You bought a house in France years ago, and now you are selling it. The French notaire (the public officer who authenticates the deed and collects the tax) tells you a large slice of the gain stays in France, and your American accountant tells you the same gain must appear on your United States return. Both are right. France taxes real estate gains on French soil first, and the United States taxes its citizens and residents on worldwide income, including the sale of a foreign home. What saves you from paying twice is not luck but a method: compute the French bill correctly, with every relief the holding period has earned you, then carry that French tax onto your American return through the foreign tax credit protected by the France-United States income tax treaty. This article walks through both sides in that order. Part I explains how France computes the plus-value immobilière (real estate capital gain), which rates apply, how years of ownership shrink the taxable base, and which exemptions Americans most often miss. Part II explains how the Internal Revenue Service treats the same sale, how the treaty splits taxing rights, and how the mechanics at closing and the challenge procedure work when the administration gets the number wrong.
I. How France Computes and Taxes Your Gain on a French House
French tax law starts from a simple proposition that covers you even though you live in America. The statute provides that “les plus-values réalisées par les personnes physiques ou les sociétés ou groupements qui relèvent des articles 8 à 8 ter , lors de la cession à titre onéreux de biens immobiliers bâtis ou non bâtis ou de droits relatifs à ces biens, sont passibles de l’impôt sur le revenu dans les conditions prévues aux articles 150 V à 150 VH” (CGI, art. 150 U, I). In plain English: gains made by individuals on the sale for consideration of built or unbuilt real estate, or of rights in such property, are subject to income tax under the rules of articles 150 V to 150 VH. A sale of a French house by an American individual falls squarely inside that sentence. The rest of Part I is about measuring the gain, rating it, reducing it for time held, and checking the exits.
A. Taxable Gain, 19 Percent Tax, 17.2 Percent Social Levies, and Holding-Period Relief
The starting point is the gross gain. The code states that “La plus ou moins-value brute réalisée lors de la cession de biens ou droits mentionnés aux articles 150 U à 150 UC est égale à la différence entre le prix de cession et le prix d’acquisition par le cédant” (CGI, art. 150 V): the gross gain equals the sale price minus the price you paid when you acquired the property. Both sides of that subtraction are then adjusted, and the adjustments are where American sellers win or lose real money, so read them slowly.
The sale price is the price in the deed, plus any charges and indemnities the buyer pays you on top of it, minus the selling costs you paid and can document, such as the real estate agent commission shown on the invoice. The acquisition price is what you paid, increased in two ways. First, the purchase costs (registration duties and notaire fees): you may count them for their actual documented amount or for a flat 7.5 percent of the purchase price. The official guidance sets the flat-rate alternative to proven purchase costs at 7.5 percent of the purchase price, and the flat works allowance at 15 percent of the purchase price once the property has been held for more than five years (service-public.fr, Plus-value immobilière). Second, construction, reconstruction, enlargement, and improvement works: either their actual amount, proved by contractor invoices, or a 15 percent flat allowance once you have held the property for more than five years. Keep every invoice from a real business; an expert estimate produced years after the sale, with no invoices behind it, does not carry the same weight, as the Paris case law discussed below confirms. If you inherited the house instead of buying it, the acquisition price is the value stated in the succession declaration, and the holding period runs from the death, not from any earlier family purchase.
Once the net gain is set, France applies two parallel charges on two slightly different bases. The income-tax charge runs at a flat rate: “Les plus-values réalisées dans les conditions prévues aux articles 150 U à 150 UC sont imposées au taux forfaitaire de 19 %” (CGI, art. 200 B). Alongside it come the social levies, which the administration rates at 17.2 percent (service-public.fr, Plus-value immobilière). Before relief, the combined bite is therefore 36.2 percent of the taxable gain, which is why the next paragraph matters more than any other in this article.
