decree to that state, the person must be released as of right, except in cases of force majeure.

The bars to extradition that French courts apply most often in terrorism-adjacent files are worth stating plainly, because they are the levers a defence actually pulls. French nationality blocks surrender: “L’extradition n’est pas accordée : 1° Lorsque la personne réclamée a la nationalité française, cette dernière étant appréciée à l’époque de l’infraction pour laquelle l’extradition est requise”. A person of French nationality is not handed over; France prosecutes its own nationals instead, under its broad jurisdiction over terrorist acts committed abroad. Political character of the offence, prosecution or final judgment already delivered in France for the same facts, limitation periods already acquired, penalties contrary to French public policy, and trial guarantees in the requesting state that fall short of fundamental defence rights all appear in the same provision and each one has generated a full body of case law. Anyone arrested in Paris on the back of a Shams II lead should therefore ask, from the first hour: what is my nationality, has France already dealt with these facts, is the request time-barred, and what court would try me over there?

Two recent rulings of the Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation show how seriously French courts police this procedure. On 9 August 2023, in case number 23-83.192, the Court examined the file of “M. [D] [S], ressortissant ukrainien, objet d’une demande d’extradition des autorités ukrainiennes aux fins de poursuites pénales des chefs de détournement et blanchiment aggravés, est placé sous contrôle judiciaire depuis le 5 janvier 2023.” After an unfavourable opinion of the investigating chamber, the defence sought release from judicial supervision, and the argument put to the Court was unequivocal: “le contrôle judiciaire dont la personne réclamée peut faire l’objet jusqu’à sa comparution devant la chambre de l’instruction, et qui se maintient de plein droit en cas d’avis favorable de cette chambre, prend fin lorsque cette dernière délivre un avis défavorable et ce dès le prononcé de cet avis”. The file then records the next step with precision: “Le 11 avril 2023, M. [S] a saisi la chambre de l’instruction d’une demande de mainlevée de son contrôle judiciaire.” The lesson for today is direct: an unfavourable opinion is not a symbolic victory, it carries immediate consequences for liberty, and counsel must convert it into release without delay. A second ruling, delivered on 28 March 2023 under number 22-84.382, concerned an extradition requested by Italy: “Le procureur général près la cour d’appel de Paris a formé un pourvoi contre l’arrêt de la chambre de l’instruction de ladite cour d’appel, 5e section, en date du 29 juin 2022, qui, dans la procédure d’extradition suivie contre M. [Y] [W] à la demande du gouvernement italien, a émis un avis défavorable.” The prosecution challenged the unfavourable opinion on human-rights grounds, arguing in substance that “si des circonstances peuvent faire prévaloir le droit au respect de la vie privée et familiale sur le but légitime poursuivi par l’extradition, ce n’est que dans le cas où ces circonstances présentent un caractère exceptionnel au regard des faits reprochés et de leur gravité”. The Court rejected the appeal. Together, the two decisions confirm that the investigating chamber’s unfavourable opinion is a robust, appeal-resistant outcome — and the closest equivalent, in extradition practice, to winning the case. Readers who want the full mechanics of that outcome will find them set out in our analysis of how France prosecutes foreign crimes after refusing extradition.

Where the requesting state sits inside the European Union, the European Arrest Warrant replaces classic extradition with a faster surrender procedure between judges. France executes warrants issued by fellow Member States, and refuses them only on exhaustively listed grounds: “L’exécution d’un mandat d’arrêt européen est refusée dans les cas suivants :” — including amnesty in France, a final judgment already delivered for the same facts under the ne bis in idem principle, and the age of criminal responsibility. A French national surrendered under a warrant for prosecution can also demand the guarantee of return to serve any resulting sentence in France. In Shams II terms, a fighter located in Belgium, Germany or Spain on the strength of an AI match and wanted by the Paris judicial authorities could be surrendered to France within weeks; conversely, a person in France wanted by another Member State on the same basis can resist surrender on those closed-list grounds, and only on those grounds, which makes early legal analysis decisive. Where France is the issuing state, the statute organises the transmission chain from the French prosecutor to the Ministry of Justice and then to the executing state, so that a Shams II match concerning a French case can become a live warrant within days.

