KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Retired in France as an American: How Your IRA, 401(k), and Social Security Income Is Taxed and Declared

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Retired in France as an American: How Your IRA, 401(k), and Social Security Income Is Taxed and Declared

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You retired to France with an IRA, an old 401(k), and a Social Security check landing every month. Then the questions start: does France tax my IRA withdrawals on top of the IRS, do I owe French tax on Social Security, and where do I even declare dollars on a French return? This week, the 2027 Social Security cost-of-living announcement is trending across the United States, so checks are on every retiree’s mind, and the answer matters more than ever for Americans living in France. French tax law starts from a blunt principle: once you are a French tax resident, France taxes your worldwide income, including American retirement money. The 1994 France-United States income tax treaty then decides which country actually keeps the tax, and its answer is surprisingly generous, provided you declare everything in the right place. This article explains the treaty mechanics for periodic IRA and 401(k) payouts, the separate rule for Social Security benefits, the French calculation with its 10 percent allowance, the special paths for lump sums, and the exact declaration routine that keeps both tax offices satisfied.

I. Your American retirement income is taxable only in the United States, and France gives you a matching credit

The treaty rule sits in Article 18 of the Convention signed on August 31, 1994. Its first paragraph covers both of your income streams in a single rule: In plain English, Article 18(1) sends two streams to the paying State alone: Social Security benefits paid to a resident of the other State, and employment-linked retirement payments from one State to a resident of the other, whether those payments arrive periodically or as a single lump sum. The treaty’s own conclusion is that such sums are taxable only in the State of origin: Social Security benefits and employment-linked retirement payouts, whether periodic or lump sum, coming from the United States to a French resident are taxable only in the first State, meaning the United States. France may not add its own layer of tax on top. That single sentence is the foundation of everything that follows, and you can read it in the official treaty text published by the French tax administration.

A. How your IRA and 401(k) withdrawals escape French tax through the treaty credit

There is a catch, and its name is the saving clause. Because the United States taxes its citizens wherever they live, the treaty lets Washington do exactly that: Under that clause the United States may tax its residents and its citizens as if the treaty did not exist. So the IRS taxes your IRA distribution under the Internal Revenue Code, treaty or no treaty. But the same paragraph 3 preserves your two essential protections: the benefits granted under Article 18(1) on pensions and under Article 24 on eliminating double taxation remain intact. Read the saving clause in Article 29 of the official treaty text and the mechanism clicks into place.

France eliminates the resulting double taxation through Article 24, and the wording repays close reading: “Les revenus qui proviennent des Etats-Unis, et qui sont imposables ou ne sont imposables qu’aux Etats-Unis conformément aux dispositions de la présente Convention, sont pris en compte pour le calcul de l’impôt français lorsque leur bénéficiaire est un résident de France” and that “l’impôt américain n’est pas déductible de ces revenus, mais le bénéficiaire a droit à un crédit imputable sur l’impôt français”, adding that “Ce crédit d’impôt est égal”, and specifically “Pour les revenus non mentionnés aux (…) iii), au montant de l’impôt français correspondant à ces revenus”. Concretely, you report your IRA and 401(k) payouts on your French return, France computes its tax on them, and then wipes that exact amount out with a credit. The American tax you paid is not deducted; instead the French tax attributable to the pensions is cancelled euro for euro. The income still counts in your total, so it can push your other French-source income into a higher bracket, a result often described as taxation at the effective rate, but no second tax is actually collected on the pensions themselves. The Conseil d’Etat regularly applies this exact credit language, including in its February 28, 2025 decision on the Franco-American treaty, which quotes Article 24 at length (Conseil d’Etat, 9th and 10th chambers combined, February 28, 2025, no. 491788, official text on Legifrance).