Holding-period relief (abattement pour durée de détention, a statutory percentage reduction of the taxable base that grows with years of ownership) shrinks the gain before the rates hit, and it does so on two different clocks. For income tax, the relief is 6 percent per year from the 6th through the 21st year of ownership and 4 percent for the 22nd year, after which the gain is fully exempt from income tax. For social levies, the relief is 1.65 percent per year from the 6th through the 21st year, 1.6 percent for the 22nd year, and 9 percent per year beyond, with full exemption only after 30 years. The administration illustrates the mechanism with a ten-year holding: five years at 6 percent, or 30 percent total, against income tax, and five years at 1.65 percent, or 8.25 percent total, against social levies (service-public.fr, Plus-value immobilière). Take a concrete American case. You bought a village house in the Dordogne in 2012 for 200,000 euros, paid 15,000 euros of purchase costs, added a documented 40,000-euro extension, and sell in 2026 for 340,000 euros with 17,000 euros of agent commission. Gross gain: 340,000 minus 200,000, or 140,000. Adjusted acquisition: 200,000 plus 15,000 plus 40,000, or 255,000. Net gain before relief: 340,000 minus 255,000 minus 17,000, or 68,000 euros. Fourteen full years of ownership give 48 percent income-tax relief (8 years at 6 percent), so the income-tax base is about 35,360 euros and the 19 percent charge is about 6,718 euros. Social-levy relief is 13.2 percent (8 years at 1.65 percent), so the social base is about 59,024 euros and the 17.2 percent charge is about 10,152 euros. Total French bill: roughly 16,870 euros on a 140,000-euro economic gain, an effective rate near 12 percent, entirely because time and paperwork did their work. Change one input, lose the invoices, sell two years earlier, and the number moves by thousands.
Two surcharges can sit on top. First, the high-gain surtax: “Il est institué une taxe sur les plus-values réalisées dans les conditions prévues aux articles 150 U et 150 UB à 150 UD par les personnes physiques” and “La taxe est due à raison des plus-values imposables d’un montant supérieur à 50 000 €, selon le barème suivant appliqué au montant total de la plus-value imposable” (CGI, art. 1609 nonies G), with progressive bands from 2 percent just above 50,000 euros up to 6 percent above 260,000 euros. A 68,000-euro taxable gain falls in the 2 percent band, adding about 1,360 euros. Second, if the property is held through certain companies or the seller’s situation triggers additional contributions, the notaire‘s computation (décompte, the detailed settlement statement) will show them; never sign the deed without reading that statement line by line, because after signature the money is gone and only the challenge procedure remains. Readers who want to understand how the notaire builds that statement in an inheritance context will find the same reading method in our guide to checking a succession bill (what the notaire charges an American heir and how to check the bill).
B. The Nonresident Layer: When France Still Taxes You, and the Two Exemptions Americans Miss
Living in Ohio or California does not move the house. French domestic law expressly treats real estate gains as French-source income: among “revenus de source française” it lists “Les plus-values mentionnées aux articles 150 U , 150 UB et 150 UC” when they relate to French real estate (CGI, art. 164 B, I, e bis). The nonresident levy then follows: “Sous réserve des conventions internationales, les plus-values, telles que définies aux e bis et e ter du I de l’article 164 B , réalisées par les personnes et organismes mentionnés au 2 du I lors de la cession des biens ou droits mentionnés au 3 sont soumises à un prélèvement selon les taux fixés au III bis” (CGI, art. 244 bis A, I). For individuals the rate is aligned with residents: “les personnes physiques, les associés personnes physiques de sociétés, groupements ou organismes dont les bénéfices sont imposés au nom des associés et les porteurs de parts, personnes physiques, de fonds de placement immobilier mentionnés à l’article 239 nonies sont soumis au prélèvement au taux de 19 %” (CGI, art. 244 bis A, III bis). The opening words, “sous réserve des conventions internationales” (subject to international treaties), point to the France-United States treaty examined in Part II, which confirms rather than removes French taxation of French real estate gains.