B. From a Face on a Video to a Terrorism Charge: What French Criminal Law Actually Punishes

Identification is not conviction. An AI match says that a face in a propaganda video resembles a known suspect; it says nothing about what that person did, intended, or knew. French terrorism law, however, is built precisely to convert presence, participation and support into criminal charges — which is why the gap between a match and a charge can close fast, and why understanding the charges matters as much as understanding the procedure. The foundation is Article 421-1 of the Criminal Code, which defines terrorist acts as ordinary serious offences committed with a terrorist purpose: “lorsqu’elles sont intentionnellement en relation avec une entreprise individuelle ou collective ayant pour but de troubler gravement l’ordre public par l’intimidation ou la terreur”. Murder, attempted murder, kidnapping, theft, extortion, destruction, computer offences, weapons offences and explosives offences all become terrorist offences when tied to that individual or collective enterprise aimed at seriously disturbing public order through intimidation or terror. A fighter filmed carrying a weapon in a jihadist video is therefore not facing a charge of appearing in a video; the footage is used as evidence of participation in a terrorist enterprise, and the charge that follows is measured in decades of imprisonment.

The two provisions that do the heaviest work in French counter-terrorism courtrooms are the association of wrongdoers with terrorist aims and the financing of terrorism. Article 421-2-1 provides that “Constitue également un acte de terrorisme le fait de participer à un groupement formé ou à une entente établie en vue de la préparation, caractérisée par un ou plusieurs faits matériels, d’un des actes de terrorisme mentionnés aux articles précédents.” In practice, the Paris specialised courts have applied this to networks, cells, logistical support, travel to combat zones, and online facilitation alike: the statute requires a group or agreement, preparation of a terrorist act, and at least one material fact showing that preparation. A Shams II identification that places a person inside a jihadist group’s visual propaganda becomes, in the hands of the National Anti-Terrorism Prosecutor’s Office, one material fact among others — travel records, communications, witness statements, financial traces — assembled to prove participation in the group. No single image convicts on its own, but no image is ever read on its own either; it is always stitched into a file, and the file is what the trial court judges.

The financing strand is equally important because Operation Shams II explicitly targeted it. Article 421-2-2 provides that “Constitue également un acte de terrorisme le fait de financer une entreprise terroriste en fournissant, en réunissant ou en gérant des fonds, des valeurs ou des biens quelconques ou en donnant des conseils à cette fin”, where the funds are intended or known to be destined, in whole or in part, for the commission of a terrorist act — whether or not such an act ever occurs. The operation’s cryptocurrency tracing, which led to three urgent disclosure requests addressed to a Virtual Asset Service Provider, fits exactly this logic: following the money is following the charge. A person whose wallet interacts with addresses linked to a terrorist network can face financing charges even if no attack resulted, and the disclosure of customer data from an exchange or custodian is often the document that turns suspicion into prosecution. France has convicted financiers, collectors, intermediaries and mere advisers under this provision, and its wording deliberately dispenses with the need for a completed attack, which means the defence must attack the knowledge element — what the accused knew and intended — rather than wait for the prosecution to prove an outcome that the statute does not require.

France’s jurisdiction over these facts is deliberately wide. French courts can try terrorist acts committed abroad when the perpetrator or the victim is French, when the act targets French interests, and in several configurations under international conventions implemented into domestic law. Combined with the rule that French nationals are not extradited but are prosecuted in France, the practical result is simple: a French Foreign Terrorist Fighter identified through Shams II will almost certainly face the Paris specialised courts — the National Anti-Terrorism Prosecutor’s Office for the investigation, the specialised investigating judges for the pre-trial phase, and the Paris Criminal Court sitting in its terrorism composition for trial. A non-French suspect found in France faces a choice of tracks: prosecution in France where jurisdiction exists, or surrender to the requesting state under the extradition and warrant rules described above. In both cases, the AI match is the beginning of the file, not its end: French procedure then demands what it always demands — material facts, intent, and a link between the two, tested at trial.