Two details protect 401(k) and IRA holders specifically. First, the treaty drafters named your plans: the text expressly lists section 401(a) qualified plans, individual retirement plans and accounts, individual retirement annuities, and section 403 plans as generally matching a retirement scheme constituted, established, and recognized for tax purposes in France. Your American plan is therefore legible to the French system by design, not by administrative favor. American retirement institutions themselves litigate under this treaty, and French judges read its provisions as written: the California Public Employees’ Retirement System fought to the Conseil d’Etat over 2,519,256.74 euros of French withholding tax levied on its French-source dividends for 2006 through 2009, and the court quashed the Versailles appeal ruling and sent the case back for retrial (Conseil d’Etat, 9th and 10th chambers combined, January 24, 2018, no. 402167, official text on Legifrance). Second, a rollover from a 401(k) into an IRA is a different event from a retirement payout, with its own proof and reporting questions, which our firm has analyzed separately for Americans moving to France (our rollover guide). Once the money starts flowing out as retirement income, the present article’s Article 18 and Article 24 mechanics take over.

One warning belongs here before any numbers. France considers you a tax resident as soon as you meet any one of three domestic tests, and the Lyon administrative court of appeal recalls them bluntly: a home or principal place of stay in France, a professional activity exercised in France unless merely accessory, or the center of economic interests in France, adding that “pour qu’un contribuable soit regardé comme fiscalement domicilié en France, il suffit qu’il réponde à l’un des trois critères définis par l’article 4 B du code général des impôts” (CAA Lyon, 5th chamber, June 18, 2020, no. 18LY02139, official text on Legifrance). If you keep homes on both sides of the Atlantic, the treaty tie-breaker decides: “Cette personne est considérée comme un résident de l’État où elle dispose d’un foyer d’habitation permanent ; si elle dispose d’un foyer d’habitation permanent dans les deux États, elle est considérée comme un résident de l’État avec lequel ses liens personnels et économiques sont les plus étroits (centre des intérêts vitaux)”. Snowbirds who split the year must settle residence first, because every treaty benefit in this article flows from French residence.

B. Why your Social Security checks are taxed only in America, including the COLA increase

Social Security benefits sit in the first clause of Article 18(1): sums paid under the Social Security legislation of one State to a resident of the other State are taxable only in the paying State. For an American retiree in France, that means the check is taxable only in the United States, and France must extend the same include-and-credit treatment described above. The annual cost-of-living adjustment changes nothing legally: the increase is part of the same benefit, governed by the same sentence, so the 2027 COLA flows through the identical treaty path, taxable in America and credited in France. Do not let a bigger dollar check tempt you into thinking France suddenly gets a share; the treaty allocates the whole benefit, increase included, to the United States.

On the American side, the taxation of those benefits follows its own sliding scale in section 86 of the Internal Revenue Code. The statute brings a portion of benefits into gross income on a sliding scale, starting at one-half of benefits or one-half of the excess over the base amount, and reaching 85 percent of the excess above a second threshold (26 U.S.C. section 86(a); the IRS computation worksheet sits in Publication 915). The trigger compares your modified adjusted gross income plus half your benefits against a base amount of $25,000 for a single filer and $32,000 for a joint return, with the 85 percent tier starting at adjusted base amounts of $34,000 and $44,000. The IRS explains the same test in plain language: benefits stay untaxed until modified adjusted gross income plus half of benefits passes the base amount for the filing status, with Publication 915 supplying the worksheet (IRS Topic 423). Many modest retirees therefore owe the IRS nothing on their Social Security while still owing regular American tax on IRA distributions, and France credits both outcomes the same way.

If you worked on both sides of the Atlantic, a second bilateral instrument may raise your benefit itself: the Franco-American Social Security totalization agreement lets American and French coverage periods combine so you qualify for each country’s pension with fewer years in either system. The Social Security Administration’s official agreement page walks through combining credits, monthly benefit eligibility, and the certificates of coverage that posted workers use to avoid paying both systems at once (SSA totalization agreement with France). Totalization changes the size of your check, not its treaty tax treatment, but for late-career movers it is often worth more than any deduction. In practice, the agreement matters in three situations: employees sent temporarily across the Atlantic carry a certificate of coverage proving they stay in their home system instead of paying twice, careers split between the two countries combine quarters to open pension rights on each side, and benefit claims can be filed through either country’s agency with payment made abroad. Health coverage follows separate rails: American Medicare generally does not pay for care received in France, while French universal coverage has its own affiliation path for retirees, both explained step by step in our retiree health guide (health coverage, PUMA, and the carte Vitale).