Social levies apply to nonresidents too, and this is where Americans affiliated with a foreign social security system have a genuine legal argument, within limits. The contribution is anchored in domestic law, which subjects to the levy “Des plus-values, gains en capital et profits soumis à l’impôt sur le revenu” (CSS, art. L. 136-6, I, e). European law then caps the charge for people insured in another European state: a person covered there “n’est soumise qu’à la législation d’un seul Etat membre, en sorte que celle-ci, affiliée à un régime de sécurité sociale d’un Etat membre, ne doit pas contribuer au régime de sécurité sociale d’un autre Etat membre (CJUE, 26 février 2015, De Ruyter, C-623-13, point 35)”, as recalled by the Cour de cassation (Cass. 2e civ., 6 June 2024, no. 21-23.396). A companion ruling the following year applied the same single-legislation logic to contribution bases (Cass. 2e civ., 30 Jan. 2025, no. 22-22.464). Concretely, an American who is also insured under another European Union state’s system, for example a dual American-French national working in Germany and posted contributions there, can challenge the French social levies on the sale gain. An American insured only in the United States, which has no totalization-equivalent single-legislation rule with France for these levies, should not budget on that escape; the levies will normally stick, and the remedy is the American foreign tax credit, not a French exemption. Do not confuse this narrow European-law argument with a general American immunity. There is none.
Two exemptions genuinely help American sellers who plan ahead. The first is the main-home exemption: the statute spares property “Qui constituent la résidence principale du cédant au jour de la cession” (CGI, art. 150 U, II, 1°), meaning the home that is your principal residence on the day of sale. The test is factual and dated: where you actually lived, with your family life, utilities, and tax residence pointing the same way, on closing day. An American who left France two years ago and rented the place out since will fail it; an American who still lives in the Paris apartment as a primary home when the deed is signed will pass it, even with an American passport. A useful variant covers the seller who already moved abroad: the building that was your main home in France when you transferred your tax residence out of France can stay exempt if you sell it no later than December 31 of the year after the move, provided it was never made available to third parties in the meantime, a rule embedded in article 244 bis A itself. If you are leaving France, calendar that deadline before you list the property; readers coordinating a departure will also want our departure checklist (exit tax, final French return, and what happens to your French house).
The second is the first-sale reinvestment exemption (exonération au titre de la première cession): a seller who has not owned a main home, directly or indirectly, during the four years before the sale can exempt the gain on a first sale of a dwelling other than the main home, to the extent the price is reinvested within twenty-four months in acquiring or building a home used as the principal residence. The Paris Court of Appeal recalled the formula exactly: “L’exonération est applicable à la fraction du prix de cession défini à l’article 150 VA que le cédant remploie, dans un délai de vingt-quatre mois à compter de la cession, à l’acquisition ou la construction d’un logement qu’il affecte, dès son achèvement ou son acquisition si elle est postérieure, à son habitation principale” (CA Paris, Pôle 4, ch. 13, 19 Mar. 2024, no. 21/01462). That same ruling is a warning about paperwork: the exemption failed at first because the sale deed omitted the mandatory statements identifying the beneficiary, the rights, the reinvested fraction, and the exempted gain, and only a corrective deed could attempt repair. Tell the notaire before the signing appointment that you claim this exemption, confirm the four statements appear in the draft deed, and diary the twenty-four-month reinvestment deadline with proof of completion.
One more courtroom lesson before leaving French soil, about the works that inflate your acquisition price. In a 2024 Paris ruling, sellers of a former main home claimed large improvement costs supported only by an expert report drawn up years after the resale. The administration answered that it “s’estime fondée à appliquer la majoration de 15%. Elle soutient que les dépenses de construction ou d’embellissement doivent être réalisées par des entreprises et justifiées par des factures”, adding that the expert’s data, “dans son rapport établi près de cinq ans après la vente du bien, sont peu précises et, en l’absence de tout élément probant pour évaluer les travaux litigieux, le juge de première instance ne pouvait que confirmer que seul le forfait de 15 % était applicable” (CA Paris, Pôle 5, ch. 10, 23 Sept. 2024, no. 22/10430). The message for an American seller is blunt: contractor invoices from real businesses, kept for decades, beat reconstructions. Scan them, store them outside the house you are selling, and hand copies to the notaire weeks before closing.