II. Can You Challenge an AI-Generated Lead in a French Courtroom?

A. Facial Recognition, Police Databases and Your Rights: Where the Machine Meets the Law

The most striking technical sentence in Interpol’s own announcement is also the most legally significant. The organisation states that programmed AI agents automated parts of collection and investigation, and that AI-generated output was subject to review and verification by trained officers and analysts, in accordance with Interpol’s Rules on the Processing of Data. That single assurance contains the entire defence roadmap: machines propose, humans verify, and rules govern. Every one of those three steps can be tested. Was the image genuinely of sufficient quality, or did the deduplication pipeline promote a blurry frame into a supposed unique face? Did a trained officer truly verify the match, and is that verification documented, reasoned and disclosed to the defence? Were Interpol’s data-processing rules actually followed for this notice, this diffusion, this entry — and if not, what follows for the acts built upon it? In France, evidence obtained in breach of essential procedural safeguards can be annulled, and the nullity of a foundational act can cascade through everything that depended on it. The AI pipeline is therefore not background context; it is a potential nullity minefield, and defence counsel in a Shams II-derived file should request the full chain — source image, quality score, match report, verification record, database entry — before discussing anything else.

French domestic law frames biometric identification with unusual strictness, and that strictness is an asset for the defence. The national automated fingerprint and genetic database operates under tight statutory control: “Le fichier national automatisé des empreintes génétiques, placé sous le contrôle d’un magistrat, est destiné à centraliser les empreintes génétiques issues des traces biologiques ainsi que les empreintes génétiques des personnes déclarées coupables de l’une des infractions mentionnées à l’article 706-55 en vue de faciliter l’identification et la recherche des auteurs de ces infractions.” The principle is general: identification files are created by statute, placed under a magistrate’s control, and confined to defined purposes. Facial recognition in criminal investigations has no comparable all-purpose statutory home in French law; it proceeds through specific, limited authorisations and remains one of the most contested frontiers between security and liberty. The European Union’s Artificial Intelligence Act, Regulation (EU) 2024/1689, now classifies biometric identification systems as high-risk and surrounds real-time remote biometric identification by law enforcement with prohibitions subject to narrow, judicially authorised exceptions. A match produced by a system operating outside those guardrails — mass scraping of faces, unreviewed automated identification, undisclosed scoring — arrives in a French courtroom carrying a visible vulnerability, and the defence should name it.

The European Convention on Human Rights reinforces the point. Any use of biometric identification by the state interferes with the right to respect for private life, and must be in accordance with the law, pursue a legitimate aim, and remain necessary in a democratic society. The extradition case law already shows French courts weighing exactly that balance: in the 28 March 2023 Italian extradition case discussed above, the prosecution’s position was that “si des circonstances peuvent faire prévaloir le droit au respect de la vie privée et familiale sur le but légitime poursuivi par l’extradition, ce n’est que dans le cas où ces circonstances présentent un caractère exceptionnel au regard des faits reprochés et de leur gravité”. Transposed to biometric evidence, the structure is identical: the state invokes defence of order and prevention of crime, the individual invokes private life and the reliability of the method, and the court decides whether the interference was lawful, necessary and proportionate. A terrorism file does not exempt the state from that test; the gravity of the facts weighs in the balance but does not remove the scales. Counsel should therefore plead the biometric interference as such — demanding the legal basis, the authorisation, the necessity assessment and the proportionality review — rather than treating the AI match as an unchallengeable technical fact.

Two further avenues exist at the international level and both run through Lyon. Interpol’s own system allows individuals to challenge the data held about them before the Commission for the Control of Interpol’s Files, the independent body that reviews whether personal data processed through Interpol’s channels complies with the organisation’s rules — including data quality, purpose, and the involvement of the requesting country. A person who believes a Shams II-derived entry is inaccurate, politically tainted, or retained beyond its purpose can petition the Commission for access, correction or deletion, and a deletion decision removes the foundation of arrests and extraditions built on that entry worldwide. Separately, refugee and asylum law can block surrender where return would expose the person to persecution, torture or inhuman treatment — a protection that operates independently of the criminal file and that French courts and the European Court of Human Rights enforce with interim measures where needed. Neither avenue requires proving innocence; both require acting early, documenting precisely, and filing in the right forum before the machinery moves.