II. How France calculates the tax it then cancels, and how you declare every dollar

France runs your American pensions through its normal pension machinery first and applies the treaty credit second. Understanding the machinery matters because the credit only cancels correctly what was computed correctly, and because lump-sum payouts open side doors, the quotient system and a 7.5 percent flat levy, that periodic checks never need.

A. Which French calculation applies to monthly payouts and to lump sums you take once

French domestic law puts your distributions squarely in the pension category. Article 79 of the General Tax Code states: “Les traitements, indemnités, émoluments, salaires, pensions et rentes viagères concourent à la formation du revenu global servant de base à l’impôt sur le revenu. Il en est de même des prestations de retraite servies sous forme de capital.” (Article 79 on Legifrance). Monthly IRA and 401(k) payouts therefore join your global income like a French pension, and they earn the standard pension relief: “Les pensions et retraites font l’objet d’un abattement de 10 % qui ne peut excéder 4 439 €. Ce plafond s’applique au montant total des pensions et retraites perçues par l’ensemble des membres du foyer fiscal”, with a floor because “L’abattement indiqué au deuxième alinéa ne peut être inférieur à 454 €” (Article 158-5-a on Legifrance). The English-language public service page confirms the practice: the 10 percent allowance is automatic, pensions are pre-filled on online returns, and you simply check and correct the figure (the allowance applies automatically to the pensions each household reports, within a 454-euro floor per pensioner and a 4,439-euro ceiling per household, service-public.fr in English). Verify the current scale each filing season, since the ceiling and floor move with the income-tax brackets, but the mechanism itself is stable.

Lump sums taken once, a full 401(k) cash-out or a one-time IRA withdrawal to buy your French home, face the same Article 79 inclusion but regime details diverge. The first safety valve is the quotient system of Article 163-0 A, whose wording the Conseil d’Etat recalls as follows: “Lorsqu’au cours d’une année un contribuable a réalisé un revenu qui par sa nature n’est pas susceptible d’être recueilli annuellement et que le montant de ce revenu exceptionnel dépasse la moyenne des revenus nets d’après lesquels ce contribuable a été soumis à l’impôt sur le revenu au titre des trois dernières années, l’intéressé peut demander que l’impôt correspondant soit calculé en ajoutant le quart du revenu exceptionnel net à son revenu net global imposable et en multipliant par quatre la cotisation supplémentaire ainsi obtenue” (Conseil d’Etat, 9th and 10th chambers combined, March 19, 2018, no. 399150, official text on Legifrance). The technique spreads a one-year spike across four quarters for rate purposes. Judges police the word exceptional strictly: in that very decision, involving successive share buybacks, the court examined whether the gain truly could not recur annually, a reminder that a voluntary cash-out timetable you control yourself invites scrutiny. Treat the quotient as arguable for a genuine one-off, never as automatic.

The second path is a 7.5 percent final levy created precisely for retirement capital. Article 163 bis of the General Tax Code provides: “Les prestations de retraite versées sous forme de capital imposables conformément au b quinquies du 5 de l’article 158 peuvent, sur demande expresse et irrévocable du bénéficiaire, être soumises à un prélèvement au taux de 7,5 % qui libère les revenus auxquels il s’applique de l’impôt sur le revenu. Ce prélèvement est assis sur le montant du capital diminué d’un abattement de 10 %.” The levy applies “lorsque le versement n’est pas fractionné et que le bénéficiaire justifie que les cotisations versées durant la phase de constitution des droits, y compris le cas échéant par l’employeur, étaient déductibles de son revenu imposable ou étaient afférentes à un revenu exonéré dans l’Etat auquel était attribué le droit d’imposer celui-ci” (Article 163 bis on Legifrance). Deductible American 401(k) contributions fit that contribution history surprisingly well, but two cautions apply. The option sits inside French statutory architecture built around domestic plans, and neighboring provisions on capital payouts are drafted for French retirement savings products, so the tax office may contest the fit for an American plan. And the request is express and irrevocable, meaning a wrong election cannot be undone. For any seven-figure or borderline cash-out, secure a written ruling (rescrit) before electing, and keep the quotient as the fallback argument.