II. How the United States Taxes the Same Sale and How the Treaty Coordinates the Two Bills
The American side starts from the opposite principle of the French side. France taxes the house because the house sits in France. The United States taxes you because you are you: citizens and resident aliens report worldwide income, and a gain on a French house is income even though France already taxed it. Double taxation is then avoided by treaty permission plus a domestic credit, not by ignoring one of the two returns. File both, pay France at closing, and carry the French tax home as a credit.
A. IRS Reporting of a French Sale and the Foreign Tax Credit That Absorbs the French Tax
Report the sale on your federal return for the year of closing. The gain is generally a capital gain, computed in dollars, with the purchase price, improvements, and selling expenses translated at the applicable exchange rates and the sale price translated at the closing-date rate. Keep the French deed, the décompte, the invoice file, and a one-page exchange-rate schedule with the return workpapers; currency movement between compromis and closing can shift the dollar gain by several percent, and the Service expects consistency, not creativity. If the house was your home in the American sense, a federal exclusion may shelter part of the gain: the Internal Revenue Service explains that a single filer may be able to exclude up to 250,000 dollars of home-sale gain from income, and a married couple filing jointly up to 500,000 dollars (IRS, Publication 523, Selling Your Home), provided strict ownership and use tests are met, in substance owning and living in the home for at least two years within the five-year period ending on the sale date. An American who lived in the Lyon house for four years before a job move back to Texas may qualify; an American who held the same house purely as a vacation rental will not. Run the American test independently, because the French main-home exemption and the American exclusion use different clocks, different definitions of residence, and different paperwork.
The treaty then does two things. First, it confirms that France may tax: gains from the alienation of real property situated in a contracting state are taxable in that state (France-United States income tax treaty, art. 13(1), consulted as the consolidated version on impots.gouv.fr), so France taxes the French house and the United States cannot complain. Second, it organizes relief: for income covered by article 13(1), among others, the treaty grants, for income covered by article 13(1) among others, a credit equal to the tax paid in the other state in accordance with the treaty (treaty, art. 24(1)(a)(iii)), and symmetrically the United States relieves double taxation under its own law, which is the foreign tax credit of the Internal Revenue Code. The Service describes the domestic mechanism plainly: a taxpayer who paid or accrued foreign taxes to a foreign country while subject to United States tax on the same income may generally take either a credit or an itemized deduction for those taxes, with the credit reducing the United States tax bill itself, which is why the credit usually beats the deduction (IRS, Foreign Tax Credit). Individuals claim it on Form 1116, Foreign Tax Credit (Individual, Estate, or Trust), attached to the return for the sale year.
Three practical consequences follow. First, timing: the French tax is collected at the French closing, often a year before the American return for that year is filed, so preserve the proof of payment (the décompte and the 2048-IMM receipt, discussed below) until the Form 1116 is prepared; a credit without proof is a disallowance waiting to happen. Second, baskets and limits: the credit cannot exceed the American tax attributable to the same category of foreign income, so a seller with little other American tax in the sale year may carry the unused credit forward within the statutory carryover rules rather than losing it; model this before choosing a closing date, because bunching the sale with a high-income American year can change the usable amount. Third, state taxes: most states with an income tax do not simply mirror the federal credit, and some offer no credit at all for French taxes, so a California or New York resident can face residual state tax on the same gain even when the federal bill is fully absorbed; check the state return separately. None of this requires exotic planning. It requires two complete returns, one treaty, one form, and a file of proofs.