B. Arrested, Flagged or Wanted After Shams II: The Practical Defence Checklist for France

When a person learns — at a border, at dawn during a house search, or through a lawyer’s phone call — that an international file links them to terrorism, the first hours decide the rest. The checklist below reflects how Paris terrorism and extradition practice actually works, not how it looks in a press release. First, say nothing substantive before counsel arrives, and designate a lawyer experienced in both criminal defence and extradition immediately; statements made in the shock of arrest, especially about travel, acquaintances or money transfers, become the fixed points around which the file is built, and they cannot be unsaid. Second, force the authorities to show the basis: demand the exact legal ground of the arrest, the requesting state, the reference of the Red Notice or warrant, and the facts alleged. A vague reference to an Interpol file is not a legal ground; the defence is entitled to know precisely what is held against the client and under which procedure — extradition outside the Union or surrender within it — because the rights, time limits and remedies differ completely between the two.

Third, attack the identification itself. Request disclosure of the biometric chain: the source image, its origin, the system’s match score and threshold, the identity of the verifying officer, and the record of human review. Challenge the quality of the match where the source is a compressed propaganda video frame, where the face is partially covered, or where the time elapsed between the image and the arrest spans years. Instruct a private expert in facial comparison where the stakes justify it, and ask the court to order an adversarial expert assessment rather than accept a police assertion that the system matched. Fourth, map every bar to surrender or prosecution: French nationality assessed at the time of the offence, political character of the facts, prior French proceedings or final judgment, limitation periods under both laws, penalties contrary to French public policy, and insufficient trial guarantees in the requesting state for extradition; amnesty, final judgment for the same facts, and minority for European warrants. Each bar must be evidenced, not incanted: nationality proved by documents, limitation computed article by article, foreign trial conditions documented through official sources and case law, not press clippings.

Fifth, build the human-rights file in parallel. Where surrender is sought, assemble evidence on prison conditions, the risk of inhuman or degrading treatment, the independence of the requesting state’s courts, and the proportionality of the measure in light of family life established in France — schooling of children, medical care, length of residence. The investigating chamber examines these arguments seriously, as the Italian case above demonstrates: the prosecution itself framed the debate around the exceptionality of private-life circumstances measured against the gravity of the facts, which means the defence must present circumstances that genuinely reach that threshold, documented and specific, rather than general. Sixth, consider the Interpol angle from day one: file, through counsel, a request to the Commission for the Control of Interpol’s Files for access to the data, then for correction or deletion where the entry breaches data rules. A pending Commission procedure does not automatically suspend an extradition, but a deletion decision destroys the file’s foundation, and even a reasoned admissibility finding can support arguments before the French courts about the reliability of the underlying material.

Seventh, never overlook the French prosecution alternative. Where France has jurisdiction — and for terrorism it very often does — the defence can argue that trial in France, before the specialised Paris courts, with full defence rights, adversarial expertise and a sentence served under French standards, is the lawful and proportionate answer to the foreign request. French courts have repeatedly preferred domestic prosecution of nationals and residents over surrender, and the National Anti-Terrorism Prosecutor’s Office is structurally designed to absorb exactly these files. Proposing French prosecution is not an admission; it is a jurisdictional strategy that keeps the client within the legal system that protects them best. Finally, protect the periphery: freezing of assets, closure of accounts, professional ruin and media exposure often strike faster than the courts. Coordinate the criminal defence with administrative challenges to freezing measures, with employment advice, and with a strict media discipline — no interviews, no social-media explanations, no family statements that the prosecution will quote back at trial. The file is won in the courtroom, and courtrooms punish what is said outside them.

Conclusion

Operation Shams II marks a turning point that international criminal lawyers cannot ignore: 108,076 images harvested from jihadist propaganda, 6,362 faces distilled by AI, 126 suspected Foreign Terrorist Fighters identified, financing trails followed through cryptocurrency disclosures, and judicial procedures already underway — all coordinated from Lyon and executed across 11 countries. The technology will only expand, and the thousands of images still awaiting processing mean further identifications, further arrests and further court cases in the months ahead. For France, the consequence is direct: more Red Notices executed at its borders, more extradition hearings before its investigating chambers, more surrender proceedings under European warrants, and more terrorism trials before the Paris specialised courts. The French system answers machine-generated suspicion with human-verified procedure — reasoned opinions on extradition, closed-list grounds for refusing surrender, statutory definitions of terrorist acts, magistrate-controlled identification files, and Convention rights that apply even in the gravest cases. Anyone caught in that machinery needs to understand it early: challenge the match, map the bars to surrender, build the rights file, and choose the forum. Interpol’s announcement closed with a promise of more results to come; the only rational response for those concerned is preparation, counsel, and procedure.

📄 Official circular