A final French layer deserves one honest paragraph without reopening a settled file. Income tax is not the only levy, and American retirees are regularly billed French social charges on United States pensions they assumed were treaty-protected. The contribution rules, the exemption for persons outside the French health system, and the refund litigation are analyzed in our dedicated guide for retirees facing CSG and CRDS on American pensions (our CSG and CRDS guide). Handle income tax with this article and social charges with that one, and neither bill will surprise you.

B. How to declare your American pensions on the French return without errors

The declaration routine has four stations, and skipping any one of them creates the classic double-tax panic where both countries seem to bill the same dollars. First, convert every dollar amount using the annual average or year-end rate consistently and keep the plan statements, Forms 1099-R, and SSA-1099 notices that prove each figure. Second, report the pensions on the foreign-income section of your French return, form 2047 attached to the main 2042 return, following the foreign-income declaration procedure described by the public service (declaring income received abroad). American pensions are not French wages, not French investment income, and not exempt income to omit; they are foreign pensions to include, so that the Article 24 credit has a base to cancel. Third, claim the treaty credit exactly where the return provides for foreign-tax credits on treaty-protected income, equal to the French tax on those pensions, and attach the treaty reference rather than deducting the American tax from the income. Deducting the IRS bill from the declared amount is the single most common error, and Article 24 forbids it in so many words. Fourth, declare every American account that paid or received the money, because individuals domiciled in France must report foreign accounts with their return, and the institutions themselves owe parallel reporting, under Article 1649 A of the General Tax Code (Article 1649 A on Legifrance). An IRA at a United States custodian is a foreign account for this purpose even though its contents are retirement savings. Open the French bank account that will receive the transfers before you need it, because American citizens face dedicated identity checks under United States anti-avoidance rules and occasional refusals, with a statutory right to an account as the backstop, as explained in our account-opening guide (FATCA checks, refusals, and the droit au compte). For currency conversion, use one consistent method all year, either an average annual rate or the December 31 rate applied uniformly, and note the method in your file so a later reviewer sees a system rather than cherry-picking.

Timing and records decide the rest. File within the French calendar deadlines for online filers in your department, pay any balance the assessment shows, and keep a treaty file for each year: the 1099-R and SSA-1099 slips, the exchange-rate sheet, the filed 2047 and 2042 copies, the United States return showing the same income, and proof of the American tax paid. If the French office questions the credit, that file answers in one envelope. If you arrive mid-year, the first French return is partial-year with worldwide income from the residence date, and the tie-breaker analysis from the Lyon decision above determines that date when both countries claim you. Retirees who also keep American rental property or dividends should note that each treaty article carries its own credit formula, dividends and interest under a paid-tax credit capped at the French tax, so pension treatment never automatically extends to the rest of the portfolio. And Roth accounts deserve a sentence of caution rather than a rule: qualified Roth distributions are tax-free in America, but their French characterization is debated and fact-dependent, which makes them ruling territory, not article territory.

Conclusion

The architecture is kinder than it first looks. The treaty assigns your IRA, 401(k), and Social Security income to the United States, the saving clause lets the IRS tax you as a citizen, and France includes the income only to cancel its own tax with an equal credit, leaving the effective rate as the sole French footprint. French law then supplies the calculation details: pension-category inclusion, the 10 percent allowance with its floor and ceiling, and for lump sums the quotient or the 7.5 percent levy under strict conditions. Your job reduces to four habits: establish French residence deliberately, declare every pension on the foreign-income forms without deducting American tax, claim the treaty credit for the full French amount, and keep the yearly proof file that makes any audit short. Do that, and the COLA increase in your Social Security check will be what it should be: good news, taxed once, in the right country.

📄 Official circular