B. Closing-Day Mechanics in France and How to Challenge a Reassessment
In France the tax does not wait for next year’s return. The notaire computes the gain, withholds the income tax, the social levies, and any surtax from the sale price, files declaration 2048-IMM on your behalf, and remits the money to the Treasury at the time of the deed. The calculation details live in the official return notice for form 2048-IMM, the capital-gains return for real estate transfers (impots.gouv.fr, sale of real estate). Your leverage sits entirely before signature: send the notaire the acquisition deed, the works invoices, the proof of holding period, and any exemption claim at least three weeks ahead, obtain the draft computation, and reconcile every line against the method of Part I above. Verify the acquisition price used, the 7.5 percent or actual purchase costs, the 15 percent or actual works, the exact count of full years of ownership, the separate income-tax and social-levy bases, and the surtax band. Errors found after the funds are disbursed can still be fixed, but only through the challenge procedure, which is slower and uncertain.
One American-specific formality comes first. As a nonresident selling taxable French property, you must in principle appoint an accredited fiscal representative (représentant fiscal accrédité) who guarantees payment to the Treasury whenever the gain is taxable, and that representative must hold administration accreditation and financial guarantees (service-public.fr, Plus-value immobilière). Three automatic dispensations exist: European Union or European Economic Area nationals covered by a treaty with France, sales priced at or below 150,000 euros, and gains fully exempt from both income tax and social levies by holding period. An American is not European, so only the price threshold or a full exemption helps; a 400,000-euro taxable sale from Florida needs a representative, whose fee, typically a fraction of a percent of the price, should be negotiated before the compromis, not discovered at closing. The representative’s involvement does not change the computation, but the absence of one when required can freeze the closing.
If the computation was wrong, French procedural law gives you a real but time-barred remedy. Substantively, claims belong before the tax courts when they seek “soit la réparation d’erreurs commises dans l’assiette ou le calcul des impositions, soit le bénéfice d’un droit résultant d’une disposition législative ou réglementaire” (LPF, art. L. 190): correction of errors in the base or computation of the assessment, or the benefit of a right under statute or regulation. A miscounted holding period, a forgotten invoice file, a missed main-home or first-sale exemption all fit that frame. Procedurally, the clock is strict: “Pour être recevables, les réclamations relatives aux impôts autres que les impôts directs locaux et les taxes annexes à ces impôts, doivent être présentées à l’administration au plus tard le 31 décembre de la deuxième année suivant celle, selon le cas”, including “Du versement de l’impôt contesté lorsque cet impôt n’a pas donné lieu à l’établissement d’un rôle ou à la notification d’un avis de mise en recouvrement” (LPF, art. R*196-1). Because the sale tax is paid at closing without a later assessment roll, the two-year clock normally runs from the payment year: tax paid at a June 2026 closing must be challenged by December 31, 2028. File the administrative claim (réclamation contentieuse) first, attaching the deed, the computation, the invoices, and the legal basis, and keep the American side coordinated, since a French refund reduces the foreign tax credit and may require amending the federal return. Typical American files that succeed are boring ones: the notaire counted eleven full years instead of twelve, applied the 15 percent works flat rate while the invoice file proved higher actual costs, or ignored a main-home exemption whose evidence, utility bills plus tax residence, was sitting in the file all along.
Conclusion
Selling a French house as an American is a two-country computation with a fixed order of operations. France taxes first, on a base you can shrink with documented acquisition costs, proven works, holding-period relief at 6 percent and 1.65 percent rhythms, and, where the facts allow, the main-home or first-sale exemptions. The United States taxes second, on the dollar gain, with its own home-sale exclusion under its own tests and, above all, the foreign tax credit that absorbs the French tax within its limits. Between the two stands the treaty, confirming French taxation of French real estate gains and organizing relief on each side. The failures are almost never theoretical: missing invoices, a miscounted year, an exemption never mentioned to the notaire, a fiscal representative appointed too late, a French refund that never reaches the amended American return, a challenge filed one year past the December deadline. Assemble the file before listing, reconcile the draft computation before signing, and keep every proof until both returns are final. The gain survives the sale; with method, most of it survives the tax.